Rare Corporal Clegg video, Pink Floyd

[pinchejuarezfeo]

always can i hear this i imagine a sad psycho clown maybe for the kazoo that used hahaha sorry for the bad english !!

[mike3rdmusic]

Amazing! This song's amazing! I've red someone says Syd played the Guitar track ... I don't know, to me it's just a great guitar track on a great crazy song.

[GeorgeRingoGirl]

LOVE YOU BOYS 3:55

[GeorgeRingoGirl]

FUCK!!! THIS AWESOME!!!!!!!!!!!

[suildhearg]

zizwho

[suildhearg]

clegg murderer

lyer wha else=tramp

[birthdayssuck]

@suildhearg Yeah, right! "Murdered" some nazi Germans in WWII.



[suildhearg]

clegg murderer

[lalala84009]

I fuckin' love this song!!!

[GoldenGoldeneye]

one of my favourites of Pink Floyd

[remberthisemail]

Syd really did make the after scarcful of secrets they ran out of ideas like syds so they tried somthing diffrent which dont get me wrong every thing after words is great but good ol syd is what I miss under my tounge

[Aleanderson90]

This video's awesome.

[sonicpixie]

Roger Water's emulating Syd's style. Arnold Layne... Corporal Clegg... see the characterisation idea? So they kicked him out of the band and carried on his style. Syd made them.

[MrPoti36]

A Saucerful of Secrets is the best album of Pink Floyd

[HELODERMANDER]

Allways Loved Syd's Pink Floyd. I think I love it now more than ever.

Just visited Pink Anderson's grave- the man who put the "Pink"

in Pink Floyd, and a fine musician as well.

[spikefred1]

The horrible folly of war... "Have you got it yet?"

[AK4TsEv3N]

Best song of A Sacerful Of Secrets, only one question, who sings it??? is it Syd Barret???

[Stefanofloyd82]

@AK4TsEv3N No..... Roger Waters lead Vocals

[AK4TsEv3N]

@Stefanofloyd82 Oh ok thanks it's that Waters' and Barret's voices are similar

[ultraviolentgeisha]

wow, people really didn't get @Gold753's joke, how sad

[LukasFin]

What a waste of food!

[moonchield365]

muy bueno!!

[guitblog]

never seen this video, I think is rare

[DudleyScardsdale]

No one will acknowledge it, but this food fight is what really broke up Pink Floyd.

[OxygenChrist]

Great song!

[shanoon]

estaba en el colegio, me fumaba mis primero pitos de marihuana, escuchaba el saucerful of secrets y sentía tanta psicodelia, ahora nada me sorprende

[Floyd4201000]

The Best Kazoo Solo Ive Ever Heard

[DatingGameKiller]

I've heard this song a million times. This is the first time seeing the real video. Love it. Love you, Pink Floyd, all 4, or 5 of you!

[jakoblfuller]

its not loud...yer old!

[marnold6879]

yes it is nick singing those funny lines

[blogzify]

9 people don't understand music!

[gamesplaystation1]

@blogzify :( 10

[JackyRowe]

this song is so cheery on teh mandolin!

[JaReD123RoX]

weird my last name is clegg

[seweryne30]

LSD !!!!!!

[TheBeatlefloyd]

@drew199321

It's David :)

OMG i love David in this video, he pors champagne on Roger, then throws food at him and starts a whole food fight!

[waluigiween]

Gilmour and Mason singing together !

[TheBeatlefloyd]

@waluigiween , is that Nick singing the "He Won it in the war..." those parts?

[mitchskater]

@TheBeatlefloyd yes

[TheBeatlefloyd]

@mitchskater that there is effin awesome

[corpralkirsch]

i named my new youtube name after this song

[OmegaWolfPack]

That is FUNNY.

[uh0oo]

Bet they had fun making this video

[MetallicBill]

Wondered how authentic this was given it's shot very obscured, however, looks real enough, here the Floyd unleash their frickin' fury... You can imagine some real pent up frustration coming out in this!!

[TheNefariousMaster]

Very unappreciated song from a great album...

[uh0oo]

this song seems to be about fantasing of being a war hero when youve never been to war. Is that true? thats what I get from it.

[MetallicBill]

@uh0oo There is a strong Waters theme running straight back to the loss of his father at Anzio in 1944, this also relates a message condemning all war, however even PF had there own internal war going on

[uh0oo]

@MetallicBill So it may be more about the poloticians not getting there hands dirty while others are dying for them.

[MetallicBill]

@uh0oo (see also Black Sabbath War Pigs!)

[MrJaybee61]

Lmao at 1:42

[bonghitlover]

War isn't cool but this song song is !

[dododye]

The first time i took acid i listened to this song and it changed my life!

[EndlessNot1]

Pink Floyd wrote "BrokenChair" '99'

[gabbagabbaskate8]

definitely a barrett style song

[corpralkirsch]

fuckin love this song, i want my xbox live name to be corpral clegg

[Chameleon96]

Best kazoo oriented song known to mankind.

[solarfire1000]

Na denn,guten Appetit. Klasse Film.Hab ich ja noch nie gesehen.Genial.

[EndlessNot1]

Pink Floyd wrote "Dogs", "Us And Them" also "Echoes"!!

[BrokenChair88]

Pink Floyd wrote "Dogs".

[XxKyokoSamaXx]

@BrokenChair88 Yeah we all know that. So you don't have to comment with that in every PF video

[LIBERTINEPARANOIC]

@BrokenChair88 ?????

[shelly10538]

Great song! My friend had this on A Nice Pair and played it for me and it was instantly my favorite from their early period. I had no idea there was a video for it.

[sandplacer]

Just the genious of Floyd...

[ladidah9]

Reminds me a little bit of The Who's Happy Jack video from 1966. Great song, awesome video.

[EndlessNot1]

Waters wrote the song, Mason, Gilmour & Wright contribute vocals

[EndlessNot1]

i thought Nick Mason sang the "We won it in the war " parts! sure sounds like him...

[ooesnohhnschecalov]

@EndlessNot1 Yes, it was Mason

[LarkSist]

Oddly enough, it sounds to me like a forerunner of some tracks in The Wall.

[schmittelt]

@LarkSist I agree. Perhaps a semi light-hearted version of When The Tigers Broke Free.

[LarkSist]

@schmittelt

Exactly.

Also, there are some musical ideas- both in production and in melody- that reverberates in Waiting For the Worms.

[schmittelt]

@LarkSist And Roger's vocal parts here (He won it in the war. etc.) are similar in tone to his "megaphone" rants in Waiting For the Worms.

[LarkSist]

@schmittelt

That's one of the things I meant by "production".

;)

[diddywahdaddy]

@LarkSist I was thinking the same.

[PhilistineTheArtLuvr]

What a demented song, but that's what I exactly love about Pink Floyd!

[MysteriousToastGenie]

pink floyd are loud now?

[smooro]

the background sounds quite similar to "one in a million"

[culdine]

If the Liberal Democrats win the election, Pink Floyd have promised to re-unite and sing this song at Nick's inauguration.

[ghigno992]

Awesome song and awesome video.

[EndlessNot1]

Jugband Blues was recorded between October and December '67' ..."Piper.." was already released so it couldn't have been recorded for the "Piper" album...

[pigonthewing1972]

good appetite!

[gatorboy1133]

Dont ever try to get girls when the kazoo part is taking place. it doesnt work

[HeWhoIsIAm7]

if the Kazoo part isnt working on the ladies then you are chasing the wrong ladies my friend. clothes end up everywhere when Kazoo part hits in my room =P

[mikefed335]

is there a bass on this track?

[jspade1019]

In the remastered CD you can hear bass, but in this video, the quality isn't good enough to hear the bass without really listening for it.

[Canaveral305]

I heard Syd sang some choruses on that song, is that true ? I know David and Nick share the lead vocals, but I'm not sure if the choruses are Rick + Roger or Rick + Syd

[HeWhoIsIAm7]

mostly Rick actually, after Piper Syd is not featured on any Pink Floyd album with the exception of Jugband Blues which was put onto the Saucerful of Secrets album but was recorded and discarded for/from Piper

[apacolipps]

"His boots were very clean."

[SRone45]

I wish this was in color.

[PinkFloydAreGods]

Such an underrated song.

[sandplacer]

@PinkFloydAreGods Classic Floyd....

[JudozIV]

mrs. clegg ano+her drop of gin???

[pigonthewing1972]

SPLAT !!! francoboy got some cake back in the face!! lol!

[baseballfuries08]

@WalterBlaine yeah, I guess he does in that moment

[francoboy100]

FOOD FIGHT (hits pigs on the wing with a a cake)

[pigonthewing1972]

fuckin class !! pink floyd live on!!!!

[ILuvPBouvier]

OMG GAZOO SOLO lol :D

Has to be the only one in the history of music let alone rock music :D

(: <3<3

[EclipsedMind]

FUCK i love that wah

[ErnieandBert1]

Yes he is.

[xipaul]

il est bien fait le clip

[ObscureIcon]

4:05 - 4:07

[nahuelbarrio123]

O.o rare

[mrsydbarret]

i put this on facebook they loved it my friend in reme 200 friends now lol

[ErnieandBert1]

It's strange hearing Nick Mason on vocals; he has that "snarling" quality in them.

[Gold753]

Why does it all got to be so terribly loud? For me, frankly, its too loud. I just can't bare it. I happened to have grown up with the string quartet which is a bit softer. So, uh, why does it got to be so loud?

[HeWhoIsIAm7]

cause thats how you listen to ROCK \m/

that and its hard to have a good trip whilst struggling to hear all the instruments,

[Gold753]

Woosh

[AFirmKickInThePants]

@Gold753 They're Pink Floyd. They can be as loud as they want

[BrennymanPage]

@Gold753 you want somethin soft go listen to us and them or echoes

[StonedReviewer]

@Gold753 cause its not a string quartet, its a rock band

[SuperNevile]

@StonedReviewer which is usually a string trio (an amplified one tho') ~ and PF is when Rick is playing piano. Just checked ~ this was written by Waters, chidhood sense of loss masquerading as satire. cheers

[Dani2mix]

@Gold753 because Pink floyd isn't a string quartet

[evajom1]

@Dani2mix 

[crazycaleb92]

@Gold753 because pink floyd is WAY better than a string quartet.

[myztainzydeout]

@Gold753  HAhahaha

[yeoungbraxx]

@Gold753 I know you older people aren't always technology-savvy, but wow. There's a little speaker icon beneath the video that has a slider allowing you to turn the volume down.

[Douglasm5]

It looks like he is really hitting him at 3:42

[tangerinedreem]

hahaha watch roger run away when david puts his helmet back on

[kmz16]

Saucerful of secrets- my favourite pink Floyd´s album

[tangerinedreem]

haha this is awesome ive always wnated to see pink floyd get into a food fight

[baseballfuries08]

Old Sid times...

[paulreeve]

Syd

[ideapazza]

SYD per sempre

[HeWhoIsIAm7]

swing and a miss!

back to the dug out

[mrsydbarret]

not just trippy but a good rock track aswell --class

[TheIsabel7]

My Goodness I love this video.

Was it Dave puring the gin?

[fujivoo]

i think after Syd was out, the boys in the band wanted to keep the sound going..Gilmour played a lot with Syd in the early days, playing together they probably developed sonic similarities, i don't think Gilmour intentionally wanted to imitate Syd though, it just evolved that way, but who knows...i'm just making an observation...

[HeWhoIsIAm7]

that couldnt be farther from the truth. he didnt imitate Syd at all, in fact when he played a gig with early Floyd without Syd, Syd showed up and David saw the look on his disappointed and heart broken face, David then proceeded to tell Roger something along the lines of "We do that again and I'm out." then they've starting homages for Syd not imitations

[fujivoo]

i said at the beginning, Gilmour's sound was similar to Syd's.if you listen to "Saucerful Of Secrets", it sounds a lot like Syd's style of playing, on "Let There be More Light"..he's beginning to get that Gilmour sound..i know eventually, their sound isn't alike..if you read my whole comment, but it's my opinion that when Gilmour first joined Floyd, he sounded a lot like Syd, you may think different, that's ok

[fujivoo]

i think early on after Syd was "ousted" the band in different ways tried to ride Syd's succesful wave...imitating his vocal as well as songwriting style, also Gilmour imitating his guitar style...but as time went on they found themselves and their sound evolved into individual styles..Gilmour slowly began to sound Gilmouresque.....

[splik2]

Nick wrote in his book that Dave was invited to join the band partly because he was really good at mimicking guitar and vocal styles. Of course he'd have to be able to unless they expected to be able to start from scratch. Syd had the lead vocal in almost every early Floyd song. The rest of the band did meet him through Syd, as he was his childhood friend, that's true.

[fujivoo]

i've checked three different Gilmour bios and they're all similar....Syd and David went to school together and used to get together during lunch etc. and played guitar....nothing about Gilmour teaching Syd...i got the impression they were both learning and playing the guitar together... that's why they had similar styles....

[Gold753]

Did you just say Syd and David have similar playing styles? Their guitar playing styles are not even close.

[Romencer17]

for some reason I remember hearing gilmour taught syd, but either way they played a lot together, so it's not like gilmour was completely imitating him early on

[fujivoo]

i'll have to check that fact out.....

[JoeChrisMorris]

Read about this video in Pink Floyd FAQ! LOL

[JudozIV]

this was sooooo advanced for the era...RIP Syd and Rick

[fujivoo]

froop!!

[alphablondy]

wena

[dangaertner7]

one of my fav floyd albums

[TheClassicRockFan]

I Have This CD First Time I Ever Saw The Video Toe I Like It I Have Ben A Roger Waters Fan For A Very Long Time.

[fujivoo]

Syd also plays crazy slide guitar on Wright's "Remember A Day"

[fujivoo]

some of the guitar parts sound so much like Syd's, especially at the beginning of the song..maybe Gilmour was trying to imitate Syd's tone on Saucerful...maybe Barrett also was at the sessions ...supposedly he's only on "Set The Controls.." and of course "Jugband Blues"

[lulabelleblue95]

Actually, David and Syd had similar playing styles because David taught Syd how to play guitar.

[skatepark4hb]

I don't know why but I love this song... especially the kazoo parts. I have absolutely no idea why....

[fujivoo]

don't get so upset monkeymelon..if you hadn't spent so much time bla-bla-ing yer whole life, maybe you'd be happier!!

have a floobity wonderful day...

[monkmellon]

im a musician. and Im... I bla bla for 39 years, im the shit and im a musician and this is money... COULD YOU SHUT THE FLOOBITY FUCK UP?

[el0chino]

i think u kinda missunderstood.. plus i didnt explain myself at all... my point was that the record companies (most of them) only care about money. i know there are really good musicians.. and nly carthat they oe about their music.. thats why they are called musicians (stupid joke.. i know..)

anyway.. i apologize if i pissed some musicians.. now that i read my comment.. it is kinda dumb.. cause i didnt make clear i was still talkin about the record companies... my bad..

[fujivoo]

i'm a musician also, been playing in bands for around 30 years and i also care about making great music and i'm lucky enough to know and work w/ great musicians but after 30 years, i do care about getting paid decent money for something i do well after many years of playing for peanuts and that doesn't take anything away from my love of creating great music

[fujivoo]

as soon as the music industry started marketing and distributing bland watered down versions of rock and r& b music and people now begin accepting this stuff as the norm...everything else starts to sound wierd..it's frightening to think what kind of impact a classic recording like Sgt. Pepper's would have in 2009 compared to 1967...sadly, it would not even crack the top 100... the "music" industry would consider it too wierd...it's now controlled by a bunch of non musician bottom line execs...

[fujivoo]

that's because back then they let the solo artists and bands be themselves and didn't have to fit some kind of look and sound before they were even signed...when you have to spend so much energy trying to look and sound a certain way, creativity and originality goes down the drain..i'm 51 and when i see people half my age liking the same kind of music that i grew up with, it's because they recognize the difference between good music and crummy music, not a generational thing..

[el0chino]

Somewhere i heard this... "back in those times, if u were an artist, u could go to a record company.. present to them a song over 10 minutes long and, if they liked it, they would put it on a record... now if u present a song that long they will say you are crazy and kick you ass out of there", sad but true... its all about money now.. its hard to find REAL music on this days, (im 23 and most of the music i listen was wrote decades before i was born)

[fujivoo]

Brokechair88 wrote" PInk Floyd wrote Dogs"!!

[Genocidebitch666]

"...his boots were very clean"

=)

[TheLadyAza]

It's all fun and games until someone throws food... then it's just fun.

Has anyone in that band ever owned up to having had the idea for this particular twist of craziness? Absolutely hilarious...

[systembug91]

lol keep it up BrokenChair88 lol

[hfield07]

Great song. Saucerful is a great album.

[BrokenChair88]

Pink Floyd wrote "Dogs".

[killeroftime978]

I get it! It's a satire comparing war to a silly food fight. Sweet.

[BemusedStranger]

this is so awesome. i love it. ''')

[xxdyogas1]

Does anyone else see the link between this video and the video of "In The Flesh?", at the beginning of "The Wall" film?

[Pulsar89]

Imagine that Gilmour had decided to stick with the kazoo...

*hears Comfortably Numb with a 5 min kazoo solo* LOL

[rogeryd]

It Would Be Cool If Someone Would RE enact This Video!

[faceofpo]

This would be so much more fantastic if it were in colour.

[Sodoffanddie]

First vocal is David, second vocal (singing "he won it in the war" etc) is a very rare appearance from Nick. Chorus is most likely a mix of David and Rick as they harmonised the best.

[themachinegunn]

love seeing "new" pf footage

[CalculateInBinary001]

Awesome song.

I can't stop listening to it.

[PontiosFotis]

A kazoo.