Yes, the original (Ewan MacColl wrote it, as others have said) had "the Salford wind", not "the smoky wind", so it's definitely about Salford. I understand that MacColl liked the change to "smoky" though, because it made it more universal. Really, is there an industrial city anywhere in the world that it isn't about? Even the reference to docks doesn't place it on the coast. Salford isn't on the coast: Salford docks were canal docks.
@LadyLumps01 The song was written originally about a town in the north of England. People think it's about Ireland because of the Pogues and The Dubliners but Ewan MacColl wrote it about England
@MsOneiroi77 ......nudgin, nudgin, nudgin.......this black duck from half irish spud farmer and half welsh nymphet circa 1857......(both had a free ticket over)!.....onya bike! XXXXX
Mind the lyrics are wrong! It should read "I met my love by the gas work's croft". I think the first Irish band to cover the song got it wrong and the others followed suit. I was told by a Mancunian that the bit of ground called the gas work's croft still exists.
@1woodnut The song was written by Ewan MacColl in 1949 as a musical interlude for his play "Landscape with Chimneys". Both the song and play are about life in industrial Salford, now part of Greater Manchester. MacColl was himself born in Salford but both of his parents were Scottish. He became the major figure in the Britsh folk revival. Apart from this song his two other best known songs are probably Shoals Of Herring and The First Time Ever I Saw Your Face
This is wrote by ewan mcall (who lived in salford )about the city SALFORD not Manchester! The original lyrics were Smelled the spring on the SALFORD wind! SALFORD SALFORD SALFORD
I seriously can't fucking quit this song.
wtg2989 2 days ago in playlist Favorite videos
Yes, the original (Ewan MacColl wrote it, as others have said) had "the Salford wind", not "the smoky wind", so it's definitely about Salford. I understand that MacColl liked the change to "smoky" though, because it made it more universal. Really, is there an industrial city anywhere in the world that it isn't about? Even the reference to docks doesn't place it on the coast. Salford isn't on the coast: Salford docks were canal docks.
digitig 6 days ago
The things i prefer with the Pogues, it's the singer's teeth !!!
Mrnono1313 3 weeks ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
best song in the world!
Bhoysingreen8493 4 weeks ago
best song in the world!
Bhoysingreen8493 4 weeks ago
Gorgeous song.
BodhranGirl98 4 weeks ago
Salford <3
mikel2187 1 month ago
republic of doyle :3 LOVE this song
CoolerThanIceCubes1 1 month ago
CELTIC!!!!!!!!!!!
LIAMxMILLER 1 month ago
Why should they be singing about England? Since when was England a town???
LadyLumps01 2 months ago
@LadyLumps01 but salford is a town and its about there ;-P
MsOneiroi77 1 month ago
@MsOneiroi77 really, always thought this song was about Dublin??..:P
johngcuntylugs 4 weeks ago
@johngcuntylugs it's definitely about Salford.
dragonash1993 6 days ago
@LadyLumps01 The song was written originally about a town in the north of England. People think it's about Ireland because of the Pogues and The Dubliners but Ewan MacColl wrote it about England
DrYang73 1 month ago
i think they shud be singing about england no offences
TheAaron0422 2 months ago
*music* love it :)
Isismusicnow 2 months ago
when they sing bout a dirty old town apart from london do they mean shitty rhyl lmaox wat a dump ...........oh gr8 song by da way x
cheznicholson2710 2 months ago
nice version! ty!
westone4u 2 months ago
Love your videos VenomousNewfie ...
weezie100160 2 months ago
amazing song !!!!!!!!!!
honigklauer 2 months ago
Ts me heritige..................eggslint!
olbassy 2 months ago
@olbassy if your English its about as Irish as a Chicago pizza
MsOneiroi77 1 month ago
@MsOneiroi77 ......nudgin, nudgin, nudgin.......this black duck from half irish spud farmer and half welsh nymphet circa 1857......(both had a free ticket over)!.....onya bike! XXXXX
olbassy 1 month ago
@olbassy yeah whatever nudge, nudge talk sense.
MsOneiroi77 1 month ago
This is really fuckin' music *.*
HydromelRaptor 3 months ago
It is a foot waggin song..hee hee. Good tune.
rtogurl 3 months ago
Fantastic song... great band... brilliant artist... shame about the choppers. There's something about the Irish and their choppers.
zroppian 3 months ago
i agree im a newfie and listing to this song makes me feel like im back home
Nwefie 3 months ago
<3
DataUnit 3 months ago
The Pogues and a Ice cold Beer, Sweet weekend beguns!!
Kotor1972 3 months ago 3
go into another world listening to this and them
wackster66 4 months ago
i only listen punkrock but if i heared this song from my brother i hear this relaxed musik and punkrock its so nice!
BlackRedStar95 4 months ago
Best song EVER!!!!
larnz12 4 months ago
i was tapping my feet whilst listening to this lool with cola in me hand :P
sweetiepatty7 5 months ago
@sweetiepatty7 good life
tinytot258 4 months ago
reminds me of margate.
sexypotterhead 5 months ago
R.I.P. Lou </3
LUKE01MAN 5 months ago
R.I.P. Lou..... you fat bastard :)
danielavendano333 5 months ago 3
Excellent song!!! This was the ending song on the last episode of "Rescue Me" last night.
rockykitty123 5 months ago
it´s not my favourite music but it sounds god
Minecraft4009 6 months ago
@Minecraft4009 it does sound god :p.
0TheBestMan 4 months ago
A good version with authentic sound. Not sure I liked the banjo. It's O.K.
909chuck 6 months ago
Three cheers for drunkin' tears in me beers!
judeyorke 6 months ago
classic
Millerbhoys7 7 months ago
this is Republic of Doyle Season 2 finishing song.
zanjani13 8 months ago 3
Was this in P.S I Love you?
sheppard67 8 months ago
i love this song i just came back from newfoundand couple months ago miss it already :(
marieamy21 9 months ago
i love that song
oamaru123 9 months ago
Mind the lyrics are wrong! It should read "I met my love by the gas work's croft". I think the first Irish band to cover the song got it wrong and the others followed suit. I was told by a Mancunian that the bit of ground called the gas work's croft still exists.
gaconnochie 9 months ago
reminds me the lovely dublin..
65groove 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
who wud thumbs down this song? ..bahhh...love it :-) swinging in me seat
wackster66 10 months ago
who wud thumbs down this song? ..bahhh...love it :-)
wackster66 10 months ago
Can't stop listening to this piece. Heard it on Republic of Doyle..... both great!
Thanks.
Captainalfie 10 months ago
Salford is next to Manchester in England
tony00165 11 months ago
2 people live in a really clean new town and have never kissed their love against the factory wall
TheUKConman 11 months ago 2
What the hell is Salford?
1woodnut 11 months ago
@1woodnut The song was written by Ewan MacColl in 1949 as a musical interlude for his play "Landscape with Chimneys". Both the song and play are about life in industrial Salford, now part of Greater Manchester. MacColl was himself born in Salford but both of his parents were Scottish. He became the major figure in the Britsh folk revival. Apart from this song his two other best known songs are probably Shoals Of Herring and The First Time Ever I Saw Your Face
gaconnochie 10 months ago 2
stephen forster jr
steeshmufc 1 year ago
BIG BIG SHANE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
solopino1 1 year ago
Bestr song ever
1funnyz 1 year ago
Lot of Cities and Towns in the U.K that could be likened to such a song-Villages tooo....
astrocomera 1 year ago
Unbelivible good song.
DonNinoFalcone 1 year ago 3
@thepeterlong its about Salford, not bloody ireland
08dawilliams 1 year ago
love this song, reminds me of my home, miss u newfoundland
newfierasta 1 year ago 2
This is wrote by ewan mcall (who lived in salford )about the city SALFORD not Manchester! The original lyrics were Smelled the spring on the SALFORD wind! SALFORD SALFORD SALFORD
c1der001 1 year ago
@c1der001 kirsty mcColls father
THEDRIVEN60 1 year ago
@c1der001 where?
hairlessbaldy 1 year ago
I love it !!!
gsteiner2 1 year ago 2
all about the old salford mills no matter wot ppl say
TONYIRISHPROUD 1 year ago
Super !
MultiB18 1 year ago
beautiful...
andjelijaue 1 year ago
This song is about Manchester you know
myers5797 1 year ago
@myers5797
yep its about salford in manchester
lickamaknob 1 year ago
this song is so nice
Chrisredfieldfan 1 year ago 27
I really like this song, thanks for posting!
newfieman7765 1 year ago 38