i realllllly didnt want to compare the two... but after watching this video for the millionth time, i just had to. as good as Fantasia is, it is just nearly impossible to compete with jeannette. this has got to be my favorite version, byfar.
If you are thinking of having an abortion this is a must see.
I watched this movie called 180 movie it was very good if you are pro-life or pro-choice, watch this award winning documentary and see where you stand at the end.
they both sound great but knowing the life Fantasia has lived I just feel her more but this girl can sing her ass off I just feel the pain more with Fantasia
She has the voice.. she has been trained.. thus the technique.. it is obvious. Now I can't understand when an honest comparison is made..why some people think..it is hate against the other artist. It is an opinion. There will always be one greater that he other. Beyonce makes millions of dollars. Beyonce does not have half the range of this girl. We all have our gifts and there are things we are not so good at.
@Jamaronharris i agree with your comment but i love to hear how much feeling fantasia puts into this song when she sings it...but as far as skill jeanett got her
That was a beautiful performance but to whomever said that fantasia cant do that... UR LYING. FANTASIA'S LIVE VOICE AND RADIO VOICE IS TOO MUCH FOR THESE WANNA BE ARTIST LIKE KEYSHIA COLE.... IM TIRED OF PPL TRYNNA DISS MY GIRL LIKE SHE CAN'T SANG KUZ IN OTHER VIDEOS SHE TORE THAT DAMN SONG UP!!!....... AND STOP COMPARING HER TO JHUD.. THEY BOTH CANT BLOW... REAL HARD!!!!!!
Let's not forget La Chanze the one that won the Tony Award for Best Leading Actress in a Musical. She was AWESOME!!! These ladies are all great Artists and we should congratulate each one of them. They are not in competition with each other. They all had the chance to play an important role in the play.
5 hours ago On December 24,2006 at 8 o'clock in the morning, a young 14 year old boy by the name of Scott Jackson was found dead.Doctors couldn't come up with the cause of his death.His mother checked his emails to see if she could figure out what happened.Turns out he was still signed into myspace.She found he had gone to sleep after he read and didn't repost a chain letter.if you don't repost this to 6 videos a girl with no face will kill you tonight.
she did good but she aint even touch fantasia on dis here fantasia straight up knocked this song out the park ole girl gotta a long way to be where fantasia at on this song!
Jeannette, all I can say is wow. She fully captures the emotion of this song. When she sings, "lovin' who i really am!", it makes me tear up. He voice has such power and tone. I can listen to this performance over and over again without getting bored. She is by FAR the best Celie, and maybe the best color purple cast member there has been. Fantasia does not even compare. Fantasia is GREAT, but Jeannette is indescribable. When she sings, "with all the love alive in me," it is just beautiful.
She can sing I give her that but she does not have enough emotion behind the words. whereas Fantasia has a true connection....In all I like both versions......
To everyone that thinks Fantasia sings this song better, you are crazy!!! Just because you have alot of black girls riffs in your song (like Fantasia), does not make you a better singer. Sorry.
I'm not sure what kind of DOPE yall smoking yes Jeannette can sing this song but to say she sang it better than Fantasia is CRAZY. Yall but be on that pure Colombian Shit! REMEMBER COCAINE IS A HELVA DRUG!
she sounds great but she performed without emotions. fantasia performs this song with the understanding of the story along with emotion. it was from the soul.
I saw her in San Francisco and got the same performance that let me speechless. Simply incredible....She didn't back down from any of those notes, but stepped up to them.
Fantasia already had a fan base and people knew her struggle which contributes to her huge reception in this role, and nothing against her, but there is simply no comparison with Jeannette. I'm glad I saw this performance.
Sometimes, I wonder why people with much less talent are celebrated, but PHENOMENAL artists like Jeannette are not very well known. It seems unfair. Jeannette Bayardelle is FANTASTIC!
I've yet to see a bad performance of this song, no matter who is singing it. The lyrics and music are both so powerful and have such meaning, it would make sense for a singer to personalize it and put their own stamp on it. I enjoy hearing the song. It is a Musical Treasure.
I think this is amazing. The Color Purple is such a moving piece anyway. Fantasia did well also but Jeanette just has a stronger voice. But they are both phenomenal.
I love Fantasia. And this sistah is working it out. Love this song. Just like Mister and Buster said. you had her your way and I had her mine. But we both had her. so Fantasia had the song her way and all the others had it their way. But they all had her and it was good. LOL
What's with all this nonsense comparing these wonderful sisters in such a negative way. It's the same nonsense when you go and view a Jhud video or a Beyonce video. We're fortunate to be alive and receive such joy from these young magnificent soulful sisters.
I also realize that you are very young people,and this is how you all respond to and with people today...I'd better be nice before you curse me out...Jeanette is dong a good job,I have seen both productions,one I have seen three times,though I am not a resident,will probably go to another performance before it closes.
Why can't they both be good singers? Why does it always have to be a competition? There's no animosity between Jeanette and Fantasia, so why should there be bickering among the fans?
We also will continue to pray Gods blessings for Jeanette because she too has and is working extremely hard. God Bless you Jeanette, may you have much success.
In saying goodbye to you and God bless you....LET GOD BE TRUE AND EVERY MAN A LIAR, In Jesus Name.Amen (that quote is a scripture from the word of God)
You all please stop all this comparison, it is getting is and it is not benefitting you, and what God has for each of them he has for them. If someone hates Fantasia style then let them its their perogative,okay.
I too have seen both productions, and I am not going to say which one I preferred because it doesn't matter,but I do agree with the person who seemed be trying to be very diplomatic to say it is great they all are working because so many others are not, whether Chicago or whereever,I think Fantasia knows she is hated by many.
OH MY GOD! When she hits the high note at :30 I got chills and my jaw dropped. Jeanette is kind of a small women and I will never assume heavy set women are the only ones with powerful lungs and voices again. She is amazing OMG! I dont know what to say but phenominal!
Oh MY GOD!!!!!!
kirkalexander 4 days ago
Lawd have mercy! I saw this show in Atlanta. It was good but all I have to say is WHERE WAS SHE??!!! Wow!
v8diva 2 weeks ago
wow, wow, wow!
ashazaria 1 month ago
i realllllly didnt want to compare the two... but after watching this video for the millionth time, i just had to. as good as Fantasia is, it is just nearly impossible to compete with jeannette. this has got to be my favorite version, byfar.
CollinJames421 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
If you are thinking of having an abortion this is a must see.
I watched this movie called 180 movie it was very good if you are pro-life or pro-choice, watch this award winning documentary and see where you stand at the end.
Look up 180 movie on youtube or 180movie.com
standingontruth1 2 months ago in playlist Oprah Winfrey
take that fantasia, now this is a performance
theemaestro576 4 months ago
they both sound great but knowing the life Fantasia has lived I just feel her more but this girl can sing her ass off I just feel the pain more with Fantasia
devore504 6 months ago
She has the voice.. she has been trained.. thus the technique.. it is obvious. Now I can't understand when an honest comparison is made..why some people think..it is hate against the other artist. It is an opinion. There will always be one greater that he other. Beyonce makes millions of dollars. Beyonce does not have half the range of this girl. We all have our gifts and there are things we are not so good at.
cassinko 7 months ago
I have to listen to this at least once a day or I have withdrawals. Amazing.
JmB8207 8 months ago
Love this woman, what a voice!!
scottyrudders 8 months ago
This version made me cry!! The power and emotion she gave. You go girl!!
blendrax08 8 months ago
is that possible to have the entire performance? I suppose it is not, but I tried!
merlino1987 8 months ago
best version among the ones I've heard
merlino1987 8 months ago
wow...talk about getting chills. love this.
naledireid1 8 months ago
WOW all I can say
wam1469 9 months ago
@Jamaronharris i agree with your comment but i love to hear how much feeling fantasia puts into this song when she sings it...but as far as skill jeanett got her
Jtscott18098 9 months ago
@Jamaronharris not all that. but u have to give fantasia her props.
Iplaypiccolo 9 months ago
Oh my God... Amazing!!!!
mountainhealer 10 months ago
Amazing ..........that's all I can say!
MsGmc65 10 months ago
13 people clearly have no soul.
roweman2 10 months ago
Amen !!!!
B2kcookies 10 months ago
@Jamaronharris I did shout!! Lord she gives me major major major goosebumps! Truly unbelievable! WOW
Beanie0687 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
that was amazing im about to cry
serenadeyuki 11 months ago
yes lawd, yes, yes...
serenadeyuki 11 months ago
That was a beautiful performance but to whomever said that fantasia cant do that... UR LYING. FANTASIA'S LIVE VOICE AND RADIO VOICE IS TOO MUCH FOR THESE WANNA BE ARTIST LIKE KEYSHIA COLE.... IM TIRED OF PPL TRYNNA DISS MY GIRL LIKE SHE CAN'T SANG KUZ IN OTHER VIDEOS SHE TORE THAT DAMN SONG UP!!!....... AND STOP COMPARING HER TO JHUD.. THEY BOTH CANT BLOW... REAL HARD!!!!!!
mrallaboutme25 11 months ago 3
1:31 "I'm beautiful..." I like the way she acts in this part ^^
davidkiller15 1 year ago
i like Fantasia's better! this lady overdid it.
rachelness3sings 1 year ago
I know Fantasia and Jennifer H sang this song but I can't count Jeannette out. This is awesome. All three are phenomenal!
ninacleveland 1 year ago
OMG!!! If this vocal doesn't knock you out, you're already dead.
The greatest voice since Aretha.
vwpnla 1 year ago
damn she held that note forevr from 0:30-0:41 wow wat an amzing voice!!!!!!!!!!
MrLuvGame 1 year ago
Let's not forget La Chanze the one that won the Tony Award for Best Leading Actress in a Musical. She was AWESOME!!! These ladies are all great Artists and we should congratulate each one of them. They are not in competition with each other. They all had the chance to play an important role in the play.
Maxie3768 1 year ago
i just wanted to cry!!! incredible!
LittleGibbo 1 year ago
i think they both killed it but i like Tasia better cause i think its her life story the song that is
tears37 1 year ago
they both sing it different ways and both are amazing versions.
muenboy 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
5 hours ago On December 24,2006 at 8 o'clock in the morning, a young 14 year old boy by the name of Scott Jackson was found dead.Doctors couldn't come up with the cause of his death.His mother checked his emails to see if she could figure out what happened.Turns out he was still signed into myspace.She found he had gone to sleep after he read and didn't repost a chain letter.if you don't repost this to 6 videos a girl with no face will kill you tonight.
zodiac1254 1 year ago
Tasia just does the song justice. she is a good singer but she just isn't our American idol.
juicyfruit515 1 year ago
I think Fantasia has the best version of this song!
robertsnowden19 1 year ago
@robertsnowden19 i agree
htowngurl17 1 year ago
fantasia's version is more emotional behind,,hers is more theatrical
hunnyboo89 1 year ago 2
She killed those high notes...amazing
0xTRellyx0 1 year ago
THIS VERSION IS BEAUTIFUL ALSO, BUT FANTASIA HAS THE POWER BEHIND IT.
jetts48 1 year ago
is this fantasia
yasmine5117 1 year ago
@yasmine5117 Hell no!
Opolla 1 year ago
Love it!
Jazzmuzik11 1 year ago
Dayyyyuuummm
makinbacon254 1 year ago
Sanggggggggg Girl! Take it home mama!!!!!!!!
eagleswing44 1 year ago
I want a better clip of this. It's making my eyes act weird...they're getting wet :S
kalarr1389 1 year ago
That was pretty much the most emotional thing I've ever seen. Intense. Amazing.
FozzyForman 1 year ago
I love Jeannette's rendition, but Fantasia's version brought me to tears. I
mmirg8 1 year ago
Magnificent!
Biskmut 1 year ago
Coś niesamowitego ...
Czegoś takiego nie można oglądać na co dzień ...
Brawo ! ! !
AaAldoniAaA 1 year ago
@Jamaronharris Lachanze has this song on her webpage
AdamEfimoff 1 year ago
no she cannot sing like that at all all the talent tv singers cannot
AdamEfimoff 1 year ago
she did good but she aint even touch fantasia on dis here fantasia straight up knocked this song out the park ole girl gotta a long way to be where fantasia at on this song!
abcg2013 1 year ago
dang... the orchestra wanted to leave early on this one! lol
she's great
boyledryce 1 year ago
wow...amazing
hard to compare compition would b tough...
kerinaite 1 year ago
@Jamaronharris babby plzx fantasia can hit that and sum more
mzprizzy202 1 year ago
Get it girl you sound nice!!
Ladiesofquality 1 year ago
DEAD.
eponinesyndrome 1 year ago
Jeannette, all I can say is wow. She fully captures the emotion of this song. When she sings, "lovin' who i really am!", it makes me tear up. He voice has such power and tone. I can listen to this performance over and over again without getting bored. She is by FAR the best Celie, and maybe the best color purple cast member there has been. Fantasia does not even compare. Fantasia is GREAT, but Jeannette is indescribable. When she sings, "with all the love alive in me," it is just beautiful.
zriopelle2009 1 year ago 4
she is awsome
HAIRMODEL4YOU 1 year ago
I like Fantasia, but her voice is screechy and squeaky at times.
This girl is an INCREDIBLE singer, and she doesn't need to over-act. She delivers a realistic, full amount of emotion.
AtLastOnTheGround 1 year ago
i disagree. i think her passion is SPOT ON
spenc24 1 year ago
I thought was fantasia but, that woman could sing real good
xxMIZZJACQUETTAxx 1 year ago
She can sing I give her that but she does not have enough emotion behind the words. whereas Fantasia has a true connection....In all I like both versions......
Taquera21 1 year ago
HAAAAY DIONNE!
Jarrod005 1 year ago
Her beginning was wayyyyyy better but fantasia had a better ending!!!!!!!!
tevin4731 1 year ago
Naw I think Fantasia bring Ms. Seely 2 life when she sings that song! Riffs and voice aside, her personality just delivers the song and the message!
singerboy3 2 years ago
@singerboy3 i think Fantasia can sing this to..... BUT!!!! this girl got pipes too...
StevieAfroP09 1 year ago
I would give so much to see her as Dionne, most incredible voice I have ever heard. That note from 0:25-0:30
ImTheRingo 2 years ago
She's gonna be amazing in Hair
blckrocker 2 years ago
@blckrocker
Who is she playing? New cast or London?
BlueJeanBaby012 1 year ago
@BlueJeanBaby012
Right now on Broadway
She's Abe
blckrocker 1 year ago
To everyone that thinks Fantasia sings this song better, you are crazy!!! Just because you have alot of black girls riffs in your song (like Fantasia), does not make you a better singer. Sorry.
khadeejahj 2 years ago
no fantasia got her beat sorry this song only sounded good with fantasia
TheAaliyah4everboy 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
for real fantasia owns this song more than anyone ever could and ever will.
bmm05b 2 years ago
Oh my....
love4triumph 2 years ago 2
The Color Purple Chicago Im Here/ Jeannette Bayardelle You can download this from w w w Y80 ORG
amithbrdna 2 years ago
I'm not sure what kind of DOPE yall smoking yes Jeannette can sing this song but to say she sang it better than Fantasia is CRAZY. Yall but be on that pure Colombian Shit! REMEMBER COCAINE IS A HELVA DRUG!
ThickChick026 2 years ago 4
@ThickChick026 im not quite sure what kind of dope you are smoking, because fantasia was just decent in the color purple. jeannette was amazing.
zriopelle2009 1 year ago
this is way better than fantacia
kertzryein 2 years ago
Jeannette Bayardelle is by far the best Celie ever!!
imtboi 2 years ago 3
fantasia sucked so bad are you kidding me? I saw her twice in the show and I couldnt even cry she was so terrible. worst actress ever.
RCPDynamics 2 years ago
I agree
blckrocker 2 years ago
brilliant, you go girl
MedlynMartin 2 years ago
plus Fantasia toke her time with this song.She had control,and range. They both sound good. I like Fantasia's performance at the Tony's music awards.
honeyluv15 2 years ago 2
she sounds great but she performed without emotions. fantasia performs this song with the understanding of the story along with emotion. it was from the soul.
honeyluv15 2 years ago 2
she reminds me of the third memeber of the dream girls. she can blow but nothing stands out. Fantasia sang this song flawless!!
honeyluv15 2 years ago
umm yeah, except for that high G in chest voice
AlwaysACoGirl 2 years ago 2
I saw her in San Francisco and got the same performance that let me speechless. Simply incredible....She didn't back down from any of those notes, but stepped up to them.
Fantasia already had a fan base and people knew her struggle which contributes to her huge reception in this role, and nothing against her, but there is simply no comparison with Jeannette. I'm glad I saw this performance.
gplus46 2 years ago
omgggggggggg her voice is on steroids...amazing!! shaking performance.
WhoIzDeejayYoung 2 years ago 3
que voz, uff! que voz linda! e folego!
newtonlsantos 2 years ago 2
amazing!
msmarchitto 2 years ago
I'm a new fan...wondering if Tyler Perry has seen her?!
mle9202 2 years ago 3
dam!!!!!!!
destineddiva93 2 years ago
damn she got pipes
ladyjmk20 2 years ago
I LOVE HER IN THIS ROLE!!!!!!!
sallad741 2 years ago 2
Holy Cow !!!!!!!! who knew ....
MasterMark123 2 years ago
Wow...so sorry I missed it Jeannette...AMAZING!
midiangurl 2 years ago
Incrível demais..... i love you
MyGuiguinho 2 years ago
What an Emotional Powerhouse! I'm a instant new fan!
SonnjaK 2 years ago
Sometimes, I wonder why people with much less talent are celebrated, but PHENOMENAL artists like Jeannette are not very well known. It seems unfair. Jeannette Bayardelle is FANTASTIC!
AlanNJUSA 2 years ago 4
She's insane. Such an incredible voice. She sings this song with such ease it's crazy. I'd die to see her in the show again.
FireGirlG 2 years ago 3
absolutely incredible performance!!
Dollface1923 2 years ago 6
WELL WELL!! yes ma'am.
SANG chile!
simplycharming 2 years ago 3
That is TALENT with a capital T! Fantastic!
AlanNJUSA 2 years ago 3
You mean with a capital T and A and L and E and N and another T. lol
FireGirlG 2 years ago 2
By the way...
UR AMAZING!!!
nathanielcrocker19 2 years ago 2
im actually crying... that woz so emotional. PHENOMENAL!
yazzieboo7 2 years ago 2
Woah. Go Girl! :)
MichaelCrawfordsFan 2 years ago 2
I...wish I could sing like that.......
mleliza3 2 years ago
WOW....
rizinstar 2 years ago
O.o ...... speechless..... wow
apuppetapuh 2 years ago
brilliant performance from an exceptional talent
thank you so much for posting this*
AdiSereana84 2 years ago
I've yet to see a bad performance of this song, no matter who is singing it. The lyrics and music are both so powerful and have such meaning, it would make sense for a singer to personalize it and put their own stamp on it. I enjoy hearing the song. It is a Musical Treasure.
kamwrites 2 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
wow is that what my lisp sounds like
ciaraslegsarehot 2 years ago
I think this is amazing. The Color Purple is such a moving piece anyway. Fantasia did well also but Jeanette just has a stronger voice. But they are both phenomenal.
jw5927 2 years ago 4
WOW..........this woman is the epitome of vocal strength and stamina. And her character is so visceral!
Theemmygoesto 2 years ago 5
I love Fantasia. And this sistah is working it out. Love this song. Just like Mister and Buster said. you had her your way and I had her mine. But we both had her. so Fantasia had the song her way and all the others had it their way. But they all had her and it was good. LOL
carterboy66 2 years ago
What's with all this nonsense comparing these wonderful sisters in such a negative way. It's the same nonsense when you go and view a Jhud video or a Beyonce video. We're fortunate to be alive and receive such joy from these young magnificent soulful sisters.
May life always be abundant for you Jeannette.
God Bless you.
Intervalintime 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
She is the best Celie there has been! Period.
civicplayer 4 years ago 210
I also realize that you are very young people,and this is how you all respond to and with people today...I'd better be nice before you curse me out...Jeanette is dong a good job,I have seen both productions,one I have seen three times,though I am not a resident,will probably go to another performance before it closes.
allforzion777 4 years ago 53
Why can't they both be good singers? Why does it always have to be a competition? There's no animosity between Jeanette and Fantasia, so why should there be bickering among the fans?
Anyways, this clip is fantastic. Go Jeanette!
ByronB88 4 years ago 132
We also will continue to pray Gods blessings for Jeanette because she too has and is working extremely hard. God Bless you Jeanette, may you have much success.
forzionsmom 4 years ago 38
This has been flagged as spam show
In saying goodbye to you and God bless you....LET GOD BE TRUE AND EVERY MAN A LIAR, In Jesus Name.Amen (that quote is a scripture from the word of God)
barrinno 4 years ago
dey BOTH Fantastic on broadway...I LUV YALL BABIIZ!!!
Jay010Jay 4 years ago 36
You all please stop all this comparison, it is getting is and it is not benefitting you, and what God has for each of them he has for them. If someone hates Fantasia style then let them its their perogative,okay.
forzionsmom 4 years ago 25
All of this compariosn needs to stop. What God has for each of them he has for them. People have a right to like whom they like.
truthb777 4 years ago 24
I'm gonna have to agree with all that you've said. Fantasia was good, but this chick was straight up FIRE. I have never heard of her. Simply amazing.
CHEETAH69 4 years ago 19
I too have seen both productions, and I am not going to say which one I preferred because it doesn't matter,but I do agree with the person who seemed be trying to be very diplomatic to say it is great they all are working because so many others are not, whether Chicago or whereever,I think Fantasia knows she is hated by many.
truthb777 4 years ago 18
OH MY GOD! When she hits the high note at :30 I got chills and my jaw dropped. Jeanette is kind of a small women and I will never assume heavy set women are the only ones with powerful lungs and voices again. She is amazing OMG! I dont know what to say but phenominal!
kamikaze80 4 years ago 5
She was amazing in Chicago! I saw her wednesday!
civicplayer 4 years ago 2
she is amazing
DannyNoriega 4 years ago 3
FIERCE!
caitididwhat 4 years ago 5
OMG! So fierce!
ktakeone 4 years ago 4
oh my gosh she gave me chills
deld2006 4 years ago 3
i seen diz woman here and fantasia dey was o soo beautiful!!!....my whole family was in tearz cryin!..."BEAUTIFUL!"
Jay010Jay 4 years ago
who did u see play Celie in the Broadway production?
ByronB88 4 years ago
amazing!
ByronB88 4 years ago 3
That was really good. She sounds great. But what happened to the rest of the interview? I wanna see it.
missparker2121 4 years ago 2
(cryin).........we was in the 3rd row, n boi was it amazing "look what GOD has done"...
Jay010Jay 4 years ago 3
i was there!!! " i was cryin"
Jay010Jay 4 years ago 2