I was 19 when I first saw these guys in Buffalo NY where I grew up. I helped them carry their gear from there van into the bar. My girlfriend at the time had given me a mixtape with a few of their emo songs. I am 32 now and I still think these guys are awesome. They coulda done without the highlights in their hair when they got signed though -.- I listened to skid row growing up so these guys doing a cover well it just doesnt get much better than that ;)
love both version, I like the original because it's heart felt, I love this because it's punk like. both unique, both their own style, can't say I like one better than the other, I'd just listen to the one i'm feeling at the time
But I also listen to bands like Open Hand, AFI, Something Corporate, Taking Back Sunday.....and bands like Atreyu, Bullet For My Valentine, Avenged Sevenfold, My Children My Bride, Eyes Set To Kill, and Dance Gavin Dance. I listen to a lot of different things. But things like this, where people butcher classic songs is not something I can appreciate.
I totally agree with u man. no one can sing like sebastian bach he is great and no one should even attempt something like this where you can't improve the song becuz its already amazing
I'm 13. I love Skid Row, Scorpions, Journey, Night Ranger, Tesla, Steelheart, Warrant, Motley Crue, Whitesnake, Cutting Crew, Don Henley, Led Zepplin, Styx, Bad Company, Kansas, Boston, and David Bowie. None of this is influenced by my parents. I was raised around country music. Not all teens listen to whats popular now. As a matter of fact, I hate all of the music played on popular radio stations. I HATE this version of I Remember You AND I hate the new lead singer of Skid Row.
solo si no te gusta no la escuches, mi padre me influencio de la misma manera y la verdad esa musica es la mejor pero hay bandas actuales que tienen esas mismas influencias y las usan muy bien creo que esta es una de ellas
Personaly i own dif stuff from whats popular and i love some bands tht ppl have never heard of :) tht and i dont own a i-pod so dont knock the teen population! Go Atreyu!!
still I like this cover though, but I never did like much of any other covers except Johnny Cash. And face it, Nobody can do a better "Dancing With Myself" The Donnas, Blink 182, Green Day, nobody... However, I did like Dope's cover of his trademark "Rebel Yell" but sorry Murderdolls is no good when they did "White Wedding"
yea, ..theres just some bands that shouldnt cover stuff.. especially classics from the 80s metal era....its like "leave it alone..its a masterpiece ..dont ruin it.." lol
let me guess , whatever is popular at the time thats what you have on your i-pod right?
you could take the worst band from the 80s and put em up against the best bubblegum pop band of today and it would just be an embarrassment , but opinions are opinions
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Oh my bad, I thought you were from Houston dick.
You talk so much shit because you've never had your ass beat. Believe me punk, I'd fuck you up. If I ever go to "A-town" I'll be sure to let you know, I'd never miss a chance show you how we deal with fucks like you.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Shut your face loser, you said you grew up in Houston, yet never heard of Channelview? I think your so full of shit.
If I did go to Austin, and I doubt you even live there, would you fight me with a dictionary? Your like a gnat buzzing around my face. Go bug the shit outta somebody else. Fucking loser.
my contribution to this original vs. cover argument is that as good as a cover is, you cannot go slagging the original. Skid row and sebastien bach are amazing for having written this. Appreciate the cover, love the cover, but RESPECT the original, the ataris obviously do.
I actually thing this is one of the best songs ever made, if you dont like it, dont listen to it, I actually think the original sucks your balls, but w/e, I really dont care. THIS SONG ROCKS!
this is horrible. This was meant to be a slow ballad song, not some fast bullshit song, that sounds like Blink 182 wrote it. Way to fuck up another classic you fuckers.
Hmm... The speed and vocals, imo, take away from the emotion that the original had. But they did a nice job "converting" it to their own style, I guess.
okay, well judging by all the "omg this is so bad" comments theres clearly alot of fanboys here. i love skid row as much as the next guy and ive never even heard of this band but its not that bad, and when you cover a song you dont try to make it the same. you make it your own. thats directed at the "this song isent the type to be covered by a punk band" and "this is played too fast" if you hate it that bad why watch it? and i know ill get flamed for this but its true.
fisrt off,the ataris arent a punk band,they are a pop band. second. this version sucks,they make it sound like something blink 182 would write, although the solo did sound kinda cool. and sebass's scream.
lol i luv how every ones like skid rows is way better cuz o nskid rows osme douche bag said this version was better i mwiht uguys skid row all the way
god.. i hate you! your a disgrace to skid row. this song is way too fast. and the singer doesnt even compare to sbastian. i wanna cry. this is sad; they suck so bad. OMIGOSHTHATRHYMED! lol. oh yeah. your gay. go fuck urself.. SKID ROW FOREVER
personally i like dustbox's version the best but thats just me
shancassidy 2 months ago
Man, just or attempting a Sebastian Bach song let alone this one. You should all give him props. And he fucking NAILED it. GREAT cover!
Kurzgan 3 months ago 2
They just made this song pop ish. prefer Skid Row! \m/
jovitheman 3 months ago 3
Probs the best cover from Punk Goes Metal
DeathDefie 5 months ago 3
I was 19 when I first saw these guys in Buffalo NY where I grew up. I helped them carry their gear from there van into the bar. My girlfriend at the time had given me a mixtape with a few of their emo songs. I am 32 now and I still think these guys are awesome. They coulda done without the highlights in their hair when they got signed though -.- I listened to skid row growing up so these guys doing a cover well it just doesnt get much better than that ;)
nathanclark79 6 months ago 2
Or I should say to whoever made the image in the video. haha
n1nj4Lo 6 months ago
I like this cover as much as I love the original. To the uploader though it's I Remember You, not I'll..... LoL
n1nj4Lo 6 months ago
too fast....
SGTChee 6 months ago
@SGTChee wake up :D if you arnt screaming this song while listening to it your not livin life right.
JamesonEmpire 1 month ago
@JamesonEmpire.... yeah you rite!! \m/
SGTChee 1 month ago
made it their own, which a cover should be!
LaserGraffiti 7 months ago
God it's the original got smashed in teh face by the Ramones and then licked clean by College Rock. I am unsure about this.
toonuraccoon 10 months ago
this song feels like High School .. haha...,
i original was best..,
but good cover...,
darylvargas1 11 months ago
I preffer the original but this cover is good
paupotter16 1 year ago
the ataris best band 4ever
vaiqnaodanada 1 year ago
Comment removed
jonvistal 1 year ago
I didn't know they did this cover
kny0123dogs 1 year ago
AWESOME song EVER! ^_^
EmOrTaLizEr 1 year ago
Eghh, they really fucked this song up! Sebastian Bach, is the one and only that can really ever sing this song. Plus, HE IS FUCKING HOT! <3
MarilynRamirez486 1 year ago
@MarilynRamirez486 they didn´t fuck it up man... they just made it their own and kinda made a tribute to skid row by covering this song
thegrouchboy 1 year ago 4
@thegrouchboy well...if you put it that way...
MarilynRamirez486 1 year ago
@MarilynRamirez486 Thats what i mean dude :D
thegrouchboy 1 year ago
@thegrouchboy Ohhh, my badd
MarilynRamirez486 1 year ago
love both version, I like the original because it's heart felt, I love this because it's punk like. both unique, both their own style, can't say I like one better than the other, I'd just listen to the one i'm feeling at the time
poeticpoverty 1 year ago
punk goes metal!!!oye i love this song!!!!!!!!!
taemobulol 1 year ago
I got to see them live and they were great. ;]
danmilam11 1 year ago
Their intentions were not to IMPROVE the song, it's just a completely other style.
WhyAreAllNamesTaken1 1 year ago 25
if you want a good cover listen to milkshakes by "i set my friends on fire"
MrWyatthaydon 1 year ago
Is thomyorkeswonkyeye done? Just wanted to make sure...
gnr4life23 1 year ago
great cover, punk not dead
halifaxmtl666 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
There are 20 angels in this world
10 are sleeping
9 are playing
1 is reading this
put this on 4 video comments within 15 mins,if u do, sum one u love will surprise u sum how!! If u don't , u will lose ur love.!!
sk8louie 2 years ago
great song
Santoslhelpa 2 years ago 2
Oh yeah, And I love Damn Yankees. =D
thomyorkeswonkyeye 2 years ago
But I also listen to bands like Open Hand, AFI, Something Corporate, Taking Back Sunday.....and bands like Atreyu, Bullet For My Valentine, Avenged Sevenfold, My Children My Bride, Eyes Set To Kill, and Dance Gavin Dance. I listen to a lot of different things. But things like this, where people butcher classic songs is not something I can appreciate.
thomyorkeswonkyeye 2 years ago
I totally agree with u man. no one can sing like sebastian bach he is great and no one should even attempt something like this where you can't improve the song becuz its already amazing
18andLifeSR 2 years ago
but i also gotta give these guys props for attempting it. great tune no matter who plays it but just can't beat the original
18andLifeSR 2 years ago
I'm 13. I love Skid Row, Scorpions, Journey, Night Ranger, Tesla, Steelheart, Warrant, Motley Crue, Whitesnake, Cutting Crew, Don Henley, Led Zepplin, Styx, Bad Company, Kansas, Boston, and David Bowie. None of this is influenced by my parents. I was raised around country music. Not all teens listen to whats popular now. As a matter of fact, I hate all of the music played on popular radio stations. I HATE this version of I Remember You AND I hate the new lead singer of Skid Row.
thomyorkeswonkyeye 2 years ago
@thomyorkeswonkyeye whoa.
nailaXDos 2 years ago
solo si no te gusta no la escuches, mi padre me influencio de la misma manera y la verdad esa musica es la mejor pero hay bandas actuales que tienen esas mismas influencias y las usan muy bien creo que esta es una de ellas
bueno es mi punto de vista
angustrato 2 years ago
Personaly i own dif stuff from whats popular and i love some bands tht ppl have never heard of :) tht and i dont own a i-pod so dont knock the teen population! Go Atreyu!!
zenex57 2 years ago
you all need to stfu your like 40 now.. all you know is jean jackets and leather pants haha ya that was soo much better
biznasty44 2 years ago
what a terrible cover, .i hate pop emo fag bands that try to cover killer 80s bands, .just dont do it..almost as bad as afi covering guns n roses
bennyratt 2 years ago
I actually thought that smooth criminal sucked
animeloverryan85 2 years ago
yea, ..that song sucked too, .they got money off of covering something...lame
bennyratt 2 years ago
still I like this cover though, but I never did like much of any other covers except Johnny Cash. And face it, Nobody can do a better "Dancing With Myself" The Donnas, Blink 182, Green Day, nobody... However, I did like Dope's cover of his trademark "Rebel Yell" but sorry Murderdolls is no good when they did "White Wedding"
animeloverryan85 2 years ago
yea, ..theres just some bands that shouldnt cover stuff.. especially classics from the 80s metal era....its like "leave it alone..its a masterpiece ..dont ruin it.." lol
bennyratt 2 years ago
hahahaha i love Joey Jordison, but i kinda think Murderdolls sucked all around haha!
tjews234 2 years ago
haha wow really? i mean i dont mean to dispute you but i loved it lol
tjews234 2 years ago
thats funny that you think skid row is a killer band
DirtyHallPromotions 2 years ago
what are you like 15 ...
let me guess , whatever is popular at the time thats what you have on your i-pod right?
you could take the worst band from the 80s and put em up against the best bubblegum pop band of today and it would just be an embarrassment , but opinions are opinions
bennyratt 2 years ago
actually im 28. and i dont own a ipod. i just hate skid row , i hate Sebastian Bach. i hate 80's hair metal.
DirtyHallPromotions 2 years ago
im 27.. and if it wasnt for 80s metal there would be no rock music of today ... obviously it aint to bad if everyone wants to cover all their songs..
bennyratt 2 years ago 3
dude, Ataris totally is not a pop emo fag band. They are punk rock and if they arent they deffinetly a pop emo fag band, and some of us like them
tjews234 2 years ago
Ditto.
SuuperSparky 2 years ago
haha the only normal comment :D xxscene
Zamaryka 2 years ago 4
ahhhh.the ataris do ahmazing covers.
XxSceneMuchxX 2 years ago 31
@XxSceneMuchxX hell yes they do
googoorockfan 3 months ago
Haha, I was just reading the comments below, and was thinking "Damn, that guy said "well said" before I could.
Then I was like, oh.. that was me :D
4cellar2door0 2 years ago
stfu no one cares nigga
willk55 2 years ago
You're white, shut the fuck up "nigga".
4cellar2door0 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Dude your starting to piss me off, come to Channelview and come get some bitch. I'll meet you anywhere.
I just wanna see how much shit you can talk with a fat lip and black eye.
jamescgale 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
What the fuck is channelview?
How about meet me in my fuckin CITY bitch.
Fuck this internet talk, man up queer.
4cellar2door0 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Oh my bad, I thought you were from Houston dick.
You talk so much shit because you've never had your ass beat. Believe me punk, I'd fuck you up. If I ever go to "A-town" I'll be sure to let you know, I'd never miss a chance show you how we deal with fucks like you.
jamescgale 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Talk is cheap pussy.
You said you wanted to man up, so get on a plane or shut the fuck up.
4cellar2door0 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Shut your face loser, you said you grew up in Houston, yet never heard of Channelview? I think your so full of shit.
If I did go to Austin, and I doubt you even live there, would you fight me with a dictionary? Your like a gnat buzzing around my face. Go bug the shit outta somebody else. Fucking loser.
jamescgale 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Nice cop-out.
"I doubt you live there"
aha
Yeah.. now the bitch is starting to come out.
Don't talk shit when you know your faggot ass can't man up.
Oh, and I don't have a dictionary, assjockey. I retain knowledge.
Suck a dick trick.
4cellar2door0 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
ahahahaha cellar door is a fuckin fruit cakee bitchin everyone out on youtube WOW your just fuckin crazy I want to be just like you.
PloughManDigMyEarth 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Eat a dick.
4cellar2door0 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
all a you, get laid.
n3cr0x 2 years ago
This song is +on my life :D
Pentagr4m 2 years ago
btw, it isnt hard to do a punk cover of a song and make it sound good. And two of the ataris biggst songs are covers lol whats that tell you.
nothinisavailable 3 years ago
As much as i prefer the original, this cover isn't as bad as i expected
NoTransitory0 3 years ago
Good cover.
:)
i love the ataris.
tessathedino 3 years ago
my contribution to this original vs. cover argument is that as good as a cover is, you cannot go slagging the original. Skid row and sebastien bach are amazing for having written this. Appreciate the cover, love the cover, but RESPECT the original, the ataris obviously do.
nothinisavailable 3 years ago 3
Well said.
4cellar2door0 3 years ago
this is better than "i remember you two"
spartafxrs5 3 years ago
this is probably the best one off punk goes metal
kloppsta18 3 years ago
The Ataris are punk, not a bunch of emos. This is way better than the original, oh yeah, you suck, blink 182 rocks
jmd182 3 years ago
eww WTF?
RedDragon45 3 years ago
You clicked it, retard.
4cellar2door0 3 years ago
I actually thing this is one of the best songs ever made, if you dont like it, dont listen to it, I actually think the original sucks your balls, but w/e, I really dont care. THIS SONG ROCKS!
klrocks0 3 years ago
me too! this is one of my favourite songs ever
kaaarl89 3 years ago
... why must emo bitchs fucking up good songs...
tjrichardson90 3 years ago
arrrrr for fuck sake this is awful..arghh
RACERXrg550 3 years ago
Their only good cover is Boys of Summer.
Ikkiku 3 years ago
auz toh mga tol...!!!
ehahahaha!!!!!
-jel :]
badrobot8869 3 years ago
this is horrible. This was meant to be a slow ballad song, not some fast bullshit song, that sounds like Blink 182 wrote it. Way to fuck up another classic you fuckers.
Overture2152 3 years ago
blink 182 sucks
Yolumer 3 years ago
i agree
lucky90445 3 years ago
they we're simply the best
nixxx04 3 years ago
Garbage.
bronc30td 3 years ago
Hmm... The speed and vocals, imo, take away from the emotion that the original had. But they did a nice job "converting" it to their own style, I guess.
Melee54 3 years ago
Its more Pop Rock.
ashkaradur718 3 years ago
thanks for fucking up another classic song
87buickgn10 3 years ago
this SUCKS
Fyrecracker396 3 years ago
great job! love the ataris
joenow7 3 years ago
Lol at all the people who jerk off while watching skid row's cockrockvideo.
The Ataris FTW
dannyramone10 3 years ago
Definetly ATARIS reallly improved this song. ATARIS FTW
waterboy688 3 years ago
The Ataris did a very good good, I enjoy their music alot more than I enjoy Skid Rows.
rapman69696969 3 years ago
thats because your a douche.
LightningStrikes89 3 years ago
Prolly not.
rapman69696969 3 years ago
your mom is a douche
waterboy688 3 years ago
Brooklinite 3 years ago 2
and just to add,
i liked skid rows much better.
Brooklinite 3 years ago
You're so right regarding what a "cover" is.
I like new interpretations. This ones a nice Punk version. but i like the original more. so whats the point in flaming this song?
the8t88 3 years ago 2
fisrt off,the ataris arent a punk band,they are a pop band. second. this version sucks,they make it sound like something blink 182 would write, although the solo did sound kinda cool. and sebass's scream.
LightningStrikes89 3 years ago
Did not know the Band before. Sorry for the Missjudge. I agree on that this song just does not "feel right".
What I meant was: whats the point in flaming something that is indisputable?
the8t88 3 years ago 2
Wow, they couldn't even get their guy to sing it at 2:41 and had to use Bach's voice. What a joke
VBackseatRomeoV 3 years ago 2
lol i luv how every ones like skid rows is way better cuz o nskid rows osme douche bag said this version was better i mwiht uguys skid row all the way
ironmaiden530 3 years ago 2
fuck you, skid row kicks ur fucking asses
gunsnrosescolin2 3 years ago 2
lol..
dokee25 3 years ago
is this guy trying to imitate baz's voice? this song isnt a type a song to be covered by a punk band
iluvroknrol93 3 years ago 3
this is a disgrace...
jonvistal 3 years ago 4
@jonvistal Jonvistal is a disgrace :D !!!
DarkHawk139 1 year ago
@DarkHawk139 what did i comment on this song man? hehehe sorry can't fu*king remember...
jonvistal 1 year ago
i0bsessEasily 3 years ago 2
This is nothing compared to the original - but still kinda fun.
AwakeAudio 3 years ago 3
nice one,but still i like the original
bring back sebastian on the skid row
johnny solinger is a piece of shit
bach is one of the greatest rock vocalist of all
adjoyce69 3 years ago 5
way to shit on a classic,
they just sped it up and got a lesser singer...
Acquisto 3 years ago 5
Yeah, this does suck. 100% GARBAGE....
20000914 3 years ago 5
@20000914 100% your mom getting banged....
timodude1985 1 year ago
@Acquisto fuck off you stinky ass cunt
LpxMusic 1 year ago
@Acquisto thats what a cover is! to make it their own not just a copy
jrack13 1 year ago
this SUCKS!!!!!! skid row forever ataris sucks high ass donkey dick
tamadrummer20 3 years ago 5
fuckin shit.
CD1127 3 years ago 4
this is very cool! but the original, is still the original! ;)
Redaktobot 3 years ago 4
way to butcher a great song..
jlam03 3 years ago 2
Me gusta de Ataris pero este cover si apesta.........
MCasty2k 3 years ago
bho una delle peggiori che abbia mai sentito
one of the worst songs i've ever heard (the cover)
Mephi23 3 years ago 3
I though this was gonna suck but actually i like it
fw000008 3 years ago
beautiful version of a great song
TommyLeftOfTheDial 3 years ago
che cagata...
Ste90PH 3 years ago