Hayley Westenra VS. Celtic Woman Amazing grace (new version)

[UndercoverCracker]

Hayleys voice is annoying...

[wiililwilly]

Both versions are GREAT; You can't just pick one

[rodman23t]

hayley is good but celtic woman is better

[megamichaeljames]

CELTIC WOMAN hands down!!!

[RMortonJ]

This is a no-brainer. The Celtic Women with Lisa Kelly is by far the best rendition I have ever heard. The bagpipe players put this song over the top. They are a true gift and I am glad they share their talent with the world.

[wksoh]

Wow,.. these voices send chills trhough my spine,.. over and over... :)

[MrHourofPower]

well done !!!

[Tangerine258]

hayley!!!!!! of course

[Theclowcard]

No offense but both versions are beautiful even though I'm an atheist. Their voices are beautiful and angelic in the very distinctive ways. Personal preference or not, saying which version is better and which one can be offensive to fans of the other sides. Therefore, I vote for both of the version. Lisa's voice is sweet while Chloe express her warmth to the audience. Alex's is friendly while Lynn's is haunting. Hayley's voice can be described as crystal.

There is no loser here. Stop comparing

[MrsAngelLover]

still Hayley but I also still gonna say that both versions are beautiful and the musical harmony within Celtic woman is amazing.

[27flocke]

finde ich total scheisse beides in ein video einzubauen,

[a2sean2]

the song in itself is amazing

[thoughtfulspeechless]

I don't think they should be compared at all.

[oddball1711]

Hayley rules

[unclesam21]

no brainer - haley

[enricodezottis]

Hayley Westenra always sounded more true and natural - even when she was part oc Celtic Woman. To me.

[oakleymelton]

whoever is making fun of my nephew

[nascar11000]

first time i heard this sent chills up my spine

[poolsa4]

i think hayley gained some weight

[Nephelos]

Hayley was just playing a special role in CW, she wasn't meant to be a member forever, was she?

[aMeeh82]

celtic woman is way better..they are awesome..

[bethieishere]

I don't think this is fair because Hayley was a part of the Celtic Woman and left to go solo. No one can beat any of them they shouldn't be compared!

[Tentenboy100]

Does anyone knows if Orla and Meav might come back after they finish their solos album

[scuilly99]

I like Haley but I like Celtic Woman's version better...

[walterrts]

It's is fair because Celtic woman only sing 1 version of Amazing Grace.

[TheAndyz17]

okay so you have 4 different versions of hayley singing amazing grace and only 1 version of celtic woman, how is that fair!? and i still like celtic woman!!!

[kidwiz999]

This version is much better than the other one

[twilightblessings]

Celtic woman's one is beautiful, Hayley's one is stunning

[7munion3]

I vote Hayley in her earlier videos but Celtic Woman for their recent version.

[glancb2011]

I vote for Hayley because she has the most amazing voice

[tasafari444]

Celtic woman version is very beautiful, but I still go with Hayley because she has the most amazing voice I have heard

[walterrts]

hayley westenra is the best

[kidwiz999]

I said this on the last video and I will say it again. I vote for Hayley Westenra. Her voice is like an angel. Everytime I listen to her singing, I feel like I'm in heaven.