Criticos! Como diablos pretenden encajar un libro en dos horas? Yo creo que se hizo un buen trabajo. Hay que aprender a deslindar una obra de la otra.
So for me as first gen indian amer. i loved it..the details..the father..exactly like my father. i gotta say..sorry to all of you who liked him..but i didnt love Kal penn in it..i wished it was someone else..but i dont dislike him either.i jsut wished for a better one. In the movie i see it as ashima's film, not totally but somewhat more. she was wonderful and to me.she made the film...well i jsut wish there were MORE films as this!
Even if what they say is true..its nt the same..beucase there are not TONS of indian assmilation films out there as he said there are with jewish films.
This movie's based off a book... bullshitting it and making it how these guys want it would completely disrespect the book. I really want to see this movie, because the book was so good.
I am surprised to see how America has perceived the movie and specially by the critics. Firstly, the movie is an experimental narrative because it leaves viewers to decide who were the protagonists. was it the parents or the children?
and secondly, the movie is not an individualized film at all. Whereas much of Hollywood is obsessed with Hero's journey narrative and classic hollywood structure and for them to think otherwise is impossible.
Criticos! Como diablos pretenden encajar un libro en dos horas? Yo creo que se hizo un buen trabajo. Hay que aprender a deslindar una obra de la otra.
84confusion 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Bengali's are ugly.
They should have picked an uglier leading character, not Kal Penn.
peanutbutterblah 3 years ago
So for me as first gen indian amer. i loved it..the details..the father..exactly like my father. i gotta say..sorry to all of you who liked him..but i didnt love Kal penn in it..i wished it was someone else..but i dont dislike him either.i jsut wished for a better one. In the movie i see it as ashima's film, not totally but somewhat more. she was wonderful and to me.she made the film...well i jsut wish there were MORE films as this!
ddtoots 3 years ago
Even if what they say is true..its nt the same..beucase there are not TONS of indian assmilation films out there as he said there are with jewish films.
ddtoots 3 years ago
This movie's based off a book... bullshitting it and making it how these guys want it would completely disrespect the book. I really want to see this movie, because the book was so good.
Vaduh 3 years ago
damnn ass wipes..the namesake's something which these freaks will never understand..so why make a review!!??
pritamttu 3 years ago
its Jhumpa Lahiri not Jumbo Lahiri and film critics are inconsequential to the society and film makers
Shaswata 4 years ago 2
I am surprised to see how America has perceived the movie and specially by the critics. Firstly, the movie is an experimental narrative because it leaves viewers to decide who were the protagonists. was it the parents or the children?
and secondly, the movie is not an individualized film at all. Whereas much of Hollywood is obsessed with Hero's journey narrative and classic hollywood structure and for them to think otherwise is impossible.
paddyshenkman 4 years ago 3
lol they said this fails... the beginning did, but the rest of the movie was great.
deepkut129 4 years ago 2
wtf fuck are these retards!
killokone 4 years ago 2
these idiots...can't even pronounce the fucking names!
websurfer98 4 years ago 6
These guys have NO idea what they are talking about. "This movie shows that the world is an arranged marriage"... what the hell does that mean???
pri678 4 years ago 4
fuck that shit i love that movie
punxgonkaos 4 years ago 2