Your too kind!!!!!!! A Feckin' hard song to decide how to play.......Luke Fucked us all up with the definitive version.....but what the hell???....the craich's good just the same
I'm not sure I've heard any versions I like so much as the one we're referring to, or indeed which others I've heard. Saw once Van Morrison do a version on telly but seemed shambolic to me. Even saw Kavanagh himself sing it,but he hadn't an especially melodic voice. Interesting you quoted Cohen too - he's perhaps my favourite singer-songwriter. All the best,
Leonard and Tom Waites both do melancholy like Luke.....I think!!!!!!!Kavanagh done it on RTE in the late 40's but I don't have a recording........but Have heard it isn't a patch on Luke's version....just 'cos you wrote it doesn't mean someone won't do it justice...but that's where the talent is.......and anyone can have a wee shot
For my personal taste, I'd say it lacks the necessary melancholy of the particular version I love. I find the harmonies a distraction also, the strings too plucky.
Spot on!.......Just a wee try at a one guitar version........and nobody done "melancholy" like Luke.......Please post any other good versions you've heard...Luke is the only one I've ever heard worth attempting
Magic our Pat.
jojogun 2 years ago
Pat....I love this tune, and I'm very touched with what you've done with it. Here's to ya, bro.....Rob
joebbbaaaw1 2 years ago
A very beautiful song ... I love the melody and voices as well ... greetings from germany, GRIT
fvfrau 2 years ago
I've waded thro dozens of versions of this song on UTube. About 98% of them are rubbish or worse.
This one is very good. You've done a good job on verse 3 which is not easy to get right.
Im very impressed -
- especially since english is not your first language.
BillKurrin2 2 years ago
shite -----so it must be brilliant.
MrWeecha1 2 years ago
The ultimate accolade..............
Had to think of some feckin' version that hadn't been tried
My fav comment!!!!!
Ta
Pat Savage
ourpat1 2 years ago
@MrWeecha1 Freakin right it's brilliant...........
savageberny 1 year ago
Awesome recording, well done!
totz83 3 years ago
Your too kind!!!!!!! A Feckin' hard song to decide how to play.......Luke Fucked us all up with the definitive version.....but what the hell???....the craich's good just the same
ourpat1 3 years ago
sounds great-very enjoyable!
mizzissippiblues 3 years ago
I'm not sure I've heard any versions I like so much as the one we're referring to, or indeed which others I've heard. Saw once Van Morrison do a version on telly but seemed shambolic to me. Even saw Kavanagh himself sing it,but he hadn't an especially melodic voice. Interesting you quoted Cohen too - he's perhaps my favourite singer-songwriter. All the best,
Jim
grobbledonk 3 years ago
Leonard and Tom Waites both do melancholy like Luke.....I think!!!!!!!Kavanagh done it on RTE in the late 40's but I don't have a recording........but Have heard it isn't a patch on Luke's version....just 'cos you wrote it doesn't mean someone won't do it justice...but that's where the talent is.......and anyone can have a wee shot
Pat
ourpat1 3 years ago
For my personal taste, I'd say it lacks the necessary melancholy of the particular version I love. I find the harmonies a distraction also, the strings too plucky.
grobbledonk 3 years ago
Ah well grobbledonk. You can't please them all.
How long have you fancied Luke Kelly? I hope your ears get better soon. When's your next record out?
jojogun 3 years ago
I don't make records, nor would i ever want to. I don't even buy them
grobbledonk 3 years ago
Spot on!.......Just a wee try at a one guitar version........and nobody done "melancholy" like Luke.......Please post any other good versions you've heard...Luke is the only one I've ever heard worth attempting
Pat
ourpat1 3 years ago
Or as Leonard Cohen said we have to:
"Ring the bells that still can ring Forget your "perfect" offering There is a crack in everything Thats how the light gets in"
Pat
ourpat1 3 years ago
good stuff
GERRYSMILES999 3 years ago
VERY GOOD VERSION.
nice pics in the video.
breffnipark 3 years ago
wow great rendition...love the rhythm!
JoeyPencils 3 years ago
Not an easy song to get your head round
Decided to do it in open tuning.DADF#AD
works quite well for one guitar
Pat
ourpat1 3 years ago
Wow =) Thanks for the message. This is brilliant!!
ANNIQUEthatsRiGhT 3 years ago
You'r too kind.just a wee carry on at home.....but I love the Cavanagh and Luke
ourpat1 3 years ago
I really like that its done as a duo, keep on singing you two! (All we have in the USA is karaoke lord help us!)
ps who doesnt love Luke???
;)
joeygsmom 3 years ago
Such a great song and a GREAT job. I love your accent:)
Beadazzle10 3 years ago
Brilliant Pat.
jojogun 3 years ago