Bad acting, the music in the background was just grating...I know you didn't have a lot of time to work on this but I would expect better from you :\.
it was good, but i pictured colin with brown hair, and john green sort of mentions throughout the book that colin has a jew-fro, so the kid who played hassan seemed like a better better for playing collin. and i picture lindsey with light hair, but thats about it.
you think the acting is just bad? all of it is bad! im sorry, i mean i understand its just for fun but honestly no one looks like their supposed to and theres no emotion and i loved this book, but this is not a good representation of it!
Sorry to be a perfectionist! BUT Colin is supposed to have glasses and an awesome jew fro! and Hassan is supposed to be fat and Muslim. Otherwise it was a good adaptation.
I think this was really, really, really well done. The music in the background was a little loud. But it makes a LOT more sense in the context of having read the book. Last time I watched this, I didn't get it. :/
Instead of all of the nerdfighters waiting forever for some big shot Hollywood guy to direct it, you should just make An Abundance of Katherines! (If you want to of course.)
I've only just got round to watching this Alan, I didn't want to get spoiled while reading (though, to be fair, I read it like two weeks ago and only just remembered to watch it) - really nice entry, good casting, dialogue, etc - I like! :)
Colin doesnt really look like Colin and neither does really ANY of them...or what the book described them as after reading the book, which was very good btw....nice tho XD
I just started/finished Katherines, so I finally allowed myself to watch this video. Seeing it acted live makes me realize how weird Colin is. Weird, but awesome.
ON THE NEAREST POSSIBLE FRIDAY BY THE LOVE OF YOUR LIFE. TOMORROW WILL BE THE BEST DAY OF YOUR LIFE. HOWEVER IF YOU DONT POST THIS COMMENT TO AT LEAST 3 VIDEOS YOU WILL DIE WITHIN 2 DAYS. NOW UV STARTED READIN DIS DUNT STOP THIS IS SO SCARY. SEND THIS OVER TO 5 VIDEOS IN 143 MINUTES WHEN UR DONE PRESS F6 AND UR CRUSHES NAME WILL APPEAR ON THE SCREEN IN BIG LETTERS. THIS IS SO SCARY Cuz IT ACTUALLY WORKS THIS reaLLY WORKS
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
no offense but the actions so dif. Lindsey never sits on the back, the burning notes took place at Lindsey's house. Colin is not as good looking as the novel describes.
Gah...Gah, I did Horribly, oh my god.. seriously I am ashamed of myself. Haha, but great work everyone else. Todd, you Rock and whoever adapted the script, nice. Looked great for such little time of filming.
That was truly awesome! I waited until I finished An Abundance of Katherines (I finished about 5 minutes ago) before I watched this and it didn't disappoint.
I like your take on the book though. You've definitely wet my appetite for a full movie adaptation of the book.
Whoever bought the rights should seriously consider making it a movie. Maybe even have you and Todd involved in its production/direction as well? I can only hope :-)
Well written and produced. Acting was a little iffy, and I'm not sure it's exactly what the Sketchies is looking for. This was more of a nice short film as opposed to a comedic sketch. Good job overall.
I don't think I commented earlier to say how awesome this was, but even if I did: awesome. I love that book, and it's hard to make me happy with an adaptation, but you did.
Now that would be a great secene in the movie (parden my spelling if i miss spelled anything))
jmaster1324 3 months ago
cute, if a little fast paced
dolphin64575 7 months ago
Interesting to see the dialog in actual motion. Too bad none of it contained "fug" or "fugging." :P
Noyjeetut 1 year ago 3
This was awful and incredibly inaccurate. Especially... everthing about it.
animelattack 1 year ago
A very nice adaptation, but it was weird to give Colin a guitar.
fuzzheadwriter 1 year ago
I liked this. Its cute. (:
angelgal9514 1 year ago
Bad acting, the music in the background was just grating...I know you didn't have a lot of time to work on this but I would expect better from you :\.
aukluk 1 year ago 2
Jew fro? No?
insanitylives 1 year ago
it was good, but i pictured colin with brown hair, and john green sort of mentions throughout the book that colin has a jew-fro, so the kid who played hassan seemed like a better better for playing collin. and i picture lindsey with light hair, but thats about it.
otherwise, it was good :)
mufasaproductionsyo 2 years ago 4
and hassan was um..... i can't remember but he wasn't white. lol
daltiepoo 2 years ago 5
@daltiepoo Arab I think.
Toastisntsquare 2 years ago
burn that shite.
rockyqw12 2 years ago
this made my day!!!
but Lindsy sort of acts like.....insanely annoying
notfromaway12 2 years ago 3
I picked up that book cause my name is Katherine, and ended up absolutely loving it
ggggtgtg 2 years ago 8
omg ii diid exactly da same thiing! hehe! awesome book! ii also ended up lovviin da author :)
PrincessK98 2 years ago 3
you think the acting is just bad? all of it is bad! im sorry, i mean i understand its just for fun but honestly no one looks like their supposed to and theres no emotion and i loved this book, but this is not a good representation of it!
BigKLittleT 2 years ago
dude if the movies gunna be like this its gunna put the book to shame:/ sorry but the acting is bad
zewbag 3 years ago
people refuse to read the description...
TGracia93 2 years ago
it was good, but the song kind of ruins it. shame, shame.
kthxrae 3 years ago
Sorry to be a perfectionist! BUT Colin is supposed to have glasses and an awesome jew fro! and Hassan is supposed to be fat and Muslim. Otherwise it was a good adaptation.
SelinaCollins 3 years ago 3
i like it very much... don't find the right words... but... awesome might do it!!!
BrettLikesCows 3 years ago
I looove this book!
i checked it out in my school library.
Very good!
I wish there was a movie(:
Acting sucks,sorry.:D
AhBabyDoll 3 years ago 4
i forgot if it's in the book, but i always figured lindsey was blond.
banishedangel6 3 years ago 3
that's okay, i figured hassan was asian...im pretty sure that was in the book
conorr6 3 years ago
this made me cringe
GeeWizz9528 3 years ago 4
this is so embarrassing. i never realized how awful my acting actually was.. haha.
noradoane 3 years ago
awfull acting lol, but i love that book
lydiam12 3 years ago 20
watching this vid back when it was first made made me want to read the book
i did and i loved it thanks guys
JimandPamfan 3 years ago
You did an awesome job!
greengurlluvzanime 3 years ago
I hate Parabolas (the graph) they are pretty hard
XxAustin00xX 3 years ago
ha, isnt hassan supposed to have man boobs tho?
loved it!
malteasermia1 3 years ago
Yeah...and he's kinda supposed to be Arab.
DOESN'T MATTER, AAOK IS MY BFF!
SpecialStory 3 years ago
Not great acting, and I winced when Colin, a highly intelligent person adept at a dozen languages, pronounced Kafka like an idiot.
ArdelSchwartzenguy 3 years ago 6
great editing, ok acting...
hamsterpoop 3 years ago 4
Made of pure awesome!
horsewhisperer990 3 years ago 3
Omg. A Honda element.
I have one too.
tsorett 3 years ago
ooo I love it!
TehKoolGeek 3 years ago 2
i agree with steviethegreat07 .
the book, plus this is great!
projoX 3 years ago
I think this was really, really, really well done. The music in the background was a little loud. But it makes a LOT more sense in the context of having read the book. Last time I watched this, I didn't get it. :/
Great job, guys!
Steviethegreat07 3 years ago
I finally read Katherines, and FINALLY got to watch this! I really liked it! Great job!! :)
Christi543 3 years ago
oh yeah , is this to be continued , or was that it?
MarineCorpsready 3 years ago
I can finally watch this because I finally read the book! Great video.
malinarana 3 years ago
Awesome. And a half. !!!
pancakeorama 3 years ago
Instead of all of the nerdfighters waiting forever for some big shot Hollywood guy to direct it, you should just make An Abundance of Katherines! (If you want to of course.)
valrockstar328 3 years ago
I've only just got round to watching this Alan, I didn't want to get spoiled while reading (though, to be fair, I read it like two weeks ago and only just remembered to watch it) - really nice entry, good casting, dialogue, etc - I like! :)
jerryhcooke 3 years ago
Colin doesnt really look like Colin and neither does really ANY of them...or what the book described them as after reading the book, which was very good btw....nice tho XD
piratecat101 3 years ago
awesome, man. This vid really got me to read the book! Thanks!
migps2 3 years ago
ily.
MrsStephanieSnape 3 years ago
I haven't read the book, so i was a little bit lost. But, now I absolutly have to go out and buy the book! It was a good video! :]
LionChica5 3 years ago
you should make a whole movie ^^
swordguilds 3 years ago
I just started/finished Katherines, so I finally allowed myself to watch this video. Seeing it acted live makes me realize how weird Colin is. Weird, but awesome.
ISnoggedHarry 3 years ago 3
Thanks Samantha, glad you finished reading. =)
fallofautumndistro 3 years ago
Oh man, I loved this book. And this is so amazing.
Decembers 3 years ago
Spread Abundance and Peace and you shall receive it.
Deanna
giftofabundance 3 years ago
Mo heckadang! That was a good adaptation. Totally awesome!
gloveboxburrito 4 years ago
i liked it
Thisplaceissoempy 4 years ago
Loving it...and the music. That's Danger is My Middle Name out of Chicago....Right....They are awesome.
lcox6 4 years ago
Yup, that's them. =)
fallofautumndistro 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
ON THE NEAREST POSSIBLE FRIDAY BY THE LOVE OF YOUR LIFE. TOMORROW WILL BE THE BEST DAY OF YOUR LIFE. HOWEVER IF YOU DONT POST THIS COMMENT TO AT LEAST 3 VIDEOS YOU WILL DIE WITHIN 2 DAYS. NOW UV STARTED READIN DIS DUNT STOP THIS IS SO SCARY. SEND THIS OVER TO 5 VIDEOS IN 143 MINUTES WHEN UR DONE PRESS F6 AND UR CRUSHES NAME WILL APPEAR ON THE SCREEN IN BIG LETTERS. THIS IS SO SCARY Cuz IT ACTUALLY WORKS THIS reaLLY WORKS
sythryu 4 years ago
Love this one. Especially since my name's Katherine. =-P
RedVelvet777 4 years ago
thats not how i predicted colin
SelinaCollins 4 years ago
i just realised that's the 5 awesome guys theme tune playing on the radio at the begining!
pol1407a 4 years ago
i <3 it!!!! you should do this for looking for alaska
bella91xox 4 years ago
lol -4 from the director i guess, im just trying to help. ur summarized almost 2/4 of the book in 3 mins
MSnoobiest 4 years ago
Is there gonna be any more to this???
Seemed like it was going to be good and iwant to know what happens from there.
SquintzGraves 4 years ago
It's based on the novel "An Abundance of Katherines" by John Green. If you want to know what happens, read the book.
TheWrittingOnTheWall 4 years ago
wo!
SelinaCollins 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
no offense but the actions so dif. Lindsey never sits on the back, the burning notes took place at Lindsey's house. Colin is not as good looking as the novel describes.
MSnoobiest 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
oh em gee, this is so unlike the book. I read it, it's awesome. People dun be lazy watching movies unstead of reading books xD.
MSnoobiest 4 years ago
continue!!!
Prelude1814 4 years ago
I is monkey
toxictemper 4 years ago
Gah...Gah, I did Horribly, oh my god.. seriously I am ashamed of myself. Haha, but great work everyone else. Todd, you Rock and whoever adapted the script, nice. Looked great for such little time of filming.
resiewnoj 4 years ago
why does it end there?
orangelaundryload 4 years ago 3
what is the song that is playing and who is it by?i want to add it to my ipod like...asap please.=]
hannahkat93 4 years ago
Rate: Check
Favourite: Check
Comment.......CHECK :D
nice video guys. keep up d gud work!! a sequel wud be deadly!
lynnetube 4 years ago 2
This is awesome for only five days! Love it! Any part two coming?
thirrin3 4 years ago
mooooore
GerardsLady 4 years ago
The girl is really pretty.
0TyMoss0 4 years ago
todd i did wat u told us 2! i actualy dont hav anything 2 say in this comment but y told us to rate comment and favorite it so i am so ya bye!
ps. awesome vid!!!
note the word^_^
get it? ah forgetit
the2ellies 4 years ago
AWESOME!
Duskamber 4 years ago
how come hassan wasn't indian!
(other than that little mishap, i loved this :)
keepyourtrouserson 4 years ago
i loved the book!! i imagined everyone WAY different though.
Dragongrrl416 4 years ago
i loved the book!! i imagined everyone WAY different though.
Dragongrrl416 4 years ago 2
I want to read this book now.
this is pretty well shot and edit for 5 days of work
EdLippincott 4 years ago
DUDE!!! you shud make a series outa this..pretty good idea and theme! WANT MORE!
danish248 4 years ago
Not related to the video, but I have to say that I love the new banner :)
snotpokkit 4 years ago
The cookie one or the personals one?
fallofautumndistro 4 years ago
The cookie one!
snotpokkit 4 years ago
must..... know...... more......
iliketodothis 4 years ago
Loved it awesome, I wanna see were this goes lol
sheepybreaker 4 years ago
She is pretty! and hasn't that dude played in movies before?
0TyMoss0 4 years ago
that was pretty good! by the way, that girl was a babe.
funnysethybob 4 years ago
i really like it alot!
I didnt picture colin like that though.
haha. never pictured hassan like that either. lol.
exhumedbitterness 4 years ago
It was great, just to short.
pinkmage05 4 years ago
Awesome!
You've made me want to go out and read this book.
FantasticTwiHards 4 years ago
That was so good, make more!!! Pretty please?
flusty24 4 years ago
That was truly awesome! I waited until I finished An Abundance of Katherines (I finished about 5 minutes ago) before I watched this and it didn't disappoint.
thatisawkward 4 years ago
Wow. Five days, and that's what came of it? You guys probably have more awesome in your pinky than most people have in their whole body.
bananas1and2 4 years ago
That was just like it, very good :D
AudreyDeary00 4 years ago
I really liked it, but it bugged me that NO ONE was waring a seat belt. Thats just my maternal instincts going crazy though. :3 good job!
devobat 4 years ago 2
excellent for time given. need more video content.
wayne19g 4 years ago
That was great. Looks like you could possibly have a long term profect on your hands. Let me know if you need help!
CalebICT 4 years ago
that. was. amazing.
sevrocksthehouse 4 years ago
mmm, i didnt really like it.
jellybeansies 4 years ago
DO MORE!!!
...please? :D
CRUNKRacoon 4 years ago
Sweet. I'm doing my own adaption for Looking for Alaska (I wonder if I should e-mail John about it).
Its the barnyard prank scene =D All in the dark done with a very bad digital camera.
Quality is horrible but when its done Im ganna post it on YouTube, maybe even video responsee it to this.
I really liked this, much better then the one Im making myself xP
Sik15 4 years ago
omg after watching this i really really wanna read the book!
intherain93 4 years ago
You haven't read the book? You MUST read the book! Its soooo good.
Pawnshopheart00 4 years ago
you didnt credit the music
christiney89 4 years ago
5'D
CptnChan 4 years ago
good job [: I LOVED an abundance of katherines one of my all time faves [: Im reading a Maureen Johnson book soon too
Nerdfighters! \\//
ohkatrina 4 years ago
Very wwell done
cinamon6377137 4 years ago
excellent, well done.
For a second I thought Lindsay was drawing a venn diagram on Colin's hand...
NERDFIGHTERS! \\// \\//
re1d 4 years ago
excellent, well done.
For a second I thought Lindsay was drawing a venn diagram on Colin's hand...
NERDFIGHTERS! \\// \\//
re1d 4 years ago
Haha, that was way jokes. I love An Abundance of Katherines.
itsamountain 4 years ago
Awesome vid Alan. I love the the five awesome theme at the beginning too.
DFTBA
Scarykidd182 4 years ago
Lol that's cool
simplytakeit 4 years ago
Lol that's cool
simplytakeit 4 years ago
good job guys! looking cool.
chemicaljordan 4 years ago
ew my name is katherine scaryy.
or is it???.
nahh it is.
weird.
and this was posted on my birthday.
haha wow thats a little freaky.
polkadottts47 4 years ago
YES!
I love the book! And the Lindsey was pretty accurate (:
taylorchyeaa 4 years ago
I didnt get it.... but now i wanna read the book to try and figure it out
JustPassingThrough34 4 years ago
tottally jokez!! has john seen this?
zamxkay 4 years ago
That was really awesome.
makafeke 4 years ago 2
That's a nice story, nerd love:)
Loxard 4 years ago 2
wow! great work! and it's like I imagined in the novel! *thumps up*
BIGTomWellingFan 4 years ago
i hope u do good!
cycoG 4 years ago
that was really good!
I loved AAOKatherines and y'all picked a nifty little bit to shoot : )
laviolander 4 years ago
that was so totally jokes! awesome work you two ;)
ArockrVideos 4 years ago
Excellent job, Alan! Break a leg with the Sketchies =]
mandikinns 4 years ago
Good job! I really want to read that book! Does anybody know if its available in Ireland? I cant buy it on the internet...
The3AmigoShow 4 years ago
awesome
i havent yet read the book but i bought it the other day
just gotta finish this other book then i'll read it
is it good?
blackparadegirl93 4 years ago
now I want to read the book really really bad
LiLPunkN 4 years ago
You should, it's a great book!
fallofautumndistro 4 years ago
wow, this was really good! it would be awesome (times 5 :P) if this was like a whole movie that you made.
animefreak1301 4 years ago
Yeah, too bad the script rights for the whole film have already been sold.
fallofautumndistro 4 years ago
I like your take on the book though. You've definitely wet my appetite for a full movie adaptation of the book.
Whoever bought the rights should seriously consider making it a movie. Maybe even have you and Todd involved in its production/direction as well? I can only hope :-)
UnculturedProject 4 years ago
i really liked this alot!!!
BooderMcDoo 4 years ago
Perfectly done. Excellent.
kenrg 4 years ago
Thanks Ken!
fallofautumndistro 4 years ago
Wow that was totaly made of awesome! :D Meow!
LittleMissKit 4 years ago
well done you guys!
coughdrop01 4 years ago
amazing!
HardKor182 4 years ago
WOOOO ALAN AND TODD FOREVER.
yourstargirl 4 years ago
sitting in a tree...
fallofautumndistro 4 years ago
alan and todd nice job!!!!
:)
oberet 4 years ago
Well written and produced. Acting was a little iffy, and I'm not sure it's exactly what the Sketchies is looking for. This was more of a nice short film as opposed to a comedic sketch. Good job overall.
JohnCocktoston 4 years ago
Thanks John. Even if it's not what they're looking for, it was still fun, and gave me an excuse to ask John if I could do it. =)
fallofautumndistro 4 years ago
It's a good thing you've found a way to release some of your awesome... otherwise you might explode!
Impressive work.
tennisluvnerd 4 years ago
YAY AN ABUNDANCE OF KATHERINES!
How I loved the book.
Ifancyharrypotter 4 years ago
Thanks fancy!
fallofautumndistro 4 years ago
What did she write on his hand?
pixiel87 4 years ago
yeh...the hand thing is confusing me a bit as well :S but overall a nice watch
0oBryo0 4 years ago
"off at seven" with a big girlie heart around it.
fallofautumndistro 4 years ago
Awesome video! Great acting, too!
ObviouslyJacques 4 years ago
excellent work, scripting, editing, directing, cam work,
PerthPete1 4 years ago
will there be a continuation? :)
corteaus 4 years ago
Nice job, Alan. You must have had about 200 different edits.
nalts 4 years ago
Over ninety minutes of footage into three minutes of screen time. It was nuts. Thanks for watching Kevin!
fallofautumndistro 4 years ago
This is dumb.
J35T 4 years ago
i love this vid is awesome
Madmatt18 4 years ago
totally made of awesome.
inanimatepers0n 4 years ago
I am very impressed. Good work!
glockbell 4 years ago
Jokesness!
This book holds a special place with me because I liked it even before I discovered the amazingness that is vlogbrothers.
The movie better be as good. =)
alieinna 4 years ago
Thanks alieinna, I appreciate it!
fallofautumndistro 4 years ago
I don't think I commented earlier to say how awesome this was, but even if I did: awesome. I love that book, and it's hard to make me happy with an adaptation, but you did.
bizcakes 4 years ago
So happy to hear that bizcakes!
fallofautumndistro 4 years ago
#49 - Most Discussed (Today)
#13 - Most Discussed (Today) - Comedy
Hell yeah!!!!!!!!!
marlon8a91 4 years ago
ALAN. this was great!!! wow. Man I really want to read Johns book.
natztheflip 4 years ago
Link to buy it is in the sidebar, it's less than $10 if I remember correctly.
fallofautumndistro 4 years ago
Entertaining !
crawleykakes 4 years ago
By the way, what kind of camera did you shoot this with and what do you use to edit?
Sorry if you've already been asked a million times.
bigmetaldude 4 years ago
I use Sony Vegas for editing. I don't know the camera model, but Toddly00 does, PM him.
fallofautumndistro 4 years ago
Have you used Adobe Premiere before? If so, how would you compare the two?
By the way, thank you for making this video. I'm gonna go scour my local book store, and if I can't find it here, I'll be paying a visit to Amazon.
bigmetaldude 4 years ago
I feel like I'm watching the movie adaptation already! Good stuff, guys. (:
TangerineVampire 4 years ago
Thanks TangerineVampire!
fallofautumndistro 4 years ago