Added: 2 years ago
From: HeathDances
Views: 24,254
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (277)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • They really should have made this an episode.

  • Just perfect und beautiful ... love the music!

  • what episode is 2:45??

    love lovelovelvoelvoelvoelvoelovelo­velovelovelovelove <3

    

  • GAH!!! And the angles you've put on some of the clips for the chorus, the fades and glows, the little details like a backwards run of Isabella taking Guy's hand to show her as Marian, her "ghost"- IT'S. WOW. PURELY ROMANCE.

  • Had to come back for another viewing- this is just so fantastic. The superimposed video clips, the timing of them as well makes this video blossom like their relationship once did. Such an excellent song choice for them too and the high quality clips make it look all the more professional, even though I'm sure it would have looked just as professional had you chosen low-quality clips. There is a beautiful ribbon of story in this that flows throughout and ties a bow around the heart. Love. It.

  • Loved this to bits. Great combination of clips and music and the audio book!

  • oooh lovely. Normally im a Robin/Marian person, but I simply fell in LOVE with this!

  • Every now and again I like to re visit your old work Heather. I love your RA vids and this one makes me want to watch Robin Hood all over again......I still miss Guy :(

  • @MsHappylass Thank you!! I know I miss him too.... *sniff* :(

  • I was reading the comments and found out that you have won the 16-th place on a Guy and Marian video contest, Congratulations! I can hardly believe that there are other videos better than this! Do you happen to know which are the ones in the top list, I'm very curious to check them out!

  • AMAZING! You are very talented.The song fits perfectly, every word matches with the clips, great great job! And Guy's voice is so sad and touching. You have captured his soul, all his sorrow in losing Marian. So deep and profound! Good choice begining the video with him killing her, it gives the perception that something broke in his heart the moment she stoped breathing and he could never recover. That's true love! And ending it with Guy killing the sheriff as the one who destroyed that love!

  • This is one of the best Marian/Guy vids i've ever seen!! Really amazing! So beautiful and sad at the same time :( Great job!! <3 <3

  • Question: when did Guy say all those things? I can't recall Marian haunting Guy in S3 at all, or him narrating like that--yet it sounds like RA! am I going crazy here?

  • @silversliver87 In the description of the video I said it was from an audio book that Richard narriated called "The Witchfinders". It was an actual RH episode that they just never filmed and made it into an audiobook instead.

  • One of my new favourite videos. Great work editing it.

  • This is so moving, poignant and masterfully edited. The relationship between the lyrics and the partnering video clips was not patronising to the watcher and you managed to capture a true tenderness between these characters. The sound bites were used to great effect, adding depth to this beautiful representation of a couple that sadly never had the chance.

  • @vampirelovewerewolf Wow thank you for such a wonderful comment! Made my day! :)

  • That was so beautiful. I just love your work. The use of The Witchfinders audio was inspired and very moving. Beautiful! Thank you!

  • Wonderful video!! Great Job! =D

  • This was so beautiful, in the end I had tears in my eyes. Wonderful

  • Perfect... just... perfect, this is definitely the best video I have seen so far, and the editing is really amazing. you did an extraordinary job

  • Genius!

  • this is the BEST vid 'bot 'em, IMHO, good job!

  • This is the best video i've ever seen ! Thanks .

    I saw it before watching 2nd and 3rd seasons .

    I was absolutely sure that Marian's ghost will haunt Guy and awfully disappointed when it didn't happen . I wanted to hear the phrases from the video in the film but only later discovered that the phrases were from audiobook :)

    In any case , from then on this has been my favourite video and I extracted the audio and listen it

  • you make very good videos! but this has to be one of my favorite because this song is so sad, touching.. so beautiful!

    If if have the time Im going to check out this singers other work! :D

  • awww this is beautifully done! I loved it and I'm not even a G/M fan I've always been 100% R/M but awwwwww such a great vid!

  • Comment removed

  • what kind of program do u use to create these videos?

  • @room2h31 It says in the description. :-) I used Adobe Premiere Pro. I currently use Final Cut Pro.

  • It had to be done but I'm glad YOU did it.

  • YOU ARE AMAZING!!! please make more like these video's!!! I loved your song choice!!!

  • amazing video loved it:)

  • This is beautiful :)

  • Congrats Heather on your win! This is such an awesome video!  Perfect! how you make Marion look as though she is haunting Guy! The song is so beautiful too! You know I love your videos! Chica

  • i simply LOVE your vid.. it's fantastic!

    fav and 5/5|* ^ ^

  • Magnificent! Loved your editing, transitions, effects, clips used - all fit song/ dark mood of despair so well! Also loved the idea of Marian as a ghost haunting Guy! :) Very well done (as always)...

    5*****!

  • Heather a tad late in getting around to saying how much I love this video of yours, having watched the finale to RH2 this weekend - I knew I had to rewatch cos you capture every look, every moment, its a stand alone piece of work - thank you so much!

  • OMG This is amazing. And I don't just say that to anyone-- lots of vids watched by me, and I know a great one when I see it...the ghost bits (esp the spoken line about Marian haunting) were perfectly timed and arranged, the song fits Guy perfectly-- I was awestruck by his story in S3, it was the main redeeming part of the S3 (in more than one way)...

  • This is probably my favourite Marian & Guy video! I actually bought the audiobook because of this... Yes, I know, slightly pathetic... Maybe the bbc should pay you an advertising fee...

  • So beautiful... I love Guy of Gisborne by Richard Armitage! :)

  • WOW that was so amazing! If you know their story, it was so deep! The editing and effects were unbelievably beautiful- making her a ghost- so creative, as are all of your storylines! =D

  • ha ha ha!! Thanks so much gaby!! It is worth watching the show just to see Richard Armitage (who plays Guy)! ;-) Thanks so much for stopping buy and commenting as I admire your videos! :-)

  • *Sniff Sniff*

    This is such a wonderful video. Stupid Robin!!

    Thankyou so much.

    :)

  • This is such a beautiful video!

    5 stars.

  • Amazing video- really touching, you're right the song is beautiful and I loved how you incorporated the audiobook along with clips from the show. I think I'm beginning to love Guy's character even more now I'm watching videos like this... he's a lot more complicated than I think a lot of people give him credit for. Awesome video.

  • u r really good in making videos

  • There is a tears in my eyes... Amazing! Perfect! Beautiful! You are really the best!

  • great vid

    does anyone know what episode 2.44 is please ???

  • its season 2 episode 3 - Childhood

  • ok thankyou

  • Beautiful. Really amazing. I can't believe how incredible this is!

  • i still can't get over how truly incredible this video is.

    in my opinion it is darn near perfect.

    and i am in love with it.

    just thought i would tell you again how amazing this video and you are.

  • Wow thank you so much!! That really means a lot and appreciate it more than you know! :)

  • OMG, WOW! (Don't think other words would make it justice :)

  • Wow, this vid really stands out...and I have seen my fair share of Marian/Guy videos...than you so much, really wonderful piece of work, the effects are breathtaing and subtle at the same time. You have a real gift.

  • You did such an awesome job with this one too. I loved your video!

  • This is the best Guy and Marian video I've seen...and I've seen quite a few. The song is perfect, your editing is superb. I imagined the entire third season Marian's ghost haunting Guy. As much as I thought I'd hate the third season without Marian there to try to save Guy's soul, it turned out to be wonderful, though heartwrenching, to watch Gisborne redeem himself.

  • Ait. :)

  • De verdad pensaron que ese Robin podria hacerle sombra a Guy/Richard Armitage???...me da hasta risa.

  • Estoy completamente de acuerdo contigo.

  • I have watched so many of your videos today it's not even funny! I just love your stuff, and your editing is just amazing!

  • amazing video

  • This is amazing. Wow. I mean seriously, this is one of the best Guy and Marian videos i've seen.

    you did an amazing job.

  • Wow thank you so much!! :D

  • Excellent vid!

    What more can I say?

  • Fantastic vid. I love that Guy ;o)

  • you are not one of them? who is 'them'?

  • Ok thought I got a jerk comment and this just proves it. Actually it is not worth a thought to ask myself that question and I seriously don't care! I was just curious but I should have known asking a 15 year old who acts like a know it all. *goes off to delete her comments*

  • OMG this video is amazing!!! I'm almost in tears and I don't even ship Guy and Marian (I ship Robin and Marian) and I think that Guy has a better story line about griving for Marian. Thats makes me really annoyed. Love the ending great job! =]

  • I stumbled across the contest awards announcement vid. and saw that you'd gotten #16 for this...out of 650 videos. YES!!!! CONGRATS!

    Now everyone knows what we have known all along - that your work is AMAZING! I loved it when it came out (it made me cry), and I love it now. STILL on my FAVORITES list.

    Bravo and again, well done, Heather! ;-)

  • The Witchfinders?... I'm so happy they've thought of such extras to the series. I'm more than happy... ^_____^

  • Yes! Finally a Robin Hood video!! Great!

  • Ohmigawd. It's gorgeous. Almost made me cry.

    You deserve to meet RA and be his best friend! Or something like that.

  • Beautiful. Well done on 16th place!

    Favved and 5 stars

    xx

  • okay so i have become officially in LOVE with this video, this song, this ship, Guy, and maybe you (in a strictly platonic way)!!!

    i can NOT believe that i have not commented before now! i have only watched this video a billion times but i looked and nope this is my first comment! well shame on me, because you are freaking fantastic!

    this is sooo touching and so sad and perfect for them!

    i am love with this video. really. i get this song in my head and then HAVE to watch this vid.

    you ROCK!!

  • Oh my goodness! This video plays like a Shakespearean tragedy! Let the tears flow big time! So much disappointment, betrayal and denial between Marian and Guy yet we all wish they had a go at their unmistakable attraction to each other just the same. What a fantastic job of editing! Seems like every word matches a scene! Much oblige as always HD!!!

  • WoW! The music and the clips blend so well✁Nice job of editing. ✂♥ great video.

    Sending my happy thoughts through the looking glass.

    ♡ ƙarolyn

  • Congratulations on your 16th place. Well done.

  • Oh wow! that was beautifully done and INCREDIBLY moving! Love it!

  • Congratulations - well deserved! This is fabulous work :-)

  • And this video has won 16th place in the contest... from more than 650 vids!!!

    No wonder why LOL.

    I'm very happy for you. CONGRATS!

  • Thank you so much!! I am quite shocked as I did not think I would win anything with THAT many videos! LOL Thank you for the other comment too!! That really means a lot when you said it looks professional looking! Wow thank you!

  • Can't believe I didn't comment before on this after viewing it so many times (stopped counting after 15... LOL)

    First thing I thought (long ago): elegant vid. So brilliant editing (the ghost Marian surely has given you more than one headache) with so few effects (the less, the better IMO)

    Well, surely there are a lot of effects but so subtle and well done that the vid seems to be professional. Honest!

    And the song choice is AWESOME too!

    BRILLIANT and BEAUTIFUL. Thanks Heather!

  • One word:Stunning. Amazing how you made it, especially when Marian was always haunting Guy. Really good video. The best video of Guy & Marian I have seen. Once again, you continue to impress.

  • Wow thank you so much!! :-)

  • Another excellent video. I especially liked hearing RA's voice. Thank you so much for posting!

  • I absolutely love your video!

    It is really beautiful but also so heartbreaking...

    Amazing job :)

  • I'm in tears!

    This is wonderful.

    Love the audio bits of Richard's. They fit in soooo beautifully.

  • Lovely video, what a tragic couple, that's why I love them. In a way they remind me of Snape and Lily in Harry Potter, she was supposed to be his salvation...anyway, your editing was flawless, kudos

  • And how Snape does season 3 Guy look? <3 :D

  • This is so beautiful and fits the story of Guy to perfection. Bravo! And I love your background. I only wish I knew how to do it....I shall miss Guy, no wonder the show is cancelled. The writers killed off the main players grrr!

    Thanks for a lovely vid

  • That was a gorgeous video!!! Loved it!!!

  • Wonderful post!!!

  • This video is stunning beautiful!  It made my heart ache....but I loved every second of it! Bravo!!

  • Your videos are always wonderful! Thank you for sharing your creativity, and these lovely videos of RA!

  • Oh I'm almost speechless! I don't have the words to tell you how beautiful this is!

    Thank you!!!!!!!!!!

  • I don't know the movie but I seem to love your video. Ö

    The song is lovely too ^^

    xxx

  • ive watched this so many times and love it more each time without a doubt the best fandom video i have ever seen - now i have to get the audiobook! thanks for sharing this outstanding video with us robin hood fans especially the guy and marian ones!

  • That last quote really makes my hairs stand on end.

  • an excellent video !!! good job ^___^ you're videos for guy and marian are the best (:

  • I'm soo tired today... and I feel a bit down... It was a bad idea to watch this now...*sobbing"...I really need a lullaby and a kiss goodnight from Richard right now... :o(

  • Watch Richard's reading of "I'm not Going out there" here on YT. It's not romantic or anything, but it will make you laugh. He's so cute, and you can just imagine him reading it to a cute little kid (maybe Boucher's?). Warms the heart. *Sigh*

  • Oh Elwren, I've already seen it... (Addict to RA? Me? What made you think that?! *lol*) And as always Richard did a really good job reading "I'm not going out there"! And thank you for reminding me of the lovely scenes i N&S between Boucher's little boy and JT... I'm pretty sure Richard will be a great father some day... *sighs* I just wished I could be the mother of those children... Oh no, now I feel like weeping again... No just kidding, I'm fine! *giggles*

  • I think there are a lot of us who wish that, if we're honest! I think we just need to clone the man. *Giggles*

  • I just have to ask: In the audiobook, which character says the lines from about 4:21 and forward? I almost hate to ask, but was it Guy or was it Robin? I'm hoping it was Guy, but it was probably Robin. Still mesmerized by the beauty of this piece. Its in a playlist I use at work and people hear G's voice and wonder what its all about. Have to spread the Guy love, don't I?

  • It was Guy ;) The audiobook is fantastic. : )

  • Oh, YAY! My day is completely made now, inspite of all of the proofreading I've had to do.

  • Anyone have the ISBN number for the CD? I've been looking and looking for it here in the US but have found nothing! Maybe I could wrestle it up if I had that.

  • Yes, that cd seems impossible to find!!! I went to London/England for my first time about 2 weeks ago and I was determind to find and buy "The Witchfinders"... I think I went to 6 or 7 different big stores and still ended up with nothing!!! I even went to the BBC shop near Oxford street only to find that it had been closed down. (Oh s**t!!! *giggles*) So I too would be very thankful if someone could help us finding the cd!!!

    Take care! /M

  • You can order the CD online on Amazon UK. They will ship it to the USA. ;-)

  • I've ordered it. I'm suprised it wasn't that expensive, even though the shipping costs almost as much as the CD. In 6 to 10 days, I will be an extremely happy woman. I'll be crying listening to this I'm sure, but I'll be ecstatically happy and terribly sad at the same time. God Bless Youtube and God bless you, HeathDances!

  • I put the link to the audio book in the description!

  • Comment removed

  • This just gets BETTER every time I watch it. You have SO much talent, please keep making video's and challenging yourself, as I look forward to so many more wonderful ideas, vids, and effects you will be creating.

  • OMG I fucking hate you right now. The tears won't stop streaming down my face.

    I kid, I kid, I kid because I love....THIS VIDEO SO MUCH AND THE GODDESS THAT MADE IT

    [/capslock rage]

    sorry :S I just get so emotional with those two. GODAMMIT why can't the show just be them and their sexy times. lawl.

    beautifully timed. (s)excellent job as always Heath, pure genius. PLEASE continue to make more, I am addicted to your videos....so poignant *teartear*

  • eonderfull! i love the video even i have not seen any episodes of the show

  • i have new found respect for Guy. I always thought he was the bad guy, but really, hes not

  • Is there some place that you can listen to Witchfinders for free i relly would like to hear it ??

  • OMG this is so beautifull and sad. Thanks for posting.

  • I don't know how many times I've been watching this beatiful video but it still makes me cry... I agree with the previous comments that Guy is really mourning Marion wheras Robin is snoging with just about anything female. Makes you wonder about which one of them who really loved Marion, doesn't it? The last episode was really touching but WHY must everyone who sees a bit of goodness in Guy have to die (refering to Meg)? *sighs* It's about time something good happens to poor sir Guy! *sad smile*

  • OMG I love this video, but am still angry that they killed lady marian she was the only reason i watch the shown. And and loved her and guy. AND ROBIN SHOULD FORGETT KATE AND ISABELLA

  • I think that's one of the reasons that I like Guy better than Robin--in spite of all his evil deeds. He hasn't forgotten Marian when the very first skirt comes along. I'm still mad the writers made HIM kill her, because I think he really did love her. K, I'm getting a bit over the top here, sorry. But in a lot of ways, Guy's actually a better man than Robin (I'll keep an eye out for the arrows that are sure to come flying my way now)!

  • I completely agree!!! I love Guy so much more this season than ever before, partly because he's still tormented by Marian's death. Whereas, Robin has moved on way too quickly after his "true love" died.

  • Isn't it strange how a TV show (and a kind of campy one at that) can just haunt us? RA's so good at being a tough guy, but he lets the vulnerability bleed through--and then our hearts bleed for his character. Pure manipulation on his part, but I don't mind. It'd would be interesting to know if the show would lose more viewers if RA left than it will when JA leaves. Hopefully, we won't have to find out. Anyone know if they are planning on season 4 w/RA?

  • Oh gosh! That was brilliant! Such a beautiful song and the video was perfect.

    Thank you.

  • Hello!

    This is a beautiful and a fantastic vidéo!!

    I love!!

    I 'am very affected!! =')

    And I love this song!

    Bye!

  • Have to say:

    "Go and haunt him (Hood)!"

    Oh noooo, Hood is not haunted by Marian, Guy, he's already hunted for new snogs by Kate, Isabella and let's see who esle! -rolling eyes, sigh-

    Once more, I feel for Guy. And this audio book based video brings me to tears.... Bravo, Heather!

  • this is so well made! amazing video and i love the song too

  • I have to say this is ony of my favourite videos that you have made! I just adore it! Have seen it so many times! In faves and 5* of course! Thank you for always delighting us with amazing videos and so well-showing of the fantastic GUY/Marian relationship!

  • OMG, this is so good!!! I really miss Guy and Marian... Ok, I'm getting emotional right now... Just loved this!

  • I can't think of an accolade you haven't been accorded by us fans for all of your marvellous Guy & Marian videography.

    So, I'll thank you again from the bottom of my heart for making another beauty!

  • I love it. Being here in America sucks because they haven't even started showing it yet. So this was a nice little video to make me watch it even more.

  • This video, and this song, just continues to haunt me. Its really breath-taking. I can see that te audiobook(s) really did inspire you.

  • Had to watch again--love,love LOVE it!!!!

  • I have to know now: What is "The Witchfinders"? Another RH story in which Marian gets killed (still?). You must tell me--and tell me where to get it. I'm on a mission to find all the RA-read audiobooks possible, and if it has anything to do with GofG and Marian its even better!

    How do you do this? Every video I see of yours is absolute perfection. I'm in complete awe of your talent. I can't type because I'm too teary!

  • Thanks for another amazing video and for feeding my RA obsession.  Totally hot!

  • All i can say is beautiful work, and the song touched me too! You always bring out the best in Gisbourne-(I wonder why? :)) makes me feel for him!, and I miss Marion more than ever!

  • Comment removed

  • You are such an amazing artist. Thank you so much for sharing your beautiful talent with us! It's such a treat to watch your videos.

  • Perfectly said. Perfectly done.

  • Amazing work.

  • Absolutely beautiful video, You are so talented. Love the music with this video as well. Great choice. Your biggest FAN

  • you do such wonderful work. I love it.  I can not wait to see what else you produce keep up the good work and thank you for sharing what you work so hard on.

  • Loved it! Guy and Marian (L)

  • i can't help but tink that, if the writers/bastards

    had only seen guy/marian the way we do...

    she might have a lady giz by now.

    still betraying him to hood etc

    because otherwise the perfection would split the time space continueum... but lady giz none the less

  • Amazing!!

    Thank you so much, this was so sweet and i like the last bit best!

    Thanks xox

  • Brillent. Really Good. i love it- it made me cry :( But its so sweet the show without them is nothing. I've watch it four times now xD. 1000000/5 :D

  • brilliant, isn't the same without this pairing.

  • Just cant help myself watching this over and over. Is Favourited, Playlisted and on My Vlog so lots will see it and see how good you are at making videos.

    B :D

  • beautiful video. I love this music and Guy and Marian too.

  • Beautiful video, wonderful, beautiful effects, we hope to win because your video deserves.

    I'm starting to efforts to work with Adobe Premiere Pro is that I find to be very complicated, you have my admiration.

  • I am in awe! So clever and full of emotion -and beautiful to watch. Added to favs immediately!

  • Absolutely wonderful. Bitter-sweet. I love this. Thank you.

    Is it Sarah McLachlan singing?

  • Thank you! The song is called "My Skin" by Natalie Merchant. I put it in the end credits and also the description of the video. ;-)

  • This is absolutely spectacular!!!! Such a GREAT Job.

  • Thank you!! I really appreciate that!!

  • Absolutely stunning. You've floored me! I'm floored! 5 trillion stars and straight to favs. Wonderful work! :D

  • Wow! I floored you?? Wow thank you so much!!

  • Heartbreaking and brilliant! 5 stars and favorited, of course!

  • Thank you so much! ;-)

  • Very sad but also very beautiful! Many thanks!!!

  • Yes sad indeed, but thank you!!

  • I've just got the audio book "The Witchfinders" from Amazon today. I'll have your video in my mind while listening to it tonight. What a video!

  • Cool!! I am sure you will enjoy it or have already seeing as it has been two days! ha ha ha

  • Does anyone know where I can watch this online?

    It's beautiful by the way, well put together and everything.

  • Thank you! I think you can watch it on the BBC website but it is probably restricted for UK viewers only...sorry.

  • This video is so moving, Good work indeed!!!

  • Thank you!!

  • I have goosebumps. That was just gorgeous! aww, I miss the Guy/Marian goodness in season 2 D: Lets just hope what the sheriff said was right with "Everything is not all what it seems." ;D

    Beautiful video!

  • Thank you!! I know I do too!! I think he was warning Guy about Prince John, unfortunately. I hate the way Guy's character is being treated this season.... *sniff*

  • Probably the best video ever.

    5*

  • Wow thank you!!

  • This is truly beautiful! :) Congratulations.

    Do you think you'd be able to put up a link to download? Pleeease?

  • Thank you! Yes, soon I promise there will be a download! ;-)

  • I can't wait :). Seriously, it's amazing and I watch it multiple times a day. Lol.

    :) Brilliantly done.

  • This is about the thousandth time I've watched this video and I still can't be over it! This SHOULD be an episode. We need Marian in our lives!

  • Thank you for watching it so many times!!! I agree it should totally be an episode but we will never get it those stupid writers!!