Added: 4 years ago
From: CathysHeathCliff
Views: 155,616
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (132)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • you dont find love like this these days :(

  • it takes a lot of strength to hate, doesn't it?

  • is it jsut me or is part 12 and 13 are the same?

  • To add onto my comment a bit, when Emily Bronte wrote this it caused a scandal. People expecting a normal romance were instead treated to something scandalous - here's Cathy, a married woman, cavorting with a lover. Back then, this novel caused an outcry - today it's like nothing. The deterioration of society.

  • Reading through some of the comments on these videos, an old adage comes to mind - "Only a fool judges yesterday by today's standards."

  • His eyes when he looked at the younger Cathy were really troubled, because she looked like his lost love.

  • This is one fucked up story, but more real then the stories you expect these days...

  • wait, this heathcliff died too young-looking, comparing to edgar! hahaha!

  • The irony is... Heathcliff the adopted son survived the other 2 siblings and took control over their inheritance and descendants. Is this what the father wanted or imagined?

  • @hedonistic2008 i know he buried the hole family including the lintons.

  • seriously?! THAT ending?! that is the cheesiest thing i have EVER seen, and the sad thing is that the movie was actually pretty good.

  • @Schoolgirl325 What I meant to say was that I laughed when Nelly told Heathcliff, "Oh for Godsake,please don't keep staring like that!"

  • I laughed when Nelly says to Heathcliff, "Oh, for Gods

  • Oh my god, Ian Somerhalder IS a PERFECT Heathcliff, he already plays a cold, dark, scary, and VERY violent character.

  • at 4:14 is that cathy#1 or cathy #2 CONFUSED :S

  • @123itssophie the younger....... heatchliff never "sees" the elder catherine he can only feel her presence while he was alive...

  • Zac efron is not hasn´t the category to play heathcliff Palph Fiennes is the best

  • Who is the girl at 7:17?

  • @twiwonder the older catherine, but as a child............ in the book when the ghost of catherine grabs lockwood's hand at the beginning, she does so in her child like form, because thats how she really is, a young girl who loves the moors and is in love with heathcliff,

  • Zach Efron as Heathcliff?! ewwweeewww!!!!!

  • i'd love to see a remake of this.ian somerhalder's perfect to play as Heathcliff =)

  • @iziiluvsedward no way. he's gorgeous and I love TVD, but his eyes and demeanor and presence and voice aren't Heathcliff enough for me. he doesn't have that hardness

  • If we are still talking about other actors that the acting chops to play Heathcliffe, I can definitely picture Stephen Moyer in this role but still Ralph Fiennes plays Heathcliffe to a perfection

  • it has been 20 years and Heathcliff is the same.. LOL

  • Hurrah, he's dead. Good ridance to bad rubbish, Heathcliff.

  • Too bad Nelly didn't play as big a part in the movie as she did in the book!! I loved her narration

  • I didn't get how he died!! Did Cathy kill her??wow! This movie is sad!

  • @sprinky311 I think he just gave up and decided to be with cathy again

  • @sprinky311 I think he just gave up and decided to be with cathy again

    it's horribly sad isn't it

  • @sprinky311 well, at least there together in the end! thats a good thing, i think :D

  • @sprinky311 he stopped eating, drinking and just gave up on life to be with Cathy.

  • @sprinky311 he stopped eating, drinking and just gave up on life to be with Cathy. That's how he died in the book at least

  • LOL Who saw the arm opening the window at 8:28? :P

  • My my this film goes on forever!!

  • is that figure in white cathy?? who the heck is it? it looks like a child

  • @bsangel93 yes, it is:D

  • I love that look on Cathy's face just before Heathcliff appears in the shot with her; she can feel him before she sees him. I also love the pan flute at 8:02. It's almost like a wild fanfare, a rejoicement over the fact that they've been reunited.

  • Nelly is so awesome!

    And shes still alive! hahaha, through like 5 generations!

  • Ralph Fiennes did an amazing job! I loved the fact that he could put a dark aura into this character. (Zac Efron would be a horrible Heathcliff) *sigh* i wish i still had my book...well atleast i have my Sense & Sensibility book...SHOUT OUT TO ANY JANE AUSTEN FANS OUT THERE <3

  • oh for gods sake please stop staring like that..

  • I love this film and the book too. I don't know whether this version is better than 2009 one though. Also how come all CathysHeathCliff's videos have completely different view numbers when it is a film? Do some people skip some? Or watch a few a hundred times? :)

  • at last they are togheder...this was a lovle but very sad story.

  • this movie is extremely sad

  • music is ......trrbl

  • Thanks so much! Definitely worth reading if you haven't already.

  • Oh dear. I strongly suggest you read the book if you haven't; I've read and studied it in depth twice, and this movie still confused me with its abrupt scene changes and the cutting of many important scenes.

  • @Elvenria they could never fit everything of a book of such depth,in terms of story movies have always been inferior and cut down.

  • @Elvenria right! this movie has cut a lot of scenes written on the book which really makes me feel dismayed.

  • heathcliffe is a prick and a bitch..... but he is SOO HOT :D

  • is it just me or does cathy look a little bit like julia roberts?

  • I know its a classic but the movie was an absolute misery. Still I am compulsively drawn to read the book now.

  • Good god Heathcliffe you are a miserable prick.

  • omg, I know it's got nothing to do w/ the story, but you've got to admit that this music is terribly ennerving. It gets on my nerve, it really does. grrrrr

  • Heathcliff wasn't better. he left her, by knewing it would hurt her. He brought her to death!

  • egyptwar73 ....

    Catherine could not bear to marry heathcliff, because Hindley had reduced him very low, and marrying him would be degrading. she wanted a high, respectable social status, and so she married Edgar Linton, a wealthy magistrate !

    stupid really, but she really threw away her love fr riches and status !

  • actually that's not true, yes she accepts Linton's proposal, but she realizes she's been wrong when she talkes to Nelly, but heathcliff only hears her say that she's going to marry Linton, and then goes awy, Cathrine becomes very sick, and Linton's there for her, and she in beliveing Heathcliff wont come back agrees to marry Linton, Heathcliff actually comes back very soon after they are married.

  • I agree with a few here if say that the effects are a little old-fashioned here. But, ah, bless tem, they did well with what they had. Anyway, thei kiss on the moor, that is filmed so differently to kisses now.

  • does anyone know which part has cathy at heathcliffs window?

  • 1st one in this movie and second chapter in the book :)

  • you are true , anyway i don't know why catherine 1 left her loveer heathcliff and married another person

  • Read the book. It may help you to understand.

  • This movie kinda pissed me off. The ending is just ugh. Technically, yes it's true but the book had sooo much more mystery and that's what made it so eerie and timeless. The fact that nobody really knows what happened to Heathcliff.

  • I have mixed feelings about it... Although I liked how "eerie and timeless" Heathcliff's death was in the book, as you said, I also warmed to how they portrayed him as having joined her beyond the grave. I just wish they did it in with better effects. lol.

  • Read the bit about the little boy who couldn't take his lambs passed 'Heathcliff and a woman'...

  • one of the creepiest parts, without a doubt...oh, and the little boy also had a sheep :)

  • patetic.

    good movie thank you so much.

  • WHY

  • Where's Joseph in all of these? Lol he's quite a comic character...he's always getting pissed off lol, Edgar's grief made me sad, Heathcliff's violence made me get angry. Catherine 1's stupidity made me get angry too lol, Ellen actually made me mad bcos she never really helped both Cathy's make good choices!! She just tagged along pretending to be sum sort of confidant or guide or whatever. Anyway...the book is awesome!

  • YH i never thought of him he would make a brilliant Heathcliff

  • NO no no!

  • thank you so much for putting the movie on you tube ! i am loved the book and I now that i saw the movie i think it's great too! there isn't a better love story of Cathy's and Heathcliff's except maybe romeo and Juliet

  • the end in the book is much better....more terrible...

  • What about Billy Zane as Heathcliff or Ryan Philippe both have proven to be able to act seductive/sexy and evil.

  • I guess it would depend on the "vibe" a director was going for, but I say...

    GOTHIC/SEXY/EERIE HEATHCLIFF= STUART TOWNSEND

    (Watch the Slept So Long/concert in Queen of the Damned, you'll see why)

    BRUTE/MANLY/STRONG HEATHCLIFF= VIGGO MORTENSEN

    But NOONE will ever be able to surpass Ralph Fiennes as Heathcliff...he was able to be gothic, sexy, eerie, brute, manly, and strong ALL AT THE SAME TIME! :) That is a rare gift that he has...

  • What about Christian Bale?

  • Yeah, he might make a good Heathcliff...I loved him in Little Women and Reign of Fire! He would be MAN enough... :)

  • Ryan Phillippe no way!

    he has not shown is evil way!

    If i was Ralph Fiennes i would be so insulted to be compared to Ryan Phillippe.

    Billy Zane would work but not as well as Ralph Fiennes

  • I know what you mean but I think he did a good job playing a today /teenage version of Valmont of Dangerious Liaisons in Cruel Intentions which is supposed to be a very mean charakter. Well, okay, they made him a lot more likeable in the teenage version, but if they ever again make a modern version of it (MTV did, with Katherine Heigl) and turn Heathcliff more into a rebel character they should use Ryan.

    Come on, he has some evilness in him, he cheated on his poor wife. ;-)

  • Oh sorry I didn't noticed that I used the account of my husband. I am danifee talking to laurenlfc48

  • Haha yes true true, he would make a good modern teenage HeathCliff.

  • For all the people who keep making comments about Zac Efron playing Heathcliff...

    HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA! I just had to laugh! He is DEFINATELY not man enough to play Heathcliff...Ralph Fiennes was a perfect Heathcliff...ALL MAN and completely mesmerizing.

  • ZAC EFRON AS HEATHCLIFF?????? O.O

    No way!!! Do you know what depth it would take to PLAY such a character????? Whoever suggested that does not grasp the character of Heathcliff AT ALL!! And I laugh with you!

  • I know, it's funny isn't it?!!!! :D:D:D I laughed my ass off when I read that!!! LOL

  • That would be the single most funny thing put on screen.

  • Zac Efron shouldn't act period, with the exception of crappy tween disney movies.

  • Amen to that!!! :D

  • hell yeah!!!!!

  • Hear, Hear.

  • lol

    actually when you do compare zac to this then he does look like a pretty bad of an actor.... =P

  • now the scene of h. death sucked ass. did the director think we are all idiots and wouldnt figure it out with a simple suggestion? ;/

  • Woooot? zac efron? come on .The world would be end for me. He is hopeless and. The worst H. EVAR

  • duh o____0

  • so agree with you, but what about gerry butler?

  • He was good as a Phantom, so... maybe. But I heard that Michael Fassbender will play Heathcliff in new version of WH.

  • i agree with presea, sure zac's a good actor, but not man enough to play heathcliffe

  • u can go to hell with that suggestion. a true thespian may only fill the boot's of heathcliff.

  • wtf is wrong with you!

  • ok heres some PLAUSIBLE actors for this:

    richard armitage as heathcliff

    filch as joseph

    i cant think of anyone amazing for catherine...

    eddie redmayne as linton

    billy zane as hindley

    yes, that would be a good movie :)

  • Ah, agreed. Richard Armitage would make a good Heathcliff in the dark and brooding way, but I think he's a bit too attractive to be Heathcliff tbh. And 'Filch' as Joseph would be good. Lol.

  • I think Kate Bush would make a good Catherine!

    And you are so right about Billy Zane! :D

  • Did Heathcliff just drob dead or did he somehow kill himself?

  • Old age, a little bit of mental instability, and a broken heart are what I think did him in.

    But I'm only gauging this from the movie.

  • Oh wow you should really read the book sometime! It's not very long, and you'll love it! There's much more to the story.

  • I plan to hunt it down ASAP at the nearest library. And possibly steal it from them. :)

  • U R right!

  • heathcliff's death scene is certainly a very strong one .. great movie and a great actor

  • I love it how Heathcliff kind of eventually start to care about Hareton - though he doesn't admit it to himself - probably because Hareton reminds him of his younger self. He originally sets out to make Hareton suffer the same fate Hindley made him suffer as a boy, but in the end they begin to bond subtly. It's not like Heathcliff ever learns to love Hareton like a son, but at least he learns not to hate him, which is already a major achievement for him.

  • Yeah...I agree with you, GoodbyeDragonfly. I think Heathcliff thought that if he treated Hareton the way that he had been treated, Hareton would turn out to be just like him. Then when Hareton turns out to be a caring person, it blows his theory all to hell. Heathcliff finally realizes that it wasn't the way others had treated himself that made him like he is...he realizes that to be good or bad was a CHOICE.

  • The irony is that Hareton boo-hooed the most for Heathcliff when he died. I think that Heathcliff was some what fond of Hareton in a twisted way because he saw himself in Hareton - trying to survive in a heartless environment.

  • good film but doesnt follow the same story as the book which is a shame.

  • God, at about 8:02 when that flute, or whatever it may be, joins the symphony... such chills.

  • the music is so chilling but romantic, its beautiful xx

  • i don't think the guy who plays hearton is not a very good actor

  • ugh so great and amazing and heartbreaking and heartwarming at the same time!

  • 7:50 to 8:14 is my favorite part and I LOVE the music so much too...great!

  • Seriously one of the greatest screen kisses ever.

  • the ghost cathy looks angelic and by the way she is wearing the dress that muslim girls wear all over the world. i dont understand then why the world hates so much for the girls to cover their body properly? isnt it itself a racism or to a wider sence Extremism?

  • I cannot understand HOW u can think of soMe concepts on the same line of LOVE !

    Love has no religion , Love has no world no breath , no nothing , but everything !

    can u try to see the EVERYTHNG in NOTHING !?

  • my sister has a book called wuthering heights

  • WostaDama was merely commenting her opinion on how girls should be dressed properly!

  • @CathysHeathCliff well if that is what you think that is perfectly fine...but really- to each his own =)

  • @WostaDama

    I'd think there was enough actual, real hate in the world for people not to use the word so inflationary. Some girl doesn't want to be dressed head to toe (it certainly doesn't make biking or running easier), someone things it's not neccessary and whoa "OMG WHY DO POEPLE HATE CLOTHING???!!!111!!"

    Murdering people or harrasing them is hate. "I don't like it for myself, thanx" isn't anywhere near hate.

  • @WostaDama

    Cathy is wearing a 'veil' which in European tradition symbolizes death. A death shroud. It was tradition to dress the dead in white and cover their faces. There is nothing Muslim about it. How on earth would such a religious discussion even enter that of Wuthering Heights?

  • thnx for postin the movie

  • Thanks for posting this!  Is there more though? It seems to cut off abruptly.

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more