omg, david liebman and wayne shorter can really play soprano saxophone...just amazing..other than 9:07 (which made my ears bleed, btw) sounding like a couple of girls screaming their heads off, or a couple guys getting their balls chopped off , this is one hell of a tribute to coltrane. Thanks for posting.
Hey Im a bass player and i really need to learn the bassline for this. Ive looked online and all it gives me is the head of the song can someone show me where to find the actual basline for it
@12jo0 hey man I'm a bass player too i have the charts for it if that's what you mean? The fake book version of this song. All that walking is all improv
I would say. I'm thinking about transcribing it down however if i get around to doing it i'll send it your way. He's doing some real interesting stuff in there. Good thing he has an intense band to back him up!
@theeviltwig ya i started to work out a bassline the only thing is i dont really get what chords are being used if you can help me out with that it would be greatly apreciated. and if you do get the charts done ill take a look at them thanks.
@12jo0 Walking over the melody is - Dm7 , Dm7 C Dm7, Gm7, Dm7, C, Dm7 , E , A , E , A , Dm7 , C, Dm7. Walking over solo section is Dm7 for four bars then Gm7 for two then Dm7 for two E7 for one A7 for one Dm7 for one then Dm7 or A7 for one.
If you need something more than that i can get it together pretty easy.
@12jo0 Walking over the melody is - Dm7 , Dm7 C Dm7, Gm7, Dm7, C, Dm7 , E , A , E , A , Dm7 , C, Dm7. Walking over solo section is Dm7 for four bars then Gm7 for two then Dm7 for two E7 for one A7 for one Dm7 for one then Dm7 or A7 for one.
If you need something more than that i can get it together pretty easy.
@12jo0 Walking over the melody is - Dm7 , Dm7 C Dm7, Gm7, Dm7, C, Dm7 , E , A , E , A , Dm7 , C, Dm7. Walking over solo section is Dm7 for four bars then Gm7 for two then Dm7 for two E7 for one A7 for one Dm7 for one then Dm7 or A7 for one.
If you need something more than that i can get it together pretty easy.
@12jo0 Walking over the melody is - Dm7 , Dm7 C Dm7, Gm7, Dm7, C, Dm7 , E , A , E , A , Dm7 , C, Dm7. Walking over solo section is Dm7 for four bars then Gm7 for two then Dm7 for two E7 for one A7 for one Dm7 for one then Dm7 or A7 for one.
If you need something more than that i can get it together pretty easy.
@12jo0 Walking over the melody is - Dm7 , Dm7 C Dm7, Gm7, Dm7, C, Dm7 , E , A , E , A , Dm7 , C, Dm7. Walking over solo section is Dm7 for four bars then Gm7 for two then Dm7 for two E7 for one A7 for one Dm7 for one then Dm7 or A7 for one.
If you need something more than that i can get it together pretty easy.
@12jo0 Walking over the melody is - Dm7 , Dm7 C Dm7, Gm7, Dm7, C, Dm7 , E , A , E , A , Dm7 , C, Dm7. Walking over solo section is Dm7 for four bars then Gm7 for two then Dm7 for two E7 for one A7 for one Dm7 for one then Dm7 or A7 for one.
@kostor1991 Yes, you are right. I have the sheet music in front of me. What song am i thinking of.. Thanks for the response to my comment i will delete them immediately.
@kostor1991 I see. I was looking at the chorus of the song in Bb. To solo over in standard key (Cmin) Chros is Cmin7 2 bars Cm7 Bb Cm7. Bar 5 - Fm7 2 bars Cm7 Bb Cm7 (anticipated Dm7) G7 D7 G7 Cm7 Bb Cm7.
Solo Section Cm7 4 bars Fm7 2 bars Cm7 2 bars D7 1 bar G7 1 bar Cm7 1 bar (G7)
You can play more than the blues scale over this tune. Perhaps the bebop scale or the Dorian scale to avoid the blues notes all the time, also helps to hit those juicy sevenths.
@theeviltwig minor7th chords are usually played as minor 6th, its a blues standart with minor 6th chords everywhere so you can play dorian or harmonic minor and still be inside the tone (at least that's what i hear in coltrane's version)
Shorter plays as he always has. Liebman plays as he does. One woeful regret is that quasi musos and critics have turned the music artform into WWF or even some freakin' sports game. While those two guys probably have good conversation afterwards, the more able critics would like more to toss them into an arena like two mindless pitbulls. I am in agreement with one thing. Go and learn something and master it as these guys are well on their way to doing exactly that. My humble opinion.
In regards to what these guys are playing they both sound great. Wayne's playing is quite abstract which is his thing and his soprano tone is very sweet which is great. On the other hand Dave Liebman's sound is so aggressive! Absolutely amazing energy so much that he plays the soprano andgives the impression he is playing Tenor. Both amazing but I enjoyed Dave's more "vicious" approach more. My humble opinion
why does everyone have to dis every video on youtube. It wasn't a high note competition. They were playing music, learn to appreciate it, considering they're way better than any of you losers who sit around criticizing videos all day without any authority to do so. get lives
wow. when liebman went for those high notes, i was like, "OH SHIT!" and when wayne shorter played those high notes and went like 7 whole steps above i fucking shit myself. shorter schooled him so bad, i actually feel bad for liebman
"I new exactly what Liebman's solo was going to be like before I even watched the video, and I haven't even listened to him as a player! They all keep talking about having your own voice and that they are individuals when all they do is stand in the shadow of Coltrane! All I ever here is Coltrane this and Coltrane that like he was the only Saxophone player that ever lived or is worth listening to! RIDICULOUS"
I new exactly what Liebman's solo was going to be like before I even watched the video, and I haven't even listened to him as a player! They all keep talking about having your own voice and that they are individuals when all they do is stand in the shadow of Coltrane! All I ever here is Coltrane this and Coltrane that like he was the only Saxophone player that ever lived or is worth listening to! RIDICULOUS
I don't even understand your message, I think it got lost in the rant that you typed. Are you saying you like them or don't, or that you like Coltrane or don't? Or do you just not like anyone and are a stuck up brat?
Dang, Jack de Johnette! I venerated him after I heard him play "Every Day I Thank You" with Pat Metheny. And I'm not even a drummer. And he's playing with Eddie Gomez!
its amazing!!!!all of them are genius!!!!who doesn´t understand what ist happening here i recommend to listen at Ricky Martin,eminem,Roberto Blanco or one of the greats singers of reggeton.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
If anybody can explain me what just happened here...i mean i like coltrane,tyner and their modal compositions and music...but i really don't understand this...sorry:) I watched this video because of Ritchie.He's coming in Linz but i'm not so impressed by his playing
Are you kiddin'??? Richie is a MONSTER! Along with Herbie and Chick, McCoy and Mehldau...he's one of the greatest EVER! Could you imagine that he possibly had problems with the sound situation or something...so, please think about this next time, thanx.
この演奏ののウェイン・ショーターはナカナカいいです。ショーターはテナーのトーンが貧弱なのでソプラノだけにしてください。それにしてもディブ・リーブマンのほうが上をいっているんじゃないの。リーブマンはルックスもいいしね。ピアノのソロは要らない、それよりディジョネットはいいね、素晴らしい。
MrHinaandmeme 2 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Shorter, Beirach and Liebman are pioneers. Pure.
SnackPackBadHooker 3 months ago
Comment removed
SnackPackBadHooker 3 months ago
YEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
alesrybar 4 months ago
I clocked it at MM 1/4=275. Not too shabby.
lcal39 5 months ago
Right! I'm off to do some soprano practice! Haha!
vandoren59 7 months ago
omg, david liebman and wayne shorter can really play soprano saxophone...just amazing..other than 9:07 (which made my ears bleed, btw) sounding like a couple of girls screaming their heads off, or a couple guys getting their balls chopped off , this is one hell of a tribute to coltrane. Thanks for posting.
aborrebach 7 months ago 4
@aborrebach I liked the ball-chopper ending too XD, it's a nice way to tense the end to the extreme!
StringKiller 1 week ago
Watching Dave Liebman play scares me. In a good way of course, but you can't help but feel terror, lol.
tjc197 10 months ago
Moammar Gaddafi on bass ladies and gentlemen!
lordbonzo 11 months ago 2
FUCKING HELL
McCoyTynerFourths 1 year ago
sean penn in LIEBMAN: a chromatic love story. coming to a blue note near you.
kevinm4435 1 year ago
Dave Liebman never had hair.
musicmanson 1 year ago
@edsensanz Just dig the jazz and stop trying to analyze every thought going through a musician's head.
Buffbodz 1 year ago
Love the song
immortal846 1 year ago
i like this chart at a slower tempo.
xxdkthxx 1 year ago
WTF is wrong with these ppl... (im saying this in a good way)
LTdrumma 1 year ago
this sounds wayyy better on the Tenor sax. even the alto would make it sound better. it just sounds too nasally
saxophoneexpert 1 year ago
now that's fast!
DB1815 1 year ago
この演奏が一番好きだ
sutaddoresu 1 year ago
Richie!so cool!!
ericream2000 1 year ago
Ugh, the soprano sax is definitely not my favorite saxophone...
Mathewkinetix 1 year ago
thats quite the sex face hes pulling
howardmoon13 1 year ago
R.I.P. big Paul!
lobo14capoeira 1 year ago
Classic!
hmoy24677 2 years ago
two great improv masters I love it !!!
SopranoSaxBoss 2 years ago
This song is amazing. I'm playing it in my jazz band class at school. The sheet music for it was nothing like this though
imrockin122 2 years ago
thats cause theyre soloing.....
666heavymetaladdict 2 years ago
amo esta cancioon
pomontty 2 years ago
That Bass was the Bee's Knees!
sjking92 2 years ago 3
Hey Im a bass player and i really need to learn the bassline for this. Ive looked online and all it gives me is the head of the song can someone show me where to find the actual basline for it
12jo0 2 years ago
learn how to improvise a walking bass line - google it!
kevinm4435 2 years ago 3
chech out Ron carter- builiding walking bass lines. :) or transcribe alot.
Nekronaut321 2 years ago
@12jo0 hey man I'm a bass player too i have the charts for it if that's what you mean? The fake book version of this song. All that walking is all improv
I would say. I'm thinking about transcribing it down however if i get around to doing it i'll send it your way. He's doing some real interesting stuff in there. Good thing he has an intense band to back him up!
theeviltwig 1 year ago
@theeviltwig ya i started to work out a bassline the only thing is i dont really get what chords are being used if you can help me out with that it would be greatly apreciated. and if you do get the charts done ill take a look at them thanks.
12jo0 1 year ago
@12jo0 Walking over the melody is - Dm7 , Dm7 C Dm7, Gm7, Dm7, C, Dm7 , E , A , E , A , Dm7 , C, Dm7. Walking over solo section is Dm7 for four bars then Gm7 for two then Dm7 for two E7 for one A7 for one Dm7 for one then Dm7 or A7 for one.
If you need something more than that i can get it together pretty easy.
theeviltwig 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@12jo0 Walking over the melody is - Dm7 , Dm7 C Dm7, Gm7, Dm7, C, Dm7 , E , A , E , A , Dm7 , C, Dm7. Walking over solo section is Dm7 for four bars then Gm7 for two then Dm7 for two E7 for one A7 for one Dm7 for one then Dm7 or A7 for one.
If you need something more than that i can get it together pretty easy.
theeviltwig 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@12jo0 Walking over the melody is - Dm7 , Dm7 C Dm7, Gm7, Dm7, C, Dm7 , E , A , E , A , Dm7 , C, Dm7. Walking over solo section is Dm7 for four bars then Gm7 for two then Dm7 for two E7 for one A7 for one Dm7 for one then Dm7 or A7 for one.
If you need something more than that i can get it together pretty easy.
theeviltwig 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@12jo0 Walking over the melody is - Dm7 , Dm7 C Dm7, Gm7, Dm7, C, Dm7 , E , A , E , A , Dm7 , C, Dm7. Walking over solo section is Dm7 for four bars then Gm7 for two then Dm7 for two E7 for one A7 for one Dm7 for one then Dm7 or A7 for one.
If you need something more than that i can get it together pretty easy.
theeviltwig 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@12jo0 Walking over the melody is - Dm7 , Dm7 C Dm7, Gm7, Dm7, C, Dm7 , E , A , E , A , Dm7 , C, Dm7. Walking over solo section is Dm7 for four bars then Gm7 for two then Dm7 for two E7 for one A7 for one Dm7 for one then Dm7 or A7 for one.
If you need something more than that i can get it together pretty easy.
theeviltwig 1 year ago
@12jo0 Walking over the melody is - Dm7 , Dm7 C Dm7, Gm7, Dm7, C, Dm7 , E , A , E , A , Dm7 , C, Dm7. Walking over solo section is Dm7 for four bars then Gm7 for two then Dm7 for two E7 for one A7 for one Dm7 for one then Dm7 or A7 for one.
theeviltwig 1 year ago
@theeviltwig it,s in c minor not d
goshajazz 1 year ago
@theeviltwig dude,mr.pc is c minor blues. 4bars Cm,2 bars Fm,2 bars Cm,Ab7,G7+9,2bars Cm.
kostor1991 1 year ago 3
@kostor1991 Yes, you are right. I have the sheet music in front of me. What song am i thinking of.. Thanks for the response to my comment i will delete them immediately.
Cm7 4 bars Fm7 2 bars Cm7 2 bars D7 G7 Cm7 (G7)
theeviltwig 1 year ago
@kostor1991 I see. I was looking at the chorus of the song in Bb. To solo over in standard key (Cmin) Chros is Cmin7 2 bars Cm7 Bb Cm7. Bar 5 - Fm7 2 bars Cm7 Bb Cm7 (anticipated Dm7) G7 D7 G7 Cm7 Bb Cm7.
Solo Section Cm7 4 bars Fm7 2 bars Cm7 2 bars D7 1 bar G7 1 bar Cm7 1 bar (G7)
You can play more than the blues scale over this tune. Perhaps the bebop scale or the Dorian scale to avoid the blues notes all the time, also helps to hit those juicy sevenths.
theeviltwig 1 year ago
@theeviltwig minor7th chords are usually played as minor 6th, its a blues standart with minor 6th chords everywhere so you can play dorian or harmonic minor and still be inside the tone (at least that's what i hear in coltrane's version)
StringKiller 1 week ago
nice a little to fast for me if they slowed it down it would be nice
fatgrunt3 2 years ago
you dont have to play it that fast
thats the best part about this song- it can be played with an upbeat tempo or be played slower in R&B form and still sound just as good
jofo37 2 years ago
Ritchie is sick. Man....I love that record Antarctica...he's an great teacher too...
kungfutongue 2 years ago
I have a guitar arrangement for this song, way awesome.
sk8ingoldschool 2 years ago
Great tune to solo over! Especially if you're into the up tempo blues! :)
Pilbromatic 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
My brother did this song in elementary school.
asland5565 2 years ago
yeah I bet it was at 60 bps too instead of the 265 that its supposed to be and the solo didnt sound like Shorter or Leibman.
johannus777 2 years ago
Your brother also sucked your **** in elementary school
Bendoengbanaang 2 years ago 6
AMazing...:|
godrobert18 2 years ago
dude we need to speed it up.................alot
dirtdude59 2 years ago
o god are u serious!?? ha thats funny i run into u guys hey whens the concert?? i gotta practice
johndabunny 2 years ago
its the 19th
dirtdude59 2 years ago
Shorter plays as he always has. Liebman plays as he does. One woeful regret is that quasi musos and critics have turned the music artform into WWF or even some freakin' sports game. While those two guys probably have good conversation afterwards, the more able critics would like more to toss them into an arena like two mindless pitbulls. I am in agreement with one thing. Go and learn something and master it as these guys are well on their way to doing exactly that. My humble opinion.
edsensanz 2 years ago 10
gigantesque!!!!!
accrojasss 2 years ago
In regards to what these guys are playing they both sound great. Wayne's playing is quite abstract which is his thing and his soprano tone is very sweet which is great. On the other hand Dave Liebman's sound is so aggressive! Absolutely amazing energy so much that he plays the soprano andgives the impression he is playing Tenor. Both amazing but I enjoyed Dave's more "vicious" approach more. My humble opinion
xantone 2 years ago
why does everyone have to dis every video on youtube. It wasn't a high note competition. They were playing music, learn to appreciate it, considering they're way better than any of you losers who sit around criticizing videos all day without any authority to do so. get lives
anapplecannon 2 years ago 32
@anapplecannon and aight it the truth! these guys fuckin' rip!
michaelp5590 9 months ago
energia hombre!!!
lilianarenas 3 years ago
Dave Liebman is a great soprano player but some parts of his solo sounded like absolute shit. Shorter kicked his ass, plain and simple.
mfhorn2564 3 years ago
wow. when liebman went for those high notes, i was like, "OH SHIT!" and when wayne shorter played those high notes and went like 7 whole steps above i fucking shit myself. shorter schooled him so bad, i actually feel bad for liebman
Pewpshmear 3 years ago
Right on. And he has to sit down....
elvind222 2 years ago
grow up dude.
kevinm4435 2 years ago
i meant 9:13. whoops
spicvic15 3 years ago
9:31 and is awesome
spicvic15 3 years ago
Jack Dejonette...wow...
jazzbass3826 3 years ago
the last two comments was for the guy that said (this tune is in Eb)thats all.
Milesdarren 3 years ago
there are obvious parallels but compare this to the solo Coltrane played on the album.
largemoose 3 years ago
"I new exactly what Liebman's solo was going to be like before I even watched the video, and I haven't even listened to him as a player! They all keep talking about having your own voice and that they are individuals when all they do is stand in the shadow of Coltrane! All I ever here is Coltrane this and Coltrane that like he was the only Saxophone player that ever lived or is worth listening to! RIDICULOUS"
It really doesn't sound that much like Coltrane.
largemoose 3 years ago
Not to mention..he gets raped by Wayne Shorter.
albanothemadman 3 years ago 2
c minor. Is that what you are going for?
Bbminorfunk 3 years ago
DAVE LIEBMAN KILLED IT!
theBUZer 3 years ago 5
I new exactly what Liebman's solo was going to be like before I even watched the video, and I haven't even listened to him as a player! They all keep talking about having your own voice and that they are individuals when all they do is stand in the shadow of Coltrane! All I ever here is Coltrane this and Coltrane that like he was the only Saxophone player that ever lived or is worth listening to! RIDICULOUS
EgyptianWarPharaoh 3 years ago
I don't even understand your message, I think it got lost in the rant that you typed. Are you saying you like them or don't, or that you like Coltrane or don't? Or do you just not like anyone and are a stuck up brat?
piehguy22 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Wayne Shorter has is own style though that he has developed! David Liebman is nothing but a boring Jew with nothing to offer!
EgyptianWarPharaoh 3 years ago
Those harmonics are tough to play.
dvnstvn9 3 years ago
ese es mi maestro....DAVE LIEBMAN
wendermusic 3 years ago
wow!! ^ ^ O O o
bandrascal89 3 years ago
I love this song
its amazing
for some reason i have an Eb fetish.
JustinPoon93 3 years ago
It's not Eb lol
SelmersRule 3 years ago
Im not sure if you know, that there is a difference between Eb and C minor?
Milesdarren 3 years ago
I dont think you know that there`s a difference between Eb and C minor
Milesdarren 3 years ago
Its the same.
JustinPoon93 3 years ago
they come fromm the same scale but it's a different mode
JustinPoon93 3 years ago
Not necessarily. Only if you chose C minor to be aeolian. Melodic Minor is often applied to the minor blues.
paulibaer 2 years ago
dangggggg!
tguvdgu 3 years ago
Dang, Jack de Johnette! I venerated him after I heard him play "Every Day I Thank You" with Pat Metheny. And I'm not even a drummer. And he's playing with Eddie Gomez!
coolweasel 3 years ago
Yeah this is Gomez!He's Mothefuckin best!
werciu 3 years ago
its amazing!!!!all of them are genius!!!!who doesn´t understand what ist happening here i recommend to listen at Ricky Martin,eminem,Roberto Blanco or one of the greats singers of reggeton.
diegotentuba 3 years ago 2
you forgot Dieter Bohlen.
memzehni 3 years ago
This is amazing. Jack is a maniac...and he looks so matter of fact.
evets530 3 years ago
mortal
RobertoLacourt 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
If anybody can explain me what just happened here...i mean i like coltrane,tyner and their modal compositions and music...but i really don't understand this...sorry:) I watched this video because of Ritchie.He's coming in Linz but i'm not so impressed by his playing
silverware8 4 years ago
Are you kiddin'??? Richie is a MONSTER! Along with Herbie and Chick, McCoy and Mehldau...he's one of the greatest EVER! Could you imagine that he possibly had problems with the sound situation or something...so, please think about this next time, thanx.
memzehni 3 years ago
Liebman owns Wayne Shorter. It's also great to hear Ritchie get a solo.
Modes9 4 years ago
sweet...mother...fucking...christ!!
lacrosseboy616 4 years ago
AAAAAUUUUUUUCHHH!!!!
franciscoae 4 years ago 2
G-g-g-g-g-g-g-g-g-goddamn!!!
LeonLeonheart5422 4 years ago
Is that Eddie Gomez on bass? That guy is a monster. He and Jack are freakin' heavy on this tune.
ianirishfan1 4 years ago
god, Jack is just all over this! Catching fire over Wayne's solo... stunning!
drumrcal 4 years ago
not everybody can stand up for the legend. he could. respect! beautiful...
axiluss 4 years ago
now i read that he'salso some kind of living legend.. i'm a jazz-wannabee, i discover this genre from a very short time forgive me :P
well... apart from that i'm amazed by their playing :)
axiluss 4 years ago 2
dude, this is sick!! The ending was awesome!!
BlackoutABX 4 years ago
REDICKULUS
littlewoda 4 years ago
Jack's solo is missing, then that would be perfect :(
guilhermejc540 4 years ago
so much vocabulary here, love the ending
jfree1112 4 years ago 2
awesome we are playing this in band!
tumericus 4 years ago 2
what a line up
TrevorKellum 4 years ago 4
awesome video of this song.
DarenSirboughMusic 4 years ago 4
fucking amazing
vitamincory 4 years ago 7
godDAMN!!!
theroshman 4 years ago 7
cool
JazzySaxE 4 years ago 7
This comment has received too many negative votes show
ten years tawny ; hmmmm ; no comment !
olmanrieur 4 years ago