Destiny's Child - Gospel Medley Live In Rotterdam 2002

[Lordfinese19]

Yo what you'll don't realize u can hate on B all u want 2 but this chick is the truth. do u even realize how she switch from several notes in this song n killing all of them.(1:33-2:07) she is unbelievable. Yes both Kelly n michelle r good but if B wasn't in this group doing they wouldn't have went as far as they did or even made it to a contract. But good performance by all of them together they are the truth. People need 2 stop hating on B recognize her great n talented she is.

[termante]

@Lordfinese19 Michelle was already in the business before she got in D.C

[termante]

@Lordfinese19 ALL OF THEM SOUND BETTER THAN ME.

[GodGivenTalent13]

I heard Beyonce started Total Praise and i almost went in!

[brealovesbeyonce]

kelly killed dat high note

[debby101]

This is beautiful, if only they stayed together <3

[JimmiThingDMB]

Go watch A Cub Bella sing this. such a tribute

[CoastPro2]

Beyonce was singing the low key people they switched up, that low key was way too good to be Michelle yal should know that now! lol They were all good though:-)

[jDesean]

@CoastPro2 thanks for knowing your girls and which part they are singing.! <3

[CoastPro2]

@jDesean :-)

[timeforachange101]

It would've been heavenly with just Michelle and Kelly. Beyonce' was not neeeded.

[lovelymusic92]

Kelly was killing on this song! and Michelle with her low notes was getting it! bey was on point too:D <3

[liln0a]

I love how michelle starts the song!!

[Damisola22897]

i feel so blessed and i surrender all was so gd jus wished beyonce sung some gospel now

[warmly32]

Beautiful ヾ(´∀`*)

[sisikipeut]

michelle is amazing

[choreographergirl101]

This is beautiful. Kelly looked like she was about to shout! Lol. Beautiful to see this.

[stupidwithit]

Kelly's part gave me chills

[AntmDancer]

Sang Ladies !! :D

[roysasi]

simran was better!

[1994cecepooh]

bey is an tenor

[Fontel456]

oh thats good!!!!

[musicmaster616]

Here's the set list of the concert Track listing "Program Start" — 1:48 "Independent Women Part I" — 3:31 "No, No, No Part 2" — 2:43 "Bug a Boo" — 2:30 "Bills, Bills, Bills" — 3:30 "Get on the Bus" — 3:23 "Nasty Girl" — 3:10 "Emotion" — 4:01 "Ooh Child" — 2:26 "Heard A Word" — 4:04 "Dangerously in Love" — 6:21 "Gospel Medley" — 3:51 "Bootylicious" — 3:16 "Say My Name" — 4:16 "Work It Out" — 3:34 "Proud Mary" — 1:26 "Jumpin', Jumpin'"/Band Break — 7:45 "Survivor" — 4:01 "Happy Face

[1994cecepooh]

@musicmaster616 do you have the whole concert on your paage

[rainbowk11d]

Yea Beyoncé and Kelly

[chriskf0122]

Thumbs up if you're watching this in 2011

[jDesean]

@chriskf0122 i STILL watch this.! i love them.

[playgirlkilling]

@Fontel456 beyonce passed thru tenor quite a few times. Think Michelle to. Not confident to say all of them did. But this is gr8 stuff. Pure vocals n not toooo many inappropriate runs n that.. Did a remake. Took me hrs n it still isnt perfect.!! Xx

[Fontel456]

@playgirlkilling is it on your remake on youtube yet

[playgirlkilling]

@Fontel456 very soon... i need to get it sent to my email first... sorry..Xx

[whyte1luv]

#team Beyonce..when she came in with the Amen!! It was just so soft and it made my heart melt...shes the Queen...

[melisababe2005]

Team Kelly



[Fontel456]

yea michelle can sing but i doupt she sung tenor i mean the lowest all the girl have sung was a low alto but not tenor

[traboe]

michelle sung ALL the parts soprano, alto and tenor thats why she's my fav!!!!!!

[Calvinnnn2011]

KELLLYY KILLED THISSSS !! Im like beyonce #1 fan but this time kelly out did beyonceee .

[josephbutawo2]

3:15 anyone know what that song is called ? the amen ending ?? :D

[MrSexiiass96]

@josephbutawo2 "Total Praise"

[tailuo5]

ahhhhhhhhhhh the dutch get everything, so jealous of u guys ^,^

[Jayouth]

I actually think that low note at 3:00 was Michelle and not Beyonce. Michelle started taking the low note from 2:54...take a look.

[icetoo06]

U betta sing it Kelly!!!

[jDesean]

actually, @javonsinger that low note at 3:00 was beyonce.

[0rangepool]

Omg michelle so gorgeous

[KailynSanchezHall]

MICHELLE HAS THAT OLD SCHOOL VOICE!!!! I LOVE HER SHE IS MY FAV!!!!! I MISS DC3!! I CANT WAIT FOR THEIR NEXT ALBUM!!!!

[LRGJRG]

The harmonies r great love the high note kelly did towards the end.=)

[Rufina]

Beyonce with the low notes, amazing....they are so beautiful and talented! Beyonce at 3;00 with that low note, amazing!

[Rufina]

Beyonce with the low notes, amazing....they are so beautiful and talented!

[Fattyyy01]

never realised how beautiful michelles voice was! 

[wwnnn16]

Lmao Michelle is SO freakin funny!

[javonsinger]

Michelle with that low note at 3:00 #Wow

[termante]

@javonsinger EXACTLY....LOL

[javonsinger]

The notes that Kelly is doing @ the 1:54 mark... absolute greatness... it gives me chills... SANG YALL!!!

[Antwanette0386]

Awesome version. I pray that they keep God first in all that they do and the center of their lives - Matthew 6:33. I pray them, their families and friends and fans all the best. Much love & God blessings!!!

[termante]

@ 2:45 HIT THAT NOTE MICHELLE

[maclaiden]

I LOVE this version....my girls did the smoothest transition of this version I have seen yet on Youtube....Love it...and the chords?....Amazing!

[misterjrhodes]

i love that run Beyonce does on I Surrender All!! #CHILLS!

[fan4mc]

i love the sound of kelly's voice

[maliklik95]

They did great as usual! I just don't understand why people decide to judge others and worry about their life styles...I don't think in fact I believe and know that Beyonce isn't in no illuminati! But anyway everybody need to worry about their selves point blank! You should be worried about if your on YOUR WAY TO HAVEN NOT ANYBDY ELSE...BC on judgement day, we're all going be judged individually! It's ur CHOICE! WORRY ABT UR SELF! JUDGE OTHERS AND YOU'LL BE JUDGED ON THAT COMIN OF JESUS CHRIST!

[8jsimone]

i seriously can't believe michele.. sigh

[whoisit203]

KELLY WOOOW!!!!

[ebabi102493]

Ilove everybody in Destinys Child..ireally think kelly is underrated tho..

[fresh8605]

U LOVE HOW KELLY CAME IN AT THE END OMG

[MEM9296]

I actually think Sim'Ran at least did as well as they just did here!

[Jeylin2010]

@MEM9296 I just checked that video out and it gave me goosebumps.

[TTB0209]

@MEM9296 I actually think they performed it better personally, their harmonies were much tighter..

[SilverD1000]

Oh... my... word... i just peed my pants

[nchoneync]

Someone stole my Live in Rotterdam DVD :( ...I WANT IT BACK!!

[premedgurl]

Let people praise God and leave it at that!

[motegn07]

their mouths say one thing but where do their hearts lie... Jesus didn`t stutter when he said you shall know them by their fruits!

[studlyfe23]

in this song michelle is beyonce in dis

[JonathanGardnerTV]

Oh Michelle totally slays in this video!! She goes from singing the soprano part right down to tenor!! Girl better sing!!!!!

[Emtoeduheikel]

you guys should check out the version of these girls. They do this medley but with such strong voices, unbelievable. It's a Dutch X-Factor audition:

watch?v=vYrRjYW6IL0

[hallsbstn]

Kelly doesn't have as much wind as Bey and Chelle.

[TheFunkyfr3sh]

omg the begin is terrible.

[puerto1rican1mami1]

the ending amen gave me chills :)

[AndielovesBeyonce]

3:17 - 4:06 The best part I was so enjoying :)♥

[coringlow]

i love this me and my best friends are going to sing this in a talent show ill tape it n post it on here

[JonathanGardnerTV]

OMGGG MICHELLE WAS KILLING THAT TENOR @ 3:00

Yes girl better sing!

[AndielovesBeyonce]

@JonathanGardnerTV That was Beyonce :) Not Michelle

[JonathanGardnerTV]

@AndielovesBeyonce No it wasn't...note how Beyonce pulls away from the mic first WHILE the note is still being held by Michelle.....Michelle holds that low note. Beyonce harmonises just above Michelle on that note and is slightly louder but Michelle holds her note longest

[AndielovesBeyonce]

@JonathanGardnerTV Whatever...but anyway i would love that Beyonce had bigger part to sing here :)...'Cause her voice is so amazing and I can listen to it forever without stop !

[JonathanGardnerTV]

@AndielovesBeyonce Didn't Beyonce get enough "bigger" parts while in DC - considering she pretty much sang lead on every song (or was at least the last person to ad-lib on it)...her voice was always featured most prominently on background vocals also...so I think it's nice that Michelle and Kelly got a chance to shine on this.

[AndielovesBeyonce]

@JonathanGardnerTV Well Ok but anyway nothing without my ♥QueenBey♥

[AndielovesBeyonce]

@JonathanGardnerTV and btw on 3:00 that was Beyonce don't say anything I know her voice

[JonathanGardnerTV]

@AndielovesBeyonce Are you not watching the video? Can you not see that Beyonce doesn't finish her note until 3:04 - she holds hers the longest...whereas Michelle (singing the lowest note there) holds her's till 3:02 - at which point Beyonce can be CLEARLY seen STILL SINGING.

[itsMUSICY]

@JonathanGardnerTV I think the note at 3:00 was BEyonce too....lol

[JonathanGardnerTV]

@itsMUSICY No...Beyonce was ssinging the middle harmony there at 3:00 with Michelle taking the lowest note. You can see clearly that Bey holds her note (which is slightly higher) for a second or two longer than Michelle who cuts out a little earlier than Bey

[LATYA09]

i wonder why Beyonce dont do this no more.......... this was good!

[whart12345]

beyonce gone from singing gospel medleys to promoting devil things

[conceithed]

I love this. Thanks for posting. I love dc3, back when they were together and did gospel oldies like this.

[conceithed]

I love this. I miss dc3. i liked them when they were together.

[airwaves7]

Love Michelle here she is truly have a gospel voice.

[mizzglammie]

God is gud

[1McMarie]

oh beyonce was cutting up!!!!! yessss!

[betrapvideos]

you guess Michelle? haha wooooooooooooooow beyonce was singing bottom? wow...this is the first time i've heard DC sing with out beyonce voice over powering the other 2 or 3 girls

[quickstar0]

@betrapvideos that was because she was sick.

[MiSsJdAtSeXcBiTcH]

@betrapvideos That was the exact same thing I was thinking

[letronthedivo]

THANK YOU JESUS!

[purewhitedaisy24]

come back beyonce from your grave I hate demonfied sasha fierce

[JonathanGardnerTV]

@crunkestdancer11 Ermm..she has released two gospel albums...Heart To Yours (2002 - #1 US Gospel, #57 US, #17 US R&B), Do You Know (2004 - #2 US Gospel, #3 US Christian, #120 US, #28 US R&B) and she released her first Pop album (which features some elements of R&B/Hip-Hop but is mostly dance-pop and electronic music) Unexpected in 2008 to much critical acclaim (#42 US, #11 US R&B).

She has two albums of Gospel music for you to revel in LOL. Trust me, all her albums are great.

[LouisRay4219]

@JonathanGardnerTV i have all 3.. dey good forreal

[JonathanGardnerTV]

@LouisRay4219 Amen to that! Michelle knows how to make a good album. They get better each time. I'm really looking forward to her next one :)

[SHoward152]

I liked michelle, she has the best gospel voice for this song

[MrIJUSWANNALISTEN]

simple beautiful

[1994Rich]

BEE... The best!

[termante]

Michelle when from high saprano to deep tenor (contralto for samiradelsol)....she is amazing.

[myblock2007]

@termante I totally agree!!!!!!

[highnote32]

@termante Actually, Michelle is a Mezzo-Soprano. She had had her earlier years singing the Alto part in a choir and she was trained in 2001-2002 to sing higher notes.

[JonathanGardnerTV]

@highnote32 Though she rarely shows off her head range, when she does, it's so effortless and piercing that I think she's a soprano. I'll message you a link to the audio where she sings a C6 and then a D#6 - playing around, not even serious!

[termante]

@highnote32 I don't care if she was a fisherman, the girl can sannnng

[ricky52x]

@termante when did she do that??? cuz im listening and me nah hear michelle do no tenor in ths song...beyonce holds the tenor..kelly does the high sopranos/ high alto when necessary

[JonathanGardnerTV]

@ricky52x Michelle and Beyonce switch up the tenor...at around 2:58, Michelle goes back down to singing tenor - as you can see Beyonce holds the longest note (singing the alto - she holds it till 3:04 whereas Michelle stops around 3:02 while Beyonce is clearly still singing). You can also hear at the end on the "amen" part (taken from Richard Smallwood's "Total Praise") that Michelle sings tenor there.

[termante]

@ricky52x @ 2:41 TO 2:51 she was the saprano and drop to tenor.

[myblock2007]

@termante yea Michelle is the best one(In my opinion)!!!

[hallsbstn]

@termante Actually they all did...They each switched from suprano, alto, to tenor. In the beginning: Beyonce-tenor Kelly-surprano Michelle alto. Middle section:Beyonce-tenor Kelly- alto Michelle suprano Ending: Beyonce-suprano Kelly-alto Michelle- Tenor.

[lovehurtsLSWR]

@hallsbstn Ending Kelly-Soprano Beyonce-Alto Michelle-Tenor*

[hallsbstn]

@hallsbstn 3:10-3:16 Beyonce was soprano, kelly alto. Amen in repeats, Beyonce Alt, Kelly Sop (Falsetto). You were right :-)

[termante]

@hallsbstn your missing my point Michelle sung high in i surrender all and the directly dropped to the low registar.

[Urboygotzswagg]

@termante she did that was pretty good and she did it on point.... so well that u have to listen a few times to catch it

[tailuo5]

@termante she was always my fav. even when i was like only 15 :)

[canttouchthis421]

beyonce can sing Tenor like no other. It's FLAWLESS, and she's not my favorite singer, but she sounds like butter singing in her low notes.

[samiradelsol]

@canttouchthis421

Tenor is the higher male voice, when a woman sings low notes it's contralto.

[Urboygotzswagg]

@canttouchthis421..... I agree beyonce tore up the tenor in this song... she usually is in the middle and michelle does tenor but im glad the switched it up on this song...

[LouisRay4219]

@Urboygotzswagg they switched it cuz beyonce was sick that nite so she had only a part of her range.. watch emotions live n rotterdam.. kelly has to take the ad lib after michelle verse

[Urboygotzswagg]

@LouisRay4219 o ok that makes sense.. i never paid attention to it but i think they sound better on those changes since beyonces voice is alot deeper and heavier than the other girls so she filled in that tenor line good on the gospel medley

[TrueZoel]

Whater an oil cant be mixed.

Are cold or heat because JAH will trow up to the warm ...

JESÚS its comíng return to him now the because the time is now return to The Lord and be safe.

[toopbeebz]

b could have changed for this she looks like a slut... ppl don'T understand they wouln't go dressed like that meeting an important person such as your boss or the president but when meeting the one and only LORD ppl dress like hookers... tststs

[conceithed]

@toopbeebz I understand. However, she still has to appeal to audiences eyes. But I do agree with you. Her dress was not to appropriate. But its hard to dress age appropriate without looking homely or slutty.

[LCJBoi2007]

KELLY DID HER THING!!!!!!!!

[WAYNICCASINGS08]

i like parts like this in a show because we get to give GLORY to his name, and introduce ppl who may NOT know GOD a chance to be ministered to.......

[cbdat804mami]

Kelly is the best vocalist from DC... iono why people on Bey like that... Kelly can out sing Beyonce ANY DAY!

[hallsbstn]

@cbdat804mami In what life time???Kelly can barely keep up with Michelle. Her voice is okay, but she aint on Bey's level on her best day and Bey's worst. Sorry!

[cbdat804mami]

@hallsbstn barely keep up with Michelle???? u serious??? lmfao nah bruh.. Michelle vs kelly odds favor for Kelly.. And yes, I do believe Kelly could Out sing Bey. Sorry Bey can sing, but yall give her entirely too much Credit.

[hallsbstn]

@cbdat804mami Okay...Kelly harmonises good. But when she sings alone, it's not the best. You should hear how she sounds on this dvd compared to Beyonce and Michelles solo performances. WHACK!!! Youtube it and see for yourself...

[Urboygotzswagg]

@cbdat804mami .... kelly is ma girl but no way is she a better vocalist than beyonce... sorry she doesnt have the range, the vocal control, or tone that beyonce has

[conceithed]

kelly did kill it. go kelly!!!!!!!!!!!!!! michelle's voice had a nice intro, and beyonce has a very broad range. i love dc3.

[Jasmine72370]

MIchelle don't "guess" that you're thanking God...Know that you are!!

[GlgandDkLover]

omg

KELLY!!

man i forgot all about this concert and i have it on dvd!

they all sound good but kelly did it for me!

[JonathanGardnerTV]

YAAAS MICHELLE BETTER HIT THAT TENOR/BASS @ 3:00 you can tell it was Michelle because Bey was holding the note above and she held it longer than Michelle!

[chewerboy]

@JonathanGardnerTV

im not sure about this note but its definitely a Eb. not sure whether its a Eb3 or Eb2. :)

[JonathanGardnerTV]

@chewerboy I think it's in the 3rd octave not second...I can sing down to a D2 and I was just able to sing the note Michelle sings an octave lower and I doubt it was an E1 I sang LMAO xD

[sgelsey]

Beyonce is holding down that low note! Yes! Then she passed it to Michelle. This group is so evenly blessed vocally it's amazing. They switch off so smoothly.

[86cmoore]

Why is Beyonce dress completely differnt if i was n dat group we would have been fighting over that dress lbs!!!

[HSMFR3AK]

That was FANTASTIC!!!! It's nice to see celebrities thank God for all he has done. Thank you DC for this wonderful gospel medley. You guys ROCK!!!!

[licettleyva]

hopefully they would all turn their lives to God and live for him...especially beyonce that seems really lost right now...how beautiful their voices would be used to glorify Jesus name!!

[nbabound254]

this is dedicated to all the haters who say beyonce is part of the illuminati

[Lonelljovan]

@nbabound254 You took the words right out of my mouth!!!!!!!!!

[slutsUSA]

@nbabound254 SIKE!

[BasketBallGirly3KS]

@nbabound254 Waitt Doo Yuu Knoww Howw Old Thiss Iss ! OMG !

[BasketBallGirly3KS]

@nbabound254 Waitt Doo Yuu Knoww Howw Old Thiss Iss ! OMG !

[nbabound254]

@BasketBallGirly3KS yes 2002 well if u want u can look up beyonce praying in her last dvd that was released last month (if thats not new enough for u)

[ricky52x]

@nbabound254 ammm hediot! this was when she became sasha fierce and then she joined during the apbum bday...so bill

[brendout20]

@nbabound254 we dont hate we tell the trueth about those who are trying to destroy salvation for others=)

[uanitylacle]

@nbabound254 this is very old though.. it takes 1 minut to become illuminati. Dont get me wrong I am not saying that she is, but the old B is very different from this rocafella, sasha fierce, jayz person

[nbabound254]

@uanitylacle ppl will make up anything to bring a successful black person down..."shes so successful shes with the devil"

[uanitylacle]

@nbabound254 Your right, i understand where you coming from. Thats why i said Im not saying anything about Bey.. I just have a ussue with Jay, and the stuff he raps. "Jesus cant save you, life starts when the church ends" and "lucifer" and stuff like that.. and shes married to him, so i guess that has a lot to do with it

[kimevans723]

Not a hater at all but the Illuminati is not a religious or anti-religious secret society. So whoever is saying that needs to READ!

[love21dance4eva]

@kimevans723 finally someone with sense lol this "illuminati" stuff was obviously started by someone ignorant to history and the real illuminati which is completely different smh ignorance is not bliss

[tsu1208]

Kelly Always held it down when they do Gospel Medley's

[grownman2010]

Kelly was the best singer on this Medley...

[ESSENCEkAMillE10]

-i love them ! beyonce had an awesome scale

[theresadanielle1]

Wow!!!!!!!

[latinpianist]

A little off on :48 But still great singing!

[intheoverflow]

Ok i was wrong...DC did sing gospel but not at the level Michelle brought it!

I luv Michelle's voice and spirit...there's something more there than just a great voice to me.

[intheoverflow]

I luv this!! Michelle really made an impact on DC3...bcuz there was no gospel singing from the group before she came to the group, just booty shaking tunes...that's a true leader, one who brings about change...luv you Michelle & DC3 4 Ever!!

[numba1beyfan]

ok. ive read the comments. if you listen close enough kelly is soprano, michelle is alto 1 and beyonce is alto 2, the closest to tenor. in most songs where it is a medley, beyonce's voice is always deepest

[dymeds]

kelly had a few notes that was strong...i think thats the strongest she ever sung!!!

[LCJBoi2007]

kelly had that soprano note on LOCK go head kelly love it

[josymarvocalista]

gosteiiiiiiiii muito

[dmandavidbeverly]

They are talented.. but where is the anointing? That's what truly makes the difference.

[KaeRules]

@dmandavidbeverly if you didnt feel anything you crazy an anointng was all over kelly look at her sing she ihad god all over and ms michelle tooo now beyonce no comment on her but hey maybe thats the reason they broke up .

[JonathanGardnerTV]

@dmandavidbeverly If you want annointing, search for Michelle Williams singing Do You Know live in Atlanta from the Destiny Fulfilled and Lovin' It Tour! She saaaang that with all her heart!

[heavenlyanc]

well i dont know what the real debate is about.... but that low low note is Michelle... if thats what your trying to figure out. They switch on the 'All' and Beyonce takes the top for the beginning of the run and then ends up in the middle...