I used to listen to this song and dream and wish I could play it, it sounds so intricate and beyond capability, and Dweezil's version I find that little bit crisper and his style is more natural smooth blues (Gilmoreish) Anyways I started playing guitar in Dec 2010. And recently worked this tune out, Bass, rythm clean, and the solo (sort of) my fingers just dont go that fast yet. But in doing so it has tarnished somewhat what I loved so much about this song. Did you feel the same once learnt ?
Who are you guys?! Just saw your covers of Red and Sylvia and this is even better. The main thing is apart from being good musicians is what pimpjuice02 said you really seem to be having a good time playing great music. Love it!
I can imagine Frank Zappa leaning over waving a baton(frowning and smoking a lot of cigarettes) while watching this.
Even though this isn't perfect(it's fucking amazing though), if anyone here hasn't ever seen the sheet music for Black Napkins in the Zappa Guitar Book.. Do so. Now.
Yea, it isn't even a professional setting either. They are just having a good time playing music, and thats what it is all about. What makes you feel good. Nice cover anyways.
I have "something bad to say (about this video)" and it's this -- tell the audience to shut the hell up! I want to see this same group post the same song in another video only this time with no audience/background noise and with better audio quality. Other than that, these boys can play and kudos to the guitarist. I've always loved "Black Napkins", saw Frank do it in '77 and '88 and the phrasing in this cover is very, very good. Nice job!
If anyone wants to say anything bad AT ALL about this video, jus'get back into your po'jamas and stop yourself from looking stoopid.this was really excellent playing!thanks for posting it....
Well... He pays great attention to detail. That has always been one of my favorite compositions and I've listened to it hundreds of times. I have much respect for this guitarist. He must appreciate the song as well to give it so much study. Frank Zappa was really something huh?
I used to listen to this song and dream and wish I could play it, it sounds so intricate and beyond capability, and Dweezil's version I find that little bit crisper and his style is more natural smooth blues (Gilmoreish) Anyways I started playing guitar in Dec 2010. And recently worked this tune out, Bass, rythm clean, and the solo (sort of) my fingers just dont go that fast yet. But in doing so it has tarnished somewhat what I loved so much about this song. Did you feel the same once learnt ?
TheMrLusk 5 months ago
Awesome!
Muito bom!
LMunhoz28 9 months ago
Pretty bad ass guys.
valienteagle 1 year ago
one can tell the feeling in your face...you truly enjoy the music :D kudos
melson17 1 year ago
Super, Wery Wery Nice!!!!
wojcicki74 2 years ago
SUPER!!
Mister wery nice
wojcicki74 2 years ago
Awesomely Executed. I AH LIKE, great success!. Thank you!
plasticjesus108 2 years ago
very good zappa cover brothers i like the live video rock evil crazydave out
daveispoor 2 years ago
come and play in england please
nicknick1963 2 years ago
wow, I swear I can hear the years between the notes....... thanks for the dedication....
jerryskid84 3 years ago
Parabéns à The Central Scrutinizer Band por manter a música de FZ viva.
Mulacighana 3 years ago
Nice jazzy version guys.
I think Frank would like this.
MorroccoM13 3 years ago
gut, wirkliche klasse dieses video und die combo
tommy10827 3 years ago
Who are you guys?! Just saw your covers of Red and Sylvia and this is even better. The main thing is apart from being good musicians is what pimpjuice02 said you really seem to be having a good time playing great music. Love it!
bibotanku 3 years ago
I am seeine ZPZ in a couple of weeks. Can't wait for it! As for this guitarist.. he nails it. I am their new biggest fan.
Exit48Kate 3 years ago
seeing zappa plays zappa soon; as the rest of you should. trust me on this.
fukyutoo 3 years ago
I can imagine Frank Zappa leaning over waving a baton(frowning and smoking a lot of cigarettes) while watching this.
Even though this isn't perfect(it's fucking amazing though), if anyone here hasn't ever seen the sheet music for Black Napkins in the Zappa Guitar Book.. Do so. Now.
You'll shit bricks!
CosmicAlfonzo 3 years ago
dude i have a look in there once in a while and when I do , I put my guitar in the case for a week and cry
shrewrepair 3 years ago
EXELLENT! WOW .. the guitar is so great! 5*
felixbrix 3 years ago
you guys have it for sure...keep that up
L0sendos 3 years ago
the understated cool of black napkins
a classic ..done well by you guys
mrlowdangle 3 years ago
Yea, it isn't even a professional setting either. They are just having a good time playing music, and thats what it is all about. What makes you feel good. Nice cover anyways.
pimpjuice02 3 years ago
Wow. This has to be the best cover of Black Napkins I've EVER heard. Good job man.
Lysol106 4 years ago
sorry but you're nowhere near zappa. but still i dug it.
amratheblack 4 years ago
i can't believ i even said this /\.
amratheblack 4 years ago
watch out! Black Widow Zappa is gonna sue now! LOL
great job!
flammaster 4 years ago
almost as good as the real thing... a pleasure to watch and listen.. many thanks...
fluxdust 4 years ago
holy shit fz is hard shit to play as a whole band congrats this is fuckin awsome.
jamminkyle 4 years ago
Cool!
Is that in the key of C#-minor?
taylor410ce 4 years ago
yes
dothedewupurs 4 years ago
I have "something bad to say (about this video)" and it's this -- tell the audience to shut the hell up! I want to see this same group post the same song in another video only this time with no audience/background noise and with better audio quality. Other than that, these boys can play and kudos to the guitarist. I've always loved "Black Napkins", saw Frank do it in '77 and '88 and the phrasing in this cover is very, very good. Nice job!
pickfinger 4 years ago
absoluteley tremendous performance,beautiful
bangform 4 years ago 4
If anyone wants to say anything bad AT ALL about this video, jus'get back into your po'jamas and stop yourself from looking stoopid.this was really excellent playing!thanks for posting it....
Mint105 4 years ago
he doesn't have the zappa improv ability but nice to see a black napkins cover
BuddyRayKing 4 years ago
Well, not many people out there can improv like Zappa.
For the most part this was a faithful reproduction of the album version. Best cover of it I've ever heard.
CosmicAlfonzo 4 years ago
Alright jazz piano Zappa. This shit ain't easy to beat
ScrubProduction 4 years ago
AWESOME...FZ forever!
ResidentMax 4 years ago
Damn!!
zed747 4 years ago
WOW! I'm well impressed... What a talented group! You've shown a lot of respect to Uncle Frank guys, thank you!!
likwidflame 4 years ago
awesome!
TaekwonMojo 4 years ago
That guitar player has the FZ-chops!
Muy bien!
Julio818 4 years ago
pqp. deveras excelente. infelizmente moro em brasília e nunca pude conferir o trabalho da Scrutinizer ao vivo...
skidoo2323 5 years ago
Well... He pays great attention to detail. That has always been one of my favorite compositions and I've listened to it hundreds of times. I have much respect for this guitarist. He must appreciate the song as well to give it so much study. Frank Zappa was really something huh?
npantelis 5 years ago
I wish I was there. Hear it live.
Zaworov 5 years ago
Rainer, mais uma vez...cê é demais! 10!!!
Mas diz uma coisa...Que raios tá fazendo essa mina com uma cerva na mão ao fundo? "total falta de senso de noção" rsrsrs
betoms01 5 years ago
amazing 5 stars
melson17 5 years ago
Commenting yet again to say that the guitarist really has Zappa's phrasing down very well.
DTGuitarX 5 years ago
Excellent!
DTGuitarX 5 years ago
Very nice.
MrGreenGenes 5 years ago