O stop bitching you queens; I am sure some of you have better choirs and some of you just think you do. I still like it. These days, it is a miracle one can even get kids together to do anything like this. Check out "Forty Boys and a Song" here on Youtube; it is a short documentary clip on the Robert Mitchell Boy Choir. They do this motet as a sort of processional I guess. Quite lovely. Does your choir sound like THAT?
No false tones BUT, this is the choeur final de l'Oratorio de Noel and this choir just sings it as if they've just come out of bed. No dynamic, no acting, no feeling :-(
No ,belonging to a cathedral choir i know that boys can sing higher than women, there it seem to be an all alto choir, singing a transposition of saint saens 's work (that i know well for i had sing it)
Muss leider sagen, dass es mir nicht sehr gut gefällt. Es ist meiner Meinung nach mit kaum Gefühl gesungen worden,wodurch,wie vorhin schon beschrieben der festliche Charakter auf der Strecke. Zu kritesieren hätte ich nur noch, dass die Silben sehr ungebunden gesungen werden (vielleicht ist das ja auch so vom Leiter beabsichtigt), dadurch verliert das Lied seine Leichtigkeit.
Im großen und ganzen nicht schlecht, aber ersten sollte lustvoller gesungen werden und zweitens in Originallage. Hier lagen ja teilweise die Unterstimmen über den haupstimmen, was dem ganzen seinen festlichen Charakter nimmt und sehr schade ist. Aber es ist sehr gut gesungen!
O stop bitching you queens; I am sure some of you have better choirs and some of you just think you do. I still like it. These days, it is a miracle one can even get kids together to do anything like this. Check out "Forty Boys and a Song" here on Youtube; it is a short documentary clip on the Robert Mitchell Boy Choir. They do this motet as a sort of processional I guess. Quite lovely. Does your choir sound like THAT?
acbulgin2 7 months ago
¿Qué bonito se escucha esto!..... Felicidades y saludos desde Chihuahua México.
jogomez1974 1 year ago
delano mn brought 5 kids and i was one of them
petteriswen 1 year ago
I dislike this. It has too much of an American accent. No r rolling. I hear scooping.
Peachtotheinfinity 1 year ago
Tenors overpower base. More feeling!!! Dynamics!!!! All of these are missing!!!
averagejoe200 1 year ago
my choir is 20 times better
killer123744 2 years ago
I know there voices are blocky and dont meld well. I agree my chior is better aswell
LethalFailure 2 years ago
Bravo to the conductor; he has each singer focused and the choir on point as a group! That is skill and experience.
jpstenino 2 years ago
No false tones BUT, this is the choeur final de l'Oratorio de Noel and this choir just sings it as if they've just come out of bed. No dynamic, no acting, no feeling :-(
TheRealPredatorX 2 years ago
This is a 7th and 8th grade boys choir who only practiced one day. You're being a little harsh.
choirgirl77 2 years ago
practiced one day? they r pretty good for one day of practice. my choir gets to sing this song in december
inoshomaru01 2 years ago
I agree, to have sang it myself, and I still do not understand why it is sang a quint minimum lower.
donhenri01 2 years ago
Sung without feeling.
This choir's version of Finlandia is equally dead.
bairen2002 2 years ago
why is is singed a quint ,minimum, lower?
donhenri01 2 years ago
it's SUNG so much deeper because a boys choir has a deeper tune of voices in general.
TheRealPredatorX 2 years ago
No ,belonging to a cathedral choir i know that boys can sing higher than women, there it seem to be an all alto choir, singing a transposition of saint saens 's work (that i know well for i had sing it)
donhenri01 2 years ago
Muss leider sagen, dass es mir nicht sehr gut gefällt. Es ist meiner Meinung nach mit kaum Gefühl gesungen worden,wodurch,wie vorhin schon beschrieben der festliche Charakter auf der Strecke. Zu kritesieren hätte ich nur noch, dass die Silben sehr ungebunden gesungen werden (vielleicht ist das ja auch so vom Leiter beabsichtigt), dadurch verliert das Lied seine Leichtigkeit.
Gummibearpilot 3 years ago
hermoso!!
morocha231 3 years ago
c'est super moch et trés trés mou
la tonalité !!!!!!
mhdf59130 3 years ago
Im großen und ganzen nicht schlecht, aber ersten sollte lustvoller gesungen werden und zweitens in Originallage. Hier lagen ja teilweise die Unterstimmen über den haupstimmen, was dem ganzen seinen festlichen Charakter nimmt und sehr schade ist. Aber es ist sehr gut gesungen!
LordL34 3 years ago
Ja, es war eine Ehre für den Chor war ich in. Dank für das Verlassen eines Kommentars.
sneakydog1 3 years ago
this one was my favorite!
Suzie281 3 years ago
my school did this song too, very good
demonguitarist92 3 years ago