Added: 2 years ago
From: whoisbetterdotnet
Views: 5,296
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (328)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • angus is funny

  • Angus with Page,Blackmore,Roth,Schenker,G­ilmour...come on it's ridicolous :)

  • jimmy page lejoos!

  • para mi estos 2 weyes son los mas chingones de todooooos a uevo!!

  • Randy Rhoads is The best

  • Paul gilbert > both

  • both the same, both awesome. Jimi Page is a more versitile guitarist, but technically angus is better in my opinion, as he ran around, rolled around and never missed a note. Page was often fairly sloppy even when he wasnt moving. They however both put a lot of emotion into their solos which is very clear, something most guitarists these days lack.

  • Brian May

  • This is like comparing a Camaro to a Mercedes.......not even in the same league

  • This isnt even a question, the anser is Jimmy Page. Jimmy page should be compared to Eddie Van Halen, Jimi Hendrix, Slash or Steve Via!

  • @Brent77brent No Blackmore? And please don't compare Page and Hendrix, cause Page is far better.

  • @MysterioFan02 agreed

  • page is alot more versatile then angus young, even though angus is a great guitar player, page is a great guitar player, and a good producer..he produced all of zeppelins cds.

  • jimmy owns again,angus is to 1 dementional

  • @Kashmir0109 amen! someone has taste!

  • the runner ups worth our time. jimmy page, eric clampton, jeff beck, van halan, jimmy hendrix, slash. this isnt the order but all these guitarists are great. alot of bad bands sell tickets now a days cause no one has taste.... acdc got tickets becuase he ran around the stage. BIG deal

  • @Kashmir0109 yeah really

  • everyone look up jimmy pages 1973 stariway solo angus young cant improvise better than that. and what a crapy video he used for page... use his early stuff.

  • jimmy page... no question...

  • para os fãns de rock watch?v=Mn_vHySxc4I

  • Page in my opinion is grossly overrated. I think theres better guitarists than ang and page. But at the end of it all angus young still sells 65+ thousand tickets a night. Who else on a top 100 list still can do that? None of them so maybe hes the under the radar best?

  • From a sitting on a stool playing perspective id say page. But if i was lucky enough to pick one for my band its angus by a mile. Far more exciting live technically they have very similar styles but jimmy is smoother on recordings. Angus puts more people on the bleechers by far

  • the question cannot be, Jimmy Page is better, listened sound quality, riffs, solos, the rythmique line

  • All u guys r sacks of seeds! Angus young all the way!!!!!!!!!

  • @RockNRollFilmz page.

  • Jimmy Page:)

  • jimmy page obviously

  • Er, Angus Young is pretty good but Jimmy Page is a liiiiiiiittle bit better. Not more. He doesn't play very accurate(cadenced). But he is very progressive (look at Dazed and Confused) and discreter. But Angus Young makes me very happy when I´m listening to his solos. But Jimmy Page can do this too AND he can make me sad too. That can't Angus Young. So Jimmy Page is manifolder.

  • Hey AC/DC is a great band and Angus Young is most likely a better guitarist than i'll ever be, but the even comparing them is a JOKE and an EMBARRASMENT to James Patick Page AKA "The Second Lord".

  • Page is good´.

    Angus is God

  • @beats10tops  switch that around.

  • @madoerin dude, it's a personal opinion, there's no 'wrong' answers with opinions.

  • I personally think AC/DC's music is better, but JImmy Paige obviously has a better technique and knows the scales better, but that's not what makes good music.

  • @brumbiesfan97 wrong, the musical quality of jimmy is way better than angus...

  • @madoerin yeah really look at pages songs... theres not even a song i dont like by zepp. acdc i can only think of like 2 or 3 songs i like.

  • @NateageIV =) i feel the same

  • @brumbiesfan97 musicly and talent level led zeppelin man. pages songs have way better quality. i can think of only 3 good songs by acdc. look at zepp most of there songs are great!

  • angus young wins im telling you angus runs on stage and jumps around plus hits all the notes page cant do that

  • @gamer9313 Maybe thats because there are hardly any notes to hit in angus' solos

  • @joshuaayush Emmm, have you listened to AC/DC before mate? There is a lot of notes to hit. granted not as much as page, but live AC/DC kick the arse off anyone. musically though zep win. Bon and Robert are equal in my opinion though.

  • @snicketsm Yeah man. I play AC/DC as well.

  • @gamer9313 al becuase you run and spin on your back doenst mean your a great guitarist... lol

  • right?

  • I share totally who supports that jimmy Page is technically most prepared, creative and versatile. Anyway Angus is a real true "BLUESMAN". He's more istinctive, natural;it's tremolo's left hand is frightening..he has a FEELING comparable to SRV.

  • As a pure talented "bluesman" i prefer Angus. As talent in absolute for whose created with Led Zeppelin Jimmy without overdubs.

  • kay, first..how did Angus Young get into this debate. Jimmy is God..close runner ups are hendrix and Clapton..Jimmy doesnt play guitar he has sex with it.

  • jimmy dose better riffs than angus but not a better guitar player than angus

  • @autumnrain8 yeah he is dude lol.... he doenst even compare to page.

  • Jimmy Page and Jimi Hendrix are two BEST GUITAR PLAYER EVER

  • @vertiz95 that was exactly what i was going to say word for fricken word...creepy... but im glad im not the only one who thinks that Hendrix and Page are the two greatest guitarists of all time

  • @vertiz95 and that's the true!

  • @vertiz95 no, randy rhoads and EVH are bro

  • @vertiz95 Impossible statement man :) There are no best guitarist.Just a bunch of damn good ones :)

  • Page win...

  • Angus Young's solos are all exactly the same. How could he be better than Jimmy Page?

  • i really like Angus, i've got a poster of him on my wall, but Page is a genious..

    Page wins,..

  • angus will never let page win never

  • ANGUS YOUNG ANGUS YOUNG ITS A BEST EVER GUITARISTE

  • angus

  • @NateageIV oh

  • I like cheeseburgers.

  • @Kashmir0109 You know you're right. I'm an idiot. hahaha. Jimmy is a better player in every way... I have to be biased a little bit! haha

  • How could anyone say Angus? Musically retarded and know nothing about guitar fail.

  • jimmy page obviously....

    angus young it´s overrated

  • JIMMY PAGEE THE BEST EVERR

  • JP better by far in any way

  • Angus for sure..

  • ambos son buenos en guitarra me dic cuenta pero es mejor mi querido jimmi

  • I have to say that Jimmy is the better guitarist, in terms of technicality, musicianship, music knowledge... hell, everything except FEEL. And I absolutely fucking love angus young, just check my channel, all AC/DC guitar covers, haha. They're both very good, and it's all about style. Do you want an over-the-top complex and talented guitarist? Page. Do you want an old-school rocker who's got the feel for the music better than anyone else? Young.

  • @Hyce777 jimmy played with all emotion and feel bro listen to there songs.

  • it is an epic battle but I think Page win

  • it is an epic battle but I think page win

  • jimmi page power

  • ANGUS YOUNG IS GOD!!!!!!!

  • Ambos bons ! 

  • Ambos bons !

  • Jimmy Page, of course !

  • Angus for feeling!!!

  • Page is obviously "technically" better no quesstion common hands down without a doubt better. but Angus Young developed his style and thats what made him what he is today. they are both greats in rock and roll no matter how good their playing skills reaslly are.

  • Jimmy Page. But Angus Young's great too.

  • Angus

  • Ohhhh, I'm at the age for Jimmy Page!! Angus has lots to offer, but he's just NOT James Patrick Page!!

  • Angus is a lot more entertaining and hes a beast. Jimmy is amazing also (just like everybody in Zeppelin), i would say Angus is better because he is a lot more enthusiastic about his playing. Angus also has the duckwalk :P

  • JIMMY PAGE IS GOD!!!

  • jimmy page wins but..angus is also my fav guitarist...

  • whos better?....well Jimmy Page ofcourse he's the father of rock you can't compare anyone to him.

  • Jimmy pages high E just an orgasm

  • Angus is great guitarist. but, Jimmy ftw

  • jimmy page

  • jimmy wins

  • @Riff28Raff dude really... we are talkin bout solos not the song. angus doesnt play slow. listen to the jack its a slow song but he does fast shit in the solo. pay attention

  • PAGE. ZEPPELIN ARE GODS

  • Angus is fucking amazing, but Jimmy is a god. Jimmy wins..

  • jimmy wins!!!!!! angus isnt that great. slash is better than angus

  • @guitarist4life1000 No, lol. Actually, here it isn't a "who's better than anyone" at all. Page could play like Angus, and I'm sure as fuck Angus could play like Page. They have different styles and they are both legends if not gods. But Slash is not even close to Angus or Page.

  • @Watzitoya eh i really dont like angus and i get what your sayin but i think slash is a tad bit better than angus and jimmy is the best. but like you said they play there own style but they each own at it

  • @Watzitoya page and angus are great, but im gonna tell you this slash is fucking great anybody who tells you that slash sucks is a flat out fucking idiot who doesn't know shit about music. rock n roll is MEASURED by era. Slash is a fucking Great Guitarist, Yes you may have your favorites but Comparing a whole different style of guitar playing is soo stupid. Page is like the world to us guitar players but slash in his time is much more then anybody in his time. Instead of who vs who Enjoy It.

  • @Watzitoya now i can play perfectly gnr, led zep, yarbirds, and acdc, they can all play it perfectly, that i know for A HARD fact, because i can play it. but its not about who can play, its about the good music they bring to us and how we enjoy it. Trust me if i can play all thier songs perfectly then whats makes you thing that they can't play it even better? It's a rock n roll community and this comparing ourselves to ourselves, hell no, we have to represent all good rock. P.s Fuck Poison

  • Jimmy Page.

  • angus is my favourot guitarist ever but i gotta say jimmy paige

  • ANGUS PLAYS EASY AND WAY BETTER BUT I LIKE BOTH VERY VERY MUCH

  • this is a bad video but Zeppelin is way better, im 14 and i can play most of AC/DCs stuff by ear and learn a whole song in 20 minutes, Zeppelins stuff takes me at least a week to learn and i half to have tabs cuz their stuff is to complicated to play by ear

  • @JakeLikesHam

    You're 14... You can't really say one band is better than the other, since it is an opinion and opinion are never true or false, they are just choices made by an individual. Led Zeppelin ain't so difficult to learn by ear for I, but yes I can agree AC/DC is way easier, but that isn't a fact, because an individual could differ with us and yes I've seen some who do and they have the right of mind to have their opinion.

  • angus

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • @Riff28Raff

    YOU actually started on Zeppelin.

    Actually no we don't shag sheep, there's plenty of your mum to go around for us all!

  • @Riff28Raff

    just leave it, kid, you'll never be the man your mother is.

  • @Riff28Raff

    unfunny uploads, well all my viewers disagree. I'd like to ask you how old you are but clearly you can't count that high.

  • @Riff28Raff

    we'r not comparing Zep, look at the title of the video you cum dumpster.

  • @Riff28Raff bad humour... that was quality.

  • @Riff28Raff

    I dont get kicks from it, clearly people like them, I've got 186 subsribers and almost 20,000 video views.

    Go stick your head in the oven and make everyone happy. You're a waste of your dad's sperm.

  • @Riff28Raff

    yes they didn't rate Zep, but we'r comparing guitarists.

    Keith Richards -

    "Jimmy Page was one of the greatest guitar players I've ever known"

    Pete Townshed-

    "they became so much bigger than The Who in so many ways, but I've never liked them"

    The evidence is there, check it out first before you let your loutish thoughts loose.

  • @Riff28Raff

    i know its a big place LOL

    i said you are of such low intelligence that you could almost thinnk that it's a small place.

  • @Riff28Raff

    proof you're a neanderthal, your appaling use of language and lack of decent rhetoric. Also the way you act like an impetualant child.

  • @Riff28Raff

    LOL you think that's a video game character. And it's there for comedy, read the comments, people found it funny.

  • @Riff28Raff

    which artists?

    I quoted the videos that YOU TOLD ME TO WATCH. Idiot.

  • @Riff28Raff

    Yes, most played song on american radio. That's a pretty big achievement.

    Of course you'll just say that America only has 12 people or something.

  • @Riff28Raff

    "geek" and "yo aint exactly einstein are you"

    a bit contradictory?

  • @Riff28Raff

    Haha someones getting a little flustered as their point is being driven under.

    You come across as a neanderthal.

  • @Riff28Raff

    lol "video game geek" again, prove this claim?

    i didn't say i was einstein LOL

  • @Riff28Raff

    im not typing just the good bits.

    Just search for Keith Moon on Led Zeppelin or Pete Townshend on Led Zeppelin, and you'l find that i've simply quoted them.

  • @Riff28Raff

    that's what i said.

  • @Riff28Raff

    proof?

  • @Riff28Raff

    They helped largely, along with other bands, yes, but they were unquestionably a huge factor in its formation. It wasn't from a poll, it was from official figures, idiot.

    "any zep fan that mentions swth or kashmir as zeps greatest work are clearly pretensious morons"

    Ok Stairway isn't their greatest work, but people say Kashmir is because Led Zeppelin actually agreed that it is their greatest LOL. Do your research before you come on here spouting any random crap.

  • @Riff28Raff

    From your channel:

    "my frogleshmee account is fucked, i think its been disconnected, dnt know why and dont care, i couldnt be bothered contacting youtube to fix it so i started a new account.

    LET THERE BE ROCK!!!!!!!!!!!!! "

    Wow....you sound so smart.

  • @Riff28Raff

    yes there are more drummers, but Bonham and Moon are the 2 considered to be the greatest ever.

  • @Riff28Raff

    and I actually HAVE videos and 186 subscribers. Whereas you don't.

  • @Riff28Raff

    haha i just watched Keith Richards on Led Zep...

    "Jimmy Page is one of the greatest guitarists ever."

    And I also watched Pete Townshend talking about Zeppelin...

    "Yes i never liked Zeppelin because they became so much bigger than The Who in so many ways."

    You've shot yourself in the foot there, kid.

  • @Riff28Raff

    Oh my God....Where did I say Jimmy Page was NOT in the Yardbirds?

    I know all that, and that Page started as bass player in the Yardbirds....

    Of course Beck was considered better then, Page wasn't famous at all.

  • @Riff28Raff

    i didn't say i thought it was great. I said that many people and critics who actually went to Zeppelin concerts stated that it was awe-inspiring. Just watch the movie The Song Remains the Same and look at the crowd.

  • @Riff28Raff

    i never said they created it, i said they formed it, which means they helped (largely) to make rock and roll into hard rock and metal. And it's definitely not true that Zeppelin didn't master rock and roll, just listen to Stairway to Heaven, considered the greatest ROCK song of all time, Whole Lotta Love, considered the greatest guitar riff of all time... I'm not biased, I like AC/DC, but Jimmy Page and Zeppelin are far superior. And it's not just me, see the highest rated comments

  • @Riff28Raff

    I have read books on rock and roll for your information. I never said he was a blues drummer....?

    And I know that he isn't the only one considered to be the best ever, and yes, people do think Moon is also a contender for the greatest ever, but what many people agree on is that Moon was more to do with style and craziness, whereas Bonham was overall a better drummer.

  • @Riff28Raff

    And you are more clearly an AC/DC fan. I've seen your favourites list.

  • @Riff28Raff

    i was mocking you there....Keith Richards was a big Zeppelin fan by the way. Also, him, Townshend etc are not great guitarists.

  • @Riff28Raff

    it was after the Yardbirds broke up that Beck saw Page play "You Shook Me". This isn't about Gilmour, Clapton or Hendrix. This is about Page and Young. And I am 100% Beck WAS reduced to tears, he described the event in the documentary "The Story of The Yardbirds and Led Zeppelin." Check it out if you don't believe me.

  • @Riff28Raff

    i said that your opinion on "the violin bow sounding shit" was of not much value.

  • @Riff28Raff

    yes they did what they liked, and that's great. And kudos to them for doing that and for not selling out. But you simply cannot compare them to Zeppelin, who formed entire genres. And I won't repeat myself, but you know what I've said about playing different genres. AC/DC are a great band. Angus Young is a great guitar player. But they simply are not in the same league as Jimmy Page and Led Zeppelin.

  • @Riff28Raff

    Yes, your opinion. Which matters not here.

  • @Riff28Raff

    Errr no, he was blues influenced. And if he did like Jazz, it certainly did not follow through into Zeppelin songs. Name one for me, if it did. And if you think the drummer who created the hard rock style of drumming and who is considered to be the best of all time is a jazz player, think again.

  • @Riff28Raff

    Ok if you want to know who's a better band, just look at each member.

    John Bonham > The guy who hits the same drum in AC/DC

    John Paul Jones > The guy who isn't even noticed or makes much of a contribution in AC/DC

    Jimmy Page > BOTH of AC/DC's guitarists (we've covered this, read what I've said.)

    Robert Plant > The singer in AC/DC who sounds like he's eaten too much chocolate or swallowed a cheese grater.

  • @Riff28Raff

    That's just a lovely story you told. But it means nothing, that other people think he's good. But if you want to talk about effect on other greats, Jeff Beck was reduced to tears seeing Page playing "You Shook Me", when he realised how great a performance it was. "your realy just a non entity" All you can do is insult me, as your argument isn't watertight. "your opinion holds no value to me" I did not try to make my opinion matter to you, and i couldn't care less if it did.

  • @Riff28Raff

    Again, it doesn't matter what he was inspired by, it matters what he performed and displayed. Yes they're a popular rock and roll band, but they don't display musical variety like Led Zeppelin did. Yes being rock and roll is fine, but just don't compare them to Zeppelin who did that (better and with more skill than AC/DC) plus much more, using many genres.

  • @Riff28Raff

    The violin bow was "pompous and sounded shit." That's your opinion, which does not matter here. And it wasn't pompous, it complemented the eerie nature of the song and was the spectacle of Zeppelin concerts, which you haven't experienced. Don't be so ignorant. You say that Page had the "look how good I am" attitude. Well he definitely did not, but look at Young strutting about in the schoolboy outfit. If anything says "look at me", that's it. He is an attention grabber. He needs it.

  • @Riff28Raff

    Name one instance where Zeppelin performed jazz for me. Page wasn't doing anything new? Look at videos of Dazed and Confused and Communication Breakdown from 1969, where he breaks into metal. And you say Zeppelin aren't rock and roll? Of all the absurd claims you've made, that one takes the cake.

  • @Riff28Raff

    Using one particular instrument does not display an entire genre. And being inspired by something means nothing until you perform it.

    "acdc are a better rocknroll band because thats all they play."

    So it's quantity over quality, and whoever writes more rock songs is better? Definately not.

  • @Riff28Raff ---continued---

    focuses on the same few genres, showing a blinkered knowledge of music.

    Honestly, you sound like a bitter AC/DC fan who cannot accept the fact that there are better guitarists out there who have more skill, can play without repeating the same chords, are more popular, possess more energy, and have ALOT more talent than Young.

  • @Riff28Raff And finally,

    Skill - Page undeniably. Page dabbled in and mastered many genres such as Celtic, Arabic, Blues, Rock, Hard Rock, Metal and many more. This shows his immense musical knowledge and talent and displays the plethora of musical roots from which he derives his genius. Listen to any Led Zeppelin album and compare it to any AC/DC album and you will notice the intense energy and musical talent that goes into Zeppelin albums. As for Young's songs, he always ----continued----

  • @Riff28Raff

    And by the way, a great guitar player is measured on their influence, live performances and skill.

    Influence - Unquestionably Page, he made rock and hard rock into what they are today. Young did influence alot of bands, but not a genre like Page.

    Live performances - Again Page. Such energetic spectacles such as the violin bowing in Dazed and Confused live are magestic and convey power. Such a performance I have yet to see from Young.

  • @Riff28Raff

    A professor prefers Young. So what? It's opinion, not fact. The facts however, are that Jimmy Page changed rock music completely, and what exactly did Young do that wasn't around before? Nothing. And a guitarist's technical accuracy is nothing, if it doesn't capture their emotion and feeling in their music, something which Page unquestionably beats Young on. Bottom line is music is about emotion and passion, not about hitting every note perfectly like a machine.

  • @Riff28Raff

    Yes they did write slow songs. But did they ever write songs which captured celtic or arabic roots? No. It's because they do not have a fraction of the talent or musical genius that Led Zeppelin possessed.

  • In my opinion... everyone can shut the fuck up because it depends on what ur into but don't u dare make assumption about one or the other i saw that some dumb shit said angus plays "slow" he has got ear problems to say that(dumb shit). Jimmy is a fucking tank and angus is a fucking tank, I personally like angus better but does that mean he's better? no. and that doesn't mean jimmy is better either. Fuck you all

  • George Lynch

  • angus destroy jimy, stupid question for a guitar player , angus has

    1) escene

    2) technique

    3) impro

    4) balls

    5) style

    6) best solos in all the songs since "high voltage"

    7) angus have better solos than this video........... :S:S:S!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! listen the solo of guns for hire or gone shootin... OMG

    sorry my bad english xD im ungry for those comments U,U

  • @thedarknessperu hahahahahahhahaha i fuckin love it

  • angus young ever

  • Page vs Young? IT's like you asking Les Paul and SG with is better??????

  • Jimmy was also a master of creating songs using exotic and various alternate tunings, which was not common at all in the hard rock genre back then.  JIMMY PAGE = FRIGGIN GENIUS

  • Jimmy Page is an incredible musician who has changed the face of rock and roll. Angus is a good guitarist who has come up with some great riffs, but just hasn't done what Jimmy has done for Rock/Metal.

  • jimmy page