Confortaby numb by Dreamtheater

[21eyepopper]

Awesomest improvisation ever !

[hallbergjonatan]

Well Petrucci is Petrucci... You can't get any better then that.

[Pleiadesz]

Three Guitarist to cover this song and they dont even come close to Gilmour haha :) with all respect after all i like Petrucci he did a great job on Any colour (thier best cover of Floyd)

[Childfromhere]

loooool @ 6:35 john hits the other guitarist by his elbow !!

[ZDCP1994]

Nice cover, and awesome solo! So many emotions and everything !! *u* I love it

[medredaazim]

What a Solo !!

I can't stop repeating it just amazing :D

[TheFinalDude]

that's so beautiful!

[SeixterTown]

I love Dream Theater but this cover sucks ._.

[gobbicarlo83]

Petrucci is the best!! Labrie so and so.... last singer is a very fucking man!!!

[BreeBree1731]

I nearly cried at Petrucci's solo. So fucking emotional and musical.....one of the best guitarists ever lived. Together with Paul Gilbert, David Gilmour and Carlos Santana.

[Dvermoet]

@BreeBree1731 I agree with the guitarists you mentioned, especially David Gilmour but do you think there is some room to fit John Frusciante between those? He really played some beautiful emotional solo's <3 (:

[099fedeSegade]

this is the best cover that i ever heard !!

[Raffael900me]

LaBrie is the fuckin man!!!!!

[dragonytx1]

Petrucci strupo os kra ¬¬

[dragonytx1]

D i F e R e N ç A da Porra de Petrucci tocando pra essa primeiro guitarrista ai ¬¬

[TheAtomicsPR]

Petrucci really nailed that solo

[Havo0ok]

What's that other band?

[Havo0ok]

@Havo0ok : Nevermind. I got it.

[kartouches]

@Havo0ok queensryche

[Joselo1693]

wait what the hell is going on??????

[Drumboy81]

Why do they play it with a swing feel?!?

Very annoying!

[mrgray455]

if you like floyd look at mostly autumn awsome band

[Satriani0101]

Really not sure what the other guitarists are doing - well done petrucci!

[JerichoDitch2]

admirable job on a classic.. well done.... no cover ever eclipsed The Floyd of course, but I wont ask the impossible

[valheru]

what is the name other band ?

[amaltash]

THERE IS NO PAIN YOU ARE RECEEDINNG!!!!!!!! <3

[claudiomek1]

El solo de guitarra que mas me gusta en el mundo !!!!

Y estas bandas que talento !!!!!

[Jmast3r6046]

Confortaby. wat.

[studman4250]

Dude can you really not spell comfortably?

[ItalianBandit]

It's either the symbol or ride, either one is fucking annoying in this song.

tink tink tinik tink tink tink tink.

[Haloplayer20]

@ItalianBandit the ride is a cymbal

[ItalianBandit]

@Haloplayer20 Yeah, i know that you cocky *******. I was being descriptive to clerically my statement. The ride is a type of cymbal but it's still called a ride.

PS: Your mom is a cymbal.

Good day to you sir!

[TimeWolf26]

@ItalianBandit

Woah, you don't know shit. First of all, you weren't being descriptive at all, and with my poor grip of the English language I wasn't aware you could "clerically" a statement. You listed a category and a subset of said category, like saying "either two or a number".

Congratulations, sir - you are an idiot.

[ItalianBandit]

@TimeWolf26 The fact that you have to point out the obvious spelling mistakes means you are looking for trouble. As you already know with your "English Degree" i meant Clearly. And how the hell was i not descriptive, it was better then you did,. I don't like fighting over the internet so you can rebuttal bbbbbbbbbuuuutt i wont give two shits. You wanna be a smart ass on the internet and i well... don't.

So fuck you and have a good day,

[TheBeeeetle]

the best cover for comfortably numb SOLO. ever

[1010abcdefgh]

have to say, i love Dream Theater but not mad about this version at all. Just reckon Gilmour does it better but hey thats what a cover version is all about. Doesn't make me think any less of Dream Theater! :-) Gotta say the first guitar solo sucked balls, horrible tone and vibrato!!!

[macchia2000]

Il tipo sembra adriano pappalardo

[hashkabreet]

Great Solo !!!!!



[Skoshtwo]

Holy shit. LaBrie seems ripped here !

[MlKEPORNTOY]

Geoff Tate = uncomfortably dumb

[baddad59]

Want to hear a great cover of this song ? One that the guitar solo is every bit as good as Gilmores and Petruccis ? Check out The Australian Pink Floyd ! They are good enough that Gilmore hires THEM when he throws a big party !!

[BrFelo]

@baddad59 I prefer the worst band ever butchers

[adrielchng]

I find it kinda ironic that the solo was cut out and made into another video, and that video has more views than this full one...

[castelluis]

me cago en la puta!!!! tengo ganas de llorar de la felicidad!!!

[MrStoney2011]

this is an exceptional ,Dream Theater and Queensrhyces Geoff Tate doing a great rendition of Pink Floyds comfortably numb.not sure if this is actually all members of Queensrhyce but this is a solid performance and love it when Tate goes into his high octave . And of course John Petrucci on the guitar....gdang.

[agdthatguy]

faggots,,,whats with paul schahfer lol and fabio, bunch of fudge packers

[DethThrasher1]

@agdthatguy pathetic..its a tribute to a great band and theres always retards like you who take offensive at it

[beto1814]

intento fallido......pero se hizo el esfuerzo.......PD..pink floyd es INIGUALABLE

[hhfs73]

Am I wrong or is Queensryche also participating here?

[hhfs73]

Am I wrong or is Queensryche also participating here?



[elmax316]

how can one person play this better than an entire band? Dreamtheater rocks, but Pink Floyd rocks harder

[chopu1992]

jajajajajaja que locos están estos fanáticos de dream theater ! PINK FLOYD LES VIOLA A TODOS, EL MEJOR GRUPO DE ROCK EN LA HISTORIA !

[beto1814]

@chopu1992 ABSOLUTAMENTE CIERTO.....EL MEJOR DE LA HISTORIA

[shabaddituktuk]

Sorry, as much as I love Dream Theater and Queensryche and although an admirable effort this was one song probably best left alone.

[gertjeeeh]

Petrucci hasn't got THE tone.

[PatriotFan1251]

i like it

[PortalRealm]

labrie killed the other singer, portnoy killed the other drummer, and petrucci killed everyone !

[abhimuscat]

@PortalRealm the other singer?? you do mean tate dont you? he sang brilliantly

[Echoes31]

@PortalRealm agree for Portnoy & Petrucci, but Labrie is the worst singer i heard in live (not in studio), and Gilmour's solo is the best guitar solo ever

[Bryanbhoop]

@Echoes31 i heard Labrie live a couple of months ago in Toronto and he was amazing. I think its the shear length of the songs that dream theater plays that make people think he is not a good singer because from what i heard it was spectacular

[Mantares92]

@PortalRealm John was feeling like Chuck Norris XD

[pamarkyo]

You people entirely suck and have no idea what talent is. The dolts at the end screw it up.

[fydsg]

nunca crei que esta cancion pudiera sonar robotica, con todo respeto,los respeto pero simplemente no me gusta.

[alexthegooner75]

petrucci is the best

[kallelal]

John Petrucci = GOD

[pamarkyo]

What shocks me is most of you idiots bashing this video can't play it! It'd be like me making fun of YOU for not being able to bang your own sister.

[eimaiokalyteros]

Feeling and emotion are useless guitarists' excuses because they can't play something more "technical". If you can't stand hearing something that it's more technical than the original then don't listen to it. You'd be happy if Petrucci was making faces during the solo,uh? Petrucci plays with the most emotion!!!

[gertjeeeh]

@eimaiokalyteros You're such a dumb ass

[eimaiokalyteros]

@gertjeeeh Probably, but I'm twice better with guitar than you're dreaming to be...

[gertjeeeh]

@eimaiokalyteros You say feeling and emotion is useless and then you say petrucci plays with emotion? lol

[eimaiokalyteros]

@gertjeeeh I didn't say they are useless. I said that useless guitarists use them as an excuse...

[gertjeeeh]

@eimaiokalyteros Petrucci has got less emotion then Gilmour, Straight timing, en hasn´t got the tone.

Petrucci´s got a metal tone not suitable for pink floyd. Gilmour uses old school big muff. Gilmour uses unexpected timing and dynamic playing.

[ZVanderberg11]

@gertjeeeh So I guess you can read Petrucci's mind and tell how much "emotion" he has, eh? You can't judge emotion. That's a personal thing, and everyone expresses it differently. You're a person who can't accept that musicians have become better as the years have gone by.

[Tultach]

Blows my mind how thin the other guitarists' tone sounds in comparison to Petrucci's.

[Tultach]

to some people, sloppy playing = emotion, apparently

[10aspiref]

David Haye @5:56

[TheKramer1992]

john petrucci y los piedreros

[JimKnopf15]

Petrucci kicking Gilmour's ass, awesome solo.

[paganiniviolin]

@JimKnopf15 This is nothing compared to Gilmour solos! I can not feel the emotion that I feel when Gilmour is playing!

[thetittymonster7]

although he lacks emotion and soul in his version of the solo, he made it good by adding pinch harmonics in the right places.. good solo.... bad style.

[geia4]

first solo has very good tone...too bad lacks emotion of the guitarists hands...also

some bend were a bit too sharp...

honestly i dont like the petrucci 's solo ...the descending of the scales are so technical that they give an ''excersise -like'' sound...also the flat third of the scale is microtonally being bend too aggresively

[yuki777guitar]

unfortunately the second voice (geoff tate) is always a bit too loud.. and wow petrucci, this is why i love this guy and have him as an idol

[sjbrave2k2]

Man that cover would have been amazing if stupid Queensryche wasn't there.

[mazingguitar]

@sjbrave2k2 Queensryche is really good band and Geoff Tate is so fuckin awesome

[corosian]

The first solo is absolutely awful lol

[vexon123]

@corosian dumbest guy in the world? i think so

[corosian]

@vexon123 no need to offend yourself :)



[rivero424]

велика композиция-затова ....прегазва..

[Electronicbard6]

all thease "murdered, it is not gilmour comments" reminds me one great video on worshipping artists.

watch?v=qB9il634dxg

worth watching.

[felphero]

somebody please make Labrie's mic louder!

[pilotman0953]

Maybe this guy can get some guitar lessons from David Gilmour.

The value of the old saying has been proved once again: Don't try something that is really out of your league.

[Blackened1994]

@pilotman0953 i hope by this guy you were referring to the two other shitheads and not petrucci

[Etogar]

vocals are miserable, music ok, petrucci´s guitar is ok ´till some part, i´ve always said that john is a great guitar player, but this is too much

pink floyd is not about speed in the guitars or a big showing off with 3 guitars, is about feeling and emotion, is that too hard to understand?????, they totaly blow this amazing song, and i´m sorry for that 'cause the are really a great band

[calummcmillan1]

@Etogar i thought it was pretty good, nothings going to be as good as the original however this is one of the best covers ive seen

[ItsNotaTuhmah]

Man, that was so weak compared to the original. Wtf with the solo? it's so empty as the Petrucci's face.

DT should stop on covering tunes that imply some degree of emotion.

[pamarkyo]

Why do I see all these fags complaining?? If you can't do it - get back on your big wheel.

[fatShowPony]

Wow it's amazing how lacking in feeling that outro solo is compared to Dave Gilmour - same notes (to start with) but one takes you to a different place, this does absolutely nothing...

[azebolsky]

I want to talk with the sound engineer for this recording... Absolute garbage. >:(

[SinFloyd]

Please mr. Gilmour save us.

[BockwurstBob]

@SinFloyd lol dude? what is wrong with you? thumbs down for that comment!

dont ever disrespect petrucci and dream theater again! you can say whatever you want, but he did a great perfomance on that solo! and in all the perfomance was very good!

[waltervt]

LaBrie looks like Thor in this clip.

[pedrowmoreno]

Wtf is that? they say That's confortably numb by pink floyd?!?

im so sorry, but this is bullshit

the vocals are trash. petruici's guitar is ok, but it's nothing compared to guilmore's....

anyway, what was I expecting?

Pink Floyd > Dreamtheater, and that is a FACT

[Exalon19]

@pedrowmoreno

Actually, that's just your opinion :)

and what you think doesn't matter, at all

[mrdeathjester]

@pedrowmoreno why so butthurt, bro?

[stiffaction]

@pedrowmoreno You don't need to be so full of scathe. Dream theater are a very talented group. What they are doing here is paying tribute to one of the best rock groups ever. So what if they don't sound the way floyd does.

If pink floyd were to play 'a change of seasons', do you think they could outdo the way dream theater plays that song. So the same way DT can't do it like floyd.

Its called R E S P E C T.

Also comparing the "good" musicians like you're comparing athletes is kinda immature.

[marshalladdict96]

@stiffaction You're absolutely right. I can't stand that a top rated comment on hear is complete BS. Is it so wrong that they want to honor one of the greatest bands ever? Is it so wrong that they aren't Pink Floyd but still want to play the song? Gosh.

[sIrRaH666]

It's the bloke from Master Chef!!!

[Lebaron1987]

Hole-e-shit, john petrucci amazed me how he turned the solo to metal/heavier rock, one of the rare remade solo that is actually amazing. I am a floyd fan, I listen to them everyday and this cover deserve's gilmour's thumbs up. They made me get an interest into their work from now on.

[gertjeeeh]

The guy on the right is the 22nd fret master!!!!

[WeeArnSon]

so shit!

[thedarkness97]

Murdered!!! >:(

[uberkelvin]

John Petrucci = skidmark on the seat of David Gilmour's underpants.

[Afterglow1337]

I just noticed the title says "Confortably Numb" haha

[Per770718]

@Afterglow1337 No! Even worse! It says "Confortaby Numb". ;)

[Afterglow1337]

@Per770718 Hahahhaha yeah

[Tylerbag]

Great solo from John Petrucci but at 5:50 lost interest when the other two ruined the solo. still not a touch on Gilmore

[laikynsdad]

dont know how to bend aye?

[MrVeegee69]

is it fabio ??? ha ha

[d3n1zc]

Pink floyd is far better than Quensryche and the Dream Theater in this song I just love how Petrucci played the guitar. Well said folk we just love to hear Jhony ;)

[ThePisciru]

I don't like this cover, sorry :/

[UltiMogr]

the solo is supposed to be played solo. no skinheads should come along and play bullshit high pitch notes. thats why they call it a SOLO!

[romulopina]

PINK FLOYD é insuperavel !!!

[acrocduck2alk]

petrucci? petrucci must suck gilmour's dick and shut up.

petrucci does maybe 3 beautiful song. gilmour does only beautiful song. GREAT song.

[PanchToTheNotch]

did anyone notice the horrible spelling in the title?

[f4d30u7]

Who the hell is the bald singer?

[vixenius]

@f4d30u7 Da bold singer?



[f4d30u7]

@vixenius I'm sure he writes in italic.

[vixenius]

@f4d30u7 I guess so.. :)

[hotrrod1973]

I wish i could play guitar like that.

Check out Sonny Landreth if you appreciate great guitar players.

Different music but awsome musician.

[jkellzer]

Petrucci would kill a chick if he fingered her.

[Mrawleth]

@jkellzer And it would be a good death ;3

[ferpeople]

Third Guitar is the Master of 22º Fret

[waltervt]

@ferpeople well, I wouldn't mind playing "the master of 22º fret" if I get to play on stage with DreamFloyd and Petrucci!

[dioseolo]

@ferpeople lmao

[botargon]

@ferpeople hahahaha

[carolegagnon1974]

Wow, great cover ! Can anybody tell me if this was taken from a DVD, I thought the DT/QR tour was amazing and if this is part of the complete show, I WANT IT !!!!!!!!! Thank you ;)

[azorian82]

Thank the holy guitar gods that Petrucci was there to save this. Without him this would be just another shitty confortably numb cover.

[op0Lyo]

Fantastic vibrate!

[funofsk8ing]

pentatonick hahaha nice name!! creative, I take it you play guitar?

[Secondlifecreator]

I KENT hear what you SAY....

It is CANT HEAR WHAT YOUR SAYING...

The drummer SUCKS , the guitar is good! The singers both are dull and without passion there. Sorry failed a little this cover :/

[guitarmenace1981]

@Secondlifecreator You speak the truth. And by truth I mean truth truth. And by truth truth I mean what Dream Theater fans know is right but don't want to hear.

[Tim733733]

As someone from England, this song is sacred. Dreamtheater honoured it beautifully. I thought it'd be impossible for any band to cover this in the style befitting the song. They did it and then some.

[Supermonkey22]

@Tim733733 Hey Tim, I respect the UK and every bit of amazing music that's come from there but I respectfully suggest you listen to Yellow Brick Road and their tribute to Pink Floyd. Listen without pride or prejudice and I bet you'll love their version as well. It's pretty badass from a bunch of Yankees. =) Cheers from the midwest in the US.

[xXQcAresiusQcXx]

There is a reason why Petrucci's guitar was louder than the others... Because he's the best!!!

[vigierandprsrule]

wow labrie's voice sounds better than usual,poor guy wrecked his vocal chrods

[gabrielbalbo555]

muito parecido seilá da uma onde loca assistir isso parece pink floyd com uma bateria mais aguçada algo louco

e com o vocal mais agudo

até que nesse ponto mandarm bem

[akoo321]

I think they are the great musician, especially Petrucci.. He is realy master but this is different style :(

[gigisca]

David Gilmour

Giant of guitar

[rasj5150]

This sucks... first solo sucked... sometimes they look like they are singing in a karaoke... and Petrucci is awesome.

PS. Guitar dudes come out of nowhere!

[paulo70412]

no no no ...

[Molfsonand]

did he burp into the mic right about 2:58?

[tonyNOS81]

@Molfsonand omg yes XD

[Arfeus85]

Come sempre Labrie non si può proprio sentire! Per il resto great great great song......



[MYE7610]

the singing sucks - one faggot and one screamer

[pamarkyo]

@MYE7610 - spoken like a biebler fan. ..

[nickdemondares]

petrucci---->>awesome

[MrFabili]

It's coMfortabLy numb

[MrFabili]

The second solo is playing John Petrucci

[9VoltProductions]

The third guitarist is like "I can hold this note all day bitches." 5:51

[pamarkyo]

@ anyone who wants to talk shit about this video : CAN YOU DO IT??

[codewarior666]

Of course, Dream Theater is an awesome collection of perfection packed together.. It has all the Gods of Guitar.. Petrucci, John myung... BUT, Gilmour is an exception out. The magic that he has in his voice and finGers are beyond any capability of reproduction. I loved the tribute as it is again a perfection put together, however, originality doesn't even come up till an inch.. Its only gilmour who has the capicity to take you a different level of feeling.. especially, this song.. !

[codewarior666]

Of course, Dream Theater is an awesome collection of perfection packed together.. It has all the Gods of Guitar.. Petrucci, John myung... BUT, Gilmour is an exception out. The magic that he has in his voice and finGers are beyond any capability of reproduction. I loved the tribute as it is again a perfection put together, however, originality doesn't even come up till an inch.. Its only gilmour who has the capicity to take you a different level of feeling.. especially, this song.. !

[GabrielDhalaman]

Gilmour seemed he was praying while soloing...and the notes just reach there,THERE so perfectly,he knew always how to pray quiet,loud...i am not religious,thank god,ahahah...but i know about the spirit and i must say,there is something very sacred on gilmour´s emotion

[sspanzer]

Quality!

[ricardobarsanelli]

what a perfect voice duet

[flatblackstrat]

Who are these guys? Some Euro band? One of the singers looks like Fabio.

[Hack3r91]

@flatblackstrat If you are refering to Fabio Lione from ROF, the long haired dude is James LaBrie from Dream Theater.

[TheCyanic]

@flatblackstrat The origional song is preformed and written by Pink Floyd. In this video however, pink floyd is playing with Dream Theater. and the fabio guy is the dream theater singer James LeBrie

[pamarkyo]

@TheCyanic - really?? I don't see a n y o n e from Floyd here. I see Queensryche and Dream Theater.

[mauriciomba1]

One of the best covers I've seen paying attribute to the best band that will ever exist "Pink Floyd". Well done Dreamheater, bloody well done as Mrwashaway said. Long live Pink floyd