I think Amy is better just throwing my 2 cents in lol.
and too all the people that say you cant compare Carly to Amy its just going to happen she put herself in the position TO be compared to Amy Lee. There is no way she joined this band and thought that people wouldnt do that naturally. Right now WATF is only surviving because of the former ev. fan base, they havent done anything to get themselves recognized they are just spring boarding off evanescecne's fame.
You know...that's kind of how I feel about it. I kind of think We are the fallen is not a good band name knowing what happened with Ben moody and evanescence... Something just doesn't sit right with me. I love her voice, I just have a weird feeling about her being in a band with everyone who was once apart of evanescence
She should go on by herself...Singing like this, Ben just invited her to play his sick play. We are the Fallen really isn't good for her voice. P.D. EVANESCENCE ROCKS
@EvRocksMySox - wahahaha!! that's right! you know what? in the official facebook page of evanescence they have 1,500,000 fans and we are the fallen has 14,000 fans only lol!!
@brianorlando Oh now I remember you. Wow, again you're late to the party. A 2 week old comment. You're so right. I need to go fuck 10 more guys. I am a hot mess.Thank you Dr. Drew.
@harryaNna92 Amy doesnt have a fraction of the voice carly has....and Amy sucks without Ben Moody. The Open Door was such a shitty record....."call me when you're sober..." ....LMAO......lame
You guy's are retarded. Carly Smithson can sing, Amy Lee isn't payin your bills, stop hatin. Carly clearly has a more powerful voice and she trained very very well.
If you say she can't sing than your just stupid or jealous.
You cant blame people for having their own opinions, the only reason people r comparing Amy with Carly is because it seems Carly is trying to be just like her,
Oh and btw, you say Amy isnt paying our bills... well Carly Smithson isnt paying anyones bills either
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
lol imannanimegod! lol, ok... but in all honesty, carly sux at singing evanescence's' older songs! yknow what?... if ben wants to be a jerk off , n be like well they were my songs too... then let him! he probably would go back next for all i know, and be like ok kelly clarkson, i want my song b/c of u back, and avril i want to have my song i wrote nobodys home, b/c i wrote it... lol whatta laugh too! just thinking about it. whatta loser! ben gay and johnny no seeds and rocky bob the builder!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Evanescence is better so you people are just wasting your time. The only reason why I'm watching this is to see if anyone said anything bad. I THINK I'M THE FIRST ONE
If I'm not mistaken, this is the audio from the US Magazine website exclusive from recorded live Idol Extra performance that never was broadcast, so it's not really "a demo".
The only thing I'd change is the male backups are too loud in the mix here.
she should have released the solo album and stayed away from WATF. She wouldn't oppose so many EV fans and this song is amazing.
ozbilege123 1 month ago
this was such much better than her work with We are the fallen
kroperea 9 months ago
what album is this from?
liz20141 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
AMY LEE 4 EVER
Carly I'll let you fall 4 sure :)
MyxLastxBreathex 1 year ago
She just had to join that damn band and scrap the solo stuff she wrote. STUPID MOVE CARLY, YOU WERE AN AMAZING SOLO ARTIST!
IAmGoombaSniper 1 year ago 3
WHEN IS THIS SONG GOING TO BE AVAILABLE?!
YoItsJourdan 1 year ago
@YoItsJourdan never...she scrapped the solo album
sweetaztecangel69 1 year ago
@sweetaztecangel69 NOOOOOOOOOO!!!!! How the Hell did John Burroughs High School get the song to use for their show choir set then?! D:
YoItsJourdan 1 year ago
@YoItsJourdan bought the rights from her publisher? I dont know...what I do know is she had to scrap the solo album to join We Are The Fallen
sweetaztecangel69 1 year ago
I say by the time WATF's second CD comes out it wont be so Evanescence sounding they are good :) but still i <3 amy lee more lol
djphan89 1 year ago
I think Carly has a great voice.
I think Amy is better just throwing my 2 cents in lol.
and too all the people that say you cant compare Carly to Amy its just going to happen she put herself in the position TO be compared to Amy Lee. There is no way she joined this band and thought that people wouldnt do that naturally. Right now WATF is only surviving because of the former ev. fan base, they havent done anything to get themselves recognized they are just spring boarding off evanescecne's fame.
djphan89 1 year ago
@djphan89
You know...that's kind of how I feel about it. I kind of think We are the fallen is not a good band name knowing what happened with Ben moody and evanescence... Something just doesn't sit right with me. I love her voice, I just have a weird feeling about her being in a band with everyone who was once apart of evanescence
SpatulaofDestiny1 1 year ago
This is not a demo, this is a live performance she made on AI Extra -.-
arturesteve 1 year ago
She should go on by herself...Singing like this, Ben just invited her to play his sick play. We are the Fallen really isn't good for her voice. P.D. EVANESCENCE ROCKS
Haibane16 1 year ago
where can i download this??
maoftwingels 1 year ago
oh my god this song sucks and she sucks ... im only hearing a DYING Cat on the road ...
EvRocksMySox 2 years ago
@EvRocksMySox - wahahaha!! that's right! you know what? in the official facebook page of evanescence they have 1,500,000 fans and we are the fallen has 14,000 fans only lol!!
03muzikah 1 year ago
@03muzikah Evanescence has been around for years dipshit...of coarse they are going to have more....
brianorlando 1 year ago
Carly's fucking delusional fans are so funny.
iLOVEChihuahuas123 2 years ago
@iLOVEChihuahuas123 shut up and get a life douche bag
brianorlando 1 year ago
@brianorlando Dumb ass, let me ask you. Why in the fuck must you reply to something so old? You delicate piece of shit.
iLOVEChihuahuas123 1 year ago
@iLOVEChihuahuas123 its less than a year old dipshit.....you really are a douche
brianorlando 1 year ago
@brianorlando Oh now I remember you. Wow, again you're late to the party. A 2 week old comment. You're so right. I need to go fuck 10 more guys. I am a hot mess.Thank you Dr. Drew.
iLOVEChihuahuas123 1 year ago
@iLOVEChihuahuas123 you really need to get laid.....i can just imagine what a mess you are.....get a life and go fuck yourself.
brianorlando 1 year ago
What a voice!! I love it :)
mozuku14 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
carly sucks
Antipolemi 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
ahahahahahaha fail, shes a ginger
maliceinwonderland6 2 years ago
Her natural hair color IS ORANGE! its not black wtf! people are so stupid!
iLOVEChihuahuas123 2 years ago
She's great. I love this song too.
happyfeetxxo 2 years ago
Wow... a bunch of ignorant haters...
shortboi13 2 years ago 7
no on else can ever supress amy's style,, haha sinply amazing, perfect by nature T_T
harryaNna92 2 years ago 6
@harryaNna92 what has that go to do with the price of fish. for fuck sakes you dip shit!
danielc2384 2 years ago
whatever you say..
amy is A LOT BETTER than carly.. and pardon me if i cant help but to compare the two. it's because carly has no originality.. you two sucks, loser!
harryaNna92 2 years ago
Agreed...
chieyX13 1 year ago
@harryaNna92 Amy doesnt have a fraction of the voice carly has....and Amy sucks without Ben Moody. The Open Door was such a shitty record....."call me when you're sober..." ....LMAO......lame
brianorlando 1 year ago
You guy's are retarded. Carly Smithson can sing, Amy Lee isn't payin your bills, stop hatin. Carly clearly has a more powerful voice and she trained very very well.
If you say she can't sing than your just stupid or jealous.
happyfeetxxo 2 years ago 5
You cant blame people for having their own opinions, the only reason people r comparing Amy with Carly is because it seems Carly is trying to be just like her,
Oh and btw, you say Amy isnt paying our bills... well Carly Smithson isnt paying anyones bills either
2813Jasper 2 years ago 3
i wonder if this song is ever gonna be released
and stop comparing Amy to Carly their voices are completely different now SHUT UP about it
esnobol 2 years ago 6
@esnobol thankyou!
danielc2384 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
She is an amy lee wanna be i see why she didnt win she sucks
lovelyflowerful 2 years ago
hahaha i agree!!!
harryaNna92 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
lol imannanimegod! lol, ok... but in all honesty, carly sux at singing evanescence's' older songs! yknow what?... if ben wants to be a jerk off , n be like well they were my songs too... then let him! he probably would go back next for all i know, and be like ok kelly clarkson, i want my song b/c of u back, and avril i want to have my song i wrote nobodys home, b/c i wrote it... lol whatta laugh too! just thinking about it. whatta loser! ben gay and johnny no seeds and rocky bob the builder!
hallowgurl55 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
*throws brick*
GET YOUR OWN IMAGE!
Imananimegod 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
UGLY
LoverxHater01 2 years ago
I love WE ARE THE FALLEN!!!
and i love Carly!!! She's so rad!
shaka055 2 years ago
Carly is a copy of Amy Lee..NEWS FLASH!!AMY LEE IS WAAAAAY BETTER THAN HER!!Screw Carly!!
aryamo1974 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
you suck carly
tarjaturunen10 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
carly is very un-talented nd she needs to get a life instead of stealing from amy lee she is just a gay fag
alexaltman11 2 years ago
you can really listen to her voice and say she's untalented? really? take off your blinders darlin
zebby511 2 years ago 6
yea cuz she is coping evanescence
alexaltman11 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Evanescence is better so you people are just wasting your time. The only reason why I'm watching this is to see if anyone said anything bad. I THINK I'M THE FIRST ONE
Samiisayshi01 2 years ago
We are the fallen ROCKS!!!! She is awesome ....Go listen to " Bury me alive "
nonameninja 2 years ago
Wow Carly!!!! Awesome!! My wife and I simply love ya! Keep pouring it out. We'll be listening!!
Jangoslave605 2 years ago
I am sooo freakin excited about this. I loved carly from day one. She is so talented. You go girl.
makiasky 2 years ago 5
Carly your the BEST!!
triamera28 2 years ago 4
AMAZING!!!! she rocks and THE FALLEN is going to ROCK!!!!!!!!!
hashim90 2 years ago 2
I FREAKING LOVE CARLYYY(:
Jesssicaalynn 2 years ago 4
go carly i love you so much you need to do a tour of like every state i love you go carly
meganjoyfan23 2 years ago
If I'm not mistaken, this is the audio from the US Magazine website exclusive from recorded live Idol Extra performance that never was broadcast, so it's not really "a demo".
The only thing I'd change is the male backups are too loud in the mix here.
cbotten106 2 years ago
I completely agree!
Priel27 2 years ago
Lve her her voice is so uniqe in a good way
0weddy0 2 years ago 5
i really like her voice!
csanne08 2 years ago 7
carly rocks!!!!!!!!! im gonna buy her album!
enquitopatrishia 2 years ago 12
wow!!! she is so amazing!!!
alvarezjezreel 2 years ago 10