Added: 4 years ago
From: hylianzeldamaster
Views: 173,372
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (864)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • this is perfect! spot on! the only better version is the origional

  • Tempo kept changing in spots and it's not the best that I've heard, but heck, it's better than I can do right now! Keep up the good work!

  • People who think the song is too slow: I prefer it slower at the beginning, so that I can also see if I can learn the song. I play piano as well. That may not have been the original intention of the poster, but it helps us who often request tutorials. As for being faster at around 2:14 - THAT part is showing what it SHOULD be played like.

    HylianZeldaMaster, I applaud you. You, either intentionally or not, created an epic tutorial. Thank you.

  • 2:14 skip to the awesome!

  • This song is amazing and Nintendo should put him on their website :D

  • Wow... really shitty... I hope he doesnt do any more -.- what an insult to Zelda

  • amazing! you just need a chick with big tits shaking a tambourine!

  • I like this and I like the original. Who's says you can't like both? Great job on your video! I enjoyed listening to you play 'Gerudo Valley'. :)

  • he play bad

  • @gaspard75015 Do you want to try it?

  • 324 cant even play the goddamn piano -__- screw what they say u did good man.

  • Romantique ok mais décevant aussi désolé (trop lent) -1

  • 321 people were arrested without having the hookshot!

  • <3

  • crappy

  • alguien se estaba cagando mientras tocaba el piano

  • LAME

  • 317 Zoras disliked this because their theme wasnt as cool

  • @iamerrorproductions make that 318.

  • @randomguy451 Make that 321

  • It's very good and I love the interpretation. But, why are you so deliberate with the notes and timing on the treble? Is there a specific intention? It's not a bad, just peculiar.

  • muy lento

  • those are some of the smoothest eighth and sixteenth notes ive ever heard

  • I cried its so beautiful D:

  • This is the romantic version, bitches! stop the whining xD

  • Freaking...beautiful...

  • You should play that on a piano at a Wild West-themed saloon....How atmospheric would that be? ;)

  • My favourite part was when he played the Gerudo Valley theme.

  • @Viddharto why do you people just care about the thumbs up? thumbs up if you agree!

  • @hatakekakashi121996 Actually, I didn't ask for any thumbs up...

  • @Viddharto Why would you upload this? It's no where as good as the others Ive seen. -_-

  • @UchihaSurvivor360 It was just for fun. It's not about being funnier than other comments, it's simply about being funny.

    Btw, why does everyone quoting me have a naruto-themed username?

  • @Viddharto Because I'm Sasuke Uchiha, the sole survivor of the elite Uchiha clan!!!

  • the very begining is ok

  • hm... 4/5

  • To those of you who can't stand anything different than the original piece, don't come to YouTube, just play the game! If you're looking for the original, just play the original. Don't go on the internet and expect to find what you want. If you want it a certain way, then you have to make it yourself you lazy complainers. Get some musical talent and do it yourself.

  • It's nice, but WAY too over-exaggerated. Took you 2:30 to reach normal speed. If you had some body movement, it would make sense why it was so slow, but it seemed too over exaggerated.

  • This is awesome. Presonally I dont' like slow music (I had to skip a bit), but it was wonderful. I really wish I had musical talent like that, or any at all really, I'm terrible with music.

  • I think he purposely made it sound really akward so lol I likey!! =P

  • That had to be a diffucult piece.. nice work!

  • me and my friend can play this perfectly now on the trombone

  • Fucking stupid.

  • @damandatwin if you dont like it then just, get out, sereously, learn good music. WAYYYYY better then the crap thies days.

    

  • @HowToMike I like the song, I don't like whatever this is supposed to be, though.

  • 0:00 0:07 was my fav part lol

  • Yyyyyaaaaa that was soo bad(that means it sucks)

  • yeah didnt like it

  • A few finger slips but otherwise a wonderful twist on the start and very good playing.

  • Dude this is amazing. i want to do this for my school talent show- can you post a tutorial?

  • I heard some mistakes, but the way you twisted the composition was beatiful, CONGRATS :D

  • /watch?v=Y1Dik3_E7xc

  • Personally as a musician I couldn't commend what you've done with this tune enough. I can see how much effort you put into this playing and I simply love how you took an already great piece and tried to put your own twist into it. Starting slow and progressively getting faster just gives off the feeling of the struggle that is being dealt with and I can feel the emotion pouring out of every key hit. I do think that some notes were off key in the slow section but I can look past that. Great job

  • you should play it as fast as you can now

  • Dear God, lots of people do stuff. I personally love to write long comments hoping that one day somebody will see my genius. Maybe if I talk about what I think and tell you not insult how i feel you will believe me. Yes, we all have opinions, and those usually are taken wrongly, but I still am happy you guys comment. And although youtube is allowing us to judge comments, we still have to feel like we are the best. And isn't the whole point of youtube to enjoy videos to start with?

  • @TheAngrySchool is it me, or are you trying to sound like stefansama45177? cause your comment looks almost identical to his xD

  • I prefer it when someone does their own interpretation of a piece rather than simply copying it. Afterall, why would you listen to a copied version when you can listen to the original instead?

    Nicely done. Some parts didn't flow as nicely as they could have and seemed almost hesitant as you played through it.

  • lol sounds like ur somg is stutering

  • WELL I LIKE IT!

  • That piano and wall look oddly familiar...were you at Magnet when you played this? Cause I could swear that that's a piano from one of the practice rooms...

  • hmm it should be played a lot faster then that but i dont care about that WELL DONE 5 stars

  • O_O i think this guy fell when he tried to jump the bridge with epona.. and link... well.... link died.. then at 2:30 HE IS BACK!!!! :) ) :)

    GO EPONA... JUMP!!!!!!!!!!!! SHIT GO FASTER AAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHH then at 3:33 he die again

  • I think this guy in a sense ruined it i dont even mind the slow part i think it "would" sound nice if and only if the whole thing were in timing which none of it is even though its a different tempo dosent mean the timing should be off

  • it would sound better if you didn't suck

  • hey guys, try this version: /watch?v=AwHoIT5Xqwc

  • so slow -.-

  • i can listen to this for hours

  • I understand slowing it down a bit, but I think you overdid that just a tiiiny bit. Its played very well though ^_^

  • For Pete's sake, people, it's art. Don't get me wrong, you just can't top the original Gerudo Valley, but people do slower interpretations of songs all the time. Just because you prefer it faster (which it does get, around 2:30 or so) doesn't mean you have to insult it. Yes, it's a cherished childhood memory, and those usually shouldn't be screwed with, but I think it's great that he's done this, it shows how deeply he appreciates the music. And isn't that the whole point of these to start with?

  • @StefanSama45177 Who's this... "Pete" Character...?

  • Uhh... Yeah. i'll have you know i do play piano. I didn't get all thse thumbs up from bullshitting.

  • It's never slow in the game, so why would you play it that way?

  • I think this is a gorgeous piece. Everyone who said "wtf wuz dat affer 0:10????//" obviously didn't listen to the entire thing.

  • you know,..id like to hear you guys play gerudo valley on anything! all of you low lifes that insult people over the internet saying that they suck or they need to die or anything like that need to shut up! i bet most of you dont even play piano and stumbled upon this video on accident. So watch what you say to people. its gonna come back to you! Good Job hylianzeldamaster! you rock! this piece is beautiful and i hope u keep making videos. ur amazing and ignore the stupid hate comments. :)

  • @Artsie1 FUCK YEAH BURN HEATHEN!!!! ITS ZELDA!!!! YOU CANT CHANGE ZELDA!!!! BURNNNNNNN!!!!!!

  • @Greymurphy01 twat

  • i dont usually comment on youtube but all these stupid comments forced me to log back in. you may make some errors every now and then but you have a wonderful sense of rubato and dynamics in general. you did something original with this wonderful piece and thats what matters. most people have obviously never thought outside of the small musical box they live in to call this shit.

  • obviously people don;t understand music.... good job dude :] I love it.

  • what the fuck... yeah i'd say about from 0:00 and to 0:10 is Gerudo valley.. the rest...

    do it again, do it right.

    training does the trick.

  • aunque los errores no son mui fuertes se notan , aun asi me encanto como tocastes y me encanta esa sinfonia es mui linda

  • fucking sucks y havent u killed yourself yet

  • first 7 seconds sounded like the game. :D u sure u ddnt play this.?

  • Sorry dude, your video sucked! That doesn't remind Gerudo Valley Theme Song AT ALL!

  • too easy to sleep this way =P

  • ur hurting my ears

  • u are playin it wrong

  • do you hace sheets for this? i love that music

  • ppl what are you talking about? this is fantastic! . . .

  • @BADAMSBABE It's too slow. It shouldn't be some sad song, it's a fast paced song that gets you pumped while fighting.

    Though this is nice itself, it isn't Gerudo Valley.

  • @BADAMSBABE Like how the ending is. Which is perfect.

  • Watch from 2:06 for the original song timing.

  • way to slow

  • @RalosMetsys Watch til the end >.>

  • You seem like a really talented pianist; WONDERFUL! I play an instrument myself, and playing something like this--so freaking complicated--by ear is NOT EASY. AMAZING.

  • slow compared to the original

  • eh, it's his best rhythm wise, but for feed back, Farewell Hyrule King is his best of course he had help with the direction. but the first time i completed wind waker I couldn't help but tear up.

  • good job 3 thumbs up!... what i killed my sister and stole hers.

  • not the good timing

  • @2000VinceCarter he was playing it slowly for more drama or summet

  • that was fucking terrible way out of time

  • @techcrazyguy wht the hell are you talking about????? that was great!!!!!!!!!

  • This helps me to appreciate the melody of the song far more. Though you should be at doublepace nearly throughout the video to catch up to how it is susposted to be played.

  • The chord structure and dynamics painted a masterpiece of a song :) I liked 2:10 and about fifteen seconds on just for the volume of emotion in it...wow. Just...WOW. Definitely a great take on a Zelda classic.

  • Wow!!This is absolutely beautiful!It seems like most people don't even bother to watch the entire video...It's perfect,and has a lot of emotion in it.Nicely done! :)

  • oh mein gott die bester version die ich je erlebt habe .. du bist grandios,perfect,unbeschreibli­ch .... gänsehaut pur

  • that was sooo awesome how you built it up like that, from slow to fast!!!

  • 2:28 needs some work.. so many wrong notes!!! and it doesnt sound like your on the same tempo with both hands

  • For the people complaining about the speed, did you even bother to watch past the 2 minute mark? He was treating it as an introduction.

  • Nice try.. but.. this song just isn't supposed to be in a tempo like that, it's made for speed. It just sounds wrong to me like this.

  • speed up speed up, that's too slow, that's the right tune but the tempo? snail's pace, you made the song longer than it should be, i vote down because the tempo is way off.

  • I gotta admit, I would've preferred if the piece was fast and upbeat earlier in the video but ehhhh.... >.> I'm not going to throw a fit here. It's just a personal preference. We each have our own interpretations of piece and such.

  • @misslolcats101

    are you slow or somthing linkphan is right

  • Perfect! I like how you start slow and slowly builds up the tempo in the song. Don't listen to people complaining on the slow part, they probably didn't listen to the whole song. ^^

  • I'm sorry, but it's seriously pissing me off that all these people are like "IT'S TOO SLOW". Did you dumbasses even listen to the whole song? >_> Jesus. This a perfection of tempo's and emotion setters here. The guy's building up slowly to set the mood then BAM, original fast tempo.

  • i remember it being faster then this

  • .........b.....e....s......t..­.....

  • Cool man. :) thx for doing it slow. I think a slower version of tht song sounds purdy good! :D keep posting ! :D

  • while listening to this all those memories came back and a little tear dropped down my face... epic!

  • This is absolutely wonderful. Brilliantly aranged. And for all those flaming, listen to the whole thing before commenting, the slow build up works great when you get into the faster tempo section.

  • perfect but i dont realy like how you slowed it down it kinda makes it unrecongnisable

  • its too slow. if you listen to the real version, its really fast. its not a sad slow song. its a happy fast one.

  • Starts off a bit too slow... But picks up nicely at 02:21

  • crap

  • Ha, you turned one of my favorite songs into something perfect for creating atmosphere at the restaurant where I work. Nice job. My one criticism is that between 2:27 ish and 2:35 it sounds like your chords are off.

  • first my little brother posted that comment second it's a really good version but the original version is fast since the beginning so don't get mad man xD

  • wayyyy to slow

  • Don't listen to anyone who says this is crap. I've been listening to this for months now. This a beautiful rendition. If people actually listened to the whole thing, they'd see that you played all of the original fast one, you just added a melodic twist at the beginning, making it beautiful. I loved it. I love all your videos. You're a wonderful musician. Keep it up!

  • toooo sloww

  • @gustas30 watch the whole video, dumb shits...

  • fuck. bad ass

  • Perfection? where

  • Hello!

    I love to see people playing their own version. But towards the end, you need more base, and not just one single finger.

  • mmhhhh... well its my opinion

    but I think this song can't be interpreted

    or at least not as exaggerated as you did

  • Sorry, but the remix you did I didn't really think was that good. You also skipped the first part: dadadadadadadadadada dadadadadadadadadada dadadadadadadadadadadada dadadadadadadadadadadada

  • @legomen457 He plays it when he speeds up.

  • that fucking sucked, the opening was cool but you suck.

  • can't anyone play their own interpretation of the song without being frowned upon? it's not like he's making the song canon and "ruining" it as many of you claim. I think it's a pretty nice version of the song. not my personal favorite, but props to you HZmaster.

  • borrrrrrring

  • DUDE !!!!!!! WTF everytime you seem to got it you loose it again

  • seriously. you started great but then the YOU comes in, YOU screwed things up. so go apologize to the piano, zelda, and us of what you done. what? sorry, you tried your best. just practice. what's your name. I will march to yo mama's house to tell her about the shame you brought

    to youtube. good day to you sir!

  • sorry, what was that crap from 0:10 onward?????

  • OH OH I KNOW it was crap

  • that crap is the same song u have been listening to ya idiot, he just slowed the tempo down Dramatically. If you speed this up it would sound the same.

  • @strongglory

    thanks, i know that it's the same song, i just think that he's brutally murdered it.

  • @MissLolcats101 you proly didnt watch the entire thing it eventually picks up the pace, but I agree the start is more off a miss then a hit.

  • @marty13612

    thanks marty, i did watch the whole thing.

    P.S it's spelt probably.

  • @MissLolcats101

    it's spelled "spelled"....

  • @afrohorse7

    Jeez, just shut up. the video is crap. end of.

  • @afrohorse7 spelt=short for spelled...smarts

  • @MissLolcats101 It's called perfection and build up. :) This guy really knows how to set the nerves for when the real epicness comes about half way through the song.

  • @linkphan123

    it's not called perfection and build up. it's crap that people like to call ''emotion'' when really it's just stalling. it should have been at the speed of 2:16 onward.

  • @MissLolcats101  dude thats so true

  • @MissLolcats101 Watch it completely and THEN post a comment.

  • @Aloz16

    find out if someone's actually watched it all the way through THEN post a comment.

  • @MissLolcats101 Okay sorry about that, did you watch the video all the way through?

  • @Aloz16

    yes, i have seen it all the way through. i agree it does get better towards the end though.

  • @MissLolcats101  you probably never played piano.

  • @MissLolcats101 hahahhahah so true, i was like wtf is happenin this is horrid, but your comment made the video funny haha

  • @thalanoth Haha thank you for not hating on me like the others >.>

  • best version

  • I love your take on this amazing song

  • muy bien!!! excelente

  • BRAVO BRAVISIMO perfecto amigo.

  • Awesome! Favorited. You've got skill!

  • great arrangement, only complaint is the rhythm is a little off.

  • Pretty good, only heard a couple of mistakes, but it looks like you're playing from memory so i will forgive you. :D

  • Great! Five Stars i'm agree about koji Kondo

  • nice ending!!

    the song was great, too.

  • Nice! The slowest part looks like an introduction to the faster part... Awesome.

  • I know I shouldn't complain about the slow part but that part really wasn't necessary. xD

    Was magnificent playing and I definitely agree with your comment on Koji. :3

  • Youre a very talented person. this is my favorite video of yours

  • incroyable!!!!!!

  • First 7 seconds are perfect, then it gets painfully slow until about 2:08. Good job!

  • really nice but somehow i think your left hand isn´t busy enough must be something more i´l give it a try myself =)