This is really good! But I love how Robert Meadmore is staring at Charlotte Church and she is staring at the audience....isn't "Christine" supposed to looking lovingly into "Raoul's" eyes? Just saying....lol..
Whoa, I just saw the Sarah Brightman (the original) performance with this song and holy crap! Charlotte Church has nothing on her!! I mean, I know Charlotte's got "the voice of an angel" sure, but with this song, it didn't suit her. I almost didn't think this was the same Charlotte Church even though it looked like her. Sarah Brightman was simply amazing. And this performance lacked some chemistry or something. maybe it's just me. I wasn't feeling it.
omg. she looked really gorgeous! this is the most beautiful version i've ever heard of this song.WOW.
she was initially chosen to play Christine in the Phantom of The Opera..the only reason she din't was because they said she had to lose some weight..but Charlotte didn't want to change how she is.Shame..she would've made a GREAT Christine Daae.
charlotte church's voice got lower as she grew up.when she was younger she sang more soprano which made her have the voice of an angel.now she is very pretty,though!love her hair and dress!
Singers are great and holds a good quality of vocal control...I don't care if others don't seem to appreciate it! I'm saying this again, without jealousy or whatever bad intentions: "this is a good video...their voice is just right"!
The girl is Charlotte Church.She's usually a great singer,but I didn't like her voice in this video.I don't know who the heck the guy is.He has a funky voice.I don't like his voice.
Because you have opened this... you will get kissed on the nearest possible Friday by the love of your life... if you don't break the chain. Tomorrow will be the best day of your life. However, if you don't send this to at least 10 people by the stroke of midnight tonight you will be forever cursed in love. Just copy and paste this.. Good Luck!
This was Robert Meadmoor, singing with Church on November 28, 2001 when she was 15, at the Royal Variety Performance, sung for the Queen. Other participants included Elton John.
she has a very pretty voice, its actually like singing, i like the actual opera sound like sarah but i prefer her and emmy, rachel barrel is pretty good too...
There is no WAY Charlotte Church is EVEN slightly better than Sarah Brightman. Sure, Sarah is annoying, but Charlotte-ick!!! Her voice is limited, blocked...just so...blah-not entertaining-no passion.
This is Michael Crawford and Charlotte Church. He played the Phantom in the Broadway Version. And yes, at least she's slightly better than Sarah Brightman, but I still can't stand her voice either.
omg...it souds alot like Michael, it might be MIchael's voice, but that dude is definatly not MIchael Crawford. The guy is younger, and I am 99% certain that he was lip singing, using Michaels voice.
I can assure you, it is. His voice is the same, and he looks like him, too. He's not Gerry Butler, but he has a decent voice. Better than Charlotte Church and Sarah Brightman any day! :D
Charlotte's voice is deeper than I thought, but it's amazing I think. People who are saying that Charlotte isn't the best person for Christine's role, well she ISN'T playing the ROLE, she's just singing - DUH. Idiots. :/
he doesnt sound like the movie raoul very much but a lil i guess; he sounds alot better than joj's last performance raoul lol he was like *girly voice* "Christine, Angel?" i mean in movie at least he was a lil ore energetic that joj's last performance raoul..
hey man dont dis emmy ang gerry they were awsome as was the original christine,sarah brightman,although sarah was a cruddy actress.anyways raoul is so much better in this than both of the movies even though hes older
I really think Charlotte at least would have tried. Emmy just assumed she had God given talent and only practiced for an hour....Gerard Butler at least tried to prepare by taking lessons...I hate it when people get their ego inflated and then deliver cruddy work.
Charlotte Church pushes her tongue WAY back in her throat and she ends up sounding like a frog. the Raoul is ok but WAY too old for Charlotte and my comfort! no wonder she doesn't get into character and make eye contact! but she's not an actress and stuff... i think Charlotte sucks too!
Charlotte seems like she's having diffuculty getting breath. Is it true she started smoking around this time? Too bad if that's true! She had such a good future...
I didn't like her pop-like voice in this one. She should sing operaticly, hence the name "Phantom of the OPERA". I guess further along, though, it was more operatic...hmmm...
Charlotte Church? Isn't she, like, really young? Maybe its the video, but the guy looks a *LOL* older than her. O____O *runs away from pedo-lookalike*
KIDDING! Its weird. I'm so used to the originals, and even the movie version; Charlotte could be okay, but she started off weird, and some parts are odd, but its good to hear her own voice evolving, since, she started "opera" singing as a 10 or 13 year old, so we need to see how her voice evolves into adulthood. And the guy's voice wasn't bad either, a very good Raoul-type voice.
'aren't as good'??? wtf? anyone's better than those two! Gerry stinks but at least he doesn't boast about 'studying' at the Metropolitan Opera! ugh! Emmy really gets on my nerves! SHE'S NOT AN OPERA SINGER!!!
the roul was amazing, who was it? i liked him better than the roul in the movie, patrick wilson or whatever. as for christine, charlotte church wasnt too bad, but i dont think she fit the part well enough, but it was ok, she wasnt bad, and i liked the high note at the end of the song. but roul was absolutly amazing, an i never really liked roul. lol
Robert meadmore is georgeous. i have met him several times, such a nice guy.
jane90186 1 year ago
The guys good, she ruins it silly cow.
markalexander123 2 years ago 4
This is really good! But I love how Robert Meadmore is staring at Charlotte Church and she is staring at the audience....isn't "Christine" supposed to looking lovingly into "Raoul's" eyes? Just saying....lol..
Alieya08 3 years ago 8
Comment removed
stitchwitch13 2 years ago
Can anyone tell me who's that guy
I like his voice so much ...
Thanks
wuanchiangel 3 years ago
I like him too ;) His name is Robert Meadmore.
Cheers!
stitchwitch13 3 years ago
Stitchwitch13
Thank you :)
wuanchiangel 3 years ago
Wonderful!=)
sosiboss 3 years ago
nothing compares with the original!
EDJIE121477 3 years ago
y is that classicly trained singers always annoy i tell you why tehy over act !!
hahaha sorry if any disagrees thats just my personal opinion like the man is awsome tho both vocals are amazing !!!
x
rachaeltaylor900 3 years ago
THANK YOU YOU TUBE.
artcandy2003 3 years ago
Whoa, I just saw the Sarah Brightman (the original) performance with this song and holy crap! Charlotte Church has nothing on her!! I mean, I know Charlotte's got "the voice of an angel" sure, but with this song, it didn't suit her. I almost didn't think this was the same Charlotte Church even though it looked like her. Sarah Brightman was simply amazing. And this performance lacked some chemistry or something. maybe it's just me. I wasn't feeling it.
QuoGirl 3 years ago
ilginç bir all i ask of you =)
pipijan 4 years ago
nothing like i heard but the guy was awesome the girl was just eh...creeped me out...
RyanxMIke121 4 years ago
beautiful !
Gunnykiller 4 years ago
this is one of my favorite song... and i like charlotte church.. powerful voice indeed!!
mikko765 4 years ago 2
What is ehr last name? Charlotte what? I need to know!
DinaxD 4 years ago
she's called Charlotte Church
Lishahhh 3 years ago
Amazing! :O I am a huge fan of Charlotte Church since I was 13. Now I'm 16. I just never saw her face?
DinaxD 3 years ago
the singing was good but not as strong as in the phantom of the opera but they probably did that with the computer i would not know
7monkeyman8 4 years ago
All of Charlotte's classical music is beautiful. As I said earlier, a person would have to be dumb and dumb not to realize this
Hedonist05 4 years ago
omg. she looked really gorgeous! this is the most beautiful version i've ever heard of this song.WOW.
she was initially chosen to play Christine in the Phantom of The Opera..the only reason she din't was because they said she had to lose some weight..but Charlotte didn't want to change how she is.Shame..she would've made a GREAT Christine Daae.
lilsis 4 years ago
I think that that this version of All I ask of you is the most beautiful one I have heard so far, charlotte church is amazing here.
mandytrue 4 years ago
charlotte church's voice got lower as she grew up.when she was younger she sang more soprano which made her have the voice of an angel.now she is very pretty,though!love her hair and dress!
AngelofMusic101 4 years ago
Is she a mezzo? She sounds like one, her voice sounds like its being pulled down. I do not like her voice!
FriendOrPhantom 4 years ago
What are you talking about? Her voice sounds amazing. Are you deaf or dumb?
Hedonist05 4 years ago
Charlotte has a pretty wonderful classical voice...but not in this video...
RiAngela 4 years ago
This is so beautiful. Thank you for posting it.
OMM06 5 years ago
i don't know t it is but i don't lyk charlotes voice esp. doin this song tiz 1 of my fav in phantom but she just ruins it xxx
sasseyo 5 years ago
Singers are great and holds a good quality of vocal control...I don't care if others don't seem to appreciate it! I'm saying this again, without jealousy or whatever bad intentions: "this is a good video...their voice is just right"!
1981CR 4 years ago
The girl is Charlotte Church.She's usually a great singer,but I didn't like her voice in this video.I don't know who the heck the guy is.He has a funky voice.I don't like his voice.
jmarianne 5 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Because you have opened this... you will get kissed on the nearest possible Friday by the love of your life... if you don't break the chain. Tomorrow will be the best day of your life. However, if you don't send this to at least 10 people by the stroke of midnight tonight you will be forever cursed in love. Just copy and paste this.. Good Luck!
Koga8291 5 years ago
shes very pretty:)
brainwasher9876 5 years ago
This was Robert Meadmoor, singing with Church on November 28, 2001 when she was 15, at the Royal Variety Performance, sung for the Queen. Other participants included Elton John.
anieb 5 years ago
she has a very pretty voice, its actually like singing, i like the actual opera sound like sarah but i prefer her and emmy, rachel barrel is pretty good too...
NoelleP318 5 years ago
These pplz r better than Antonio and Sarah but not as good as Emmy and Patrick!!!
SnoopyGurlX13 5 years ago
yeah!!! i totally agree!!!
cassp6 5 years ago
Eh... girl's amazing, guy sings strangely. Girl is acting too much, guy is acting fine. :)
Iiridescent 5 years ago
michael Crawford was born Jan 19. 1942.. so he will be 65 next month, that guy probably is in his late 30s that is singing with that broad
CloggieIllinois 5 years ago
I dont think that is michael crawford... He doesnt sound like him and doesnt look like him XD
xangelofmusic101 5 years ago
omg i hate her voice on this song....and that is NOT Michael Crawford (for whoever wrote that)
jlpmusic100 5 years ago
Sarah's voice isn't bad but her acting is horrible- look at her expression in the first few seconds!
dsfjhskdjh 5 years ago
There is no WAY Charlotte Church is EVEN slightly better than Sarah Brightman. Sure, Sarah is annoying, but Charlotte-ick!!! Her voice is limited, blocked...just so...blah-not entertaining-no passion.
LittleLotte7793 5 years ago
who's raoul? i like that singer. not raoul. hate raoul.
mintrose 5 years ago
omg peopel! How on eath can u think that is Micheal Crwaford? Micheal Crawfor was like 55 at thsi time, that guy is in his 40's!
Cutekitty22 5 years ago
OMG, love this clip
puyen26 5 years ago
Micheal Crawford is a good Raul but i think the charecter Raul in general sucks
bsara100 5 years ago
This is Michael Crawford and Charlotte Church. He played the Phantom in the Broadway Version. And yes, at least she's slightly better than Sarah Brightman, but I still can't stand her voice either.
BarrelsPolesandJack 5 years ago
That isn't Michael Crawford.
Ponchochickendoc 5 years ago
omg...it souds alot like Michael, it might be MIchael's voice, but that dude is definatly not MIchael Crawford. The guy is younger, and I am 99% certain that he was lip singing, using Michaels voice.
Cutekitty22 5 years ago
I can assure you, it is. His voice is the same, and he looks like him, too. He's not Gerry Butler, but he has a decent voice. Better than Charlotte Church and Sarah Brightman any day! :D
BarrelsPolesandJack 5 years ago
at least its better than sarah brightman.
AngelofMusic101 5 years ago
wow... umm chin shaking + old guy = creepy performance :/
samashchick05 5 years ago
I s'port Cardiff! Muppet! Nice singing voice but she's got the most god awful accent.
JaydeSabbath 5 years ago
they were good. Just not together.
awaitednightmare 5 years ago
x.x omg, he's so much better than her....
the movie was so good nothing else sounds anything like it! lol, that's kind of sad....
DamonnischerEngel 5 years ago
Charlotte's voice is deeper than I thought, but it's amazing I think. People who are saying that Charlotte isn't the best person for Christine's role, well she ISN'T playing the ROLE, she's just singing - DUH. Idiots. :/
pinkdiamonde 5 years ago
the girl sounds awful
needs a different thingy
kezzaroona 5 years ago
he doesnt sound like the movie raoul very much but a lil i guess; he sounds alot better than joj's last performance raoul lol he was like *girly voice* "Christine, Angel?" i mean in movie at least he was a lil ore energetic that joj's last performance raoul..
NoelleP318 5 years ago
HANG ON !!! THAT'S CHARLOTTE CHURCH
Phantomstruelove 5 years ago
Who is the guy?
frankthe2nd 5 years ago
this is wonderful! i know i couldn't sing like that even with lessons! so all you dissers need to be nice!
phantomslostlover 5 years ago
both are terrible.... emmy rossum should give the play a shot
Nerris121 5 years ago
man i got the cold chillzz when i heard this. the ending was not as good as the middle but it was good
that dude sounded just like the raoul in the movie now thats good
musicnotes1 5 years ago
Stop dissing it everyone! I'd like to see you do better, they did great and it's so cute
JohnnyDeppIsSexy333 5 years ago
i like raouls voice too
g4gamer06 5 years ago
I dont like the girl's voice, but the guy sounds good. I hate how they made cuts in the song too.
Crawford1987 5 years ago
Where is this play from? Broadway?
Nerris121 5 years ago
hey man dont dis emmy ang gerry they were awsome as was the original christine,sarah brightman,although sarah was a cruddy actress.anyways raoul is so much better in this than both of the movies even though hes older
redheadoperasinger 5 years ago
I really think Charlotte at least would have tried. Emmy just assumed she had God given talent and only practiced for an hour....Gerard Butler at least tried to prepare by taking lessons...I hate it when people get their ego inflated and then deliver cruddy work.
Duszka 5 years ago
wait was teh guy weird al..becuase it looksed alot like him
worryrock4life 5 years ago
Charlotte Church pushes her tongue WAY back in her throat and she ends up sounding like a frog. the Raoul is ok but WAY too old for Charlotte and my comfort! no wonder she doesn't get into character and make eye contact! but she's not an actress and stuff... i think Charlotte sucks too!
operaticxingenue 5 years ago
Charlotte seems like she's having diffuculty getting breath. Is it true she started smoking around this time? Too bad if that's true! She had such a good future...
I didn't like her pop-like voice in this one. She should sing operaticly, hence the name "Phantom of the OPERA". I guess further along, though, it was more operatic...hmmm...
yumichan89 5 years ago
I loved Raoul's voice. It's very pretty.
It's too bad that he isn't younger, since Raoul and Christine were only supposed to be around nineteen-twenty one.
But he sounds so good. <3 Brava
tothewesternsky 5 years ago
this is supposed to be a love song...they hardly look at each other...i'm sorry but those i've seen in the west end know how to play these roles!
phantomjo 5 years ago
Cute video
Maxkustrap 5 years ago
Woah... I loved Raoul... Who was it?
Phantess 5 years ago
Charlotte Church? Isn't she, like, really young? Maybe its the video, but the guy looks a *LOL* older than her. O____O *runs away from pedo-lookalike*
CyberAndromeda 5 years ago
KIDDING! Its weird. I'm so used to the originals, and even the movie version; Charlotte could be okay, but she started off weird, and some parts are odd, but its good to hear her own voice evolving, since, she started "opera" singing as a 10 or 13 year old, so we need to see how her voice evolves into adulthood. And the guy's voice wasn't bad either, a very good Raoul-type voice.
CyberAndromeda 5 years ago
Charlotte isn't horrible, she's not the best person for Christine's role but she's decent. I really like the Raoul though, who is he?
clarinerd85 5 years ago
The Christine is pretty, She sure are beautiful !
Geronimo84 5 years ago
those two people stank especially the ugly raoul
phantomlover17 5 years ago
Just because they aren't as..."good"...as Gerard Butler and Emmy Rossum doesn't mean they stink. Haven't you even heard of Charlotte Church? O_o
yumichan89 5 years ago
'aren't as good'??? wtf? anyone's better than those two! Gerry stinks but at least he doesn't boast about 'studying' at the Metropolitan Opera! ugh! Emmy really gets on my nerves! SHE'S NOT AN OPERA SINGER!!!
operaticxingenue 5 years ago
Eh, you obviously didn't get the joke. I put good in quotes, meaning I'm being sarcastic. Of course they're not good. I agree with you 100%.
yumichan89 5 years ago
the roul was amazing, who was it? i liked him better than the roul in the movie, patrick wilson or whatever. as for christine, charlotte church wasnt too bad, but i dont think she fit the part well enough, but it was ok, she wasnt bad, and i liked the high note at the end of the song. but roul was absolutly amazing, an i never really liked roul. lol
angelofmuzik 5 years ago
I KNOW! altho the Raoul is werid.
MaskedAngelKiss 6 years ago
i think its just pure! love it!
beybey 6 years ago
She's shaking her jaw to create vibrato! Yarghh!
lakme 6 years ago
Charlotte Church actually NOT singing a cheap pop song! Something I havn't seen in years, but nice to see :)
Drewbie 6 years ago
Never heard Raoul with an accent...oh well, I don't like him anywayz...lol...her dress is pretty
irishreb 6 years ago