I love this beautiful song, delivered with so much love and emotion by Phil. He seems to have allowed criticism to get the better of him, but he's one of the greatest ever. Maybe not the hippest or most avant-garde, just one of the best ever.
I haven't read all the posts here, but I'm sure I'm not the first one to say that I think this recording is even better than the original....some things do get better with age!
Genesis Six Hours Live 1972-1980 2DVD set, Genesis The Lamb Live at the Shrine 1975 3-disc 2CD/DVD set, Genesis Live in Montreal 2CD set, Genesis Live in Zurich 1977 2CD set available at Tommygun Video - please visit our youtube channel ClassicrockDVD for link, video/audio clips, more details
Phil used to follow Yes around in concert and was a good friend of legendary drummer Bill Bruford. That must have solidified the interest he had in progressive rock which led him to Genesis. Though it is interesting that Phil also had a hand in changing the band toward pop.
I dislike how people tend to compare phil and chester where drumming skills are concerned. I think they are both incredible drummers and have their own styles of playing and technique etc and when they come together like on many songs from the Genesis live concerts they just work so well. btw great performence, When In Rome is probably my favourite live dvd of them all. :)
My parting shot. Should have been in bed a good hour ago! Early Genesis, but still one of my favorites. Have a good week, y'all. I'll catch you when I get back from the Cape. :-)
My parting shot. I should have been in bed an hour ago, but I got sidetracked tripping down musical memory lane. Early Genesis that just keeps getting better with time.
Someone that writes insulting comments (due to not having a life), about superior, successful, accomplished artists that will most likely never see them, is the epitome of both hypocrisy & cowardly. If you're replying to me, you also must "not have a life" either, 'loveupskirts'. And, why are you making a point to write how long ago you posted the comment? What's the difference? Unless, in that months time, you changed your opinion. I didn't see it last month. I was busy w/ my life..
What the heck? Do you want a hunk or a true musician? Do you want the great label or the fine wine? Bah! The media did a good job manipulating you being stuck at the surface of wonderful and deep things that make life so much more bearable.
Forgot to add that also, Phil Collins could sell records with just his voice. Didn't need to dress in certain outifts or present a great video in order to get people to like his music. Something we have lost nowadays.
@pabsk67 I couldn't agree w/ you more man. my dad made me listen to Genesis as a kid and i hated it most of teenage yrs. now it's my favortie band ever.Music isn't what it was then and that's a sad thing.Phil has TRUE talent!! No auto-tune needed here.
Perfect example of someone who can sing. What you see is what you get. He sounds just as awesome live as he does on the record. Try doing that Britney, etc.
Funny how he had a great solo career when he was still apart of Genesis and it bombed when he left.
john5000ize 1 month ago
@john5000ize
Yea....other peoples failures are hilarious! Whats wrong with you? jealous of others success???
jooby24 11 hours ago
awesome
intraining01 2 months ago
irreplaceable
revsbr1 2 months ago
Check out Cunter Rutherford. He looks the same as he did 30 years ago..........
Poltergeist40 3 months ago
I knew the figure turned on a light, but I just now got that it was a spot on Phil. Wooooow.....LOL!!
kamwrites 4 months ago
brazil!!!!!!! love it!!!!!
pitel1970 5 months ago
Adriana... pasaron 33 años y este tema sigue haciendo que te recuerde con el mismo AMOR...
jguilmann 5 months ago
I love Phil Collins!!!!!!!
Lucymae77 5 months ago
i want to go to his concert to bad he announced he won't be singing anymore
eruru08 5 months ago
I love this beautiful song, delivered with so much love and emotion by Phil. He seems to have allowed criticism to get the better of him, but he's one of the greatest ever. Maybe not the hippest or most avant-garde, just one of the best ever.
dawndrk123 5 months ago
@dawndrk123 I think his talent is largely underrated. More talent than most.
ladyfuschia 5 months ago
LOVE IT!
gocathy 6 months ago
Ah, this was the song my first love and I said was our song. I was 17 then, 50 now!!
al987 6 months ago
Phil Collins is the definition of coordination
drmmr456 6 months ago
I'm so glad that music is a gift to all of us, and I can still shed a tear to a song written decades ago!
Tacomadome24 6 months ago
i love this song w phil collins <3
nino57rott 8 months ago
One of my favorite songs of all time! I actually saw Genesis live in L.A. in '83, it was so great! Thank you, jeff for taking me!
Gingersmom97401 8 months ago
Comment removed
BukeLaker 8 months ago
This is Genesis.....not Phil Collins. Its not hard
adelamere1 10 months ago
I LOVE THIS SONG .
alanbkent 10 months ago
If you haven`t partner to enjoy this wonderfull world...let`s to do it together... follow you follow me .....
jhonnyo100 10 months ago
Love this shit
RBDrummer5 10 months ago
@RBDrummer5 Hehe...love this shit too :)
Ferguccio 10 months ago
Absolutely, that is the TWITTER hymn!!!!!!!!!!!
Guljacka 10 months ago
phils best song
MrMANUNITEDTILLIDIE 10 months ago
Awesome song......along with you i will follow you follow me all the days and nights...........la la la la la la
SkinnyBabe38 11 months ago
Good Luck, Phill!!
sobrinatiti 11 months ago
Comment removed
stlladyt 11 months ago
I haven't read all the posts here, but I'm sure I'm not the first one to say that I think this recording is even better than the original....some things do get better with age!
stlladyt 11 months ago
awesome!!!!
soleconection 11 months ago
Genesis Six Hours Live 1972-1980 2DVD set, Genesis The Lamb Live at the Shrine 1975 3-disc 2CD/DVD set, Genesis Live in Montreal 2CD set, Genesis Live in Zurich 1977 2CD set available at Tommygun Video - please visit our youtube channel ClassicrockDVD for link, video/audio clips, more details
ClassicRockDVD 1 year ago
Geilomatic..!
Pitfeder 1 year ago
a true spiritual music legend!! we salute you phil stu essex
TheHammers1973 1 year ago
Nice touch having the artwork from "Duke" on the big screen.
bigworld3001 1 year ago
phil te amo sos el musico de mi vida!! cuando volves a argentina?
tanturulis 1 year ago
phill te amo sos el musico de mi vida!!!!!!! cuando volves a argentina?
tanturulis 1 year ago
Phil used to follow Yes around in concert and was a good friend of legendary drummer Bill Bruford. That must have solidified the interest he had in progressive rock which led him to Genesis. Though it is interesting that Phil also had a hand in changing the band toward pop.
saarnoldbhm 1 year ago
He's singing about Twitter.
GunpowderJones 1 year ago 27
@GunpowderJones lol
schase10353 1 year ago
lindo !!!!!!! bela música!!!!
pitel1970 1 year ago
awesome love this :)
TheTwinerd1 1 year ago
Simply beautiful....
whenairhitsyourbrain 1 year ago 2
Excelentismo!.. Massimo!!! Gratie!!!
VivaLaFrance2009 1 year ago
I dislike how people tend to compare phil and chester where drumming skills are concerned. I think they are both incredible drummers and have their own styles of playing and technique etc and when they come together like on many songs from the Genesis live concerts they just work so well. btw great performence, When In Rome is probably my favourite live dvd of them all. :)
kingofkeyboards 1 year ago
Lo baile mil veces en la secundaria. Me trae hermosos recuerdos. Gracias por subirlo.
Condesa1964 1 year ago
10/10 Still makes the hair on my arms stand up!
Tacomadome24 1 year ago
One more time! please! So love this band!
Sunnyrae4 1 year ago
Wow, this was done nearly 30 years after the song was released. Still sounds good.
sirtinycreep 1 year ago
DEVINNE!!!
49rita 1 year ago
My parting shot. Should have been in bed a good hour ago! Early Genesis, but still one of my favorites. Have a good week, y'all. I'll catch you when I get back from the Cape. :-)
trioak 1 year ago
My parting shot. I should have been in bed an hour ago, but I got sidetracked tripping down musical memory lane. Early Genesis that just keeps getting better with time.
trioak 1 year ago
very nice production design
score1x 1 year ago
Thank you for the pleasure of listening to you all.
justphil101 1 year ago
I will love this Song forever,thanx Phil,alexandra
AlSexis6 1 year ago
the mans a ledgg playing drums and singing live how many other ppl can do this the way that mr collins has done here.......
karlymarly 1 year ago
qualidade! Poucas bandas ao vivo conseguem essa perfeição!!!
Congratulacions Phil! You as the mam!
jorgebonato28 1 year ago
this was my parents wedding song now they are not together :(
TheFlower24ism 1 year ago
This is real music. Great vid - thanks for the upload.
vishy 1 year ago
lovely:)
musicalkaratekid 1 year ago
all my love largo and winston
stuckinafishbowl 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i physically hate phil collins, but i love this song.
canadianchewie1 1 year ago
Go Phil! :-D:-D
Christina879 1 year ago
Linda demais!!
pretofn 2 years ago
genesis con phil collins es lo maximo TE AMO PHIL
carlosmagambini 2 years ago
splendide.... que de souvenirs!
62mumu 2 years ago
soppy song but simply the BEST live band ever
tommytink04 2 years ago
i physically hate phil collins, but i love this song.
loveupskirts 2 years ago
I seriously doubt that Phil Collins would care that some "genius" that names himself "loveupskirts" on YouTube hates him.
klwewf 2 years ago 2
do you think phil collins reads youtube comments from 1 month ago?
no, he has a life.
unlike you.
loveupskirts 2 years ago
Someone that writes insulting comments (due to not having a life), about superior, successful, accomplished artists that will most likely never see them, is the epitome of both hypocrisy & cowardly. If you're replying to me, you also must "not have a life" either, 'loveupskirts'. And, why are you making a point to write how long ago you posted the comment? What's the difference? Unless, in that months time, you changed your opinion. I didn't see it last month. I was busy w/ my life..
klwewf 2 years ago
@klwewf you shut up!
TheFlower24ism 1 year ago
@TheFlower24ism What did I say?
klwewf 1 year ago
What the heck? Do you want a hunk or a true musician? Do you want the great label or the fine wine? Bah! The media did a good job manipulating you being stuck at the surface of wonderful and deep things that make life so much more bearable.
aihoschema 2 years ago 3
Close at hand I´m better for the smile you give ... i will follow you ;-)
poehacker 2 years ago
Phil is an incredible drummer!!!! Very underrated!!!!!
redhead5150 2 years ago
@redhead5150 Quote... "Philis an incredible drummer!!!! Very uderrated!!!!!".....
Underrated by who???
ask ANY musician, or even non-musician who knows anything about music,
and you will find unanimous recognition for Phil Collins' drumming ability ;-) !!!
jpscoey 1 year ago 4
@jpscoey
Just listen to a Brand X cd -- especially Unorthodox Behaviour...
Bio4ce1 1 year ago
Simultaneous drumming and singing is automatic WIN.
Germany1111 2 years ago
NiCe SounD!!! Voice like butta.
margaretkraus 2 years ago
Phil's voice is silky smooth in this version. Excellent..my only wish would be that Tony use a real analog oscillator on the solo!
jonathan401 2 years ago
Forgot to add that also, Phil Collins could sell records with just his voice. Didn't need to dress in certain outifts or present a great video in order to get people to like his music. Something we have lost nowadays.
pabsk67 2 years ago 44
@pabsk67 I couldn't agree w/ you more man. my dad made me listen to Genesis as a kid and i hated it most of teenage yrs. now it's my favortie band ever.Music isn't what it was then and that's a sad thing.Phil has TRUE talent!! No auto-tune needed here.
sickestwitch 1 year ago
Perfect example of someone who can sing. What you see is what you get. He sounds just as awesome live as he does on the record. Try doing that Britney, etc.
pabsk67 2 years ago
NOONE ELSE CAN LOVE LOVE MORE ,XXxxxx DelphineCV
yodasparadox 2 years ago
DELPHINE YOU ARE MY LOVE
yodasparadox 2 years ago
Phil, Mike and Tony....perfection!
Avlisodnanref 2 years ago 2
Hell yeah''' I love Phill Collins'' Genesis''
kingsandqweens 2 years ago
i love this live version
sadmanbadmanGLADMAN 2 years ago
No, esto no es del 78. Creo que es del ultimo concierto
MICHITO62 2 years ago
I always did like this xxx
mariloveswill 2 years ago
i love this song!!!!! Genesis rock´s!!! Phil is the best!!!!
rOuXVipr 2 years ago 2
tune
e4eug 2 years ago
One of my favorites! Such a beautiful song.....
star3777 2 years ago 2
What year is this?
analyzingfunny 2 years ago
1978''it was
kingsandqweens 2 years ago
Hooray! The original key!
PeterMayer 2 years ago