Jesus in Christianity & Islam - Debate

[999Paiva]

God said to Moses I am WHO I am, this is what you are to sayto say to the Israelites, I am has sent me to you- Exodus 3:14

Jesus answered before Abraham was born , I am

John 8: 54:58

[mrlogicalman1]

xtians say babies go to hell forever cos theyre not xtian.

[ushigirl]

sorry mustafa lost get over it

[maggietem878]

Legend1One; I completely Disagree with you, stop trying to make this a win for muslim over Christians, because you're wrong. SAM STATED FACTS, gave EVIDENCE, mentioned several REFERENCES, incl. Testimonies from the "The GreaT Prophets", "Psalms" and the "The Gospels" yes, actual witnesses. "The Holy Trinity" that's all you got, Please, the very nature or objective of any debate is stating FACTS etc, Mustafa, seemed unprepared, unorganised and well I've been more confused about Muslims until now.

[hanerp1]

@maggietem878 Lets have a respectful conversation:) so im guessing you believe that jesus is God's son im i right?

[maggietem878]

@hanerp1 There is no doubt in my mind that Jesus Christ is the Son of God, also, where exactly in the Bible (verse, chapter or reference) is Muhammed's name in the bible? You mentioned it, quote the Scripture, then get back to me ok. Furthermore, in what part of my conversation was I disrespectful..I state Facts only..If you want Historical references or any other factual information You provide me with dates, times and references from any of the Great Prophets then get back to me.

[hanerp1]

@maggietem878 Ok so? all the prophets were called sons of god your not making a valid point lol but anyway just go to youtube and put in "muhammed in the bible" then click on the virst video where it briefly describes how is name is mentioned in the bible..more accuratley it was in the jewish scriptures but wasnt mentioned in the bible for some reason. If you dont want to watch the full video just start from 3:20 and i hope you reflect on this in a positive way

[hanerp1]

@maggietem878 oh and it tells you the verse and where to look it up :)

[mrlogicalman1]

@maggietem878 prophet muhammeds name is in song of solomon 5;16 in the original language. but xtians translated his name a NOUN

[hanerp1]

@maggietem878 and also i wana ask do u believe muhammed's name is n the bible?

[julio14335]

The concept of the trinity is the most nonsensical idea i have ever heard in my life, for Gods sake if you cannot defend it pls dont link it to the koran...

[MrTonyshit80]

Dear watcher...Really, i,m very worried each time the christian scholar debating with moslem...they have not enough proper knowledge ( always have not rigid point )

and become as loser to moslem....

[EasternRomanEmpire]

Unfortunately, this was not a fair debate. Samuel Green is an accomplished Apologist whereas Mustafa Shakarji is a student. Professionalism & Experience always wins irregardless of point of view.

[Legend1One]

Christianity vs Islam

And as predicted, the Muslim guy wins again.

Samuel Green is a sharp guy, and by no means did he lose due to lack of skill in debating; but, he lost because the concept of the Trinity, when examined truthfully and logiclly, failed. I mean, the Muslim guys is no scholar, in-fact, he's a student there at the University, and he beat a guy (Sam) who makes his living, traveling the World, as a Christian apologist. Think about it!!!

[maggietem878]

Just to elaborate Hebrew text (Tanakh), the Torah refers to ("The Teachings" or Laws") from the first five books of the Bible. Modern Historians and Biblical Scholars alike has found NO evidence to support the resurrection of "Judas", nor is it written in the Bible or teachings from the Prophets, Psalms and Gospels. Read and Study the Bible before preaching blasphemy. The "Virgin Mary" is NOT "Miriam" as stated by Samuel (1,500 years apart) another False Message. I totally agree with Sam. Amen.

[maggietem878]

Thankyou, Samuel Green, terrific debate, stating Historical facts, supported by evidence in the form of testimonies from the earlier Prophets of the Old Testiment or Torah (Hebrew text) incl. "Psalms" and New Testiment (Greek text) incl" The Gospels". Thankyou, Mustafa al Shakarji, for your view, very interesting perspective, however, I needed to hear FACTS through many testimonies, not just the testimony of one (Mohammad). There is no evidence to support Judas being crucified on the cross, NONE

[BigBookHarry]

The trinity doctrine created by Constantine in 325 A.D. continues to undermine Jesus position in relationship with the Father. Through Jesus all things were made, He is a creator son. In Hebrews the Father call Jesus "A" God and He is the exact representation of the Father, never greater than the Father and is the mediator for mankind.

Muhammed learned from the Catholics about the trinity and placing excessive importance upon Mary.

[julio14335]

@BigBookHarry If Jesus is "God" let us dont ignore the fact that Mary is the Mother of "God" Catholics is a sect of Christainity for me they are quite right, and is a problem you need to settle among yourself. in the other hand all sect in Islam believe in Allah as the one true God and Muhammad (saw) as his last and final prophet,no dispute no argument about it.

[BigBookHarry]

@julio14335 Jesus is "A" God Hebrews 1:8-9, also read chapters 7-10 He is unified with the Father as one while retaining His own personality. If you choose survial you will have this same opportunity.

Mary was blessed to be used such as you are given opportunities, period.

[BigBookHarry]

"no dispute no argument about it."

The root of Islam started in the cave of Hira (Bukhari V9 B87 N111) where Mohammed was met with physical violence and terror that ultimately led to suicide attempts. There is a very comprehensive history report that reveals what happened after the cave and the legacy that was left after he died.

islam-watch. org/MA_Khan/IncessantTerrorism­. htm (remove space after dots)

[BigBookHarry]

Satan has been at work creating division. It started with Constantine in 325 A.D. with the creation of the Roman Catholic Church into Europe. (Paul warned many times in his letters about this) Then in 610 A.D satan took Mohammed using him and his knowledge that he learned from the Catholics to spread deceit and division into the Middle East, Asia, and Africa. Then in 1525 A.D. satan used Martin Luther to spread His work into the protestant denominations into North America.

[BigBookHarry]

The Jews don't seem to have ever lost their mentality of rejecting Jesus since their ancestors had Him Crucified by the Romans. Now there is the matter of the scribes known today as the bankers operating under satan's influence to gain power. (which they already have) satan is the king of liars and has been doing it for a long time and he will deceive you.

[BigBookHarry]

My only concern of this world is the spiritual welfare of my Brothers and Sisters and their development of a personal relationship with the Father. There is only one true religion and that is you and your personal relationship with the Him.

I don't trust the government or any religion period.

I trust only in Jesus and the fact that He is our ambassador to the Father for us. His instructions are in the first four books of the Bible.

[julio14335]

@BigBookHarry Who blessed Mary, why cant you worship the one who bless mary...

[BigBookHarry]

@julio14335 The Father blessed Mary, You worship Him throuth Jesus our mediator.

[Florin123k]

amazing debate. Samuel did a nice work, though I have to point out that he failed to point that his opponent's sources were from a showman who didn't even know the basis of Greek articles.

[chikoo20005]

Ahmed Deedat was a legend whose words and memories should be kept alive just like in this debate...

[Florin123k]

@chikoo20005

Please sir, just listen to the speakers yourself. If the muslim has to copy word for word a showman who didn't even have the most basic knowledge of Greek and have the nerve to re-translate John 1:1, doesn't that tell you something?! It tells me something: it tells me his daawa is weak, and ineffective.

[shamounian]

I am very disappointed in this Muslim who uncritically parrots Ahmad Deedat's lies and mistakes. At the 1:49 minute mark he parrots Deedat's gross perversion of what the creed says, and even uses the same exact analogy that Deedat used! I challenge Mustafa to quote any creed which says that the Father is a Person, the Son is a Person, and the Holy Spirit is a Person, yet not 3 Persons but 1 Person. That is a lie since no creed says that.

[Florin123k]

@shamounian

sharp mind as always Sam. But then again, that's the mohamedan mindset. Though I have to say, at least he lacks the annoying accent. Otherwise, a perfect Deedat clone, just like Inamullah Mumtaz, Yusuf Ismail or brother Imran. I'd hate to have to bear Deedat's burden.

[AllAmericanMuslim]

It should be a pleasure debating someone that can't defend his faith and does not understand yours, it makes for an easy victory.

When the muslim was asked about salvation in Islam he showed his dancing skills and how quick he can change the subject by criticizing the Christian position (or his understanding of it). It would have been helpful if he had answered the question honestly.

[oceanistoosmall]

awesome! 

[EngagingWithIslam]

It was a pleasure to debate with Mustafa again.