It's ok but saint etienne were always a band where some songs were like 70% of good, but never great. I love this song, but it wasn;t meant to be a hit, they made so many bad shit songs as well they really didn't have a chance to be successful
I love Good Humor and got the double CD (in America) with Farifax High. It's great and plenty of us on the west side of the Atlantic love them too! Can't we all just get along.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I cannot believe you defend this garbage...are you all retarded? this is horrid music...i am done you. oh and who ever said karma eats your soul, honesty saves it.
@paganklh1 Jeez, dude... quit being so damned narcissistic! There's a little somethin' for everyone out there. You have your taste, and I have mine... she has her's, he/his. Get over yourself!!!
@paganklh1 Oh well, something for everyone. Honestly, I don't get why people even bother commenting on something they don't like. If ya don't like a thing... then just go "whatever", and walk away from it, right? Complaining is annoying. Criticism is good, but only when it's constructive. Otherwise, put a sock in it. No offense. Just a little constructive criticism. :)
@paganklh1 Sorry, but your critical leaves YOU wide open to be criticismed.
..and by the way, thank you for exemplifying my point. I'm also flattered that you seem to think that this is my band. ...and Garbage was a good band, too. Wonder whatever happened to them.
Great song, weak negative video. Visuals should be more positive for this group. They have been underrated because they are about the music and not sellout models who are musically untalented like most pop artists who succeed in the mainstream.
Yes and the whole album is ("Good Humor") - should be listed to from start to end in one piece....and then again...and again... ;-) My favourite St. Etienne record, recommend it.
this was the first song i bought when i started working when i was 17 and it blew me away and ended up buying the album (good humour) and been a fan since like a couple of people have said a very underrated band
If you mean frequent light tone mismatches and an impression that the woman is emotionally excited, then it was always this way. But sure I would not say it makes the singing "bad" - with her beautiful voice and articulation it just makes it sound natural and urge.
had the chance to see them live around '''93 .. one of the 2 background, glitter mini-skirted backup go-go dancers fell on her ass while dancing, sarah turned around briefly, laughed & shrugged, & continued singing w/out missing a beat . . .
I got this song from an English penpal back in 1998 or something, I always liked the song, but never saw the video, until just now.
But I don't really get it - the black haired girl does not look like a sister, she looks Thai or something and much older than 17.
While Sarah is blonde and looks nothing like "her little sister" ...
Sarah's role in the video is perfectly fine, but for her sister I would have taken a typical cheerleader, cute, 17, a believable high-school queen ... you know? ...
I've loved this song since the day I bought the "Bad Humour" album in 1998, and I can't tell you how many times I've listened to the track. Yet, this is the first time I've seen the video. Great stuff! Thanks for uploading ;-)
Yes, they had some 90's chart success here in the UK , but they deserved so much more than they ever got. The music-buying folk are a strange bunch...
I think Saint Etienne are one of the most underrated groups of all time. Although they had some chart success in the UK in the 90's , they remain largely ignored.
good humour is in the top 5 of my favorite records of all time. amazing melodies, amazing production & mixing, amazing lyrics which fit the songs perfect.
Great song from a great group! Was The Bad Photographer relased as single??? I love that one and Im sure I seen it years back when it was released?? Or maybe Im imagining it!! Ace of base have a song very like this called "Donnie" trying to capture this very sound! there another mis understood pop group that make all their own music! Only love can break your heart is also the exact same Chords as All that she wants & similar hooks as their other hit Beautiful life check it out!
Cantforgetyou, that's a good question. I've been a huge fan of thier music since the early 90's, and I think it's just that they're too progressive for America's general concensus appeal. They've gained considerable recognition in the charts in the UK and much of Europe. But, historicaly speaking, the progressive formats that most brit-pop arrangements tend to usualy have just don't seem to float well here. It's a shame. Thier style seems to be over the average american's head.
@ohthehughmanatee Yea..uhhh...I wouldn't say over the average Americans head....this song bites. Remember, just because you like the song, does not necessarily make you sophisticated.
In this case it does, average Americans (such as you) bite, and like most things with any degree of subtly this song is indeed over your silly little American head. Just saying...
Good song. Why were they never in the charts? Bad record deals? No good promotion? Or do they want to be underground. Cause the songs are very easy listening.
Thank you for posting this- the first song to turn me on to Saint Etienne! My flavourite band! Just waiting for a Donovan/Saint Etienne mash-up. A girl can dream!
Nice song.
Disbelieverful 2 weeks ago
It's ok but saint etienne were always a band where some songs were like 70% of good, but never great. I love this song, but it wasn;t meant to be a hit, they made so many bad shit songs as well they really didn't have a chance to be successful
girlie347 1 month ago in playlist Liked videos
I remenbered some (very) early stuff, what a shite this is!
skroew 3 months ago
Ere, if the character in the song is her little sister, why is she black ?
dirkbogarde44 5 months ago
Pour toi ma petite Sylvie !
Philou
Amazone1975 6 months ago
mourinho was in the right way...why?why?....why one of the betters groups are forgiven?
brettie76 8 months ago
I love Good Humor and got the double CD (in America) with Farifax High. It's great and plenty of us on the west side of the Atlantic love them too! Can't we all just get along.
aredhedguy 9 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I cannot believe you defend this garbage...are you all retarded? this is horrid music...i am done you. oh and who ever said karma eats your soul, honesty saves it.
paganklh1 9 months ago
@paganklh1 Jeez, dude... quit being so damned narcissistic! There's a little somethin' for everyone out there. You have your taste, and I have mine... she has her's, he/his. Get over yourself!!!
ohthehughmanatee 9 months ago 6
@paganklh1 One word for you TW@T
CaptEngland 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@paganklh1 One word for you TW@T
CaptEngland 8 months ago
One of my favorites by St. Etienne
murmurclient 10 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
awful just awful!
paganklh1 10 months ago
@paganklh1 Oh well, something for everyone. Honestly, I don't get why people even bother commenting on something they don't like. If ya don't like a thing... then just go "whatever", and walk away from it, right? Complaining is annoying. Criticism is good, but only when it's constructive. Otherwise, put a sock in it. No offense. Just a little constructive criticism. :)
ohthehughmanatee 10 months ago 6
@ohthehughmanatee if you don't want to be criticism then make better music. Or better still stop posting garbage.
paganklh1 10 months ago
@paganklh1 Sorry, but your critical leaves YOU wide open to be criticismed.
..and by the way, thank you for exemplifying my point. I'm also flattered that you seem to think that this is my band. ...and Garbage was a good band, too. Wonder whatever happened to them.
ohthehughmanatee 10 months ago 4
@ohthehughmanatee hey, Garbage are back!! :D
subhuman78 6 months ago
@paganklh1 Karma eats your soul. Beware.
menyc2 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@ohthehughmanatee if you don't want to be criticism then make better music. Or better still stop posting garbage.
paganklh1 10 months ago
@paganklh1 you listen to system of a down for god's sake.
birdcagemind 8 months ago
interesting.
Goldenvoiice 11 months ago
i really like it but i cant help not paying attention to it. its like an exceptional porn soundtrack.
Nukleurfire 11 months ago
Great song, weak negative video. Visuals should be more positive for this group. They have been underrated because they are about the music and not sellout models who are musically untalented like most pop artists who succeed in the mainstream.
BHAMOK 1 year ago
I love this song. The video's not very interesting.
Grimgorus 1 year ago
the best!!!!!!
tikismike 1 year ago
the first decent album i ever bought was good humour by saint etienne was and still is amazing
eitherwaybarneyrubbl 1 year ago
i didnt even know this music existed
ScarOnMyAss 1 year ago
my cat is named after this song :D
SeptimusKincaid 1 year ago
Does someone understand the story in this video (the handkerchief and the bag stuffs) ?
And once again, who's this bearded man ?
musicsavage 1 year ago
Love this song. Thanks for uploading the video!
gotanigo 1 year ago
このプロモ初めて見た。名曲だよな。
It's my first time to see this V.
Marvellous isn't it?
KAORIMOKO 1 year ago
@KAORIMOKO
Yes and the whole album is ("Good Humor") - should be listed to from start to end in one piece....and then again...and again... ;-) My favourite St. Etienne record, recommend it.
gotanigo 1 year ago
i love it when she says she'll have to shut you down to Sylvie
nosaj128 1 year ago
this was the first song i bought when i started working when i was 17 and it blew me away and ended up buying the album (good humour) and been a fan since like a couple of people have said a very underrated band
eitherwaybarneyrubbl 1 year ago
Não entendo como este grupo não é reconhecido como dos melhores de sempre - I do not understand how this group is not recognized as the best ever -
934631107 1 year ago
I LOVE SAINT ETIENNE!!
bubito2002 1 year ago
The very trancey Stretch 'n' Vern Mix of this song is spectacular!
HeathenLoveGod 1 year ago
wtf is this blasphemus doo doo :P:P !!!
I saw the title ..and that was the name of a person I used to "date" ish kinda and my name is Sylvie..:P sheesh:D the peeerveeerzsiiiionz:D:D arhhhh
silvie1994 1 year ago
Nice :)
dancing0being 1 year ago
stupid woman
sickbastard80 1 year ago
Cuba?
JefferyK 1 year ago
I <3 Sarah Cracknell.
ennuieffect 2 years ago 4
next time play only love can break your heart or he's on the phone LOL
jjluvsjam 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Was her singing always this bad? Girlfriend sounds weak.
ThePhunckyOne 2 years ago
If you mean frequent light tone mismatches and an impression that the woman is emotionally excited, then it was always this way. But sure I would not say it makes the singing "bad" - with her beautiful voice and articulation it just makes it sound natural and urge.
LubosTomsa 2 years ago
really awesome. thanx for the uload srarah rules.
had the chance to see them live around '''93 .. one of the 2 background, glitter mini-skirted backup go-go dancers fell on her ass while dancing, sarah turned around briefly, laughed & shrugged, & continued singing w/out missing a beat . . .
desertshore 2 years ago
Isn't there a remix of this somewhere?
TheYTStuff 2 years ago
she's mine
pikknz 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
what the fucking fuck?
Poopoos124 2 years ago
What a naff video. Whose the weird guy with the beard, he looks about 40. And how is Sylvie Sarah's sister? Great song, rubbish vid.
clsleamington 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Is it just me or does the lead singer kinda resemble Toni Collette a little bit at about 0:23 or 0:24 seconds in?
WavyGravy22 2 years ago
Comment removed
WavyGravy22 2 years ago
Wow. A studio track by St Etienne that hasn't been pulled off YouTube. It's an endangered species. So many others: POOF! Gone.
bgbreakdown 2 years ago 3
I got this song from an English penpal back in 1998 or something, I always liked the song, but never saw the video, until just now.
But I don't really get it - the black haired girl does not look like a sister, she looks Thai or something and much older than 17.
While Sarah is blonde and looks nothing like "her little sister" ...
Sarah's role in the video is perfectly fine, but for her sister I would have taken a typical cheerleader, cute, 17, a believable high-school queen ... you know? ...
Yavanna77 2 years ago
i think the point is how off it is...
kehya 2 years ago
i think the "sister" theme is being used metaphorically here. they're keeping it intentionally vague, video-wise.
desertshore 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
these ppl stink and my name is in their band name! D:
spyguysae 2 years ago
I like this video, made in Cuba no doubt
fredmila 2 years ago
Who's the bearded man in the video?
musicsavage 2 years ago
@musicsavage
Why, he's The Most Interesting Man In The World, from that beer commercial : )
tamcon72 1 year ago
I think I am actually in love with Sarah Cracknell!!
Embryonicboy 2 years ago 2
Eat your heart out, she's married.
Terbyn 2 years ago
ha yeah she is indeed. I shall admire from afar! :)
Embryonicboy 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
terrible music
jillysavage 2 years ago
Por esta canción me compré el CD, y no me arrepiento, porque dentro de él está esta genialidad.
Gracias por el vídeo.
ChaosWolrd 2 years ago
very cure, pitty it wasnt a radio hit
mobyboy 2 years ago
I've loved this song since the day I bought the "Bad Humour" album in 1998, and I can't tell you how many times I've listened to the track. Yet, this is the first time I've seen the video. Great stuff! Thanks for uploading ;-)
Yes, they had some 90's chart success here in the UK , but they deserved so much more than they ever got. The music-buying folk are a strange bunch...
Lee71England 2 years ago 3
I think Saint Etienne are one of the most underrated groups of all time. Although they had some chart success in the UK in the 90's , they remain largely ignored.
DazedSheep 3 years ago 28
@DazedSheep fully agree with you there......... but i think thats the great thing about them.............. a hidden gem =)
tixxstixx 1 year ago
good humour is in the top 5 of my favorite records of all time. amazing melodies, amazing production & mixing, amazing lyrics which fit the songs perfect.
darbonne1979 3 years ago 3
Brilliant song, and brilliant video. Brilliant band!
PANZYPOTTER 3 years ago 4
love this song they played it at the end of the last episode of season 4 of daria
mesmerize00 3 years ago 3
'Leave him alone,because he tells me he Love's me.......Over & Over & Over & Over Again'...
Brilliant Band...Excellent 'Live'
Lol
PatsyS3 3 years ago
Video goes great with the song. Kinda reminds me of "Hungry Like The Wolf" but maybe it's the setting.
mistermiracle72 3 years ago
i dont understand the video?
casssea 3 years ago
:))))))))))
JelNeshtoAvailable 3 years ago
Great song from a great group! Was The Bad Photographer relased as single??? I love that one and Im sure I seen it years back when it was released?? Or maybe Im imagining it!! Ace of base have a song very like this called "Donnie" trying to capture this very sound! there another mis understood pop group that make all their own music! Only love can break your heart is also the exact same Chords as All that she wants & similar hooks as their other hit Beautiful life check it out!
BASSER81 3 years ago
Bad Photographer was a single and had a video. hopefuly someone will put it up her soon.
boredreiver 3 years ago
Cantforgetyou, that's a good question. I've been a huge fan of thier music since the early 90's, and I think it's just that they're too progressive for America's general concensus appeal. They've gained considerable recognition in the charts in the UK and much of Europe. But, historicaly speaking, the progressive formats that most brit-pop arrangements tend to usualy have just don't seem to float well here. It's a shame. Thier style seems to be over the average american's head.
ohthehughmanatee 3 years ago 11
@ohthehughmanatee LONG LIVED BRIT POP AND FUCK AMERICA
immahotpepper 1 year ago
@ohthehughmanatee Pitchfork media adores them though and Sub Pop's boss
pierreerichexum 1 year ago
@ohthehughmanatee Yea..uhhh...I wouldn't say over the average Americans head....this song bites. Remember, just because you like the song, does not necessarily make you sophisticated.
mrubiquitous 1 year ago
@mrubiquitous
In this case it does, average Americans (such as you) bite, and like most things with any degree of subtly this song is indeed over your silly little American head. Just saying...
Shirokinukatsukami 11 months ago
Good song. Why were they never in the charts? Bad record deals? No good promotion? Or do they want to be underground. Cause the songs are very easy listening.
cantforgetyou 3 years ago
Hombre, tío.. muchísimas gracias por subir este video. Saint Etienne is one of the most underrated bands in the world. I love them.
orvgg 3 years ago
Thank you for posting this- the first song to turn me on to Saint Etienne! My flavourite band! Just waiting for a Donovan/Saint Etienne mash-up. A girl can dream!
HurdyGurdyChallenge 3 years ago
I 've been waiting for this video in youtube for years... For me, It was impossible to understand how it could not be here yet!!!
Thx a lot!! & Kisses from Spain.
I love this song
chemakema 3 years ago