Point is not whether Pakistani or Indian point is w work you should acknowledge the due credit and name against the music and lyric merithen you borrow someone elses you should acknowledge the due credit and not state your own name against the music and shyari merit. This is movie Alag Alag made in 1985 Pakistani movie was made in 1982 called Mehrbani
@9911199497 ABAY DUNIYA K SUB SAY BARAY CHUTTU... THIS SONG IS COPIED FROM A PAKISTANI MOVIE SONG.. THE WHOLE THING.. SONG SITUATION EVERYTHING... AND FOR YOUR STUPID FUCKED UP INFORMATION INDIA'S MOST MOVIES ARE COPIED FROM HOLLYWOOD EVEN YOUR HISTORIC FAMOUS MOVIES LIKE SHOLAY SHARABI ARE FUCKING COPIED SHIT... YOUY HAVE COPIED HUNDREDS OF PAKISTANI SONGS AND YOU GUYS ARE SO SHAMELESS YOU DONT EVEN ADMIT IT... BHARWAY
this song has no comparison to sung by ikhlaq ahmad (pakistani singer)..... kishore's voice doesnt match the tone of the song . if they copied the song they shouldnt copy the whole video from A to Z ...
Plagiarism is a crime and can not be favored and imitation can never be compared with originality. I am posting original one for you to decide impartially
both songs are very goood at there times in my openion the diffrenc is kishore kumars voice is rocking and ikhlaaq ahmads voice is so smooth and flows like a stream.
and another fact is that if you copy any thing u always intend to make it better then previous version like every new microsoft windows version.
@nomigujjar how dumb are you?... A copy is a copy... Microsoft windows is released by the same company isnt it?... This song is not from the same people... How dumb are you?... India not only copied the theme of the wording.. they copied the fucking situation even the way it end when a car comes.. God... they need a life because its okay they copied fine.. but their stupid people DONT ADMIT IT!!!!
subhan allah kya awaza hai kishore , subhan allah, bhal yeh iklaq kis chidimaar ka naam hai. mainey to is naam ko nausikhiyo ke beech bhi kabhi nahi suna , allah khair karey
Stop all of you commenting on all the artists. If our generation think in this way than our future is certainly very dark. Kishor kumar and akhlaq ahmad both were good and they have there own places in the world of singing. stop dishonoring them by your words.
hahahah people r comparing akhlaq ahmad with kishore. hahahha
no wonder y good singers get voted out from sa re ga ma or indian idol. this is bcause people have no sense of music. r u crazy or wot?? u can compare akhlaq ahmad with toshi n musarrat but not with legend.
If you take off patriotic lenses and listen to the original by Ikhlaq Ahmed and the copy by Kishore Kumar, the difference is quite obvious.
Ikhlaq Ahmed's voice was what you call the "honey dipped" voice. Kishore as great as he was, perphaps captures 80% percent of the magic of the original.
As somebody said earlier, the beauty of Ikhlaq Ahmed's voice was equal to great Muhammad Rafi, although he didn't get that recognition. People listen to the original and decide for urself.
with kishore voice quality pronunciations and the emotions conveyed thru the song by kishore....i think he goes way ahead of the original...he is unmatched...lets face it...the industry will never ever b able to replace a kishore kumar...
Yes. Surely. I agree. When anyone sings the same with Kishore, KIshore version always comes out better even when the other singer is very well classically trained
At the end of the day this Indian/Pakistani differences should be irrelevant, at the end of the day they were part of the same land at one point, Credit to the Late Great Anand Bakshi for in his own right creating the impactful lyrics, I've just heard the pakistani version, But at the end of the day Kishore Kumar More than matched up to the original, and in some respects out-did it! This version cannot be termed as 2nd rate to that one
even tho its a copy of Kabhi Khwahisho ne loota, but its still 100000000000000000000 times better than the original 1. Akhlaq Ahmed can never even dream of singing like kishoreda.
singing its not just abt how well u sing its abt how well u perform it n thas wot kishore did to this song. i noticed ikhlaq ahmad went off the sur many times in his song.
IF you noticed, u r i think some thing like musision type person and you r the only one.. but most of the listners or viewers are simple like me.... so we did not notice any thing wrong in Iklaq ahmed's song...and it is orignal song not a copy.... i don't think he did any thing wrong in sur or somthing...
Pl my comment wasn't to offend anyone esp chamogaa.I say plagiarism is worthwhile, if its intention is right. This song must have been loved my millions of people and not even 1% would be knowing where it was originated but I still say 99% of people wont have had this song ever in their memory,if limited to its original singer. Now wasn't I right, who cares,not even 1% of them may be a member of youtube, where you are saying it's a shameful act. Anyway thanks for ur information. best wishes
come on grow up...i never heard the song u are talking of....even if its a copy..thats fine...at least i got to know this beautiful song...so i dont need to go into its root...who sang it first, where it was done etc etc...i got this song, liked it ....thats all that matters to me....enjoy..life big enough for talking and creating issue for such small things...isnt it...just enjoy and be happy....
The scene and the song are uncannily similar to the clip from the Pakistani film Meherbani. The song is sung beautifully by Akhlaq Ahmed. As great as Kishore was, this theft should be condemned as shameful; the Pakistani film was released three years earlier(1982 vs. 1985). And please , let's refrain from defending this blatant plagiarism by arguing that the Pakistanis do it, too. Let's enrich each other, but let's give credit where it is due. I speak as an Indian.
good song...........but its copy of "Kabhi Khwahisho ne loota (Mehrbani)" Pakistani films i like the poetry of other song........anyone can have his own opinion....no offence.
Point is not whether Pakistani or Indian point is w work you should acknowledge the due credit and name against the music and lyric merithen you borrow someone elses you should acknowledge the due credit and not state your own name against the music and shyari merit. This is movie Alag Alag made in 1985 Pakistani movie was made in 1982 called Mehrbani
arshedkhwaja 3 months ago
this can never be better than original after all original is original
pesh007 9 months ago
Mohd rafi and kishore are GReat singer ....
its indian classical which makes a singer......
danger963 9 months ago
NICE SONG BRO
rashid301gb 11 months ago
i think this only good song isnt it?
alokknw 1 year ago
sabse bade chor to tum paki ho - aaj tak kuch apne aap kiye ho? jo bhi kiye ho - ya to wo chori thi yaa bheek chahe kisse milo jo!!!
9911199497 1 year ago
@9911199497 ABAY DUNIYA K SUB SAY BARAY CHUTTU... THIS SONG IS COPIED FROM A PAKISTANI MOVIE SONG.. THE WHOLE THING.. SONG SITUATION EVERYTHING... AND FOR YOUR STUPID FUCKED UP INFORMATION INDIA'S MOST MOVIES ARE COPIED FROM HOLLYWOOD EVEN YOUR HISTORIC FAMOUS MOVIES LIKE SHOLAY SHARABI ARE FUCKING COPIED SHIT... YOUY HAVE COPIED HUNDREDS OF PAKISTANI SONGS AND YOU GUYS ARE SO SHAMELESS YOU DONT EVEN ADMIT IT... BHARWAY
SamAbbasi 7 months ago
copied song frm pakistani film mehrbani
adil657 1 year ago
wah kia baat tum indians chorri main sab say aagay ho composition lyrrics hatta ke scen pic had copied whole a to z shame on u
adil657 1 year ago
awesome
cadburrydream 1 year ago
awesome song......
tanishq000 1 year ago
copy is copy chahye jo marzi kehte jao pakistani original song is far better than this copied version
omerpharmacist 1 year ago
its awsome, thnx!
lokman2505 2 years ago
Wah Kishoreda Wah !!!
chaitanyajosh 2 years ago
this song has no comparison to sung by ikhlaq ahmad (pakistani singer)..... kishore's voice doesnt match the tone of the song . if they copied the song they shouldnt copy the whole video from A to Z ...
newcityworld 2 years ago
@newcityworld i swear abhijeet sawant can sing better than ikhlaq ahmad. n ur comparing him with god kishorda.
BRITISHALQAIDA 2 years ago
Plagiarism is a crime and can not be favored and imitation can never be compared with originality. I am posting original one for you to decide impartially
tmjatala 2 years ago
nice attitude...
amit85kumar 2 years ago
Pakistani or Indian....DOES IT MATTER BROTHERS ??...bottom line..... its ONE HELL OF A SONG......
luv n peace ppl...
brainzout79 2 years ago 7
both songs are very goood at there times in my openion the diffrenc is kishore kumars voice is rocking and ikhlaaq ahmads voice is so smooth and flows like a stream.
and another fact is that if you copy any thing u always intend to make it better then previous version like every new microsoft windows version.
nomigujjar 2 years ago 3
@nomigujjar you are right
Sweetyfashonista 1 year ago
@nomigujjar
yeah well said i have to agree with u ...!!!
BRITISHALQAIDA 1 year ago
@nomigujjar how dumb are you?... A copy is a copy... Microsoft windows is released by the same company isnt it?... This song is not from the same people... How dumb are you?... India not only copied the theme of the wording.. they copied the fucking situation even the way it end when a car comes.. God... they need a life because its okay they copied fine.. but their stupid people DONT ADMIT IT!!!!
SamAbbasi 7 months ago
this tune is copied from a pakistani song and also the film is a copy of the same pakistani film
HASSPK 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
this tune is copy,this acting is copy this film is copy welldone copymasters,,,wah
hawantwo 2 years ago
mehfil hi loot li wah wah kishore G !!
Bebassi 2 years ago
wahh wah!
Bebassi 2 years ago
subhan allah kya awaza hai kishore , subhan allah, bhal yeh iklaq kis chidimaar ka naam hai. mainey to is naam ko nausikhiyo ke beech bhi kabhi nahi suna , allah khair karey
lionofJSR 2 years ago
wahhh this is really bad comment ikhalq has much better voice than kishore. u should test ur ears..
newcityworld 2 years ago
this song was firstly introduced in pakistani film
l3on007 3 years ago
superbly done by kishore,but still my favourite is RAFI
mdashraf90 3 years ago
Stop all of you commenting on all the artists. If our generation think in this way than our future is certainly very dark. Kishor kumar and akhlaq ahmad both were good and they have there own places in the world of singing. stop dishonoring them by your words.
neeravs3 3 years ago 2
hahahah people r comparing akhlaq ahmad with kishore. hahahha
no wonder y good singers get voted out from sa re ga ma or indian idol. this is bcause people have no sense of music. r u crazy or wot?? u can compare akhlaq ahmad with toshi n musarrat but not with legend.
BRITISHALQAIDA 3 years ago
Cool it folks
zainulkhan 3 years ago
This is a copy from the Pakistani film and singer IKlaq Ahmed....
786maq 3 years ago 2
If you take off patriotic lenses and listen to the original by Ikhlaq Ahmed and the copy by Kishore Kumar, the difference is quite obvious.
Ikhlaq Ahmed's voice was what you call the "honey dipped" voice. Kishore as great as he was, perphaps captures 80% percent of the magic of the original.
As somebody said earlier, the beauty of Ikhlaq Ahmed's voice was equal to great Muhammad Rafi, although he didn't get that recognition. People listen to the original and decide for urself.
Muryk 3 years ago
dont compare kishore with anyone mate.
he is the legend.
aliuk28 3 years ago
Original song was written by Masroor Anwar and composed by M. Asraf from Pakistan.
PakFilm 3 years ago 3
so?
aliuk28 3 years ago
Very nicely said
shyamkumarnp 2 years ago
with kishore voice quality pronunciations and the emotions conveyed thru the song by kishore....i think he goes way ahead of the original...he is unmatched...lets face it...the industry will never ever b able to replace a kishore kumar...
jhatpats 3 years ago 2
agreed 100%
aliuk28 3 years ago
Yes. Surely. I agree. When anyone sings the same with Kishore, KIshore version always comes out better even when the other singer is very well classically trained
saswata98 3 years ago 2
At the end of the day this Indian/Pakistani differences should be irrelevant, at the end of the day they were part of the same land at one point, Credit to the Late Great Anand Bakshi for in his own right creating the impactful lyrics, I've just heard the pakistani version, But at the end of the day Kishore Kumar More than matched up to the original, and in some respects out-did it! This version cannot be termed as 2nd rate to that one
yuvraj01 3 years ago
ya i agree 'dontbsmartuasshole'
stdio 3 years ago
even tho its a copy of Kabhi Khwahisho ne loota, but its still 100000000000000000000 times better than the original 1. Akhlaq Ahmed can never even dream of singing like kishoreda.
dontbsmartuasshole 3 years ago
OMG.... how could you compare this song with orignal....
every one know kishoor kumar is great singer...but
in this case IKHLAQ AHMED is way ahead... real pain in his voice..
yasersad 3 years ago
singing its not just abt how well u sing its abt how well u perform it n thas wot kishore did to this song. i noticed ikhlaq ahmad went off the sur many times in his song.
dontbsmartuasshole 3 years ago
IF you noticed, u r i think some thing like musision type person and you r the only one.. but most of the listners or viewers are simple like me.... so we did not notice any thing wrong in Iklaq ahmed's song...and it is orignal song not a copy.... i don't think he did any thing wrong in sur or somthing...
yasersad 3 years ago
Pl my comment wasn't to offend anyone esp chamogaa.I say plagiarism is worthwhile, if its intention is right. This song must have been loved my millions of people and not even 1% would be knowing where it was originated but I still say 99% of people wont have had this song ever in their memory,if limited to its original singer. Now wasn't I right, who cares,not even 1% of them may be a member of youtube, where you are saying it's a shameful act. Anyway thanks for ur information. best wishes
bruno30080 3 years ago
come on grow up...i never heard the song u are talking of....even if its a copy..thats fine...at least i got to know this beautiful song...so i dont need to go into its root...who sang it first, where it was done etc etc...i got this song, liked it ....thats all that matters to me....enjoy..life big enough for talking and creating issue for such small things...isnt it...just enjoy and be happy....
bruno30080 3 years ago
The scene and the song are uncannily similar to the clip from the Pakistani film Meherbani. The song is sung beautifully by Akhlaq Ahmed. As great as Kishore was, this theft should be condemned as shameful; the Pakistani film was released three years earlier(1982 vs. 1985). And please , let's refrain from defending this blatant plagiarism by arguing that the Pakistanis do it, too. Let's enrich each other, but let's give credit where it is due. I speak as an Indian.
chamogaa 3 years ago 2
good song...........but its copy of "Kabhi Khwahisho ne loota (Mehrbani)" Pakistani films i like the poetry of other song........anyone can have his own opinion....no offence.
mianyounas 3 years ago
Gajab ka gana hai ye.
justicejayant 3 years ago
Thank for upload this song. This sung by Kishore Kumar in Alag Alag. I'm very interested. Thanks..
balasubram 3 years ago
Lajawab Kishreda !! What a genius !!!
chaitanyajosh 4 years ago 3
Awesome Song.
pickeno 4 years ago 3