....Walter recorded this with the NBC Symphony, too.....eternally, the musicians played it in the Toscanini way...they never forgot how Toscanini told them to play this particular piece...this goes for other pieces, too...after the Toscanini way....they saw no other way to play it......that is, the NBC Symphony
Yup. Toscanini had "branded" the NBC Symphony with his stamp. Too bad.
The little Italian had a head way too big for his britches. He and Mahler, the greatest conductor of Wagner in his day had a battle royal over who would conduct Tristan at the Met when Toscanini first came to America. Toscanini would not conduct at all unless Tristan was in the contract. It caused Mahler to leave the Met entirely and take over the NY Philharmonic.
At the beginning of Side II, the orchestra goes back 5 bars, for the sake of continuity, to bar 227. A wise move, Jhouse, to preserve the overlap! And tausenddank bei Bruno Walter & Smetana!
In my youth it was always a contest between Toscanini and Walter. I would go from one to the other, never being able to make up my mind. I still can't to this very day!
Walter was by far the greatest of the two. In my humble opinion. Also, Walter had a direct connection to Gustav Mahler, whom I consider the greatest of them all. Walter is our only link, recordings-wise, the the Great One.
I like the faster version because that's the first one I was exposed to. The slower version is nice, too. I like that I can hear the runs more clearly in the slower version.
this is really good-right up there with Szell-Toscanini and Reiner
jameswginn 1 week ago
anyone like the Fritz Reiner version ?
bcom11 3 months ago
....Walter recorded this with the NBC Symphony, too.....eternally, the musicians played it in the Toscanini way...they never forgot how Toscanini told them to play this particular piece...this goes for other pieces, too...after the Toscanini way....they saw no other way to play it......that is, the NBC Symphony
valdengo1 1 year ago
@valdengo1
Yup. Toscanini had "branded" the NBC Symphony with his stamp. Too bad.
The little Italian had a head way too big for his britches. He and Mahler, the greatest conductor of Wagner in his day had a battle royal over who would conduct Tristan at the Met when Toscanini first came to America. Toscanini would not conduct at all unless Tristan was in the contract. It caused Mahler to leave the Met entirely and take over the NY Philharmonic.
flylooper 1 year ago
Superb! TY.
paulostroff99 1 year ago
At the beginning of Side II, the orchestra goes back 5 bars, for the sake of continuity, to bar 227. A wise move, Jhouse, to preserve the overlap! And tausenddank bei Bruno Walter & Smetana!
schwei56 1 year ago
In my youth it was always a contest between Toscanini and Walter. I would go from one to the other, never being able to make up my mind. I still can't to this very day!
Edward245100 1 year ago
@Edward245100
Walter was by far the greatest of the two. In my humble opinion. Also, Walter had a direct connection to Gustav Mahler, whom I consider the greatest of them all. Walter is our only link, recordings-wise, the the Great One.
flylooper 1 year ago
I like the faster version because that's the first one I was exposed to. The slower version is nice, too. I like that I can hear the runs more clearly in the slower version.
happydigits101 2 years ago
I think this version is a bit slow. Listen to Berliner's interpretation: it is more brilliant!
Maroichi 2 years ago
Comment removed
tapiq 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Besides the fakt that cellos are terribly out of the measures around 1:06 :)
tapiq 2 years ago
thanks when I started with the kamloops symphony this was the first peice they did thanks for the memeories it was over 30 years ago
tenosinovitis 2 years ago
WOW!!!!!
Barbapippo 2 years ago
Magnifique ! J'adore !
Merci
jackylen57 2 years ago
Fantastic 70 year old recording. Thanks for sharing - and the sound quality is brilliant.
brok328 3 years ago 8
menchia....la voce del padrone.... GRANFE!!!!!
gaetanotano 3 years ago