I think the first girl was dating the guy and they were going to get married but the other girl was jealous because she also loved the guy. So she placed a picture of her and the guy under their hotel room door. The first girl saw and thought that her boyfriend was cheating on her, so she left and that's why they're all crying. The 2nd girl is also crying because she realizes how much the guys loves the first girl and that what she did broke them up. She now knows that she can never have him.
i think the girl 1 did something. she placed a picture of her and the guy beside the other pic. she slid it through the door. and maybe the girl 2 is thinking the guy 1 has a relationship with the other?
@iheartysh it makes sense. i think the girl the guy like thinks he likes the other girl because of the picture thats y she left...the guy is crying because she left and the other girl is crying because the guy likes the other girl..
@ColorfulGobstoppers Even though I don't know the full story, I want to try and give some input. So what I read a few days ago is that there was 4, but then 3 left and then only 2 joined...Then I read that 1 left...But I know that's not the case since I saw the old 4Men. So then I went on google..and from what I gather is that the first 4Men disbanded and then the second 4Men also disbanded...and now there are these 3, looking for 1 more to become 4Men once again.
@ColorfulGobstoppers That might be why this album is 3rd generation. Personally, I love this group. The guy with the mushroomish cut is the best out of the 3, IMO. I just got into them a bit ago through a K-Drama called Secret Garden. The OST for it is called 'Reason' and it's very nice if you wanna check it out. Personally, I only LOVE this one and 'Reason'. I can't get enough of the one dude's voice. Haha. When they combine their voices it sounds so amazing too.
@TairaaGani yeah, me too.. I come to know them because of Secret Garden.. And I started listening to their other songs.. They're great.. They have many great songs.. Toktoktok, Vision of Love, U, Babybaby.. I tried downloading them all and I love them.. But I don't know anything about them except their songs and names.. :'D
@ColorfulGobstoppers lol. They aren't SUPER popular, so I don't know too much about them, myself. Google searches are relatively limited, as well. Probably because they aren't as pretty, as tall, or as fit as most Korean groups. But they can really sing...I love them....Well mostly the guy who is always in the middle during live performaces...xD I find it kind of depressing how they aren't as popular despite their ability to sing. Looks aren't very important when it comes to MUSIC. Haha.
Girl 2 is crying because she likes girl 1. And girl 1 can't go to the guy because she is secretly lesbian and loves girl 2. that is why they are all crying and shit
owww, yeah! It's Shin Young Jae and not Shi Jae Young. I'm sorry. What was I thinking, then? I got his name misspelled.. Anyways, Thanks for bringing that up! Godspeed! :D <3 KOMOWO !! :)
why cant there be English songs as touching as this? i dont find it cheesy just beautiful :') seriously i think the americans and british have just gone for too much of the dance music and auto tune stuff that they forget it could be stripped away and made emotional with music like this and im not just talking about korean songs but other countries and youtubers =P
@bcmusicdancefanatic i agree......but don´t call U.S. people "american" because brazilian, mexican, canadian, peruan...are american too ^^ when someone call them "american" this means that they control the whole america (i know that this hapen...but a lot of people don´t like it) ^^ i don´t wanna be rude...sorry
@sarahconnorfan41 oh how u are wrong but ok =D listen im not here to have those long arguments on youtube i just think its kinda harsh to cancel out fat people thats why i defend them they're people to, does it matter if someone makes a comment they are fat or not people have opinions anyways all i can say is have a good new year =P
lol i dont understand after watching it =.= but i think that the story is that the guy like both girls but he dont know who he really like, thats why he decide to leave both girls ... then the girl 1 with the ring thought that he like another girl , so she left, the girl 2 thought he like the girl 1 then also left ... thats wat im thinking ... and im just guessing ... can anyone who really know the mv story just write out wat the heck is happening T.T
NO, i heard that..the girl in the black likes the guy, but the guy has a GF already so she's trying to breaks the guy && his GF up by writing a letter to the guy's GF that he don't wanna be with her anymore. Thats why his GF leave && cry because she thought that the guy was the one who wrote the letter but then its not him! its the other GIRL(the girl in the Black) who likes him! &&the guy's Crying because his GF leave him!
I love this song although I don't know Korean at all. I heard Mi's version from Secret Garden and search it online and came across this version. Thanks for the English lyric. I finally understand the meaning. Such a sad song and story. I still don't quite understand the mv fully, but thanks for all the explanations regarding the mv. Reading them help me make more sense of the mv. 4MEN voice is so emotional and touching.
noo noo i got it!!! the guy was sleeping wid the girl that worked wid him, and the girl he was with found out...and left him....yeaaaa....I GOTTA BE RIGHT! 2 girls 1 guy sooo much shit!
3 people.. 1guy 2 girls... the guy and girl 1 works in the same hotel, girl 2 is engaged to the guy, girl 1 has crush on the guy, girl 1 is always around the guy but the guy doesn't notice, the guy does an event for girl 2 but she doesn't show up and leaves... The guy is crying because girl 2 left him breaking the engagement, Girl 1 is crying because she is sad that the guy never looks at her and, Girl 2 is crying because she probably has some unfortunate reason why she had to leave.... kapish?
@PhiluiYYYY actually i thought it was the guy broke his engagement with the girl after a last romantic get together with her (thats y shes sad already and leaves) then the he set everything up for the girl who worked there but the working girl saw that he was engaged so shes leaving (thats y shes crying) he realizes the working girl he wants isnt showing up he thinks she doesnt love him and thats y hes crying. thats what i think neways
@yupmonk3yzrul3 I think he loves his girlfriend much more than his lover ( the employee ). He was supposed to propose to his girlfriend and the ring they're both wearing are just promise rings I guess.
Everyone is missing a BIG part. You see..Guy & girlfriend meet once again & the employee gets hurts because she sees them together happily. Straight to the point, the employee is the lover of the guy she gets hurt because he abandons her unexpectedly for his gf. The other girl slips the picture of the guy & her together inside the hotel room of the guy & his gf. The guy's gf sees their picture & leaves with a goodbye note. All of them end up hurting each others feelings.
i think i get it....so there are 2 girls the boy and the girl loves each other, but the other girl loves him, but he doesnt kno! then the girl he loves has to leave and he was just about to purpose to her. They both cried cuz they didnt want to leave each other, but for some reason the girl had to go. And the other girl watched them being together and being happy, and it hurts the girl cuz she loves him so much, but he probably doesnt even kno she exists. hope that helps anyone who doesnt get it
This song was like a song written after everything that happened. Saying how his life is now that shes gone and how he cant do anything. Its a great song i was addicted to it for a while. :)
The MV is about how the guy is in love with the girl in the white, and how the waitress loves him but he doesnt love her. The girl in the white loves him but not enough to spend the rest of her life with him. But he believes that they should spend the rest of their life together. The waitress loves him and just watches him and the other girl. In the end the girl leaves the guy, and he wanted to propose to her. The waitress just watches them in pain, as her love gets his heartbroken.
the MV is sorta confusing...is it that the girl liked him? but he likes another person? then when the shots of him with the birthday cake is in the future? when he realises the person he loves is gone? but you dont need to understand what is going on, to understand the pain and tears behind this beautiful song
the sad thing is this video portrays the real fact that such a situation do happen in real life.i saw the live performance without understanding the song and the melody and singing evokes such emotions of sadness and longing..
OMFG! the video is SSOOO sad. why'd she decide to leave? Poor Girl who works with him...didn't have a chance then she shows up then he gets heartbroken ugh...DRAMA. I love it but I hate it lol
i soo was not expecting this video!! i really love the song and these men who sing this song because their voices are to die for...but the video really disappointed me!!..
They both like the same guy , but the girl who works at the hotel finds out that the other girl left cause of her,because she didnt wanna hurt her by marrying him. so she's crying on the floor, and so is she? (I wish T.T)
Okay, so the guy works at the Hotel and there's this girl he liked and she comes back with the suitcase and stuff.They have history--thats why they have the picture together and stuff. BUT there's this other girl that works at the hotel too and she likes the guy but the guy likes this girl with the suitcase. and in the end, the girl he had history with leaves him and she's sad. the guy made a dinner plan and he's alone so he's sad. and the last girl is sad because theguy doesnt like her.
I think, its about 2 gal in luv with 1 guy(they have a pic with the same guy).
But the guy only luv the gal who has a coupl ring. He prep a propose her,but the ex gf(the waitress) giv their pic to her& she think he has a relationship with other gal& that's why she not came up&choose leaving the guy. The ex knew she did wrong,but she can't stand if the guy she luvd with another gal&the end no1 happy anyway.they have nothing but pain.
the story of the mv is that this guy can't live his life after he breaks up with this one girl... he tries to start a new relationship with other ppl but it does not work for him... deep down he still feels attached to his ex
@wowcoolgirl the start of the mv is actually the ''ending'' .. so the whole mv is actually a flashback..
the guy was preparing to propose to the girl ( in white. )
but the girl saw it from her window,she isnt prepared to settle down,she didnt turn up for the proposal.
the guy's colleague ( in black ) actually likes him ( one sided ) is crying because she thought that the man she likes is gonna get married with another person.
@wowcoolgirl Colleague thought they are gonna get married, so she decided to forget this man.
leaves the photo of them together with stating she will forget him,be happy..
At the same time the girl that this man lovs,also decides to leave coz she cant get married with him ( what reason it may be.. ) leaves the photo with a note saying sorry ( i cant read whats the others..lol )
@wowcoolgirl idk. i watched it a couple of times. i think the girl in the black suit is in love with the guy, but the guy is in love with the girl who packed and left. like a love triangle. the one who packed loves the guy, but she can't marry him.
@wowcoolgirl two girls are in love with that guy. he's in love with the one that met him in the beginning and that other girl has an unrequited love for him. the couple spends some time together after being apart for so long and i guess the girl just realized that they didn't have much in common anymore. the guy was going to propose to her, but she stood him up. the other girl saw her leave and was crying because she loved him and was sad that the girl he loves, walked out on him....
@wowcoolgirl they're separated, she forgets her memory, he tries to bring back her memories but is deeply grieved. they start over to fall in love again, but then she gets her memories back. they live happily momentarily, but then she gets eye cancer. she goes blnid, its metastacized, so she ends up dying in his arms.
@wowcoolgirl idk if u still care but the start of the vid u can hear a man and a woman's voice chorusing "i can't return to you. without me, you'll be fine right?" i take it that those words are by the lead guy for his ex-girlfriend, the girl that works in the resort. the female voice is the girl who plays his love interest in this mv. the one who eventually leaves him and stood up his proposal.
I think the story is the girl in the white used to date him then she left. He never forgot her but started dating the girl in black, she dumped him and the girl in white came back, girl in black realizes that she loves him deeply and cant stand to see him with white girl. White girl then leaves on the night that he decides to propose to her. She doesn't really want to leave but she feels like she has to. Hence, they are all crying.
either he loved the worker girl too much and told the other girl off, or the other girlf ound out about the worker girl and now their all crying? i'm soo confused!! but this song just awesome!!!
i don't think the guy was working in that hotel.. he's more like a guest or the owner, if not how can he afford luxurious meal, boat and a room..? and his girlfriend who has left also looked like a rich girl.. the employee girl was in love with the guy but couldn't express her love bec he has a girlfriend then.. the employee girl cries bec she saw how much he love the other girl and was now crying so much bec she left..the gf didn't want to go as well but it looks like she needed to..
The other photo under his door is from the girl that left. She also said goodbye by slipping the photo under the door instead of saying goodbye to him face-to-face. Hence, to show the meaning of the story they showed both photos in one shot. One is an unrequited love between the man and the lady who works at the hotel. Then the other is between him and the ex-gf who leaves. She is sad for leaving him, he is sad for being left, and she is sad for sorta seeing rejection.
I think that the guy also works at the hotel and his ex-gf came to see him. But for some reason she decides to leave and is super sad (maybe the narration in the beginning is by her?). At the same time, the lady who also works at the hotel who likes him decides to forget him (I think) so she leaves the photo with the words under his door. You can see her walking away from his room door going to the lobby and then she sees the other girl leaving.
awwwwwww so stunning song so much feelings involved amazing.......
tatana18 6 days ago
Anyone knows who are the actor and actress in the MV?
margaret1006 2 weeks ago
Como se llama este dorama o pelicula?
Tifanny0012 1 month ago
please i say as it is called the movie
lesslyeandrea 1 month ago
i heard this song in secret garden's ost, but it was sang by a girl...
TheIcyblu33 2 months ago
@TheIcyblu33 there are many version to it. the female version is by Mi alone.
lifeisnotabutton 2 months ago
Wow 5 people that dislike this must be drunk, accidentally pressed dislike, or something.
Anonymous2424 2 months ago
who are the actor and the actresses here? PLEASE REPLYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY
siczxthien 2 months ago
this was shoot in cebu, philippines Imperial palace..
i wish i was there at that time..kkk
uglyka 2 months ago
i thought the guy was crying because his girlfriend left and cuz he was cheating on her...
XxRockinAngiexX 3 months ago
it's a good song and it's sooo hard to sing
ldgk2779 3 months ago
I think the first girl was dating the guy and they were going to get married but the other girl was jealous because she also loved the guy. So she placed a picture of her and the guy under their hotel room door. The first girl saw and thought that her boyfriend was cheating on her, so she left and that's why they're all crying. The 2nd girl is also crying because she realizes how much the guys loves the first girl and that what she did broke them up. She now knows that she can never have him.
Misspandababybear 4 months ago 24
I'm crying right now. This song and 4men's voices are just beautiful.
Cairrie 4 months ago
@bcmusicdancefantatic
soo trueeeeee. omg its good to know someone understands that korean songs and hollywood CANNOT be compared.
i didnt get the story tbh, but seeing a HOT KOREAN guy cry like that. omg. enough for my emotions to scream.
doramaaprncss 4 months ago
is a drama tell me the name please
lesslyeandrea 4 months ago
@lesslyeandrea it is not a drama, a movie or something. scenes are taken only for this song.
EyesDelicate 3 months ago
i think the girl 1 did something. she placed a picture of her and the guy beside the other pic. she slid it through the door. and maybe the girl 2 is thinking the guy 1 has a relationship with the other?
iheartysh 5 months ago 7
@iheartysh it makes sense. i think the girl the guy like thinks he likes the other girl because of the picture thats y she left...the guy is crying because she left and the other girl is crying because the guy likes the other girl..
purple09 4 months ago
this song makes me cry...I'm kind of in a situation like this right now.
thank you 4Men for making this song! :)
Pataco95 5 months ago
I searched this bcos of Yoseob but this is a great song! :D
TheCuteYuki 5 months ago
is this "thank you for your smile"?...if not, i cant find it, can anyone tell me where to find it!? thankss
owlxyooj 5 months ago
who's the guy on the MV? is he also member of 4men too?
nuttyalmonds 5 months ago
this should be a drama
idontdohw 6 months ago
Hi! I'm just a new fan of 4Men, and I am confused.. How come I only see 3 men instead of 4? lol.. and can you guys please recommend a good 4men MV?
ColorfulGobstoppers 6 months ago
@ColorfulGobstoppers Even though I don't know the full story, I want to try and give some input. So what I read a few days ago is that there was 4, but then 3 left and then only 2 joined...Then I read that 1 left...But I know that's not the case since I saw the old 4Men. So then I went on google..and from what I gather is that the first 4Men disbanded and then the second 4Men also disbanded...and now there are these 3, looking for 1 more to become 4Men once again.
TairaaGani 6 months ago
@ColorfulGobstoppers That might be why this album is 3rd generation. Personally, I love this group. The guy with the mushroomish cut is the best out of the 3, IMO. I just got into them a bit ago through a K-Drama called Secret Garden. The OST for it is called 'Reason' and it's very nice if you wanna check it out. Personally, I only LOVE this one and 'Reason'. I can't get enough of the one dude's voice. Haha. When they combine their voices it sounds so amazing too.
TairaaGani 6 months ago
@TairaaGani yeah, me too.. I come to know them because of Secret Garden.. And I started listening to their other songs.. They're great.. They have many great songs.. Toktoktok, Vision of Love, U, Babybaby.. I tried downloading them all and I love them.. But I don't know anything about them except their songs and names.. :'D
ColorfulGobstoppers 6 months ago
@ColorfulGobstoppers lol. They aren't SUPER popular, so I don't know too much about them, myself. Google searches are relatively limited, as well. Probably because they aren't as pretty, as tall, or as fit as most Korean groups. But they can really sing...I love them....Well mostly the guy who is always in the middle during live performaces...xD I find it kind of depressing how they aren't as popular despite their ability to sing. Looks aren't very important when it comes to MUSIC. Haha.
TairaaGani 6 months ago
jeez too much crying!!
lilian23910 7 months ago
you all are wrong.
Girl 2 is crying because she likes girl 1. And girl 1 can't go to the guy because she is secretly lesbian and loves girl 2. that is why they are all crying and shit
zxuunn 7 months ago 3
@zxuunn
I like this version. Yuri Goggles! >:O
TheEkzist 7 months ago
what drama is this?? :>
preciouscullen 7 months ago
@preciouscullen This is not drama, this is just mv for this song
ZaiLiangShi 7 months ago
mv made me LAWL. O:< !
GazRockK 7 months ago
so sad bcoz the drama was only for the mv
jaehwabella 8 months ago
LIKE this song!!!! :) :) :)
nurarifahizzati 8 months ago
great song.. :')
MissNa91 8 months ago
i love 4men, specially Shi Jae Young. his singing voice was great! thanks for uploading this MV.. :))
rhymesandreasons1 8 months ago 2
@rhymesandreasons1: Are you talking about the main vocalist? Isn't His Name Shin Yongjae :)
rawr6127 8 months ago
owww, yeah! It's Shin Young Jae and not Shi Jae Young. I'm sorry. What was I thinking, then? I got his name misspelled.. Anyways, Thanks for bringing that up! Godspeed! :D <3 KOMOWO !! :)
rhymesandreasons1 8 months ago
who is the guy? reply please!
riemathestar 9 months ago
can someone explain why mi is always involved in 4men's music? for example, here i am, I can't and may many many more!! please reply!!!
riemathestar 9 months ago
What's the name of that guy in the MV???
He is so good~
He kinda look like Song Joong Ki too
ve8n9us 9 months ago
@ve8n9us Thats true!! I thought it was song joong ki too!! haha
BlingBlingDenise 9 months ago
yo~
oh my gosh, this song look familiar and finally found it..
it was appear in running man show and secret garden ><
yoRoseberry 10 months ago
@yoRoseberry this song doesn't appear in secret garden or running man. you're probably thinking of "here I am"
fr0mNY 9 months ago
@fr0mNY actually it did come out in secret garden, but MI sang it!!
widad94 9 months ago 3
@fr0mNY
yo, this song definitely come out from secret garden and running man 110424 episode 2pm that episode , a guy who sang this song --''
yoRoseberry 9 months ago 2
Wat?! I kinda don't get this mv! Can someone explain to me wats happening?!
Becie1997 10 months ago
I cried when I saw the guy crying. He cries really sadly. T^T
hackleBERRYk 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i really like this song.....full of emotions... next time i want to sing this song i have a chance....love it...
eRomish 10 months ago
i really like this song.....full of emotions... next time i want to sing this song i have a chance....love it..
eRomish 10 months ago
借轉
THANKS
lavenderliang 11 months ago
Can anyone translate the note at 2:51 and the words on the photos at 3:37?
FranticFriendsFans 11 months ago
ommggg i got butterfliess
xoxoMADinLovexoxo 11 months ago
I understand this too well.
cityincolors 1 year ago
why cant there be English songs as touching as this? i dont find it cheesy just beautiful :') seriously i think the americans and british have just gone for too much of the dance music and auto tune stuff that they forget it could be stripped away and made emotional with music like this and im not just talking about korean songs but other countries and youtubers =P
bcmusicdancefanatic 1 year ago 144
@bcmusicdancefanatic those are what i call pop noise. THIS is what i call pop music.
muzaecian 11 months ago
@muzaecian agreeed =P
bcmusicdancefanatic 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@muzaecian agreeed =P
bcmusicdancefanatic 11 months ago
@bcmusicdancefanatic same feeling here
TheTisay18 7 months ago
@bcmusicdancefanatic i agree......but don´t call U.S. people "american" because brazilian, mexican, canadian, peruan...are american too ^^ when someone call them "american" this means that they control the whole america (i know that this hapen...but a lot of people don´t like it) ^^ i don´t wanna be rude...sorry
ps: i tottally agree with you ^^
belachompoo 6 months ago
@bcmusicdancefanatic You're probably fat.
sarahconnorfan41 1 month ago
@sarahconnorfan41 even if i was would it matter?
bcmusicdancefanatic 1 month ago
@bcmusicdancefanatic Thanks for confirming that you're fat.
sarahconnorfan41 1 month ago
@sarahconnorfan41 oh how u are wrong but ok =D listen im not here to have those long arguments on youtube i just think its kinda harsh to cancel out fat people thats why i defend them they're people to, does it matter if someone makes a comment they are fat or not people have opinions anyways all i can say is have a good new year =P
bcmusicdancefanatic 1 month ago
For yhe subs you ned to put la "cc" option .
7AL1 1 year ago
im confused also...
x81489 1 year ago
lol i dont understand after watching it =.= but i think that the story is that the guy like both girls but he dont know who he really like, thats why he decide to leave both girls ... then the girl 1 with the ring thought that he like another girl , so she left, the girl 2 thought he like the girl 1 then also left ... thats wat im thinking ... and im just guessing ... can anyone who really know the mv story just write out wat the heck is happening T.T
ytngng 1 year ago
Whats the Movies called? it seems a good movies to watch?
Pakou143 1 year ago
@Pakou143 It only an mv for this song
sunnisa 1 year ago
the guy in the vid is kinda hawt!
Mizzydiba 1 year ago
NO, i heard that..the girl in the black likes the guy, but the guy has a GF already so she's trying to breaks the guy && his GF up by writing a letter to the guy's GF that he don't wanna be with her anymore. Thats why his GF leave && cry because she thought that the guy was the one who wrote the letter but then its not him! its the other GIRL(the girl in the Black) who likes him! &&the guy's Crying because his GF leave him!
msKimLOVEhim 1 year ago
i like the best when this band sing for Secret Garden
muramasa1984 1 year ago
I love this song although I don't know Korean at all. I heard Mi's version from Secret Garden and search it online and came across this version. Thanks for the English lyric. I finally understand the meaning. Such a sad song and story. I still don't quite understand the mv fully, but thanks for all the explanations regarding the mv. Reading them help me make more sense of the mv. 4MEN voice is so emotional and touching.
sunnisa 1 year ago
Awww..I almost cried. :''''(
myBEASTlyhoTTies 1 year ago
nice song, but too much tears hahah...
Acupofhope 1 year ago
wooow, this is really confusing with everyone crying
animegrrl123 1 year ago 2
the girls face almost the same lol.. im confuse
beckslipout 1 year ago
noo noo i got it!!! the guy was sleeping wid the girl that worked wid him, and the girl he was with found out...and left him....yeaaaa....I GOTTA BE RIGHT! 2 girls 1 guy sooo much shit!
LATIFAH009 1 year ago
And i just have to say this.
OMG. The cake is REALLY pretty. With the candles and everything.
show05angel 1 year ago
LMAO! Is it weird that i understand the MV pretty well?
It's really, really sad though.
I think you have to like understand the lyrics first before understanding the MV.
show05angel 1 year ago
2 girls in love with 1 guy? Oo? i dont get it =_=
applexjuicex 1 year ago
Wat? EVrboDiES is CRYiNG?
SMilEsNiNa2010 1 year ago
so its a love triangle???
xchel4ever08 1 year ago
omg so sad...i dont understand it tho, but still...
i think the guys cute but i cant tell the difference btween the 2 girls ;P lmao
i realyyyyy love the song tho <3
03livingthelife23 1 year ago
3 people.. 1guy 2 girls... the guy and girl 1 works in the same hotel, girl 2 is engaged to the guy, girl 1 has crush on the guy, girl 1 is always around the guy but the guy doesn't notice, the guy does an event for girl 2 but she doesn't show up and leaves... The guy is crying because girl 2 left him breaking the engagement, Girl 1 is crying because she is sad that the guy never looks at her and, Girl 2 is crying because she probably has some unfortunate reason why she had to leave.... kapish?
PhiluiYYYY 1 year ago 141
@PhiluiYYYY best explanation
hyunbin2766 1 year ago
@PhiluiYYYY actually i thought it was the guy broke his engagement with the girl after a last romantic get together with her (thats y shes sad already and leaves) then the he set everything up for the girl who worked there but the working girl saw that he was engaged so shes leaving (thats y shes crying) he realizes the working girl he wants isnt showing up he thinks she doesnt love him and thats y hes crying. thats what i think neways
tsubasangel 1 year ago
@PhiluiYYYY But I think girl 1 was also the guy's ex-girlfriend... wasn't she?? Since in the end there's their picture
sweety7771 1 year ago
@PhiluiYYYY you're right. that's what i'm about to post!! haha ..
rhymesandreasons1 8 months ago
@PhiluiYYYY no kidding im glad u kno how to watch the video like evreyone else
ericsgirl1920 5 months ago
Comment removed
ericsgirl1920 5 months ago
@yupmonk3yzrul3 I think he loves his girlfriend much more than his lover ( the employee ). He was supposed to propose to his girlfriend and the ring they're both wearing are just promise rings I guess.
@eyeheartkorea94 :D
Kagomelover72 1 year ago
amazing voice ^,^
MrJojoba09 1 year ago
Once again, I fell a love with 4men's song.
myBEASTlyhoTTies 1 year ago
Its a love triangle~ :O
NhixLizz 1 year ago
Am I the only one that understands this mv?
f8re1 1 year ago
Everyone is missing a BIG part. You see..Guy & girlfriend meet once again & the employee gets hurts because she sees them together happily. Straight to the point, the employee is the lover of the guy she gets hurt because he abandons her unexpectedly for his gf. The other girl slips the picture of the guy & her together inside the hotel room of the guy & his gf. The guy's gf sees their picture & leaves with a goodbye note. All of them end up hurting each others feelings.
Kagomelover72 1 year ago 2
@Kagomelover72 i think you're right but which one does he love the most, which one was the dinner and everything for, the girlfriend?
yupmonk3yzrul3 1 year ago
@Kagomelover72 hurm that does sounds right.
eyeheartkorea94 1 year ago
i think i get it....so there are 2 girls the boy and the girl loves each other, but the other girl loves him, but he doesnt kno! then the girl he loves has to leave and he was just about to purpose to her. They both cried cuz they didnt want to leave each other, but for some reason the girl had to go. And the other girl watched them being together and being happy, and it hurts the girl cuz she loves him so much, but he probably doesnt even kno she exists. hope that helps anyone who doesnt get it
asianXdancers 1 year ago
@asianXdancers That doesn't really make since bc in the video there are pictures of him with both girls.
f8re1 1 year ago
@f8re1 well that was my oppinion.....its prob not right, but dats how I interpreted the mv
asianXdancers 1 year ago
the girls in the mv remind me of IU and JOO
ASIANJELLO 1 year ago
This song was like a song written after everything that happened. Saying how his life is now that shes gone and how he cant do anything. Its a great song i was addicted to it for a while. :)
iiChocolatee 1 year ago
The MV is about how the guy is in love with the girl in the white, and how the waitress loves him but he doesnt love her. The girl in the white loves him but not enough to spend the rest of her life with him. But he believes that they should spend the rest of their life together. The waitress loves him and just watches him and the other girl. In the end the girl leaves the guy, and he wanted to propose to her. The waitress just watches them in pain, as her love gets his heartbroken.
iiChocolatee 1 year ago 3
if this was a drama~ I think I'll be crying everytime~:')
ghummyglee 1 year ago 3
everything 4men does touches my heart....
the MV is sorta confusing...is it that the girl liked him? but he likes another person? then when the shots of him with the birthday cake is in the future? when he realises the person he loves is gone? but you dont need to understand what is going on, to understand the pain and tears behind this beautiful song
cecilianhttc 1 year ago
the wax dripping and covering the ring was genius.
this was a beautiful music video..
surrenderurall 1 year ago
the sad thing is this video portrays the real fact that such a situation do happen in real life.i saw the live performance without understanding the song and the melody and singing evokes such emotions of sadness and longing..
hazellina07 1 year ago
OMFG! the video is SSOOO sad. why'd she decide to leave? Poor Girl who works with him...didn't have a chance then she shows up then he gets heartbroken ugh...DRAMA. I love it but I hate it lol
a2nbiotch 1 year ago
is this a MV or a OST for a drama??
paperdoll1988 1 year ago
nice song...i love it....love it...love it..arhhh...sad song but i really love it
zulridzi 1 year ago
OMG! I love this song!
it's so sad.
It really touch my heart.
asukafantasy 1 year ago
this is a really nice song. he has a lovely voice.
i think i might get the mv. maybe? possibly.
he is pretty good at crying. nice to see a guy cries so freely
linited 1 year ago
i soo was not expecting this video!! i really love the song and these men who sing this song because their voices are to die for...but the video really disappointed me!!..
shilbe09 1 year ago
why when i download this video, the subtitle was missing?
is there anyway to download this video incl the teks?
thanks
ndoenk83 1 year ago
They both like the same guy , but the girl who works at the hotel finds out that the other girl left cause of her,because she didnt wanna hurt her by marrying him. so she's crying on the floor, and so is she? (I wish T.T)
mady2244 1 year ago
Okay, so the guy works at the Hotel and there's this girl he liked and she comes back with the suitcase and stuff.They have history--thats why they have the picture together and stuff. BUT there's this other girl that works at the hotel too and she likes the guy but the guy likes this girl with the suitcase. and in the end, the girl he had history with leaves him and she's sad. the guy made a dinner plan and he's alone so he's sad. and the last girl is sad because theguy doesnt like her.
xindhx1 1 year ago
His voice is amazing. New obsession(:
jacinda2310 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i love this song..but i can't understand the MV..can somebody help me..:(
4men is really a good singer...
arraniza 1 year ago
i love this song..but i can't understand the MV..can somebody help me..:(
4men is really a good singer...
arraniza 1 year ago
I think, its about 2 gal in luv with 1 guy(they have a pic with the same guy).
But the guy only luv the gal who has a coupl ring. He prep a propose her,but the ex gf(the waitress) giv their pic to her& she think he has a relationship with other gal& that's why she not came up&choose leaving the guy. The ex knew she did wrong,but she can't stand if the guy she luvd with another gal&the end no1 happy anyway.they have nothing but pain.
tha2chan 1 year ago
Hmmm but why the ex leave him since she came back for him?
invisible0621 1 year ago
the story of the mv is that this guy can't live his life after he breaks up with this one girl... he tries to start a new relationship with other ppl but it does not work for him... deep down he still feels attached to his ex
ericha3535 1 year ago
is this the actual movie or is this some highschool skit project?
ahdhffkdyd1 1 year ago
they sound so good... this is such a sad video.. but i love it.. thanks for sharing it... got me all teary...
blissfulsoul 1 year ago
AWWW.....i teared up just listening to this song.. thanks for sharing...
blissfulsoul 1 year ago
i love it...
nslsk22 1 year ago
would it sound stupid if I said I don't understand this video ? Can somebody explain?
wowcoolgirl 1 year ago 28
@wowcoolgirl lol no one actually understands it either ..
KAIIIYO 1 year ago 25
@wowcoolgirl the start of the mv is actually the ''ending'' .. so the whole mv is actually a flashback..
the guy was preparing to propose to the girl ( in white. )
but the girl saw it from her window,she isnt prepared to settle down,she didnt turn up for the proposal.
the guy's colleague ( in black ) actually likes him ( one sided ) is crying because she thought that the man she likes is gonna get married with another person.
chortforms 1 year ago
@wowcoolgirl then the flashback starts.. where this girl comes back to find the guy..
they still have feeling for each others as they are still having the couple ring..
the colleague has to pretend that is okay for her though she is feeling hurt inside.
they spent time together..
chortforms 1 year ago
@wowcoolgirl Colleague thought they are gonna get married, so she decided to forget this man.
leaves the photo of them together with stating she will forget him,be happy..
At the same time the girl that this man lovs,also decides to leave coz she cant get married with him ( what reason it may be.. ) leaves the photo with a note saying sorry ( i cant read whats the others..lol )
the stroy is more or less like this..
chortforms 1 year ago
@wowcoolgirl idk. i watched it a couple of times. i think the girl in the black suit is in love with the guy, but the guy is in love with the girl who packed and left. like a love triangle. the one who packed loves the guy, but she can't marry him.
jusschaa 1 year ago
@wowcoolgirl two girls are in love with that guy. he's in love with the one that met him in the beginning and that other girl has an unrequited love for him. the couple spends some time together after being apart for so long and i guess the girl just realized that they didn't have much in common anymore. the guy was going to propose to her, but she stood him up. the other girl saw her leave and was crying because she loved him and was sad that the girl he loves, walked out on him....
The1originalhachi 1 year ago 2
@The1originalhachi thanks for that explaination, i got lost too.
hazellina07 1 year ago
@wowcoolgirl umm nope..cos i didnt either!!!got it now though
hazellina07 1 year ago
@wowcoolgirl they're separated, she forgets her memory, he tries to bring back her memories but is deeply grieved. they start over to fall in love again, but then she gets her memories back. they live happily momentarily, but then she gets eye cancer. she goes blnid, its metastacized, so she ends up dying in his arms.
AzNSwag 1 year ago
@wowcoolgirl idk if u still care but the start of the vid u can hear a man and a woman's voice chorusing "i can't return to you. without me, you'll be fine right?" i take it that those words are by the lead guy for his ex-girlfriend, the girl that works in the resort. the female voice is the girl who plays his love interest in this mv. the one who eventually leaves him and stood up his proposal.
chimeraspunk 1 year ago
@wowcoolgirl just listen to their singing tone and you will get the feel of it (: it's ok that people don't understand korean,so do i
monkeylzh4713 9 months ago
this song is so beautiful
i cry from just listening to it even though i don't understand the words.
its like i can feel it.
i love this song ver much.
cralie718 1 year ago
Translation is pretty off..might want to translate it again, correctly.
livendienjoy 1 year ago
it's very sad song :(
yoshiganteng 1 year ago
Its A very sad song, and it made me cry T_T
eycee143 1 year ago
I don't get why the white lady left... :/
theblackcat6 1 year ago
I think the story is the girl in the white used to date him then she left. He never forgot her but started dating the girl in black, she dumped him and the girl in white came back, girl in black realizes that she loves him deeply and cant stand to see him with white girl. White girl then leaves on the night that he decides to propose to her. She doesn't really want to leave but she feels like she has to. Hence, they are all crying.
debbieization 1 year ago
the guy looks like onew
n1nawhatever 1 year ago 2
either he loved the worker girl too much and told the other girl off, or the other girlf ound out about the worker girl and now their all crying? i'm soo confused!! but this song just awesome!!!
kaniely 1 year ago
did somebody know, where i ca find the instrumental version of this song? THANK YOU :)
Saranghae19 1 year ago
I CANT STOP LISTENING TO THIS SONG!! its so sad and emotional!
and the singing is just amazingly done :)
brendonurie08 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
...please translate it into english...I really want to know what the song is about...;((((((((
lilBGgirl 1 year ago
...can you please translate it into english...I really want to know what the song's about...PLEEEASE!!!!;((((((((((((
lilBGgirl 1 year ago 2
@lilBGgirl it is translated
KAIIIYO 1 year ago 3
@KAIIIYO OMG!!!!!Thank youuuu!!!! :))))
lilBGgirl 1 year ago
@lilBGgirl Put the CC thing at the video bar thing on, and the translations there.
DluxMVee 1 year ago
how is the main vocal?
ydwlai 1 year ago
its a classic love triangle...the girl likes the boy but boy likes someone else...love this mv
pennypen017 1 year ago
i dont get the story for this eitherr? help please ?
krngirl159 1 year ago
i cried for that host girl i feel so sad for her
asmaa103 1 year ago
i love this song so much even that it is so sad but still lovin it
asmaa103 1 year ago
this is such a sad song :(
chobosamurai 1 year ago
i don't unterstand *_* what happened ?
AndieeTTSF 1 year ago
love this song..
such a good song..
makes me cry..
StEvAnIe 1 year ago
the video was confusing
key7a 1 year ago
why is the girl he loves leaving him?
SHINeeLove123 1 year ago
DOOD. i just wish that they would just stop crying and GET ON WITH THEIR LIVES.
neoMushroom 1 year ago 2
i don't think the guy was working in that hotel.. he's more like a guest or the owner, if not how can he afford luxurious meal, boat and a room..? and his girlfriend who has left also looked like a rich girl.. the employee girl was in love with the guy but couldn't express her love bec he has a girlfriend then.. the employee girl cries bec she saw how much he love the other girl and was now crying so much bec she left..the gf didn't want to go as well but it looks like she needed to..
honeyslevin 1 year ago
The other photo under his door is from the girl that left. She also said goodbye by slipping the photo under the door instead of saying goodbye to him face-to-face. Hence, to show the meaning of the story they showed both photos in one shot. One is an unrequited love between the man and the lady who works at the hotel. Then the other is between him and the ex-gf who leaves. She is sad for leaving him, he is sad for being left, and she is sad for sorta seeing rejection.
kczenitsuj 1 year ago
I think that the guy also works at the hotel and his ex-gf came to see him. But for some reason she decides to leave and is super sad (maybe the narration in the beginning is by her?). At the same time, the lady who also works at the hotel who likes him decides to forget him (I think) so she leaves the photo with the words under his door. You can see her walking away from his room door going to the lobby and then she sees the other girl leaving.
kczenitsuj 1 year ago