@65dirt I don't know what your on about? Max Q is really good but here you have the 4 best barbershoppers on each of the parts... Mayeb the reason you think "Max Q is better" may be because they are a quartet who obviously reherse often and these guys just get together for random performances? But yes Max Q is really good but i still prefer De Rosa on Barri...
People wonder if Oxley and Connelly's voices would blend in a quartet. My biggest concern would be whether their hair could coexist. This video has me on the fence.
gary lewis should be singing baritone and jim henry should be singing bass. Lead and tenor are good where they are. why is tony de rosa singing baritone?
@myself462 I don't think anyone, but you, has ever asked the question, "Why is Tony DeRosa singing baritone?" I think you need to listen to a little Keepsake and PLATINUM. You'll find your answer. I don't mean to sound rude. I just couldn't believe it.
These guys are very good but for all of you who think they are the absolute best, take a look around Youtube for more barbershop. There are some astonishly good performances ( usually from the USA! ) which are amazing.
@ChrisisBass13 Because that was the part he sang with his previous Gold Medal winning quartets. While he is an amazing Lead, he's sublime as Baritone.
I look at it this way: Vocal spectrum is a fantasy quartet in itself, with 4 amazing singers, especially Jonny M and Tim w. And the Lead and bass are something special too. I love the Moroni's voice!!!!
MaxQ without question IS a fantasy quartet with Gary Lewis as the true Backbone of this group.
i think that, because all four of them are so renowned for being the best of the best, they almost outshine each other, and it kindof throws the blend off.
im not denying that any of them are anything short of amazing, but i dont think they actually work together as a quartet.
I'm sure if they were actually given time to work together over a larger period of time they would blend better and it WOULD work. But IMO there could have been a better fantasy quartet.
The bass and baritone are Max Q members, but Joe Connelly (Lead) never sang with Max Q. He sang lead in Interstate Rivals, Keepsake and PLATINUM and Tim Waurick (Tenor) sings with Vocal Spectrum. So you're missing Greg Clancy and Tony DeRosa to form Max Q. In this formation however, you get the best of today's barbershop!
No, you're a bit wrong: actually Tony de Rosa appears in this quartet as he is singing the baritone part. "Max Q" members not in this video are Greg Clancy (ten) and Gary Lewis (barit). Maybe you are confused as Tony de Rosa sings the lead part in "Max Q", however he is considered the best baritone from his performing at "Platinum" and "Keepsake" quartets.
to all the people badmouthing connely his medal count 3 on the international level yours probably zero so before you criticize him why dont you step up and do better =] i know everyone has an opinion but come on relax and enjoy the music or just dont listen to it at all.
Hey guys, can we just all agree that this is amazing and appreciate the beauty of music instead of insisting on pointing out whether or not it could have been better? I mean... This is a fantastic recording (albeit a little quiet). We as a society focus far too much on what went wrong in a performance.. We lose sight of the great gift that the world has: music. Nothing will ever be perfect. Just sit back and enjoy :)
im not here to bad mouth connelly. no denying what he has done with other quartets. but for this song, he didnt do very well. his vowels are off from everyone else, which makes him stick out, and sound a little flat. Half of his sustained notes are him scooping the note. I know who connelly is, but this was def not his best stuff by far.
lead needs to blend better. hes bring the song flat. you think with the talent on this stage they couldve come up with something better sounding than this...
wow....need i say more...... amazing, the last chord always sends shivers down my spine with, dare i say ordinary barbershop tags but this one..... wow.
I'm so jealous of the baritone. I know he's like the greatest baritone/lead ever, but his range is unbelievable. I could never in a million years sound that good on the tag at the end. Unbelievable.
I certainly hope so .. Because they really would sound good.. Tenor from Vocal Spectrum, who won 2006 Lead from Platinum, who won 2000(?), Bass from Max Q, and also lead(bari) from Max Q, who won 2007. There is no way they can't be good and lead is amazing guy! good very good voice
i just want to start by saying that these guys are awesome! as individuals, they are the best at what they do, and in their quartets in the past, they have shined, but in this one, i don't know what it is, but it just doesn't sound right. it may just be that their blend is off. i know that that is why this is a fantasy quartet, but does anyone understand what i mean?
yea. I'm not sure if it's because I've listened to the acoustix version thousands of times, but it's just not the same. They are still amazing though :)
Well they have it listed as Fred King now which I knew he did one of the versions. But looking on there I didn't see the other person who did it because they used to have two. And I'm pretty sure it was Rutherford. If it was Oxley then I stand corrected.
I believe that it was the legendary Fred King with some alterations by Jeff Oxley when he was singing in Acoustix.. Hope that helps! - Tim W. (tenor of Vocal Spectrum/Fantasy Qtet!)
ppl might disagree with me but thats ok. now im not disputing that this tag is extremely hard...IT IS, its just that ive heard better renditions of it here on youtube [accoustix stars and stripes] BUT one has to admit that the last chord makes up for any faults in the song. that chord ROCKED!!!
@Rubano5428 make that 4 medals now Ralph :)
DKTHOMP93 2 months ago
isnt the baritone in this video now the lead for max Q?
laruenm95 2 months ago in playlist Barbershop
What arrangement is this?
FantasticBaritone 4 months ago
I don't know why they broke up but the MaxQ group beats this group to pieces.
65dirt 7 months ago
@65dirt They didn't "break up". They were brought together for this performance only.
supersingerevan 6 months ago in playlist More videos from OCTenor2
@65dirt I don't know what your on about? Max Q is really good but here you have the 4 best barbershoppers on each of the parts... Mayeb the reason you think "Max Q is better" may be because they are a quartet who obviously reherse often and these guys just get together for random performances? But yes Max Q is really good but i still prefer De Rosa on Barri...
TheChoirboy1995 1 month ago
I love watching joe's face during the tag! hahaha
jcirmsa 9 months ago
I'm sorry I'm a bass singer when I hear the tag and Tony's "ALL"!
abuckajaga 10 months ago
I would quit bitching about who got voted into this quartet... Three of the the members have three gold medals... That should say something!
applesauc3 1 year ago
@applesauc3 All four do XD
Icyveins906 6 months ago
I dont understand why people are saying that they should replace Jeff with Jim Henry.....I'm pretty sure Jeff is a better bass. =] lol
JeffOxleyFan 1 year ago
People wonder if Oxley and Connelly's voices would blend in a quartet. My biggest concern would be whether their hair could coexist. This video has me on the fence.
DeRosa full voicing it=EPIC!
KrinkBro 1 year ago 4
gary lewis should be singing baritone and jim henry should be singing bass. Lead and tenor are good where they are. why is tony de rosa singing baritone?
myself462 1 year ago
@myself462 Tony sang Bari with Keepsake, and Platinum. He is an original Bari...that's why. :)
warthogfixr 1 year ago
@myself462 Look up the video Blue Skies by Keepsake. Wait until the end, and hear Tony's post. He sang Bari in Keepsake.
LilKroog 1 year ago
@myself462 N00b... LOL... Tony's first gold medal was on baritone when he was 18... LOL
jmittsinger 1 year ago
@myself462 I don't think anyone, but you, has ever asked the question, "Why is Tony DeRosa singing baritone?" I think you need to listen to a little Keepsake and PLATINUM. You'll find your answer. I don't mean to sound rude. I just couldn't believe it.
bshopbug 11 months ago
amazing post and tag
myself462 1 year ago
fabulous
jhill74893 1 year ago
These guys are very good but for all of you who think they are the absolute best, take a look around Youtube for more barbershop. There are some astonishly good performances ( usually from the USA! ) which are amazing.
Happy hunting!
PianoFatso 1 year ago
I say get rid of Connelly and replace with ... hm... Slamka maybe, and replace Oxley with the one, the only, Jim Henry. /end.
stringX90 1 year ago
why is tony de rosa singing baritone?
ChrisisBass13 1 year ago
@ChrisisBass13 Because that was the part he sang with his previous Gold Medal winning quartets. While he is an amazing Lead, he's sublime as Baritone.
acapellaman129 1 year ago
does anybody know where i can get sheet music for this???
Drummertime0707 1 year ago
omg- i want robert cuccioli to sing for my 50th- if i can's get him, these guys would be my 2nd choice.
Mrpurrfet 1 year ago
HOLY CRAP this is so beatiful!!!
LucasRMend 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
when and where did these guys perform?
seyboo52 1 year ago
i like better with the accoustix
luisr267 1 year ago 3
These guys are so in sync it's amazing - great job!!
nukeitout 1 year ago
I look at it this way: Vocal spectrum is a fantasy quartet in itself, with 4 amazing singers, especially Jonny M and Tim w. And the Lead and bass are something special too. I love the Moroni's voice!!!!
MaxQ without question IS a fantasy quartet with Gary Lewis as the true Backbone of this group.
And of course....... awesome Joe.
MJkate 1 year ago
nice arrangement moment, yet weaker moment, the original is a more powerful moment.
onceigoblack 2 years ago
Jeff has the richest tone ever :)
frostBuckle333 2 years ago
Comment removed
LucasRMend 2 years ago
Epic! So Cool, thanks for posting!
Stratocaster07 2 years ago
i think that, because all four of them are so renowned for being the best of the best, they almost outshine each other, and it kindof throws the blend off.
im not denying that any of them are anything short of amazing, but i dont think they actually work together as a quartet.
sephiroth3782 2 years ago
@sephiroth
I'm sure if they were actually given time to work together over a larger period of time they would blend better and it WOULD work. But IMO there could have been a better fantasy quartet.
mcpicklejar 2 years ago
@sephiroth3782
It could work very well some practice. The only problem really is that Joe needs to back off a hair. Overall it's great stuff though.
bcv1990 2 years ago
Listen to that last chord. AMAZING! What a ring!
jonathan1234911 2 years ago
Isnt that the Max Q quartet?
J999ACK 2 years ago
The bass and baritone are Max Q members, but Joe Connelly (Lead) never sang with Max Q. He sang lead in Interstate Rivals, Keepsake and PLATINUM and Tim Waurick (Tenor) sings with Vocal Spectrum. So you're missing Greg Clancy and Tony DeRosa to form Max Q. In this formation however, you get the best of today's barbershop!
sgtsonny 2 years ago
No, you're a bit wrong: actually Tony de Rosa appears in this quartet as he is singing the baritone part. "Max Q" members not in this video are Greg Clancy (ten) and Gary Lewis (barit). Maybe you are confused as Tony de Rosa sings the lead part in "Max Q", however he is considered the best baritone from his performing at "Platinum" and "Keepsake" quartets.
nicoinvestigators 2 years ago
@J999ACK 2 of the members are from the maxQ
ChrisisBass13 2 years ago
Ahh Thanks!
J999ACK 2 years ago
That last chord with those icons...amazing!!
vanceperry 2 years ago
No really. Do you guys even listen to that last chord? Oh how I wish my quartet could get that ring!
the2ndgoo 2 years ago
to all the people badmouthing connely his medal count 3 on the international level yours probably zero so before you criticize him why dont you step up and do better =] i know everyone has an opinion but come on relax and enjoy the music or just dont listen to it at all.
Rubano5428 2 years ago 7
Hey guys, can we just all agree that this is amazing and appreciate the beauty of music instead of insisting on pointing out whether or not it could have been better? I mean... This is a fantastic recording (albeit a little quiet). We as a society focus far too much on what went wrong in a performance.. We lose sight of the great gift that the world has: music. Nothing will ever be perfect. Just sit back and enjoy :)
bcv1990 2 years ago
im not here to bad mouth connelly. no denying what he has done with other quartets. but for this song, he didnt do very well. his vowels are off from everyone else, which makes him stick out, and sound a little flat. Half of his sustained notes are him scooping the note. I know who connelly is, but this was def not his best stuff by far.
skankinjay 2 years ago
Comment removed
aohlead89 2 years ago
Comment removed
davec727 2 years ago
lead needs to blend better. hes bring the song flat. you think with the talent on this stage they couldve come up with something better sounding than this...
skankinjay 2 years ago
shut up fag. you bow to joe connelly
speedyfingers25 2 years ago
completely agree
jhernandez16 2 years ago
10 quartet gold medals on that stage, amazing! Wish I could've seen this.
hastosing 2 years ago
I agree...Tony would be much better on the lead!
BstRedSox23 2 years ago 2
made my spine tingle =]
Rubano5428 2 years ago
is it possible to get some of the sheets this fabolous choir is singing?
my goood! it's great
sheets anyone? :D
brjoldek 3 years ago
Sheet music for this arrangement is available from the Barbershop Harmony Society
WhatTheHeckWorks 2 years ago
Where abouts on the page? I can't seem to find it!
G
Guthrief87 2 years ago
it's product ID number is 113727 and was arranged by Fred King and Jeff Oxley. You can order by calling 800-876-SING.
WhatTheHeckWorks 2 years ago
wow....need i say more...... amazing, the last chord always sends shivers down my spine with, dare i say ordinary barbershop tags but this one..... wow.
lukeedy 3 years ago
beautiful,,,,bravooooo
lponce74 3 years ago
shhhh!!! or u won't mbe able to hear them.
jayliminator 3 years ago
I'm so jealous of the baritone. I know he's like the greatest baritone/lead ever, but his range is unbelievable. I could never in a million years sound that good on the tag at the end. Unbelievable.
springer331 3 years ago 3
yea, i think tony derosa would've been better on lead.
jcjcjjcc 2 years ago
i don't
krbarbershopman 2 years ago
@springer331
Maybe you should check out Tim Waruk's (sp) 9 octave clip before you go spouting off on range. Not slamming DeRosa at all, he's a monster!
seyboo52 1 year ago
He's there because hes the greatest Lead to ever hit BBS!
coolsinger016 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
they need to switch up a lead. im not really a fan. His range is a little limiting for a lead.
jhernandez16 3 years ago
dude...thats joe connelly your talking about...
guitarherokevin 3 years ago
so...whats ur point? hes not flawless.
jhernandez16 3 years ago
Joe is an amazing lead, and one of the best that have ever been in the society, but Mike Slamka is by far my favorite!
mcpicklejar 3 years ago
i was just talking to mike slamka this weekend at the PIO district comp.
rexy84 2 years ago
The point is that this lead has three International gold medals...
Linkthe3rd 3 years ago
dude, do you spend all day bad mouthing quartets and quartetters? this guy has 3 gold medals. how many do you have?
TenorJOE 2 years ago 2
Hey man I'm not the only one who has this opinion. Look at all the comments on this page.
jhernandez16 2 years ago
yeah, i dont think they have any gold medals either. and they probably aren't a certified barbershop judges.
TenorJOE 2 years ago
so are they actually gonna be a quartet now?
fujunction 3 years ago
I certainly hope so .. Because they really would sound good.. Tenor from Vocal Spectrum, who won 2006 Lead from Platinum, who won 2000(?), Bass from Max Q, and also lead(bari) from Max Q, who won 2007. There is no way they can't be good and lead is amazing guy! good very good voice
jg984507 3 years ago
fucking awesome
Jordanpwnschu 3 years ago
Gorgeous! Thanks for sharing your amazing talent guys.
IvoryRose123 3 years ago
Beautiful.
Veggieman87 3 years ago
please don't say holly derosa. he might start to believe it. :S
jayliminator 3 years ago 4
HOLY DEROSA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
MJkate 3 years ago
Amazing! Goosebumps!!
vanceperry 3 years ago
Joe Connelly's voice sounded like it was hurting pretty bad. I'm sure they do it much better. But yeah DeRosa just killed on that last chord!
Falcusaronius 3 years ago 7
Hes just trying to sing it low (ala Acoustix)
...I think he's probably just heard the acoustix version a million times too.
MJkate 3 years ago
i just want to start by saying that these guys are awesome! as individuals, they are the best at what they do, and in their quartets in the past, they have shined, but in this one, i don't know what it is, but it just doesn't sound right. it may just be that their blend is off. i know that that is why this is a fantasy quartet, but does anyone understand what i mean?
PrimalHunter 3 years ago
yea. I'm not sure if it's because I've listened to the acoustix version thousands of times, but it's just not the same. They are still amazing though :)
spcbass 3 years ago
haha, so much sound. four loudest people ever. you can hardly hear tim, heh
gordonice 3 years ago 2
They're incredible. Tony's third at the end was awesome. I've been trying to learn this tag from ages. does anyone know it?
Lince7777777 3 years ago
I've transcribed the whole song if you want it just em@il me
jibcraip 3 years ago
I want this arrangement haha.. actually I want all of your transcriptions lol ^^
daniscool99 3 years ago
You should really give money where its due (to Joel Rutherford.) Its available on the barbershop website.
Bighead6365 3 years ago
I was under the impression that it was Oxley who arranged it...
bordonthestreet 3 years ago 3
Well they have it listed as Fred King now which I knew he did one of the versions. But looking on there I didn't see the other person who did it because they used to have two. And I'm pretty sure it was Rutherford. If it was Oxley then I stand corrected.
Bighead6365 3 years ago
I believe that it was the legendary Fred King with some alterations by Jeff Oxley when he was singing in Acoustix.. Hope that helps! - Tim W. (tenor of Vocal Spectrum/Fantasy Qtet!)
VSTenor 3 years ago 10
I believe they did this show on 2 hours of practice
nairb8109090 3 years ago 4
wow quite impressive !!
jibcraip 3 years ago
Excellent...I wish the lead was the one from Acoustix though (his voice his stronger in the low register) the tag is awesome ! on of my favorite
jibcraip 3 years ago
MORE FROM THE STAGE SET!
Launchywiggin 3 years ago
ppl might disagree with me but thats ok. now im not disputing that this tag is extremely hard...IT IS, its just that ive heard better renditions of it here on youtube [accoustix stars and stripes] BUT one has to admit that the last chord makes up for any faults in the song. that chord ROCKED!!!
baddiss74 3 years ago
Wow!!!
kpenn0910 3 years ago
The tag is the best tag ever...in the history of the world...it's amazing!....now i'll be off to go pick up my jaw off the floor
jcbball0012 3 years ago