Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (89)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Best episode ever!

  • OH GOD. Been looking for this song desperately. People kept saying it was 'This is Gallifrey'. *cries* So happy to have found it. It's truly beautiful.

  • i remember walking round co-op a few years ago with this song on repeat on my mp3 player. it's brilliant :)

  • Steven Moffat and Murray Gold are genius'

    'Nuff said :)

  • @4evaharrypotterfan Do you mean Russel T.Davies? He wrote S2! ANd he is an absoloute BRILLIANT genious! :D

  • @DoctorWhoLovr No Steven Moffat wrote this particular episode but I agree Russel T Davies was really brilliant at the beginning but started to go downhill at the end of Tennent's reign. But that's just my opinion :) :) Great song right?

  • @4evaharrypotterfan Russel is my favourite writer, but that's just my opinion and yes! It is an amazing song! :D

  • I feel happily in my element on this video. Of all the episodes of Season 2, THIS was my favourite. Always will be.

  • Zero dislikes. Now that is what I like to see (';

  • Hurry my love, my time is growing short and I am so very weak, godspeed my lonely angel....

  • The Girl in the Fireplace remains my favorite Dr Who episode.

    <3

  • @Kerrianne08 Not to sound like a Rose Tyler hater or anything cause I like her a lot compared to other companions, but romantically speaking I don't think that her and the Doctor would not make a good couple. She was always the one admiring and in awe of him, the Doctor was never seen reacting the same. But with Reinette he would admire and loose regular thought if only for just a few moments. He was even willing to have himself trapped in 18th century France just to save her.

  • As our faces fade from memory, and our souls from life, they look to the stars, to the worlds far beyond. To all the shining stars, they echo through time, our last words, no other word can describe. Beautiful, so beautiful.

  • Such a heart wrenching song, and no words are even needed. Shows how beautifully composed this song truly is.

  • Also the fact that while he was with Reinette, he seemed to forget Rose on the ship for 5 HOURS. That says a lot.

  • I liked Doctor/Rose a lot but think Reinette in one episode showed more love than Rose and the doctor did all this time. To me, Rose just seemed constantly in awe of him and really desparate to be good enough for him, however Reinette didn't need to try to be like him or understand him, somehow, she just trusted him and realised that all the things she had in her life, felt incomplete without the doctor. Also, notice how in that one episode the doctors emotions kept changing more than usual...

  • @theamvgirlx couldn't have said it better myself.

  • @Kerrianne08 I know right! All the diehard fans of Rose/Doctor cry about doomsday yet seem to completely ignore this episode. When you see how quickly the doctor is prepared to dump Rose as soon as he saw Reinette.

    And it's nice, for once, to have someone with the same opinion as me. I thought I was the only one thinking this. :)

  • @theamvgirlx I hate how Doomsday seems to be the one that sticks in everybody's head! In my opinion this episode shows so many different emotions and like you mentioned, you can FEEL the connection between The Doctor and Reinette. You can feel a connection more so with Reinette ast Rose was constantly in awe of The Doctor for me it didn't show a lot of love. A passion to learn about him maybe but not love.

  • @Kerrianne08 I know. This episode was sadder than doomsday in my opinion.

  • God -_- all the brony comments are annoying, Im a brony and a doctor who fan. But these comments are so annoying, like how they did to a few remixs and vids -_- And I love this song so much ^^

  • The lump in my throat still wont go away every time I hear this song...

  • ponies brought me here

    they also brought me anti-depressant prescriptions.

  • this song is just absolutely divine. its so well composed. i love it soo much

    once you hear it it effects you and touches you

  • No dislikes~! That's awesome!!

  • doctor whooves.. Y U NO STOP CRYING?!

  • Doctor Whooves is best pony.

  • Brohoof

  • When I listen to this song...I can just see and feel all the memories that have happened while taking the slow path, the sad ones, the happy ones and the special ones you never forget no matter how long ago they were. It's a truly amazing piece.

  • this song is so beautiful and amazing, that no one had the courage to dislike it... :')

  • This episode in general made me cry...

  • beautiful, just beautiful.

  • This episode is Awesome. This music makes me cry. Tenth doctor is the best doctor.

  • A truly haunting theme from one of the greatest 43 minutes of modern British television! My heart breaks.. xx

  • Doctor Who can excite and scare us... But at his best the Doctor makes us cry and feel a little more human. That is why this was one of my favorite episodes.

  • Such a beautiful piece... I read Reniette's letter out loud to this.

  • I love both this song and the episode it is featured in. :) Thanks for posting.

  • This song is so emotional, it leaves footprints on my heart:)

  • got kicked in the gut by this episode. had to watch it twice :(

  • This song is so beautiful and sad.

  • Murray Gold is a genius. Doctor Who is spectacular, but without Murray Gold it would only be brilliant. :o)

  • Love this so much, it's so beautiful and sad. At the end I can see an empty spaceship floating through space......

  • This <3

  • I love this music. It's beautiful, sad, and nostalgic all at the same time.

  • @Serenity113 I just watched this episode for the first time, then found this song, and then I read your comment. And I just want to say that, in a world full of loneliness, it's nice to know two people can hear the same thing. Thank you.

  • This is so beautiful, it really shows the tragedy of French society in the 18th century, the poor with nothing and an upper class hated and despised by all

  • @megalord921

    Maybe because this music is designed for when she died and it's not a very jolly song it's quite sad

  • i did this song on ice

    very hard song to dance to.

    but its perfect for putting emotion into somthing u love doing :')

  • @shadowshart1 That sounds like it would be amazing to watch! :)

  • @BrightFlashOfLight thanks, i did get a very HIGH GRADE FOR IT. then my mom took me 2 greace for me doing so well :3

  • idk why but every single time i listen to this song it makes me cry idk why it just does.....makes me think about alot of long lost memories and friends :')

  • Before I started watching Dr. Who I would call this the mermaid song...Now I just cry whenever I hear it. Its so wonderful!

  • AWESOME

  • This song i so butiful and it makes me cry so much because it makes me fink of all the people that are less fortunet that us and all the poeple who have died and the people who will die. i no it is tragec but that is how my mind works it always looks on the bad side of things so i leave you this message so you to can understand how i am feeling.

  • To me, this song represents everything that is beautiful in the world, and everything that could be beautiful if we all just slow down once in a while.

  • Why aint humanity raising instead of fighting eacother, we should descover the universe not go agenst contry and waring.. if every singel person in this world could listen to this song and just think about what we can do together .

  • When I learnt to play this on the piano, was like "HELL YEAH BI***ES!" Of course, upon returning to live with my mum, I had to face the stark reality that she doesn't own a piano, or a keyboard, and that I'd just wasted three weeks of my life . . .

  • I adore this song. I loved Madame De Pompadour and the Doctor... This will always make me cry.

  • 0:00-3:48= pure beauty.

  • This is the most beautiful and romantic songs I have ever heard

  • I cried when I heard this today, it made me think of watching my brother grow up for the past 14 years and that I'll continue watching him grow, taking the slow path together

  • the most heartmoving song i've ever heard in my life

  • "Madame de Pompadour, you look younger every day!" HAH! whan you're a french Doctor Who fan, you can't don't be prad to see the history of country in the best serie ever! 8D

  • Comment removed

  • Such a beautiful song <3

  • @xoxMichiruxox I don't know about you, but it really calls out to me emotionally ... I want to cry every time I hear it ...

  • @TumasMuscat Yes it does call out to me emotionally, but not to cry (I think I have acrying dosorder or something). I never cry. But this song does make me imagine thinga and it has really inspired me for this story I am writing. I found this sonf just as I was about to quit, and I was inspired when I heard it. It also relaxes me before a soccer game... it gets me in the zone

  • @xoxMichiruxox It's not that you have a crying disorder, don't worry ... it's just that, having seen the episode, this music reminds me of its poignant conclusion. Maybe I'm a softie for having actually at one point cried at that ...

    I can understand the inspirational aspect of this piece too. Interesting use you found there for the football game, maybe I should try it next time!

  • @TumasMuscat Thanks, your actually the first person who tells me I don't have a crying disorder xD ... the last time I actually remembered crying was in March... because I was so tired, I think I had only slept 3 hours that night. I cry when I'm tired xD

    But I also found the end very touching, especially when the Doctor leaves, but she doens't want him to.

  • This song makes me cry, it's so incredibly fantastic

  • @22emme22

    lol thanx hope you enjoyed it

  • my advice is that the BBC steals our money to put on programs that now air not popular concent or opinion but is now a retiringly scared institution who put on mainly rubbish eg parkinson left because of this ,so download this sountrack for free they take more than enough money from us they only need enough to air their (sincearly) good documenterys and the semi impartial news which is alot better than the news making media of new .the dramas is so bad since the last 2 directers took control

  • this is amazing brilliant, thank you, i am inspired to buy the soudtrack, actually i was going to do that just having a look what was on it

  • no worries it is a good song and good album you should buy it!

  • FINALLY an unaltered, speech free version. You are awesome. Thank you very much.

  • no worries

  • a soon as the prices come down on ebay

  • @MrDalekBuster What?

  • what do you mean, im trying to buy the cds but im skint so i need money, from somewhere, or need it cheap and i can only find it on ebay got it

  • Lol, and why are you telling me this? Oh I see, you accidentally replied to my comment instead of the one above mines. Apologies mate.

  • no you said

    @MrDalekBuster what?

    i assumed you didnt know what i was saying haha no worries

  • Thanks for uploading this i love music like this =D

  • no worries glad you like it

  • I adore this music. Thanks for puttin it up. :)

  • no worries glad you like it

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more