@AnotherWhiskey Seriously, you don't realise how much you have just helped me!!!!!!! I've just spent the best part of an hour trying to figure out what song that the piano part reminded me of.... and i saw this comment and literally screamed with happiness. thank you so much hahaha
saw these a fortnight ago for the fifth time and they just get better,forget blur the stone roses,oasis these are the top boys to come out of that scene
This tune is class.Found out it was the Charlatans & I couldn't believe such hot tune from a band who were fresh when I were a kid.I am now 40.
These have been together for ever,,must be at least 22yrs.,..give a few.!! Just cannot believe the band are still producing music.,period.Well done to the Mancs'..
I cant believe I never heard of these Guys, They are "Long In The Tooth", Good Movie, Guess those two just broke up? Shame, On screen Charisma, Fun plot
@INOX2005 oasis are a joke..the stone roses is the influence on their early stuff..stone roses..best debut album ever..i would say best album..but the beatles revolver is too good..
@sharpo88 I was confused,thought,Gael Gallagher was Oasis Vocalist, but the right name is Noel, who`s not the vocalist of Oasis, haha never mind i just did a bizarre comparation.
Great stuff, best Music Video on YT. Toward the end where the guys are scrambling around for the dollars, it's all $1s. Love this song, love the characters, love the feel.
Get Loaded in the Dark hits the Coronet on Easter Thursday April 1st 2010 and is set to be another sell-out event!!
Joining the already confirmed Black Grape, who will play their first Live Show since 1997, will be The Sunshine Underground, Young Fathers, Jakwob and Grum!!
Get your tickets now at ticketWeb or visit getloadedinthedark(dot)com for all news, info, line-ups and much much more!
okay same as OCS I have been in NYC for 10 years havent been keeping up with the brit bands , where did the charltans go this sounds like a bad porno tune why have the brit bands lost there edge ..
the sound of this song is sick...the rhythm is just to faking good. First heard it in the movie, "jumper" and went crazy trying to find it....love it!!!
you're all bitching about taht woman but chances are if she went away you'd feel the song is incomplete. she makes the song what it is. if you really appreciate the song and listen you can hardly tell she's there.
@AllanHP You're right, she shouldn't have been in the video in the first place. She shouldn't have to stick by and help support a moron while her life is at stake. I'd like to hear a few bludgeons to her boyfriend's head. Eh, or your head, whichever sounds more painful and makes you realize the inherent misogyny in this video.
Es la mejor rola del mundo rockero!!!! los acordes, el ritmo, la mezcla, la letra, la voz!!!! definitivamente los ingleses saben hacer musica, I LOVE IT. Blackened Blue Eyes rules!!!
The most awesome thing about this video for me (besides the greatness of the song itself) is the fact that I'm a white guy in Asia with an Asian girlfriend named "Ruby" so it feels like this video is about us.
Yea, same here! I made it a friggin top priority to read those credits as the movie went off. I write down "Charlatans" and raced to the net and download. Such a mellow, chill song, this one.
The Charlatans (UK), broke through in early nineties helping to form the "then nineties Manchester sound" with other groups like Happy Mondays and Stone Roses. I highly recommend you check out their first album. Great Stuff
in my opinion the 90's was a big comeback from the 80's..... from 2000 onwards got shite again.... lets just hope their will be a big comeback after 2010...
A little over a year ago a little boy called Josh was playing in his room when a raper crashed trought his window and killed him.Today Josh will kill anyone moking this message and if you don't paste comment on 10 other videos in the next 10 minutes Next time you play in your room he will burst trought your window and kill you.
I wouldn't go as far as Alfred McLuvian, but we have the best music scene and are bloody cool. Thats why its good to be English and not Scottish like McLuvian. Hadrians wall was built for a reason.
My pal said he introduced me to the Charlatans,but he did'nt really he said to me,'Have you heard the Charlatans before'.And I said,I have heard the name of the band but never listended to them,and a few weeks back I listened to them and loved just about every song of theres I have heard.And now my pal thinks he was the one who introduced me to them,just cause he asked me if I had ever heard of them before.PISH.
fookin´n hell, what are ya talkin´ bout?? that´s manchester-tunes and nothing compares to that!!oasis, roses, charlatans, verve...best bands of all the time...
you can say its just a music video all you want, but you try making a music video, tell me who you cast, naturally you would cast someone that is familiar to you, whatever race you may be.
Like falling in love, its something you cant control, but your statments basically says the (for example) a chinese person should only fall for someone of the same race? We are all human at the end of the day an personally if the girl in the Video was from my country (scotland), and was protection here jamacian boyfriend, it would not even enter my mind that this was racist, it would simply be a white girl who has fallen for a black guy, no more no less
No i don't think people should fall for their own race. I think that people should not choose who they are attracted to based on what media and society says is acceptable.
theres too many poor portrayals of asians in media, i've heard too many racial/stereotypical remarks made of asian men by asian women with no facts or experience. this video shows the social trend of asian women dating only white men for status. In the beginning of the video, the girl says in cantonese "i'm very unhappy with my life, my name is Ruby, i'm that kind of girl" implying that she is a prostitute. Asian women EXCLUSIVELY dating white men in america is a widespread social problem
take in consideration that as an artist, the director of the music video had to come up with the concept which includes deciding on what characteristics the each role must portray and in turn what race to portray said characteristics, thus making a statement of the race by picking them specifically over another race. If you think casting in films and music videos is purely chance and blind, then you are sadly mistaken,
and the fact that they bothered to record the character Ruby in Cantonese and overlap it with an English track shows that they want to pin an ethnic identity on her and not just have her be a generic American that just coincidentally Chinese because its "just a music video" I'm not going to say that this is particularly racist towards asians, because I don't think that its so much of a statement of Asians treating their women poorly,
but a statement of asian women running to their white knights (even if they are fallable as the Johnny character in the video was) and having some romantic notion that white people are better, and no i'm not blaming white people, i'm just blaming the asian women who are being racist towards their own culture and not keeping it real by believing in the their dumb fairy tales of being accepted into "white america".
why beg for acceptance and breed yourself out? thats just low in my opinion, in this day and age especially, since the world has become supposedly so much more liberal minded and politically correct, I think that people should learn to be proud of their heritage and not run from it.
How much the Charlatans had a creative control over this video I don't know, maybe they are trying to make a statement themselves, and I would like to believe that they are, as any good musician should if they have the power to spread a message. ultimately everything is open to interpretation but i hope that my thoughts are enlightening to someone
1. Its just a music video 2. Its got fuck all to do with any part of America, the bands British 3. The term Asian is so fucking wrong and it pisses me off there are thousands of people in the Asian continent, Asian does not just mean Oriental or Pakistani or Indian ect. Everyone needs to get a grip and know about every race before they start calling everyone racist because that is what narrow mindedness is!
I think you need to learn the roots of the word Oriental because i find that term to be even less accurate than just using "asian" as a blanket statement of race. there are more than thousands of people in asia. the director of the video CHOSE to portray the girl as a girl of hong kong/cantonese heritage living in new york with a caucasian boyfriend appearing to be of italian heritage.
For Cool T-Shirts & Hoodies click on my name and you can find the address on my page, alternatively click on any of my vids and you'll find it there too.
...not just "very cliched" I specifically meant to say that it's not very well thought out, and too similar to entertainment from the past that were definitely racist. As if it's trying to keep some sort of meme alive.
It's not deliberately racist but it brings to mind a lot of stereotypes used in movies and shows from the past.
There are the asian males portrayed as a corrupt triad members bullying their women, asian women shown being oppressed by old-fashioned chauvinistic asian males, and then we have the white man standing as a symbol of freedom, liberating the woman from her oppressors.
Again, probably not the intentions of the director(s), but at the same time very cliched.
i never thought there was racist implication in the video. Nontheless, this video just sucks. It's painfully bad, and I really cannot watch it. I see they (or just the record company) were trying so hard to change the band's image or push them in the middle of the trendy American music scene. This is not really the charlatans that I always love. They need a different record label or at least completely different idea for their marketing.
The ppl who say its racist are just reading far too much into the video. The fact that you automatically assume that the because the women is of an ethnic minority that ppl are try to stereotype that group is narrowed minded of you. Can you not just accept that it is really just a musi video and not racially motivated?
one of the best british bands by far
sirgeggs 2 weeks ago in playlist Favorite videos
Summer 2006
VillaTragedia 1 month ago
good
tredicipuntocinque 1 month ago
Just jumped in
ItsMeGaryG 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This video was just added to a music playlist at JustPlay.fm
justplayfm 2 months ago
The piano part reminds me a bit of "Extreme Ways". I wish there was an instrumental version of this.
AnotherWhiskey 3 months ago
@AnotherWhiskey Seriously, you don't realise how much you have just helped me!!!!!!! I've just spent the best part of an hour trying to figure out what song that the piano part reminded me of.... and i saw this comment and literally screamed with happiness. thank you so much hahaha
stokeysk8ter 2 months ago
The only instruments that are catchy to me is the piano, guitar and...yeah :D THESE GUYS ARE EPIC! ^^
kunal2045 4 months ago
SIMPLESMENTE DU CARALEO ESSES CARAS!
deaepaulo 6 months ago
these guys are fuckin legends
sirgeggs 7 months ago
BEST OF THE BEST!!!CHARLATANS UK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
giorgosaris1000 7 months ago
SLAG
Jstand1 7 months ago
stfu ruby
oddpipe 7 months ago
Amazing!!
jmoranproductions 9 months ago
an absolute class tune!
TheMrMadchester 11 months ago
Napa Live Festival June 16th
vanpatten1 1 year ago
' you've seen Charly? *slap*
urbano83 1 year ago
@urbano83 it was me that got slapped. i was very scared.
deanfragile 9 months ago
inspiral carpets
bohsblur 1 year ago
Check out this band from the UK.
The Captive Hearts. Their single is out in Japan this week and is out currently in the UK.
Search - The Captive Hearts - Hummingbird
You can also find them on Facebook
Theprose 1 year ago
One of the best pianist on the world!
DiegoCherry911 1 year ago
Madchester!!!
Superemil23 1 year ago
There is a good live version of this track at XFM's edit suite, multi cameras angles the lot
AlMeTube 1 year ago
JUMPER!!!!! :D love Jumper!
mairs20 1 year ago 3
saw these a fortnight ago for the fifth time and they just get better,forget blur the stone roses,oasis these are the top boys to come out of that scene
gladhand1001 1 year ago
like the song
androlegend 1 year ago
This tune is class.Found out it was the Charlatans & I couldn't believe such hot tune from a band who were fresh when I were a kid.I am now 40.
These have been together for ever,,must be at least 22yrs.,..give a few.!! Just cannot believe the band are still producing music.,period.Well done to the Mancs'..
Warren111able 1 year ago
Unfortunetaly I think I like the instrumentals better than the vocals and the rest of the song... The random talking is a bit annoying
wgjhey 1 year ago
I cant believe I never heard of these Guys, They are "Long In The Tooth", Good Movie, Guess those two just broke up? Shame, On screen Charisma, Fun plot
sweetitis 1 year ago
The voice sounds similiar as the Gael Gallagher (Oasis Vocal) , anyways Sounds So Fkng Good.
INOX2005 1 year ago
@INOX2005 It's Liam Gallagher (Gael is a hilarous name btw) and yes he quite sounds like Tim Burgess.
SallyCinnamonette 1 year ago
@INOX2005 oasis are a joke..the stone roses is the influence on their early stuff..stone roses..best debut album ever..i would say best album..but the beatles revolver is too good..
hoppybhoy71 1 year ago
@INOX2005 who the fuck is Gael Gallagher?
sharpo88 1 year ago
@sharpo88 I was confused,thought,Gael Gallagher was Oasis Vocalist, but the right name is Noel, who`s not the vocalist of Oasis, haha never mind i just did a bizarre comparation.
INOX2005 1 year ago
yummy
EltomeiroJackson 1 year ago
stfu love.
Yugguy1970 1 year ago
Me encanta!!!!
GUSTAVOBETANZO 1 year ago
NATIONAL TREASURES
MrJonnie22 1 year ago 2
I hear this song from jumper and LOVED it.Never heard of the UK band though,they are very good.
imacgoo 1 year ago 3
good song, but the people talking kinda ruin it, they should be quiet, it kinda ruins the song! but still a pretty good song! haha
KDOGG331 1 year ago
why does everyone hate simpatico????
109pt2 1 year ago
let me post comments dammit!
flyvibe71 1 year ago
saw this at the end of the movie "jumper" forgot about it. glad it was brought back 2 me . it sooooo rocks!
flyvibe71 1 year ago
Great stuff, best Music Video on YT. Toward the end where the guys are scrambling around for the dollars, it's all $1s. Love this song, love the characters, love the feel.
jamesdewer 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Get Loaded in the Dark hits the Coronet on Easter Thursday April 1st 2010 and is set to be another sell-out event!!
Joining the already confirmed Black Grape, who will play their first Live Show since 1997, will be The Sunshine Underground, Young Fathers, Jakwob and Grum!!
Get your tickets now at ticketWeb or visit getloadedinthedark(dot)com for all news, info, line-ups and much much more!
See you down the front!!
LockNLoadEvents 1 year ago
okay same as OCS I have been in NYC for 10 years havent been keeping up with the brit bands , where did the charltans go this sounds like a bad porno tune why have the brit bands lost there edge ..
TheNessy21 1 year ago
j'adore!!!!
corbax78 2 years ago
blee
Erisblee23 2 years ago
saw them do this in Bingley of all places.........still they rocked as usual
jimvortex 2 years ago
Great song! The first time I heard this I swore it was Gene Loves Jezebel. Was I the only one? They sound alot a like during the opening lyrics.
rog1967 2 years ago
What?
withoutchanclas 1 year ago
meet tim last week, cool guy for sure!
333snottbox333 2 years ago
I love this song!!
ALESSA73 2 years ago
oasis eat your heart out motherfuckers! this is a real band!
shaneshaky1 2 years ago
i heard it from the "jumper" movie too!!!
Christdie4you 2 years ago 13
Great song!!! I've been trying to find out who did this song ever since I saw the Jumper movie.
dmb3808 2 years ago
the sound of this song is sick...the rhythm is just to faking good. First heard it in the movie, "jumper" and went crazy trying to find it....love it!!!
diegontoya1 2 years ago 5
Me Likey this songy
ParaBokGibiHuzurYok 2 years ago
anyone know where i could download this? or does any1 wanna send me it?
allfooie 2 years ago
"Youtube mp3 converter"
....google it!
llNeevall 2 years ago
great song
wonderjohny 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
STFU bitch
coochicoo25 2 years ago
Comment removed
dekyl935 2 years ago
TUNE
shareschannel 2 years ago
you're all bitching about taht woman but chances are if she went away you'd feel the song is incomplete. she makes the song what it is. if you really appreciate the song and listen you can hardly tell she's there.
ArchingRaptor 2 years ago
i like this video
:)
and this song
baileyboo2011 2 years ago
she's fit as fuck that ruby chick
imperialpt2 2 years ago
SHUT UP RUBY!!!
JaySlater907 2 years ago 82
@JaySlater907 but she is so pretty
oscar987753 1 year ago
Comment removed
dekyl935 2 years ago
seriously, what I would give for an instrumental version of this song without that god damn girl talking in the background
scottkane000 2 years ago
lol ano shes annoying as fuck
mckyle9 2 years ago
good song
but that lass really needs to shut up
daniellejxo 2 years ago 3
EDWARD CULLEN!!!!
the dang girl needs to shut her mouth...
KNHMAP22 3 years ago
correction robynsegg: this song was THE ONLY thing good about jumper
jtryx 3 years ago
her life is not that bad WHAT!!!!!!!
she's a prostitute whit a bum for a boyfriend
if that's not that bad then my life rules
robbietherobot01 3 years ago
compared to 99% of the world her life is still better.
zoomskiller 2 years ago
thats true but she can help her self the 99% not so much
robbietherobot01 2 years ago
Good song i wish that i had the powers of the guy in jumper.
mammasboykalo2 3 years ago 5
Awesome song... 1 of the best things about jumper
robynsegg 3 years ago 4
NO RUBY NO!!!
LOL
PsychOMoE88 3 years ago
iRUNWiTHVAMPiRES(teamedward)
i love themmm.
agreed. the girl should stfu lol
onesxychik2010 3 years ago
the girl should shut up
she screws the song!
AllanHP 3 years ago 49
agreed.
Supernonee 3 years ago 3
@AllanHP amen to that
swigglyswiggles 1 year ago
@AllanHP You're right, she shouldn't have been in the video in the first place. She shouldn't have to stick by and help support a moron while her life is at stake. I'd like to hear a few bludgeons to her boyfriend's head. Eh, or your head, whichever sounds more painful and makes you realize the inherent misogyny in this video.
flawedxromancexo 4 months ago
... una song de puta madre... !! ademas la banda tb es recontra brava... como la mayoria d las indie -rock britanicas
anaximandro78 3 years ago
oh great, another white savior video
Josephmgo 3 years ago
haha so true. here comes mr. white sucker or capt. save a hoe
ugotpimp 3 years ago
ich auch:D
rufffy25 3 years ago
habs bei jumper gehört...sehr geil =)
TelegymLady 3 years ago
this is such an awesome song so catchy
hazzaboy11 3 years ago 5
Es la mejor rola del mundo rockero!!!! los acordes, el ritmo, la mezcla, la letra, la voz!!!! definitivamente los ingleses saben hacer musica, I LOVE IT. Blackened Blue Eyes rules!!!
sussienovoa 3 years ago
esta cancion el lo maximo ajajaja!
la escuche en la peli de jumper y me quede hasta el final solo para saber su nombre!!! es asombrosa !!!! de lo mejor!
ferkes15 3 years ago
lo mismo por aca jaja... muuy buena
rodrigozamo 3 years ago
this song rocks and is sooooo melodic awesome!!!
sicktube666 3 years ago 2
Dont forget inspiral carpets and james
who completed the madchester scene..
bohsblur 3 years ago
awsome! =D
F3nNec 3 years ago
The most awesome thing about this video for me (besides the greatness of the song itself) is the fact that I'm a white guy in Asia with an Asian girlfriend named "Ruby" so it feels like this video is about us.
perchorin 3 years ago 2
Know the feeling, I am in San Francisco, same trip.
jamesdewer 1 year ago
Can't get enuff of the lead vocals
dadDONTeatME 3 years ago
This would make a kick-ass theme song for a set of moives like The Bourne Trilogy.
StrikeSquad666 3 years ago
that jumper film uses it during the credits
onetoanother 3 years ago 7
i should a read a little down the page before putting that, oh well top song
onetoanother 3 years ago
I heard this song from the movie jumper...I never heard of this group..it rocks
blondier66 3 years ago
cool Lisa!
Reefercrabness 3 years ago
Yea, same here! I made it a friggin top priority to read those credits as the movie went off. I write down "Charlatans" and raced to the net and download. Such a mellow, chill song, this one.
dadDONTeatME 3 years ago
thats exactly what i did..hahaa
blondier66 3 years ago
The Charlatans (UK), broke through in early nineties helping to form the "then nineties Manchester sound" with other groups like Happy Mondays and Stone Roses. I highly recommend you check out their first album. Great Stuff
xpansion2012 3 years ago 3
in my opinion the 90's was a big comeback from the 80's..... from 2000 onwards got shite again.... lets just hope their will be a big comeback after 2010...
aaronboi07 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
A little over a year ago a little boy called Josh was playing in his room when a raper crashed trought his window and killed him.Today Josh will kill anyone moking this message and if you don't paste comment on 10 other videos in the next 10 minutes Next time you play in your room he will burst trought your window and kill you.
Jessi562572 3 years ago
what's that question supposed to mean, gizzel345?:P we've always been the rulers of the world, hehe.
the song is rly good. i like them vmuch.
AlfredMcLuvian 3 years ago 2
Cool Video-
How come Brits are so up-to-date with music and fashion?
One of my fav's
gizzel345 3 years ago 3
I wouldn't go as far as Alfred McLuvian, but we have the best music scene and are bloody cool. Thats why its good to be English and not Scottish like McLuvian. Hadrians wall was built for a reason.
piespace1 3 years ago
this is song is good and on jumper its even better :)
sparky4244 3 years ago
that guy had an awesome hat
Seidreken 3 years ago
This song is on the movie "Jumper"... :D
PESHybrid 3 years ago
great song m8
slyfoxstealth 3 years ago
Adore this video!--- as sad as it is -- is awesome though~ !
Brandii141 3 years ago
fooking excellent. arent ya glad youtube was invented so you can see good shit like this whenever you want. top of the pops in newcastle last night.
topyoke 3 years ago
My pal said he introduced me to the Charlatans,but he did'nt really he said to me,'Have you heard the Charlatans before'.And I said,I have heard the name of the band but never listended to them,and a few weeks back I listened to them and loved just about every song of theres I have heard.And now my pal thinks he was the one who introduced me to them,just cause he asked me if I had ever heard of them before.PISH.
saintmirrentilIdie 3 years ago
best charlatans song by far!!!!
hussey316 3 years ago
fookin´n hell, what are ya talkin´ bout?? that´s manchester-tunes and nothing compares to that!!oasis, roses, charlatans, verve...best bands of all the time...
oberguess 3 years ago
saltydog1690 - There better than you.
share81 3 years ago
A musical subject I authenticate. You will say that she names has the Eastern girl
alfaro741 3 years ago
good song old chap
MrTurkos 3 years ago 2
Okay Jumper was awsome!.. so don't dis the movie!
rewop1996 3 years ago 3
I luv the charlatans bt they're not a patch on the roses, squire is god.
saltydog1690 3 years ago
Squire is a fud.
brido77 3 years ago
great song
Gilraena 3 years ago
jumper was a good moive and so was the music
beakman10 3 years ago 2
wat r u tlakin about jumper was amazing
burf3r 3 years ago 2
yes, Jumper wasnt a great movie, but it's soundtrack was awesome!
erinhenrici 3 years ago 5
a beautiful girl featured in the video
oscar987753 3 years ago
the charlatans are the pride of manchester! long live tim burgess
martyjburns564 3 years ago
They're not from Manchester. The Charlatans are from Northwich
brido77 3 years ago
i had this song on my last mp3 and just cudnt remem the name... tracked it down tho.... fukin beezer
jamdodge15 4 years ago
same !!!
ukno162 4 years ago
haha same for me
i just waited until the end of the credits cos im sad like that =D
Superdude951 4 years ago 2
haha everyone must love the jumper soundtrack, cause im looking for them too!! haha.
mccheesy27 4 years ago
Yes! I've finally found out who sang the song at the end of Jumper Movie
lookatmeyah 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This is horrible, who the hell sent me this crap?
480vPowerSystem 4 years ago
She's a classy hooker
igotaquestionmark 4 years ago
god..i love them.
so great.
raeschn 4 years ago
went to see them last night @ glasgow abc, absolute class man
hellothere1888 4 years ago
JUST A FUCKIN BETTER BAND MATE!
modsheff1 4 years ago
I know, seriously intense song. Who is the hot chick at the begining?
-also-
Are the Charlatens as popular as "Oasis"?
windsurfingfun 4 years ago
The Charlatans are Quality. Going to see them @the Ritz in Manchester on the 4th November. Cant wait ;-)
CANTONA92 4 years ago 2
What the fuck is that kitchen sink chatting at the beginning.
andrew1983123 4 years ago
great song but how has this had 74,000 views whilst the rest of the charlatans song remain undiscovered on youtube best band going
onetoanother 4 years ago
I think it s because it's a new song (released in 2006) charlatans are an 90's group, not so succeded in world outside UK
kollimatias 4 years ago
for example take a look at Manic street preachers songs on utube. Motorcycle emptiness has liitle views compared to their new "your love alone"
kollimatias 4 years ago
Tim Burgess is fab...another brilliant song
108mantis 4 years ago
Love this band to bits and what made me love them was melody with a swagger this song has neither HATE IT.
KingHotdog 4 years ago
Burgess is cool and all...but...there's no bloody song there. Absolutely MELODY FREE.
soulstylist 4 years ago
I love this song! its da best, my nickname came from this song,'Blackened blue eyes' for all the black eyeliner i wear! Haha! xEmzx
emmatindahouse 4 years ago
AND THERE WONT BE A DRY EYE IN THE HOUSE TONIGHT!!!! what a song!!!!!
Smithysheff 4 years ago
seducing song.
Antarctic1 4 years ago
i love that song is one of my fav.love ganza too...LEGALIZE GANZA .sun+weed=perfect..hellinic ganza.....................mmmm....ruby take a paf!
ketamon 4 years ago
yh i agree m8 who cares its a fucking good song does it realy matter the message its giving out?
keithtrueblue 4 years ago
you can say its just a music video all you want, but you try making a music video, tell me who you cast, naturally you would cast someone that is familiar to you, whatever race you may be.
rogeriu 4 years ago
Like falling in love, its something you cant control, but your statments basically says the (for example) a chinese person should only fall for someone of the same race? We are all human at the end of the day an personally if the girl in the Video was from my country (scotland), and was protection here jamacian boyfriend, it would not even enter my mind that this was racist, it would simply be a white girl who has fallen for a black guy, no more no less
ESPYD 4 years ago
No i don't think people should fall for their own race. I think that people should not choose who they are attracted to based on what media and society says is acceptable.
rogeriu 4 years ago
theres too many poor portrayals of asians in media, i've heard too many racial/stereotypical remarks made of asian men by asian women with no facts or experience. this video shows the social trend of asian women dating only white men for status. In the beginning of the video, the girl says in cantonese "i'm very unhappy with my life, my name is Ruby, i'm that kind of girl" implying that she is a prostitute. Asian women EXCLUSIVELY dating white men in america is a widespread social problem
rogeriu 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
3 words - THICH, CHINK, FUCK
azzy1331 4 years ago
Comment removed
fletch1701 2 years ago
take in consideration that as an artist, the director of the music video had to come up with the concept which includes deciding on what characteristics the each role must portray and in turn what race to portray said characteristics, thus making a statement of the race by picking them specifically over another race. If you think casting in films and music videos is purely chance and blind, then you are sadly mistaken,
rogeriu 4 years ago
and the fact that they bothered to record the character Ruby in Cantonese and overlap it with an English track shows that they want to pin an ethnic identity on her and not just have her be a generic American that just coincidentally Chinese because its "just a music video" I'm not going to say that this is particularly racist towards asians, because I don't think that its so much of a statement of Asians treating their women poorly,
rogeriu 4 years ago
but a statement of asian women running to their white knights (even if they are fallable as the Johnny character in the video was) and having some romantic notion that white people are better, and no i'm not blaming white people, i'm just blaming the asian women who are being racist towards their own culture and not keeping it real by believing in the their dumb fairy tales of being accepted into "white america".
rogeriu 4 years ago
why beg for acceptance and breed yourself out? thats just low in my opinion, in this day and age especially, since the world has become supposedly so much more liberal minded and politically correct, I think that people should learn to be proud of their heritage and not run from it.
rogeriu 4 years ago
How much the Charlatans had a creative control over this video I don't know, maybe they are trying to make a statement themselves, and I would like to believe that they are, as any good musician should if they have the power to spread a message. ultimately everything is open to interpretation but i hope that my thoughts are enlightening to someone
rogeriu 4 years ago
1. Its just a music video 2. Its got fuck all to do with any part of America, the bands British 3. The term Asian is so fucking wrong and it pisses me off there are thousands of people in the Asian continent, Asian does not just mean Oriental or Pakistani or Indian ect. Everyone needs to get a grip and know about every race before they start calling everyone racist because that is what narrow mindedness is!
WlLKO 4 years ago 2
I think you need to learn the roots of the word Oriental because i find that term to be even less accurate than just using "asian" as a blanket statement of race. there are more than thousands of people in asia. the director of the video CHOSE to portray the girl as a girl of hong kong/cantonese heritage living in new york with a caucasian boyfriend appearing to be of italian heritage.
rogeriu 4 years ago
racist - get ta fuck, what a lot of PC pish some people spout!!!
ESPYD 4 years ago
u'z fucking doint even get it ,it's about one of tim,s family
dezaufc 4 years ago
For Cool T-Shirts & Hoodies click on my name and you can find the address on my page, alternatively click on any of my vids and you'll find it there too.
Modpimp 4 years ago
...not just "very cliched" I specifically meant to say that it's not very well thought out, and too similar to entertainment from the past that were definitely racist. As if it's trying to keep some sort of meme alive.
PebblesMintstone 4 years ago
It's not deliberately racist but it brings to mind a lot of stereotypes used in movies and shows from the past.
There are the asian males portrayed as a corrupt triad members bullying their women, asian women shown being oppressed by old-fashioned chauvinistic asian males, and then we have the white man standing as a symbol of freedom, liberating the woman from her oppressors.
Again, probably not the intentions of the director(s), but at the same time very cliched.
PebblesMintstone 4 years ago
The Charly's rule. Enough said.
everlasting123 4 years ago
i never thought there was racist implication in the video. Nontheless, this video just sucks. It's painfully bad, and I really cannot watch it. I see they (or just the record company) were trying so hard to change the band's image or push them in the middle of the trendy American music scene. This is not really the charlatans that I always love. They need a different record label or at least completely different idea for their marketing.
pageone99 5 years ago
The ppl who say its racist are just reading far too much into the video. The fact that you automatically assume that the because the women is of an ethnic minority that ppl are try to stereotype that group is narrowed minded of you. Can you not just accept that it is really just a musi video and not racially motivated?
ajhrules 5 years ago