@gilmourguitar123 Yes. The three Floyd albums that preceded this one. This is most certainly the worst thing they have ever done. The production is shoddy, and the compositions themselves are the epitome of beating around the bush. The music is generally unexciting.
It's there to prevent people, especially the fakes and phonies who infest the world who pretend to be your allies and friends so they can leech off of you, from getting close.
Does anybody else notice that at the very end of this song, a man, or "Pink", says "Isn't this where", and at the beginning of the album, "In the Flesh", Pink says "Where we came in?", making the story of Pink's life come full circle, showing that after completing the wall around his life, the only way was to tear it down? Ya, blew my fucking mind too..
Ahh thank you so much for that! It used to bug me when I was younger that I could hear him say that at the end and never understood why. I hadn't noticed the bit at the beginning of 'In the Flesh'. It's like you've just added a whole new perspective to the album. :).
@Fenixchan "isn't this where" is what he says since it's the last song on the album, and on the first song he says "we came in" so if you listen to it on a loop he says "isn't this where we came in?" as it transitions back to the begining.
2012?? somebody tells that its the end of the world but i'm so confuse that why some food are expired in 2013..:)) mean 2012 its not the end of the world
The whole album just shows how depressing life can be. And how it all goes round in a circle, like a loop, just like the album. The first track In The Flesh starts with 'We came in?' and the last track, this song, ends with 'Is this where?' Even though he's 'outside the wall' he's not really, because it's just one continuous vicious circle, and before you know it's you're back in the wall. I could have worded that better but I cba
@mollehhhx Or, the album loops because it was meant to be told over and over again. Pink isn't the most reliable narrator ever, so he may be telling us a story through the album, not a biopic inside his head. Noone really knows what The Wall's actually about.
@Ninja1Ninja2 or, it IS actually supposed to be depressing, and is about the fact that someday, someone is going to pick up the pieces and rebuild the wall. Not that its a bad album, of course not. But Waters admits that it is about the torture of his life.
@Ninja1Ninja2 hmmmmmm. i may be diluted a bit, but i see the message clearly. how old are you? abandonment, belittlement, betrayal, solitude, and painful self reflection of one's own failings coming to a head during a moment of deep thought. call it a wall, a bubble, a steep cliff, what have you. we all can form our own barriers that inevitably will come crashing down.
this is a higher being speeking through roger waters letting us know how it will be walking up on the other side of 2013. the hole album speaks of this, disk 1 before dec, 21st 2012 and disk 2 walking after. radiohead, ok computer is very similar, a higher being delivering a message. ex. exit music for a film
@roadykev420 truly gone fishing, have we? self induced human demise may be coming, but no one will ever know the date until it has already happened. and what about the album's contrast?
Anyone who's experienced emotional unavailability (or been a victim of it) can identify with this song. Those who really love you can't because you're unable to let them in. And so, your loved ones suffer. I'd like to give Roger Waters a big hug for this one, because it fucking sucks being in such a state.
they say this because pink is now back to where he was before he trapped himself in the wall.when his dad died mom was over pertective and had terrible teachers
At the very end of the song you can barely hear "Isn't this where-" with an odd cut off.
And on the first song of the album, "In the Flesh?" the melody continues and it begins with (or should I say continues with) "-we began?" So it loops on over.
If you listen closely(or look at the lyrics in the description), at the end of the song, he says "Isn't this where--" And at the beginning of "In The Flesh?"(Track 1), he says "We Came In".
So It's like they're going back into the wall and doing it all again. Its a neverending loop.
@789TheBeatles Amazing, ...we came in? i've heard the Wall 1000 times and i never made that connection before, Roger Waters is certainly the master of madness and that one detail just added another deep layer of depth to already deep album.... i was convinced for 20 years that Pink forgave his mother and accepted his madness by forgiving himself, but since it's a vicious cycle, i know he'll have to do over and over again.... poor Pink, good luck my friend! Isn't this where.....
I downloaded The Wall and I burned it on two CD's... I listened to them in my bedroom. It was awesome... until I listened to the last track, the last second: I was like: "WHAT THE FUCK? I'VE LOST TWO CDS ON THIS CRAPPY VERSION!" because I thought someone had cut the end :P
@jcast18k I just heard this album for the first time yesterday and thought the same thing! I also remember, when listening to "Abbey Road" for the first time, that "I Want You (She's So Heavy)" had the same thing where it cuts off suddenly. I was very confused.
@supermd4589 Yes!!! and Dream Theater song "Pull Me Under". Anyway those albums (The Wall, The Dark Side Of The Moon, Abbey Road, Sgt. Peppers, Tommy, The Snow Goose, etc) must be correctly ripped because a lot of songs are linked with the next song. If there is a little silence between them it sucks :P
Sorry for my bad english... Im from Argentina and Im 15 ^^
This is my favorite song on the Album, simply because once the song ends, I have to restart the CD so that I can continue where the thing left off. Isn't this Where... *replays from begining* We came in?
epic, Pink Floyd, simply Epic. You people are the Gods of Music!
Pink Floyd are the real deal. I mean bands come and bands go but few can touch your soul like they did. This album is pure creation of genius combined with raw honesty...I cannot describe what it really is, but it's one of the best albums of all time, that's for sure.
@pintozazz Yes, their cyclical, the album just repeats.
Like at the end of Atom Heart Mother on the vinyl record, if you leave the record on, the dripping noise at the end keeps repeating, cause the grooves stretch to the very edge of the vinyl, so it just skips.
I think that the person who destroy Pink it was is ex wife, because after all he was trying to take her back and she...destroys the last pieces of his heart and mind, besides his mom...and the other reasons.
@Lazydog64 I agree. If Pink just got over the fact that his mom is overprotective, his schoolteacher was a dick, and his dad died in World War II, he probably would've turned out for the better; if he just accepted those events as what they were, instead of obsessing over them and letting them bother him, he probably would have no wall. Or, even if he just talked about it with someone, it would've helped. So, technically, he is to blame for his own insanity,
Such a great song. Just like all of Roger waters songs there's great lyricism but this one really stands out!! For me it took a while to really understand though.
"the one's who really love you walk up and down outside the wall" is the most crucial line to understanding this song because it says that the people who love you are'nt the friends that pink envisioned in his dreams of being a fascist dictator but the one's who recognized his insanity and stayed outside the wall. you dont look at this song from pinks perspective but from societal view in general
I hope you understand what i just said, i know its a hand full
"The one's who really love you walk up and down outside the wall" is crucial to understanding the song. Because its saying one's friends arent your drinking buddies but the one's who got your back and won't do crazy shit with you" The people who really love you are the people who try to break down your wall and reconnect with you. I hope that helps i wrote this rather quickly. :)
You are so right Eric. See, i had those drinking buddies you say, in a dark age when i did alcohol and drugs. One night I overdosed and almost died. Those drinking buddies suddenly dissapeared. My real, long time friends however gave me all their support and love to get out of that hell hole my life was. Every time I hear this song I remember about that. What a great band.
maybe its an exposure of all the things can can tear the body down (war, official institutions such as education, whatever his overprotective mother may symbolize)
A year ago, I listened to this song and I had no clue what it meant. And now, I know because I can relate... my best friend has built a wall around herself... she occasionally becomes emotionless and indifferent, and that's when I feel truly lonely. :'( I wish her happiness in the future, so that she can "get better".
At the beginning of the record it says "we came in?".... put the end with the beginning and it says, "Isn't this where we came in?". The same music from this song is also heard at the beginning of the record.
yes it does. it's because In the Flesh? says "we came in?" at the very beginning. if you loop the album, putting "In the Flesh?" after this, you hear "isn't this where we came in?" signifying that the album is kind of a repeating cycle.
when you really think about it, there is no end to the wall untill someone says stop. The next track on the album is ours, we decide our fate and the heigth of the wall we create. Heck, mabey we can choose not to build any walls at all.
It's hard listening to singles in this album. All of the songs are way better when you listen to them all in a row, like they were meant to be listened to.
whew....i thought i had bought a bad cd becuase it got cut off at the end, but then i realized its just the song...does anybody know why it gets cut off?
@doktorsteiner at the very beginning of the album, you hear a queit voice say "isn't this where" then at the end, you hear the voice "we came in". The album loops with that phrase - "isn't this where we came in?" there is a reference to this in the song Octavarium by Dream Theater lol both of those bands like to do clever things in their albums
@5lilmonkeys5 I thought it was to signify that once one wall is torn down, another will be built by another individual. Its all like a cycle. Well anyway, I love this epilogue so much, its so hopeful.
@TheMasterOfPuppets44 I've always thought so too. Think of it; If a certain failed Austrian artist, crushed by the death of his mother, builds a wall and becomes an all-powerful genocidal dictator, the deaths he'll cause
the wall is neutral, is how you think of what matters
xenoghost1 8 months ago
@gilmourguitar123 Yes. The three Floyd albums that preceded this one. This is most certainly the worst thing they have ever done. The production is shoddy, and the compositions themselves are the epitome of beating around the bush. The music is generally unexciting.
xxKYLExGxx 8 months ago
Isn't This Were....
Halodude889 8 months ago
@Halodude889 ...All Started?
Ze0do0Gas 8 months ago
@Ze0do0Gas Very Nice :P
Halodude889 8 months ago
@Halodude889 Thank you:) That's the only way I think the sentence makes sense, at least to me.
Ze0do0Gas 8 months ago
It's just beautiful. We could all learn a lot from Pink Floyd, and perhaps think about tearing down our own walls before it's too late.
regreegg 9 months ago
@regreegg What? Tear down the wall? Are you mad?!
It's there to prevent people, especially the fakes and phonies who infest the world who pretend to be your allies and friends so they can leech off of you, from getting close.
The wall is good.
MaximillianZakes 8 months ago
this song gives me goosebumps
OmegaStalked 9 months ago
Does anybody else notice that at the very end of this song, a man, or "Pink", says "Isn't this where", and at the beginning of the album, "In the Flesh", Pink says "Where we came in?", making the story of Pink's life come full circle, showing that after completing the wall around his life, the only way was to tear it down? Ya, blew my fucking mind too..
nightmeer6 10 months ago 4
@nightmeer6
Ahh thank you so much for that! It used to bug me when I was younger that I could hear him say that at the end and never understood why. I hadn't noticed the bit at the beginning of 'In the Flesh'. It's like you've just added a whole new perspective to the album. :).
MrGenericgirl 9 months ago
Best album of all time? I think so.
RoasterBlack 10 months ago
How did Waters write such an epic album essentially by himself? :O
EyeHawk777 10 months ago
@EyeHawk777
Because he's a hell of a talented bastard? :)
GhibliFan1 10 months ago
@GhibliFan1
you could so that i suppose? x
EyeHawk777 10 months ago
Cheers for uploading this work, KMRakaKAT
carlrothwell 10 months ago
I STARTED WITH THIS SONG AND THEN WATCHED ALL THE 26 SONGS IN THIS CHANNEL
thumbs up if u did that too and felt that something has died and another thing has born in you
tiger7234 10 months ago 18
@ivar14 Maybe an accident
lorax121323 10 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Most. Overrated. Album. Ever.
xxKYLExGxx 10 months ago
@xxKYLExGxx i will cut you
themightygreenman 10 months ago
@xxKYLExGxx you got it wrong, you meant underrated. even though it's one of the best.
devilzadvokit13 10 months ago
How the eff, can anybody make thumbs down on this?
ivar14 10 months ago
whenever i get fed up with excessive stupidity in the internet, I come here <3
Vasoslaihiala 10 months ago
it took me a couple of listens to the entire album AND watching the film to think that I totally understand the lyrics
SWarProductions 10 months ago 4
At least Pink Floyd trys to warn us...
SuperiorSwagon1 10 months ago
And when they've given you their all, some stagger and fall, after all its not easy banging your heart against some mad bugger's wall
Lpz0rds 11 months ago
"The bleeding hearts and artists make their stand."
DaddomanITA 11 months ago
What did he say at the last half second of the song?
Fenixchan 11 months ago
@Fenixchan "isn't this where" is what he says since it's the last song on the album, and on the first song he says "we came in" so if you listen to it on a loop he says "isn't this where we came in?" as it transitions back to the begining.
CorwinOfAvelon 11 months ago
This song brought me to tears. I'm not kidding and it was in the middle of my math class
aledandrian 11 months ago
I hope someday I can be Half as good as pink floyd. But If I where half of what I hope I would be I would more than half satisfied.
TheDanielRagsdale 1 year ago
Isn't this where...we came in?
undeadelite 1 year ago 4
My album doesn't have this song on it :(
bearwithgun14 1 year ago
good song, but this album isn't there best
DiegoDyaz 1 year ago
EVOLUTION 2012!!!!!! look it up..
bub2u3 1 year ago
THE BEST!!!!!!!!!!
bub2u3 1 year ago
2012?? somebody tells that its the end of the world but i'm so confuse that why some food are expired in 2013..:)))
thectrlfn 1 year ago
I dont see why ppl are so worked up about 2012. Its end of the world as we KNOW it. doesnt mean its THE end.
PearlJammer1000 1 year ago
2012?? somebody tells that its the end of the world but i'm so confuse that why some food are expired in 2013..:)) mean 2012 its not the end of the world
thectrlfn 1 year ago
Comment removed
blazefire2 1 year ago
@thectrlfn
Along with termites, canned food also survives apocalypses.
blazefire2 1 year ago
@thectrlfn not end of the world jus a shift in a higher lvl of consiousness is all :) a.k.a EVOLUTION
bub2u3 1 year ago
@SolidLittle
I see you are still trapped inside the wall, all boxed into your square head!!
roadykev420 1 year ago
The whole album just shows how depressing life can be. And how it all goes round in a circle, like a loop, just like the album. The first track In The Flesh starts with 'We came in?' and the last track, this song, ends with 'Is this where?' Even though he's 'outside the wall' he's not really, because it's just one continuous vicious circle, and before you know it's you're back in the wall. I could have worded that better but I cba
mollehhhx 1 year ago
@mollehhhx Or, the album loops because it was meant to be told over and over again. Pink isn't the most reliable narrator ever, so he may be telling us a story through the album, not a biopic inside his head. Noone really knows what The Wall's actually about.
Ninja1Ninja2 1 year ago
@Ninja1Ninja2 or, it IS actually supposed to be depressing, and is about the fact that someday, someone is going to pick up the pieces and rebuild the wall. Not that its a bad album, of course not. But Waters admits that it is about the torture of his life.
ViewBattle 1 year ago
@ViewBattle I see now. It's a good album, and one of the best of all time.
Ninja1Ninja2 1 year ago
@Ninja1Ninja2 hmmmmmm. i may be diluted a bit, but i see the message clearly. how old are you? abandonment, belittlement, betrayal, solitude, and painful self reflection of one's own failings coming to a head during a moment of deep thought. call it a wall, a bubble, a steep cliff, what have you. we all can form our own barriers that inevitably will come crashing down.
pectinmania 1 year ago
"Isn't this where we came in?"
J14ngL00 1 year ago
this is a higher being speeking through roger waters letting us know how it will be walking up on the other side of 2013. the hole album speaks of this, disk 1 before dec, 21st 2012 and disk 2 walking after. radiohead, ok computer is very similar, a higher being delivering a message. ex. exit music for a film
roadykev420 1 year ago
@roadykev420 Oh shut the fuck up, go take your bullshit somewhere else. People like you fill me with the urge to defecate.
SolidLittle 1 year ago 3
@roadykev420 what the fuck?
IAMOCKWORD 1 year ago
@roadykev420 truly gone fishing, have we? self induced human demise may be coming, but no one will ever know the date until it has already happened. and what about the album's contrast?
pectinmania 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Roger Waters Was like the choco Cake and David Gilmour was the Cream sweets and sparkles.. and you can go on and on with that thinking
slubert 1 year ago
good song
4wowmaster 1 year ago
im i the only one who finds the movie version of this album extremely better?
Murrtalica 1 year ago 6
Anyone who's experienced emotional unavailability (or been a victim of it) can identify with this song. Those who really love you can't because you're unable to let them in. And so, your loved ones suffer. I'd like to give Roger Waters a big hug for this one, because it fucking sucks being in such a state.
HanginWithSnakes 1 year ago 38
@HanginWithSnakes No-one ever learned anything from Tik Tok, though, did they?
CrapTurret94 8 months ago
My spine shivers when i get to this song after listening to the wall.
bimmer1919 1 year ago
Can someone tell me this =o
Why does the end of this fit so perfectly with the beginning of the very first song on the album?
hookshotagain 1 year ago
@hookshotagain Of the theme of the album is the vicious cycle.
AmonDevilman 1 year ago
they say this because pink is now back to where he was before he trapped himself in the wall.when his dad died mom was over pertective and had terrible teachers
soccergage23 1 year ago
2 persons are heartless.
mexicangoregrinder 1 year ago
At the very end of the song you can barely hear "Isn't this where-" with an odd cut off.
And on the first song of the album, "In the Flesh?" the melody continues and it begins with (or should I say continues with) "-we began?" So it loops on over.
Fantastic album.
LordyJake 1 year ago 3
@LordyJake wow you are totally right!! I never realise it... They probably reccorded this song before ''In The Flesh?''
Nad yeah... Fantastic Album!
LeTiProQuebecois 1 year ago
If you listen closely(or look at the lyrics in the description), at the end of the song, he says "Isn't this where--" And at the beginning of "In The Flesh?"(Track 1), he says "We Came In".
So It's like they're going back into the wall and doing it all again. Its a neverending loop.
Pink Floyd is just awesome.
789TheBeatles 1 year ago
@789TheBeatles Amazing, ...we came in? i've heard the Wall 1000 times and i never made that connection before, Roger Waters is certainly the master of madness and that one detail just added another deep layer of depth to already deep album.... i was convinced for 20 years that Pink forgave his mother and accepted his madness by forgiving himself, but since it's a vicious cycle, i know he'll have to do over and over again.... poor Pink, good luck my friend! Isn't this where.....
bimmer1919 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
BEST. ALBUM. EVER.
the47monkeys 1 year ago
I downloaded The Wall and I burned it on two CD's... I listened to them in my bedroom. It was awesome... until I listened to the last track, the last second: I was like: "WHAT THE FUCK? I'VE LOST TWO CDS ON THIS CRAPPY VERSION!" because I thought someone had cut the end :P
jcast18k 1 year ago
@jcast18k I just heard this album for the first time yesterday and thought the same thing! I also remember, when listening to "Abbey Road" for the first time, that "I Want You (She's So Heavy)" had the same thing where it cuts off suddenly. I was very confused.
supermd4589 1 year ago
@supermd4589 Yes!!! and Dream Theater song "Pull Me Under". Anyway those albums (The Wall, The Dark Side Of The Moon, Abbey Road, Sgt. Peppers, Tommy, The Snow Goose, etc) must be correctly ripped because a lot of songs are linked with the next song. If there is a little silence between them it sucks :P
Sorry for my bad english... Im from Argentina and Im 15 ^^
jcast18k 1 year ago
I feel this last song of the album like very sad,I mean,like if somebody was being buried,and it makes me cry.
kalispera64 1 year ago
Anyone here count how many times they said "babe"?
But any way, amazing.
DaKilla27 1 year ago
@DaKilla27 haha i was thinking the same thing
kjkj1002002 1 year ago
at the end of this song on the album listen close they say something . but idk what?
warpigs777 1 year ago
@warpigs777 they say "Isn't this where."
Listen closely to the beginning of In the Flesh? also.
xcheesyxbaconx 1 year ago
"The bleeding hearts and the artists
Make their stand" haha that's us
santiagodebellavista 1 year ago
Comment removed
santiagodebellavista 1 year ago
The Wall will always define who we are inside, we all have a wall we build to block out all of the shit and for some of us it finally breaks!
chrispycritter2 1 year ago
easily the best lyrics on the entire album in my opinion
joshbbglover 1 year ago
This is my favorite song on the Album, simply because once the song ends, I have to restart the CD so that I can continue where the thing left off. Isn't this Where... *replays from begining* We came in?
epic, Pink Floyd, simply Epic. You people are the Gods of Music!
imperfectmaster 1 year ago 6
whole THE WALL is one sad true but beutifull story..
Delorean997 1 year ago 2
whole THE WALL is one true sad story..
Delorean997 1 year ago
i just got done listening to the whole album...this was my last song..... i LOVE
omegazeta112196 1 year ago
i have listened to every song in this album in the last two hours! XD
MetalDrummer776 1 year ago
really hard to hear this song
orboknown 1 year ago 2
i think i'm getting this tattooed somewhere on my body.
serenityMMM 1 year ago 3
Pink Floyd are the real deal. I mean bands come and bands go but few can touch your soul like they did. This album is pure creation of genius combined with raw honesty...I cannot describe what it really is, but it's one of the best albums of all time, that's for sure.
clapphamjunction 1 year ago 4
In the Flesh? Begining: Isnt this where.....
End of this: We Came In?
unkwonstudios 1 year ago
@unkwonstudios oh my god that just blew my mind. fucking genius.
snappopsnap 1 year ago
@unkwonstudios -- You've got it backwards.
iamthebyron 1 year ago
2 people can't break free
Silverstrike021 1 year ago
the wall live by Roger Waters en septiembre 15
jorgealbertobaron2 1 year ago
@jorgealbertobaron2 see you in Toronto too :D
BlackFuryFx 1 year ago
This album changed my life, particularly this song.
Cheezburger2012 1 year ago 29
@Cheezburger2012really how cause i still have a wall
fab462 1 year ago
Albums that sound like a long ass song are the best. and this and Dark Side in the list of the greatest albums of all time
thefatpiggytail 1 year ago 4
The end of the last song and the begging of the first song. listen to them.
pintozazz 1 year ago
@pintozazz Yes, their cyclical, the album just repeats.
Like at the end of Atom Heart Mother on the vinyl record, if you leave the record on, the dripping noise at the end keeps repeating, cause the grooves stretch to the very edge of the vinyl, so it just skips.
gorillazhead 1 year ago
listening to this album makes me feel complete
zepdude13 1 year ago 2
this song plays into the first song on the first disk, i just noticed.
MrFlamerTamer 1 year ago
@MrFlamerTamer I noticed that too.
skullcrusher301 1 year ago
Reminds me of the holocaust, when they all get set free.
MrFlamerTamer 1 year ago
I know Syd barrett wasnt with Floyd when they made the wall, but since its partly about him, i'd just like to say that Syd was very hott :)
businesschic24 1 year ago
Bliss
spootboy123 1 year ago
isn't this where.......
tmprogram 1 year ago 5
BEST. ALBUM. EVER.
LunarIntellect 1 year ago 61
I think that the person who destroy Pink it was is ex wife, because after all he was trying to take her back and she...destroys the last pieces of his heart and mind, besides his mom...and the other reasons.
Anyway the whole album it is exquisite.
NEMEPOLYNHA 1 year ago
This has to be the best song off of the whole album because it is so insanely true.
judasantichrist1515 1 year ago 47
amazing
jacoblight7 10 months ago
All in all ????????
deansusky 1 year ago
this album always make me cry
shaharbin25 1 year ago
great song.looks like these commenters need to get married, though. blaaaaah blah blah
trilobite3339 1 year ago
@Lazydog64 I agree. If Pink just got over the fact that his mom is overprotective, his schoolteacher was a dick, and his dad died in World War II, he probably would've turned out for the better; if he just accepted those events as what they were, instead of obsessing over them and letting them bother him, he probably would have no wall. Or, even if he just talked about it with someone, it would've helped. So, technically, he is to blame for his own insanity,
Alnoshic 1 year ago
Banging your heart against some mad buggers
Wall
punk1rock2 1 year ago 2
Such a great song. Just like all of Roger waters songs there's great lyricism but this one really stands out!! For me it took a while to really understand though.
eric111999 2 years ago
what was your understanding of the song im curious to know because i have my own opinion and its always cool to compare opinions
xXBullets69Xx 2 years ago
"the one's who really love you walk up and down outside the wall" is the most crucial line to understanding this song because it says that the people who love you are'nt the friends that pink envisioned in his dreams of being a fascist dictator but the one's who recognized his insanity and stayed outside the wall. you dont look at this song from pinks perspective but from societal view in general
I hope you understand what i just said, i know its a hand full
eric111999 2 years ago
the song is not from pinks perspective.
"The one's who really love you walk up and down outside the wall" is crucial to understanding the song. Because its saying one's friends arent your drinking buddies but the one's who got your back and won't do crazy shit with you" The people who really love you are the people who try to break down your wall and reconnect with you. I hope that helps i wrote this rather quickly. :)
eric111999 2 years ago
You are so right Eric. See, i had those drinking buddies you say, in a dark age when i did alcohol and drugs. One night I overdosed and almost died. Those drinking buddies suddenly dissapeared. My real, long time friends however gave me all their support and love to get out of that hell hole my life was. Every time I hear this song I remember about that. What a great band.
Samael66618 1 year ago 3
Thank you for the 26 videos.
I was able to download all these song son my mp3 player because of you! Thanks!
=D
IamPersonMan 2 years ago
My bad. In "In the Flesh," he says "Where we came in?" so instead he says "Isn't this where we came in?"
businesschic24 2 years ago
Yes, the two songs run into eachother.
thatguyoverthere12 2 years ago
I love this song because at the very end you here someone say, "Isn't this where-"
And then at the beginning of the album in "In the Flesh," you here someone say, "We left off?"
So if you put it on repeat then it'll say "isn't this where we left off?"
so that's just how genius pink floyd is.
businesschic24 2 years ago
@moguri64
maybe its an exposure of all the things can can tear the body down (war, official institutions such as education, whatever his overprotective mother may symbolize)
knoxrox167 2 years ago
Sorry, it is last song according to description.
Snakemast345 2 years ago
Last track or not?
Snakemast345 2 years ago
omg this song is so sad but I want it to last forever why did it have to end at 1:44 ?
BEL79NUN 2 years ago
someone know the name of the song where a men says "craaaazy, im craaaaaaazy", that is a part of that song
execatl9 2 years ago
@ execatl9 The song is called "The Trial".
Dirtjocky12 2 years ago
"Crazy, over the rainbow, I am crazy."
Is that right?
If it is, it's called "The Trial" by Pink Floyd, and it's a great song:)
It's the song that comes right before Outside The Wall.
NicoleTangerine 2 years ago
thanks, i have the song since 1 week ago because my dad told me the name of the song, but thanks.
execatl9 2 years ago
The song makes me want to cry, almost.
MissCartoonist 2 years ago 7
makes me cry too.
jonfender123 2 years ago 5
same here...
nbomb1204 2 years ago 2
A year ago, I listened to this song and I had no clue what it meant. And now, I know because I can relate... my best friend has built a wall around herself... she occasionally becomes emotionless and indifferent, and that's when I feel truly lonely. :'( I wish her happiness in the future, so that she can "get better".
MissCartoonist 2 years ago 5
in my album it doesn't say "isn't this where" in the end
i think. does anybody know why it's there?
1988wonderwoman 2 years ago
At the beginning of the record it says "we came in?".... put the end with the beginning and it says, "Isn't this where we came in?". The same music from this song is also heard at the beginning of the record.
mrowepat 2 years ago
yes thank you, i checked it and you're right!
PINK FLOYD FOREVER!!
1988wonderwoman 2 years ago 3
yes it does. it's because In the Flesh? says "we came in?" at the very beginning. if you loop the album, putting "In the Flesh?" after this, you hear "isn't this where we came in?" signifying that the album is kind of a repeating cycle.
mysticat614 2 years ago
It loops, at the beginning of most copys of In the Flesh? say "Where we came in"
stude444 2 years ago 2
Man, this album is so awesome I could get Brain Damage from it. XD.
NtropyPyroductions 2 years ago 4
its not an end dude. chill.
daniloh91 2 years ago
Comment removed
boomer4666 2 years ago
after all it's not easy banging your heart against some mad bugger's wall
kikkakia 2 years ago 2
when you really think about it, there is no end to the wall untill someone says stop. The next track on the album is ours, we decide our fate and the heigth of the wall we create. Heck, mabey we can choose not to build any walls at all.
themetalman3 2 years ago 3
I've listened to The album about 7 or 8 times all the way through in the past 4 Days. It is a masterpiece!
archfat 2 years ago 2
@archfat me too..
TrondheimEastSide 2 years ago
omg me tooo! I am on a floyd kick like no other and THIS ALBUM!
cherryantacid421 2 years ago
The entire album loops around. That's hard to follow, even if you have the cd's.
daltonh4 2 years ago
It's hard listening to singles in this album. All of the songs are way better when you listen to them all in a row, like they were meant to be listened to.
xcheesyxbaconx 2 years ago 89
@xcheesyxbaconx difficult ? you're being generous. For who is a fan and knows the work, it is IMPOSSIBLE to listen to The Wall pieces.
matmagu 1 year ago
@xcheesyxbaconx i especially and particularly wanted to hear this closer..but yeah, cuz you say so...therefore it must be so...
codern 1 year ago
@xcheesyxbaconx they are in perfect succession as far as continuity goes..~.~
vaibhav1803 1 year ago
whew....i thought i had bought a bad cd becuase it got cut off at the end, but then i realized its just the song...does anybody know why it gets cut off?
patsfan4life26 2 years ago
At the end of this song "outside the wall," there's a faint quick vocal that says "isn't this"
if you go back to the first song on the album "In The Flesh?" within the first two seconds, it quickly says, "where we came in?"
put these two back to back, and you get "isn't this where we came in?"
this represent a cycle of the main character, pink's life
codarkstarxx13 2 years ago 16
ahhh......thats pure genuis....along with everyhing else of pink floyd
patsfan4life26 2 years ago 3
yes indeed it is.
and sorry i got it wrong.
it's actually "isn't this where"
and then "we cam in?"
codarkstarxx13 2 years ago 2
if you have headphones it plays from the left to right of you :)
1nubby1 2 years ago
That;s the end of that wall
Now flip the record over and build a new one
tamburich 2 years ago 3
This song has a lot of meaning to it.
Lordofthepastries 2 years ago
This is the second time I've listened to the album all the way through at once. It gets better every time
pestopalooza 2 years ago 6
the final song of a great.... GREAT! album of an epic band on all history...(Y) PINK FLOYD!! \,,/
romzeppelin 2 years ago
Isn't this where?
evilfetus 2 years ago 11
....we came in??
doktorsteiner 2 years ago 75
@doktorsteiner Lol, I like how the album's cyclical.
"Isn't this where...
...we came in?"
gorillazhead 1 year ago 5
@doktorsteiner Isn't this where...
BaBYPuNCheR133 1 year ago 2
@doktorsteiner at the very beginning of the album, you hear a queit voice say "isn't this where" then at the end, you hear the voice "we came in". The album loops with that phrase - "isn't this where we came in?" there is a reference to this in the song Octavarium by Dream Theater lol both of those bands like to do clever things in their albums
5lilmonkeys5 1 year ago
@5lilmonkeys5 You mean at the end of the album a voice says "Isn't this where" and at the beginning you hear "we came in?"
Jaffell 1 year ago
@5lilmonkeys5 I thought it was to signify that once one wall is torn down, another will be built by another individual. Its all like a cycle. Well anyway, I love this epilogue so much, its so hopeful.
TheMasterOfPuppets44 1 year ago
@TheMasterOfPuppets44 I've always thought so too. Think of it; If a certain failed Austrian artist, crushed by the death of his mother, builds a wall and becomes an all-powerful genocidal dictator, the deaths he'll cause