Added: 1 year ago
From: leonie1310
Views: 193,178
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (180)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Its jst so cool that it is another track from Prince...

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Am I the only who prefers this version? Sinead can't really sing this from her soul if she didn't even write it. Plus, you might say I'm crazy... but Sinead can't actually sing. I know this because my dad has a friend who produced for her, and they had to put auto-tune on her voice for the song and her performances!

  • I've seen sinead 5 times in concert and she has the VOICE OF AN ANGEL.....I think your dad was talking total bull...The proof of the pudding is in live performance and she sounds BETTER live than on record..so what you going to say about that?????? BTW Im a big Prince fan..

  • @honestguy77 Well believe what you want to. The producer told me for sure that Sinead's voice even was altered on stage. You don't have to be so rude, I was just telling the truth. I know that someone would be ignorant and disagree with me. But I stick to my word. That's fine you're a Prince fan... but unfortunately even people that are supposedly good, aren't. Sorry.

  • @WC95Productions Me being Rude..How do you work that out? You are the one posting bullshit on the WEB...Sinead performed live on the Graham Norton show tonight and she was amazing..I have no problem with critism if its warranted but to say Sinead O connor cannot sing is just plain WRONG...FACT...As I said before if you bothered to read my post was that I saw her sing LIVE..She stormed it everytime..I'd rather take factual evidence over the word of a backstreet producer any day.

  • @honestguy77 Jeez, I should have known someone was going to have a go at me. You saying that I'm talking bullshit is your opinion. And I'm not the only one who would say that she can't sing. It's not a fact, it's opinion. I know you said she sang live, but she even gets auto-tuned LIVE. Like I said, believe what you wanna believe. I don't expect you to take my word for it. I'm not saying Sinead can't sing at all, she just can't sing incredibly well that's all.

  • fuck this is SO GOOD!!!!!! makes me cry

  • this is the way this song should really sound, by the master. sinead did it a little justice.

  • amazing . thanks a lot for sharing.

  • This guy sure can sing. This version rocks my world!

  • Comment removed

  • I like both the same good music is good music:-)

    

  • Looove my purple man! ;)

  • are people seriously trying to say sinead o connor has no emotion? LOL!

  • He wrote the song but it was meant to be sang how Sinead O' Connor sang it! It's probably the only song in history that a cover is better than the original.

  • QUEEEEE SUPER ROLAAA!!!

  • This is my favorite version hands down :)

  • Prince, please promise you won't do that again!

  • and may i add to this typically intelligent youtube conversation "blah blah blah woof woof woof bark poop hah hah etc..."

  • I'm sorry but Prince is the best. Sinead has a good voice and she did justice to this song, but nothing compares to Prince.

  • @emoprincess523

    So Trueee! I Love this version!

  • Prince and Sinead have an overwhelming talent, nobody can deny that, just enjoy both! in this song i like more Sinead version, it's only a matter of taste

  • Prince is only ONE !

  • Sinead will always own this song...period.

  • This destroys Sinead's version. The original and best.

  • Sinead made this song "hers"!

  • i actually find the re-harmonization of sinead a lot better then this one, this sound almost like muzak to me, elevator music, and lack emotion at all, im not a prince fan, iv never got how this pretentious little man was consider a genius,and i know music, he is arrogant and a jackson wanna be. go hear Kevin smith talk about is experience dealing with this mormons, (that says a lot about somoene when you belleive joseph smith was actual prohete, and your waiting for jesus to come back in utha)

  • @lapmarty What the fuck are you talking about?! lol First of all, I really have no idea what the hell you just said! You grammar matches that of a fruit fly. You somehow went from calling Prince a "pretentious little man" to Mormon's waiting for jesus in .. Utha?.... The man IS a genius! He was able to play 7 instruments by age 13... And he played them WELL!!! You sir, are an idiot!

  • @Charles87sf im french, you may critic my grammar i dont give a shit, maybe when you can writte in french as good as i do, in english you can talk about my grammar,

    as for my opinion, well, this is youtube you dont have to share it, A genius, is a term now that is highly overated, beethoven mozart, oscar peterson, keith jarret, mayne other are genius, but i can assure you, any serious musician, dont look at this man as a genius, more like a brainwashed mormon idiot, that act like a diva

  • @Charles87sf but you have your right to fin him to be a genius, by the way being a asshole isnt excuse by having peoples calling you a genius,

    this man have his head so big, he cant leave is mormon home, where he waits for jesus to come back,

  • It is clear that Prince got his fame with the song "Purple Rain"

  • I can't believe your discussion about this topic,

    THIS IS THE ORIGINAL VERSION, Prince wrote it!!!!!!!!

    If you don't know, you must be a little kid.

    This discussio reminds me all the kids who think:

    "Hey, Guns N' Roses are imitating Tokio Hotel" OMG!!!

    Please come back to your cradle babys!!!!!

  • prince is a great songwriter but after sineads version i cant even hear this one!!!!!!!

  • Love this song!

  • hm this seems to be quite week in comparision to sinead live version of the song :). but its older

  • Amazing voice :)

  • Amazing!

  • manic monday ....... yes sir, manic monday is just another masterpiece that evolved from the heart of this gentleman popularly known as prince....PLEASE i beg art thou to give him his due credit

  • think the only way 2 cover a song is if u hav big feelings towards it or a situation in ur life is connected with it. Most covers are not half as good as the original. Sinead sang hers about her Mother who had abused her, thts why u can feel her passion even tho they are nt her words. 90% as good, Prince is better. Only cover tht is better than this one is Johnny Cash "Hurt", which of course he had a massive connection with if you read about him and watch video. GOOD EFFORTS ALL ROUND LOL

  • Sinead O'Connor did a good job but nothing compares to Prince!

  • this is good, and i like Prince, but I like Sinead's version of this song better. she has a beautiful voice.

  • @AvariGirl Sinead gives this song the soul and power it needs. I know Prince wrote it, but Sinead gives it LIFE!

  • He wrote this wow!! and all the rest what a diamond guy,match him if you can :)

  • no but no sinead made it her own by far and i love prince, think he would agree.

  • I'LL ALWAYS LOVE YOU!!!!!

  • the way prince killed this song makes me wonder why he wanted to give away in the 1st place. so poetic.

  • The preceeding ad was better.

  • Emotional? This version isn't even remotely emotional. It's a very good performance, but Sinead meant every word of it. You could see that she was baring her soul.

    Purple Rain, now that's emotional!

  • @rocketmagnet Prince didn't mean it? He wrote the damn thing!!!

  • both versions are awesome! i feel the power in both songs

  • cool einzige deutsche hier

  • Each to their own....but i prefer Prince

  • now i aint talkn ish about the other artist who made this track blow up up this version is so much better than hers prince and rosie gains thumbs up after all prince wrote it

  • O'Connor`s version is the best version and will always be the best version... Stop judging by the color of the skin and more by the performance... As far as emotion goes.. O`Connor has fucking tears coming out near the end of her video... Beat that for emotion.

  • @RipTone79 who is talking about race, no one is...she is okay but Prince and Rosie just sing it better so calm down, take a breath and move on

  • @RipTone79 R u a rasist?:))) who said something about color????it's all about the song...how can u compare sinead with prince???r u a bieber fan???:))))

  • i don't kow who wrote it, and frankly, i don't don't give a damn, however, o'conners version sounded so much better.. and there's all this talk about princes' version having more emotion to it, bull, i thin sinead's version sounds better and she has more emotion.. srry, just being truthfull...

  • It's a good music to listen while fuck.

  • Nothing to do with O'Connor's version.....They sing.

  • Prince did not this write this song. Sinead O'Conner didn't write this song. FFS a band from Memphis wrote this like 20 years ago and they broke up the same year they wrote it. Prince just brought it to the masses... Dont believe me? Google it. Also I prefer Sineads. not saying its better, better is a tricky word. I prefer Sineads..

  • @davidigleniec To recap. Neither wrote this song originally.

  • @davidigleniec 20 years ago? So 1991? So how did Sinead's version come out in 1990? And how did it appear on The Family album in 1985. Don't talk about stuff you don't know about.

  • @davidigleniec Prince wrote this song, he was the one who produced The Family album look at the album his writing credits are on it.

  • prince and rosies duet is brilliant,but sinead brings something special to it

  • @carlsburgh no way Rosie and Prince rock it out much better... besides the fact that prince actually wrote this and you can hear much more emotion in this version...

  • @chefdube01 .each to there own.i know he wrote it.and its a great duet ,but to me it sounds better as a tune when sinead sings it,purple rain is my favourite tune so...

  • he says 13 days she says 15

  • Prince version is really good.

  • This version is 2.000 times better than Sinead's. End of the question.

  • i heard sineads version 1st... years later this one... i love them both... its like hearing the beatles version of "a little help from from my friends" and then joe cockers... they both rule ... i love them both so much...

  • I think even Prince would have to admit that Sinead's version is the definitive one. He can take the credit for the writing but she brought it to a new level with her voice.

  • @applehunter87 her voice is nothing special. the production, all the layers over her vocals and the video is what make her version iconic. her voice, bare, not so much.

  • @BlackArtNo1 haha, a foreigner. at least give him/her props for going at it without using babelfish! or, perhaps they don't know about it, lol...

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • child please... Prince can't be topped, you need to be slapped.

  • Love Sinead's version but this just OWNS, for some reason it works so well as a duet.

  • This guy ripped off Sinead O'connor.

  • @antdigger He wrote the song and sung it first... he didnt rip her off

  • @antdigger He wrote the song. PA LEASE

  • Comment removed

  • I Really Prefere this to Sinead O'Connors version... Here voice is very distictive, and the song sounds horrible and less tuneful when I here her version of it. She makes it sound Atonal! But that's just my opinion! :)

  • I've known Prince wrote the song longgg ago, but I am just now listening to it. I like Sinead's version better. It invokes an emotional response from me each and everytime. This one, not so much. But its still great.

  • first time i have heard this version (even tho i knew he wrote it) f**ing AMAZING!!!!! sorry Sinead your version is good but this is SOMETHING ELSE :D

  • What a beautiful composition from a great Musician -- Thank you for being a part of my life Prince !

  • Nothing compares to the original

  • @CreativeMinds111111 Yeah, the original was done in 1985 by The Family written by Prince for his then girlfriend, Susannah Melvoin. I have the original album on my wall. 5 years before Sinead's lovely cover in 1990 from her album, I Do Not Want What I Haven't Got.

  • @CreativeMinds111111 JUST SINEAD'S VERSION!!!

  • this is far better.......though I like the other version too...... :-))

  • Just goes to show that Prince is a musical genius..........

  • Till Charlie Brady ... ♫ ♪ Det har varit 7 år, 6 månader och 24 dagar, sedan du Tok din kärlek ifrån mig ♫ ♪.........i'm just so glad we finaly found each other darling,you have made me the happiest man in the world....great things come to those who wait,and if you can,my god it's gonna be forever,i can just feel it...soul mates and lovers,does it get any better??? love you sooooooo much xxx

  • @guygers1690

    Hjärtat! Why havent we got the chance to be with each other earlier? I think we have a lot of years to catch up and we will begin NOW!

    I will do everything i possible can to be with you, to live with you, to love you, get to know youre friends and i will wait.. Im in no hurry as long as I know I have you in my heart. I have waited for so many years for this day to come so i can wait for a couple of more years! Can't wait til seeing you real soon baby!

    Love u now and forever hun

  • Any true Prince fan know that this was originally sang by a group of his called "the Family" as a duet....just as he as Rosie does....I still remember the day that O'Conner debut the song and I knew ever word to it!!!! Prince is an amazing musician and will forever be known for that!!!! Prince Fan Forever!!!!

  • mfbekker@AOL.COM

    

  • I love his song 7

  • Sinead did do a good job with this song but........ Nothing compares to Prince and Rosie. They laid this song out. You can't help but feel every emotion. A tear jerker!!

  • @Lirae4925 Yeah her version was great, they're both good. I like shinead's video.

  • @Lirae4925 I don't feel EVERY emotion... that would be too much, lol. But I know what you mean, it's such a beautiful song

  • Wouldn't it be awesome if Prince dueted with Sinead on this, with Sinead singing Rosie's part?

  • @plasticbricks i have wanted that for years!

  • Woaaaaahhh

  • @warriorprince1010 to bad you dont have ears

  • @warriorprince1010 too bad you dont have ears

  • @warriorprince1010 ????? I know everyone has their own opinions, but I think you are incorrect....I think he bought this song to life. I havbe never heard the Sinead O'Connor version but I know this version is so soulful that it gives me shivers when hear it.  But like I said, we all have different opinions....

  • best song he ever did

  • @BlackArtNo1 why? because i said thar owns to sinead cuz her version make the song a hit,Sineas owns this songs when she makes the cover, i preffer the sinead version that this. sorry my opinion.

  • i love this song i sing it too my girl everytime we are together

  • ESTA VERSION, LA ORIGINAL, ES LA MEJOR. PERO LA DE SINEAD NO ESTA TAN MAL. A MI Y A MI NOVIA NOS GUSTA LAS DOS.

  • 100 times better than the chick.

    well... obviously.. i mean. he is PRINCE.

  • perhaps he is the author of the song, this songs own to sinead, not to him, just like johnny cash cover of hurt not belong anymore to Trent Reznor.

  • @losterx

    Thats NOT true. Prince owns ALL rights to this song.

  • sinead's version cannot even be compared to this one!

  • Comparing the versions for quality is like comparing apples to oranges. The original version by The Family (prince) was done in completely different context than the Sinead version, and from this version. Sinead really nailed the emotion and vocal power in a raw way, but that doesn't make it better. Just different. Love all versions of this song.

  • This version is a lot better that the version that we all know by Sinead. But usually the person who wrote it and performed the original is always better.

  • @WC95Productions Please, speak for youself! I actually prefer Sinead'version. And no, the original is not always better.

  • @tonibonboni2 IYHO.......

  • definitly much more better than sineads cover-version !

  • @cliefi Hahaha, oh my god, you must be fucking joking you absolute retard.

  • prinnce did sooooooooooooo much betta,,,wtf is yall hearing???who da hell is O'Connor?

  • no this shit from word to word

  • soul

  • I prefer this to O'Connor's versions. I think it could do with out Gaines - it's just great to hear Prince sing this song. He has a very distinctive song writing style and his voice fits the melody perfectly.

  • This is better as sineads, but it still isn't that great...

  • I like both versions. Sinead's more because I heard it first but this one (the original) is good as well.

  • Omg this was a lot better than Sinad O'Connor's version!

  • The reason that the Pince version has less views, is because Prince's version sucks. Sinead, whatever you think of her, poured her soul into that song. Her mother had died as a teen. Sorry, Prince and "Rosie" don't impress.

  • @jimguyer Sorry, you're on drugs lol

  • @ujamaa4 Just calling them as they come across the plate

  • @jimguyer That's so sad, when exactly did you go deaf?

  • @MChantal76 best response all month. brilliant.

  • @MChantal76 I judge the music on the music, not on the race of the performer

  • @MChantal76 I judge the music on the music, not on the performer. Somebody needs to tell "The artist formerly known and once again known but not really a Prince" that his 15 minutes were up 30 minutes ago. Maybe one day he will find time to wash his hair.

  • @jimguyer Well if you're judging it on the music, Prince wins by default.. since he wrote it all.

  • It is a disgrace that S. O'Conners version have more views than any other Prince video on youtube.

  • haters...lol...nothing like hearing prince sing this song! don't get me wrong, i love sinead's too but there's something about prince and rosie that evokes much more emotion...for me at least.

  • @toodlesgal This original version is about the song. Sinead's cover is about Sinead's singing.

    This evokes more emotion for you because you listen to the music I suppose.

  • I'd take Sinead O'connor's version any day. The Prince wrote it and an angel made it famous. Thanks Sinead - you're the best on this one...

  • Prince is a prolific writer who has penned songs for many other artists

  • the pic looks like m.j and a friend told me to look this up and i never knew prince wrote it. sinead whatev the name is did it better. sorry prince

  • "I can eat my dinner in a fancy restaurant." I never liked this lyric. Something about it. Cool song, Prince's and Sinead's version. The Family's version just doesn't do the song justice.

  • Prince took his song back and smacked Sinead O'Connor in her bald head with it!

  • long live prince !

  • well,Sinead's version gives me more chills than this..I love Prince but come on,Sinead makes me cry,this version doesn't..

  • I like the horn solo around the 3:30 mark.

  • I love this song cuz it help make through a tought time(: go Prince!

  • Every artist that has sang this song has put their own stamp on it, that is for sure..

    Beautiful song, Given Prince wrote it, his vision was quite different than those who followed. Great to hear the variety of interpretations.

  • I just can't imagine anybody but Sinead singing this song, but his original is so good. So beautiful, like all of his music.

  • Nothing Compares to this!

  • Seriously this man is a living LEGEND!!! Sinead O'Connor version is rubbish when you compare it to the orginal

  • No offence i love it, but Sinead did it better...

  • @EagleCJL172  you right, she went in for real

  • @EagleCJL172 nonsense. This is his song. She it different but no one can do it better.

  • PRNCE YOU ARE AMAZINGGGGGG!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • I am so glad that he actually sang this, even though Sinead made it famous. he is the original composer and you can feel the emotion in this song :)

  • I can compare the one person that dislike this to alot of things, and they're not good

  • i love rosie gaines like.. no, seriously. one of the greatest singers to ever record. ever.