Its true! what is taken by force which in that case can only be returned by force. I'm not saying that the Jews had no right to be in palastine but they had no right to eject and butcher millions throughout the past 60 yearsa and we as humans can only forgive certain things in life but you can not forgive what the zionists has done to the palastinians, Lebanese and Egyptians. free people never give up. Israel has already suffered a minor defeat in Lebanon and the major is indeed imminent .
Alhamdulillah! This man has a clear mind and NO traces of bias! May the world be filled with people like this, Jews, Christians and Muslims AMEEEEEEEEEEEEN!
Wonderful. Great for him to tell the truth in the U.S., the country that SUPPORTS ISREAL'S GENOCIDE! There is such rabid propaganda in this country. It is disgusting that if you point this out, you are immediately called "anti-semetic".
In Germany the opposition was openly tortured and murdered,almost everybody knew,many took part,few denied collaboration.These were persecuted after ww2 by the BND, the renamed GESTAPO. One of the non collaborators was an uncle of mine which caused my family being persecuted till today,see my channel and homepage. Read: The Brown Network, printed in 1936. Or the Brown Book of the Reichstag fire. Millions of these books had been printed in many languages before ww2
His point of view is regretfully very f laud. He accuses the student for a dirty trick to make an association in the mind of the audience, yet he makes the analogy between Israel and Nazi Germany. Israel as opposed to Nazi Germany, is applying its force towards guarding itself inwardly, not expanding.
Israel has to have strong military to fight the constant evil of the islamic terrorism.
I support Israel and any actions they take to fight the islamic terrorism. They have every right to defend themselves from terrorists, just as all other countries do.
I was directed to this vid and have no idea who this man is. But he says something that I've heard before, that Israel can't continue what its doing and survive. Not because of some moral dilemma but because its too expensive to maintain a welfare/warfare state. Something is gonna have to give I suppose and it can't be a good thing if Israel vanishes. So what is the upshot, what will be the answer?
Finkelstein speaks about "blockade" and occupation etc but how come the muslims wanted to destroy and kill all jews even before new Israel existed? proof? Watch "Hitler und das Islam" or Hitler and Mufti palestinian. Israel ended up as an occupying country ONLY AFTER ALL ARABS wanted war against Israel in 67. Did the international community forget about that? Hamas wants the destruction of Israel, isnt it against international law? Muslim lobby gives lots of cash dirty finkelstein
That sums up well the debate style of Mr. Finkelstein, first to attack and personaly humiliate the opponent and then the debate is almost over. But you need to be very good debater to do that correctly :)
P.S. I don't have a stance on what he is talking about. I'm just a debate team leader.
2:19 ... come on... I know things are bad, but suffer just like Hiroshima and Nagasaki? All right the situation is at this point, but suffer like that? Civilian Atomic Bombing?
As much as I agree with Finkelstein, I must add - as a German - that my people also heve become the most brainwashed by "political correctness".
Our government has made the absolut support and acknowledgement of the State of Israel, that Finkelstein is correctly calling a "lunatic state", its "raison d'etat" !
The moment a certain opinion reaches public attention that does not comply to the political correctness, it gets hammered, condemned and even prosecuted by State-Propaganda!
damn this guy is good! The way he explained the transition of Germany from a Nazi to a peacefull country and compared it to the opressive israeli regime is just amazing! Israel will suffer the big defeat. The sooner the better.
Lunatic Finklestein makes absolutely NO sense in comparing Israel to Germany. Germany needed to be defeated, and it's a good thing it was defeated, because it was run by a madman who wanted to conquer Europe and commit genocide, and, after killing MILLIONS of Jews, Gypsies, gays, communists and other Europeans, did a damn effective job. Israel has no intention to conquer the world or commit any genocide, but rather to use a combination of diplomacy and military force in order to...
Dr. Finkelstein has a pair of steel ones. No doubt!...I sure hope he gets to walk around w/them......ON another note. Ppl. dont know man. They just dont know that so many Jews in the USA are not only ashamed; they are horrified at the way Israel has been behaving. They just wont come out and say it Publicly. And as an American-Arab.......I also condemn Hamas' rocket launching. It has to stop! And peace has to START. For once you gun wielders; give the real ppl. a chance man.
i don't understand what finkelstein is mad about. the student asked him questions, though i am a revisionist myself i think finkelstein needs to chill out a bit.
Were the Allies collectively punishing the citizens of Germany for electing Hitler? If they were, World War II would have begun in 1933. It began in 1939, after Hitler attacked Poland, an act of war. Hamas fired 8,000 rockets into Israel since its unilateral withdrawal in 2005. Israel finally responded to those acts of war—not Hamas’s election—in 2009. As the Allies tried to halt Hitler’s army, German citizens died. So too as Israel tries to halt Hamas. Tragic, but not a war crime.
there is NOTHING WRONG with the guys question!! norman finkelstein admits in an interview with al jazeera that he got an invitation to the revisionist conference in iran (in december 2006) and that he WOULD GO on three conditions...none of which were met, so he rejected the invitation.
you can read the interview for yourself. just google "Interview: Tear down the walls" its the first result, the link leads to the website of al jazeera.
Zionism in its true form is not evil, jews should have a homeland. However, what most people and Dr. Fink disagree with is the way Israel is going about it. e.g destroying homes and displacing people and the increasing illegal expansion. I hate how the media portrays him as a radical and tries to isolate him, but in fact there is a sizeable amount of jews that deplore the treatment of the Palestinians, but are sometimes afraid to speak out through fear of being outcasted and labelled a traitor.
the only reason ppl can tolerate him is because he himself is israeli or jewish..if a muslim stood up for palestine liek that, they would call him a terrorist...
Alot of things said about what the Nazi regime did in regards to the Jewish. I ask does antone question the Jewish of Israel as to the things they have done to the Arabic Muslims of Palestine?, or what they did to Beirut?
Although i fully agree with Dr Finkelstein in his argument, but i still dont see anything wrong with the guy's question. I think Dr Finkelstein took it a bit personally and over-reacted. lol... however, it was interesting to know that he did attend the conference; it shows that the conference was very well represented internationally.
@MozesAllawati well yeah, as he says, his whole family was exterminated in the holocaust. anyone who knows anything about Dr Finkelstein knows that. so asking that question was just purely disrespectful.
@hitmanno120 he's likely a true jew, but does it really matter? What he is arguing for is military and political goals (to shed light on the unspeakable violence being perpetrated by Israel right now), not religious goals
His parents were both Jewish, both survived Holocaust in concentration camps, all his extended family perished in the Nazi Holocaust. He is Jewish by birth but he says that he is not religious himself.
The question about attendance to the Holocaust Memorial is a filthy and offensive maneuver. Norman Finkelstein was raised into the "smoke of the holocaust", being son of parents (both) who survived Auschwitz and Majdanek and having lost absolutely all his relatives in World War II.Norman Finkelstein is simply the bravest man alive.You need to have balls of steel to oppose Israel discourse being a Jew yourself!
@MrManumona Not the Holocaust Memorial but the Holocaust Denial Conference in Iran that the student is asking about! President Ahmedinejad hosts a conference with many Holocaust Deniers coming! For him to ask that question is basically rude as hell! I personally believe few Jews used the Holocaust to further their agenda! I don't deny that, but I don't deny the Holocaust either! BTW....don't ever ask a Jew if he ever attended that...sounds like ur accusing him of being a self hating jew!
Don't think they have to suffer... They just need to stop kicking their neighbors. I wouldn't be surprised if loud mouth Iran gets their ass kicked from Israel. I agree with Dr. about their arsenal and the progression on their building and acquiring of arms. Just don't think they should suffer...
Suffering is not the best word he should be using here. They should be monitored and inspected regularly...
I don´t hear what Fink. answers first (before everyone applauds), is like "question", "stop", "reading", or something like that; could someone clarify it please? Thanks in advance!
@Arabmanly What is brave about preaching to the choir? He speaks at Universities and other incubators of left-wing extremism and misdguided support for the Palestinians. This kid in the audience was brave, calling Finkelstein out in this den of jackals. You people that support Finkelstein need to look in the mirror and realize that you, and he, support some of the nastiest, vilest terrorists the world has ever known-yet you act as though you're somehow operating from the moral high ground.
@Arabmanly Umm sorry. Can you define what Zionist means in dummy terms? The media and even the internet seems to perpetuate lots of lies and drastically different views. Sorry and thanks. :)
Dr. Finkelstein is an honest & accurate jewish-american whom I respect very much. He tells the truth & because of that, most (not all) of his fellow jews cannot stand him. The real battles are currently being fought internally within the jewish community. The majority of jews are extremely pro-israel and extremely anti-Palestinian, however there is a good portion (perhaps 25%-30%) who are opposed to zionism and very much opposed to what israel is doing to the Palestinians.
check out also David Cole, another secualr/atheist born into a jewish background (hence an atheist) ostracized and even givne death threats by the terrorist JDL because of his findings and refutal of official jewish statistics on deaths at Auschwitz
@spazabarri The guy asked a "complex question", hence Finkelstein's joke. I believe he was asked "Did you attend the Holocaust Denial conference nine times in a row." To answer in the intended format, i.e., with a 'Yes' or a 'No', is to take as a given that he's ever been to such a conference in the first place.
israel is a militarist state becuse they dident belive the 2007 US intelligence report? (thet we now know.. was written by a man with radical anti israeli and pro islamist views.)
even the US government dident belive this report!
europian countries as well dident belive this reports..
all the intelligence about iran said one thing.. and this reports said the opposite thing
no one breathe a sign of relief.. this report was dangerous becuse he misled people
All over the world people are sick and tired with the game that Israel is playing. How many times God put trust in you and you betrayed him? Israel will never accept peace until it destroys all resistance in islamic countries AND impose it own rules! You'll never learn from your mistakes...a wonder!!!!!
@jason0998 Oh, you speak for all them? I can tell you that buddhists, most christians, and most other compassionate and intelligent people think that finkelstein is a joke. he's been kicked out of all his university jobs because he's a hack. the dalai lama, for example is a great friend to israel and jews.
im a cristian from lebanon with hezbollah.. i love this powerful man.. i really didnt believe that one day a jew would kno the truth about the game going on in the world.. hes a hero.. those people as norman are the people of god.. god bless him and protect him cz many evils want kill him.. and note people that there are many cristians within hezballah members.
Its true! what is taken by force which in that case can only be returned by force. I'm not saying that the Jews had no right to be in palastine but they had no right to eject and butcher millions throughout the past 60 yearsa and we as humans can only forgive certain things in life but you can not forgive what the zionists has done to the palastinians, Lebanese and Egyptians. free people never give up. Israel has already suffered a minor defeat in Lebanon and the major is indeed imminent .
zabraoota1 11 months ago 102
I love Finklestein...but what did the young man ask? I can't hear it.
AnnaSofiaR 11 months ago 83
Alhamdulillah! This man has a clear mind and NO traces of bias! May the world be filled with people like this, Jews, Christians and Muslims AMEEEEEEEEEEEEN!
mooneyes89 11 months ago 182
Wonderful. Great for him to tell the truth in the U.S., the country that SUPPORTS ISREAL'S GENOCIDE! There is such rabid propaganda in this country. It is disgusting that if you point this out, you are immediately called "anti-semetic".
divina6dunia 11 months ago 101
Finkelstein is great!
OfficialCommentator 11 months ago 75
In Germany the opposition was openly tortured and murdered,almost everybody knew,many took part,few denied collaboration.These were persecuted after ww2 by the BND, the renamed GESTAPO. One of the non collaborators was an uncle of mine which caused my family being persecuted till today,see my channel and homepage. Read: The Brown Network, printed in 1936. Or the Brown Book of the Reichstag fire. Millions of these books had been printed in many languages before ww2
wwwtotalitaerde 11 months ago
subtitles plzzzzz..
I couldn't hear what were the question and answer!!
elbnderi 11 months ago 17
It´s funny, when White people like a Jew they immediately declare him a Super Jew.
He´s just a good guy with a lot of common sense. I don´t distinguish between Jews and non-Jews.
EbClectic 11 months ago 23
His point of view is regretfully very f laud. He accuses the student for a dirty trick to make an association in the mind of the audience, yet he makes the analogy between Israel and Nazi Germany. Israel as opposed to Nazi Germany, is applying its force towards guarding itself inwardly, not expanding.
aelroy 11 months ago
this video got the most likes! haha!
ningakid99 1 year ago
who is this guy? what is the context of the speech?
kenfo0 1 year ago
I LOVE Norman Finkelstein ,,,,,,,, ALSO CHECK george galloway he is just like this good man
faqat7assan 1 year ago
Who the fuck filmed this, Michael J Fox?
Poopsmith01 1 year ago 13
Israel has to have strong military to fight the constant evil of the islamic terrorism.
I support Israel and any actions they take to fight the islamic terrorism. They have every right to defend themselves from terrorists, just as all other countries do.
islam4scum 1 year ago
Finkelstein is my dude!! He tells it like it is everytime!!
dappa1 1 year ago 8
I wonder what happened to that student who asked the filthy question?
TheVoiceOfReason93 1 year ago
When this man speaks I listen.
SimianAxiom 1 year ago 11
I was really hoping he would say that Israel needs a non-violent defeat.
Because destruction in these modern times would not happen with tanks and conventional airstrikes.
(please don't respond to this)
BCsJonathanTM 1 year ago
Finkestein makes being Jew more than just screaming Zionist slogans...
ElectricQualia 1 year ago
Finklestein laying down the pownage!
TheHerpaderpderp 1 year ago
I was directed to this vid and have no idea who this man is. But he says something that I've heard before, that Israel can't continue what its doing and survive. Not because of some moral dilemma but because its too expensive to maintain a welfare/warfare state. Something is gonna have to give I suppose and it can't be a good thing if Israel vanishes. So what is the upshot, what will be the answer?
ripperduck 1 year ago
What is exactly the question the guy asked?
MegaRogerism 1 year ago
VIVA PALESTINE! Viva Finkelstein! May the voice of truth and justice always stand tall against voice of oppression and ignorance!
hansbricks912 1 year ago 3
the last time we suffered a devastating defeat was about 2000 years ago we don't have the strategic size to suffer another one
byhybyhy 1 year ago
Finkelstein speaks about "blockade" and occupation etc but how come the muslims wanted to destroy and kill all jews even before new Israel existed? proof? Watch "Hitler und das Islam" or Hitler and Mufti palestinian. Israel ended up as an occupying country ONLY AFTER ALL ARABS wanted war against Israel in 67. Did the international community forget about that? Hamas wants the destruction of Israel, isnt it against international law? Muslim lobby gives lots of cash dirty finkelstein
mypoliticalchannel 1 year ago
I think israel needs to suffer more than a defeat... it needs to be reconstructed as a non-racist law-abiding multinational state.
decidererer 1 year ago 3
damn. not only did he shit on that guy with the wife-beater remark, he also took the time to thoroughly answer his question after
xtreadxsoftlyx 1 year ago
Why is the student called Filthy?
dudemantwo 1 year ago
“Goyim (gentiles) were born only to serve us. Without that, they have no place in the world; only to serve the People of Israel"
- Zionist Israeli Sephardic leader Rabbi Ovadia Yosef in his weekly Saturday night sermon.
Source: JTA
karlkarlkarl1234 1 year ago 2
what a peice of garbage
eytan12 1 year ago
This man is remarkable.
aydivine 1 year ago
That sums up well the debate style of Mr. Finkelstein, first to attack and personaly humiliate the opponent and then the debate is almost over. But you need to be very good debater to do that correctly :)
P.S. I don't have a stance on what he is talking about. I'm just a debate team leader.
gomunkul 1 year ago
2:19 ... come on... I know things are bad, but suffer just like Hiroshima and Nagasaki? All right the situation is at this point, but suffer like that? Civilian Atomic Bombing?
tukianimation 1 year ago
the voice is not clear
can anyone make subtitle for this clip plz
sadgull 1 year ago 557
tell it like it is brotha!
AAtaak 1 year ago 33
have a lot of respect for this guy!
HaBeelovesKA 1 year ago 45
He's American?!!! :O
He's the only politician with a heart....i support him! :')
HaBeelovesKA 1 year ago 84
04:05
As much as I agree with Finkelstein, I must add - as a German - that my people also heve become the most brainwashed by "political correctness".
Our government has made the absolut support and acknowledgement of the State of Israel, that Finkelstein is correctly calling a "lunatic state", its "raison d'etat" !
The moment a certain opinion reaches public attention that does not comply to the political correctness, it gets hammered, condemned and even prosecuted by State-Propaganda!
d0dge25 1 year ago 49
Dr. Norman Finkelstein is the best guy i have ever seen ,, he always tells the truth and he proofs it by the facts and history ...great guy
artin74 1 year ago 42
damn this guy is good! The way he explained the transition of Germany from a Nazi to a peacefull country and compared it to the opressive israeli regime is just amazing! Israel will suffer the big defeat. The sooner the better.
TheAlexhamza 1 year ago 25
Dr. Norman Finklestien = Super Jew :D
screampie755 1 year ago 59
This guy is making some big calls! He would quickly lose confidence if handed a weapon and asked to contribute to this so called "defeat"?!
theETERNITYprojeckt 1 year ago
Lunatic Finklestein makes absolutely NO sense in comparing Israel to Germany. Germany needed to be defeated, and it's a good thing it was defeated, because it was run by a madman who wanted to conquer Europe and commit genocide, and, after killing MILLIONS of Jews, Gypsies, gays, communists and other Europeans, did a damn effective job. Israel has no intention to conquer the world or commit any genocide, but rather to use a combination of diplomacy and military force in order to...
Adeelicious121 1 year ago
Zionists want muslisms representet as evil but unfortunatly there are bright people there to express themselves in an intellectual perspective.
7numrat 1 year ago 2
Dr. Finkelstein has a pair of steel ones. No doubt!...I sure hope he gets to walk around w/them......ON another note. Ppl. dont know man. They just dont know that so many Jews in the USA are not only ashamed; they are horrified at the way Israel has been behaving. They just wont come out and say it Publicly. And as an American-Arab.......I also condemn Hamas' rocket launching. It has to stop! And peace has to START. For once you gun wielders; give the real ppl. a chance man.
peace/salam/shalom
translationwiz 1 year ago 9
im a muslim and i can safely call Dr. Norman Finkelstein the jewish Dr, Zakir Naik
he knows whats happening and he knows whats he talking about
yoneverknow123 1 year ago 7
OWNAGE MY HIGHEST RESPECT GO To THIS GREAT MAN
brrrrrrrratt 1 year ago
i don't understand what finkelstein is mad about. the student asked him questions, though i am a revisionist myself i think finkelstein needs to chill out a bit.
ultradumbass 1 year ago
Were the Allies collectively punishing the citizens of Germany for electing Hitler? If they were, World War II would have begun in 1933. It began in 1939, after Hitler attacked Poland, an act of war. Hamas fired 8,000 rockets into Israel since its unilateral withdrawal in 2005. Israel finally responded to those acts of war—not Hamas’s election—in 2009. As the Allies tried to halt Hitler’s army, German citizens died. So too as Israel tries to halt Hamas. Tragic, but not a war crime.
elachechino 1 year ago
finally some one know about israel crimes . i will support this guy who know all the truth and nothing else the truth
qusaisaher 1 year ago 42
there is NOTHING WRONG with the guys question!! norman finkelstein admits in an interview with al jazeera that he got an invitation to the revisionist conference in iran (in december 2006) and that he WOULD GO on three conditions...none of which were met, so he rejected the invitation.
you can read the interview for yourself. just google "Interview: Tear down the walls" its the first result, the link leads to the website of al jazeera.
Syphex 1 year ago
excellent
missy01339 1 year ago 8
Zionism in its true form is not evil, jews should have a homeland. However, what most people and Dr. Fink disagree with is the way Israel is going about it. e.g destroying homes and displacing people and the increasing illegal expansion. I hate how the media portrays him as a radical and tries to isolate him, but in fact there is a sizeable amount of jews that deplore the treatment of the Palestinians, but are sometimes afraid to speak out through fear of being outcasted and labelled a traitor.
scarface072 1 year ago 17
Jews...Zionists...know the difference.
jeyespiedra 1 year ago 13
the only reason ppl can tolerate him is because he himself is israeli or jewish..if a muslim stood up for palestine liek that, they would call him a terrorist...
blacklight019 1 year ago 45
Ouch. Wouldn't wanna be that guy. But then again, I wouldn't ask a question simply to slander the person i was asking.
TheEasyWay8 1 year ago 473
So this man seriously is denying that WW2 and all those murderings of the jews didnt happen?....and this many people listen to that lie ??
No wonder the world is in the shape its in. That man is evil
anddihier 1 year ago
Alot of things said about what the Nazi regime did in regards to the Jewish. I ask does antone question the Jewish of Israel as to the things they have done to the Arabic Muslims of Palestine?, or what they did to Beirut?
dan16387 1 year ago 6
just showing my support for finkelstein
chasteice 1 year ago 37
i read one of his books. it was not very good.
Thronsohn 1 year ago
What a man I wish to meet him as he is a brave and honest in his evaluations
m6a2kh2 1 year ago 16
Although i fully agree with Dr Finkelstein in his argument, but i still dont see anything wrong with the guy's question. I think Dr Finkelstein took it a bit personally and over-reacted. lol... however, it was interesting to know that he did attend the conference; it shows that the conference was very well represented internationally.
MozesAllawati 1 year ago
@MozesAllawati
He implied that Finkelstein is a holocaust denier .
BlakByte 1 year ago 7
@MozesAllawati, the second question was clearly an attempt at trolling, and that is unecessary in a debate between intellectuals.
shariotoflove 1 year ago 8
@MozesAllawati well yeah, as he says, his whole family was exterminated in the holocaust. anyone who knows anything about Dr Finkelstein knows that. so asking that question was just purely disrespectful.
khoshgelak07 1 year ago 37
@MozesAllawati Finkelstein stated that he did NOT attend the conference, for the record. Replay the video if you cannot hear it.
ThePowerofReason 1 year ago 2
ok im gonna have to ask a question out on the blue whats his religion or dose he have a religion im not offending im only asking
hitmanno120 1 year ago
@hitmanno120 Not sure if someone already answered this, but Finkelstein is Jewish for sure... not sure if he's devout or secular
Syphex 1 year ago
@hitmanno120 he's likely a true jew, but does it really matter? What he is arguing for is military and political goals (to shed light on the unspeakable violence being perpetrated by Israel right now), not religious goals
ThePowerofReason 1 year ago
@hitmanno120
His parents were both Jewish, both survived Holocaust in concentration camps, all his extended family perished in the Nazi Holocaust. He is Jewish by birth but he says that he is not religious himself.
optimistsRUS 1 year ago
What author is Finkelstein quoting and in what book does he claim this (based on what, nukes)?
ReX342 1 year ago
wow about time! a man with a fking backbone and education.
^^ he earned my respect!
lol lunitic state
movingdisaster 1 year ago 8
This man is a hero! I love to hear him speak and to read his books. :D
brenna68t 1 year ago
wish he were the President of the USA...
clonach 1 year ago 21
@clonach wish more people just read history and not consume mainstream media.
LSRochon 1 year ago
The question about attendance to the Holocaust Memorial is a filthy and offensive maneuver. Norman Finkelstein was raised into the "smoke of the holocaust", being son of parents (both) who survived Auschwitz and Majdanek and having lost absolutely all his relatives in World War II.Norman Finkelstein is simply the bravest man alive.You need to have balls of steel to oppose Israel discourse being a Jew yourself!
MrManumona 1 year ago 11
@MrManumona Not the Holocaust Memorial but the Holocaust Denial Conference in Iran that the student is asking about! President Ahmedinejad hosts a conference with many Holocaust Deniers coming! For him to ask that question is basically rude as hell! I personally believe few Jews used the Holocaust to further their agenda! I don't deny that, but I don't deny the Holocaust either! BTW....don't ever ask a Jew if he ever attended that...sounds like ur accusing him of being a self hating jew!
lebaneseameer 1 year ago
@MrManumona Check out the blog ANNA IN THE MIDDLE EAST.
WhiskeyyWoman 1 year ago
I like to call him, The Common Voice of Reason.
GamerDudester 1 year ago 9
Don't think they have to suffer... They just need to stop kicking their neighbors. I wouldn't be surprised if loud mouth Iran gets their ass kicked from Israel. I agree with Dr. about their arsenal and the progression on their building and acquiring of arms. Just don't think they should suffer...
Suffering is not the best word he should be using here. They should be monitored and inspected regularly...
esh1 1 year ago
i think he said "holocaust denial conference," perhaps
MangaChocobo 1 year ago
Interesting clip but I want to beat the camera man with his terrible tripod.
iloveravi 1 year ago
Sound is really not understandable, plaease someone add lyrics or translation or something :S
Pampadoro 1 year ago
What did the guy even ask in the first place?
hbunnyo 1 year ago
i cant hear what the guy asked in the beginning...anyone plz ?
pengo2007 1 year ago
@pengo2007
The student asked whether Finkelstein attended the Holocaust denial conference in Iran.
italia981 1 year ago
I don´t hear what Fink. answers first (before everyone applauds), is like "question", "stop", "reading", or something like that; could someone clarify it please? Thanks in advance!
Burdell22000 1 year ago
That guy is great! Zionism is morally dead.
237Michael 1 year ago
Fink is great.
MrDarkbloom 1 year ago 4
Christians, tolerants muslims, jew, bouddhist, Bahaes (who live in Haifa in Israel) are against your poison.
We re sorry about your traumatism of shoah but you have to go to the doctor please for the good.
superoxydan 1 year ago
Great Video Upload
LSRochon 1 year ago
What a brave man !
God bless him !
He' s not afraid of the Zionists.
Arabmanly 1 year ago 467
@Arabmanly Honestly, do you even know what a zionist is. Just please give a definition of what you think it is.
613iceman 1 year ago
@Arabmanly not as afraid as you seem to be, at least
fatmeteor 1 year ago
@Arabmanly whats a zionst?
bskulldragon100 1 year ago
@Arabmanly What is brave about preaching to the choir? He speaks at Universities and other incubators of left-wing extremism and misdguided support for the Palestinians. This kid in the audience was brave, calling Finkelstein out in this den of jackals. You people that support Finkelstein need to look in the mirror and realize that you, and he, support some of the nastiest, vilest terrorists the world has ever known-yet you act as though you're somehow operating from the moral high ground.
oldstock1607 1 year ago
@Arabmanly Oh my God! It is so barve of him to speak his mind in a Democratic society... Truely the most brave person I have ever seen.
SDK2584 1 year ago
@Arabmanly Umm sorry. Can you define what Zionist means in dummy terms? The media and even the internet seems to perpetuate lots of lies and drastically different views. Sorry and thanks. :)
I want to understand
spiritfired 1 year ago
I love this guy.
Louii92 1 year ago 12
Dr. Finkelstein is an honest & accurate jewish-american whom I respect very much. He tells the truth & because of that, most (not all) of his fellow jews cannot stand him. The real battles are currently being fought internally within the jewish community. The majority of jews are extremely pro-israel and extremely anti-Palestinian, however there is a good portion (perhaps 25%-30%) who are opposed to zionism and very much opposed to what israel is doing to the Palestinians.
jasaahae 1 year ago 20
check out also David Cole, another secualr/atheist born into a jewish background (hence an atheist) ostracized and even givne death threats by the terrorist JDL because of his findings and refutal of official jewish statistics on deaths at Auschwitz
shitonMOHAMMAD 1 year ago
@shitonMOHAMMAD David Cole recanted though, but I can understand him doing so to be relieved of death threats.
PornographicSoul 1 year ago
it's true. germans are some of the most peace loving moral individuals. i have good friends there. he's speaking the truth. i'm liking this guy.
sylence7 1 year ago 4
I think he said Holocaust *denial* conference? not sure :S
spazabarri 1 year ago
@spazabarri The guy asked a "complex question", hence Finkelstein's joke. I believe he was asked "Did you attend the Holocaust Denial conference nine times in a row." To answer in the intended format, i.e., with a 'Yes' or a 'No', is to take as a given that he's ever been to such a conference in the first place.
alienproxy 1 year ago 2
@spazabarri Meh. I think I'm wrong.
alienproxy 1 year ago
snap!
FreedomAtRisk 1 year ago
guys! I didn't catch what was the question, the answer is clear but not the question.
Would anybody tell me what is it?
Thank you
1985eman 1 year ago
@1985eman he's secondon question was weather or not he went to the holocaust denial conference
SomaliMakeupLover 1 year ago
If this guy were on the weekend pundit shows, he'd demolish every other person there. (I suppose that's one reason he's never invited!)
flimpkin4 1 year ago
to help clerify your information section, he says "did you attend the holocaust denial conferance in iran?"
capcloud 1 year ago
lol his arguments are soo poor...
israel is a militarist state becuse they dident belive the 2007 US intelligence report? (thet we now know.. was written by a man with radical anti israeli and pro islamist views.)
even the US government dident belive this report!
europian countries as well dident belive this reports..
all the intelligence about iran said one thing.. and this reports said the opposite thing
no one breathe a sign of relief.. this report was dangerous becuse he misled people
Zionyy 1 year ago
All over the world people are sick and tired with the game that Israel is playing. How many times God put trust in you and you betrayed him? Israel will never accept peace until it destroys all resistance in islamic countries AND impose it own rules! You'll never learn from your mistakes...a wonder!!!!!
swiftspy 1 year ago 13
israel is a militarist state because they steal land and kill innocent people.
Tmacbryant 1 year ago 5
only if we have such a leader in the arab world , they`re all pussies
fo2sh20 1 year ago 17
real talk..
anathaki 1 year ago
so true.
ecs177 1 year ago
what was the question and what was the reply? i couldnt hear a thing
AkulaFB 1 year ago 2
@AkulaFB Read the discription!
BobCassidy 1 year ago
Dr. Finkelstein is a hero !
Muslims, Christians, Budhists, Bahaes are all with u
jason0998 1 year ago 354
@jason0998
This guy speaks the truth! Do you know where i can get his full lectures from?
An0therBr0ther 1 year ago 2
This guy speaks the truth! Do you know where i can get his full lectures from?
An0therBr0ther 1 year ago
This guy speaks the truth! Do you know where i can get his full lectures from?
An0therBr0ther 1 year ago 4
There are quite a few full-length lectures by Finkelstein right here on You Tube. Just click around. You'll find them.
bapyou 1 year ago 4
@jason0998 Couldn't be more precise myself! 120% Support to Dr. Finkelstein!
AGQ181 1 year ago
@jason0998 count atheists (at least me) in, too!
BalthazzarCH 1 year ago 3
@BalthazzarCH me too!
Raedkt 1 year ago
@jason0998 Don't forget Atheists and Jews.. my best heroes are Jews.
tamagochita 1 year ago
@jason0998 definitely mate
IIIDarkWorlDIII 1 year ago
@jason0998 Hindus as well!
All people who understand the importance of REAL peace!
dimwriting23 1 year ago
@jason0998 Oh, you speak for all them? I can tell you that buddhists, most christians, and most other compassionate and intelligent people think that finkelstein is a joke. he's been kicked out of all his university jobs because he's a hack. the dalai lama, for example is a great friend to israel and jews.
bhaktitube 1 year ago
@jason0998 And atheists... :D
seraph101 1 year ago
@jason0998
"comments pending approval"
Gee, what a surprise.
chris2002Rocklin 1 year ago
It is hard to follow him.
Can you please write what he is saying, even in English would be fine.
THANKS
janzeer99 1 year ago
Can't wait for his new book coming at the end of March 2010.
doitdeviant 1 year ago 6
@doitdeviant
which book? I would love to buy it!
An0therBr0ther 1 year ago
@doitdeviant
which book? I would love to buy it!
An0therBr0ther 1 year ago
A brave and honourable man
henchman696 1 year ago 23
WOW, there is still a humanbeing between americans and jews!!
he is a real hero , who doesnt scared from zionest!!!
uglylion2000 1 year ago 250
@uglylion2000
true true, try youtube'n jews agins israel! youll find more,
it is a known fackt for clear thinking people that the problem in the middle-east isnt a religius but a sekularistic, sorry for the bad spelling! :D
oONuggamusOo 1 year ago
@uglylion2000 I still argue that good people in the US are in the majority, we just have little or no serious representation.
itchykami 1 year ago
@uglylion2000 you said it,
i would be so scared if we didn't have a public figure such as him.
TheElefaunt 1 year ago 5
im a cristian from lebanon with hezbollah.. i love this powerful man.. i really didnt believe that one day a jew would kno the truth about the game going on in the world.. hes a hero.. those people as norman are the people of god.. god bless him and protect him cz many evils want kill him.. and note people that there are many cristians within hezballah members.
maxim42530 1 year ago