I find it so funny how Christina fans constantly refer to the 'voice of a generation' tag ONE magazine poll concluded with, especially compared to the countless polls, acolades, awards and critical acclaim Mariah has recieved over the years. Don't get me wrong, Christina can SANG, but that stupid tag means nothing. Every vocalist has been hailed 'the voice of their generation'.
@BigBlyeEyes1234 thats true, that tag means nothing, but we both know, she IS the voice of this generation, 1998-Now, just like Mariah and Whitney were on the 90s
@brandonlivega Hmm, I guess. But arguably, so could Britney Spears (even though she sucks). She's had a lot of success and everyone remembers that 'oh babay babay' voice of hers... And that's why I think the 'voice of this generation' thing is so pointless - it doesn't necessarily mean she can sing.
ohhh poor fat frog, this mariah can not to be compared whit Xtina, it is the true, Xtina is the VOICE of her generation, in the roolig stone ranking, Xtina kick mariah's fat ass, so, i'm so so soooo sorry for you, LOOSER
mariah is the first female singer who has most number ones, writes and produce her songs, is idolized by christina and thousand of other international succesful singers, hahahaha she sold just with 2 records more then christina offkeylera ever will, while christina had her period, on a funeral singing stage and killed the anthem, never ever compare such untalented FLOP, who floped harder the anybody and cant sing live to legends like mariah who sang with michael jackson and whitney!
@bornstar20 christina has no technique and control,it's why mariah won't do a duet with her,go to singing class,it's what mariah'll say,christina's voice isn't more powerful,she screams too much and that fools you thinking it's more powerful,mariah's voice isn't at its prime beacuse she's been singing for 22 years,but she can still sing great,christina's voice isn't at its prime in less than a decade cos she didn't take care of her voice,mariah beats christina,mariah has big range and techniqu.
mariah carey is the best voice, but her music is not precious and special, if i i will choose christina because can sing alot of kinds of muisc, jazz, blue, pop, rb, but mariah just only pop and rb, so xtina u win
Mariah all the way!!!but why are y'all using old vids of her she can still hit the majority of those note today!!! And I agree they should sing together
@lukemichaelhenderson Are u sure? christina mostly finishes her belts in screams and her voice turns very screachy in the high notes. No one can belt like Whitney Houston, and this is general opinion. Mariah belted some great many notes in the 90's , now she isnt able to do that anymore. I think christina is overrated when it comes to her singing,her live performances are good but her singing style is very one dimensional.she's no match for Whitney in intensity and natural power.
Mariah Can Sing a G2 So She Dominate the Low Notes, Mariah Can Belt an A5 And not only That She Has showed That She can Belt a F5 2 or 3 consecutive times!! And She Has Hit an amazing G7 and not only That also she can Sustain a D7 For more than 10 seconds So For Me Mariah is the best Singer, Christina Is Talented but She is a beginner compared with Mariah!!
Mariah's gotta a better overall range, and definitely has more control over whistle register. But Christina dominates the low range, and gets way better volume; there's a reason they call her "The Voice", you know.
Mariah's voice is also much clearer; she doesn't add that rasp that Christina does very often. Personally, I like girls with that raspier tone in their voice (P!nk anybody? :D ), so I prefer Christina.
i prefer xtina she have stronger voice and carey isnt nice for my ears but they should sing together and show all this commercial untalnted bitches like rihanna gaga madonna perry etc what treu talent mean
I like Christina better her voice just sounds better especially the notes in "Ain't no other man" and "Fighter"! Mariah has a better vocal range but her voice sounds boring! and besides she's not really around any more.
Mariah Carey is #1 Queen Forever and always~~~ Christina has a good voice but when she sings high she strains her voice too me.. And its agervating... Mariah Carey has a more natural powerful voice!!! And Her 90s era was an Extrodinary time but Now its Even better!!!! Her voice more machure and more stronger~~~~ MARIAH ALL THE WAY 4ever!! CRT FOREVER
selves cause that's low and immature. If you can't accept that Mariah's the far better vocalist then that's a problem, but you can't honestly sit there and say xtina is a better Technician? Come on now, that's crazy. That's like someone saying Aretha franklin has no soul and that billie holiday had a 6 octave range. Delusional. who you perfer is alright but.....why am I givin a speech to people ova the internet? ya'll ain't go listen anyway. I'm not ya'll mama. Bye.
even stolen a few runs from Mariah, and she tries to whislte like Mariah, and she tries to belt like she just Aretha franklin. The sad thing is that she does have a soulful voice, but tries too hard to be soulful, she always uses melisma inapropratley and she could be a high belter if she didn't sing from the throat and had bad placement. Fact is ya'll repeat everything someone said about xtina and past it on MC. Which is crazy. The "sane" fans only talk about the technique, not the artist them
You two got problems forreal. Mariah is not a Whitney never be. She came out 5yrs after whitney. Minnie inspired her to do the whistle register, but that's about it. sHe neva tried to be like Minnie. Mariah doesn't strain, but you can't wrap yo thick skulls around that fact. The only bad thing she does is Lipsynch, and again ya'll act like she do it all the time. If anybody's the copycat it's xtina because she tries to be soulful like Whitney and etta, tries to riff and run like mariah, she's
@MrXSTANx predictable is xtina stans who always keep mentioning the invalid title only called by justin nasal timberlake, that trolling stone flop list, and diplomatic praise by some singers. every time i meet xtina stans, they keep choosing one of the three points to show their favorite supposed superiority, which didn't exist. so yeah, who is predictable? oh the hypocrisy! next
@MrXSTANx If they could just admit that Moomoo isnt perfect and is off key and lispynchs alot of the time, I would understand thier argument, but they don't they watch Moomoo lipsynching and praise her miming, not here for that.
@MrXSTANx@XTINADISCIPLE Christina's voice has taken a massive nose dive, whereas Mariah's has actually perked up recently (2010). I'm not trying to dampen your enthusiasm for Xtina, I'm just saying that after years of forcing and straining, it's finally starting to take its toll.
Mariah carey because she sounds like she is not straining and because her singing always sounded pleasing to the ear. Even when SHE sings a whistle note. Christina is more or of a soul singer??
@kelvinpyaeko Manriah cant sing like she used to. never will be the voice again. you manriah stans are the deluded ones thinking she still got it. she sounds like ass. lost her voice at 30, went nuts at 30, she will always be second to whitney houston. but always 1st when it comes to lip singing. #LMAO
@MrXSTANx MANriah? i like the hypocrisy from you pressed xtina stans. i see you are pressed when someone called your favorite such low-life names. but anyway, where did i say she has still got her prime voice? now did i, bitch? NO. lol 'lost her voice at 30' oh the irony: that's what is happening to christina lmfao. babe, have you watched 'what happened to christina aguilera' video? she sounds so cute, tbh next>>>>
@MrXSTANx did i say 'never' bitch? NO...'the voice'? bahahaha it's whitney legendary houston's offical acclaimed title. stop snatching other people's wigs, honeypie. but wait, do you have to steal other people's titles too because your favorite 'the voice of our generation' title is invalid and disputable? i see!
@MrXSTANx lmfao...i feel bad for you. xtina will never be the voice. it's whitney's title. lmfao and even for the 'voice of our generation' title, how is it surfaced? oh i see, her friend named justin timberlake started it out, out of diplomacy, apparently. lmfao..poor thang
@kelvinpyaeko Not only been praised by justin but Etta James, andrea bocceli, aretha franklin patti labelle, Celine Dion, whitney houston, mick jagger, Bono, neeed i go on? Xtina is the voice! still at 30 years old. the youngest to appear on rolling stones's list of best singers at #58 while manriah was #72. she's done and out, karma got her fugly ass for being such a bitch to madonna and the rest of her peers
@MrXSTANx lmao..i am talking about her title 'the voice of our generation'. no one (etta, celine, whitney, patti, aretha) called her the voice nor the voice of her generation. oops so how could she be the voice? to her stans? ouch!!! like i said, check out that cute video and you'd see how she SINGS at 30 lmao. you mean trolling stone biased list? is that the only support you could give to defend? OH talk about karma, isn't it christina having karma in her life cycle right now, flopping? oops
@kelvinpyaeko Shes paid 4 million per hour a show, and the voice pays her enough to be the fat and rich. Mariah is fat, lip singing, flopping left and right, and lets not bring up glitter movie sales lmfao! and by the way you are right. Celine dion didnt call her the voice, she said "Christina Aguilera is the best singer in the world" look it up, poor moomoo the best lip singer of the world
@MrXSTANx lol a typical xtina stan: getting out of the toopic and starts bringing up irrelevant subjects. when did i talk about the voice, and in your case, movie? and the truth is even the movie is flopped, the glitter soundtrack sold more than burlesque soundtrack. so!!!! 'flopping left and right'? wait, what's so successful about bionic? oops there you go! what celine said is mere opinion! lmao where the facts are at? next
@kelvinpyaeko Same thing i could say about mariah. dummies like you saying shes the best is mere shitty opinion. fact is manriah stays lipping and flopping. and even though bionic flopped. Christina bounced back with the voice, poor moomoo..where is her bounce back from her last flop? HSN???a!!?? LMFAO
@MrXSTANx oh where did i say that mariah is the best? find me one comment, bitch where i said she is the best singer in the world or something. now you dare? 'bounced back with the voice'? like how? lmfao
@kelvinpyaeko The voice was #1 in ratings for weeks. it brought NBC back and she was paid more than the rest of the coaches. Moves like Jagger is a hit on itunes and the hot 100 sitting in the top ten. No HSN needed here honey
@MrXSTANx lmao...but do you know we are comparing singers who were born 10 years apart? where was mariah at 30? she was still making hits (not invalid hits like MIJ where she has to feature like what? 20 seconds? lmfao)
@kelvinpyaeko Its a feature with her name on it, 20 seconds or 1. mariah has done plenty of features, they count too right? point is everyone has a different opinion but there is no need to discredit the other to boost one up, which is what all xtina haters love to do. that's why i came at mariah the way i did because of the comments i read below.
@MrXSTANx It's unfortunate but it's true MC's voice is dead, whats really funny is what her delusional stans consider "singing" to be, she steps on stage, sings the easy bits live (sometimes even lipsynching the easy bits) and then when the big notes kick in so do her pre-recorded vocals, her stans watch her performances and clap like mindless apes, it's really very tragic.
If you listen to quality of their voices when they belt, you can hear that Mariah's notes come out with ease, whereas Christina's sound harsh and strained. I think Christina has a good voice, but anything above a B4 is a struggle for her.
Overall, Mariah's voice sounds fuller and more rounded in comparison.
is this any competition??? its Mariah of course duh! There needs 2 b a live vocal video comparing Whitney Houston and Mariah Carey because to me their 2 of the top female vocalists of all time Whitney's the only other female thats on the level of MC. It's a slap to MC's face to compare her to Mariah Carey wanna-be's such as Xtina smh get it together.
@dafuture93 whitney's never on the same level of Mariah's!!!
i think that it's cool 2 bring such a powerful singers like Christina or Leona with a huge name like Mariah,,,,,they r amazing 2.no1's like the other,but it's so fair 2 get Xtina here cause she's wonderfully unique as well,...........
btw,try 2 check out how Whitney's voice sounds now!!she's lost it while Mariah and the others r just getting better with old!
We all know that Mariah has a higher range and has a technical ability. She has a nice powerful and yet sweet voice. With christina, she strains has a bad technique. But who gives a damn with all that. Christina can make people drop their jaws at jump in concerts. She's one hell of a performer. Her voice suits well in every genre. Christina has soul. She can pull off every tributes she does. I dont care mariah's whistle. Christina's whistle n0tes is enough for me.
Mariah's Voice is Sweet and at the same time Strong but with an elegant and fresh tone, Christina has volume but she sometimes is like sreeching so Mariah objectively is the winner.
mariah isn't a queen of high notes.. but she's a queen of whistle.. maybe christina isn't a queen of high note also, but she's the queen of everything because she's the one who can sing all kind of musics
WHY DO PEOPLE ALWAYS TRY TO COMPARE CHRISTINA WITH MARIAH? THERE IS NO POINT OF DOING THIS...MARIAH'S VOCALS ARE BY FAR BETTER THAN CRISTINA'S...AND MARIAH IS THE QUEEN OF HIGH NOTES.
Anyone who tries to detract from either of these women vocally is pressed!
The Xtina/Mariah hater philosophies are so predictable as well. If Mariah has a bad day it means she can't sing & if she kills it then, of course, she must've been lipsynching! Xtina haters on the other hand, always bang on about her 'poor' technique, yet this woman's range is rivaled only by the legendary Ms. Carey herself & Chris can still sing ANY other modern female singer into submission.
Is that D6 Xtina does repeatly lipped/studio enhanced? It sounds so fuckin perfect.
shaunmike 6 days ago
@shaunmike Its her voice...but its studio
raveoni926 6 days ago
I love them both. I be lovin Xtina's rasp I just hope it gets healthier
shaunmike 6 days ago
I DISLIKE THE TEASE -_-
luvintheair123 1 week ago
xtina won.
jezzi665 1 week ago
Xtina all the way!!!! I dont care how much top comments Mariah have, of course she is good, but i prefer a rude and powerful voice
brandonlivega 2 weeks ago
can i have mariah's lady marmalade please?
AuliyaNoer 2 weeks ago
I find it so funny how Christina fans constantly refer to the 'voice of a generation' tag ONE magazine poll concluded with, especially compared to the countless polls, acolades, awards and critical acclaim Mariah has recieved over the years. Don't get me wrong, Christina can SANG, but that stupid tag means nothing. Every vocalist has been hailed 'the voice of their generation'.
BigBlyeEyes1234 2 weeks ago 2
@BigBlyeEyes1234 thats true, that tag means nothing, but we both know, she IS the voice of this generation, 1998-Now, just like Mariah and Whitney were on the 90s
brandonlivega 2 weeks ago
@brandonlivega Hmm, I guess. But arguably, so could Britney Spears (even though she sucks). She's had a lot of success and everyone remembers that 'oh babay babay' voice of hers... And that's why I think the 'voice of this generation' thing is so pointless - it doesn't necessarily mean she can sing.
BigBlyeEyes1234 2 weeks ago
ohhh poor fat frog, this mariah can not to be compared whit Xtina, it is the true, Xtina is the VOICE of her generation, in the roolig stone ranking, Xtina kick mariah's fat ass, so, i'm so so soooo sorry for you, LOOSER
fasayago 3 weeks ago
mariah owns the crown,christina the anthem horror isnt even halftalented!
keep dreaming hahahaha xtina stans, screamin loud isnt singing retards!
zanoases 3 weeks ago
Xtina can sing, act, and dance! she is an artist complete! no like this mariah
fasayago 3 weeks ago
mariah is the first female singer who has most number ones, writes and produce her songs, is idolized by christina and thousand of other international succesful singers, hahahaha she sold just with 2 records more then christina offkeylera ever will, while christina had her period, on a funeral singing stage and killed the anthem, never ever compare such untalented FLOP, who floped harder the anybody and cant sing live to legends like mariah who sang with michael jackson and whitney!
zanoases 3 weeks ago
Xtina wins! Xtina is better than this mariah who? go go go the only one, the new whitney houston, her name is: CHRISTINA AGUILERA yeha!
fasayago 3 weeks ago
Manriah sucks ass. And the worst thing... some performances u put of Slutriah are LIPPED. Unfair to Xtina. Very bias video.
Boulivard81 3 weeks ago
Christina winds... Mariah lose the voice
steinbeck19 3 weeks ago
Mariah wins easily.
CyprusHot 4 weeks ago
Check out my channel LAMBS
MsMCMariah 1 month ago
no they should never do a duet no way mariah is smart because christina will kill her on every note mariah is played out
bornstar20 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@bornstar20 If Mariah was also only 31 years old like Christina, then you know who would be slaying whom.
sandyzmz 1 month ago
@bornstar20 Christina's voice is louder but I don't think she is better than Mariah.
She can't sustain notes as well as Mimi and she doesn't have really pleasant belts as well
YeungTheSparkle 1 month ago
@bornstar20 christina has no technique and control,it's why mariah won't do a duet with her,go to singing class,it's what mariah'll say,christina's voice isn't more powerful,she screams too much and that fools you thinking it's more powerful,mariah's voice isn't at its prime beacuse she's been singing for 22 years,but she can still sing great,christina's voice isn't at its prime in less than a decade cos she didn't take care of her voice,mariah beats christina,mariah has big range and techniqu.
apio9 1 month ago
what's mariah song at 5:05 ???
marco1416 1 month ago
@marco1416 That is Stay The Night from The Emancipation if Mimi
YeungTheSparkle 1 month ago
mariah can belt, christina can strain and scream u.u overrated.
lucaschermontsantos 1 month ago
Whistle register of Mariah is clear. Mariah's High notes are so sweet, much better than Aguilera.
R4F4EU 1 month ago
CHRISTINA ..
aljanize 1 month ago
mariah carey is the best voice, but her music is not precious and special, if i i will choose christina because can sing alot of kinds of muisc, jazz, blue, pop, rb, but mariah just only pop and rb, so xtina u win
9738858 1 month ago
@9738858 mariah can sing any type of music that christina sings.
apio9 1 month ago
@9738858
Mariah can sing any of the genre you mentioned.
lizzyvance 4 weeks ago
I like how the person who made this video....opted out of putting Mariah's G7 notes on here.....We all know Christina could never!
CarlLeeHowell 1 month ago
What the heck the beginning?
Mairahforever96 1 month ago
@Mairahforever96
It was a hilarious MadTV Skit - Aries Spears as Missy Elliot - also too funny
OKzs 1 month ago
Guys come one, they both are great...
guydirrty 1 month ago
Mariah all the way!!!but why are y'all using old vids of her she can still hit the majority of those note today!!! And I agree they should sing together
luisboricua9 1 month ago
christina has actually got to be one of the worlds greatest singers, theres actually no singer who can belt the same as her
lukemichaelhenderson 2 months ago
@lukemichaelhenderson Are u sure? christina mostly finishes her belts in screams and her voice turns very screachy in the high notes. No one can belt like Whitney Houston, and this is general opinion. Mariah belted some great many notes in the 90's , now she isnt able to do that anymore. I think christina is overrated when it comes to her singing,her live performances are good but her singing style is very one dimensional.she's no match for Whitney in intensity and natural power.
sandyzmz 1 month ago
@sandyzmz mariah can still belt,not at her prime but she can still sing great,and now that she rested for 2 years,her voice has gotten stronger.
apio9 1 month ago
@lukemichaelhenderson That's because she doesn't belt, she shouts
STRATEKOOL15 1 month ago
Mariah on every note in every register.
Stefano94x 2 months ago in playlist Uploaded videos 3
mariah = G#7 .. highest
firdyXIAOs 2 months ago
well,Mariah Carey for me,no doubt :))
but i wish Mariah and Xtina will do a collabo together..:))
GhenMariahyonce1995 2 months ago
Mariah Can Sing a G2 So She Dominate the Low Notes, Mariah Can Belt an A5 And not only That She Has showed That She can Belt a F5 2 or 3 consecutive times!! And She Has Hit an amazing G7 and not only That also she can Sustain a D7 For more than 10 seconds So For Me Mariah is the best Singer, Christina Is Talented but She is a beginner compared with Mariah!!
ivennein 2 months ago
i prefer aguilera she is the best for me, but mariah is so talented too, they should sing together
BluesInTheNight18 3 months ago
Mariah Carey is The Best
piterpz 3 months ago
I couldn't choose, they are both great and both deserve to be appreciated.
gaara125able 3 months ago
Xtina !
aNdiiiziiiThoOo 3 months ago
Mariah on every Note!
christopherducati 3 months ago 16
3:20 was she singing Vision Of Love? OMG yass amazing young Xtina sannggg
sxcjojo2env2222 3 months ago 3
@sxcjojo2env2222 I know right!! gotta love xtina!!
raveoni926 3 months ago
Mariah's gotta a better overall range, and definitely has more control over whistle register. But Christina dominates the low range, and gets way better volume; there's a reason they call her "The Voice", you know.
Mariah's voice is also much clearer; she doesn't add that rasp that Christina does very often. Personally, I like girls with that raspier tone in their voice (P!nk anybody? :D ), so I prefer Christina.
Monjaru 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Mariah can't be compared! She's unique!
Thifny 3 months ago 2
Comment removed
Thifny 3 months ago
i prefer MARIAH CAREY she have stronger voice and XTINA isnt nice for my ears
edsssooonnn 3 months ago 18
@edsssooonnn lmao christina voice is wayyyy more powerful
bornstar20 1 month ago
i prefer xtina she have stronger voice and carey isnt nice for my ears but they should sing together and show all this commercial untalnted bitches like rihanna gaga madonna perry etc what treu talent mean
BluesInTheNight18 3 months ago
I like Christina better her voice just sounds better especially the notes in "Ain't no other man" and "Fighter"! Mariah has a better vocal range but her voice sounds boring! and besides she's not really around any more.
MrKarltonn 3 months ago
Mariah ... :)
Litalici0us 3 months ago
No body can't stop mariah ... love u mimi
lukman15081985 4 months ago
lol Christina of course....
UndeadEmperor2 4 months ago
Mariah Carey is #1 Queen Forever and always~~~ Christina has a good voice but when she sings high she strains her voice too me.. And its agervating... Mariah Carey has a more natural powerful voice!!! And Her 90s era was an Extrodinary time but Now its Even better!!!! Her voice more machure and more stronger~~~~ MARIAH ALL THE WAY 4ever!! CRT FOREVER
ILoveMcWhMj4ever 4 months ago
I prefer Christina here. However Mariah can do better :)
ForeverComplaining 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I'll go with Mariah coz her whistle notes are incomparable and I am one of her BIG fans (Bias? LOL) but Christina is not too far from her. XD
JustCallMeKikko 4 months ago
Comment removed
JustCallMeKikko 4 months ago
Love em both...
atrayu90602 5 months ago
haha :D eventhough there is a Teaser video of mariah .. It's Mariah ofcourse :)) 4ever :)))
NiRie017 6 months ago
where is the G#6 of love takes time? what performance is it?
iiAmitx3 6 months ago
Christina aguilera shout, MARIAH better!
sergyngs 6 months ago
@sergyngs Thank you! at least someone knows the facts here =)
vicshang 5 months ago
I Want Some One To Show Me One Video Where She Did Anything Just Like Mariah Because I NEVER Seen It
AnonymousXtinaSinger 6 months ago
selves cause that's low and immature. If you can't accept that Mariah's the far better vocalist then that's a problem, but you can't honestly sit there and say xtina is a better Technician? Come on now, that's crazy. That's like someone saying Aretha franklin has no soul and that billie holiday had a 6 octave range. Delusional. who you perfer is alright but.....why am I givin a speech to people ova the internet? ya'll ain't go listen anyway. I'm not ya'll mama. Bye.
MrButler124 6 months ago
even stolen a few runs from Mariah, and she tries to whislte like Mariah, and she tries to belt like she just Aretha franklin. The sad thing is that she does have a soulful voice, but tries too hard to be soulful, she always uses melisma inapropratley and she could be a high belter if she didn't sing from the throat and had bad placement. Fact is ya'll repeat everything someone said about xtina and past it on MC. Which is crazy. The "sane" fans only talk about the technique, not the artist them
MrButler124 6 months ago
You two got problems forreal. Mariah is not a Whitney never be. She came out 5yrs after whitney. Minnie inspired her to do the whistle register, but that's about it. sHe neva tried to be like Minnie. Mariah doesn't strain, but you can't wrap yo thick skulls around that fact. The only bad thing she does is Lipsynch, and again ya'll act like she do it all the time. If anybody's the copycat it's xtina because she tries to be soulful like Whitney and etta, tries to riff and run like mariah, she's
MrButler124 6 months ago
What is that on the floor ? #Oop it's Mariahs wig, X just tore it off.
XTINASDISCIPLE 7 months ago
@XTINASDISCIPLE Moomoo fans are so predictable
MrXSTANx 7 months ago
@MrXSTANx predictable is xtina stans who always keep mentioning the invalid title only called by justin nasal timberlake, that trolling stone flop list, and diplomatic praise by some singers. every time i meet xtina stans, they keep choosing one of the three points to show their favorite supposed superiority, which didn't exist. so yeah, who is predictable? oh the hypocrisy! next
kelvinpyaeko 7 months ago
@kelvinpyaeko Pointing out the facts that you moomoo fans cant stand and have to live with lmao
MrXSTANx 7 months ago
@MrXSTANx and ain't i right with the fact that you xtina stans are desperate and predictable, too? oops
kelvinpyaeko 7 months ago
@MrXSTANx If they could just admit that Moomoo isnt perfect and is off key and lispynchs alot of the time, I would understand thier argument, but they don't they watch Moomoo lipsynching and praise her miming, not here for that.
XTINASDISCIPLE 7 months ago
@XTINASDISCIPLE its true, they talk about xtina's voice but mariah slacking so they shouldnt even say anything about "straining"
MrXSTANx 7 months ago
@MrXSTANx Poor APEriah :( a failed Whitney Houston/Minnie Ripperton never-be
XTINASDISCIPLE 7 months ago
@MrXSTANx @XTINADISCIPLE Christina's voice has taken a massive nose dive, whereas Mariah's has actually perked up recently (2010). I'm not trying to dampen your enthusiasm for Xtina, I'm just saying that after years of forcing and straining, it's finally starting to take its toll.
imafan123456 6 months ago
@XTINASDISCIPLE fail flop xtima.
BeyFan3000 6 months ago
@BeyFan3000 LOLz
kelvinpyaeko 6 months ago
@BeyFan3000 Xtina - 50 million records sold WW, Yonka - 23 million sold WW, find a seat.
XTINASDISCIPLE 6 months ago
@XTINASDISCIPLE Beyonce 100 mill WW
Mariah 200 mil WW.where Xtina.aww nice though.
BeyFan3000 6 months ago
@BeyFan3000 100 million ? HAHAHAHAHA LOL BWAHAHAHA, Xtina > Yonka #dealwithit
XTINASDISCIPLE 6 months ago
@XTINASDISCIPLE yup and 4 is a WW success.stop hating and deal cus beyonce is da king.
BeyFan3000 6 months ago
@BeyFan3000 hating ? sweetie, I left a comment here and you responded to me, if you don't like being owned, don't do it again #DISMISSED
XTINASDISCIPLE 6 months ago
@XTINASDISCIPLE how is yonka anyway?
BeyFan3000 6 months ago
ALSO it is funny how we have to end in Christina's vocal range, while Mariah's goes all the way to the seventh octave.
MC7368 7 months ago
@MC7368 roft at 7th octave. need i say more? these manriah fans are delusional as ever
MrXSTANx 7 months ago
Mariah carey because she sounds like she is not straining and because her singing always sounded pleasing to the ear. Even when SHE sings a whistle note. Christina is more or of a soul singer??
MC7368 7 months ago
Christina Aguilera hands down...Mariah's lip singing notes are ok though..
MrXSTANx 7 months ago
@MrXSTANx 'lip singing notes'? bitch you are deluded. oh i see. you are a xtina fan, so that's common
kelvinpyaeko 7 months ago
@kelvinpyaeko Manriah cant sing like she used to. never will be the voice again. you manriah stans are the deluded ones thinking she still got it. she sounds like ass. lost her voice at 30, went nuts at 30, she will always be second to whitney houston. but always 1st when it comes to lip singing. #LMAO
MrXSTANx 7 months ago
@MrXSTANx MANriah? i like the hypocrisy from you pressed xtina stans. i see you are pressed when someone called your favorite such low-life names. but anyway, where did i say she has still got her prime voice? now did i, bitch? NO. lol 'lost her voice at 30' oh the irony: that's what is happening to christina lmfao. babe, have you watched 'what happened to christina aguilera' video? she sounds so cute, tbh next>>>>
kelvinpyaeko 7 months ago
@kelvinpyaeko never lip singing like manriah. Christina is the voice ugly deal with it
MrXSTANx 7 months ago
@MrXSTANx did i say 'never' bitch? NO...'the voice'? bahahaha it's whitney legendary houston's offical acclaimed title. stop snatching other people's wigs, honeypie. but wait, do you have to steal other people's titles too because your favorite 'the voice of our generation' title is invalid and disputable? i see!
kelvinpyaeko 7 months ago
@kelvinpyaeko Whitney and Xtina are the voices. lip singing notes by manriah are ok though
MrXSTANx 7 months ago
@MrXSTANx Manriah has a beautiful title, "the lipsynching songbird" :)
XTINASDISCIPLE 7 months ago
@MrXSTANx lmfao...i feel bad for you. xtina will never be the voice. it's whitney's title. lmfao and even for the 'voice of our generation' title, how is it surfaced? oh i see, her friend named justin timberlake started it out, out of diplomacy, apparently. lmfao..poor thang
kelvinpyaeko 7 months ago
@kelvinpyaeko Not only been praised by justin but Etta James, andrea bocceli, aretha franklin patti labelle, Celine Dion, whitney houston, mick jagger, Bono, neeed i go on? Xtina is the voice! still at 30 years old. the youngest to appear on rolling stones's list of best singers at #58 while manriah was #72. she's done and out, karma got her fugly ass for being such a bitch to madonna and the rest of her peers
MrXSTANx 7 months ago
@MrXSTANx lmao..i am talking about her title 'the voice of our generation'. no one (etta, celine, whitney, patti, aretha) called her the voice nor the voice of her generation. oops so how could she be the voice? to her stans? ouch!!! like i said, check out that cute video and you'd see how she SINGS at 30 lmao. you mean trolling stone biased list? is that the only support you could give to defend? OH talk about karma, isn't it christina having karma in her life cycle right now, flopping? oops
kelvinpyaeko 7 months ago
@kelvinpyaeko Shes paid 4 million per hour a show, and the voice pays her enough to be the fat and rich. Mariah is fat, lip singing, flopping left and right, and lets not bring up glitter movie sales lmfao! and by the way you are right. Celine dion didnt call her the voice, she said "Christina Aguilera is the best singer in the world" look it up, poor moomoo the best lip singer of the world
MrXSTANx 7 months ago
@MrXSTANx lol a typical xtina stan: getting out of the toopic and starts bringing up irrelevant subjects. when did i talk about the voice, and in your case, movie? and the truth is even the movie is flopped, the glitter soundtrack sold more than burlesque soundtrack. so!!!! 'flopping left and right'? wait, what's so successful about bionic? oops there you go! what celine said is mere opinion! lmao where the facts are at? next
kelvinpyaeko 7 months ago
@kelvinpyaeko Same thing i could say about mariah. dummies like you saying shes the best is mere shitty opinion. fact is manriah stays lipping and flopping. and even though bionic flopped. Christina bounced back with the voice, poor moomoo..where is her bounce back from her last flop? HSN???a!!?? LMFAO
MrXSTANx 7 months ago
@MrXSTANx oh where did i say that mariah is the best? find me one comment, bitch where i said she is the best singer in the world or something. now you dare? 'bounced back with the voice'? like how? lmfao
kelvinpyaeko 7 months ago
@kelvinpyaeko The voice was #1 in ratings for weeks. it brought NBC back and she was paid more than the rest of the coaches. Moves like Jagger is a hit on itunes and the hot 100 sitting in the top ten. No HSN needed here honey
MrXSTANx 7 months ago
@MrXSTANx lmao...but do you know we are comparing singers who were born 10 years apart? where was mariah at 30? she was still making hits (not invalid hits like MIJ where she has to feature like what? 20 seconds? lmfao)
kelvinpyaeko 7 months ago
@kelvinpyaeko Its a feature with her name on it, 20 seconds or 1. mariah has done plenty of features, they count too right? point is everyone has a different opinion but there is no need to discredit the other to boost one up, which is what all xtina haters love to do. that's why i came at mariah the way i did because of the comments i read below.
MrXSTANx 7 months ago
Comment removed
kelvinpyaeko 7 months ago
@kelvinpyaeko fail flop xtima
BeyFan3000 6 months ago
@MrXSTANx It's unfortunate but it's true MC's voice is dead, whats really funny is what her delusional stans consider "singing" to be, she steps on stage, sings the easy bits live (sometimes even lipsynching the easy bits) and then when the big notes kick in so do her pre-recorded vocals, her stans watch her performances and clap like mindless apes, it's really very tragic.
XTINASDISCIPLE 7 months ago
Christina Aguilera Back then and now. Mariah back then....not now
crazyworldwelivein12 7 months ago
If you listen to quality of their voices when they belt, you can hear that Mariah's notes come out with ease, whereas Christina's sound harsh and strained. I think Christina has a good voice, but anything above a B4 is a struggle for her.
Overall, Mariah's voice sounds fuller and more rounded in comparison.
imafan123456 7 months ago
Mariah Carey won.
pinko7589 7 months ago
The Legendary Mariah Carey-Cannon>>>>The Other Chick
QueenMariahCarey 7 months ago
Christina holds her own. Mariah is not better.... They are both good.
atrayu90602 7 months ago
Mariah is so much hotter and beter singer fuk that chihuhua
luisboricua9 7 months ago
also the the effortless C#5's frm Mariah are the best eva
Shazni1409 7 months ago
i love the tease parts their funny but u shud have put them i a seperate vid really and plus it's gd vid Mariah all the way no competition
Shazni1409 7 months ago
XTINA :)
MrJsmoore 7 months ago
i love them!!
Mrcamilu22 7 months ago
is this any competition??? its Mariah of course duh! There needs 2 b a live vocal video comparing Whitney Houston and Mariah Carey because to me their 2 of the top female vocalists of all time Whitney's the only other female thats on the level of MC. It's a slap to MC's face to compare her to Mariah Carey wanna-be's such as Xtina smh get it together.
dafuture93 8 months ago 25
@dafuture93 whitney's never on the same level of Mariah's!!!
i think that it's cool 2 bring such a powerful singers like Christina or Leona with a huge name like Mariah,,,,,they r amazing 2.no1's like the other,but it's so fair 2 get Xtina here cause she's wonderfully unique as well,...........
btw,try 2 check out how Whitney's voice sounds now!!she's lost it while Mariah and the others r just getting better with old!
AbdullahBreikat 4 months ago
@dafuture93 Mariah is good but than again so is Christina aguilera, I believe they are the same, as far as talent
richardpearce400 3 months ago
Mariah of course
Raoulirshan 8 months ago 17
@11:34 can you please tell me where u got that? Or a link on here on YouTube? thnkx
DanielAvilaAGT 9 months ago
Mariah Carey's E6 notes are just sexy
Bigchriztian01 9 months ago
@raveoni926 why do u need to put the >tease part< HUH??!!
MARIAH ALL THE WAY
30mav97 9 months ago
@30mav97 So ppl wouldnt think that is was spam video when they first begin watching
raveoni926 9 months ago
@raveoni926 ...hmn.. ok.. well that was a great video.. but it will be perfect if u take out the tease part!
30mav97 9 months ago
@30mav97 it did it to make it different and interesting
raveoni926 9 months ago
@raveoni926 --> well .,, i just hate it hahha..! but i like when u put new clips !! :))) great job..
30mav97 9 months ago
@raveoni926 why do u need to put the >tease part< HUH??!!
MARIAH ALL THE WAY
30mav97 9 months ago
7:29 is Xtina's best attempt at an F5. It didn't sound pinched and like she was gasping for air like all her other ones.
AMOBBDOWNNE 9 months ago
mariah is twice the vocalist christina is
MrSoulshock4444 9 months ago
snijders30 10 months ago 2
@snijders30 Like people do not jump, scream, pass out and lose their minds when Mariah comes on stage. WE lambs LOOOVE her.
initochanchan 8 months ago
what song is this 10:23 (mariah carey)
12Jeancr 10 months ago
@12Jeancr the song is == get your number
kloskal 9 months ago
wow I love that christina Eb5 @ 5:20 but ima still go with Mariah. glad to see so many different clips used here
xolilbraxo1993 10 months ago
@xolilbraxo1993 yea thats one of my favorite clips from this video...and thanks bcuz i was tired of seeing ppl use the same clips over and over ughh!
raveoni926 10 months ago
sometimes christina screams!!! mariah is much better...
aNdReW16944ever 10 months ago
Mariah Carey all the way !
bishona 10 months ago
Queen Mariah Carey>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Xtina
DON'T EVER COMPARE A QUEEN LIKE MARIAH TO Xtina!!!
QueenMariahCarey 10 months ago
OOOOOHH whats the song from 10:12-10:18? It sounds awesome!
capcomfighter13 10 months ago
@capcomfighter13 its the remix to Mariah Carey's song "All I Want For Christmas Is You"
raveoni926 10 months ago
@raveoni926 Thanks, dahling!
capcomfighter13 10 months ago
@capcomfighter13 welcome!! make sure u rate sub and favorite...and watch my other stuff ;)!
raveoni926 10 months ago
Carey on every note except the G6.
Devotedlamb19 10 months ago
I love at 05:59 the eb5 is literally coming out of her mouth lol
LollipopBling 10 months ago
02:12 "unless this don't sell - then i'm going right back to be a whore"
this was prophetic :)
MrJudube 10 months ago
@MrJudube christina isn't a whore she a chameleon!
raveoni926 10 months ago
@yhjkl Christina performed songs from the album Bionic on the MTV Awards
raveoni926 10 months ago
Even with this being kinda one sided with tina based on the video choice Marian still eats it
Antboogie0828 10 months ago
I love both! this is hard, but i prefer xtina! I love you too mimi! U_U
dimryman 11 months ago
Mariah's Voice is Sweet and at the same time Strong but with an elegant and fresh tone, Christina has volume but she sometimes is like sreeching so Mariah objectively is the winner.
ivennein 11 months ago
mariah isn't a queen of high notes.. but she's a queen of whistle.. maybe christina isn't a queen of high note also, but she's the queen of everything because she's the one who can sing all kind of musics
chintyaLOVEchristina 11 months ago
you need a power to sing beautifully..that's christina...
chintyaLOVEchristina 11 months ago
Mariah wins with no effort at all!
musicguy713 11 months ago
wow, xtina slayed fugriah.
XTINASDISCIPLE 11 months ago
Two words: Mariah Carey! :)
sonekkinha 11 months ago
WHY DO PEOPLE ALWAYS TRY TO COMPARE CHRISTINA WITH MARIAH? THERE IS NO POINT OF DOING THIS...MARIAH'S VOCALS ARE BY FAR BETTER THAN CRISTINA'S...AND MARIAH IS THE QUEEN OF HIGH NOTES.
beachfanatic2010 11 months ago
Both are great singer
But I prefer Christina Aguilera, She is a performance, she sing amazing..She inspire me...and sing every kind of music she wants...
vanylc99 11 months ago
Anyone who tries to detract from either of these women vocally is pressed!
The Xtina/Mariah hater philosophies are so predictable as well. If Mariah has a bad day it means she can't sing & if she kills it then, of course, she must've been lipsynching! Xtina haters on the other hand, always bang on about her 'poor' technique, yet this woman's range is rivaled only by the legendary Ms. Carey herself & Chris can still sing ANY other modern female singer into submission.
They're both legends!
Fresocable 11 months ago
MARIAAAAAAAAH
2iLLustRioUs4U 11 months ago
lol
xtina´s the best...!!!
9david9100 11 months ago
Mariah slayed with no effort.
Stefano94x 11 months ago