Yûsuf Estes has even warned against Hamza Yusuf.. i think it was him you meant.
And I've read a pdf from Bilâl Phillips, he said the sufis mixed islâm with their cultures when they became Muslims i,e Iranians mixed islam with fireworshipping, indians with hinduism, africans with african dancing etc.... May Allâh reward you akhî.
What is it with these "Sufi Masters" knowing things that they should not know? Where I come from many people who have had sihr done on them have gone to "sheikhs" and before they could even talk, this "sheikh" just suddenly knew everything about the person and their family's history...and that is one of many things...which include very disturbing stuff..I think the answer lies only in one category...you call this Islam? Audhubillah!
I love you for the sake of Allah and love all your lectures!! Keep up the good work inshAllah brother and may Allah reward you and increase you in knowledge!!!
It is not at all. There are more calamtious facts I missed or id not have time to mention. If you are speaking of Zuhd, then these two are not related and a Sufi today is not a Zaahid, he is a Jaahil
@herndonboy13 i don't see it as biased..how can you say biased? Tasawwuf?!? How can something that is not from the time of the Prophet SAWS even be CONSIDERED whether it's tasawwuf or satawwuf or anything?!? BIDA'AH!
And for the record..i've seen videos of what these sufis doo.piercing yourselfs and making sujud to your "masters"..Astagfirullah!
?? I hope no one understood from my speech that I said Thikr is Haraam! How can that be? It is a sunnah to say these 33 times Tasbeehaat.... I was referring to the Sufi invented Thikr and not the one taught by the Prophet.
Masha Allah akhi.. You've explained the points so beautifully! Indeed your reward is with Allah!
The explaination you gave about dhikr of "Allahu" is so true.. I've read it once from a magazine published by Jama't-ad-Da'wa (I hope you might have heard about it).
You are so right.. According to people, if one is not practicing sufism, he is wahabi (like its a bad word).. My family wasn't completly sufi.. But as soon as we changed our ways, people of our area have started calling us wahabi..
@idrisfaiz I quote "this is guy is idiot". It shows from your language and sentence structure who the real ........ is. Subhaanallaah who disgraced you for your transgression and did not grant you the success to use better words or even construct a correct sentence.
What a waste of time and letters. Another classical example of the feeble-minded Sufis. Just in case some people did not believe the content of the lecture, Pandittjee proves everything I said to be correct.
by allah this guy is right i heard that myself that sufis does claime these things . sufis rong they do say things like oh muhammad sws existed befor any human being.
@AAAjMMMiRRR And now show me the application of this Ayah in the actions of the messenger. Who understood the Ayah best? Did he ever say Allaah or ARahmaan only. Prove it, if you can't, stop commenting and wasting time.
@OneWayToParadise --fighting bidah is straight path and I agree with the video but sometimes it's just going too far. If you read the seerah and life of the sahabas, you will see that they showed love in a way that he (SAW) didn't directly teached them. There is also extremism in fighting bidah, the middle way is the best way, Allah knows best...
@AAAjMMMiRRR But the messenger of Allaah's warned us plenty against introducing anything into the Deen.. So many narrations. How then would we understand them? Also, what they did and he approved is a Sunnah. So it can not be labeled as a Bid'ah.
@OneWayToParadise Constructive discussion: the first verse of surah 55 is Ar-Rahmaan and it is a complete verse. Is it wrong to repeat one ayat? Is it wrong for an 'Abd to say the name of his Rabb 'Allah' over and over again? it is a dhikr - remembrance. Can we write a different salaam? Is it bid'ah to do this? Owais Qarni (RA) wrote dua's related by Ali (RA) which our Prophet (SAW) did not teach. Is it bid'ah? wats ur view?
@AAAjMMMiRRR Yes it is wrong to repeat the Ayah as a Thikr. Can you get an Ayah from the book of Allaah and turn it to a Thikr? Again, did the messenger of Allaah do that? It's so simple so don't complicate it. Whatever the messenger did not do, tell us to do, or approve during his time, is an innovation.
Great lecture, my whole family is sufi and I tell them almost everyday that some of the things they do are not from the sunnah, but they shrug it off.
@dreamlx33 Akhi. Please read the book of Imaam AnNawawee RyiaduSsaaliheen, go to the chapter on backbiting, then read the 6 excpetions mentioned there. Hamza Yusuf has been advised by many brothers and he made not changes nor did he take heed, It is an obligation to warn against him. We need to be united upon the truth and not simply united.
Asalaamu Alaikuum. Mash Allah you are blessed with a lot of knowledge brother, but I wonder if it is correct for you a very knowledgeable muslim to criticize another muslim brother so openly. You should have more athab than this brother, if you want to talk about Imam Hamza, then why do you not speak to him directly instead of talking about him based on hearsay. Surely you know better. Asalaamu Alaikuum.
@dreamlx33 Wa Alaykum Assalaam. As I clearly mentioned in the lecture(maybe you haven't watched that part yet), it is necessary to warn the Muslims from individuals who are off track. Speaking to him has nothing to do with warning the Muslims against him. Please refer to the works of our scholars in order to learn more about this brother. Also, many others have warned against him as well. Did you ever wonder why? Oh, by the way, he is not "Imam" Hamza... That's a heavy title there Akhi.
Don't assume that what is true about someone is true for somebody else based on generalizations. Not all sufis are alike just like not all shia, sunni, salafi etc are alike. Hamza Yusuf is an incredible man of immense knowledge and I would make 70 excuses for him before even thinking about going after his aqeedah. And I also disagree that simply saying the word "Allah" is sacrilegious, the speaker is a young man and he needs to watch what he says.
@ImyManz99 Dear Brother, I am not assuming anything here. I have solid facts that are available for all to see on Hamza's site. Further, on what basis do you make the claim that repeating the word "Allaah" is acceptable? Did the messenger of Allaah or the companions do it? Finally, I, "the young man", am older than you. :)
@OneWayToParadise Asalaamu Alaikum. My understanding of Shariah is that everything is permissible unless proven otherwise. Summoning the name of the Creator (any 100 of them) is an act of remembrance and worship by itself, it may be inferior to saying SubhanAllah or adding something meaningful, but it is still dhikr nonetheless. We were created to remember Allah, so give your brother the benefit of the doubt.
@ImyManz99 Wa Alaykum Assalaam, Beloved Brother, your understanding is very much off. Concerning acts of worship, everything is impermissble unless there is an evidence which allows it. If that was not the case, then the people would come up with new acts of worship everyday... Answer the simple question, did the messenger of Allaah remember Allaah is this fashion? If not, can anyone worship Allaah better than him? Also, we were not created to remember Allaah. We created to be slaves and worship
Yûsuf Estes has even warned against Hamza Yusuf.. i think it was him you meant.
And I've read a pdf from Bilâl Phillips, he said the sufis mixed islâm with their cultures when they became Muslims i,e Iranians mixed islam with fireworshipping, indians with hinduism, africans with african dancing etc.... May Allâh reward you akhî.
TheMuslim0 9 months ago
May I know who this Sheikh is?
I would like to know his name, please. JazakAllah!
muddz7 10 months ago 2
Who is this brother. What are his Qualifications for speaking? Just curious. I want to know who i am listening to insh'Allah.
xxxlilk 10 months ago 6
What is it with these "Sufi Masters" knowing things that they should not know? Where I come from many people who have had sihr done on them have gone to "sheikhs" and before they could even talk, this "sheikh" just suddenly knew everything about the person and their family's history...and that is one of many things...which include very disturbing stuff..I think the answer lies only in one category...you call this Islam? Audhubillah!
CGJUGO80 10 months ago
I love you for the sake of Allah and love all your lectures!! Keep up the good work inshAllah brother and may Allah reward you and increase you in knowledge!!!
MrAsad1230 11 months ago 2
Im so confused i sunnism and wahhabism same? May Allah keep me and the Ummah on the Right path.Ameen.
tarin638 11 months ago 2
brother i love you for the sake of Allah . great lecture! mashAllah
samia7756 11 months ago
hes very extreme.
syedrasheed23 1 year ago
brother u have so much noor on ur face plzz make duaa for me and i realy like the work u doing to expose deviant sects .
choudry7861 1 year ago
mashaAllah such a great talk!
littlemisshijabi 1 year ago
Salamallaikum bro, i gotta admit i love ur lectures ( na7sabuk 3la 5air isA)
May Allah bless u
ahmed2437 1 year ago
I've got to admit this is a very biased view of tasawuf
herndonboy13 1 year ago 2
@herndonboy13
It is not at all. There are more calamtious facts I missed or id not have time to mention. If you are speaking of Zuhd, then these two are not related and a Sufi today is not a Zaahid, he is a Jaahil
OneWayToParadise 1 year ago 6
@herndonboy13 i don't see it as biased..how can you say biased? Tasawwuf?!? How can something that is not from the time of the Prophet SAWS even be CONSIDERED whether it's tasawwuf or satawwuf or anything?!? BIDA'AH!
And for the record..i've seen videos of what these sufis doo.piercing yourselfs and making sujud to your "masters"..Astagfirullah!
CGJUGO80 1 year ago
also brother I was wondering is dhikir really haram?like for example sometimes i say
Allah is great 33times,subhanallah33 times,allhmdulliah 33 times and etc.
lail111 1 year ago
@lail111
?? I hope no one understood from my speech that I said Thikr is Haraam! How can that be? It is a sunnah to say these 33 times Tasbeehaat.... I was referring to the Sufi invented Thikr and not the one taught by the Prophet.
OneWayToParadise 1 year ago 13
i'm so confused and saddened by the state of the ummah I can't believe ppl strayed so far from the correct path of the sunnah.may Allah guide us all.
I knew were divided into sects but I had no idea it was this serious.
do these ppl never read the Quran or read the hadiths?
lail111 1 year ago 15
Masha Allah akhi.. You've explained the points so beautifully! Indeed your reward is with Allah!
The explaination you gave about dhikr of "Allahu" is so true.. I've read it once from a magazine published by Jama't-ad-Da'wa (I hope you might have heard about it).
You are so right.. According to people, if one is not practicing sufism, he is wahabi (like its a bad word).. My family wasn't completly sufi.. But as soon as we changed our ways, people of our area have started calling us wahabi..
lipglosse87 1 year ago
this is guy is idiot..may Allah show this guy a straight path ameen..
idrisfaiz 1 year ago
@idrisfaiz I quote "this is guy is idiot". It shows from your language and sentence structure who the real ........ is. Subhaanallaah who disgraced you for your transgression and did not grant you the success to use better words or even construct a correct sentence.
OneWayToParadise 1 year ago
@idrisfaiz Don't use abusive language.. & don't use your own interpretation if you do not have the knowledge..
May Allah open our hearts to accept the right knowledge..
May Allah guide all of us towards the Right Path & let us not astray from it. Ameen!
lipglosse87 1 year ago
wahaabi kalamah BIDAH , BIDAH , BIDFAH , BIDAH , BIDAH , BIDAH ,BIDAH , BIDAH BIDAH ,BIDAH BIDAH BIDAH BIDAH BIDAH BIDAH BIDAH BIDAH BIDAH BIDAH BIDABH BIDAH BIDAH BIDAH BIDAH BIDAH BIDAH BIDAH BIDAH BIDAHG BIDAH BIDAH
pandittjee 1 year ago
@pandittjee
What a waste of time and letters. Another classical example of the feeble-minded Sufis. Just in case some people did not believe the content of the lecture, Pandittjee proves everything I said to be correct.
OneWayToParadise 1 year ago
@pandittjee
o yes they love this one very much !
OldschoolPokemon 1 year ago
by allah this guy is right i heard that myself that sufis does claime these things . sufis rong they do say things like oh muhammad sws existed befor any human being.
javed119 1 year ago
@AAAjMMMiRRR And now show me the application of this Ayah in the actions of the messenger. Who understood the Ayah best? Did he ever say Allaah or ARahmaan only. Prove it, if you can't, stop commenting and wasting time.
OneWayToParadise 1 year ago
@OneWayToParadise --fighting bidah is straight path and I agree with the video but sometimes it's just going too far. If you read the seerah and life of the sahabas, you will see that they showed love in a way that he (SAW) didn't directly teached them. There is also extremism in fighting bidah, the middle way is the best way, Allah knows best...
AAAjMMMiRRR 1 year ago
@AAAjMMMiRRR But the messenger of Allaah's warned us plenty against introducing anything into the Deen.. So many narrations. How then would we understand them? Also, what they did and he approved is a Sunnah. So it can not be labeled as a Bid'ah.
OneWayToParadise 1 year ago
@OneWayToParadise Constructive discussion: the first verse of surah 55 is Ar-Rahmaan and it is a complete verse. Is it wrong to repeat one ayat? Is it wrong for an 'Abd to say the name of his Rabb 'Allah' over and over again? it is a dhikr - remembrance. Can we write a different salaam? Is it bid'ah to do this? Owais Qarni (RA) wrote dua's related by Ali (RA) which our Prophet (SAW) did not teach. Is it bid'ah? wats ur view?
AAAjMMMiRRR 1 year ago
@AAAjMMMiRRR Yes it is wrong to repeat the Ayah as a Thikr. Can you get an Ayah from the book of Allaah and turn it to a Thikr? Again, did the messenger of Allaah do that? It's so simple so don't complicate it. Whatever the messenger did not do, tell us to do, or approve during his time, is an innovation.
OneWayToParadise 1 year ago
@AAAjMMMiRRR Are you better guided that the Messenger of Allaah?
OneWayToParadise 1 year ago
Great lecture, my whole family is sufi and I tell them almost everyday that some of the things they do are not from the sunnah, but they shrug it off.
Btw brother, what is your education.
heronhorde 1 year ago
@dreamlx33 Akhi. Please read the book of Imaam AnNawawee RyiaduSsaaliheen, go to the chapter on backbiting, then read the 6 excpetions mentioned there. Hamza Yusuf has been advised by many brothers and he made not changes nor did he take heed, It is an obligation to warn against him. We need to be united upon the truth and not simply united.
OneWayToParadise 1 year ago 2
@OneWayToParadise Jazak Allah khair, I will read this book insh Allah. I wasn't aware there were exceptions to backbiting.
dreamlx33 1 year ago
Asalaamu Alaikuum. Mash Allah you are blessed with a lot of knowledge brother, but I wonder if it is correct for you a very knowledgeable muslim to criticize another muslim brother so openly. You should have more athab than this brother, if you want to talk about Imam Hamza, then why do you not speak to him directly instead of talking about him based on hearsay. Surely you know better. Asalaamu Alaikuum.
dreamlx33 1 year ago
@dreamlx33 Wa Alaykum Assalaam. As I clearly mentioned in the lecture(maybe you haven't watched that part yet), it is necessary to warn the Muslims from individuals who are off track. Speaking to him has nothing to do with warning the Muslims against him. Please refer to the works of our scholars in order to learn more about this brother. Also, many others have warned against him as well. Did you ever wonder why? Oh, by the way, he is not "Imam" Hamza... That's a heavy title there Akhi.
OneWayToParadise 1 year ago
jazakAllahukhair
citacitasejati 1 year ago
Don't assume that what is true about someone is true for somebody else based on generalizations. Not all sufis are alike just like not all shia, sunni, salafi etc are alike. Hamza Yusuf is an incredible man of immense knowledge and I would make 70 excuses for him before even thinking about going after his aqeedah. And I also disagree that simply saying the word "Allah" is sacrilegious, the speaker is a young man and he needs to watch what he says.
ImyManz99 1 year ago 4
@ImyManz99 Dear Brother, I am not assuming anything here. I have solid facts that are available for all to see on Hamza's site. Further, on what basis do you make the claim that repeating the word "Allaah" is acceptable? Did the messenger of Allaah or the companions do it? Finally, I, "the young man", am older than you. :)
OneWayToParadise 1 year ago
@OneWayToParadise Asalaamu Alaikum. My understanding of Shariah is that everything is permissible unless proven otherwise. Summoning the name of the Creator (any 100 of them) is an act of remembrance and worship by itself, it may be inferior to saying SubhanAllah or adding something meaningful, but it is still dhikr nonetheless. We were created to remember Allah, so give your brother the benefit of the doubt.
ImyManz99 1 year ago
@ImyManz99 Wa Alaykum Assalaam, Beloved Brother, your understanding is very much off. Concerning acts of worship, everything is impermissble unless there is an evidence which allows it. If that was not the case, then the people would come up with new acts of worship everyday... Answer the simple question, did the messenger of Allaah remember Allaah is this fashion? If not, can anyone worship Allaah better than him? Also, we were not created to remember Allaah. We created to be slaves and worship
OneWayToParadise 1 year ago
asalamo alaikom warahmatullah wa barakatuh
jazakAlah khair brother this is very important
but where is the rest
i have been waiting for something like this
jazakAllah khair brother
AYEMAQ 1 year ago
@AYEMAQ wa 'alaykumus-salaam wa rahmatuLlaahi wa barakaatuh,
wa iyyakum. we're still in the process of uploading all parts. we'll publish it once everything's been uploaded inshaa-Allaah.
OneWayToParadise 1 year ago