Beyonce Knowles vs. Charice Pempengco (E5 - G#5 LIVE)

[kelvinpyaeko]

my god..there wouldn't be anything more annoying than karaoke-rice's voice...bee doesn't even have to try

[Fattakink]

where is that Jumpin Jumpin F#5 from?

[ablackguy123456789]

beyonce hands down! charice won the G5 and G#5. though she is very impressive but she's very one-dimensional. she has no style of her own and she has yet to sing her own song(s).

[Stefano94x]

Beyonce slayed Charice's karaoke ass.

[Davines27]

Beyonce!

[jwaggerz]

Beyonce, with ease. Better technique. 

[Leinard04]

I don't understand y people say that one singer is better than the other just because she hits higher notes?! Bee doesn't just hit high notes, she sings with a lot of emotions. Happy, angry or sad, u will really feel it from her. Not to mention her excellent facial expressions. Charice hits high notes brilliantly, no doubt about that. But her style has always been the same. All songs are sung the same manner, especially at the bridge to end part. I guess u know what i mean.

[porschetweety]

@Leinard04 Charice style is the same and that is what makes her unique and original. that she is not influenced or changed by the world but stays her true self.

[Leinard04]

@porschetweety Unique? Original? Says who? Her style is very Whitney, Celine, J Hud.......Pleeeease, no one in the biz has been original since the 2000's. Not even Bee or Gaga.

[Soom342]

Just look at the last note G#5.

Than you'll know, who can hit and hold better the high notes.

Moreover, Charice can vibrate and hold G5, which you can't see in this video.

I hate those comparisons between fans, but I have to say that Charice ' HAS NEVER LOST'

[stardusth2o]

Beyonce won easily.

[math11as]

charice holds high notes longer

[lightningshock12]

Who ever said Beyonce won should go jump out a window and kill themselves. From E5 and up, in this video, HOW IN THE WORLD could you possibly begin to say that Beyonce is better than Charice? I don't understand that at all. It takes just one ear to be able hear that Charice is obviously the better singer. BETTER SINGER, and that's a fact. How could you dare say Beyonce is a better singer than her? You're obviously not using your ears to determine this. Charice is by far better, hands down.

[kelvinpyaeko]

@lightningshock12 yep, charice is a better KARAOKE singer lmao

[ChariceBillboard]

charice won by landslide

[brownchix18]

Beyonce is Talented ! Over talented .. Charice is efortless , she doesn't even know how to impress.

[9481bdaybeyonce]

beyonce

[iCharlie94]

You sing AND dance AND try to sound good while doing it then you call me. To the person who said she's passed Whitney and Mariah, you MUST be dumb.

[yongsua1989]

Beyonce has better voice control than Charice.

[aftertonight13]

I'm being completely unbiased right now as I'm in love with both their voices, but it's obvious that Beyonce is superior. Period. She is the superior vocalist, singer, and musician. I bet a real musician or voice major would agree. Any musicians or voice majors on here that wanna back me up?

[ChariceBillboard]

charice G#5 is effortless proven she can way alot higher

[55hotshit]

Beyonce uses special effects to carry out her notes.... Charice all the way

[pritykazy]

beyonce, she is singing with her own style, and she is singing in her natural tone, she not lowering her larynx just to sound thicker and rounded ala whitney like charice,.. BEYONCE OWNS!

[yongsua1989]

@pritykazy Agreed.I prefer Beyonce because she naturally born to be a dramatic voice type singer and she has superior vocal control.Unlike Charice,lowering her larynx to get big fat tone,sometimes her super high chest register is uncontrollable.She need voice control.

[tiklovesaom]

beyonce!!!! duh! charice is good but no where near Beys level.

[ladyvampire0295]

I' m sure those who SIDED on CHARICE are Filipinos...

don't be biased.

[Ruboanti]

@ladyvampire0295

I know Beyonce is more popular, but I'm sorry Charice is clearly a way better singer...

[ladyvampire0295]

@Ruboanti no!..she will not rise to popularity without her OUTSTANDING SKILLS!!!..let's compare the sales of their album?..and back on Destiny's Child..Beyonce already possessed ORIGINAL STYLE!..unlike that pepe..that pepe who sounds like jojo,..mariah,..beyonce..lady gaga..and anything more..she is not identified as charice. So how can you say pepe is CLEARLY A WAY BETTER SINGER??!..when you cannot declare the uniqueness in her style??..argue??

[Ruboanti]

@ladyvampire0295

I'm not talking about style, I'm talking about her singing, Charice is a way better singer... Maybe not a better artist, but yea, a better singer, indeed.

[wjaniban12]

@ladyvampire0295 im a filipino ! but i love beyonce . i do liked her style and voice when singing. she amazes me everytime she performs. it's an insult to beyonce to compare her to a thick, fat, skunk, smelly mammal! haha

[ladyvampire0295]

u all look-like a pepe!

why are you comparing Beyonce to Charice??

we all know that Beyonce is fucking TRILLION WAYS BETTER than this OVER-ACTING FEMALE artist(??)

she has no fight when it comes to ORIGINALITY and she has no SENSE OF SINGING STYLE!!!

CHARICE HAVE TO EAT MILLIONS OF KILOGRAMS OF RICE WITH RICE STALK TO BE ABLE TO BE AT THE SAME LEVEL WITH BEYONCE!!

Beyonce ROOOOOOOCCCCCKKKKKKKSSSSSSSS TRILLION TIMES!!!!

oh' c'mon??

who wants to argue with me??

[beyrock]

My gosh, if you try to compare their voices, Beyonce just stands up and Saaaang those notes, I appreciate Charice's Effort but The way I see it, Man she's struggling...

[daiell09]

Beyonce is waaaay better! She can dance and sing and still sound good. =)

[ChariceBillboard]

I can't even hear Beyonce G5 AND G#5

[FiskHandlarn1]

@WhitneyElizabethH

There is no link.

But if you call MJ's family or something they can confirm it :)

[daiell09]

Beyonce Duh. She doesn't even have to try. Charice is good, but yeah....

[FiskHandlarn1]

Those who comments against charice here.

Havent checked her up at all.

She can't dance?

MJ Invited her PERSONALLY to dance and sing with on his last tour.

She can DEFFENTLY sing and dance same time. Stop hate on a little girl :)

Thank you!

[WhitneyElizabethH]

@FiskHandlarn1

Lol post the link where MJ asked her, i highly doubt it

[FiskHandlarn1]

Just want to say something..

Charice didnt have any PROFFESIONAL Vocal training not til the age of 18.

She's 12-14 in mostly of those videos.

in 1, 11 years..

Take her age double with proffesional training.

There is no doubt chariec will become the greatest singer the world has ever known.

[UttRenier]

charice, so clear and consistent voice.. beyonce has shaky voice.

[MrSoulshock4444]

charice has a bigger voice, but i don't think she's a better singer

[cleoalba]

charice all the way..

[aaronpaul8]

and if you're a good critic you will see the truth... charice hit and hold the notes and belt it to a high note to the highest note, she don't need to do add libs because she can sustained the high notes with her powerful chestvoice charice's videos here was not her best unlike beyonce if you're going to watch all her videos you will hear add libs and add libs and why she's ding that? because she can't sustained the high notes CLEARLY i'm not saying beyonce is not good but i'm juz stating facts

[aaronpaul8]

yeah beyonce is more successful and more popular than charice but the reality was charice is better.. why? at her young age she can overcome all divas like beyonce, christina a., celine, whitney, mariah and etc. no offense but that's the fact.. you can watch charice's videos and you will see... peace........

[alishatat]

but what about Declan Galbraith

No comparable

Declan is the best

[lovindacheese]

Charice doesnt even come close to Beyonce....and never will.. so guys lets stop comparing cus it pointless

[Breniznit]

@lovindacheese But erm? Charice's g#5 just ate Beyonce's and her vocal cords aren't even completely developed yet . She may not be as popular as Beyonce but sorry she won in this video, plus Charice managed too hit eb6 as well and Beyonce only did exclamations.

[lovindacheese]

@Breniznit its not about how high you can sing, its about power, pitch, stamina and also beyonce is one of the greastest performers to this day!! so eat that bitch!

[Breniznit]

@lovindacheese Hon, Charice was more on pitch and was more solid with that g#5 then beyonce was, hate too stab you with the truth but that's what it was.

And eat what? are you suggesting i should take a chunk out of your thigh? If so im sure there is enough for you too share with the rest of youtube,anyone else want some cellulite?

[WhitneyElizabethH]

@Breniznit

Brendy, the FROG SUCKS lol

[Breniznit]

@WhitneyElizabethH Yeah but the frog is also only like 16 years old at the time..

[WhitneyElizabethH]

@Breniznit

im kiddin with ya

[Breniznit]

@WhitneyElizabethH If i didn't know you were kidding ..i wouldnt have called charice 'the frog' twice in a row : /

[HUGOM2C]

Charice is damaging her voice, her notes aren't natural at all, you must not known anything about vocals. By lowering her larynx to add power to her voice, she loses resonance and she actually sounds forced (a-la Christina Aguilera). You can see in her face that the notes she reaches aren't confortable.

[WhitneyElizabethH]

@HUGOM2C

lol HA!

how long does she have before she starts deterioating?

[Jared95C]

@HUGOM2C Or maybe the faces are for emotions also? Cause she doesn't struggle with them, but it does sound forced and her tongue is never relaxed idk haha.

[thedrakkarnoir]

Charice isn't even in her prime yet :| 

[ltgen22]

Charice no match for Beyonce...

[09393687221]

beyonce syempre

[beyrock]

Whoever Puts this video lacks in knowledge.. As we all know there are certain Facts that put CHARICE to shame. Let us all see, that in all video posted, All were live and compared to Beyonce's performance, She was singing while dancing and hitting those notes. Beyonce can kill Charice if they were on a Showdown especially live. With that type of vocal ability, im sure , It'll be a piece of cake.

[beyoncetyrafan]

@beyrock i agree 100% charice doesn't know how to dance and sing at the same time, she on;y knows how to sing, i'm not a hater i just hate it when people make stupid videos like these. Just stop making videos related to beyonce if there;s any negative thing in it. Thankyou

[mcronde]

@beyoncetyrafan What are you saying!!! watch Charice singing "I wanna dance with somebody" so that you can see Charice singing and dancing at the same time!!!!

[daiell09]

@beyrock Thank you!

[lc0309]

anybody can be better than beyonce ! that's easy fo charice

[killerflick]

@lc0309 Lol you must be smoking some crazy shit if you are saying Anybody can be better than beyonce

[austinfrombustop]

@lc0309 Beyonce hater

[abut0]

you guys really cant compare the two best singers..

they both superb lungs to bang those freakin high notes

[agators212]

such a short video...haha...there are better notes from charice now that she's been on tour with david foster for quite some time now

[yahiie]

charice is already better than her. At least in belting notes above F5.

[VoceGuru]

Charice is superb!!!

[ayyyitsmeee]

i love beyonces e5

[garakyut24]

beyonce hits the high notes effortless unlike charice..

[garysazon]

ano b discussion d2,galing o taas ng boses?hay nku ang mga pinoy tlga,sobrang naive.mkrinig lng ng mtaas n boses mgaling n.that's not what singing is all abt. d ptaasan ang lbanan. pgandahan! vocal production.now,whther or not you can hit a hi note,it's only 2ndary.kc kng taas lng pla ang basehan e d tumili k lng pla psado ka ng singer.e d sna sumikat c regine worldwide @ na-outpace nya pa c mariah & whitney kc mas mtaas ang chest voice nya kumpara sa 2. di yan pataasan mga ating.just so u know.

[idolfun14]

charice sings listen by beyonce better...Charice of course....beyonce can't sing anything other than R&B....charice can sing pop and rock and of course R&B better than beyonce....

[wjaniban12]

@idolfun14 my God !!! did i just read "beyonce can't sing anything other than R&B??" . hahahah .. have you watch her movie cadillac records ?! Damn . she can sing jazz, blues amazingly soulful. c'mon. your writings apparently proves that you don't know Queen Bee that much! unlucky you. lol :)))

[MrKrisAlejandro]

beyonce is better than charice . charice is bullshit!!!! do not compare her to beyonce beyonce is the best!!!!

[mrsaraholic]

@MrKrisAlejandro

y r u saying bad words?....y cant u accept dat not all people like beyonce...

me honestly i like charice better than beyonce...

[VoceGuru]

@mrsaraholic So do I!!!

[headpimpincharg]

Beyonce is the queen;]

[Jaleelsinger]

beyonce won sorry charice has a beautiful voice tho... but beyonce won beyonce didnt even have to try

[aNdReW16944ever]

E5:tie

F5:beyonce

F#5:beyonce

G5:charice

G#5:charice

FOR ME...CHARICE IS MUCH BETTER IN VERY HIGH NOTES (G5,G#5)....

[Jaleelsinger]

gud opinion but i think beyonce won... wait why r we comparing a girl to a women? lol

[marrisah]

Beyonce won!!!! hands down...whats wrong wit yall?

[BenjoTube09]

beyonce is better for fashion..

charice better to sing!

beyonce cannot birit! whistle

[jEeVeH]

beyonce is better..

charice is also good but she shouts and needs so much effort only to sing high notes..

beyonce sings very effortless...

[mrsaraholic]

@jEeVeH

but i think charice can reach high notes compared to beyonce...

[jEeVeH]

its okay..

im a filipino and im proud of charice..

but charice shouts and beyonce not really.. =]

[jEeVeH]

@mrsaraholic i don't care.. hha joke only... but i really love beyonce than charice.. sorry..!!

[Giuse94LoveBee]

@mrsaraholic so what?

[mrsaraholic]

@Giuse94LoveBee

so what mo mukha mo!...

[xLilLadyMcgx]

charice is great but beyonce definately beats her voice and performance wise DEFFO. did you see how much more effortless beyonce's performances were?

[thaqsonoran]

What's the song when Charice hit a G#5

[jd8391]

I believe (the one fantasia and diana degarmo sings in american idol)

[mazda1979]

beyonceeeeeee is a diva better vibrato and color voice,charica is more stronger voice

[andrewlavigne]

Charice is better at belting. But if we go beyond sustaining that particular belted note, I prefer Beyonce's vocal color and agility.

[naxXo0]

Beyonce is way better but Charice is good :)

[FASHO111DOPE]

BEYONCE IS THE BEST FA-SHO  Charice is good BUT BEYONCE IS WAY BEtter that is a fact people!!!!

[MinaLoveLove]

dang charice u go girl. i wish she would make a

[ramliug]

beyonce has beautiful voice, proportion to her beautiful face,

beautiful body and beautiful soul!!

charice has big voice, proportion to her big face that looks like a full moon!!!

ha ha ha!!!!

[DisszWun94]

Deep ahaa! LooooooL.

[strumx1]

omg how dare you compare beyonce to charice who is she next to charice

[mazda1979]

charice is a graet singer but BEYONCE is the QUEEN.beyonce 4ever

[JAYRYANTV]

damn charice just blew her away

[xxoxxemmaxoxx]

E5- Charice

F5-Charice

F#5- Beyonce

G5- Charice

G#5- Charice

[rjg89]

charice rules.. lmao

[T2luvs]

E5-Beyonce

F5-Charice

F#5-Beyonce

G5-Charice

G#5-Charice

[observer00100]

go home B!just write songs and charice will handle them! lmao!

[Angelfully]

Both are great

[CCcream11]

Can you people stop the name calling it ain't that serious you guys get so competitive they are both great why does there even have to be a best singer anyways!!!!

[musickidjg]

beyonce and charice are great! also tiffany evans! go to musickidjg please

[6426524]

beyonce era

[kennetskyz]

lipsync?? i think you searched for britney spears not beyonce !! :)

[xmavrawr]

lol why are you comparing a woman to a girl

beyonce is in the peak of her career

and charice is just starting

give her time to improve

you'll never know charice will be better than her

[deadworms]

@xmavrawr the point of the video was that it was trying to compare the vocals, not the career.

[yahiie]

@xmavrawr she already is :)

[4oki4e]

@xmavrawr and what you see a video of beyoncewhen she was young ..even there she is beter than charice I think the people are strange they say they love beyonce but what I dont know its my opinion but charice dont have this strong and powerful and amazing voice like beyoncce~!!

[xxmuzicchickxx]

they're both great singers i don't understand the need to post hateful comments every time there are 2 talented women on yt. and i also really don't understand why they're being compared.

[joshrexrode08]

maybe its just me but i think all of beyonce's live high notes are prerecorded because i here a lot of echo, she is a descent singer, but i think she yells more than she sings and her voice is not pleasing to the ears, just my opinion

[beyrock]

ahaha... precorded? shut up, she sings live everytime she performs.. duh..

[VOICESinONE]

Beyonce IS the best .

GET OUTTA THE WAY , Charice .

go the wherever the hell u came from!

[repentyourselff]

charice's G#5 is THE SHIT.

this is kinda tough...

[Cristiian007]

Beyonce is the best.

[blackpanthabites]

her lower range needs work alot it's boring really boring her high notes are the shit though but sing high isn't everything

i prefer beyonce anyday sorry!

[latinheat801]

First of all learn how to spell and then say something ok.

[damskooo]

yes its true beyonce has much better notes,.

lmao this video makes it seems as if charice is like close to bee rofl funny

[2scoopz]

Very biased. This guy is obviously a Charice fan. If youre gonna do a comparison video at least make sure all featured are actually featured equally. Beyonce has a range of E5s she hit in Ring the Alarm performances. Why werent they here? As for F5-F#5 Beyonce kills these in her Green Light performances. Where were they? G#5 Beyonce did in a live performance of Deja Vu and in her performances of Suga Mama. She does the note numerous time in Suga Mama performances. Why was 3 to 4 seconds shown?

[latinheat801]

You cant totally see and hear Charrice beat the hell out off bee in all the notes bees notes seam like she has to yell to hit the notes while charrice notes sound more pleasing and i dont care what other crazy delusional beyonce fanatics think.

[damskooo]

go sleep bish.

lmao charice better then bee not in her wildest dreams.

o and she will never be considerd as one of the great vocalist.

lmao get your babystrain staning ass outta her fool

[mazda1979]

ＢＥＹＯＮＣＥ　is the queen.

[tisoy001]

You used better examples of Charice hitting the notes in your other compilation against Celine Dion.

v=iHQjtlgefTk

[warmildred]

charice is the next big thing!! i tell u...

[91BROWNIE91]

beyonce's range is not as high as this girl. Beyonce's voice is more beautiful and pleasing to the ear. Beyonce makes you feel what she's singing.

[suhsforever]

Just the fact that she's being compared to Beyonce, a major star already. And she just a 16 year old girl (15 in most of the clips here). Being compared to Beyonce, noticed by Ellen, Oprah, David Foster and the likes, out of all the talents here in youtube. Says a lot in itself about how incredible this girl really is. Charice is phenomenal, that's it. Beyonce's a star already, no doubt. But Charice is going and starting to be one too, no doubt...

[arkibytz]

those clips are bias!try all charice vid those higher version of those songs...c'mon!i love beyonce too but i know charice is better!

[Fletchou]

Beyonce

[damskooo]

beyonce.

[khyrk]

wow beyonce is good, but charice is the better belter

[Radioslmfao]

Wtf are you deaf... no offense Charice is a great belter, but Beyonce was off the chart. Beyonce's belt was WAYYY more powerful and she can actually sustain a note longer than Charice. The only note i liked from Charice was the F5, G5, G#5 everything else was ok.

[agators212]

how can you say charice can't sustain notes longer than beyonce? charice holds the higher notes longer than beyonce. for a 16 year old and has that much control already at the top of her range is awesome. beyonce is awesome also, love her new song, but she's a lot like christina. vocal runs all over the place. but in terms of singing a song straight she's ok like her version of "at last". etta james still sings that song better than anyone else.

[CFNumeroUno]

Wow, I didn't know Beyonce was this damn good. Charice, I already knew...Beyonce, not so much.

[Maryara87]

Maybe is the eco, but I gotta a dificult time to realize what's live or not from B.

Anyway, as a belter, Charice.

[drxclassic2]

wow, charice is a great belter. really good. but that's it.

[Got2BeDowne69]

charice! charice has a powerful voice than beyonce!

[1991keith]

Beyonce

[xxoxxemmaxoxx]

E5- Charice

F5- Charice

F#5- Beyonce

G5- Charice

G#5- Charice

Love Beyonce though!!!

[theasiancountries]

I really dunntorte believe it but charice wins....