wish you were here

[gobbledygook1980]

i think these guys should stick to the shit they make themselves instead of taking the piss out of musical masters like pink floyd.

[kingofthephonies]

This is ridiculous. Pink Floyd should never be covered, but this is a new level of bullshit.

[olimpiax]

he has big talent..

[Y2Kevo]

way to destroy a classic about Syd Barrett by adding a bunch of bullshit that was never in the original song to make it about terrorists.

[longitudes]

100% agree

better sparklehorse and radiohead cover

[i723]

this is the death to music

[mnkypoofling]

fed durst has no talent......

[roxydog2004]

Yeah but these guys are singing wish U where here for a whole nother reason and they worked it

[oltyger]

I like limp bizkit

i love it

this cover is great

but pink floyd is beter in this song

much beter

but this is really limp bizkit style

[LOCXP]

You got to hand it to them...

Who?

Blind prostitutes!

That's a joke. Just like getting Fred Durst to cover a such a great song. That was painful. Better go listen to some Pink Floyd

[Twiztednate]

Did these guys even listen to the song before they decided to play it? Like come on, Pink Floyd should bitch slap Fred Durst.

Pink Floyd forever!

[JoshHawkinsMK]

Honestly Fred Durst doesn't have much talent.

[NilleZack]

just great!

[Karaadam]

I LOVE This! Thanks! :)

[jeijei7]

k-pedo-con-la-letra?

k-asco

[jamesasn]

eres nada como dices k que pedo con esa letra no sabes nada de musica solo te gusta la mierda que cantan, ni se que asco tu

[jeijei7]

io-me-refiero-a-los-cmabios-k-­lehicieron

obvio-k-se-cual-es-el-origen-p­orque-pink-floyd-es-mi-grupo-f­avorito

i-si-tienes-razon-tocan-pura-m­ierda

esos-dos

[jamesasn]

siendo asi ten pido disculpas es que me da malgenio, que alguien diga algo sobre temas como este, son himnos del mundo del rock'n roll no tenemos la culpa que manes como estos imiten un tema como este que podemos hacer

[jeijei7]

:)

ntp

no-me-di-a-entender-jaja

claro-que-es-un-himno

aunk-ia-no-estan-dos-de-ellos

syd-i-rick

pero-bueno-les-keda-esta-grand­iosa-cancion

:)

[dinosaurjerk]

very move

[Area5107]

Considering the circumstances, and I'm not a fan of LB, that was pretty good.

[superfrog1000]

i love limp bizkit..

but i don't like this cover..

and if durst was going to sing this, do you not think he might want to when wes has left? =P

but yeah, its alright =\

[projektmachineshop]

VanCityKyle, you're an idiot

1. This isn't the second best version. It was really good (considering how bad LB sucks) but Velvet Revolver takes second.

2. LB is just a poser version of RATM so don't say RATM sucks and like LB.

[outerheaven8]

LB and Rage are nothing alike.

[Raminator5651]

I thought this was good.....

[IH8WRONGPPL]

Given the situation of the world at the time, this hit me and i thought it was good.... Sorry it doesn't "flow good enough" for others in this time...... FFS, it was about 9/11 and they poured their hearts into doing this, even with broken hearts just like every other sane, moral human being.... I remember Fred Durst saying how nervous he was to do it, but tried to do the best he could given short notice, and not being really his style to begin with.

[lyssus]

That was one bad version. Fred Durst is a mediocre singer and not worthy to sing this. And i hate the fact that he decided to modify the lyrics. What an ass!

[jranner]

not so good. check out velvet revolver's version instead.

[l3umblexl3ee]

they kinda just jumped into singing lol no solo but still pretty good, pretty good

[tori13vc]

its different with soo much meaning from it cuz of 9/11--pink floyds original is still the best but this was a great collaberation for a great cause, and the meaning is awesome, i think floyd would approve...

[reefeo99]

its not that good!!

[VanCityKyle]

Second best version of this song! Um Pink Floyd is the first!!

[hillznit87]

I don't really like any of the bands these guys are in  but they did a great job on this cover

[AlDelu0x]

ODIO TUTTO QUESTO DELAY!!!

[roxydog2004]

Wow what a way to cover a song

[atom2009]

Actually I don't like anyone doing Floyd but I really enjoy this version. Fuck korn

[RustyRyan5]

My fav cover ever!

[lordbibi]

VanCityKyle... you're fucking weird... Sorry, maybe Fred Durst had some "talent", but never as good as Pink Floyd... He's not a legend! This song is holy shit from his mouth, and PINK FLOYD ARE WAY BETTER THAN LIMP FUCKING BIZKIT! He's an ass hole, like someone who said LIMP BIZKIT ARE WAY BETTER THAN PINK FUCKING FLOYD....... you.

[VanCityKyle]

Well in my opinion i think that limp bizkit are really under rated! And Pink Fucking Floyd are way to over rated! "Oh look at me im in pink floyd and i sing with a mellow voice and our guitars sound really cool, oh and everyone likes us cuz were Pink Floyd" Shut the fuck up!!

[lordbibi]

You're right, Limp Bizkit are under rated, but in my opinion, and for mostly people, Pink Floyd is not over rated... they are innovators, specials, and yes their guitars sounds very cool... Wish you were here is an incredible song, and I just want to say that from Fred Durst, no sense!!! But with each one is opinion!

[VanCityKyle]

Obviously Pink Floyd are innovators and revolutionarys in the music industry! A lot of my comments were totally exagerrated! I just think that Fred Dursts appeal was that hes just an average looking guy who doesnt have the best voice or image in the music industry, but he did lead a generation of teenagers, and i was one of them! they were everyones high school band from 99-01! Same with Eminem!

[VanCityKyle]

Yes Rage Suck! But Smashing Pumpkins are really talented and always have quality material! I just kind of lost interest when Billy Corgan did the solo thing and the Zwan thing! But im kind of glad there back! Apparently there new album kinda sucks but at least they have dozens of old classic album material to play at live shows! Billy should grow his hair back!!!

[VanCityKyle]

One band that im really dissapointed that came back were smashing pumpkins! Not to say there new music isnt good, its just not relevent to music today! And i fucking pray that Rage Against The Machine doesnt come back!!

[lordbibi]

Oh I pray with you, please not Rage Against The Machine!!! But Smashing Pumpkins is not too bad, I like certains of their songs. I'm agree with you, Fred Durst/Limp Bizkit leads our high school generation, I'm 22, I remember that, and Eminem too! How I liked him!!!

[VanCityKyle]

Well technically Eminem never fell off! You have to remember that his last album sold around 18 million copies worldwide! 50 cents best album sold 11 million worldwide! So Eminems skills maybe not as great as say "The Eminem Show" but still very relevent! I mean his greatest hits sold 5 million! I cant wait for shady to drop a new album!

[jneka]

suck me!!! ratm come back & no one can't stop them now!!!

[VanCityKyle]

Nobody will even bother to try to stop them! RATM is way overrated! Same with Sublime. Kid Rock and Limp Bizkit are way better than them!

[aannaam]

who the hell are RATM anyway?

[VanCityKyle]

Rage Against the Machine=RATM!!!

[aannaam]

yeah i know their name. but like..i've never heard of them before u mentioned them.

[VanCityKyle]

Probably cuz they suck ballz and everytime i hear them on the radio i just turn them off!! Rage Against The Machine suck ballzzzzzzz!!!

[knailed]

???

[letsgocubs13]

It pisses me off even more that he changed the lyrics. It wasn't all that horrible, but at least sing the right fucking lyrics.

[NorwegiaWeightlift]

That was completely garbage. Fred Durst should stick to his own music

[jonletter]

wow, what a kick in the shins to pink floyd, this is a hilariously horrible "performance". can't believe some people here actually think its good, maybe try getting your fucking heads out your asses.

[aannaam]

what the hell are u talking about? your comment just proves how narrow-minded u are and nothing else.

[tori13vc]

it was a good cover, and i think u need help big time with that anger issue.

[tori13vc]

anger issue 4 jonletter

[nemesis50]

cool

[Majinius]

word :D @tag3434

[tag3434]

i bet you guys can do better but you rather stay in your bedroom all day

[pretaanluxis]

John Otto kicks ass

[starkey1988]

what is everyones problem with Fred Durst?

[jonletter]

hmm lets see, he butchered a classic, all his albums are complete garbage, he is a product of mtv that the kiddies just eat up.

[starkey1988]

lmfao

[VanCityKyle]

I think that fred durst's voice is wonderful. I think that this version is way better than pink floyd. Oh and yes all three of their albums were pure classics and really led a generation of angry teenagers into a fun place! I think that Eminem and Fred Durst sparked a flame for the industry today! FRed should do a solo album!!

[jonletter]

Canada eh? figures.

[VanCityKyle]

Oh and i suppose you guys think that Eminem has no talent either! Just listen to Freds vocals, you can tell he puts his heart into his music!!! Why are you guys even on this page if your dissing Fred! Whatever i still support anything fred durst does!You guys have to remember that from early 99 to late 2003 fred durst sold over 40 million albums! And you all bought at least one of them!!

[kennjad]

why am i on this page? becaus i was looking for videos from PINK FLOYD... a band with actual style and talent... fuck your opinion... its wrong... and no... i did NOT buy one of limp bizkits shitty albums... even when i was 12 years old i still knew they fucking blew

[VanCityKyle]

Ha thats funny because 45 million people across this planet did buy Limps albums. I bought all 4 and they are all a masterpiece! LIMP BIZKIT ARE WAY BETTER THAN PINK FUCKING FLOYD!!

[kennjad]

i really need to stay of these comment boards... i wanna fuckstart your head you piece of shit... but i cant... because youre nothing but words... i hope you get hit by a truck...dumbshit mother fucker

[VanCityKyle]

Yeah i went a little far with my comments! I know that Pink Floyd is way more legendary than Limp Bizkit! But im fucking sick of people always dissing Fred Durst, He has more talent than most rockers out there, and he can rap better than most rappers out there. Sorry if i offended you, i hope i get hit by a truck too, well whatever your opinion is as valid as mine! IT TAKES A MAN TO REALIZE WHEN HE'S WRONG!!!

[kennjad]

but you havent realized youre wrong... you still think fred durst is an "unsung hero"... and im sorry ive offended you... but you are wrong... it has nothing to do with floyd being more legendary... it has to do with floyd being better... period... and this cover was wrong... period... and im done with you......... period

[danathomas316]

the lyrics were meant to be relevant to 9/11. WOW! so quick to hate on Freddy D LMAO j/k. Still, i thought it was alright and im a fan of Pink Floyd

[jamesblake1]

oh holy fuk dear lord no...someone please remove this... i have no more words

[Tabbueno]

I like it.

[gambit1337]

Fred Durst is the biggest asshole in music for last few years.

[VanCityKyle]

Fred Durst is one of the unsung heroes of our generation. I think he and Eminem sparked a revolution. I wish that Fred Durst would release a solo album in the near future! I FORGIVE ALL THE HATERS FOR NOT SEEING THE TALENT THAT FRED HAS...

[Danf9687]

troll

[jonletter]

"Fred Durst is one of the unsung heroes of our generation" omg please tell me you're kidding either that or you are really fred durst.

[idividebyzero]

Damn that sucked. Roger Waters and Eric Clapton did this at the tsunami donation thing, its a stark contrast in quality. They show how you change songs without making them retarded.

[JujuZer0]

WTF ?

Let's say it's not a cover, and they wrote it a few minutes before the show, and it happens to look a bit like a well known Pink Floyd song ...

(If it's really a cover it's really outrageous :D )

[thejoshuatree13]

gong

[lovethebass78]

They fucked up a very legendary song. The members of Pink Floyd are going "pull the plug!!!!"

[ph51]

wtf is this shit?

[Kazmarazin]

This is truly the most painful, mediocre and ridiculous cover ever made. Please leave Pink Floyd music alone...

[carlosariars]

This is quite a nice cover which is quite different from the original. I'm tired of unoriginal cover of Wish You Were Here. I also noticed they changed the lyrics slightly. Oh well. It's good, nonetheless.

[NBT1313]

I liked this cover actually but I would've preferred the Goo Goo Dolls to have done it alone. But still, I enjoyed the performance just as much as when I first heard it.

[Timpossible999]

i like this cover

[Ezelrengo]

ok... this is the way to ruin that song. Just.. painful

[hungrybiatch]

You people are fucken haters fred rocks dude people really gotta stop talking shit about him and limp bizkit i got mad respect for them.They dont need fucken wes borland

[kennjad]

wes borland was the only talent IN that shitty excuse for a band... fred durst is waste... his musical ability and talent is non existant... fred does not rock. fred blows.

[VanCityKyle]

Wes borland has no talent compared to Fred! How many albums has Wes borlands band sold! umm next to none!

[wwjohan]

wycleaf jean makes the best cower of this one i think

[short2003]

awful, they demolished it..

[pretaanluxis]

John Otto's got to be one of the most groovy drummers ever

[Krista87Bryan85]

wes borland performed that song pretty good

[bizkit01]

nice

[scaylor]

This is like writing a love a song for your woman then having some fag sing it about his man. And I'm not even against gays.

[freakinsic]

once again freddy destroyed a classic:) he sure knows how to do that dont he

[Kongenpaahaugen]

great... loved it

[GNRsakuL]

i don't like Fred much or even Goo Goo Dolls but this song was performed good that's for sure!

[kennjad]

get raped

[dannycarr40]

Man i love pink floyd

and how dare they changed the lyrics to 1 one the greatest songs ever

notice why freds voice has lots of effects... its because its shit!!

[Tecato22]

Fuck ya' self haters. Stick yourself up in the ass. You're so fuck'd up ignorant and kind'a fools y'all. I'm gonna throwin' up. Oh my fucking god.

Whats the matter with Fred? He sings better than others singers from bands like the fucking creepy Black Rebel Society.

You probally got no flava for music.

[kennjad]

whats the matter with fred? hes a waste... hes contributing to the shittiness of my generations music... and ive got no "flava" for music? i guarantee i do... c i like REAL music... radiohead.. pink floyd.. led zeppelin.. the doors.. FUCK FRED DURST!!!

[jonletter]

fuck yeah, durst sucks ass. yorke is surperior to durst both lyrically and rhythmically. and this just reconfirms my believe of how shitty a musician durst was.

[kennjad]

YORKE IS A GOD

[ibey]

oh man, that was shit, i dont care if it was for charity, u wood b better off using one of ur own songs than take some one elses and changing it, fuking tits!!

[kennjad]

FUCK YOU FRED DURST!!! this is terrible... ne1 that thinks this is good? ur stupid.. sorry not tryin do b a music nazi... truly im not... but this SHOULD NOT HAVE BEEN DONE!!! it was written bout syd barrett... not fucking freedom... GET A DIFFERENT SONG FOR FREEDOM!!!

[coondogtheman1234]

Hey Fred Nice Hat Man GO YANKEES

[quebecross]

Johnny Rzeznik sounds great doing this song...

[alexchiu]

i think jonny reznik was good the guitars but fred durst singing!? wtf that was crap

[SetnaroX]

Not the best version of "wish you were you here". The notes are too low and a bit flat. And why the new set of lyrics?

In it's own way, it's ok. But as a re-edition of a classic song, it's too inferior. Sorry Goo Goo Dolls/Fred Durst.

[Kornspel]

It sucks!!!

[KyraBearraRoxie]

yes and limp bizkit rocks

[elaparato]

fuck the haters

[kennjad]

fuck you

[JohnaldChaffinch]

what i find sick about this is that he cant even move up a note at times in the melody to make it sound right, he just flaots around on the same note. what a daft tit.

[egluze]

yea.. :D

[wasps1]

i understand using the song for this event... but never change the words... if you are going to do that... write a new song

[Panterhead]

oh my god...how could he do that to pink floyd ??? He has just ruined one of the best songs ever !!!!

[egluze]

the best wersion than real pink floyd.in my small opinion

[Panterhead]

Yes, you're opinion is definitely small ....

[f0rsaken408]

fred blows rofl...

[snozzleman]

i thought it was good it was for a cause not for just shits an giggles

[lilspite]

I want to kick fred durst in the face for trying to cover pink floyd

[Argamis]

agreed... jesus what a awful version of the music :S

[ruthieskid]

I don't mind the cover for a good cause, but don't change the words of a really great work of another artist - it's mockery. Did they think they could improved on Pink Floyd's lyrics?!?!? Pu-lease

[TLHouston]

NO PLEASE SHOW YOUR ASS IM SURE THE CAUSE COULD USE THE PRESS. SCREAM ON GIRLFRIEND!!! bad press is press

[inSaneNR]

dumb motherfuckers shut the fuck up... it was for an good reason ... so shut ur fat asses!

[cliffordchan]

ntb

[LimpAlien]

loved it

[ILCtroupe]

Ouch. Way to kick good music in the balls when it was down.

[hewhololz]

I didn't mind it. I thought it was pretty good.

[jonletter]

awe, yeah well thats just because you have shit taste in music =(

[dennisr92482]

yeah lets completely forget the cause... going to barf reading these comments

[pedrotol]

with so many motherfuckers to think this shit is good, there's no way to stop those dicks ruining everything the real musicians did

[gu88766]

i just lost complete respect for the goo goo dolls just by association. i'm gonna barf.

[pinkfloyd16]

Ugh. Way 2 ruin a great song.

[sweetpopcorn1]

its not that bad actually =)

[jonletter]

yes it is.

[twelch12]

first behind blue eyes now this? is limp biskit out to ruin every classic song?

[Boogity8]

i actually love this rendition....think they both did an excellent job.

[jonletter]

you're a douchebag boogity. and you have shit taste for music.