Added: 4 years ago
From: AnimeMira
Views: 101,548
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (682)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • he's dead sexy with glasses.

  • To just imagine Ed on stage singing in a bunch of people for his brother. I'm a big sister and have very bad stage fright but if it was for MY little brother I would do the same. This sounds a whole lot like Ed and if he WAS on stage singing this, I bet it would be like Martin Luther King's famous " I Have A Dream.."speech. :)

  • This song is so touching, I was almost in tears...

  • I didn't know vic sang... AWESOME!

  • Him, Chuck Huber, and Chris Sabat are my top three favorite voice actors

  • I wish they got both Vic and the voice actor for Al to sing this song togther. It seems that some verses are for Al's character

  • @HFeather15 Would be good but have you heard the old Al's voice now? Definitely doesn't suit Al anymore. It's terrible in the Chibi Party OVA :P

  • was I the only one picturing ed singing this ? xD really beatiful song but the original is better!

  • I just cried so hard. This is the most beautiful song I have ever heard.

  • My Mom HATES Fullmetal Alchemist!!

    But This Song, She LOVES!!

  • @GotItMemorized7 I made my mom listen to some of the OST and she fell in love too! And was only a tiny bit annoyed that it was from Fullmetal :)

  • It's realy great! But russian versia better...

  • This is Such a Beautiful Song xD

    I love Full Metal Alchemist

    Can't Wait to see Vic @ Ichibancon in Janurary

  • @GymTanLaundryGirl24 im going too gahh this is gonna be a fun weekend XD

  • Comment removed

  • @savvythehedgehog Or Should I Say it Was xD

  • @GymTanLaundryGirl24 yeah :D i loved it >w<

  • Vic has such a beautiful voice :D

  • *sob sob sob* gosh I'm getting all choked up...wonderful series, beautiful song, made perfect by Vic...

  • Anyone notice that he is singing in Ed's voice :)

  • @xixfullmetalxix

    ^-^

    This song is amazingly beautiful, and that he sings in Ed's voice just makes it.

  • @metaniterocks no that's just how Vic sounds

  • Envy disliked it 10 times out of jealousy

    Lust disliked it once cause anymore would be pointless

    Gluttony was too busy eating to dislike

    Sloth disliked it once

    Pride disliked it 4 times

    Greed secretly liked it.

    And Wrath went on a rampage constantly hitting the dislike button but, youtube had a glitch and only counted one.

  • START this Song.

    Go To "Google IMAGES" type in "ViCTEMS of WAR".

    and Witness the Ulimate Truths BeHIND CORRUPTION, GREED and TYRANNY. FUELED by MANs WORLD POLITICS and Prosperous Corporations.

    Thank you WALL STREET.

  • @LTNOHEATZ1 You're welcome.

    -Wall Street

  • I watched a Vic panel and the VERY FIRST THING he did was Rickroll us...

    He started singing the ONE SONG I HATE, but made it better because it was him not Rick Astley XD

  • where can i buy this song????? they only have the remixed version on ituens and i dont like that!!!!! where can i get an un-remixed wersion?????!!!!!!

  • i think its cool how he looks like an older version of ed :)

  • @deadpool1377 he kind of does though :D

  • Melted my heart <3 Thank you for uploading this! You are amazing.

  • i love this song. its so beautiful and peacful. Vic had me close to tears when i first heard this

  • I love this song, I listen to it over and over again. The more you listen to it, more the it sounds like Ed!

  • You know are an amazing voice actor when you take the place of a goddess like Romi Paku and no one complains. This guy is a legendary anime voice actor and he isnt asian, respect.

  • i want to marrie vic, and have him only talk to me as ed...

  • when i hear this, i picture ed singing, not vic.

  • It's so hard for me to listen to this without crying. Such an amazing voice. It's so sad and touching

  • okay, this NEEDS to be in Fullmetal Alchemist!!!!!!

  • listen to this with rainymood . com omgggg...

  • @Zakear7 I was about to post teh exact same comment xD

  • 17 people are obviously tone death...

  • I'm in love with his voice :)

  • This is so sad! :'(

  • Manly tear...

  • Comment removed

  • 17 people clearly can't hear a good voice when it sings.

  • @Slayer4LadyBlackVamp no truth is 17 people aren't fans of the series

  • When I watch this I hear Broly. >D

  • @BLAZ3R0 HA!!! Odd thought.....serenading Goku

  • @Aij8 I know right

  • Im planning on watching this series so what comes first, fullmetal panic or fullmetal alchemist?

  • @Shayshifter214

    those aren't the same series, but full metal alchemist comes first

  • @Shayshifter214 two different series fullmetal alchemist and fulmetal alchemist brotherhood are the same series tho fma follow the manga some what then veers off completely but fmab completely follows the manga.

  • When I listen to him.. I feel I'm listen to Edward.. best guy ever.. Edward Elric

  • it's impossible not to cry when listening to this.

  • i got goosebumps to i love this song and vic mignogna

  • I just got goosebumps.

  • Vic Mignogna is just...so awsome.

  • when i first heard this song i cried simple has that VIc puts so much emotion in this song

  • I love this!!!!!

  • DAFUQ NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!

  • DAFUQ NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

  • Vic is amazing :D Some of the acting on the Eng dub of FMA is quite bad but I thought Vic did an amazing job at voicing Ed :)

  • @Bloodshotshatterbone he did a great job for brolly, spirit from soul eater, i forgot his name he has long white hair with two sickles in sengoku basara, and many more hes a great anime english voice actor

  • @RobsEpicFret The Sengoku Basara character is Mitsuhide Akechi/Tenkai. 

  • damn...I listened to this song before watching FMA...I watched FMA...And I cried when I listened to this ;A;

  • Listen to this staring at a cute picture of Ed, MEGA FANGIRL EEP!!!! >.<

  • WOW he did the voice of Eward Elric, Yoshimori Sumimura and BROLY!!

  • this song is so wonderful....and vic....this voice is incredible. I could listen to this song over and over again.

  • Wow, Vic nearly lulled me to sleep then! And I was close to tears! He has such a great voice, such a touching song too.

  • I really wanna meet vic, i think he's a amazing voice actor maybe sometime in my life i might be able to meet him when i get older, because im only 12 *sigh* :/

  • i met him.. shacked hes hand on my birthday.. and he congratulated me and gave me a hug.. thank you vic <3

  • This Song ; U;

  • i think i should watch fma again..

  • When I finished watching the movie and started reading FMA fanfiction I always listened to this song. It fits like a glove

  • Ed should sing in FMA :')

  • guess what?

    he was at a convention in sweden (WICH IS WHERE I LIVE!!!)

    and me and my friend.. well... WE FRIGGIN HUGED HIM!

    and we got autografs =w= and when I asked him if he could draw a little Tamaki, he drew a chibi Edward with the text "NOT SHORT" x'''D

  • @EnPotatismos BUHU JAG VILLE OCKSÅ TRÄFFA HONOM MEN JAG ÅKTE IN PÅ NÄRCON FÖR JAG HADE INGEN ATT ÅKA MED ;______________; *heartbroken*

  • @ErithWolf Et eller andet med traffe ham, tror jeg.. og så ''heartbroken''.. men alt det andet forstod jeg ikk noget af.. xD

  • I meet him in person...I really love his voice acting

  • how could anyone dislike this? Its amazing! I'm almost crying which doesn't happen to often with me.

  • im crying cuz i remember how envy diedDX and how ed suffered x<

  • ohmai. he's quite amazing isn't he? ^~^

  • I met him at anime kaigi 2011 he hugged me and I got to do a scene from FMA me doing Alphonse an him being Ed of course ^^

  • wowww who knew Edward could sing? :)

  • Hey, Killermak2, this is me saying

    I love Vic Mignogna I love Vic Mignogna I love Vic Mignogna I love Vic Mignogna

    I love Vic Mignogna I love Vic Mignogna I love Vic Mignogna I love Vic Mignogna

    I love Vic Mignogna I love Vic Mignogna I love Vic Mignogna I love Vic Mignogna

    I love Vic Mignogna I love Vic Mignogna I love Vic Mignogna I love Vic Mignogna

    I love Vic Mignogna I love Vic Mignogna I love Vic Mignogna I love Vic Mignogna

  • @RikuHarada1890 HEY, I've met Vic Mignogna :^D Hahah I LOVE HIM TOO. :D

  • wow he is good this is the firsat time i have ever heard him sing and damn he has a beutiful voice

  • nobody could equal the emotion vic put into this song :')

  • Comment removed

  • i liked the 1st FMA but brotherhood i was like :ooooooooooo(xinfinity)

    i believe the 1st one was more about family & the 2nd one was well your ordinary manga,villain(s), hero(s), situations, & the final conflict

  • his voice is magical and this song tells a beautiful story, makes me cry wanting something more.

  • man why did they do the manga version... most people say brotherhood is better but they couldnt be more wrong FMA was just.... I cant replace FMA with brotherhood it's impossible. plus the voice actor changes drives me nuts O.o

  • @MegaXthen I couldn't agree more! I watched FMA first, then went to Brotherhood and I couldn't watch it! It was too weird and different! I just couldn't handle it! :(

  • @D4ncingD4wn54 Brotherhood is actually more based on the manga than the previous series of Full Metal Alchemist.

  • @Tentiez Oh I know! I just happened to watch FMA first so I expected something more like that for Brotherhood and it didn't meet my expectations.

  • @Tentiez I recently finished watching brotherhood and I liked it more than the original fma series

  • @MegaXthen

    oh man, i completely disagree, i feel like fma had no plot, and it was really boring to me, but then again, i watched brotherhood first, so...

  • wait didnt this guy voice act broly in dragon ball z O.o

  • ...................-Droooooooo­ooooooooooooooooooooooool-

  • @IWasBornStupid Ha!Me too!!!!

  • I looks like one of his lenses is messed up. O.O.......WHAT?

  • Vic <3 <3 him to death :D

  • this is one of the few aniem songs that dubs well.

  • when i first heard this song i cried now i just love it and Vic <3

  • Comment removed

  • I havent really seen FMA but this still makes me so sad and oddly...happy too (TTwTT) Vic has a amazing, dare i say beautiful, voice! now i wish he would go out to become pro in singing so i listen to him. am not a stalker i swear. i just really love his voice <3 Vic ur amazing!!

  • @Nativekunoichi

    He is a professional singer. He has multiple CDs out and goes on tour.

  • @Masuabie really?? (O___o) yay! XD

  • @SilverAlchemistFull Yes! I think the dub of this anime is actually better than the sub! That's rare! I'm beyond impressed; I'm AWED. Vic is awesome! Fullmetal Alchemist is awesome! :D

  • THE ARTISTS NEED TO ANIMATE EDWARD SINGING THIS <3  :*(

  • He singing, and you can feel edwards voice in it. Full metalalchemis need s video of ed singing this.

  • i love this song so much theres so much energy. i can just imagine if fullmetal alchemist was a disney movie this would be like the lament song in every disney movie

  • Have dis lovely beautiful song on my fone

  • this song is soooo amazing, it makes me wanna cry thats how good it is. BTW get his REVIX album its epic!!!!! im so happy i got to hear him sing this song live at a Q&A session at the Phoenix Comic-Con ^_^ his voice is amazing and his fiance (yes i got to talk to them both while i was there) told me that he has one of those natural singing voices that is soo sicking-ly amazing and she was so right ^^ i <3 VIC MIGNOGNA ^^

  • Comment removed

  • this song fits many sorrowful lyrics

  • 11 people are Mustang fans.

  • @matt182martin i think you mean miniskirts lol but i love this song :)

  • I Want an FMAB episode with Edward singing this song. i dont care if it isnt in the manga PUT IT

  • suck you people that put their

    finger down sunk you people!!!!!!!!!

  • I heard him sing quite a lot of different songs now.. but this one just fits him best.. because you know.. his voice has this very soft side, but it's still very meaningful..

  • when it gets to this part

    And how can I make amends?

    For all that I took from you?

    i keep wanting to sing it as

    And how can I make amends?

    For all of my sins

  • His voice is .. soo orgasmic! meaning its amazing! i really like it because i have a tiny crush on Edward & now the person who is his voice aha

  • oh my... this voice is so damn beautiful! <33

  • Is this song on itunes?!?

  • @Speedgirl1516 i dont know but its on beemp3 for free

  • Vic is sexy :) omg :) love him :)

  • Can everyone please stop! I've lost too much recently and this is not helping!!! Why must we lose those we love most? Y.Y

  • OMG its makng my eyes water its soooo sweet if you think it from edwards point of view :')

  • IT IS AT THE POINT WERE WE CAN HEAR EDWARD ELRICS VOCIE IN IT!!!!!! OMG

  • 11 people have no emotion

  • Vic has such a beautiful voice, and goes great with this song. I also like the japanese version with the child choir singing, but Funimation translated this song very well.

  • @MrFlavorcrayon errm there isn't a Japanese version of ''Brothers" the other version is Russian

  • @polkol12 Yeah I messed up on that part. xD

  • it sounds like ed singing

  • I actually cried. I'm talking ACTUAL tears. Poor Elrics. They may get their bodies back, one day, but the emotional scars will stay there forever.

  • Beautiful song! Beautiful voice!

  • Has anybody figured out that he looks like a blond Maes Hughes

  • @ang5521 O_O i just shat my self in amazment... ever noticed the guy who voices maes hughs could probly pass as him lol

  • @ang5521 How interesting...

  • @ang5521 You are completely right he does look like a blond Maes Hughes

  • @ang5521 O.O Holy s***, you're right!! I never noticed before!

  • HE'S SOOOOO CUTE!!! KYAAAAAA!

    This song makes me cry every time!!!!

  • I went into cardiac arrest.....5 times after hearing this song.. Love it XD

  • lol fangirls. Hey, listen. When I was like 11, I watched my first actual anime ever: DN Angel. M'yep, and as you can imagine, like every other preteen fucktard I LOOOVED Dark. This is probably why when I went to watch a certain well-known anime, I opted for the dub. This is probably why I love Vic's voice, it's practically in my blood now - not unlike how I prefer Aaron's Al. Still, this doesn't mean that everyone will or does, nor does it give you the right to attack someone over an opinion.

  • I love vic<3

  • N... no words...

    Should've... sent a poet.

  • the sound of the music is way too similar to this little song off of this anime called sasami...........

  • Have you ever watched Kekkaishi? He does the voice of Yoshimori too! This man is so talented. I simply adore his voice, and this song is beautiful. It really expresses Edward's guilt and love for his brother... just beautiful.:)

  • @SilverAlchemistFull yes... he's Edward Elric's voice for English dubbed version

  • Vic is the best singer

  • this is so beautiful ;_;

  • this man cannot make a better video!

  • this man can't make a better video that's what!!!

  • his Kekkashi character reminds so much of Edward ;) which reminds me i got this picture of Edward Elric Beating up Edward Cullen its pretty epic XD

  • I wish they could have gotten Aaron Dismuke to sing the second part.

  • Vic is so sexy :)

  • I like hearing this and picturing ed as an almost adult TALLER xD and singing at a kareoke contest rofl

  • ...Ok, I want this song in Brotherhood... now

  • @GunBunnyShift same here :D Vic is such a good singer

  • @GunBunnyShift I know god I miss Hughes

  • @GunBunnyShift me too i already put for brotherhood its not the same :P

  • the first time i heard this song i cried Vic puts so much emotion in this song its not funny plus i love his voice its like its Edward singing sometimes imagine it

  • It takes a manly sort of man to go from screaming at the top of his lungs as Broly to singing something as awesome as this. The only possible thing that could have made this better is the VA for Al singing the appropriate parts; otherwise this is amazing.

  • @DXAshram if only aaron dismuke didnt sound like dying cats when hes singing!

  • ( : . : ) Where is the love button for this? Vic is just amazing!

  • OMG I accidentally met him at Katsucon over the weekend and I got pictures ^\\\\\\\\^

  • omg this song is like my new favorite forget anything i have ever herd befor this tops it all

    like my ears have never herd anything so beautiful befor in my hole intire life this will always have a verry special place in my heart for ever <3 i love you vic you have compleated my life

  • omg one minute in my hand started shaking like crazy and i was almost crying (just started crap)

  • @OtakuAme i know like seriously beautiful and sweet ahhhhhh i love him and his voice

    

  • he makes me think ed is singing =D

  • I always heard this in the anime. Never with words though.

    Now I have. I am FUCKING BLOWN AWAY!!!!!!

    *sniff* beautiful....

  • shivers all over my body. beautiful.

  • @leavemichellealone i totally agree with you. Vic has a beautiful voice if you ask me

  • HOLY CRAP!!!!! ITS VIC MANANANA!!!!!!! XD

    Yu-gi-oh! the abridged series reference... TEE HEE!!!

  • 10 people don't realize a beautiful voice when they hear it. Nor care for the meaning.