Ih...das klingt teilweise von der Intonation wie "Deutscher Schlager"...passt überhaupt nicht zu diesem schönen Stück...Die Dramatik ist gänzlich dahin...
Although the original has a special place in my heart, this song is reborn with Anette on board. An extremely beautiful performance, indeed. If was there, that would've brought me to tears.
I'm so happy I started to listen to this band 5 years ago and still do!!!!
I travelled to Finland from England to go to this concert. This was one of the highlights of the entire night. No-one knew it was coming and the surprise was so amazing. All the lights were so beautiful, I very nearly cried. So to hear it again brings back all the memories of that amazing night, thank you =) .
The Anette singing resembles the original version (which is sung by a kid), but Tarja's version is much better, stronger, intense pulsed ... as was the old Nightwish!
I love this song so much! However, as much as I am a fan of Nightwish, I like Celtc Woman's Chole Agnew's better than both Annette and Tarja's versions. This is not a song that is meant to be belted, most definetley. And I don't like how they changed the key either. don't get me wrong, I LOVE Nightwish, but I think Celtic Woman just nailed this song!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
This song is ok with her voice..!!* n__n although Celtic woman version is in a wayfar better! n_n go anette go... you child-voice keep on learnin' doing these things n_n
I'm trying to speak to a grown up person here, not to some idiotic 5 year old fantard. So I ask you to at least be able to make a distinction between being able to sing something, and your personal taste.
Anette, as a matter of FACTS, can sing the songs. She reaches the notes, sings on right tempo, etc.
Now if you don't fucking like it, that's a whole new story, and I dont give a shit about it.
BTW, what's so wrong with eva? it's a nice ballad, and you can hear vocal quality there.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
she couldn't sing stargazers, and she couldn't sing THE PHANTOM OF THE OPERA... She'd fail... she's a soprano but she focus her voice in alto's ways! x) Tarja rocks..
You can't focus your voice in "alto's ways". Even if you sing your whole life in a low pitch, you'd still be soprano. And BTW, that's not even an argument, and you failed at proving...whatever you were trying to prove.
Anette could perfectly sing Stargazers. But obviously you wouldn't like it 'cause you've got your head stucked way too deep inside Tarja's rear end.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
haha!!* "Anette could perfectly sing Stargazers" hahaha!!!* out of her range, the child-voice is not for OCEANBORN original range!* REALIZE! Simone Simmons, Floor Jansen, they could do it, but Anette? haha!!* Never!* it'd happen like "Romanticide" that turned into Popmanticide!* sucked.! =) anette sings well "Eva" hahahaha...
When they started the tour, everyone thought she wouldn't be able to sing Sacrament, and she did. Then it was dark chest of wonders, she did. Next She is my Sin, and she did.
The hard ones came into the scene: Dead Boy's Poem, she totally owned it.
Ghost love score? everyone was so sure she would never do that live, and she sang it succesfully.
She has proved enough, you retarded Tarja ass licker, can't belive you still can't see her talent.
Your post makes me very happy. Now i know that I'm not the only one who doesn't see this "incredible" range that Tarja "has". Tarja recorded, that's nice, but live, I think the woman sounds like she's going into labor while running a 5k.
Tarja sings the old Nightwish songs at her concerts and her new band plays the songs very well! Maybe people who prefer Tarja listen to her live performances instead of complaining here about Anette! And I know that this is not a Nightwish song but a Howard Blake! Anette is a good singer and I am so happy that I heard her version of this song. It is closer to the original. I must say though, that I prefer the older Nightwish version of this song due to the dramatic ending and the guitar solo.
i've heard they had professional cameras there filming for the big screens they had up. my friend and i think though that they might use it for a dvd though. :) we can hope!
I know, but yes, I do agree her accent is better. And yes, pretty, pretty cool version. Too bad they didn't play it when they came to Mexico well, along with many other great songs included later... Such a pity.
There is a difference in how the languages are built though as well... Finnish uses the letters in pairs or the words are dominated by A's, E's and those letters... The words flow differently.. The best way I can describe it is that finnish sound harsher than swedish....
It feels so so very weird to me to finally hear the "villages go by like trees" part pronounced correctly. As in, not willages or weelages. Yay for correctly used English. :D
Well, gotta remember Tarja is finnish, and pronunciation in an english-language song when having a different native language can be very tricky sometimes.
I think they were because most of the talk in between tracks was in Finnish - if it was for a dvd they would have talked in English - plus Tuomas said he wouldn't make another dvd until after next album - I'm hoping this show is made into one too though
This version i so beautiful! I can't believe they waited the entire tour to preform this song after they said they never would with Anette!! I love this version!!!
Toumas also said they would never play Passion and the Opera, Stargazer, and Elvanpath.
We will probably never hear Bless the Child, End of all Hope, Pharaoh Sails to Orion, or The Kinslayer again either. If were lucky we will hear Planet Hell...in a lower key because the notes aren't THAT high to hit. Heck I'm a guy and a baritone in chorus and I can hit Tarja's studio recorded notes on that song.
I've heard that he's said that there is no song of NW's that Anette cannot sing.... Also, I believe that they have played End of All Hope already... During the beginning of the tour... I believe they were somewhere in South America when they played that one... I also believe that they've played The Kinslayer... I think TurquoiseWaterfall(s) has a video of it...
Actually they rehearsed Elvenpath for this gig but Tuomas said it didn't work with her voice, but i cant see why she couldnt do phantom of the opera :)
There is an interview up on youtube that has Tuomas saying that there isn't a NW-song that Anette couldn't sing... I'm guessing the time just wasn't right... Maybe they'll do it at a later time... Maybe next tour???
I'm pretty sure I wasn't... Cause I haven't watched any videos of She is my sin yet.... Don't really like that song much and since I don't like it, I don't watch it...
Well she can't sing Phantom because her voice is more suited for either rock (which really makes me wonder why Elvanpath wouldn't work) or soft melodies. Phantom is too Opera for her vocal range.
oh I see. They probably wanted to save it for something special for the final show. But of course I understand the disappointment of not hearing it live..
how can somebody dislike this video! I bet tarja marcelo and fuckin harus pressed the dislike button...
MasterChico13 1 month ago
affs ... merda
brunnosleepwalker 4 months ago
Ih...das klingt teilweise von der Intonation wie "Deutscher Schlager"...passt überhaupt nicht zu diesem schönen Stück...Die Dramatik ist gänzlich dahin...
beFashLG 5 months ago
Although the original has a special place in my heart, this song is reborn with Anette on board. An extremely beautiful performance, indeed. If was there, that would've brought me to tears.
I'm so happy I started to listen to this band 5 years ago and still do!!!!
23lonelywolf 11 months ago 2
I travelled to Finland from England to go to this concert. This was one of the highlights of the entire night. No-one knew it was coming and the surprise was so amazing. All the lights were so beautiful, I very nearly cried. So to hear it again brings back all the memories of that amazing night, thank you =) .
DayAsDarkAsNight 1 year ago 9
@DayAsDarkAsNight You're welcome. :) Amazing night, amazing song.
Susitar 1 year ago
I like this version.
Amaranth2020 1 year ago
I'm a Nightwish fan, but I've always hated this song. But since I've heard this version, I love it...
Lightofthehunder 1 year ago 3
I just love this performance!! I can't even quess how great the new album will be! Nightwish forever!!!
DeadToTheWorld92 1 year ago 3
Tuomas said this one and The phantom of the opera wouldn't ever be played again live by them... WTF?!
r4xNW91 1 year ago
@r4xNW91 I recall it was Over the Hills And Far Away and The Phatom of the Opera. :)
SilverCreek24 8 months ago
The Anette singing resembles the original version (which is sung by a kid), but Tarja's version is much better, stronger, intense pulsed ... as was the old Nightwish!
sirstranger 1 year ago
This song was meant for a little boy to sing....
Wasn't meant for Tarja WHAT SO FREAKING EVER....
h06anbjo 2 years ago 20
I love this song so much! However, as much as I am a fan of Nightwish, I like Celtc Woman's Chole Agnew's better than both Annette and Tarja's versions. This is not a song that is meant to be belted, most definetley. And I don't like how they changed the key either. don't get me wrong, I LOVE Nightwish, but I think Celtic Woman just nailed this song!
DauntaQue 2 years ago
DauntaQue, you call this singing belting :)
konked 2 years ago
@DauntaQue Anette's not belting in this song. ;)
HeartsEyes 1 year ago
this song is great! i love this perfomance!!i love nightwish!
Silra123GoldrainCRN 2 years ago 10
I love this version of Walking in the Air. I hope they release some of the live versions of the older songs as bonus tracks on the next album
lqleviathan 2 years ago 12
this version is also good
but i prefer Tarja version
Kafurry 2 years ago
everytime when i listen to this performance I feel like I'm in another perfect world... :) <3
SuperDeluna 2 years ago 10
No keyboard, guitar and some double kick ending? (From wishes to Eternity)
=(
Still great tought!!
Doum92 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This song is ok with her voice..!!* n__n although Celtic woman version is in a wayfar better! n_n go anette go... you child-voice keep on learnin' doing these things n_n
Evnightlerd 2 years ago
I'm trying to speak to a grown up person here, not to some idiotic 5 year old fantard. So I ask you to at least be able to make a distinction between being able to sing something, and your personal taste.
Anette, as a matter of FACTS, can sing the songs. She reaches the notes, sings on right tempo, etc.
Now if you don't fucking like it, that's a whole new story, and I dont give a shit about it.
BTW, what's so wrong with eva? it's a nice ballad, and you can hear vocal quality there.
MrReason09 2 years ago 10
This comment has received too many negative votes show
she couldn't sing stargazers, and she couldn't sing THE PHANTOM OF THE OPERA... She'd fail... she's a soprano but she focus her voice in alto's ways! x) Tarja rocks..
Evnightlerd 2 years ago
Tarja fantard in sight!
You can't focus your voice in "alto's ways". Even if you sing your whole life in a low pitch, you'd still be soprano. And BTW, that's not even an argument, and you failed at proving...whatever you were trying to prove.
Anette could perfectly sing Stargazers. But obviously you wouldn't like it 'cause you've got your head stucked way too deep inside Tarja's rear end.
MrReason09 2 years ago 9
This comment has received too many negative votes show
haha!!* "Anette could perfectly sing Stargazers" hahaha!!!* out of her range, the child-voice is not for OCEANBORN original range!* REALIZE! Simone Simmons, Floor Jansen, they could do it, but Anette? haha!!* Never!* it'd happen like "Romanticide" that turned into Popmanticide!* sucked.! =) anette sings well "Eva" hahahaha...
Evnightlerd 2 years ago
When they started the tour, everyone thought she wouldn't be able to sing Sacrament, and she did. Then it was dark chest of wonders, she did. Next She is my Sin, and she did.
The hard ones came into the scene: Dead Boy's Poem, she totally owned it.
Ghost love score? everyone was so sure she would never do that live, and she sang it succesfully.
She has proved enough, you retarded Tarja ass licker, can't belive you still can't see her talent.
MrReason09 2 years ago 14
Your so right!!!
Doum92 2 years ago
Still I would like to hear her sing Stargazers, I dont think that she could really reach the chorus high notes :S
Doum92 2 years ago
@Doum92
lol tarja can't reach either. (i mean live) And a classical singer must be able to reach them. poor tarja :)
reafras 2 years ago 4
@reafras
Your post makes me very happy. Now i know that I'm not the only one who doesn't see this "incredible" range that Tarja "has". Tarja recorded, that's nice, but live, I think the woman sounds like she's going into labor while running a 5k.
playtagwithasemi 1 year ago 10
ANette sings like an angel.
barunka0010 2 years ago 5
This was so beautiful... This acoustic version is very nice, it fits on Anette's voice very well. :)
KalmanHerra 2 years ago 8
humm, where are the tarja fanatics now? there aren't any bad comments about anette. what's up? do you realize now that anette was the perfect choice?
if not you should really search a doctor to repair your ears..
oamadeife 2 years ago 7
Tarja sings the old Nightwish songs at her concerts and her new band plays the songs very well! Maybe people who prefer Tarja listen to her live performances instead of complaining here about Anette! And I know that this is not a Nightwish song but a Howard Blake! Anette is a good singer and I am so happy that I heard her version of this song. It is closer to the original. I must say though, that I prefer the older Nightwish version of this song due to the dramatic ending and the guitar solo.
Calliopeia666 2 years ago
Nice one xD
angelofdarkness49 2 years ago
only cameras i saw was the ones they used for filming stuff to screens so I think they wont release dvd :(
EsteriH 2 years ago
there were cameras so think the have to put this in a dvd
sonic588 2 years ago
wooow! I'm amazed. I realy love her voice!
And 'i hope thay will make a DVD, ofc. thay HAVE to!!
fixmixazterix 2 years ago 2
i think we can now safely say beyond a shadow of a doubtthat annette is extremely good at what she does :)
she just keeps getting better and better, and i'm betting that the next album will be incredible.
vantheflan 2 years ago 42
Wonderfull. So much emotion...
fgavrilovic 2 years ago 8
PLEASE tell me that there were cameras there filming this for a dvd? Please someone from the concert let me know asap!!!
dylanno1fan 2 years ago
i've heard they had professional cameras there filming for the big screens they had up. my friend and i think though that they might use it for a dvd though. :) we can hope!
jooleah74 2 years ago 2
I was near the front of this show! So amazing! Flew all the way from California!
BrandonHarami 2 years ago 7
Awesome, beautiful version, congratz Anette
JustPawel1 2 years ago 9
Another song completely nailed by anette. I just love her voice, clear as water. Just beautiful.
Hippydude777 2 years ago 50
Thanks for this - I travelled from Scotland for this gig but got camera taken off me
cornixregina 2 years ago 2
Yes but Anette is Swedish so english is not her native language either. She has a better accent than Tarja it's a fact :)
And this version is absolutely amazing !!!
Jaxom003 2 years ago 8
I know, but yes, I do agree her accent is better. And yes, pretty, pretty cool version. Too bad they didn't play it when they came to Mexico well, along with many other great songs included later... Such a pity.
DivaDarkie 2 years ago 4
There is a difference in how the languages are built though as well... Finnish uses the letters in pairs or the words are dominated by A's, E's and those letters... The words flow differently.. The best way I can describe it is that finnish sound harsher than swedish....
h06anbjo 2 years ago
hopefully the camera wernt just for the video screens :D
ParadiseNox 2 years ago
It feels so so very weird to me to finally hear the "villages go by like trees" part pronounced correctly. As in, not willages or weelages. Yay for correctly used English. :D
Lovely performance, once again.
EndlessCompassion 2 years ago 10
Well, gotta remember Tarja is finnish, and pronunciation in an english-language song when having a different native language can be very tricky sometimes.
DivaDarkie 2 years ago
I think they were because most of the talk in between tracks was in Finnish - if it was for a dvd they would have talked in English - plus Tuomas said he wouldn't make another dvd until after next album - I'm hoping this show is made into one too though
cornixregina 2 years ago
gorgeous!!!
IvyOmega 2 years ago 4
This version i so beautiful! I can't believe they waited the entire tour to preform this song after they said they never would with Anette!! I love this version!!!
animeclay345 2 years ago 14
There's only one song that they'll never do with Anette that I've heard of... And that's the Phantom of the Opera....
h06anbjo 2 years ago
Toumas also said they would never play Passion and the Opera, Stargazer, and Elvanpath.
We will probably never hear Bless the Child, End of all Hope, Pharaoh Sails to Orion, or The Kinslayer again either. If were lucky we will hear Planet Hell...in a lower key because the notes aren't THAT high to hit. Heck I'm a guy and a baritone in chorus and I can hit Tarja's studio recorded notes on that song.
animeclay345 2 years ago
I've heard that he's said that there is no song of NW's that Anette cannot sing.... Also, I believe that they have played End of All Hope already... During the beginning of the tour... I believe they were somewhere in South America when they played that one... I also believe that they've played The Kinslayer... I think TurquoiseWaterfall(s) has a video of it...
h06anbjo 2 years ago
I would love to hear her sing the kingslayer, where can I find the video???
EosEvanggelys 2 years ago
I was so sure I had watched a video of that song... But it seems as if I didn't or the user has taken that video down....
h06anbjo 2 years ago
Actually they rehearsed Elvenpath for this gig but Tuomas said it didn't work with her voice, but i cant see why she couldnt do phantom of the opera :)
Alan4Rayne 2 years ago
There is an interview up on youtube that has Tuomas saying that there isn't a NW-song that Anette couldn't sing... I'm guessing the time just wasn't right... Maybe they'll do it at a later time... Maybe next tour???
h06anbjo 2 years ago
Probably and perhaps you're thinking of a video of "she is my sin" instead of "the kinslayer"?
Alan4Rayne 2 years ago
I'm pretty sure I wasn't... Cause I haven't watched any videos of She is my sin yet.... Don't really like that song much and since I don't like it, I don't watch it...
h06anbjo 2 years ago
Hm... I wonder :) well i much prefer Anette singing itso check it out :)
Alan4Rayne 2 years ago 3
I don't know anymore...
I was so sure I had seen a video of that song with Anette singing it.... I just can't find it now...
h06anbjo 2 years ago
I think so! haha I wish she could sing "Angels fall first, Stargazer, Passion and the opera"
Evnightlerd 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
And I wish Tarja could sing "Amaranth, Bye bye beautiful, For the heart I once had..."
Rikiya57 2 years ago
Dio can sing Stargazer.
SuperPelimies 2 years ago
Well she can't sing Phantom because her voice is more suited for either rock (which really makes me wonder why Elvanpath wouldn't work) or soft melodies. Phantom is too Opera for her vocal range.
She is an alto and Phantom requires a saprano.
animeclay345 2 years ago
She's mezzo-soprano not alto and if ghost love score workrd im sure that can. Would love to see stargazers too :)
Alan4Rayne 2 years ago 3
yeahh
soraelegido 2 years ago
Anette's voice is suited for heavy songs too. I was pretty sure everyone had understood that already.
Anette's a soprano, not an alto. And you require a classical trained singer to perform Phantom, not just any soprano.
I don't think theres something "too high" for Anette's (theorical) range.
MrReason09 2 years ago 5
I think it's just that Anette would sound kind of odd singing Elvenpath. It's one of those songs that only work for Tarja.
ZeldaKirby 2 years ago
OMFG this is so beautiful with anette :'(
0o0Ryuku0o0 2 years ago 8
sweet, so sweet!
i love this version...tarja's version is nice too, of course
neohk 2 years ago 11
this is a cute version! it fits anette's voice...but i also love the tarja version...they made this one to fit anette and thats badass...
KarmaEstrella25 2 years ago 4
Actually, this version is closer the original version that was composed by Howart Blake.
BlueOcean24 2 years ago
So beautiful *-*
CKBrunnoA 2 years ago 11
....я ждала эту песню в Москве..
Un4givenToo 2 years ago
sorry?
Susitar 2 years ago 4
she wrote that she hoped for this song on their Moscow gig :) I guess because the band hasn't been playing there for so long
PieniPeippo 2 years ago 5
the band recently played there, like, last week. :\
deutschesmaedchen 2 years ago
Yeah, I know. I mean, ppl were so eager to hear everything ^^ so it was upsetting for them not to hear Walking..
PieniPeippo 2 years ago
oh I see. They probably wanted to save it for something special for the final show. But of course I understand the disappointment of not hearing it live..
Susitar 2 years ago
anyway, thanks to you we can enjoy it now :)
PieniPeippo 2 years ago
Туомас, хитрый, приберёг для своих))
Oomka 2 years ago
Amazing <3
katriin881 2 years ago 9
Fantastic. Absolutely great.
feikki 2 years ago 7