I think there would be no DT without a PF. Or at least Dream Theater would not be as great as it is without Pink Floyd. If that wasn't a fact i think you wouldn't be hearing a cover to Pink Floyd played by Dream Theater.
this band is from another planet....of course they are way better than pink floyd in everything....and if someone says that dream theater have no feeling.....well.....they have no fucking idea....................
@GeorgeADTOE u cant say dream theater is better than pink floyd thats just stupid ... .. u can mix oranges and apples... u cant compare between them .. thats just wrong!!!!
why compare DT to PF? Both make the music they love. The skill is only a tools to do the music you wanna make. Other than that skills only offer you to explore other sounds, still if you have found the sound you like, being overly skill is useless most of the time! I prefer DT but its only IMO.
im listening to this on my isolation headphones....and petruccis solo...sounds SOOOO Good. he hits every note, and even though its obviosly more distorted, its perfect. i dont want to hear anything about feeling, its a song, not a movie. feeling is not judged by how many stupid faces a guy makes, but the music itsself. this rules.
Floyd plays their music better than DT plays Floyd's music, but overall, DT is the better band. Productivity and innovation go to PF for sure but DT is more skilled in every other way.
Dude, I can't believe you just said that. Gilmour smashes whoever there guitar player is. he played like 15 of the best solos ever. ever!!!!!! 15. most are luckey to have 1. witch this dude dosen't.
Is that bad? Are you judgung musicians by wether their music is mainstream or not?
And I don't think Pink Floyd is mainstream.
It certainly wasn't when they came up. You're probably just feeling they're mainstream because a lot more peple know them than DT but that is because PF is older.
It's been so long I don't even know what I meant when I wrote that comment.
But no, I like Pink Floyd as much as I like Dream Theater, so I'm not saying that it's a bad thing that Floyd is more mainstream then DT, just that more people have heard of Pink Floyd, and sometimes this makes them assume they are better.
Why some guys says, they didn't give anything more, they changed little things and you're saying that's shit, only because it's dream theater "shred" group they did it bad, accept it, its really good and cool cover
How can you vary the bass line for money? That is how just about everyone knows the sound dude... And it's dream theater.. of course it's going to be way distorted..
This just confirms what I've always thought about Dream Theater: excellent musicians, but someone really should cram a squirrel down that singers throat. Seriously, he sucks! I know you DT fan boys are going jump on this, but he really is pathetic. He ruins a nearly perfect cover.
Dude, you've got to be kidding me. He has a range that is out of this world. Yeah, he's such a bad singer thats why he was sought out by some amazing singers across the fucking world to do a project with them eh? If you watch their new 20th anniversary SCORE DVD he does PERFECT. How many singers can sing perfectly live? So who are some other bad singers, Geoff Tate? Rob Halford? Dio? Bruce Dickinson? I bet those guys suck too dont they?
Pink Floyd and Rush the founders of Prog Rock/Metal
Classic1942 1 week ago
I think there would be no DT without a PF. Or at least Dream Theater would not be as great as it is without Pink Floyd. If that wasn't a fact i think you wouldn't be hearing a cover to Pink Floyd played by Dream Theater.
(That's my opinion, no drama bitches please.) :)
whatisthisyou 2 weeks ago
this band is from another planet....of course they are way better than pink floyd in everything....and if someone says that dream theater have no feeling.....well.....they have no fucking idea....................
GeorgeADTOE 1 month ago
@GeorgeADTOE u cant say dream theater is better than pink floyd thats just stupid ... .. u can mix oranges and apples... u cant compare between them .. thats just wrong!!!!
chedromania 3 weeks ago
@GeorgeADTOE Different styles. I like both Dream Theater and Pink Floyd.
Adennos 1 week ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This song is like a picnic for DT! But great cover anyway...
Blackfist2106 1 year ago
This song is like a picnic for DT! But great cover enyway...
Blackfist2106 1 year ago
mind you this is a live version, if it was a corrected studio version it actually might sound better then the original!
anyhow GREATASS cover!!!
metalmusiking 1 year ago
why compare DT to PF? Both make the music they love. The skill is only a tools to do the music you wanna make. Other than that skills only offer you to explore other sounds, still if you have found the sound you like, being overly skill is useless most of the time! I prefer DT but its only IMO.
ilikeshred 2 years ago 2
I think petrucci has an awesome tone here!
mpk1000000 3 years ago
the only thing that brings this cover down is the vocals, the music on the other hand is fucking spot on!
screamcarl 3 years ago
I love their respect for music. no showing up, no thechnical tricks, just purely the pink floyd magic
pitheww84 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
TubeComments.(INFO) want to blow up your channel or website? get your ad right here with the same software i'm using Totally RAD -
Emma31708 3 years ago
im listening to this on my isolation headphones....and petruccis solo...sounds SOOOO Good. he hits every note, and even though its obviosly more distorted, its perfect. i dont want to hear anything about feeling, its a song, not a movie. feeling is not judged by how many stupid faces a guy makes, but the music itsself. this rules.
leashomemea 4 years ago 2
Floyd plays their music better than DT plays Floyd's music, but overall, DT is the better band. Productivity and innovation go to PF for sure but DT is more skilled in every other way.
SilentFox12345 4 years ago
Dude, I can't believe you just said that. Gilmour smashes whoever there guitar player is. he played like 15 of the best solos ever. ever!!!!!! 15. most are luckey to have 1. witch this dude dosen't.
Lemaster2316 4 years ago
is that your oppinion, or is it a fact?
anyway, you cant really compare them like that. david gilmoure is a great guitarist in many ways, but petrucci is better technically.
erlinghone 4 years ago
Ok, musically, I'd say Gilmour...but technically, Petrucci. Fair enough? In other words, Petrucci's stuff is harder to play.
SilentFox12345 3 years ago 3
Pink Floyd is mainstream. Dream Theater is not.
NickReilly 3 years ago
Is that bad? Are you judgung musicians by wether their music is mainstream or not?
And I don't think Pink Floyd is mainstream.
It certainly wasn't when they came up. You're probably just feeling they're mainstream because a lot more peple know them than DT but that is because PF is older.
doctorlorenz 2 years ago
It's been so long I don't even know what I meant when I wrote that comment.
But no, I like Pink Floyd as much as I like Dream Theater, so I'm not saying that it's a bad thing that Floyd is more mainstream then DT, just that more people have heard of Pink Floyd, and sometimes this makes them assume they are better.
NickReilly 2 years ago
OMG! that motherfucker portnoy... simply great!
edgar160905 4 years ago 2
Just another reason why dream theater kicks ass!
JordanLPC 4 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
kill the singer!!!!
rouxlaki 4 years ago
the bass needs to be tuned a wee different and played a little faster, but i thought it was very well done
e7331 4 years ago
One of the greatest played by one of the greatest band ever... MAKES EVERYTHING SO GREAT!!! =D
killerdrumer 4 years ago
lolz... owkkvh you stupid ass, dont undertand shit about music omg...how can you say that ..zomg...
hallaahhahaa 4 years ago
very nice, one great prog band covering another
wilkinscs1 4 years ago 5
Everyone loves Pink FLoyd!!!!
insidethewall 5 years ago
Excellent cover!! Though LaBrie can't do this song as good as Gilmour, he's great, and so is everyone else in this band! I love Dream Theater!
Erotomania89 5 years ago
i agree with you but its is normal that labre cannot sing that son aswell as Gilmour... it is not his song
dav24642 4 years ago 5
Your a fool if you think this sounds bad. Best cover I heard of this song.
mattjm82 5 years ago
where was this filmed? cus if it was london i was there
niiice
TimatorA 5 years ago
Well they change the setlist everynight on a tour... so it's unlikely that it'll be from any other date on that tour...
gsmushman 5 years ago
Why some guys says, they didn't give anything more, they changed little things and you're saying that's shit, only because it's dream theater "shred" group they did it bad, accept it, its really good and cool cover
Bennettsito 5 years ago
How can you vary the bass line for money? That is how just about everyone knows the sound dude... And it's dream theater.. of course it's going to be way distorted..
metalhead492 5 years ago
i think the bass line could have been a bit varied... sounds boring.
and for a pink floyd cover, there's way too much distortion in the guitar sound. but still, it's a nice and very precise played cover.
owkkvh 5 years ago
Dream Theater should try covering Rush's 2112.
Johny117 5 years ago
there is already a cover of that song, by dream theater!
Erotomania89 5 years ago
labrie does have a hidden talent he can play almost as good as petrucci on guitar his solo albums are amazing and he ploays guitar on them
disneyguitarist 5 years ago
LaBrie does NOT play guitar on any of his solo work. Mike Keneally plays guitar with Mullmuzzler and Marco Sfogli plays on Elements of Persusuasion.
Biaxident0 5 years ago
not bad but pink floyd do better (it's sure)
but good job!
fanpinkfloyd 5 years ago
yeah the solo is pathiec
rogerwaterhasgonemad 5 years ago
its sound very similar to floyd...
but the solo sucks...
and the bass player rocks!!
nicogilmour 5 years ago
good, but
guitar suck petrucio.
Gilmour is Gilmour!
Fender is Fender!
cmtesioux 5 years ago
Upload more!!!!
Superb work as always!! \m/
nightofire 5 years ago
great cover
great song!!!
dos melhores esse
ericomonken 5 years ago
It's true... they play what they want... DT rocks!!!
cesarjusto 5 years ago
wow that was amazing.
wouldn't it have been good though if James Labrie pulled out a sax and revealed a hidden talent instead of that other bloke.
Pwnagemerchant 5 years ago
i wouldent say james sucks....not the best.. but he is on key and this is a progressinv band!!! kudos to james!!! i love you DT
shmeeufp 5 years ago
fucked that solo up a treat, get a strat
siwillan 5 years ago
stfu noob
gtrslinger 5 years ago
Dioses
ardegan 5 years ago
Great cover.
tambian89 5 years ago
Well played, but I don't really see the point. They added nothing to the original, but LaBrie really butchered it.
StefanAlexander 5 years ago
This just confirms what I've always thought about Dream Theater: excellent musicians, but someone really should cram a squirrel down that singers throat. Seriously, he sucks! I know you DT fan boys are going jump on this, but he really is pathetic. He ruins a nearly perfect cover.
linguizic 5 years ago
Dude, you've got to be kidding me. He has a range that is out of this world. Yeah, he's such a bad singer thats why he was sought out by some amazing singers across the fucking world to do a project with them eh? If you watch their new 20th anniversary SCORE DVD he does PERFECT. How many singers can sing perfectly live? So who are some other bad singers, Geoff Tate? Rob Halford? Dio? Bruce Dickinson? I bet those guys suck too dont they?
FritzDT2112 5 years ago
That was actually awesome!!
LerxstTheAnalogKid 5 years ago
great cover
toocooly 5 years ago
Well, thats the best band in the world, isn´t it? LOL
They can do whatever they want.
Have you seen them playn Metallica? It´s perfect.
frajolaking 5 years ago
;O!
nice shirt, Mr Petrucci xDD
Great cover.
This mates rlz.
Pollyasdf 5 years ago
Dream Theater hacen lo q quieren,tocan Rush,Pink Floyd,Led Zeppelin,Eltohn John,Kansas,Metallica,etc,..... q buenossssss
yagorush 5 years ago
OMG... would you upload more?
mhobbit 5 years ago
Absolutely superb... Well as usual
Top Class!!
ikickedyourmum 5 years ago
amazing..which dvd is this?
facnunc1 5 years ago
Toatally Awesome....Would love to see more from this performance.
rickramos775 5 years ago
I WAS THERE!!!! AWESOME COVER IT WAS!! loved it
andythenutter 5 years ago
awesome
brakkum 5 years ago