Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (47)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • So what's the song for the 2nd G5?

  • @olskolsoul the second G5 is "Body Rock" recorded during the DIL and DF era

  • @Angelfully She's listed on the internarional album as a background bocalist. Whydon't you look it up instead of just assuming things?

  • @hessounusual95 I don't assume, I do look up things. The songs I picked didn't include Farrah at all, believe me. Her voice isn't strong either, she was more a replacement. I'm not being rude but it's irritating when people claim it's other artist when they don't even know the songs playing and know who are singing them. But anyway it's all good, I'm not coming at you. I'm just making a point. Sorry

  • @Angelfully You are still assuming things. I was just telling the beyonce stan who claimed that dc didn't use background vocalists that they did use a background vocalist. I wasn't discrediting any notes in this video, you assumed I was though :/ I was just correcting an incorrect statement that is all.

  • What's the song for the 2nd G5

  • I love when sings lower notes.

  • I like that you used different songs instead of the ones ppl always use.

  • whats. the first song.?

  • The F#2 was Beyonce. I'm not a huge fan of hers, but I can spot what's her voice & what isn't, it was her. I listened to them in some headphones that really allows vocals to shine, it's her.You can even listen to the B2 (Background) & then go back to the F#2 harmonized & tell it's her singing that.

  • the F#2 is Beyonce , Amazing Video .. One thing, Beyonce Have another harmonized Low Note in "Until the End of time" (Justin Timberlake SOng) at the part were she says " This one for the ladys...."

  • OMG I LOVE Stay and Killing Time.

  • Great video. I don't know what everyone else is hearing, but those low notes are definitely Beyonce. She has gotten better as she's gotten older, but I know it isn't Kelly or Michelle and we all know they didn't use background vocalists

  • @aaliyonce THANK YOU. That's ridiculous. Them using background vocalist? Laughable. Michelle has a great low register, but Beyonce sang the extra low harmony at times. It's not impossible for her to reach an F#2 considering how she projects so well down the lower register.

  • I know it's asking like waaaaaayyyy too much of you, but can i have the title of several of these songs.... pleeeeeeeeaaaaaasssseeeee!! :x

  • Everyone is saying that there's no proof that it's her, where where's the proof it isn't her?

  • Her lower register wasn't developed or prominent then as it is now? lol the BEST live Bb2 we have is from a DIL performance she did 2002. If there's something that hasn't got better with time but always stayed the same in Beyoncé's voice, it's her lower register.

  • that F#2 is from michelle williams!

  • @MimiXtinaChelleKRow Fail, as usually.

  • @Stefano94x

    um... michelle is always doing background vocals as alto...

  • @MimiXtinaChelleKRow

    just because i dont reply doesnt mean you get the final say/you are right i actually have what you call a life... thus, i dont bother quarreling with you...

    the F#2 timbre was relatively bright and the the tone was thin thats why i say its michelle coz bey's tone is thicker...

  • @MimiXtinaChelleKRow You have a life? LMFAO. I found you talking about me on other channels. That's not having a life, that's being a coward. You're a master at it.

    Bye now.

  • @MimiXtinaChelleKRow But that low F# was clearly hit by Bee. That was just another of your pathetic attempts at diminishing her.

  • Quite a few are wrong. F#2 is not Beyonce, doesn't sound like her at all. The F#2/G#2 aren't her either. Unless you can prove that no background vocalist were used on the album then you shouldn't assume so. Her low register wasn't anywhere near as development or prominent as it is now. It's like with Mariah's Say Somethin', people thought she was doing G#2s but Trey Lorenz was a background vocalist, so you can't be sure. Why Don't You Love Me is a Bb5 and not a B5, 8:39 is a C#6, not a B5/C6.

  • @calvin9999999999 WRONG in Perfect Man, Beyonce and Kelly were only singing. That G#2 was her. Why would their be a background vocalist? The girls can sing. I also believe the F#2 was her too (it's arguable, b/c it could have been Michelle). And the exclamation was a C6, I listened to it several times. It was alittle flat. But yeah. You're points are invalid. I'm huge DC listener and I can spot when Beyonce is singing. Thanks for commenting anyway, but you're wrong here. Sorry

  • @calvin9999999999 yes Mariah uses background vocal, but Beyoncé don't, even now she sings every vocals, of course even DC sang all their vocals.....

  • @GCassa94 Actually they did have a background vocalist on this album, Farrah Franklin. Look it up.

  • @hessounusual95 lol No they didn't. Farrah wasn't even around long enough in the group to record an album with them, that's how I know you are making up stuff.

  • @hessounusual95 Ferrah didn't hit that F#2 and she was not a background vocalist! She was a member of DC, so they didn't have any background vocalist...

  • @GCassa94 Did I say that Farrah hit the F#2? What is with you stans being so defensive and jumping to false conclusions? Farrah is listed as a "background vocalist" on the Survivor album.

  • @hessounusual95 Oh my bad. I guess I didn't read your previous conversation. I thought you were implying that Farrah hit those notes. Any who...continue with your other convo

  • F#2 sounds fry-ish.

  • "Why Don't You Love Me" sound pitched... i remember it was Bb5

  • Where is that F#2 from btw?

  • @TheVocalPower "White Christmas"

  • An F#2!? :O OMG!!!

  • Great video!! That F#2 was insane I had never heard it before!

  • Love this :) So glad you included the C#3s in 'Love' no one ever uses them!

  • YES! YOU DID THIS!! The F#2, Bb2 & G#2 in perfect man YES! B2's are lethal, C#3's & D3's in honesty. I love this

  • Living the Queen !

  • what song is that very last low note. after "Bridges"

  • That F#2 is latavia roberson.

  • @VisualInfamy No it isn't b/c Latavia wasn't in the group during that time. That was DC3

  • @Angelfully Oh, it sounds like her. Doesnt really sound like Bey to me.

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more