Now, the video shows us that her boyfriend has died in the war and she has moved on with another man, but she is haunted by her old love's memory and their past happiness that she knows she will never achieve with her new man. It's that simple.
I think it's hilarious that ppl think this song is about her cheating when it is actually about her losing her boyfriend. Even though she has moved on physically, she cant seem to move on emotionally. Why?? BECAUSE WHEN SHE IS WITH HER NEW GUY SHE IS CONSTANTLY THINKING OF HER PAST LOVE.
i know its a sad song my great grama died and i played this song for her and she was 99 i still miss her and i have 1 pic of her but im ok ill still have her in my heart
Of course she can write a song about that. Artists don't write songs to show you how awesome they are, they write about real people, and real people are not perfect. They cheat, they make mistakes.
In The Video, Her Boyfriend Who She Was In Love With Went Off To War, He Died While Serving His Country. "'Cause When I'm With Him I Am Thinking Of You."
@joeyt7923 : I don't mean to be rude,but you're so lost. It's RIGHT there! The vid means that when her bf was in war,she cheated on him. Now that he's dead,she regrets having an affair.
No I think you'll find from what she say's in her interviews about the song Isn't her cheating, It's that she used to go out with the guy who she keeps thinking back about, he went to fight the war so they broke up, she went out with someone else while (the guy in the same room), but keeps thinking about her ex bf while she's with her current one. Ex bf dies fighting so I except she's on the mailing list to find out as she's still very close to him even though they're not an item.
@southsidehustla2 : Oh,ok. But that's what the song is about. In the video,it doesn't show the break-up before he goes to war. That's why most people think she's cheating. I guess it's just the director's fault...
huh? actually the story of this song for short is that:
Katy still loves her past boyfriend who died in action in a war... her memories with her PAST boyfriend (NOT EXBOYFRIEND COZ THEY DID NOT BROKE UP) flashbacks....
then she still misses him... Katty's getting over her PAST boyfriend is SLOW...
then here she has a New BOYFRIEND... but who she didn't LOVE so MUCH than Her PAST BOYFRIEND....
Actually, I don't really get this song! Or, well I get the song, but the video! Is she cheating on her boyfriend, who is out in war? I just don't get it! No offense! It's really emotional and beautiful, but could someone tell me the concept?
well, her ex-boyfriend went out to war, and told her to move on. so she goes with this guy, and says that she feels horrible for it, because she would rather he was her ex, because to her he was perfect, and she misses him. make sense now? :)
her boyfriend died in the war and now she's with another guy but she still thinks of her other boyfriend.. thats why she read a letter that he died and she was getting ready for a funeral or she was just sad and dressed uo in black haha
um btw in the 1st she wanted a guy....the one that was all in white.....and being sweet.....and drinking wine with her...that is why she was all distant from the other guy and pulled away when the girl tried something.....and she was talking all about being disgusted with herself bc after all in that one she isn't with the one person she loves. She is instead with two ppl she doesn't love.
oh no minds its when she just kiss a girl and was just implying sexual atraction but when it all of a sudden means more and becomes more intament of a song everyone freaks out
I fucking hate this shit those corprate assholes trying to make this song about something its not it has nothing to do with war this song is about falling in love with someone of the same sex and then breaking up because people want you to be with guys instead then later regreting it because you know in your heart it doesn't feel right and you want to be with the person you love regradless of what there gender is
@SPIDERLILY21: actually its not bout war but it gots somthing she tells her to move on cause hes going away so if he dies she wont feel so hurt. he made a big mistake tho cause she loves him w. her heart, she tries to 4get him w. another guy but she cant cause hi is her true love. the song and the vid go w. each other. n this song is not 4 saying i love lesbians or i love homos is bout love doesnt matter wut gender u belong 2. love is love no matter how or w. who. ATT MADDIE
Calm down, okay. Everyone has their own interpretations. You just can't force the others to have it your own way; that's just becoming...equally intolerant.
I think, the video, is about Katies bf going off to war and dieing. But, before he left the bf told Katie to move on if he did pass away in the war. She does move on, but everytime she is with the new guy, she keeps thinking of her first bf that she did love and cherish. So, every guy she dates after her bf dieing, will just feel like second best and make her happy, but not what she really wants. She will, always, want her first bf that died. Thats my take on the vid, I could be wrong though : )
Hey. At least, you are better than he is. You are so precious. This is what make you so special than any girl. Believe me, he just lost a treasure. He's a pig, and he doesn't deserve it. It's not good when a pig steps on a pearl. Be strong over any man you date with.
oh, ic '.' and hey, i was only explaining it in the way i interpretated it. the video didn't really show her cheating on her previous boyfriend and to me, the lyrics sound like she didn't ^^;
I know I can't have you after all we went through and how much you hurt me. I met Nick and he taught me how to push my love to the back of my mind and move on but... I always loved you. I don't want you, but I love you so fucking much.
hes goin into air force... stop bitchin... you sound like hes goin to die or somethin... if he aint joinin the army and goin INFANTRY(hooah).. you got nothin to worry about
soooooooooooo.. i still dont see how thats dangerous..... sounds like he is FO followin PL around and being protected 24/7--- if you dont know shit stfu bitch
What a beautiful woman she has become...she may be the mother of my children any day...
Za7a7aZ 1 year ago
this is matt dallas?? woah. he looks awesome with katy!!!! :)
wade8081 1 year ago
Makes me cry daily.
grundefsun854 1 year ago
ummm. Matt Dallas???
potterizeme 1 year ago
this song makes me want to cry but i like it
rileylover56 1 year ago
I am the ex boyfriend, who was killed in action, this song makes me weep a lot as well, wierd but true.....miss u katy kat xxx
manomogul 1 year ago
I am so so so so so so sorry katy I know what you feel like my xboyfriend died in action
grace87002 1 year ago
Last part=shivvvvvveerrrrrrsssssss
Traxxas1992 1 year ago
Sad:'( omg shes so beautiful
Traxxas1992 1 year ago
LOve The Song.. But the Quality Sucks
MrsKool12 1 year ago
shes not that talented,at least in this song..
wilsongymballer 1 year ago
Her voice sounds terrible in this song.
bubblygemini 1 year ago
Lindo!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
julianabastos1977 1 year ago
OMG! Kate X-boyfriend was KYLE XY! :-O
Love u both kate and Kyle..:-)
igleng 1 year ago
this is so sad :'(
TheAllthatglitters12 1 year ago
gracie12341234123
o no
grace87002 1 year ago
that wasso sad and beautiful, much betr than first version
rachgurlie 1 year ago
Comment removed
grace87002 1 year ago
Now, the video shows us that her boyfriend has died in the war and she has moved on with another man, but she is haunted by her old love's memory and their past happiness that she knows she will never achieve with her new man. It's that simple.
GeminiLaw84 1 year ago
I think it's hilarious that ppl think this song is about her cheating when it is actually about her losing her boyfriend. Even though she has moved on physically, she cant seem to move on emotionally. Why?? BECAUSE WHEN SHE IS WITH HER NEW GUY SHE IS CONSTANTLY THINKING OF HER PAST LOVE.
GeminiLaw84 1 year ago
This video made me cry,
sexytimemuffincakes 1 year ago
i know its a sad song my great grama died and i played this song for her and she was 99 i still miss her and i have 1 pic of her but im ok ill still have her in my heart
iLOVEainme 1 year ago
Why is it when I go to a funeral, this song plays in my head?
790936 1 year ago
@790936 Ditto.. :)
TheMuffinWoman13 1 year ago
who's the dead boyfriend? :DDD
fishnetproductionsx 1 year ago
@fishnetproductionsx Matt Dallas AKA Kyle XY
GIGIUNITED 1 year ago
how come she don't upload any more good songs on here?
Timaptimean 1 year ago
Wow..the end of this music video gives me chills every time...
AnthonysAngelgirl 1 year ago
i agree with mikee5891..
ginnylady02 1 year ago
i love this song...<3 <3 <3
alexandrboo 1 year ago
omgsh i started crying when i saw this i'ts so sad. :'(
guitargirly66 1 year ago 3
Of course she can write a song about that. Artists don't write songs to show you how awesome they are, they write about real people, and real people are not perfect. They cheat, they make mistakes.
swanx 1 year ago
this isnt about her cheating you dumb asses. why the fuck would she write a song about her cheating. Use common sense.
xPeter69KatyPerryx 1 year ago
Comment removed
HeavyMetal3426 1 year ago
is the guy in the picture kyle xy?
eyestii27 1 year ago 5
@eyestii27 : YUP :)
HeavyMetal3426 1 year ago
Wow...dead BF looks like Marlon Brando...huh.
amphagori 1 year ago
and I'm thinking in him <3
:3
I LOVE YOU!!
sasutayu 1 year ago
Jak źle opiniuje to od razu usuwacie? :/
No to powtórzę :
To brzmi jak piosenka Miley Cyrus The Climb. To znaczy na początku.
Gabisenka 1 year ago
I like this one waaaaaaay better than the 1st version the first one is way confusing and this one has a lot deeper meaning.
JasminePersonal123 1 year ago 3
no it doesnt
TheDianaJC 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This is sound like song Miley Cyrus The Clibm... :/
Gabisenka 1 year ago
Erm, no, it really doesn't : S
vevi69 1 year ago
katy perry not kate perry
georgiaBillK 1 year ago 4
sozard... its only a spellin mistake :L
mizztaylor11 1 year ago
it makes me remember adrian all the time :(
girlz2ne1 1 year ago
this doesn't make sense to me...
joeyt7923 1 year ago
In The Video, Her Boyfriend Who She Was In Love With Went Off To War, He Died While Serving His Country. "'Cause When I'm With Him I Am Thinking Of You."
staci110196 1 year ago 2
@joeyt7923 : I don't mean to be rude,but you're so lost. It's RIGHT there! The vid means that when her bf was in war,she cheated on him. Now that he's dead,she regrets having an affair.
HeavyMetal3426 1 year ago 2
No I think you'll find from what she say's in her interviews about the song Isn't her cheating, It's that she used to go out with the guy who she keeps thinking back about, he went to fight the war so they broke up, she went out with someone else while (the guy in the same room), but keeps thinking about her ex bf while she's with her current one. Ex bf dies fighting so I except she's on the mailing list to find out as she's still very close to him even though they're not an item.
southsidehustla2 1 year ago 2
@southsidehustla2 : Oh,ok. But that's what the song is about. In the video,it doesn't show the break-up before he goes to war. That's why most people think she's cheating. I guess it's just the director's fault...
HeavyMetal3426 1 year ago
its katy, btw
rhiaanbaby 1 year ago
I gave this a 1 bec the title is a lie. It's not hd
DarkAurora2002 1 year ago
well now i'm gonna cry, oh. oh I really needed that, thanks.
Sugarlandjackson 1 year ago
amazing, amazing.
xxPOISONEDcupcakeXX 1 year ago
this made me cry... :'(
MegaNx934 1 year ago 30
i love this reminds me of my x
876Candy 1 year ago
brings tears to my eyes
ilovedemi12345 1 year ago 2
hes from kyle xy isnt he?????????????????
alonelyfairy 1 year ago 2
yeah he is
Matt Dallas
RavenRoth67 1 year ago
i'm so carried away by this vid.... it made me so sentimental
jadenalexis820 1 year ago 2
huh? actually the story of this song for short is that:
Katy still loves her past boyfriend who died in action in a war... her memories with her PAST boyfriend (NOT EXBOYFRIEND COZ THEY DID NOT BROKE UP) flashbacks....
then she still misses him... Katty's getting over her PAST boyfriend is SLOW...
then here she has a New BOYFRIEND... but who she didn't LOVE so MUCH than Her PAST BOYFRIEND....
SHE DID NOT CHEAT ON HER PAST BOYFRIEND...
mikee5891 2 years ago 22
@mikee5891 Actually, thats what the first music video for this song depicted.- sorry. they changed it last minute to this.
psimpson1982 2 years ago
@mikee5891 Yes, that is very true mikee5891
manomogul 1 year ago
shes like an indian summer in the middle of winter.. hmmm..
u1inmotion 2 years ago
Actually, I don't really get this song! Or, well I get the song, but the video! Is she cheating on her boyfriend, who is out in war? I just don't get it! No offense! It's really emotional and beautiful, but could someone tell me the concept?
JonasSisterJS 2 years ago
well, her ex-boyfriend went out to war, and told her to move on. so she goes with this guy, and says that she feels horrible for it, because she would rather he was her ex, because to her he was perfect, and she misses him. make sense now? :)
danfan099 2 years ago
OMG...I didn't get the video too and now that I know that it's even more horrible!
garancevn 2 years ago
Oh, yes, thank you! ;)
JonasSisterJS 2 years ago
the guy in the military died and she found someone new but shes still thinking of him.
i think
xXvampickleXx 2 years ago
her boyfriend died in the war and now she's with another guy but she still thinks of her other boyfriend.. thats why she read a letter that he died and she was getting ready for a funeral or she was just sad and dressed uo in black haha
malacamoo 2 years ago
this music video makes me cry :(
lolzitsmary 2 years ago 2
love her shoes
alpuke 2 years ago
um btw in the 1st she wanted a guy....the one that was all in white.....and being sweet.....and drinking wine with her...that is why she was all distant from the other guy and pulled away when the girl tried something.....and she was talking all about being disgusted with herself bc after all in that one she isn't with the one person she loves. She is instead with two ppl she doesn't love.
AceCarmen 2 years ago
oh no minds its when she just kiss a girl and was just implying sexual atraction but when it all of a sudden means more and becomes more intament of a song everyone freaks out
spiderlily21 2 years ago
there was nothing wrong with the first version oh she wants to be with a woman so fucking what if thats who she loves thats where her heart belongs
spiderlily21 2 years ago
the only reason this verson was made was to apease conservative christian types and people who are against gay rights its fucking bull shit
spiderlily21 2 years ago
I fucking hate this shit those corprate assholes trying to make this song about something its not it has nothing to do with war this song is about falling in love with someone of the same sex and then breaking up because people want you to be with guys instead then later regreting it because you know in your heart it doesn't feel right and you want to be with the person you love regradless of what there gender is
spiderlily21 2 years ago
@SPIDERLILY21: actually its not bout war but it gots somthing she tells her to move on cause hes going away so if he dies she wont feel so hurt. he made a big mistake tho cause she loves him w. her heart, she tries to 4get him w. another guy but she cant cause hi is her true love. the song and the vid go w. each other. n this song is not 4 saying i love lesbians or i love homos is bout love doesnt matter wut gender u belong 2. love is love no matter how or w. who. ATT MADDIE
PRandNY 2 years ago
Calm down, okay. Everyone has their own interpretations. You just can't force the others to have it your own way; that's just becoming...equally intolerant.
Pamelflurry 1 year ago
her name is spelt Katy Perry.
nbbroxmysox123 2 years ago
Saddest Shxtt I've Ever Seen Besides "The Boy In The Striped Pajamas" Movies!
sexidimplez08 2 years ago
@sexidimplez08
seen that movie so sadd when they get gassed :(
criedd . XX
CutieShoot 2 years ago
KYLE XY !!!!!! @ 0:27
EMIlovesUNICORNS 2 years ago
this video is so much better than the first one.
cookiecuddle 2 years ago
Comment removed
cnovartis 2 years ago
Aww. I like this video much better than the other. OMG! It's Matt Dallas from Kyle XY! QT!
tizzydancemaniac 2 years ago
Thinking of you Christine....
malsante 2 years ago
i love Katy Perrry's Music :Dx
CupCakesxx123 2 years ago
OH MG i cried so hard even my mom cried!!
joeyj299 2 years ago 2
this song reminds me of my crush i have but were both to shy to talk to and i love this video it's my fave =)
hjb31698 2 years ago
I love the shoes she's wearing!!!
mstifffni 2 years ago 5
I think, the video, is about Katies bf going off to war and dieing. But, before he left the bf told Katie to move on if he did pass away in the war. She does move on, but everytime she is with the new guy, she keeps thinking of her first bf that she did love and cherish. So, every guy she dates after her bf dieing, will just feel like second best and make her happy, but not what she really wants. She will, always, want her first bf that died. Thats my take on the vid, I could be wrong though : )
sillynut91 2 years ago 10
@sillynut91 great ! but we know...
MattDaneTV 2 years ago
No shit sillynut91. The lyrics told us that. lmfao
fandanstan 2 years ago
ha ha ha!!!! true
charliexranxaway 2 years ago
Ohh My Dayss iiCriied At Thiis ! ♥
MadiiBabii 2 years ago 3
that guy is from kyle x or somethhing
CoolGal519 2 years ago
this is such a sad song :(
but i luv katy perry's voice :D
wutever234 2 years ago 2
i really like this song. i can't really relate to t though..
ellen5281991 2 years ago
my man left me. every time im on a date with another guy, i think of him and it kills me. =(
SalasraTheBandie 2 years ago 3
Hey. At least, you are better than he is. You are so precious. This is what make you so special than any girl. Believe me, he just lost a treasure. He's a pig, and he doesn't deserve it. It's not good when a pig steps on a pearl. Be strong over any man you date with.
Tibly 2 years ago
i dont really get this can someone explain
robe121 2 years ago
1) Kate + perfect guy
2) perfect guy goes to war
3) perfect guy dies
4) Kate ends up with not-perfect guy
5) Kate goes to perfect guy's funeral
It's basically about how she misses her first love and how she's always thinking of him even when she's with guy no.2
bn8299 2 years ago
@bn8299 no.
1)Katy+Husband
2)Husband goes off to war
3)While Husband is @ war, Katy cheats with a diffrent guy.
4)Gets letter about his death.
5)Katy is guilty b/c he was fighting for her to be more free, and she cheats oin him.
6)Wishes he was the last person she kissed.
that is how it is. HE DIES! they NEVER broke up. smaryty
AMA09ish 2 years ago
she's dating a guy but everytime she's with him, she thinks about her previous relationship if a guy who was killed and she misses him
crazylovinbutterfly 2 years ago
@robe121 she is betraying her 'husband or boyfriend' with a guy while the husband is away at war. and then the husband dies.
PheebsDeLaCarterre 2 years ago
@PheebsDeLaCarterre
exactly!
AMA09ish 2 years ago
oh, ic '.' and hey, i was only explaining it in the way i interpretated it. the video didn't really show her cheating on her previous boyfriend and to me, the lyrics sound like she didn't ^^;
bn8299 2 years ago
@bn8299 okie doke
AMA09ish 2 years ago
@PheebsDeLaCarterre i think the husband had already died
meggypooh101 2 years ago
Katy Perry has a Bettie Paige thing going on here. Hotness.
DaMorg3 2 years ago 3
Kyle XY ffs
irmelinklementin 2 years ago
waw the soldier that was killed in action is pretty hot!! who is he??
ivytheleader1 2 years ago 2
The soldier is Matthew Joseph Dallas. If you want to see more of him, check out the show Kyle XY. He is the lead role in it.
Cheers.
DivineDubai 2 years ago
yeah!
ellen5281991 2 years ago
missing is the worst feeling of the world,but forgetting is even worst.
lollipop32599 2 years ago 7
This has been flagged as spam show
I like the way you put that :)
JoyNine7 2 years ago
thx...thats why i try hard not to miss the bad things,but always remeber the good things =)
lollipop32599 2 years ago
sexxi soldier in the viideo,lol
luciddreamluv87 2 years ago 4
its similar to ghost of you by mcr
DragQueen 2 years ago 3
The first version of this video makes no sense lol
britneeirenebenson 2 years ago 3
how does it not make since???
WITCHY420WOMAN 2 years ago
relly good
0607marina 2 years ago
Kristine I miss you so much,
I know I can't have you after all we went through and how much you hurt me. I met Nick and he taught me how to push my love to the back of my mind and move on but... I always loved you. I don't want you, but I love you so fucking much.
With all her love,
Brantly Harper Iracleanos.
HarperJeevas 2 years ago 2
missing is the worst feeling on the world!
DragQueen 2 years ago
no, guilt is.
BLANKETxR 2 years ago
lindo video
919722able 2 years ago
Simplesmente Linda!
Keissi19 2 years ago
ameiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii
DaNiElA31401 2 years ago
matt dallas...so dreamy
javiiiro 2 years ago
great video
Msjf22 2 years ago
the end is soo sad.
sunshinelollipops96 2 years ago
This is an amazing song:]
I'm just curious what's an Indian summer??
julianna962 2 years ago
its hot whether, in the middle of the winter, so its some nice hot whether in the cold. basically he's great
RyanOBrienMusic 2 years ago
is the guy one of the characters in kyle XY??.. he is the main character right??...
chyrlene18 2 years ago
@chyrlene18
yeah he's the guys kyle XY
MsGracie1995 2 years ago
this song is so sad i amost cried
TheLovelyP 2 years ago
Reminds meof MCr's Ghost of You video
SummerII 2 years ago
Hermosa cancion, no me canso de escuxarla
Milliefv 2 years ago
lol what??
they had like the notebook scene in there riding on the bikes
SunRisenStars 2 years ago
its so sad and romantic...
I LOVE THIS SONG!!!1
kOkKoLiKa 2 years ago 5
today my 17 year old boyfriend for the last three months told me he is going to an air force recruiter with his friend Bret tomorrow
he will be 18 tomorrow. . . i am 16 and i know im young but to me this is love
idk why i posted this but i did
meJUSTme243 2 years ago 4
hes goin into air force... stop bitchin... you sound like hes goin to die or somethin... if he aint joinin the army and goin INFANTRY(hooah).. you got nothin to worry about
noclip77 2 years ago
well shes scared for him. gosh.
TheGuavaHead 2 years ago 2
thanks for understanding
meJUSTme243 2 years ago
actualy he is goin to be on call for air support in the midle east . . .
meJUSTme243 2 years ago
soooooooooooo.. i still dont see how thats dangerous..... sounds like he is FO followin PL around and being protected 24/7--- if you dont know shit stfu bitch
noclip77 2 years ago
my favourite song ....! love the video ( the 2nd one)
yagoo501 2 years ago 3
thats the guy from Kyle XY right?
jacobkun2004 2 years ago
Yeah, it's Matt Dallas. :) He's so hot. And such an amazing actor.
stupivideoswithKnE 2 years ago 2
This video makes me think of one of my ex's that i still love. : '(
pinkskulled 2 years ago 4
I love you kate perry...............
RLCProds 2 years ago 6
I love this video... its so sad and romantic...
rosehillwarriorf1215 2 years ago 9
i luv kate perry no homo an all her songs
WifeyWells 2 years ago 3
Eu ChORO com esse VideO !
TheGabyzinha4 2 years ago 3
this song is so sad but i love it
titanicmoviefan112 2 years ago 3
HD my ass!
abuelodelmal 2 years ago 2
lol.
maimingbetty 2 years ago
the was so cute..as well as the song and story..hmm so sad scene.. i love this song..
olizel 2 years ago
I'm not so sure cute is the right word... I would use heart-breaking.
Jteether 2 years ago 2
i like this video better than the other one
such a good song
this video is very notebook like even though noah didnt die but i mean there are many scenes that reminded me of the notebook :)
argbarb8 2 years ago 9
i got the creeps with this song
DeathW8 2 years ago 4
lol why xDDD
hailprism 2 years ago
she'is a beatiful girl and I love this song.I love you Katty
Tefa8Tita 2 years ago 7
This is such a sad video.... But very beautiful.
Uphadis 2 years ago 3
Beautifully sad.
Belgari 2 years ago 6
she looks like the girl from YES with Jim Carry!
KrazyKirby101 2 years ago 3
I illways thought the same! They do look a lot alike!
lucianocopete 2 years ago 2
muito show esse clipe!
sigla100 2 years ago 2
may I know the actor name in the video?
Is it the same as Lady gaga paparazzi one?
queenie0111 2 years ago 2
his name is matt dallas
WaitingForMyEmmett 2 years ago 3
aht
Geovana52 2 years ago
just beautiful i love it becouse i live something like this history and that's so sad i love you edgar i love you!!!
mrastareggae 2 years ago
this song always hella makes me cry...
meg1241989 2 years ago
this is one amazing looking woman, she's got a spell over me
GQchris75 2 years ago 5
incrivel esse video muito linda essa musica,
parabéns para quem postou o video.
pedrodemesquitasousa 2 years ago
i really don't like katy perry but holy crap i almost cried in this video.
chiipooted 2 years ago 6
lindo de mais
hansonmaniaco 2 years ago
This video isn't HD, but it's great
raposaesquila 2 years ago
JUST BEAUTIFUL KATY! wanna see her and david cook acoustic together! SOO MUCH FEELING! IMAGINE
NyCArole426 2 years ago 2