Added: 3 years ago
From: KMRakaKAT
Views: 245,053
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (313)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • The Wall + The Final Cut = Roger at his best

  • For me, this is the best Pink Floyd album. The post war dream is just a dream, man will never stop killing each other until the panet is gone.

  • What did happen to the post war dream?

  • Amazing stuff right here...

  • My favorite album of all time and such a beautiful track

  • Damn right

  • maggie thacher?

  • So the child of a Nazi is now sabre rattling? Wasn't the last conflict painful enough for both sides? She should listen to this album and book a seat in the Fletcher Memorial Home.

  • I LOVE THIS SONG! And Pink Floyd

    Can't wait til Roger Waters comes to Argentina :D

  • what a dream..!

  • maggie.. MAGGIE WHAT HAVE WE DONE???!!!!..

  • what happened to OUR post war dream

  • he's not actually calling the japanese "nips." he's using that the same way black flag has a song called "white minority" and like mark twain's "nigger jim."

  • 2:12 gets me every time...great song.

  • its just... no words can explain!!! yes ?!?!

  • Gotta love the holophonics. It sounds amazing!

  • Anything less than 10 minutes silent contemplation after listening to this album means you need to play it again.

  • the best album ever written, by any band, at any time.

  • When I first heard this, I wasn't sure. It grows on you. Now with certitude, this is my favourite album (of any band)

  • In todays world, this album, as rich as it already is. Just grows in depth.

  • what happens when you deny real domocracy human rights and justice and peace in order that a few greedy people can steal the world and its future and leave the mass of the people in destitution, exploited using mass murder and fear lies and military might and ignorance

  • @sydneygpearson dumbocracy....

  • everytime he says daddy makes me cry inside a little....

  • Cries

  • This is sad :(

  • Think of it like this, if Roger's dad hadn't of died, half of the music that has changed and enhanced our lives would not exist. The fact that Roger's dad died serving his country inspired generations of people, and I'm sure his father would be proud to know that.

  • best albulm pink floyd evermade

  • I just got a new tablet and I thought this should be the first thing I visited.

  • Comment removed

  • this song should be in the movie trailer... just saying.

  • not yet, when the Muslims has taken over then we will ask "what have we done to England?"

  • @MrKurmann Not sure if troll or just...evil.

  • @MrKurmann, the true "terrorists" aren't the Muslins, Sadam, Bin Laden, Alá, Buddah, Jesus...

    The true "terrorists" are the ones who rule our lifes. They come to tv everyday, create laws to force us to work more, with less conditions, create economic crisis and incute fear to us, only to take our freedom. The true terrorists are Bush, Obama, Sarkosy, Markel, Cameron, etc. They are the ones that should be in Fletcher Memorial Home!

    Then the final solution could be applied...

  • @HolyMuscleOfLove and who said those are terrorists? but you are right to some extent, those controlling the "systems" are.. I won't call them "terrorists" I call them organized crime. They are so well organized that they become legitimate. The protests in major cities now, I believe are of the same thought. but it's also true that Muslims are slowly taking over the west. question is, is this the natural course? do we want that to happen in England? you know what it will be like then...

  • @MrKurmann Muslims are taking over the west? There have been protests in America long before these past few years. Have you ever seen a picture from the 60's?

  • @camarorider67 nope.. that would probably be too far back.. but I m talking about now. 01 city in West Yorkshire has been taken over. France have more practicing Muslims than Christians.. they are building Mosques in Alaska dude!

  • @MrKurmann I can already tell that you hold a paranoid prejudice against Muslims so, i'm just gonna leave you with this comment. All religions spread, Christianity at one time was just a single group of men in a few basements. Scratch that, two comments. They can't take over America on account of this little piece of paper called the Constitution, it promises that no one religion can impose its laws on the others, so you don't have to worry about Sharia Law here in the states. Peace.

  • @MrKurmann

    true, glad someone has the ballls to speak up!

  • Eargasmic...............

  • wow, this album is so underrated

  • @lio543 nope sold over two million, two million people listened to this and even more today

  • @Rorschachxx1985 Yes, but i meant underrated near albums like Dark Side of the Moon or The Wall (which were also amazing)

  • Imagine a current mainstream rock album actually naming and accusing a serving prime minister! Passionately concerned with this country's modern history... And geting to number 1. Those were different times indeed. The best post-Syd-Barrett Floyd album my miles.

  • In Roger we trust!!!!

    David has NO CLUE to reality in the world!!

    Believe me.

    Cambridge is and allways has been a retreat for academics who do NOT live in today's reality.

    They live in the past and the future (Hawkins at DAMTP).

    Roger has allways dealt with reality as he perceived it.

    Today this is just as important as ever.

  • @blitzman64 Pink Floyd is a band that has(-d) as members both Roger and David. And both had their very important role in the history of the band, so no need to classify them. If you love PF you love them as they are, it's like this simple.

  • god bless roger waters

  • in floyd we trust \\m//.god bless you guys.music for the gods

  • @010:06 "Was it you, was it me, did I watch too much TV, is that

    a hint of accusation in your eyes?"

  • really great album and I grew up on P F and everyone I knew had "The Wall" dark side seemed this never got the notoriety it should have

  • I'm almost glad Roger ended his Pink Floyd with this. It's a beautiful, emotional, and shocking album.

  • thanks for the full playlist to this

  • Should we shout? Should we scream? What happened, to the post-war dream?

  • El Corte Final es una obra maestra del talento de Pink Floyd!

  • I personally think The Final Cut was one of the GREATEST PFloyd albums out there..

  • @BigRockMusicFan and very likely the  greatest rock album ever

  • @nydukeman absolutely!

  • mais n'y a-t-il donc pas d'auditeurs français ?? ou francophones du moins ? non, je ne peux pas croire ça... où êtes-vous ?

  • ôôô, comme tout ça me prend aux tripes, et c'est toujours le même effet depuis presque 20 ans... et pour longtemps encore j'espère !

  • You know its really interesting how a used to be pornstar person ends up having over 3 hundred million views but this barely over 2 hundred thousand. These songs have meanings for god sakes. every songs these guys wrote had something to think about.

  • Brilliant album....I love the talking sheep who repeat the party line on this album.....get an original thought idiots

  • I just love this album

  • This album *is* a full grown man crying.

  • I teared up.

  • @seanryan22 what are you talking about? Pink Floyd never gonna die...

  • I cant believe how much this song applies to England right now. Awsome album

  • 'Maggie, what have we done?' That line reflects everything that everyone today is thinking...

  • OMG this is for Japan, and now Japan is everywhere...you'll see if you don't...yet.

  • Brilliant song, my marching band is doing this song in our show and I cant wait

  • This Album can Make a full grown man cry

  • @holycrackers123 Trust me, It has.

  • @holycrackers123 Aside from ATD this is Roger Waters finest moment...and seems to be coming full circle in 2012...my brother is likely to be setting sail for the South Atlantic any day now...so sad

  • @SneakyShark

    how sad that it seams innevitable that the islands will have to be defended again. Hopefully a show of intent now will keep your brother safe.

  • roger blows my head and mind gunners dream man its my funural song

  • mozart then you dont understand go back to school

  • there can't be much fun for them beneath the rising sun.... :(

  • I love this album...as it can adress so many levels of your mind if you let it.

  • Fair enough, and I in no way feel less of anyone for liking it.

  • Sorry, but IMO this album should never have been made. It's got a couple good songs, but seems to be just a self indulgent rant by Waters. It sounds like leftovers from "The Wall".  Pink Floyd is one of my favorite bands and I can't get through this thing.

  • @Mozart1220 I've heard this opinion before and it has some sens but this still is one of my favorite albums. i think that its not a mistake they put it out because it has really beautiful songs in there that i think can't fit anywhere else

  • @Mozart1220 According to Gilmour, I said to Roger, "If these songs weren't good enough for The Wall, why are they good enough now?"

  • The Final Cut is my favorite Pink Floyd album... A bit gloomy tough....

  • ...night...i and my truck...solitary road...music by "the final cut"...thanks Roger...

  • Pink Floyd has been and will always be...my all time favorite...awesome talent making even more incredible music...ahhh...therapy for troubling times..

  • wht the fuck happend to the Paranoid eyes - pink floyd video?!?!?! what the fuck is '' EMI music'' doing, how the hell is it claiming videos for it self?!?!?!?!? fuck you emi!!!!

  • oh. my. god. this is amazing

  • BEAUTIFULL!!!!

  • This simply to me is the best floyd album

  • Before I get chomped on, let me say I am a huge Pink Floyd fan. Vocally, eh, they weren't amazing. In their ability to write the music for the instruments? Eh, average. Lyrics? Godly. Arrangement? Sexy.

  • @freethetech

    Surely, you have such mediocre taste that you cannot truly understand Pink Floyd.

  • @xabixabixa Mediocre taste? You're calling a die-hard Beatles, Pink Floyd, and Zeppelin fan mediocre? Alright, buddy.

  • @freethetech A die hard pink floyd fan would never say that they were "Eh" or "Average"

  • I just can't understand people saying this is the worst Pink Floyd!!

  • @kingfraiser

    I found Division Bell to be my least favourite album. The Final Cut is fucking awesome!!

  • Listening about the nips building ships, its almost as if they could see the future.

  • @awesomepants18 You spoke to soon :(

  • Another Floyd master piece!!!

  • @vLegendKiller They wanted to make an album that was comprised of solo material from all four members, I guess it was just because it was the avant garde period, and they were testing the waters- you hear the finished result. The only tolerable thing on Ummagumma is Gilmour's "The Narrow Way," and even that's not GREAT

  • @cford1992 Sadly, the album was comprised of solo material from all four members of the band because it was Roger Waters' labour of love, comprised of the individual efforts of four band members who simply weren't and wouldn't speak to eachother at the time. Politics and the misguided striving for individual glory destroyed this once great group. Haven't heard much ground breaking new material since their break-up, have you. We know where most of the great song writing came from, Roger.

  • @cford1992 Testing the Waters - no pun intended?

  • What have we done?

  • What? Who? Where are the bodies buried?

  • Just goes to show you. It's 2011, I thought just about the most outspoken song of the time/subject matter was 'Shipbuilding' however, because the British Press/Music Press find The Floyd so difficult to deal with, this one gets burried. Shame. Waters screams out 'Maggie', naming the guilty party. Do The Floyd get any credit for being politically outspoken or active though in the way, say Elvis Costello did back in the day? Not a trace as far as I can tell.

  • @MrCheatsandliars really.? maybe you should dig a little more.

  • Three men, who disliked this, live beneath the rising sun and they are committing suicide.

  • any1 listening to pink floyd would like band of horses(new album) dr.dog, The Band so many more

  • Masterful song, sounds a bit too much like sam stone by johnny prine to me though.

  • @wesmusic1 check out The show must go on vs. Paul Simon's The only boy living in new york

  • There is nothing wrong with The Final Cut, for me, Pink Floyd's worst album is A Momentary Lapse of Reason

  • @cford1992 No. I got hooked to Pink Floyd first by listening to A Momentary Lapse of Reason

  • @CheersGP It's not better than the Final Cut, next to Ummagumma, Lapse of Reason is the worst

  • @cford1992 Can't help but agree that it's not better than this.

  • Good move, nonesta. 

  • the best forever!!!

  • His father would've been fucking proud.

  • @buddy39914 Well said!

    

  • who the fuck disliked this?

  • i can't feel Pink Floyd in this one....maybe.... add a little of Gilmour?

  • @Theinoch NEVER

  • YAY!!! back to 0 dislikes

    

  • Jesus died for our sins., The good sheppard lays down his life for the sheep he does nto run from the wolves. Ohh i tell you the truth they are here. These words are not mine. ipromise U

  • @TrueColors311 For the love of fuck. Do you religious freaks have a compulsory obligation to rant on every video, no matter what it's about? Do you realize you are insane, or do you insane people don't have a concept of that?

  • @1971ojoalparche1971 Shut up! You know nothing about saving world and dieing for people! Sheppard saved us all from Reapers!

    Jks=) But seriously if you ask me i hate every religious dumbass who does nothing but tries to preach teaching of their "god" which is nothing but lie!

  • @Theinoch Mass Effect ftw :D

    I agree wid dis cooment lololol

  • @TrueColors311 I decided I like this song now. Just because of you :)

  • what 1 knob disliked this???

    

  • sorry, i had to dislike this video. Its pretty much a blatant rip off of the song, "Sam Stone" by John Prine released 13 years before this. Same melody, same pace, same subject matter... I love floyd, but this is unacceptable.

  • @tominniti wow yeah it is. this album in general wasnt roger waters greatest ethical moment to be certain

  • @tominniti

    waters is a fan of prine

  • @RockAndRollMassacre

    Ah I didn't even think about that. You think it was a tribute?

  • @tominniti Sorry you missed the point. Waters was giving a nod to John Prine. "Why was Jesus crucified/Is that the reason daddy died?" and the line, "Did I watch too much TV?" This song is a tribute to Prine by Waters ... not a rip off. Musicians do this a lot. More than you think.

  • 0 dislikes

    thats how it should stay

  • Nice song, but not pink floyd.

  • @JewishChickenburger Of course it is pink floyd this album bring together the songs which weren't used for "the wall"

  • @JewishChickenburger It is Pink Floyd this album bring together the songs which hasn't being used in the wall

  • This is an amazing song! I think this album was a litle under rated, but you have to have an acquired taste to love Pink Floyd.

  • this album was created for destroy heads!

    the malvines belongs to argentine! Maggy tatcher to the guillotine!

  • EPIC.

  • Insanely underrated classic

  • in most bands there are a few good songs, but in pink floyd they are all so brilliantly fantastic that is dificult to tell that one is better than another

  • Pink floyd har ganske enkelt dannet mig. Det mest fantastiske band jeg nogensinde har hørt. pink Floyds tekster og lyrik slår til dato bunden ud af enhver og gør alt til billige kopier.

    Lars

  • tell me true , tell me why? was Jesus crucified, ? Rogers profound words fill my head , . . .

  • theres a reason there no dislikes

  • @awesomepants18 Sadly, 5 people have stepped in :(

  • @ahitler1000 i agree totally roger has influenced me since i started listening to the floyd since i was 10 im now 17 and he has influenced me and got me into playing the bass guitar, but he himself said that he was abit of a idiot in the later yrs of his carreer with the floyd

  • this album pisses me off i donno why roger didnt just relese it as a solo album after all i read that it said written by roger waters and perfomed by pink floyd

  • @ThePinkfloyd1969 youve got to read the book by nicklas shafner called "a saucerful of secrets, the pink floyd odyssey, . . it will answer all questions of rogers reasons , he, s my favorire so I guess Im a little predjudiced ,

  • pink floyd make me feel every thing in their songs..some take me back to my child hood..your right jonathan p ,they are a music genre

  • best anti war song ever!

  • An album so underestimated

  • My Favorite album!

  • was it for this that daddy died

  • it´s so beautiful. I cry always that listen this wonderful song.

  • ....no words need spoken

  • Thankyou so much for this great upload. It is much appreciated. Thanks PF. I owe you guys at least a case of beer in this life or the next, maybe a whole brewery.

  • Should we shout, should we SCREEAM ..?

    What happened ..?

  • looking forward to when the wall tour comes to norway

  • 0 Dislikes =)

  • i feel the need to go out and buy every single pink floyd album

  • @nonesta13 I think you should.

  • @nonesta13 Already have 'em, they're GREAT TO THIS FUCKING DAY!

  • @nonesta13 on september the floyd are doing a box set of all thier albums

  • @nonesta13 You haven't already? :O

  • roger waters is the man

  • Maggie what have we done?

  • thewall no. one the fincut no. 2 that it is fuck do u not hear it and see it

  • sorry about your father roger but i think we all got the point by now

  • @okrabay Do you have a father ?

  • musica que ficou gravado na memoria de quem realmente sabe o que e ser feliz e que saber discernir o que melhor a vida oferece...

  • Chistians versus Muslims. will your daddy die for this? is that a hint of accusation in your eye?

    

  • what have we done to england

  • such an under rated album