A/ He is either an idiot with a low attention span, who believes the heavily editted footage they show...
or
B/ He is a DISHONESTED, TWISTED, GOB SHITE WITH NO INTEGRITY who is prepared to do ANYTHING or TWIST ANY STORY, ANY WAY to please his right-wing,neo-con paymasters.
Can anyone else see the Fox employee's fist up his ass?
I just watched the video on what his thoughts on Hawking were, and.... damn. I think a better question than why we're here, why we're alive, is why this clown has his own show.
Bill O is a boob!!! I think we know how the planet got here, Bill.... we also know Evolution is a FACT.... and anyone who doesn't understand why the tides go up and down need to shut up for a while and start listening instead of running their mouth pretending like they know what they're talking about. What an ignoramus!
Adult/fetus stem cells are exactly the same. Ignorant O'Reilly! You call yourself a "pro life" as if the others were against life. That's a mistake from the get go. We'd better listen to some intelligent people, people from science not these religious morons.
Gotta hand it to him, who else can stretch "I don't know" out to a minute and four seconds?
On the other hand, had he done a minute and four seconds of research in advance of his non-answer, he might have prevented this video from being a complete waste of time.
@ec123456789able Much as I agree that Bill has no knowledge of science, I'd disagree with this statement.
There is a difference between a blastocyst and an egg yolk. A Blastocyst will develop into a Human. It is an early stage of all human lives. The egg yolks we normally eat are unfertilised, and won't develop into living organisms.
An egg yolk is more like the discharge a woman experiences on a period - a byproduct of the female reproductive cycle when fertilisation doesn't occur
@Joey100816 Yes, but when I was merely trying to say is that a ball of cells is not akin to a human being, whether it develops into one or not is irrelevant.
A foetus is not alive. It doesn't have brain activity until 50 days into the pregnancy. As much as people feel uneasy about stem cell research and abortion, there is really no reason to be morally against it.
I am pro-life in other ways. I am against war and am a pacifist.
@mmprotest2 because Bill works for FOX news (the right-wing news station). Bill is Conservative, Roman Catholic, Rich, and doesn't kiss Obama's ass, but doesn't spend his hour long program shitting on Obama (unlike Hannity, and Beck). That being said, he's all of that, but these videos are posted on YouTube. His videos are usually disliked by Liberals who hate him.
No, by Liberals I mean people who hate tradition, the ORIGINAL constitution, religion, complain about EVERY fucking thing, despise dicipline and principle, practice hypocracy by telling people to be "open minded" and "tolerant" but they quickly rant, scorn, and jeer people who don't agree with them, self-entitled losers who whine about everything, but never act on anything. That's what I mean. In reference of thinking, just people who think TOO TOO much.
@yoyo2121d25 It's stuff like not understanding the tides or 'how'd the moon get there', that really makes the 'thinking people' hate him, because it's so ignorant. This is the opposite of that. This is saying 'I don't know how the tides work, can someone explain it to me?'
Its a religious fact that life begins at the exact moment a man gets an erection. And we all know the bible is a scientifically accurate book and cannot be wrong. Therefore stem cell research is wrong.
Fetal stem cells are more flexable in what types of cell they can produce so there are more options of organ in fetal stem cells, they can also be alterd so they match any persons blood type. There you go Bill what do you have to say now?
If life begins at conception, then most 20yr olds should be able to buy liquor, because they're actually 9 months older than what's on their birth certificate.
Seriously, if they try to arrest you, just say that you believe that life begins at conception!
Honestly, I like how he doesn't care whether people are atheist. I think that's a respectable thing to have, and honestly, you can't concretely explain any of the phenomena he's given: you can explain them on a scientific basis, sure, but that isn't realistic, given the fallible nature of science.
DNA proves it? How? Because an embryo has complete DNA upon conception?? Almost every single cell in a human carries a complete copsy of that human's DNA. If you take the DNA from a hair off the floor of a barber shop and microinject it into any egg cell it will become a human. Does that mean its immoral to flush a hair down the toilet now that you know it has the potential to become life? Life is mechanical, not magical.
This is Bill? Bill O'Reilly? Huh? Spouting his uninformed opinions is what he does for a living! Why not do it for stem cell research as well? Why take a reasonable stance and accept that you don't know enough? Was he on (or off?) drugs the day he made this?
@Chibithor Did you watch the video. He said he'd have to talk to those people involved with it, and confessed what he beleived. His opinion was "Don't force it on people." He's open to the subject, he has his opinion, but he's open for the conversation.
@yoyo2121d25 Which is exactly what I said in my comment. He's being open, what's that all about? Bill is never open. Never. Except now, for some reason.
@Chibithor True, he's not open about everything. But neither are Liberal political analysts. Like Stewart who doesn't even invite Conservative pundits on his show. Maher will invite them, but only to insult them, a little like what O'Reilly does, but the language is alot fouler. Like everyone on MSNBC who talk over people who are contrary to thier stanpoints.
So you feel comfortable gathering the facts for stem cell research before debating the topic. But when it comes to astrophysics you automatically say no one knows and know will ever know, when that it is simply not the case. And your belief in that God did it is not a valid theory. Especially when people who study science know how these things happened.
People, if you want to be consider an intelligent guy, or just a normal person, your objective in life is to be THE OPPOSITE of what Bill O'Reilly is.
HARVESTING ADULT STEM CELLS IS JUST AS VALID IF NOT MORE BENEFICIAL TO THE DONOR (PROVIDING THEY ARE FROM HIS OWN MARROW) THAN THAT OF FETAL CELLS. HOWEVER, WHEN THERE IS GREAT PROGRESS JUST HANGING IN THE BALANCE - LETS MAKE AN EXECUTIVE DECISION AND RECYCLE WHAT EVERY NON-PRO LIFER THROWS AWAY IN A MEDICAL DUMPSTER. GET. REAL,
O'Reilly: "I need to sit down with the guys involved with that before I make a decisio and spout off the top of my head". This is truly THE ONLY intellegent statement ever uttered by this clown. Shame he doesn't think that more often
I came from the Hawking video and now here and I think it is now fair to assert that even if Bill did sit down with the people he says he wants to he would either not understand them, or he would dismiss anything they said.
I'm just trolling. But seriously Bill O'Reilly is fucking stupid. No logic behind anything he says. All he says is "HOW DID IT GET HERE, EH?" "HOW DOES THAT HAPPEN, EH?"
WELL... I DONT KNOW, OBVIOUSLY A FUCKING INVISIBLE MAN/WOMAN IS DOING THAT SHIT.
Hawking offers an explaination. Religion offers lies. Btw, since you have heard about DNA, did you know that there is a gene that causes people to believe in a god?
@lordcodicus his argument that dna proves life begins at conception isnt a bad case really, as for everything other argument hes ever put forward............ he may as well have said dna proves it
Block comments on videos that get too many negative comments? I guess I'll comment here then. Hawking CAN explain how the moon got there. Oreilly confuses his OWN lack of knowledge on a particular subject (we ALL lack knowledge on particular subjects) with mankind's lack of knowledge on said subject.
this also is a comment to his Dawking video...religious people are not going to be influenced by reason or logic instead you just get a pyschological reaction....retrenchement deeper into threatened beliefs...this problem will not be overcome but surely we are duty bound to save children from molestation and brainwashing by these people...so respond Bill to the evidence and come on side and defend us from the religious crazies?..surely you must condemn 9/11 ?
At least Bill is correct on this one. We don't need fetal stem cells anymore, we have the ability to extract stem cells from living and dead adult humans at this point. That being said, shouldn't we be using fetal stem cells instead of throwing them in the garbage?
Wow... am I really about to defend Bill? Typically, this guy is a total moron, but he pretty much said "I can't make a call on that until I know more about it." I totally understand that. Why he didn't do some research instead of posting a non-answer is beyond me, and yes, O'Reilly deserves more shit than anyone could possibly shit. However, in this single isolated incident, I wasn't ashamed to be the same species as him.
So Bill... Which portion of the genome represents the "soul"? With the advances in neurology it is becoming more and more clear everyday that the "soul" is a byproduct of the nervous system. There is no part of the genome that builds the "soul" consciousness constructs the "soul".
lol how does the human DNA prove "life begin at conception", obviously some twisted interpretation of the definition of "life" but still better than his other comments xD
It's not true Bill, Adult stem cells are already differentiated into their "niche" organs... so sperm stem cells, spermatogonia, then produce only spermatazoa (motile sperm). Fetal stem cells (i.e. In-vitro fertilization embryos that sit in freezers until space is needed and they are dumped in the trashcan) can be used for therapeutic gain across the board, as well as in research of mammalian development which could lead to gains in knowledge on cancer pathways and carcinogenesis.
Ron Paul could be Jesus, Moses and Buddha reincarnated and still its the SYSTEM which is Corrupt. In other words the best of intentions will be watered down, compromised on, distorted and a most likely abandoned by the criminals which control DC. Organize Locally meet your neighbors. Politics is about hype and broken dreams.Keep it Real.
Vote Ron PauL! Corporate media can't censor facts!
I'm surprised he actually said something halfway not moronic. Usually he makes conclusions based on bad logic, but he actually admitted he would not make a decision unless he talked to the experts. g2g is correct adipose stem cells are not totipotent and can only form adipose tissue and there are many other stem cells such as HPCs which can only differentiate into a specific lineage of cells. The only truly undifferentiated cells exist in the fetus as these cells are responsible for all tissues.
uh... no. this is actually part of my GRADE 10 SCIENCE curriculum. fetal stem cells are totipotent, which means they can be specialized to be anything in the human body. adult stem cells can only be for muscle mass or skin.
I don't get this guy. We already have tons of peer-reviewed articles that make this distinction clear. Fetal stem cells are totipotent, they can be induced to make everything in the human body, placental and adult "stem" cells cannot. They can be induced to create a portion of what we need but they are nowhere close in potential as fetal cells. What the hell Bill? Do you just ignore the stuff that explains all this???
Right, that's it. I'm boarding the next flight to the USA and I am coming to kill you Bill O'Reilly. Somebody needs to silence your ignorance and stupidity for good.
I was appalled at the level of ignorance of this man. While not being competent on a subject is no crime, speaking openly and giving an opinion without so much as wiki-level knowledge on the said subject is irresponsible and borderline destructive. I have no respect for such individuals especially public figures.
Bill it's not hard to learn about stem cells. Heck, you have a large investigative staff. Use them. Btw, when you find out the good that comes from stem cell research will you promote it on your show? Probably not, huh?
I just saw the Hawking video he did, I don't think this guy has a valid opinion on anything. He is such an idiot. Did this person even go through school? Everyone should know that the answer to all his things that he asked is simply Gravity.
I am staggerd by this mans idea that his ignorance is equaly valid to others knowlage. If this man botherd to get even a elementary school science education he could see we have perfectly reasonable theories for all those things. The arguments he puts forward may have worked in the 15th centuary which he seems to think is where our current state of science is.
@starofcctv94 Yeah exactly what I thought. We do kinda know why the planet is here and why the "sun goes up and down". O'Reilly is stupid enough to use the old "science can't explain everything (yet)" argument without even knowing what the gaps are.
@starofcctv94 Totally agree. Does anyone really not know how the sun goes up and down? Or how the tides come in and out? These are common knowledge. O'reilly would be better served by asking "how did life begin?" or "how did the universe begin?" These are the real questions.
@starofcctv94 actually, he's right. An atheist is no better than a religious person. Atheists don't know the answer either. The only rational position is to be agnostic and admit we don't know the asnwer. There might be a God afterall. We don't know. Science is a method so we can know more.
@bizso09 science tells us that nothing we have ever observed has ever been connected to the existence of gods, it also tells us that humans like to make up stories.
Wow, so Bill manages to sound somewhat reasonable in this video. Such a pity that in the vids where he is an undeniable asshole, he has disallowed comments. I feel so ripped off. Oh, by the way Bill: Venus and Mars do have a sun, it's the same one as ours. Mars has two moons (unlike the sun, we don't share moons) but Venus has none. Asshole.
why is everyone talking so much shit. hes being completely rational and level headed. i guess its just become common practice to flame whoever disagrees with you.
@Psychiatrium There are, actually. Their use is more limited than that of fetal stem cells, however. Fetal stem cells can virtually become anything. Adult stem cells already have a specific use.
0:26 - Basically, he's saying he doesn't want to use force against people getting abortions. Then later in the video he says we shouldn't use fetal stem cells. If they're going to be aborted anyway, you might as well use them, especially when they could save lives.
There is a huge difference between "fetal" (his term) and "embryonic" stem cells. It was clever how he said he doesn't know enough about it to offer an opinion... and then he goes ahead and gives one anyway!
it's funny that these "pro life" guys are also the guys that are pro death-penalty and that are pro bombing countries.. where's the pro-life in that bill? ps: you have never said anything so far that didn't make me facepalm...
I am surprised there is so many negative comments on all his videos. I am not a fan of the man by any means, but I thought he had support among Republicans. Yet I don't see them here trying to defend him. Has he lost support even from the Republicans? If so, how is he still on the air?
Why are there so many dislikes about this? This is the first reasonable thing I've ever heard come out of this man's mouth. He is suspending judgement on a topic he has not been adequately informed about. What's wrong with that?
If you really think that an embryonic stem cell and a baby are one and the same, you are truly a fucking idiot. If you were sitting in a medical clinic, and a fire suddenly broke out, what would you do? Would you save the young child in the waiting room, or would you save the test tube full of embryos? ( assuming you only have time to save one) According to bill's logic, you would clearly save test tube. Why save one child, when you could save 100+ children?
If adult stem cells were genetically identical to embryonic ones, then wouldn't harvesting them also be considered killing a "human"? Penis goes in, child comes out; never a miscommunication. YOU CAN'T EXPLAIN THAT!
The stem cells we can get from a fetus are DIFFERENT to ones from an adult. That's the reason we need to get them from a fetus you ignoramus. A fetal stem cell can become ANY other cell type, making them extremely useful for research, whereas adult stem cells can only become a select few including blood, skin and intestine cells if i recall correctly. Not that you'll read this.
My friends mom died from MS now he's suicidal and beats his younger brother and his dad drinks too much and he's no longer my friend. Thanks to the lack of stem cell research.
Why does this have so many dislikes on it? I mean, I understand that O'Reilly is controversial, and so is the issue, and you don't have to like it if you don't want to, but what did he say in this particular video that would be so provocative?
@jwdeming Most people go after the majority to do evil and condone embryonic stem cell research or are compassionless, supposedly-pro-life people. Thus, they don't like Bill O'Reilly's trying-for-the-middle-ground approach.
@jwdeming Many people want an all-or-nothing, compassionless approach; as in the case of @billoreilly in which, as I said, they "go after the majority to do evil and condone embryonic stem cell research or are compassionless, supposedly-pro-life people." Karaite scholar Nehemia Gordon cites that Scripture anticipated this-- i.e., that most would do some kind of evil in any given kind of situation: "On the contrary, Scripture teaches us: "Do not go after the majority to do evil" (Exodus 23:2)."
Adult stem cells are more or less useless in comparison to fetal stem cells. The Vatican "allows" adult stem cell research, trying to come off as helpful to society and mankind. Explain to all the catholic parents who ever lost a child why Limbo no longer exists. That would be the start of useful.
@LightBrand I know what conception is, when the sperm fertilizes the egg obviously, my point is, is that not every orgasm needs a name! Even when conception happens, most likely the egg will actually be washed out during those glorious few days of the month, does a woman's naturally acting bodily system make her a killer. Certainly not, it's easy to disprove life beginning at conception, ask any intelligent person without that religious dogma shit in their head.
Fox News built up Mr. Cain, because he was new, because he's black. O'Reilly said Mr. Cain couldn't win, that the GOP has promised Romney the nomination already. Fox ignored Dr. Paul completely. Now, I see Fox TEARING DOWN Mr. Cain! Build him up, just to tear him down? That's dirty of Fox. When O'Reilly comes on tv, I switch the channel to Fox Business News "Freedom Watch." to learn about the news of the day and the CONSTITUTION. KILL MEDIA BIAS!
Seriously?? Why can't he just get this into his god damn thick head that stuff like this ALL HAPPENS FROM SCIENCE. Like the tide goed in tide goes out bullcrap. Ithas to do with the moon's gravitational field, oh how did the moon get there? Good question Oreilly, the moon and all the other planets are made from dust particles in space and chemical reactions, how do we know this from scientific EVIDENCE. You don't even have any EVIDENCE that god or jesus were even real, until you can prove that
@Alfredochau Technically we have more proof of jesus existance than we do of our theories of the universe. Most of the things we know of evolution and the universe stand with theories only and scarse proof. Not that I'm with O'Reilly on any of it tho. The theories still work better than what religion states. (A theory has a scientific/sensible base atleast)
Yes, because scientists that have dedicated their lives to making the world a better place need Bill O'Reilly's permission to study stem cells that would be thrown in medical waste otherwise, unless Bill can understand complex cell biology.
SERIOUSLY?!?!
Does he think scientists just experiment on fetal stem cells because it gets them off or something?
There's a reason to it Bill, and your ignorance of complex biology doesn't give you a chance in hell to stop scientific progress.
@AtheismandSkepticism He never said any of what you're implying. He stated that he would have to sit down with them, to research into it before he made an opinion on something, which is a smart thing to do. Granted, he would probably reach a conclusion which both myself and you would not agree with, but don't put words in people's mouths.
I have donated stem cells and I have been informed about the difference between them and bill is wrong about them being interchangeable, however I would agree to some extent with Bill's position if you take his understanding of stem cells.
I hate when I fall one the side of Bill on subjects.
It is not possible to do the same things with adult stem cells as is done with embryonic but if you could it would be the more ethical way.
Why does Bill think they use embryonic if they are the same?
human DNA proves it??? dumbass who taught you bout human DNA?? SCIENCE!! the same HUMAN DNA PROVES EVOLUTION.. yu pinhead study n do yur research b4 yu start talkin trash about science. even a high school student can answer questions like how did the moon get thr n why tides r formed n BTW.. tides r always in perfect order???r yu srsly that dumb???hav yu ever heard of Tsunami???n tides r NOT in perfect order when the land mass of earth is twards moon tides r higher than usual yu dumbass.
While typically O'Reilly is a complete moron, this one actually isn't that bad. If only he could keep the same, "I would need to talk to the people involved" approach to all his questions about science...
Oh my God... He said something that almost made sense.
prefuffle 3 days ago
This has been flagged as spam show
O'Reilly is ONE of TWO things...
A/ He is either an idiot with a low attention span, who believes the heavily editted footage they show...
or
B/ He is a DISHONESTED, TWISTED, GOB SHITE WITH NO INTEGRITY who is prepared to do ANYTHING or TWIST ANY STORY, ANY WAY to please his right-wing,neo-con paymasters.
Can anyone else see the Fox employee's fist up his ass?
Murdoch, IS THAT YOU?
:)
BlackRoof 5 days ago
I just watched the video on what his thoughts on Hawking were, and.... damn. I think a better question than why we're here, why we're alive, is why this clown has his own show.
samuriguy909 1 week ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Bill O is a boob!!! I think we know how the planet got here, Bill.... we also know Evolution is a FACT.... and anyone who doesn't understand why the tides go up and down need to shut up for a while and start listening instead of running their mouth pretending like they know what they're talking about. What an ignoramus!
ganalisto 1 week ago
Comment removed
ganalisto 1 week ago
Adult/fetus stem cells are exactly the same. Ignorant O'Reilly! You call yourself a "pro life" as if the others were against life. That's a mistake from the get go. We'd better listen to some intelligent people, people from science not these religious morons.
Antimoron2 2 weeks ago
adult stem cells are the same as fetal stem cells
YOU CAN'T EXPLAIN THAT.
ubermensch826 2 weeks ago
Bill should read "Letter to a Christian Nation". It has a whole chapter devoted to this question and the so called right to life movement in general.
jfdoser 3 weeks ago
Sure you can make stem cells from adult cells, you just take adult sperm cell and adult ova cell and there you go, load of stem cells.
Treblaine 4 weeks ago
Gotta hand it to him, who else can stretch "I don't know" out to a minute and four seconds?
On the other hand, had he done a minute and four seconds of research in advance of his non-answer, he might have prevented this video from being a complete waste of time.
methinxaweezil 1 month ago in playlist Uploaded videos
You can't explain how this pinhead got here!
insanewarlock666 1 month ago
24,000+ views for keywords: stem cell research. Keep writing stem cell research in all your videos and maybe you'll get more views than Alex Jones.
combatsambonyc 1 month ago
A ball of cells is not a human being any more than an egg yolk is a chicken.
The foetus is brain dead in the first 50 days of pregnancy, when a patient in hospital is brain dead, the life support machine is turned off.
DNA doesn't prove anything in this video, you merely asserted ''DNA proves it'' without saying why.
I don't think you understand DNA or even basic Biology, Bill.
ec123456789able 1 month ago
@ec123456789able Much as I agree that Bill has no knowledge of science, I'd disagree with this statement.
There is a difference between a blastocyst and an egg yolk. A Blastocyst will develop into a Human. It is an early stage of all human lives. The egg yolks we normally eat are unfertilised, and won't develop into living organisms.
An egg yolk is more like the discharge a woman experiences on a period - a byproduct of the female reproductive cycle when fertilisation doesn't occur
Joey100816 1 month ago
@Joey100816 Yes, but when I was merely trying to say is that a ball of cells is not akin to a human being, whether it develops into one or not is irrelevant.
A foetus is not alive. It doesn't have brain activity until 50 days into the pregnancy. As much as people feel uneasy about stem cell research and abortion, there is really no reason to be morally against it.
I am pro-life in other ways. I am against war and am a pacifist.
ec123456789able 1 month ago
How is this guy still on air when every one of his videos is heavily disliked?
mmprotest2 1 month ago
@mmprotest2 because Bill works for FOX news (the right-wing news station). Bill is Conservative, Roman Catholic, Rich, and doesn't kiss Obama's ass, but doesn't spend his hour long program shitting on Obama (unlike Hannity, and Beck). That being said, he's all of that, but these videos are posted on YouTube. His videos are usually disliked by Liberals who hate him.
yoyo2121d25 1 month ago
@yoyo2121d25 By Liberals you mean the 'thinking people' right?
mmprotest2 1 month ago
Comment removed
yoyo2121d25 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
No, by Liberals I mean people who hate tradition, the ORIGINAL constitution, religion, complain about EVERY fucking thing, despise dicipline and principle, practice hypocracy by telling people to be "open minded" and "tolerant" but they quickly rant, scorn, and jeer people who don't agree with them, self-entitled losers who whine about everything, but never act on anything. That's what I mean. In reference of thinking, just people who think TOO TOO much.
yoyo2121d25 1 month ago
@yoyo2121d25 It's stuff like not understanding the tides or 'how'd the moon get there', that really makes the 'thinking people' hate him, because it's so ignorant. This is the opposite of that. This is saying 'I don't know how the tides work, can someone explain it to me?'
Chibithor 1 month ago
Food goes in. Poop comes out.
You can't explain that.
GeneralSauerKraut 1 month ago
Its a religious fact that life begins at the exact moment a man gets an erection. And we all know the bible is a scientifically accurate book and cannot be wrong. Therefore stem cell research is wrong.
Anarchistt86 1 month ago
Fetal stem cells are more flexable in what types of cell they can produce so there are more options of organ in fetal stem cells, they can also be alterd so they match any persons blood type. There you go Bill what do you have to say now?
Numb3rkid 1 month ago
If life begins at conception, then most 20yr olds should be able to buy liquor, because they're actually 9 months older than what's on their birth certificate.
Seriously, if they try to arrest you, just say that you believe that life begins at conception!
mchandler2112 1 month ago
To his Hawkings video:
Honestly, I like how he doesn't care whether people are atheist. I think that's a respectable thing to have, and honestly, you can't concretely explain any of the phenomena he's given: you can explain them on a scientific basis, sure, but that isn't realistic, given the fallible nature of science.
theothercheese 1 month ago
DNA proves it? How? Because an embryo has complete DNA upon conception?? Almost every single cell in a human carries a complete copsy of that human's DNA. If you take the DNA from a hair off the floor of a barber shop and microinject it into any egg cell it will become a human. Does that mean its immoral to flush a hair down the toilet now that you know it has the potential to become life? Life is mechanical, not magical.
CasterTown 1 month ago
Comment removed
CasterTown 1 month ago
This is Bill? Bill O'Reilly? Huh? Spouting his uninformed opinions is what he does for a living! Why not do it for stem cell research as well? Why take a reasonable stance and accept that you don't know enough? Was he on (or off?) drugs the day he made this?
Chibithor 1 month ago
@Chibithor Did you watch the video. He said he'd have to talk to those people involved with it, and confessed what he beleived. His opinion was "Don't force it on people." He's open to the subject, he has his opinion, but he's open for the conversation.
yoyo2121d25 1 month ago
@yoyo2121d25 Which is exactly what I said in my comment. He's being open, what's that all about? Bill is never open. Never. Except now, for some reason.
Chibithor 1 month ago
@Chibithor True, he's not open about everything. But neither are Liberal political analysts. Like Stewart who doesn't even invite Conservative pundits on his show. Maher will invite them, but only to insult them, a little like what O'Reilly does, but the language is alot fouler. Like everyone on MSNBC who talk over people who are contrary to thier stanpoints.
yoyo2121d25 1 month ago
Whilst he is misinformed, it is nice to see Bill approach a subject with humility and thought.
TweedEchidna 1 month ago
THIS IS A COMMENT TO HIS HAWKING VIDEO:
There is only one thing more dangerous than having no knowledge and that is THINKING that you know something...like Bill O'Reilly - what an idiot.
Serbinnhio 1 month ago
What are those books doing in the background? Bill reads?????? wtf???
stickydog480 1 month ago
Mixing up life with personhood sure is fun... I guess.
EPR89 1 month ago
Why didnt he just say god knows its wrong its not like him to get actual facts before spouting his crap.Why the moon? mars has no moon,moron.
TheTomtuffy 1 month ago
Though I am not a fan of O'Reilly, I feel this video was actually very open-minded.
TheWirelessBrain 1 month ago 34
This motherfucker right here. Ugh.
khoops66 1 month ago
Lol. We know why the tides come in and the tides go out Bill. The gravitational force of the moon.
Also, no Bill, Dawkins makes his money as a scientist, you make your money as a crackpot commentator.
elroddin76 2 months ago
Have you seen this guy's Hawking video? He said that we have no explanation for the sun rising and setting, or the tides coming in.
Jesus, he's so ignorant it's painful to watch...
123skard123 2 months ago
Is this Oreilly actually acting sensible for once?
30mmPwnage 2 months ago
"my opinion, dont force it on anyone esle" I have seen this guy make many so many suppositions based on opinion I refuse to keep count now,
Bollockmetwotimes 2 months ago
Mars has no Sun. You heard it from this guy, folks!
pupplepeak 2 months ago
@pupplepeak Shit, for real?
YouthEnergy 2 months ago
So you feel comfortable gathering the facts for stem cell research before debating the topic. But when it comes to astrophysics you automatically say no one knows and know will ever know, when that it is simply not the case. And your belief in that God did it is not a valid theory. Especially when people who study science know how these things happened.
slicingwater 2 months ago
Comment removed
tonycatman 2 months ago
People, if you want to be consider an intelligent guy, or just a normal person, your objective in life is to be THE OPPOSITE of what Bill O'Reilly is.
esc0barrr 2 months ago
HARVESTING ADULT STEM CELLS IS JUST AS VALID IF NOT MORE BENEFICIAL TO THE DONOR (PROVIDING THEY ARE FROM HIS OWN MARROW) THAN THAT OF FETAL CELLS. HOWEVER, WHEN THERE IS GREAT PROGRESS JUST HANGING IN THE BALANCE - LETS MAKE AN EXECUTIVE DECISION AND RECYCLE WHAT EVERY NON-PRO LIFER THROWS AWAY IN A MEDICAL DUMPSTER. GET. REAL,
whthefckrudoin 2 months ago
O'Reilly: "I need to sit down with the guys involved with that before I make a decisio and spout off the top of my head". This is truly THE ONLY intellegent statement ever uttered by this clown. Shame he doesn't think that more often
thatblokefella 2 months ago
I came from the Hawking video and now here and I think it is now fair to assert that even if Bill did sit down with the people he says he wants to he would either not understand them, or he would dismiss anything they said.
ec123456789able 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Ok wait. Life begins at the conception?
/watch?v=AvF1Q3UidWM
I'm just trolling. But seriously Bill O'Reilly is fucking stupid. No logic behind anything he says. All he says is "HOW DID IT GET HERE, EH?" "HOW DOES THAT HAPPEN, EH?"
WELL... I DONT KNOW, OBVIOUSLY A FUCKING INVISIBLE MAN/WOMAN IS DOING THAT SHIT.
HOW ELSE?
how come we can comment on this video? ;D.
littlebidee 2 months ago
Hawking offers an explaination. Religion offers lies. Btw, since you have heard about DNA, did you know that there is a gene that causes people to believe in a god?
Orbitusx 2 months ago
Bill O'Reilly is hilariously idiotic lol. I'm referring to the Hawking video too by the way.
lockpride 2 months ago
Harvesting Fetal. Wow Bill O is a MORON.
sk80soarus 2 months ago
@sk80soarus You are a derp. There are so many legitimate things to criticise O'Rilley about, but you found something that wasn't an error.
Otto2712 2 months ago
Life begins at conception, DNA proves it.
Tide goes in, tide goes out, DNA proves it.
The moon got there, DNA proves it.
lordcodicus 2 months ago 56
@lordcodicus his argument that dna proves life begins at conception isnt a bad case really, as for everything other argument hes ever put forward............ he may as well have said dna proves it
1888rooney 1 month ago
fucking moron
rhillner 2 months ago 2
The problem with this guy is that he DOES force his opinion upon other people.
Long story short, he must die.
DaveDamnit 2 months ago
@DaveDamnit testify.
whthefckrudoin 2 months ago
@whthefckrudoin Bitchplease.. Random O'Reilly vids. Look it up
DaveDamnit 2 months ago
Block comments on videos that get too many negative comments? I guess I'll comment here then. Hawking CAN explain how the moon got there. Oreilly confuses his OWN lack of knowledge on a particular subject (we ALL lack knowledge on particular subjects) with mankind's lack of knowledge on said subject.
ryanwyshynski 2 months ago
this also is a comment to his Dawking video...religious people are not going to be influenced by reason or logic instead you just get a pyschological reaction....retrenchement deeper into threatened beliefs...this problem will not be overcome but surely we are duty bound to save children from molestation and brainwashing by these people...so respond Bill to the evidence and come on side and defend us from the religious crazies?..surely you must condemn 9/11 ?
couthyband 2 months ago
At least Bill is correct on this one. We don't need fetal stem cells anymore, we have the ability to extract stem cells from living and dead adult humans at this point. That being said, shouldn't we be using fetal stem cells instead of throwing them in the garbage?
MadChef82 2 months ago
Bill is a piece of shit.
ericriouxriouxrioux 2 months ago 3
Comment removed
demkomusic 2 months ago
Wow... am I really about to defend Bill? Typically, this guy is a total moron, but he pretty much said "I can't make a call on that until I know more about it." I totally understand that. Why he didn't do some research instead of posting a non-answer is beyond me, and yes, O'Reilly deserves more shit than anyone could possibly shit. However, in this single isolated incident, I wasn't ashamed to be the same species as him.
Linazazel 2 months ago 4
So Bill... Which portion of the genome represents the "soul"? With the advances in neurology it is becoming more and more clear everyday that the "soul" is a byproduct of the nervous system. There is no part of the genome that builds the "soul" consciousness constructs the "soul".
agronoxdt 2 months ago
lol how does the human DNA prove "life begin at conception", obviously some twisted interpretation of the definition of "life" but still better than his other comments xD
bardiche1989 2 months ago
It's not true Bill, Adult stem cells are already differentiated into their "niche" organs... so sperm stem cells, spermatogonia, then produce only spermatazoa (motile sperm). Fetal stem cells (i.e. In-vitro fertilization embryos that sit in freezers until space is needed and they are dumped in the trashcan) can be used for therapeutic gain across the board, as well as in research of mammalian development which could lead to gains in knowledge on cancer pathways and carcinogenesis.
Keimerkid 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Ron Paul could be Jesus, Moses and Buddha reincarnated and still its the SYSTEM which is Corrupt. In other words the best of intentions will be watered down, compromised on, distorted and a most likely abandoned by the criminals which control DC. Organize Locally meet your neighbors. Politics is about hype and broken dreams.Keep it Real.
Vote Ron PauL! Corporate media can't censor facts!
julioabruno2254 3 months ago
I'm surprised he actually said something halfway not moronic. Usually he makes conclusions based on bad logic, but he actually admitted he would not make a decision unless he talked to the experts. g2g is correct adipose stem cells are not totipotent and can only form adipose tissue and there are many other stem cells such as HPCs which can only differentiate into a specific lineage of cells. The only truly undifferentiated cells exist in the fetus as these cells are responsible for all tissues.
ImtheTroubleIn421 3 months ago
uh... no. this is actually part of my GRADE 10 SCIENCE curriculum. fetal stem cells are totipotent, which means they can be specialized to be anything in the human body. adult stem cells can only be for muscle mass or skin.
g2g144 3 months ago in playlist More videos from billoreilly
...Sperm are technically life, and they have human DNA... how come you aren't murdering millions of babies every time you jack off?...
iPhTx3 3 months ago
I don't get this guy. We already have tons of peer-reviewed articles that make this distinction clear. Fetal stem cells are totipotent, they can be induced to make everything in the human body, placental and adult "stem" cells cannot. They can be induced to create a portion of what we need but they are nowhere close in potential as fetal cells. What the hell Bill? Do you just ignore the stuff that explains all this???
capchaos888 3 months ago
Right, that's it. I'm boarding the next flight to the USA and I am coming to kill you Bill O'Reilly. Somebody needs to silence your ignorance and stupidity for good.
BarryDong 3 months ago
SOMEBODY SHOOY THIS THICK AMERICAN
PhoenixTheKnight 3 months ago
DNA proves it. Oh wait that's science lol, I meant to say CAN'T EXPLAIN TIDES HAWKING
NondairyDanzig 3 months ago
I was appalled at the level of ignorance of this man. While not being competent on a subject is no crime, speaking openly and giving an opinion without so much as wiki-level knowledge on the said subject is irresponsible and borderline destructive. I have no respect for such individuals especially public figures.
Razomir 3 months ago
Bill it's not hard to learn about stem cells. Heck, you have a large investigative staff. Use them. Btw, when you find out the good that comes from stem cell research will you promote it on your show? Probably not, huh?
thybigballs 3 months ago
I just saw the Hawking video he did, I don't think this guy has a valid opinion on anything. He is such an idiot. Did this person even go through school? Everyone should know that the answer to all his things that he asked is simply Gravity.
IamBread18 3 months ago
THIS IS A COMMENT TO HIS HAWKING VIDEO
I am staggerd by this mans idea that his ignorance is equaly valid to others knowlage. If this man botherd to get even a elementary school science education he could see we have perfectly reasonable theories for all those things. The arguments he puts forward may have worked in the 15th centuary which he seems to think is where our current state of science is.
starofcctv94 3 months ago 106
@starofcctv94 Yeah exactly what I thought. We do kinda know why the planet is here and why the "sun goes up and down". O'Reilly is stupid enough to use the old "science can't explain everything (yet)" argument without even knowing what the gaps are.
Chris197980CH 1 month ago
@starofcctv94 Totally agree. Does anyone really not know how the sun goes up and down? Or how the tides come in and out? These are common knowledge. O'reilly would be better served by asking "how did life begin?" or "how did the universe begin?" These are the real questions.
upizdown 1 month ago
@starofcctv94 actually, he's right. An atheist is no better than a religious person. Atheists don't know the answer either. The only rational position is to be agnostic and admit we don't know the asnwer. There might be a God afterall. We don't know. Science is a method so we can know more.
bizso09 1 month ago
@bizso09 Atheism isnt the assertion that there is no god, it is the rejection that there is any valid evidence for one- hardly irrational
1888rooney 1 month ago
@bizso09 science tells us that nothing we have ever observed has ever been connected to the existence of gods, it also tells us that humans like to make up stories.
mauriciohavok 1 month ago
@starofcctv94 WHO CARES?
yoyo2121d25 1 month ago
You clearly know nothing about stem cells. Do some research before you blab on about adult and fetal stem cells.
If you believe that a life only starts on conception, why is it that cloning can occur, and produce a living individual.
Get your shit right before you post shit on youtube.
XxImm0rtallityxX 3 months ago
Wow, so Bill manages to sound somewhat reasonable in this video. Such a pity that in the vids where he is an undeniable asshole, he has disallowed comments. I feel so ripped off. Oh, by the way Bill: Venus and Mars do have a sun, it's the same one as ours. Mars has two moons (unlike the sun, we don't share moons) but Venus has none. Asshole.
stevelynagh 3 months ago
idiot.
halflifeproductionz 3 months ago
why is everyone talking so much shit. hes being completely rational and level headed. i guess its just become common practice to flame whoever disagrees with you.
bFuddlez 4 months ago
my stem cells were opining nola town any pine etcetra sir, but...
/watch?v=zBmIoUO7_Gc
anytime afterimage like preddator in your head
SuperMegaUberGenius 4 months ago
The reason why they have to use fetal stem cells is because there are no stem cells in fully grown humans.
Psychiatrium 4 months ago
@Psychiatrium There are, actually. Their use is more limited than that of fetal stem cells, however. Fetal stem cells can virtually become anything. Adult stem cells already have a specific use.
SeedsOfHatred 3 months ago
0:26 - Basically, he's saying he doesn't want to use force against people getting abortions. Then later in the video he says we shouldn't use fetal stem cells. If they're going to be aborted anyway, you might as well use them, especially when they could save lives.
PastafariansWON 4 months ago
Bill is a cock sucker ..Hope you die bitch
julioabruno2254 4 months ago
as if stem cell researchers are going to 'sit down' and talk to this fuckwit
mp9828 4 months ago
DNA does prove it, anyone who says different is ignorant.
However, a fetus is irrelevant. It's life means nothing.
ChillOnlyKetchup 4 months ago
How did it get there, you can't prove it.
ChronoTriggerMusic 4 months ago
Holy hell the lord must have shined down on the world, he wasnt overly opinionated and irrational!
massacreman3000 4 months ago
The DNA proves it
ImJustSlime 4 months ago
He says stuff like "i think the DNA proves it" and then denounces science in other contexts just to help support his arguments.
FUCK BILL O'REILLY!
SUCK. MY. DICK.
stottspage 4 months ago 2
There is a huge difference between "fetal" (his term) and "embryonic" stem cells. It was clever how he said he doesn't know enough about it to offer an opinion... and then he goes ahead and gives one anyway!
Oracle195608 4 months ago
wow! this vid has comments enabled! you can't explain that.
menriquex 5 months ago 111
Stem cells could help us fashion Bill a new brain.
KidInsight 5 months ago
@KidInsight :lol:
freiheitsalv 5 months ago
It is now official, the world is going to end.
Bill O'Reilly stating something as his opinion and not as a fact is the proof
AscotMusic 5 months ago
it's funny that these "pro life" guys are also the guys that are pro death-penalty and that are pro bombing countries.. where's the pro-life in that bill? ps: you have never said anything so far that didn't make me facepalm...
amendolara69 5 months ago
i love how almost all the videos he has that are so to explain how they are wrong have the comments disabled on the
AoNoFreak1 5 months ago
i fuking HATE THIS MAN!
hobbohippy2 5 months ago
No shit life begins at conception, Bill.
ComeAllYouWeary 5 months ago
I am surprised there is so many negative comments on all his videos. I am not a fan of the man by any means, but I thought he had support among Republicans. Yet I don't see them here trying to defend him. Has he lost support even from the Republicans? If so, how is he still on the air?
onslaught147 5 months ago
Stem Cell Research? FUCKING THING SUCKS!!!
rockman35004 5 months ago
food comes in, shit comes out, can you explain that????
scubandre1 6 months ago
There is no justification for going against fetal stem-cell research that isn't based on religious dogma.
Wallyrus 6 months ago
dick goes in, baby comes out, CAN'T EXPLAIN THAT.
TheSuperfly2009 6 months ago
This actually made sense...WOW
nickwkcin 6 months ago
babies are delivered by the stork...
dynastynyy 6 months ago
wow. Was Bill being open minded?
krjo4215 6 months ago
Why are there so many dislikes about this? This is the first reasonable thing I've ever heard come out of this man's mouth. He is suspending judgement on a topic he has not been adequately informed about. What's wrong with that?
sswpp8908 6 months ago
Yes we can use skin cells, treat them with transcription factors, and end up with stem cells
iliveon 6 months ago
Some of the comments or replies are desperate, stupid, pathetic, and pusillanimous
vkorchnoifan 6 months ago
If you really think that an embryonic stem cell and a baby are one and the same, you are truly a fucking idiot. If you were sitting in a medical clinic, and a fire suddenly broke out, what would you do? Would you save the young child in the waiting room, or would you save the test tube full of embryos? ( assuming you only have time to save one) According to bill's logic, you would clearly save test tube. Why save one child, when you could save 100+ children?
A stem cell is not a child.
joslinnick 6 months ago 2
If adult stem cells were genetically identical to embryonic ones, then wouldn't harvesting them also be considered killing a "human"? Penis goes in, child comes out; never a miscommunication. YOU CAN'T EXPLAIN THAT!
oOpumpkinheadOo 6 months ago
The stem cells we can get from a fetus are DIFFERENT to ones from an adult. That's the reason we need to get them from a fetus you ignoramus. A fetal stem cell can become ANY other cell type, making them extremely useful for research, whereas adult stem cells can only become a select few including blood, skin and intestine cells if i recall correctly. Not that you'll read this.
flurble33 6 months ago
i think this is the most intelligent/adult thing i have ever heard him say
HolyReaperX01 7 months ago
This video has comments enabled, while most of his religious ones don't. You can't explain that!
Notwithoutmypants 7 months ago
My friends mom died from MS now he's suicidal and beats his younger brother and his dad drinks too much and he's no longer my friend. Thanks to the lack of stem cell research.
ChetzNation 7 months ago
you have to admit he wasnt that much of a narrow minded pecker head in this vid as much as his others :P......you cant exsplain that!!
casketXcreep 7 months ago 2
@WadeC0 lmao!
myvidutube 7 months ago
Gotta have the right to do research in the first place to get results Bill O-retard -_-
Xceles618 7 months ago
O'Reilly is an idiot, but this answer is actually really good. I hope he can keep an open mind like this for other stuff as well
zidarsk8 7 months ago
Why does this have so many dislikes on it? I mean, I understand that O'Reilly is controversial, and so is the issue, and you don't have to like it if you don't want to, but what did he say in this particular video that would be so provocative?
jwdeming 7 months ago
@jwdeming Most people go after the majority to do evil and condone embryonic stem cell research or are compassionless, supposedly-pro-life people. Thus, they don't like Bill O'Reilly's trying-for-the-middle-ground approach.
Nickidewbear 7 months ago
@Nickidewbear I guess, but I just don't understand what inspires that type of mentality. It just bewilders me.
jwdeming 7 months ago
@jwdeming Many people want an all-or-nothing, compassionless approach; as in the case of @billoreilly in which, as I said, they "go after the majority to do evil and condone embryonic stem cell research or are compassionless, supposedly-pro-life people." Karaite scholar Nehemia Gordon cites that Scripture anticipated this-- i.e., that most would do some kind of evil in any given kind of situation: "On the contrary, Scripture teaches us: "Do not go after the majority to do evil" (Exodus 23:2)."
Nickidewbear 7 months ago
You can harvest Stem Cells from umbilical cords. We just throw those away anyways.
josefopeda 7 months ago
Adult stem cells are more or less useless in comparison to fetal stem cells. The Vatican "allows" adult stem cell research, trying to come off as helpful to society and mankind. Explain to all the catholic parents who ever lost a child why Limbo no longer exists. That would be the start of useful.
Cambrand 7 months ago
If life begins at conception then does that mean all the sperm cells wasted in my teenage years make me a baby killer?
Messmaster08 7 months ago 2
@Messmaster08 That's not what conception means.
LightBrand 7 months ago
@LightBrand I know what conception is, when the sperm fertilizes the egg obviously, my point is, is that not every orgasm needs a name! Even when conception happens, most likely the egg will actually be washed out during those glorious few days of the month, does a woman's naturally acting bodily system make her a killer. Certainly not, it's easy to disprove life beginning at conception, ask any intelligent person without that religious dogma shit in their head.
Messmaster08 7 months ago
It's stupid fucks like you that impede progress for people that are actually ALIVE and suffering bill.
You never have anything of value to say it seems.
Shit goes in, shit comes out, always a miscommunication.
drpeppa2357 8 months ago 135
@drpeppa2357 Shit goes in, shit comes out?
You can't explain that....
Daipire 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@drpeppa2357
Fox News built up Mr. Cain, because he was new, because he's black. O'Reilly said Mr. Cain couldn't win, that the GOP has promised Romney the nomination already. Fox ignored Dr. Paul completely. Now, I see Fox TEARING DOWN Mr. Cain! Build him up, just to tear him down? That's dirty of Fox. When O'Reilly comes on tv, I switch the channel to Fox Business News "Freedom Watch." to learn about the news of the day and the CONSTITUTION. KILL MEDIA BIAS!
vechorik 4 months ago
@drpeppa2357 Shit goes in, shit comes out. Can't explain that.
MarkusMcMidget 3 months ago
@drpeppa2357 I can't shit properly. You can't explain that!
astikel 3 months ago
Seriously?? Why can't he just get this into his god damn thick head that stuff like this ALL HAPPENS FROM SCIENCE. Like the tide goed in tide goes out bullcrap. Ithas to do with the moon's gravitational field, oh how did the moon get there? Good question Oreilly, the moon and all the other planets are made from dust particles in space and chemical reactions, how do we know this from scientific EVIDENCE. You don't even have any EVIDENCE that god or jesus were even real, until you can prove that
Alfredochau 8 months ago
@Alfredochau Technically we have more proof of jesus existance than we do of our theories of the universe. Most of the things we know of evolution and the universe stand with theories only and scarse proof. Not that I'm with O'Reilly on any of it tho. The theories still work better than what religion states. (A theory has a scientific/sensible base atleast)
SkuLLetjaH 7 months ago
@SkuLLetjaH This is pretty good - even though I know you're trolling I still get mad reading it.
xtysonboswellx 7 months ago
Anyone think he's just king of the trolls?
Banteroth 8 months ago
@Banteroth No, but a very good puppet for the conservative right.
alphaenemy 7 months ago
I bet he gets really drunk before he makes these videos.
MitchGettman 8 months ago
Yes, because scientists that have dedicated their lives to making the world a better place need Bill O'Reilly's permission to study stem cells that would be thrown in medical waste otherwise, unless Bill can understand complex cell biology.
SERIOUSLY?!?!
Does he think scientists just experiment on fetal stem cells because it gets them off or something?
There's a reason to it Bill, and your ignorance of complex biology doesn't give you a chance in hell to stop scientific progress.
AtheismandSkepticism 8 months ago
@AtheismandSkepticism He never said any of what you're implying. He stated that he would have to sit down with them, to research into it before he made an opinion on something, which is a smart thing to do. Granted, he would probably reach a conclusion which both myself and you would not agree with, but don't put words in people's mouths.
Scoat 8 months ago
How'd Bill get on the internet? How'd he get there? Who put him there?
eternalgracenote 8 months ago
I used to eat my nails. OH GOD! I am a cannibal!
TheFinlandnator 9 months ago
I have donated stem cells and I have been informed about the difference between them and bill is wrong about them being interchangeable, however I would agree to some extent with Bill's position if you take his understanding of stem cells.
I hate when I fall one the side of Bill on subjects.
It is not possible to do the same things with adult stem cells as is done with embryonic but if you could it would be the more ethical way.
Why does Bill think they use embryonic if they are the same?
rarrmonkey 9 months ago
Wow, a RATIONAL O'Reilly opinion that admits to not knowing the facts and only making a generalized statement? You can't explain that
sithlord7m 9 months ago 85
human DNA proves it??? dumbass who taught you bout human DNA?? SCIENCE!! the same HUMAN DNA PROVES EVOLUTION.. yu pinhead study n do yur research b4 yu start talkin trash about science. even a high school student can answer questions like how did the moon get thr n why tides r formed n BTW.. tides r always in perfect order???r yu srsly that dumb???hav yu ever heard of Tsunami???n tides r NOT in perfect order when the land mass of earth is twards moon tides r higher than usual yu dumbass.
chinamanspeakenlis 9 months ago
While typically O'Reilly is a complete moron, this one actually isn't that bad. If only he could keep the same, "I would need to talk to the people involved" approach to all his questions about science...
bdelgado14 9 months ago
yesterday was thursday, today is friday, tommorow is saturday and after that comes sunday.
you cant explain that.
xilixang999 9 months ago
"The human DNA proves it..."
and then...
"EVOLUTION IS A LIE!"
KLowD9x 9 months ago
HAHA O'Rielly saying that he needs to see the facts before me makes a decision. Has that stopped him before?
ibanezdude2000 9 months ago
everyone at fox news is an idiot
HPhenomenal 9 months ago
@WadeC0 LMFAO 8==>
juanarruti 9 months ago
@WadeC0 You made me lol. Thanks man.
Shmossy 9 months ago
pictures in the back changed in 2011 lol I dont know why I pointed that out
eminence18 10 months ago