It's basically the And All That Could Have Been version but without the audience. Well, the REAL video version is anyway. This is pretty close but I much more prefer the actual AATCHB rehearsal version (from the actual video). This def. comes in at a close 2nd, though.
@jdubmacelly Why woudl you get mad, I believe the song is about his grandmother and when she passed away. If you listen to the Quiet/Still version, you soon realize that the song is quite sad. I get a little tearful when I hear this.
@drgn1290 Who cares what the song is about. At least the song is good enough to get various emotions out of different people. To each their own. I saw that person's comment as flattering for NIN. I would hate to see someone tell me why I didn't feel what they did listening to a song as were not all the same. :)
This Whole CD Is Fire, Like my truck caught on fire and the detecives said it was from the cd players and i was like what about my NIN cd and they were all like this is arson and im like chill out bro. Ok, I lied about all that but This cd is Awesome.
Actually Trent hates the old record companies he worked for and has openly told people to steal all his old music. He says not to steal other people's music though...
yeah i tried to download this song from the site on the description and its not letting me download it, does anyone know where i can get this version of the song? i would realllllllyyyy like it if someone could tell me where i can get it!!!
Please tell me that you mean.... as of now , and not forever?!
They are my fav. band. one of the only bands that I've actually bought all their cd's some of em 3 and 4 times each :S. I'm gonna go kill someone if I missed my last chance at seeing NIN live.
:S god damnit! I'd gotten charged w/ aggravated assault and assault w/ a weapon charges . No leaving Canada for me.
This totally RUINED my day. I should have seen em the last time they went to Vancouver, but i don't keep up w/ concerts at all. I thought I'd have years to see NIN live. I really hope trent is one of em guys who can't quit rockin his ass off and has like 3 more farewell tours.
i know how u feel. i spent 400 bucks on tickets and didnt go cuz everyone bailed out without telln me at the last moment, and now im pissed cuz like the rumor of nin waving goodbye
Hmm, between the album version, quiet version and this one it's tough, I like all three. I bought this album when it came out and went to a cemetary to take pictures for a photography class. Listened to both discs on the CD Man while looking at 200-300 year old headstones, awesome memories for me.
This is amazing, at 2:30 is the start of what sets this version apart from any of the rest. it reminds me of the live version on aatcb but with even more feeling in the guitars. at 4:11 i love that riff to death
It's an easteregg on the "And All That Could Have Been" DVD. The easiest way to get to most of the hidden content, or Easter Eggs, on the DVD is via the "Beneath The Surface" menu hidden on disc two. During "Head Like A Hole" at the 11:20 mark, press 7 on your remote (some users report that 7 doesn't work but 6 does) then Enter. The menu will come up and you will have access to the hidden content.
You know that Trent TRASHED The Fragile? Pretty much completely disowned it. :( It is, without question, one of my favorite albums of all time of any band.
Yeah, I wonder why trent trashed it. Because he believes it or just agreeing with critics. Maybe he thinks it's pure indulgence. The way a lot of people claim Axl rose did with the Illusions cd's
I read one of the remarks that someone likes the studio version from the Fragile better. I think I might have to disagree with you. And All That Could Have Been was an awsome album(with the exception of Hurt(I hate that song)) I think I'm gonna have to pick the Live version off of AATCHB.
Though the live versions aren't bad I prefer the original, especially the louder part after the verse. Such an incredible wall of sound, maybe best piece of music I've ever heard.
original version is on The Fragile i think, thats the version you here in the terminator trailer minus drums i think... the other versions I got (Me i dont know about anyone else) on a album titled the day the whole world went away, it was just the remixes and stuff.
I remember reading an interview Trent gave...he said he wrote this song about watching his grandmother die slowly when he was a boy. Like most of NIN's songs it's very personal stuff.
I agree. This is an amazing song and was my personal favorite when i saw them play it on the fragile tour. Seeing it on the Terminator preview almost stopped my heart. In a good way. It was perfect. Be a real fan and enjoy it with others and help open there mind to better music.
Oh god guys get over yourselves, who honestly cares if people found this song because of a trailer. It's better people know of it rather than not! I hate whiney music snobs. Just enjoy the music and stfu about hearing it 'first'.
this is not the original song that fit the video. the ive "and all that could hav been" version is the original version of the song to fit the vid. but they took that of u tube
i have to agree but then it will become too known and over used which makes me want to kill every one who listens to it because of Terminator Salvation. =( damn them for using it in the trailer........*sigh*.......
what the fuck y its because of terminator i know the song fagot i dont like the band but the song is coool ill kill you mother fucker....... hahahahahah
Damn, some time ago there was a version of this song with same video but SLIGHTLY different soundtrack, andi liked it a way way more, i think it was some kind of limited version and they removed it from YT... if somone has it PLEASE leave me a massage, thx!
the one he's referring to is not the piano version. Its the original version but it's been altered by Trent Reznor. He made it sound "live". It was the original music video version but I think youtube doesnt allow it for copyright problems or soemthing. something about the album copyright i think
amazing song!! the guitar solo after the verse and the chorus is using some of the riffs/solos off of all that could've been (probably the most depressing NIN song)
If you want the "Terminator Salvation" version come and get it. I accidentally deleted someone's message. I just remember that wanted the mother fuckin version. If you want it resend that message.
~~~~~copy and paste if terminator salvation trailer led you to this~~~~ I love NIN, but i heard this song and my flame for NIN reignited, buy THE FRAGILE is a true masterpiece!
aaargh the guitar"solo" in the background arround 4:00
wicked :D
btw this isn't the version taken from halo seventeen, although it's the same video, right?
dermonkey 2 months ago
fuckin' great version...
wuselfoo 2 months ago
great version
izzuken 4 months ago
The Happiness in Slavery video compared to this.....???? How do you judge Trent Reznor? I sit at my computer desk and worship this man.
OverworkedMexican 5 months ago 3
This video = one thing: HEROIN
StickyInADarkBlueCut 6 months ago
Comment removed
LooPaperRocks 8 months ago
He is gonna do more NIN after he has his baby and finishes the HTDA full length.
tylerbrennan 9 months ago
Hey I wrote almost the same thing in the year 1998.
ffejgib 9 months ago
It's basically the And All That Could Have Been version but without the audience. Well, the REAL video version is anyway. This is pretty close but I much more prefer the actual AATCHB rehearsal version (from the actual video). This def. comes in at a close 2nd, though.
Thanatos420 9 months ago
stop it @ 00:14 it looks like yoda lol
houstoncrawford 11 months ago 8
This is the version he plays live but the released version is very different. I MUCH prefer this version.
rudolpma 11 months ago
A masterpeice.
jonf21c 1 year ago
awesome i absoltely in love from that so beautiful tune
thefrag1l3 1 year ago
this makes me want to get MAD ! AND FIGHT SOMEONE IN THE RAIN!!!
jdubmacelly 1 year ago
@jdubmacelly Why woudl you get mad, I believe the song is about his grandmother and when she passed away. If you listen to the Quiet/Still version, you soon realize that the song is quite sad. I get a little tearful when I hear this.
drgn1290 1 year ago
@drgn1290 Who cares what the song is about. At least the song is good enough to get various emotions out of different people. To each their own. I saw that person's comment as flattering for NIN. I would hate to see someone tell me why I didn't feel what they did listening to a song as were not all the same. :)
Nesnej1501 1 year ago
si belle...
lulumousie 1 year ago
Getofgmynuts: lol...
umbsix 1 year ago
at 2:30.... i get chills Everytime
AlboKid23 1 year ago
This Whole CD Is Fire, Like my truck caught on fire and the detecives said it was from the cd players and i was like what about my NIN cd and they were all like this is arson and im like chill out bro. Ok, I lied about all that but This cd is Awesome.
GetOffMyNuts88 1 year ago 2
How does this not have more than 100k views? Oh well, serves right less people appreciate something genuinely good these days - CHEETOS!!!!!
jjoliver22 1 year ago
@jjoliver22 it does now! =D
992171B 1 year ago
Dude this version is seriously kick ass. Thanks for posting it. Listen to Trent all these years and wasnt familiar with this version.
Merceade 1 year ago
the song ended and they're still singing.
karlztt 1 year ago
my favorite version
snuffydoug 1 year ago
Best version of arguably their best song. Great video.
oleggud 1 year ago
I really don't like NIN but this is just the best song!
XXXPharcydeXXX 1 year ago
i lovet this song <3
urieltapia17 1 year ago
Awesome!!!
dogaet 1 year ago
beautiful song.
Unleashed2k 1 year ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
the version they used in terminator is better
vampireallie 1 year ago
This song rox... same 4 it's music video
PeterHegenauer 1 year ago
really, does that "if you want the song as an mp3" box need to be up during the ENTIRE VIDEO?
wm45954 1 year ago
You could L2 youtube and turn off the annotations... you know... instead of bitching!
TheRonin5 1 year ago
Does anybody know what video the black and white footage is from?
peteagassi 1 year ago
it's from the first official vid to the song...never released...
shavarshodadjian 1 year ago
too awesome. hurts my brain. . . . .
onebadfriday 2 years ago 4
the guitars in the non vocal section are apocalyptic and beautiful. thank you for bringing this version to light, and download.
whobetterthan 2 years ago 4
Purple Haze mix for stoners. I could dig that. >__>
Tonsolery 2 years ago 2
i heard theres a red and blue mix i mean wtf is up with that at least this is the original next thing you know its purple haze mix for stoners
historyghosthunters 2 years ago
when i dl this am i getting a video, or an mp3?
mellowmonster17 2 years ago
mp3, of course.
CeejayGSPB 2 years ago
buy the cd/lp/mp3 , but don't download it!
Terrorkruemel15 2 years ago
Well, you have to download it, because it's not available anywhere except free download.
And btw. I reuploaded the file. Link's in the description!
CeejayGSPB 2 years ago 3
Seh grad das du Österreicher bist.
ich dachte das wär ein link zur studioversion.
Terrorkruemel15 2 years ago
@Terrorkruemel15
Actually Trent hates the old record companies he worked for and has openly told people to steal all his old music. He says not to steal other people's music though...
Plur307 1 year ago 2
yeah i tried to download this song from the site on the description and its not letting me download it, does anyone know where i can get this version of the song? i would realllllllyyyy like it if someone could tell me where i can get it!!!
chewypoopoo1 2 years ago
its sad that they aren't touring anymore
ap0c8 2 years ago 36
Please tell me that you mean.... as of now , and not forever?!
They are my fav. band. one of the only bands that I've actually bought all their cd's some of em 3 and 4 times each :S. I'm gonna go kill someone if I missed my last chance at seeing NIN live.
MistaQuake4 2 years ago
The fare well tour is gong on i cali if your going to see the last concert is coming up
ap0c8 2 years ago
:S god damnit! I'd gotten charged w/ aggravated assault and assault w/ a weapon charges . No leaving Canada for me.
This totally RUINED my day. I should have seen em the last time they went to Vancouver, but i don't keep up w/ concerts at all. I thought I'd have years to see NIN live. I really hope trent is one of em guys who can't quit rockin his ass off and has like 3 more farewell tours.
MistaQuake4 2 years ago
Smart choice man, keep the assaults to a maximum, maybe shoot them up next time, and dont forget to tell us all abou it...
:/
Pierceher 2 years ago
the last show was on september in cali, I was on the 9-2-09 show at the hollywood palladium, that is it, no more touring for trent.
makapac2k3 2 years ago
@MistaQuake4
i know how u feel. i spent 400 bucks on tickets and didnt go cuz everyone bailed out without telln me at the last moment, and now im pissed cuz like the rumor of nin waving goodbye
clyse88 2 years ago
Comment removed
Guerillaradio13 2 years ago
is this the actual video for this song? i love NIN but i dont know everthing about them so dont hate. trent is epic.
hastethedangerous 2 years ago
This is the actual video however the original audio (which was from the Fragility Tour) is dubbed over with With Teeth Tour rehearsal audio
eiresmif35 2 years ago
@eiresmif35 -- 2005 rehearsals, then? :)
minuteforce 1 year ago
The bass line it's fuckin' easy but i love it! great song
tourforthemasses 2 years ago 3
Easy, yet original
Guerillaradio13 2 years ago
the guitar just follows the bass line. Thus it's not that hard either.
ComaAlpha 2 years ago
seen him twice live fuckin epic shit
Guerillaradio13 2 years ago 25
Hmm, between the album version, quiet version and this one it's tough, I like all three. I bought this album when it came out and went to a cemetary to take pictures for a photography class. Listened to both discs on the CD Man while looking at 200-300 year old headstones, awesome memories for me.
lastvestiges 2 years ago 7
My favourite NIN song, and one of the songs that always change my feelings to the better!! its full of energy!!
YaTEdiGo 2 years ago
mmmm i love music videos with slow moving snakes....
kylehindu 2 years ago
Hell yeah dude this is the best version in my opinion
kylehindu 2 years ago 2
I love this version better than the album. A lot more soothing, yeah soothing.
ominuka 2 years ago 2
yer man its ace version love this song!
Guerillaradio13 2 years ago
My favorite NIN song of all time<3
misfitdoll23 2 years ago 5
na terrible lie , the line begins to blur, and the big come down are way better
BIGJBIGEBIGC 2 years ago
The Fragile Album is one of my fav. albums its so fucking magical,like a heroine trip on X.
aworld360 2 years ago 3
ur a fiend
snuffydoug 2 years ago
Trent facepalm at 2:20 :P
DarthCannabis 2 years ago 2
...SImply Epic...
fz6284a 2 years ago 2
can u please get rid of all the writing on the video?
xninxx 2 years ago 9
if you press the little upwards arrow thing on the bottom right of the video then click the page corner icon it takes the notes off btw.
Raider1648 2 years ago 6
In theater i was like "OMG it's NIN !!!!" when I saw the T4 trailer
rocksinoo 2 years ago 3
cette version est tout simplement parfaite <3
Aykhen 2 years ago
Fuck "T4'! This song owns anything "McG" could ever do. Period.
knailed 2 years ago
go n' fuck yourself !
hummerKLB 2 years ago
the vids not even nececary just listen
asdf12344321ful 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
I can't get enough of this song!!!!
phemohilia 2 years ago
Phenomenal video to an amazing song. Nuff said
tyler80s 2 years ago
This is amazing, at 2:30 is the start of what sets this version apart from any of the rest. it reminds me of the live version on aatcb but with even more feeling in the guitars. at 4:11 i love that riff to death
Alex1XD 2 years ago 2
Amazing song, trully moving piece.
I was little bit dissapointed, when i didn't hear it on the terminator movie (the trailer had it, movie didn't)
tiesioglinas 2 years ago
This song never gets old! Anyone can listen to it over and over again!
mobball221 2 years ago 3
Nothing evokes so many different emotions like this masterpiece.
I feel like kicking ass when this is playing.
SrustinLim 2 years ago 3
I love this song...
=)
KolkaEntSimonka 2 years ago 2
When I first saw the trailer in theaters, i started laughing really bad because I recognized it on the guitar chorus!
tvsuicide4 2 years ago
ahah samee
mistressmarigold 2 years ago
I knew when I first saw the Terminator preview that it had to be NIN
Cool
EntertainmentIsGood 2 years ago 2
i like the all that could have been second half sound of this version of the song! nin is 1 of the best.
idropped77 2 years ago
I don't know what it is but this song is just so fucking awesome! You can listen to this song any and all the time
mobball221 2 years ago
Amazing. Thank you.
79Sebek 2 years ago
21st century version of Gloomy Sunday.
csy1991 2 years ago
F...EN GREAT! :)
,\m/
debilnoto 2 years ago 2
that's the best version of this song that I ever hearded in my entire life
RicardoxParedes 2 years ago 4
obviously u havent heard it live then...bonnaroo NIN rokced the fuckin stage
jtothejawill 2 years ago
the best version is the live version( and all that could have been) album! check it out.
idropped77 2 years ago 2
could listen to it all day long,
great song.
cycling4ever 2 years ago 7
grande, mitico
nosds 2 years ago 2
The video is a hidden track on the 'all that could have been' dvd. Disc 2. Same song, but live. Similar version too. Very cool.
Hicksx 2 years ago
outstanding.....thanks for adding
Loveland80 2 years ago
ah....love it... sounds like freestyle-playing
HiFiboy20 2 years ago
this sounds sick as hell
xxxginoxxx92 2 years ago
Fuckin great!!
godse7en 2 years ago
which version of the song is this? which year rehearsals?
Soint 2 years ago
With_Teeth era (2005, maybe 2006)
CeejayGSPB 2 years ago
no, 99' or 2000, Fragile sessions not WT
NINzack 2 years ago
The song is from Fragile era, but this rehearsal was recorded in 2005/06. It is from mofoboy's With_Teeth Rehearsals.
CeejayGSPB 2 years ago
hmmm, thats weird, why does it show robin fink and everyone else from TF playing at the end? (no sarcasm seriously curious)
NINzack 2 years ago
Because this video is originally for the AATCHB Live version.
CeejayGSPB 2 years ago
so fuckin' amazing .... see u guys on rock n coke ...
Gurji555 2 years ago
in which CD is this video? Closure? or and all that could have been?
euginius13 2 years ago
It's an easteregg on the "And All That Could Have Been" DVD. The easiest way to get to most of the hidden content, or Easter Eggs, on the DVD is via the "Beneath The Surface" menu hidden on disc two. During "Head Like A Hole" at the 11:20 mark, press 7 on your remote (some users report that 7 doesn't work but 6 does) then Enter. The menu will come up and you will have access to the hidden content.
CeejayGSPB 2 years ago
It will come to pass sooner than anyone cares to believe, The whole world will go away.
hdcuz1 2 years ago
NIN rules
VideoCobra1234 2 years ago 2
The Fragile is Best NIN Album, fuck the critics.
NvikIngsN 2 years ago 7
You know that Trent TRASHED The Fragile? Pretty much completely disowned it. :( It is, without question, one of my favorite albums of all time of any band.
negahawk 2 years ago
Yeah, I wonder why trent trashed it. Because he believes it or just agreeing with critics. Maybe he thinks it's pure indulgence. The way a lot of people claim Axl rose did with the Illusions cd's
NvikIngsN 2 years ago
is this the original song??
JCortez515 2 years ago
I read one of the remarks that someone likes the studio version from the Fragile better. I think I might have to disagree with you. And All That Could Have Been was an awsome album(with the exception of Hurt(I hate that song)) I think I'm gonna have to pick the Live version off of AATCHB.
ComaAlpha 2 years ago
Trent Raznor rules!!! NIN
rvonfrankenstein 2 years ago
Though the live versions aren't bad I prefer the original, especially the louder part after the verse. Such an incredible wall of sound, maybe best piece of music I've ever heard.
laydown666 2 years ago 5
led me here, and here i am!!!!!!
thomathius 2 years ago 2
To everyone who wants to post this "C&P if Terminator Salvation led you to this": Forget it. I'll delete them without any commentary.
CeejayGSPB 2 years ago
nin is my life
sampwnzu 2 years ago 5
Can't believe it took the Teminator trailer to find these guys.
I always thought NIN were a weird punk band, but this is excellent and extremely atmospheric.
Anyone know of any other bands along a similar vein please do say!...
Smorg85 2 years ago 7
Soundgarden? Stone Temple Pilots?
afixsxe 2 years ago
nine inch nails
Alien8990 2 years ago
awesome song
greywing81 2 years ago
This song is great but I prefer the remix.
Sorry~~~~
Astrogirl107 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
what album is this on?
lovebabyL1 2 years ago
original version is on The Fragile i think, thats the version you here in the terminator trailer minus drums i think... the other versions I got (Me i dont know about anyone else) on a album titled the day the whole world went away, it was just the remixes and stuff.
i13m 2 years ago
I remember reading an interview Trent gave...he said he wrote this song about watching his grandmother die slowly when he was a boy. Like most of NIN's songs it's very personal stuff.
groundzer077 2 years ago 2
I think his grandmother lived through his childhood. She raised him I think...
NvikIngsN 2 years ago
yes, she did
TerrribleLie 2 years ago
most beautiful song and video i have ever seen
weses2 2 years ago
i need this versions tablature
clyse88 2 years ago 2
I agree. This is an amazing song and was my personal favorite when i saw them play it on the fragile tour. Seeing it on the Terminator preview almost stopped my heart. In a good way. It was perfect. Be a real fan and enjoy it with others and help open there mind to better music.
696NiN 2 years ago
Oh god guys get over yourselves, who honestly cares if people found this song because of a trailer. It's better people know of it rather than not! I hate whiney music snobs. Just enjoy the music and stfu about hearing it 'first'.
jessicaR4bbit 2 years ago 9
Comment removed
MyRealityIsMine 2 years ago
Comment removed
MyRealityIsMine 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
firthh 2 years ago 2
this is not the original song that fit the video. the ive "and all that could hav been" version is the original version of the song to fit the vid. but they took that of u tube
silentsmokeNIN 2 years ago
I'm glad they used this song in the new terminator trailer
aredof15 2 years ago
i have to agree but then it will become too known and over used which makes me want to kill every one who listens to it because of Terminator Salvation. =( damn them for using it in the trailer........*sigh*.......
Uberassassin93 2 years ago
Whatever happened to someone listening to music because it's good, rather than it being outside the mainstream? Are you like . . . 13?
joshuare5768 2 years ago 9
This has been flagged as spam show
what the fuck y its because of terminator i know the song fagot i dont like the band but the song is coool ill kill you mother fucker....... hahahahahah
Albiceleste8 2 years ago
I find it hard you could throw a straight punch, when you spend all your time on youtube attempting to make yourself look big.
Daedalus969 2 years ago
youtube sucks more, day by day...
YaTEdiGo 2 years ago 5
Damn, some time ago there was a version of this song with same video but SLIGHTLY different soundtrack, andi liked it a way way more, i think it was some kind of limited version and they removed it from YT... if somone has it PLEASE leave me a massage, thx!
MaD4tehwin 2 years ago
was it soft and had mostly piano or more hardcore....
lordbbbbb 2 years ago
the one he's referring to is not the piano version. Its the original version but it's been altered by Trent Reznor. He made it sound "live". It was the original music video version but I think youtube doesnt allow it for copyright problems or soemthing. something about the album copyright i think
NynInchNayls 2 years ago
great song
NiklasKing87 2 years ago
i was lookin for rehearsal version since ages. o.0
<3
AninhaNinah 2 years ago
geilste ever
Beefe666 2 years ago
good song
dodster 2 years ago
i need this version of song, whared u get
clyse88 2 years ago
Check out the link in the description.
CeejayGSPB 2 years ago
amazing song!! the guitar solo after the verse and the chorus is using some of the riffs/solos off of all that could've been (probably the most depressing NIN song)
pnd066 2 years ago
it would seem so, lot of nin make me sad
clyse88 2 years ago
Can someone send me this to my youtube account? or from some downsite
Chainedfear 2 years ago
ugh i cannot find the original version of the song that came with the vid
silentsmokeNIN 2 years ago
too soft lol
LeaderHeat 2 years ago
Comment removed
brandonman22 2 years ago
i wish i had tabs for this
clyse88 2 years ago
If you want the "Terminator Salvation" version come and get it. I accidentally deleted someone's message. I just remember that wanted the mother fuckin version. If you want it resend that message.
lvarmy2lt 2 years ago
I would love it!
thekates 2 years ago
Yeah just give me your e-mail address and I'll send it to you. I'm not going to send anything else just that one song.
lvarmy2lt 2 years ago
indeed! plz send me this song! :)
fataltotal 2 years ago
I would say I want that version of the song...but that would be a lie...I don't think I could live without it....o.0
I MUST HAVE THAT TRACK!!!!
CBCarucci 2 years ago
Just send me your e-mail.
lvarmy2lt 2 years ago
can u send me the song version to?
clyse88 2 years ago
Send me your e-mail address.
lvarmy2lt 2 years ago
If you want the "Terminator Salvation" version message me.
lvarmy2lt 2 years ago
never heard that version b4, luv that they're using it for terminator. one of my fav songs!
fetusblender 2 years ago
fuck havent heard this song in a while
covester 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
~~~~~copy and paste if terminator salvation trailer led you to this~~~~ I love NIN, but i heard this song and my flame for NIN reignited, buy THE FRAGILE is a true masterpiece!
VergilFermin 2 years ago
Comment removed
bulldognagol 2 years ago
IF YOUR LOOKING FOR THE ACTUAL TERMINATOR TRAILER song i have it, check my video
MistaMixxxa 2 years ago