Who are the RIGHTLY GUIDED CALIPHS? Question that led a sunni to Shia Islam

[MohsinAlley]

Every Shia should and Must watch this video and specially "4SHIA" who claims to have read nahj ul balagha from cover to cover and give me an answer to this! I DEMAND AN ANSWER ON BEHALF OF THE UMMAH for this VIDEO...

Dr Tahir ul Qadri's Irrefutable proves on Shia Sunni History Maula Ali as & Khilafat of Hazrat Umar & Abu BakrRA

[4Shia]

@MohsinAlley where is the video ya 3ami i want to see what ya got

[MohsinAlley]

If you have read Nahj Ul Balgha from cover to cover.. how did you miss Qutba (

sermon) 146 where he says "Umar, your lashkar is lashkar e ilahi, and calls Umar RA as "qalifa amr e ilahi"

Which means he is the Qalifa as per Allah's will and is RIGHTLY GUIDED" Now my brother, you have to believe either one of these two

1) Book Nahj ul Balagha is NOT AUTHENTIC and you dont believe in it

2) Hazrat Umar RA was the rightly Guided Qalifa as per Mawla e Kayanat Hazrat Ali ul Murtaza RA.

Your choce.

[4Shia]

@MohsinAlley i want to be respectful with you but it seems you dont deserve it

1) that is not in Nahjul balagah i just read the sermon and its not there and my version is printed in egypt by a sunni publisher called dar alfajr

2) nahjul balagah isnt 100% authentic and just believing some hadith in it isnt authentic doesnt make the book not authentic ... you people have many books that have weak hadith in it for example sahih altormithi and sahih ibn majah

[MohsinAlley]

@4Shia OK.. here's the deal.. stop bulshitting about shit when u dont know shit.. U claimed that u read Nahj ul Balagha.. hence i showed u proof.. and as expected from a typical rafidhi.. u laughed cos u cant say shit about it.. anyways,.. dont be respectful to me.. cos I dont need ur respect when u cant be respectful to the wives of the Prophet SAW

Can ou even tell me what Nahj ul Balagha means? It means "style of writing" and it holds no value cos None of the sermons etc have a sanad

[MohsinAlley]

Read "Qutba number 146 from Nahj ul Balagha where Hazrat Ali RA talks about Hazrat Umar RA at the time of Ghazwa e Iran , when Iran was being won in the daur e qilafat e Umar Ibn Khattab RA.

-Maula Ali RA says that "as per Allah this battle is the battle of Haq and Umar you are on Haq"

[4Shia]

@MohsinAlley again thats another lie .. you know what? i want you to take pictures of the book and the pages you are getting this bullshit from and post a video so i can make a proper response to your crap

[MohsinAlley]

@4Shia Lie???? Pictures??? Bullshit???

Well, heres the bullshit and the source that iam getting this information from... Hope u will like the picture of YOUR OWN Books (so called read by you) proving the love between Hazrat Ali RA and Hazrat Umar RA..

Type "Mola Ali RA on Sayiduna Umar RA from own shia books"

Face the truth.. May Allah guide u to Seerat um Mustaqeem

[MohsinAlley]

Also... If it is the farman of Hazrat Ali RA, And you call ur self a Shian e Ali and Reject what he said.. I dont know what else to tell you my brother.. and please change the profile pic that "according to you" is the picture of Ghadeer e Khum.. becaus in Islam there is no such thing called "photos,pictures etc.." and when u are talking about calf worship.. i would appreciate if you can amend yourself and change the pic..

[4Shia]

@MohsinAlley why should i change it? ghadeer khom is an event recorded by sunnis and shia and pictures arent haram unless you prove it .. we dont worship pictures my friend

[MohsinAlley]

Just Think once: ALLAH loves his Prophet. Right? Yes or No? Didnt he call him as his HABEEB? Yes or No? I know u will say Yes. Now my question is, WHY... WHY would ALLAH want his HABEEB to marry someone like Ayesha RA if she was not good? For eg: If you like ur younger brother.. will u allow him to marry some girl who is not good? NO, similarly ALLAH chose the BEST and GUIDED companions and Wives for his BELOVED HABEEB!! we have no right to talk who is "rightly guided" When ALLAH already decided

[4Shia]

@MohsinAlley didnt Allah love other Prophets as well? then why did Allah marry Noah to a kafira? why did he marry Lot to a kafira? why did he marry Hud to a kafira? why did he marry Asiya to a kafir? and there are many more examples ... as for the whole companion story Allah didnt choose the companions the companions chose the Prophet just like the other Prophets companions chose them as well and they betrayed their Prophets like how they killed Jesus and the Jews worshiped the golden calf

[MohsinAlley]

Didnt our holy Prophet know that as per shai, the Other three QALIFAS WILL BE MISGUIDED? How come our divine holy Prophet overlook this if he knew this already and did not warn us of Abu Bakr, Umar and Uthman RA?

Why did he always supported them and took them whereever he went? Why are they lying beside him in Madina? Cursing Sahaba is a SIN cursing the prophet's wife is a SIN! REFRAIN!!

[4Shia]

@MohsinAlley you guys say the Prophet (P) didnt know the future so according to your sect that question doesnt make sense

who said he supported them? thats what you say we dont say that

as for cursing sahabah prove to me the word sahabah from Quran or sunnah and then we will finish the argument

[MohsinAlley]

@4Shia The one who says that the prophet did not know about the future is not a sunni my brother.. u r misguided and u talk about Qalifas being misguided?

[4Shia]

@MohsinAlley hahahahahhahahahhahahhahahahha bro go read your own books i feel like im teaching you your own religion ... copy and paste this link in your browser and see what your scholars say about that

understanding-islam(DOT)com/q-­and-a/islamic-beliefs/did-prop­het-mohammed-pbuh-know-the-fut­ure-5922

[MohsinAlley]

@4Shia I really feel sad about the way u belive in your "CHANGED" and "ADULTERATED" books and try to prove a point which does not make any sense.. Its sad that your deen is not MUKAMMIL. I feel nice that I get to "TEACH" shias, khawarijs and Wahabis that how "SICK" is their Aqeeda.

Enough of teaching.. hope u will like ur so called "pictures from YOUR books" as proof.. Hope u have a spine to check them out and come to the TRUTH

[MohsinAlley]

My question: How can Abu Bakr be truthful if he was not rightly guided?

Another question: If you say that Abu Bakr, Umar and Uthman (RA) are not rightly GUIDED... Do u mean that the Holy Prophet under whose GUIDANCE they were is not a good GUIDE? was he not successful in guiding his CONMPANIONS?? Brother, indirectly u and the shias are saying that the prophet was not a good GUIDE (Nauzubillah!)

Question: Why did he alwys ask Abu Bakr to lead prayer? according to shia books?

[4Shia]

@MohsinAlley that has nothing to do with nothing .. Jesus a.s tried his best guiding his companions in the end they told the romans where he was and they killed him .. Moses a.s tried his best guiding his companions but when he went to mount sinai for 40 days they worshiped the golden calf ... the Prophets mission is to give the message and its up to the people to reject it or not

[MohsinAlley]

Brother, all qalifas Abu Bark, Umar, Uthman and Ali are rightly guided.. if u r saying that only Ali RA is the rightly guided and others are not, then u r not following what the prophet said when HE, ALI and ABU BAKR were standing on the mountain of Hira and it started shaking, he said "O Mountain, I command you to stop shaking as upon you stand the Apostle, The Martyr and the Tuthful"

He mentioned himself (apostle), Ali (Martyr) and ABu Bakr (Truthful)

[4Shia]

@MohsinAlley that hadith is in your books not ours and we do not believe in your books

[MohsinAlley]

Well, I cant stop myself from typing this... your video does not say anything about the other Qalifas, how did ur shia speaker ignore the sermons and letters of Imam ALI RA in NAHJ-UL-BALAGHA where he said "I swear to ALLAH, I have heard with my ears that the prophet said that I'm the last NABI and there is no NABI after me, However IF THERE WAS A NABI AFTER ME, IT WOULD ME UMAR" mentioned in Nahj ul Balagha, NOW... WHO IS THE RIGHTLY GUIDED QALIFA??

[4Shia]

@MohsinAlley that isnt in Nahjul Balagah i have read Nahjul Balagah from cover to cover twice in my lifetime and there is no such thing like that in Nahjul Balagah

[MohsinAlley]

Contact me brother, open your eyes may allah bless and guide u on the right path. Ameen. (PEACE)

[MohsinAlley]

Brother, it is ironical that you made this video stating RIGHTLY GUIDED QALIFA and sadly brother you are the one who is MISGUIDED. I'm sorry brother, I shall Pray to ALLAH SWT that you get back to your true roots and do not fall for anything what the Rafidhi Shias say and Preach as they do not have complete knowledge, for eg: Do you or any shia even know why our Holy Prophet even said Mann Kuntu Mawla Fa haza Aliyun Mawla @ Ghadeer? Why did he suddenly say that verse? I will give u the answer

[MohsinAlley]

Brother haqq110, I'm a Muslim Alhamdullilah and my Brother, I have all answers for you, please reach me at alley_kh1@yahoo.co.in or mohsin.alley@gmail.com

All the claims mentioned in the video can be explained and hope Allah Guides you to the right path. Just to start- the verse that you have mentioned from the Holy Quran about the WALI which says Yukeemoona, Raakioon if you analize are "PLURAL" and they cannot be for ONE-SINGULAR person, hence the ayath is not talking about any one person.