Added: 1 month ago
From: 107e5WickedFan
Views: 32,103
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (208)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I went to see Dan Radcliffe last May, and that was an incredible experience.

    However, Dan had immense success before that. Before Glee, I knew that Darren would be successful, and to see him doing so well in all these projects and stuff makes me so proud. It's like seeing a good friend you knew in school doing well in life because you know they deserve it.

    Love you, DC!!!

  • @0:58 interesting Mathew Broderick impersonation... and he is really struggling to project and stay in tune... although this is actually one of his better performances.

  • The thing is that the character J. Pierpont Finch is a goofy, weird and very clueless. I thought that Dan portrayed perfectly. now my issue is not that Darren is a bad actor but that he is to suave for the role. Dan is a smooth guy if you had to describe him in one word it wouldn't be weird, nor goofy nor clueless. He doesn't naturally fit it the description. I love Dan and Darren but Dan is more of that goofy awkward guy. If you saw the movie Robert Morse he was perfect, as awkward as can be.

  • I like Dan's version better but its still good

  • I don't get why? Everyone is slamming Darren's version. Of the song. Anyways: Well I know everyone would go with the orginal Daniel Radcliffe, and that no one could replace them. But Darren criss could be the next. Daniel Radcliffe on broadway. And having his acting, career would actually help him out. I was and still is one of those people. I dreamed myself, of becoming a actress, and I started out in school musicals. And did numerous dance recitals. At the age of 5.

  • I don't know why people are upset with Darren Criss's rendition of this song. I think he did amazingly for not having very much time to prep. Besides, he has always been mega talented. Anyone who thinks otherwise should go on Starkid's Youtube page and listen to all of the wonderful music HE wrote

  • @katiroxursox Well he had two weeks, that is what everyone has when they are taking over for a role on Broadway. That is what Jonas had, that is what Stamos had when he took over after Broderick, it is standard for Broadway. And he knew he was going to be doing the show back last summer, so he had the time with the music and libretto to study on his own. So being out of tune, not having Broadway strength behind his voice, dropping lines, having blocking problems can't be excused.

  • @sinatrabooth89 I agree that the audio of this video makes his voice sound weak but I don't think that's what it sounded like live. Also the audio made his voice sound a little flat from catching vibrato. Even the chorus sounds weak in this video.

  • I think Darren was already on Glee by the time I started watching AVMP, but I watched AVMP before I got in to Glee...

    Anyway, congratulations, Darren! Great job!

  • Any one saying Darren is horrible....your dumb because he is amazing...I would like to see yourun around and dance and sing and see how you sound....plus the critics don't agree with you...they LOVED him...and so do I:)

  • Darren criss is horrible!! Go Daniel Radcliffe!!!!

  • @MultiKnight13 its better to experience the sex of his voice live

  • Your awesome! I love you so much! If you read this darren, please comment back

  • God , Daniel Radcliffe is soooo much better

  • I was a Gleek first discovered Darren there, and because him i started to get into Starkid and now i am a huge starkid fan as well... I think some people think that if you discovered Darren through Glee, you can't be a starkid fan.... thats not the case (:

  • Guys, i know its great and fun to say "I knew Darren when..." and as a fellow starkid, i totally get it! But does it really matter? I mean if you love Darren Criss, then you love Darren Criss! My best friend isn't a starkid, but she loves him from Glee. And that just means more D-Criss fans and more potential starkids!!

  • @tapstar84 Thank you for that! I mean I do take pride in knowing him before he was on Glee, but some ppl take it too far. Darren loves all his fans no matter how long they have loved him.

  • @tapstar84 yes, thank you! I admit, i didn't know him from AVPM. I was like 15 then and I never went on youtube then. I didn't even start to watch glee until last summer. Some starkid fans go as far as saying Glee fans aren't 'true darren fans' unless they knew before he was on glee.

  • i love how people try to say theyre darren criss fans after he got on glee......the true fans know him from AVPM/AVPS, cuz hes TOTALLY AWESOME!!!

  • Guys, seriously, you can´t compare Dan´s and Darren´s version when Dan´s si studio version and this is stage version, when you have to dance other stuff... :D Dan is great, he really showed that he is not just "that guy that plays Harry Potter", but Darren is Darren, he is extremely talented and he had only a little bit of time for preparing his role and I think he´s incredible! :)

  • I've looked on itunes and the album of Daniel singing this is out. Does anyone know when the album of How to Succeed will be out with Darren?

  • @ZaMizuZoku They usually only make recordings of the 1st cast unfortunately. :(

  • I'd feed myself to Aragog's children for him to make a recording of all the H2$ songs!

  • Seeing this live was one of my favorite experiences in the theatre. I'm tearing up just thinking of Darren in this show by hearing this song. Thanks for posting :)

  • I love Darren.

    But I have to say this isn't as good as I expected it to be :/

  • guys don't forget that darren was also dancing while singing this, while in dan's recording he was in a studio.

    i grew up with dan and love him so much and he was incredible in the show. i'm obsessed with darren and he was equally incredible in the show.

    i saw the show with both and you cannot compare them! they were honestly both amazing in their own ways!

  • THANK YOU

  • doesn't anyone else think it's funny how daniel and darren are both harry potter :P

  • Daniel--Great

    Nick--ok

    DARREN---SUPERMEGAFOXYAWESOMEH­OT

  • Considering he had only two weeks of rehearsal, while the majority of Broadway actors have months, I think he did a good job. I bet if he'd had a bit more time to prepare, nobody would be saying he "doesn't have the pipes"...or maybe they would. Haters gonna hate.

  • @125Dave8 I hear you big time, he was on a tight schedule, but so are many Broadway replacements. I don't think any amount of preparation changes the fact that he doesn't have a powerful enough voice to fill a 1500 seat theater.

  • @futurephantom Well, I´ve heard Darren sing a lots of songs, including live and theatre performances and he has very, very strong voice... :DD

  • @LittleAnnieH well that's good to hear. I really do love Darren Criss. I had tickets to this show during his run and when I heard this recording I worried that his voice would not fill the theatre. Unfortunately, my fear was confirmed when he displayed a thin, feathery voice. But that can be due to allow of factors, maybe he improved, and maybe he didn't have enough time.

  • @futurephantom I believe in him, he is extremely talented and everyone has bad day sometimes... ;)

  • Dear Society,

    Please give us back Darren Criss, we need him to make "A Very Potter Musical 3".

    Sincerly,

    A TeamStarKid Fan!

  • @Kelso016 Dont worry! He's gonna be in it!

  • He did sound better when I saw him a couple of days ago.

  • Daniel Radcliffe is fucking Harry Potter and even HE can sing it better lolz.

  • @mreaglesfan1995 daniel may be fucking harry potter, but darren is HARRY FREAKING POTTER

  • I saw him on Thursday the 7 and he was amazing! I wish he could come back again!

  • I saw this yesterday!!! He was supermegafoxyawesomehot!!!!!

  • @thewizofseus101 Me too!! Did you see him at the stage door after the show??

  • He was amazing!! I saw his closing night and he killed it!!

  • I love Darren Criss but he doesn't have the pipes.

  • Fabulous, fabulous, fabulous. Saw it last night with my cousin! Loved it!

  • His voice is priceless!

  • Seeing this Tonight!!!!! :D

  • @CatMuse16 I saw it last night, too.. so AMAZING!! it was breathtaking! I was watching it with tears in my eyes.... so proud!!

  • If they were just to have Darren do one song from the whole musical to record I would sell my soul for it to be this one.

  • I think the comparisons are going to come again when Nick Jonas takes over the role next Tuesday the 24th of January.

  • Everyone, has to understand that Darren Criss comes from a theater background. Before he got his start in hollywood with television shows, he was trained at a theater company in Michigan.

  • @nmjean05 Even before that. When he was a child he was in many different professional plays with his parents and even with out them.

  • @fivebluroses People just need to stop hating!!!! He is Darren Criss, not Daniel Radcliffe, and Daniel Radcliffe isn't Darren Criss!!!!

  • I'd practically sell my soul to see Darren in this.

  • He can't even remember the words to songs he wrote himself...how the hell did he remember these? ;)

  • I'm impressed Potter ... and no I wasn't meant to leave this on Dan Radclift's Version ... (although I've left him one too)

  • I don't know why some are saying his voice is not strong, considering he is dancing while singing he sounds great!!

    Good for Darren for selling out the house night after night.

  • Love Darren, but Dan just fit the role better:P

  • I like his voice a lot. But judging by listening to this recording and listening to a Daniel Radcliffe recording (I never saw the show live, unfortunately), I actually like Daniel's voice in this better. Not saying that Darren isn't good (because he is!), I just think that Daniel's voice fit the role a bit better, you know?

  • @leopardstar5556 My thoughts exactly! I love Darren with all my heart, but I do agree that Dan's voice fit the part better. But I loved Darren's facial expressions, and dancing, they were priceless! He brought his own character to the part, and i really loved that :)

  • So, when I went to see Darren in this show it was such an adventure. I scared Jane Lynch (By accident!!!), sat next to my friend who i didnt know who was going tot he same show, and got Darren's autograph. Best night of my life!

  • Dan wasssssss SO much better, like me and my friends cried when we saw him

  • i saw daniel in this and it was the most amazing show ive ever seen. love it.

  • God, I want to see him on Broadway SO bad!

  • @XxMadAboutPotterxX Same except I'm in LA!!

  • Don't like this. Daniel was way better.

  • is this from his opening night? 

  • Honestly Darren was like the triple threat at this show. He can act really well, sing really well, and he's an amazing dancer.

  • i am going to see him tonight!!!!!!!!

  • I love Darren, but I don't like how he kind of... swoops his notes instead of just hitting them straight.

  • This was recorded at the show I was at... I know because I can hear myself screaming....

  • i like danrad way better 

  • this. is. amazing. you are a saint for posting this.. A SAINT! <3 oh Darren i love you <3

  • I'm proud to say that I sat up and waited for the "A very Potter Musical/Sequel" came out live on youtube. I'm proud to say I knew of this awesome, talented guy before he got big. Thumbs up if ur one of the few who followed Darren rise to fame.

  • Darren is just adorable (: Just listening to his voice is a blessing ❤

  • I don´t know really a lot about Darren.. but in my opinion he´s not good for Broadway, sorry.

    I must had been hard fr him debuting with a leading role, though, I´ll give him that. But, he´s on Glee, where he is "used" to sing and dance. I think he is the best dancer, seeing the videos of Brotherhood of Man, Dan is the best actor, and since I know how Nick can change his voice (Hairspray) and dance still, I think Nick is the best singer. But, idk, my opinion can still change

  • I wonder what night this is from. I saw him on 1/8 and he sounded much, much better. His voice was stronger and had more of a Broadway quality to it. He danced well and sang well. He didn't sound winded and weak. I wonder if this version is from opening night.

  • HARRY FREAKIN' POTTER!!!!

    less than three <3 <3 <3 <3 <3

  • Comment removed

  • is this the soundtrack?!?!

  • darren <3 i don't see how ppl can like dan rad's version more, his voice is too coarse for singing n he tries way too hard cuz i dun think his voice is meant for reaching those notes.

    n darren has 2 weeks to prepare only and dan rad has a whole year, tat's one big difference

  • I really was hoping for something that sounded more like "Something's Coming" from glee, but I still love Darren's voice nonetheless. 2 weeks rehearsal for a 2 act musical is INSANE. ♥

  • Jeez his voice is thin and bland. And I did see this live, the choreography was extremely dumbed down. I just want Dan back or someone else that isn't mediocre.

  • This makes me appreciate what an absolute gem Daniel Radcliffe is.

  • @deb90566 but darren has 2 weeks to prepare only n dan rad had a whole year

  • @tchadinton That's what I don't get either. He never seems to be one to get nervous, and if he's doing THIS then you'd think he'd be prepared?? I admire him a lot, but I just can't get my head around this...

  • @gingachick14 its because he's not using an MT voice he's using a pop style voice that he uses on glee, and its not in the style of the musical and it doesnt have any support.

  • i have posted a video of this song with darren x its on my channel so check it out! :)

  • @107e5WickedFan

    do you have grand old ivy, how to succeed, and been a long day if so please post them up. I would really appreciate that

  • Okay, so people should stop arguing.

    Darren and Daniel are two different people, with different talents, who may do similar things, but you shouldn't compare them.

    Darren is brilliant in H2$ even though he only had 2 weeks rehearsal, and he's not exactly trained to be a Broadway singer, while Dan had a lot of training for the role.

    So you can't really compare them.

    Just enjoy the music.

  • @EbzzOutLoudX Darren has been singing and dancing much longer, and of course he had his score and book months ago. So saying he only had 2 weeks of rehearsal, and not trained is missing the point. Frankly, I found him to be the worst leading man I have ever seen on Broadway. And trust me I have seen dozens of productions on Broadway alone. He does not belong on Broadway, and clearly does not have a bright future there.

  • @EbzzOutLoudX And now we wait to hate the shit out of Jonas.

  • @SuperKaitie333 nick jonas actually has had the most Broadway training so i think he will be very good

  • I stopped reading comments. It feels as if I should just enjoy the music and imagine how great he is and how his dream being in Broadway came true.

  • Stop argueing and enjoy! It's awesome!

  • I'd like to add that I have lots of friends that have seen him perform this several times. They said that the 5th performance was a lot better than the opening night performance. Also, i saw a video of last night's show. The singing was greatly improved over this video and the dancing was wonderful. Go Darren!

  • @53emilyanne You saw a video of last night's show?? Where? :D Oh, and I totally agree with you!! X

  • @TheGleekoftheWeek Sorry, I meant that I saw a video of brotherhood of man. Just that 5 minutes. You can message me if you would like to see it and i'll send you the link.

  • @53emilyanne Oh, yeah I know what you meant! :) I'd love to see the video of "Brotherhood of Man"!!! :D

  • I would also like to add in Darren's defence that he had what, 2 weeks rehearsal. Daniel had 2 years, for this role.

  • Darren usually sings better than this, I feel like he's holding back a bit??? Could it be nerves? I agree that he may not be suited to this particular role, but hey: You never know until you try. I have full respect and faith in him, and know that he is a talented guy.

  • @gingachick14 If he's nervous he shouldnt be on broadway.

  • @tchadington come on , he has 2 weeks to prepare only n dan rad had a year. any one would be nervous if they haf 2 weeks to prepare only for a broadway show n tats his 1st time on broadway

  • You all seem to be making excuses as to why he doesn't sound up to par with Daniel...

    Funny thing is, nobody makes excuses for anyone else on broadway.

  • guys if you haven't seen this visually you don't remotely understand how great he actually was! I have never seen him dance like that, like seriously he stuck out from the rest of the company on dance he was wonderful on this the number seriously was incredibly

  • @FeelingLikeOctober24 Yeah it was really amazing! He needs to dance with Harry on Glee like that!!

  • I feel like this recording doesn't do his voice justice at all! Knowing that he was never a trained singer, I went into the show prepared to hear some off-key pitches and a thin voice, but that was not the case. He owned this song-vocals, dancing, emotion and all! I think it's impossible to get a great recording from a simple point-and-shoot camera, if that is what this was recorded on.

  • I do like Dan's Finch better, but still I know how hard Darren is working, and this is his first Broadway show and he only had a two week rehearsal process so I can understand that he would be a little nervous and weak. He has said himself in interviews that he doesn't have any actual musical theatre training, so this is really a first for professional plays. Though I like Dan's Finch better, I still feel really proud of how far Darren has gotten himself and that he has his dreams coming true

  • I really like Darren usually, but...I have to say, DanRad sang this number a lot better.

  • I guess we can only make our judgment when we have the actual dance as well... making a judgment NOW is a bit too soon. And this version is, well, an illegal version. And the Dan Rad ones you see on YouTube are pretty official so they have better audio.

  • I love you!!!! I saw this yesterday and it was my favorite performance.

  • i can't believe ppl r saying dan rad's version is better -_- dan rad's voice is not meant for singing n he tries way too hard :/

    n ppl, darren had 2 weeks to prepare only, dan rad had one year

  • @joannako127 Dan did a really good job though. He hit all the notes while also holding an American accent. He's not primarily a singer or dancer and he did both.

  • I really like you Darren but ...

    I already miss so much Dan's Finch !

    It's not about voices performance, or dance performance (they are both great singers and dancers)

    But, for me, the problem it's how Darren "plays" Finch, actually, it's like he's here to sing (very well) and dance (very well) but it seems he forgot a bit the "ACTING PART" of the character .. :S

    (BUT PLEASE DO NOT HATE EACH OTHERS, WE ARE HERE TO SHARE OPINIONS, NOT TO BE BAD AND INSULTING ! :D)

  • Wow, first Harry Potter than this? Darren is stealing all Daniel's characters

  • @Waddlepop8898 actually, this is not "Daniel's character". Robert Morse opened the role on Broadway. And then the revival had Matthew Broderick. And then, and only then, did Dan take the role in the 2011 revival.

    Dan has played many other characters in Equus and December Boys etc. and Darren has not touched them. And Darren is on Glee, which has nothing to do with Dan.

    So, no. I don't think he really is "stealing all of Daniel's characters." Nice try though. :)

  • he's really great, but he doesn't have a broadway voice, he's got a recording voice which is why he's so good on Glee but DanRad was so much better for this role and broadway

  • #ProudMamaMoment ;D less than three

  • while darren isn't bad, beau bridges is terrible... so glad i saw this play back when it was quality..

  • This is not good people, can't you see? Please. He's great and i love him, but this literally sucks. There's no emotion. AT ALL.

  • @mydadisnotaphoneduh Dan didn't have much emotion in this song either. It's not exactly an emotional song. It's a con man's song. How much emotion can there be? More relief at not getting fired than anything else. Besides, you can't judge how he's acting when you can't see anything.

  • dans version is so much better

  • Can't.

    Stop.

    Loving.

    THIS MAN!!!!! <3

  • DANIEL PUT WAY MORE EMOTION INTO THIS SONG

  • suck that 10 person who disliked this

  • he makes it sound like a highschool production. sorry hes not cutting it.

  • I want everyone who said that this wasn't ABSOLUTELY AMAZING to know that Darren is the most talented person I have ever known in my entire life!!! He brought something different to the charactor NOT something bad!! Now seriously go away and do some research on darren so you can understand why you are soooooooooo wrong and don't say anything rude about his performance because no one who cares about darren wants or likes to read it!!!

  • Does anyone know what date this performance was by any chance?

  • This is so brilliant!!! He can not be real!!! How can anyone be that gorgeous, that talented, that charming, that fuuny, that smart, that humble and that nice? The scientific community really needs to stop cloning sheep and start cloning him!!!

  • God! This is brilliant. He is brilliant...... Thats where he belongs ...... on a big Broadway stage :) Makes me so proud <3

  • I'm so proud of DarrenXD I do think he does a totally awesome job in this...but I just don't think he fits the part, he'd be better suited for playing link larkin or fiyero, but his voice is just too modern for the time period this takes place in, i think dan did a better job with the character.

  • Love Darren! If I could meet one person in the world, it would DEFINATELY be him. :)

  • they say they tone down the dancing. watched the vid of this. same as dans. he did awesome

  • Oh little hobbit.. <333

    

  • I don't care how illegal this is, i am dying of happiness seeing this video.

  • so many mama feelings. I've watched him go to Starkid to Glee and now to Broadway!!!! So proud of our little hobbit!!

  • Comment removed

  • have you got the video ? I really want to see this performance :) (but thank you for this !)

  • Darren can never seem to escape using ugly bowties as part of his characters

  • I wish there was a studio recording with darrennnn :(

  • When he sings mediocrity it finally hit me and I started sobbing I am so proud of him!!!

  • DanRad>>>>>>>

    I know Darren only had two weeks to prepare, but for someone who's supposed to have musical theatre experience this doesn't sound too good..

    Also after his run is over will he finally stop single-white-femaling Daniel? That's all I want to know.

  • Hey Guys, calm down! He might not be the best or as good as Dan was, but that's because while Daniel Radcliffe had several months to prepare for this role, Darren only had two weeks. He said it him self in an interview, he only had TWO week to learn every dance move and vocal!

    Now I'm not trying to bash Dan at ALL! I saw him in How to Succeed and he was AMAZING! b! But honestly give Darren a break! He's only been at it for a few days! I'm sure he'll improve as the days go on.

    GREAT job Darren <3

  • holy shit he sounds fucking amazing! i can't wait to see this<3

  • guys, it's really hard to sing and dance in the same time. He said himself that he's not a broadway trained singer, So what if he sounds a bit weak? he's still awesome and I hope that after these 2 weeks he'll get other proposals for broadway!

  • @singingharp he went to school for theatre performance he should be trained for it. If he can't handle the role he shouldn't get the role. End of story.

  • he sounds like he's talking rather than singing

  • S have been positive and everyone has loved him and praised him; he finished filming glee at like 3 in the morning on the Saturday, did a couple of gigs in the weekend then had only 2 weeks to prepare for his opening night and if this song is anything to go by, he's done extremely well in those 2 weeks and I'm sure he is giving nothing but 110% to this!

  • Right, if one more person insults Darren, heads are going to roll! He has worked SO damn hard to succeed in this industry and he has worked tirelessly for the last 2 yrs! He deserves every minute to this and he is extremely talented! I have nothing but infinite respect for him and how far he has come and people need to stop comparing him - besides all the review

  • every time someone says 'supermegafoxyawesomehot', a unicorn dies.

  • It makes me sick *_*

    His voice is miscreated!!!! Only Dan can succeed in this musical!!!

    Darren is opprobrium!!!!!

  • @outslider2011 NO, DARREN CRISS IS AWESOME

  • Don't like his style of singing, his voice!

  • I think his voice is still kind of stuck in the Glee stage. It sounds like he should belong in HSM or something. It's a little soft for broadway. He's still good though! Although I prefer Dan all the way <3

  • :D Saw him Thursday Jan 5th :DDDD I didnt like the first scene, as in he was good but ... not that great but then after the first musical number I was like WOW fucking christ love it. (only his 4th performance) And just wow his comedic timing ahhaha and the freaking dancing scene with beau bridge about football and this one was flawless loved it. ahha

  • one more thing. dans debut reviews were not all positive. so don't hate

  • he's not Dan and Dan isn't mathew who was awesome. each finch is different.

  • Dan fans remember he had a year to prepare. DC 2weeks.

  • Can you please post more from the show. Thanks I love Darren

  • I was at the show this was recorded at. Darren was made for the stage. He's phenomenal.

  • I think i'm gonna cry

  • omgomgomgomgomgomgomgomgo SO PROUD OF HIM <3

  • For all of you saying he doesn't sound like Daniel Radcliffe... He's not Daniel Radcliffe! Daniel was good, and Darren is good. Their voices are very different so I don't think it's fair to judge as one better than the other. They both have very good, very different voices.

  • Darren is nothing but perfect. Bitches and hos need to stop complaining.

  • Well, he's no Harry Potter...

  • bless your cow

  • Now I just gotta see him do this fun dance :C