Doctor Who - Because I Knew You (For Good from Wicked)

[chiefnut48]

Thanks so much for this one. Great blend of music and vids.

[Bronybynight]

I just... have something in my eye, that's all... why would I be crying?

[sailorjulesjuju]

Wow beautiful. I love doctor who and I love wicked!

[tonks0]

This is one of the most beautiful vids I've seen of them. Song captures it perfectly. <3

[MONKEYGRRLZ]

ii'm so sad i miss rose :( but at least she had a happy end and got to be with the doctor :)

[jonesfan2008]

this video is so perfect because it's a beautiful song and when you think about rose did change the doctor to be a more fun loving person and the doctor showed rose what life could really be like. i love this video!

[auntloretta14]

Amazing! Thanks.

[jadelouiselippett]

u know what kind of video you should do

[WhovisionTV]

This song is actual called For Good.

[qu3en8]

I really loved this video, at first  I didn't think the song would really fit but after watching , it was perfect match and a beautiful video

[missy01missy]

I just finished watching series 2 and am trying to cheer myself up. so thank you, this helped.

[picardythirds]

hey, great video and song choice. Because they knew each other, the Doctor and Rose both have changed for good

I love wicked and Dr. Who...so this is awesome :)

[picardythirds]

hey, great videos. :)

[FAWYful]

The scene on the beach always gets me no matter how many times I watch it.

[spacexbutterfly]

This song is SO pefect for Rose & the Doctor. I watched this a couple years ago, but I can't remember if I commented then - oh well, it's just as lovely! Ever consider making an updated version with some of the Turn Left/Stolen Earth/JE episodes? This version is awesome as is, I just thought that it would be cool to have some Rose-in-charge clips since that goes well with the theme of the song. Anyway...thanks for making an excellent vid :-)

[LovingFictionalGuys]

Beautiful... :D

[bobbiwib]

im saving up to see wicked with my mum :/ neithe of us have the money it sucks

[nimmie54]

Doctor Who + Wicked = freakin awesome. :D

[Becca8Becca]

That song matched the doctor and roses story perfectly. Awesome Job!

[Titaniczna]

This song fits perfect to Rose and the Doctor! Good job, I really like it :)

[CrazyGood88]

3:24-the sweetest kiss in the entire Doctor Who series...save the kiss that 10 gave astrid before he sent her to fly with the stars. Eccleston/Tennant...my heart breaks just thinking of them. I was inconsolable for Eccleston, and am now inconsolable for Tennant.

[twilightbowzer91]

Great video!

[mii910]

perfet

[moonlitshadow27]

i'd love to see a follow-up with Martha and "I'm not that girl" which is so fitting it's kinda eerie. and, to a certain degree, Donna's song would be good deed... she saves the universe but is forced to sacrifice the best moments of her life anyhoo i've made too many comments on this vid i love it

[CrazyGood88]

@moonlitshadow27 I like your thinking! thats brilliant!!!!

[SnapeGirlUSA]

Doctor Who is my favorite thing in the world--especially Rose/10. And so I'm crying my eyes out right now. But I'm going to see Wicked tonight on Broadway and I can tell from this song that I'm going to be crying again when I hear it!

[SnapeGirlUSA]

Well, the show was brilliant! And I DID cry during this song when Elphaba and Glinda sing to each other.

Did you ever think of trying to use "Defying Gravity" for Rose/Doctor. It's also very fitting. ;) Great video here though.

[doctorwhonrose]

love it

[TheWarnerSister]

I think I just melted.

This astronomically more sad than Elphaba and Galinda parting - and that was SAD. This may be closest I have ever come to crying over a YouTube video.

I love this so much.

[darkhuntressamanda]

Love <3 <3 Pure and Simple.... i <3 Wicked i <3 Doctor Who..... the combo was amazing!! 5/5 Faved Playlisted!!

[Beautifulo0oFantasy]

Perfect Song :) Made my heart , melt into a little pool :) This is Amazing well done

[flyingpigs1197]

This is beautiful. I really like looking at the end of their relationship like this. Doomsday was SO sad, but I love thinking that even if they never see each other again, they will always remember each other. I actually cried in this video, especially when Elphaba's/the Doctor's part starts.

[dumblemop]

Ahhh, these go together perfectly. <3

[pinkchan831]

That was absolutely perfect. Seriously. Five stars and a favorite for you. :)

[JoshandCassie4ever]

i have been a wicked fan almost from the moment that it started, and I started watching Doctor who from kind of a late point but in that time I have come to love it. If you love Wicked and Doctor Who you will love this vid. It is an amazing combo. thank you so much for posting. It made me cry!!

[auuggghhh]

I'm not even gonna watch this, and do you know why?

Because if I do, I will sob hysterically for hours on end, and I won't be able to stop for anything.

However, I have been thinking for a very long time that somebody needs to make a Doctor Who video using this song, and I don't have the technology for it, so I thank you very much for posting.

Thank you!!!!

[NickeyNoodles]

so cute

massive doctor who and wicked fan

love it :D

[cayechapelgirl]

Made me cry too.

[Denawo0301]

Im a massive Wicked fan , and Doctor Who fan, and this song fits their story so well I think. This vid makes me cry lol.

[Rox159th]

cool video, and the song's good too. 5/5

[Kine139]

brings tears to my eyes :)

this has my vote to stay up as long as it can

[padsblack]

absolutely brilliant! it really fits the song, especially considering everything thats happened since :D also fits with the song in that its been used in much the same way as in the musical :D bravo

[moonlitshadow27]

i know i already posted, but oh well *crying* I really liked Rose bc you could see her maturing and changing... I know when David Tennant regenerates I'll be inconsolable I love him so much. perfect perfect perfect video

[lacrossebabe11]

omgg! i luv this videoo! its beautifull!!!!!!!

[montypython203]

Wonderful vid! It fits with the lyrics so perfectly!

[moonlitshadow27]

That was beautiful! Two of my obsessions put together- it was very moving and I loved it. Good job & thanks for posting!

[torchwoodladi]

this is beautiful i have the wicked soundtrack but never thought of doing anyhitng like this this is brilliant so amazing

thanks

[KLady3]

It's very true, they both changed each other's lives so much. Great use of the lyrics images to match up with the fake scenery of Doctor Who like the comet etc. I especially like that you ended it with two of their reunions instead of their parting. Wonderful video and a song I've never heard!

[Richieboy78]

superb!!!

I've made a Dr who video myself if anyone wants to check it out.

Congrats on this one thou, really enjoyed it.

[leglesstheelf]

I was never a fan of the Doctor/Rose romance, but this video is heartbreaking! Great job.

[harleyguy5]

Lindy, I miss you more everyday. I will always be thankful for the wonderful years you shared with me, allowing me into your heart and soul. You were taken so young. Because I knew you....because I knew you....because I knew you, I have been changed for good. See you again my angel.I love you

[prisoner0932]

Oh, man.

Gorgeous. Perfect song, perfect clips. Kudos to you.

[FATE522]

"He'll need you and that's very me." Greatest vid tribute to Doctor Who thank you so much!

[FATE522]

Someone sent me this link because they thought this was me...and now that I see this I can't believe someone thinks of me like this...

[paigehobo]

i love this song from wicked, it and defying gravity are tied for me. this one however makes me cry because it is exactly what you say, two best friends who've changed each other's lives, saying goodbye.

This would also work in a way with the recent events in JE, they are always saying goodbye!

:(

makes me sad. beautiful beautiful video though

[haynesy2008]

Nice one! This is BRILLIANT (as Doctor 9 might say)

[CrazyGood88]

@haynesy2008 9 said *FANTASTIC*, 10 said *BRILLIANT*

[haynesy2008]

@CrazyGood88 typo =S

[CrazyGood88]

;-) all cool...still two brilliant Doctor's in my POV so its all good lol!

[haynesy2008]

Lol, definately! They are both brilliant and fantastic at the same time. =D

[CrazyGood88]

YEEESSSS!!!!! lol!!!

[kt27rule]

i love this video it so cute and sweet

[shimmershadow30]

i havent seen the musical, movie, zip. But i loved the vid and music:)

[TheNextRoseTyler]

Thank you soooo much for this vid. At first I thought I wouldn't like Wicked, as I'd only heard a snippet of 'Popular' and thaought it might be like High School Musical... The less said about that the better *shudder*

But then I saw this amazing video and listened to more of the soundtrack, and now it's one of my favorite musicals! Thank you so much!!!!!

[applegrassdude]

OMG! I'm so happy I encouraged Wicked!Love!! It's one of my favourites too, just behind The Sound of Music and joint with Hairspray and Joseph :D

[madda27]

Hey i have a question how come u spell favorites like this f-a-v-o-u-r-i-t-e-s??? Not trying to be mean or nothing i just wanted to know

[applegrassdude]

Because I'm English :D Just like you say color I say colour, right? And there's gray and grey, too...

You also spell sulphur as sulfur which I'm sorry to say I just can't stand. And it's in all our textbooks now D:

[madda27]

Oh ok i see i didnt no sorry if i bugged u

[applegrassdude]

No tis OK :D

[CrazyGood88]

@applegrassdude don't forget honor honour! ;-) sorry but I could not resist that one! or theater theatre! there are so many!I am actually in the middle of studying the difference between English and American speaking and spelling(thanks to Doctor Who and Torchwood lol) and I am enthralled by the differences! brilliant vid! aweosme!

[HeartlessArchangel93]

Yeah, the sulphur/sulfur thing is driving me mental at the moment T_T. I'm taking GCSE chemistry at my high school, but my chem teacher is french, so he's never sure which ones right - and he goes by the one in the textbook! So everytime I write 'sulphur' in my book, he puts a line under it and writes 'sulfur' when he marks it...it's driving me insane...*headsdesk*

[bobolishas]

sweet! I like it! Beautiful!

[wifhucifjfdiuew]

omg u just combined my favorite song from my favorite musical with my favorite tv show! ily!

[Hallam92]

I COULD NOT AGREE MORE! :)

[Islesburg]

I saw Wicked in London last week...this song fits so beautifully with the Doctor and Rose's story. I think i almost cried when i saw it on stage despite already knowing the songs. 5 stars :)

[jamestparshall]

No words. Beautiful just beautiful. :) Thanks!

[FlowerGirl9016]

Oh, so beautiful I almost started crying! This song fits them so well! And the clips you chose are equally as wonderful. Five stars and favorited!

[coriejo24]

This is such a perfect song for the Doctor & Rose!! Great job.

[schwindlig]

Love it - yoou have combined two of my favourite things - Wicked and Doctor Who - and so effectively! Tis so sweet :)

[angelgirl1992]

Such a beautiful song. Amazing video too.

[retrogal180]

My school sung this! I know the whole song!!!

[kaiyam1]

me too, some people sang it at School Spectacular last year and we did about 6 performances

[LJSchuster]

omg. thats so beautiful, i nearly cried

[grbd150]

His scooter in the idiots lantern looks like Sasha, from scrubs.

[Sheba6001]

I love this song.My Vu chouir class from school sang it and started crying cause they are seniors and what not.Then my cuzs choirus sang it.

[juju1597]

the chorus at my school (i am in it) did a show called broadway musical showcase. each grade chorus sang songs from broadway musicals and some individual people sang their own songs too. two girls from our show choir sang this song and i almost cried. i have never seen the musical or heard that song before then. now i love this song! thanks for the vid!

[JazziLuffsWicked]

First time I saw Wicked I sooo thought of the Doctor and Rose when Idina and Helen sang this song! It's so beautiful! xx

[GallifreyRose]

OMFG! Amazing! love it!

[rubix110]

Wonderful concept! You did a marvelous job!

[TheNextRoseTyler]

One word. Goosebumps.

[callumseyalook]

OH MY GOD!!! just had a bitching idea...Doctor who, the musical??? Any takers?

[BeckusTitheroff]

hmmm....!! Not sure it would either end up absolutely brilliant of completely crap!!!

[funnygirl023]

this song ws played for us by my teacher, who was leaving because she was only a student teacher. she was the best theology teacher i have ever had and ill miss her.

[baboonbuttface22]

My friend Kyra Conway recently died...

5 girls sang it and everytime i hear it now..

i cry

[NarnianPrincessVMK]

Amazing song choice; it goes so well with the Doctor and Rose! Wonderful clips; great video. :)

[awsomepwincess123]

oh my goodness ryt i went too see little shop of horrors wiv my skewl at the west end on the 11th of july that is such a conincidink lol and my song + dance which is popular from wicked ani wayz that was a fantastic vid i loved it lol well done

[rubyandroll]

That's so lovely and sweet! And the weird thing is I went to see Wicked the other day and I thought about this song for these two.

Funny, I also thought of "What is this feeling" For Sarah-Jane and Rose, and "I'm not that girl" For Martha....

Do you think Russell T Davies is a fan of Musicals?

[TimeXFlies]

I havn't seen wicked yet but I plan to because I love all the songs and this is such a beautiful video!!

[RubberDucki12]

I LOVE WICKED AND DOCTOR WHO

This video is so sweet.

[soccertennant]

Ahhh, my two favourite things EVER. Doctor Who and Wicked all in one musical and science fiction-y package! =]

I saw Wicked with Eden Espinosa as Elphaba. And let me just say WOW. Defying Gravity was the most amazing song ever.

<33

[cazzykay23]

i love this video ti so sad

[DoctorWhoFan4evax10]

brilliant vid!! totally doctor and rose song. five stars and favorited:))

[lily33433]

HI i lue doctor who it is the best show eva do u no when the next when is coming on in Englend?????????PLZ reblay BACK PLZPLZPLZ

[kaiyam1]

i heard this performed at school spec and just thought of them

[soccertennant]

I'm seeing Wicked next Sunday!!!

[chsro]

Is this Kerry Ellis singing on this?

[applegrassdude]

Nope, it's Kristen Chenoweth

[dreamer20k]

no Kristen Chenoweth and Idina Menzel

[Aislynn815]

That was fantastic! Loved it! ♥!

[dreamer20k]

Oh my God you are so luck to have seen Kerry Ellis.

amazing vid. For Good is my favorite song from Wicked

[Citril1]

You have such a gift! How you manage to fit the scenes in perfectly with th lyrics, I'll never know! Absolutely beautiful!

[121dancinbeanaho]

:-0 i wanna go 2 yr skl! i luv wicked n doctor who!!!! wooooo!!!!

nice vid btw. =)

[emily2210]

Beautiful

[meeplesquadge]

And idina and kristin rule too! theyre voices rule!!

[meeplesquadge]

I LOVE THIS!!!

WAIT a second...didnt i give you the idea for this? except for defying gravity? lol, all credit to you tho, i love it!!!

[applegrassdude]

THANKS!

Your idea was for Defying Gravity...yaaaa...but I can't actually figure out how I'd make Dr Who fit to Defying Gravity atm. Working on it, tho :P

[cazzykay23]

I LOVE THIS VIDEO IT ROCK LOVE IT

[whoknows2007]

We want Rose back! Sign the petition for a Doctor Who movie with Rose and the Doctor (we'll be sending it to the BBC when we get enough signatures):

w-w-w dot petitiononline dot com / rosie111

Sorry if you think this is spam, but I don't reckon it is - I just want Rose back, and I know lots of people agree.

[ilovetheDoctor]

I LOVE IT!!!!!! I am a HUGE Doctor Who fan and Wicked fan. and this is so well don i am going to send it to everone that both loves doctor who and wicked!!!!!

[takeabananatoaparty]

Lovely, lovely, lovely. =D

[littlehotaru3001]

Wonderful! The end made me all teary! I love it!

[scarlettina710]

Nicely done! The first time I heard this song, I instantly thought of the Doctor and Rose and I've been waiting for someone who could actually do videos to do it. THANK YOU!

[RmceWrtr]

Wonderful! I'm sending the link to my daughter now... both a Wiicked and a DW fan

[raevyn17]

Lovely!

[darlingdoctorsdame]

I love this song, and I love WICKED, and I love Doctor Who...it was brilliant!