Roger Waters (In The Flesh) - Perfect Sense (Parts I & II)

[gudagilmour]

Man is a tool in the hands

Of the great God Almighty

And they gave him command

Of a nuclear submarine

And sent him back in search of

The Garden of Eden

[1stchoicemodern]

It makes you wonder with so many fans of Roger Waters come more people can't se the fucking truth!!!! All these idiots sit in their little boxes labeling themselves Rep or Dem and can't see outside of their boxes and what fools they have turned into. Turn off your TV have an original thought, if you are still capable!

[johnnahodil]

its like goin to church.....accept the preacher is telling the truth!!!

[kristina1577]

mad goosebumps everytime...all you intelligent floyd listeners know what im sayin....peace

[MrAlanmcmahon]

to all conspiracy perpetuators. mankind, no matter how well he plans things, rarely ever go according to plan. the smaller the plan the better chance of it reaching fruition, you see there are too many 'x' factors involved also no matter how many electronic gadgets and grown ups toys he can create he is still basically quite stupid

[SneakyShark]

just amazing...

[Cocknajo]

Best od the best !

[einrib4truth]

"It ALL makes Perfect Sense... Expressed in...$'s!" "Wake-UP!" Does EVERYONE think that the Whole "World-Wide" Financial Demise is just a COINCIDENT? It has ALL been stealthily and deceivingly "ORCHESTRATED" to be this way so the ZIONIST/JEWISH Bankers can take TOTAL Control over "EVERYONE!" Read: wake-upbeforeitstoolate(dot)co­m and understand just how far this MASS DECEPTION goes! Roger Waters KNOWS! This is WHY he is touring the WORLD NOW!!

[studyhistory2ctruth]

No it doesnt make perfect sense i choose to blame a entire party. Im to stupid to think further.

[lordsybok]

thank you, just thank you for this song, a good eye opener .... or how you call that :-)

[lisapit1]

waters has the perfect knowledge to capture his audience!!...brilliant!!...thi­s is excellent and i just love it!!..they don't make music like this anymore!!...

[A2W2H2666]

@lisapit1

true, true!!

[TheMe6o]

What can i say.......it,s a magic...this is a different world.....like no other !!

We are blessed to having you ROGER !!

[GONZALOBLOOD]

THAT 5 PEOPLE HAVE TO DEAD

[kingfaffer]

wow amazing song..

[takkcertu]

Very nice

[whydoiwant1]

JUST LOVE IT THANKYOU POSTER!!!

[deepbreakfast1960]

The second part of this makes me feel like I'm at church!

[deepbreakfast1960]

This is such a gut wrenching song!

[alirezac130]

bomb of energy

[HywieBach]

Fucking AMAZING...........Yes prove Roger is Mr. Pink Floyd minus the name.....Which David traded off once they all broke up. Glad they managed to sort thing out though before Rick went. Life's too short......OneLove.xxxThanks for posting this.

[Fairleighbrown]

One of my favorite songs....love it!!

[CARPENTER1979EGY]

The 4 dislikes is from Germans ,Jews , Arabs and the hostages

[ram9000]

Richard Gere?

[ThePinkfloyd51]

A perfect album indeed.

[mario1638]

perfect song, thank you Roger, thank you.

[potdeew]

Belleza! 

[sandermatthijs]

Such a special one, thank you Roger you make my world a little better..

[CtrlRm]

Perfect album.

[amma220]

perfect perfect perfect sense <3<3<3

[Matyldonka]

Amazing song!!!!!

[datimsta0]

beautiful...the gift of sight through song

[wonputt777]

...enlarge your screen,

use a nice pair of headphones

and you will see and hear

ALL of the genius here...

[einrib4truth]

It all makes perfect sense because the whole god-dam demise of the world is being purposely orchestrated. Roger Waters has known this for years!!

wake-upbeforeitstoolate(dot)co­m and look at the 1st video link in the introduction and see how one individual brags about how he started in "controlling us!"

[MrIlZurdo]

I was in that concert in Oregon What's the name of that girl singing the solo? I Want to marry her...Saludos desde Matamoros, Mx

[srtaxnachita]

Here we have answer of why is going on in our world.

[MichelleRundell]

Need to see what lies beneath?Not getting any results from techniques that you have found?Unleash your true psychic powers.Enter THE-HIDDEN-SPIRITdotCOM and finally get what you've been looking for.

[gugaisaac2]

my godness.......... can't breath

[renegado992002]

its really a masterpiece, I hear it for so many times and it sounds each time better.....

[alexeiev22]

amazing, just beautiful, and the introduction, perfect, perfect sense, love it...

[SprinklesBrightly]

i love this song ive saw it live 6 times

[claytonlee1975]

exactly were we lie pounds, chillings and pence isnt any wonder why we are in such a mess.

[sandermatthijs]

Watched 'The Wall' live at Arnhem this year, Waters was outstanding, never to forget..

[ksifounwn]

Can't you see

It all makes perfect sense

Expressed in dollars and cents,

Pounds, shillings and pence

Can't you see

It all makes perfect sense ..... so true!! νομιζω δλδ....

[thedam98]

@ksifounwn - a truly great artist of our time telling us flat-out why the world is the way it is. We need to wake up, everyone, and be the change we want to see in the world.

Roger, thank you! It's truly an honor to have shared the Earth at this time with you!

[einrib4truth]

@ksifounwn And the Parasites who control the Worlds Banks... Control "EVERYTHING!" and when the WORLD can "Wake-Up!" and understand this hidden deceitful Fact! then we can finally EXPOSE these Psychotic Parasites for what they have stealthily done! Roger Waters has been clearly saying this for years but too many do not connect to the serious connotations he is implying! Everyone should read: wake-upbeforeitstoolate(dot)co­m and understand how we have ALL been incredibly deceived

[tff1293]

got to see the wall in 2010 in philly. AMAZING. there will never be an artist quite like him ever again. some of his solo stuff is as good as or better than some floyd. he is a true artist, a breed that is slowly fading today. alright, i have to go, ill be late for my justin beiber show.

[LeisaObrien]

Need to see what lies beneath?Not getting any results from techniques that you have found?Unlock your true spiritual and psychic potential.Go to THE-HIDDEN-SPIRITdotCOM , your search is finally over.

[kaernkraft]

sitting with ur google translater and translate specific words like "kill" "the""jews"

OMG racist 20yrs of loving PF down the drain HAHAHA

[kaernkraft]

P.P Arnold (female singer) in this song is so fucking awesome

i mean listen to her voice!!

And all you who think they hate Jews, haha wtf?

LISTEN TO THE FUCKING LYRICS

[goferba]

the best songwriter ever and this is one of his masterpieces which he has, by the way, several

[ItchyClickfinger]

the Germans kill the Jews and the Jews kill the Arabs and the Arabs kill the hostages and that is the news !!!!!!

[gianluka11]

Ogni volta che ascolto questa solista mi commuovo cazzo!

[nachosayons]

asi como nosotros(la gente)les llenamos los estadios y los hicimos estrellas ,ahora es tiempo de que dejen de lado egoismos y peleas y se junten con David y nos devuelvan algo.... tan solo un poco ...genios°!!!!!!!!!

[garmyste]

cant believe some of these comments on here concerning the lyrics....

[garmyste]

thnx ..does she do the great gig in the sky?

[marcusdolby1]

@garmyste No, actually, the woman who does Great Gig in the Sky on Dark Side of the Moon is Clare Torry. She is a white woman much to my suprise. Not that it makes any difference. But I allways thought that must be a black woman, I was wrong.

[phallius]

I'm done with PF. I had no idea he hated Jews so much. Ba-Bye....the Jews have been through enough already. Find another scapegoat,,,and another brainwashed fan. 25 years of loving Floyd,,,down the drain. Good job David G. Go ahead and follow your friend down the deadend road.

[danieladanyhella]

@phallius

If you think he hated Jews you simply didn't get the message of that all... And if you think this song and similar ones is the deadend road I'm really sorry for you, dude...

[Vulturefood]

@phallius You turn fast for someone that doesn't know the meaning of this song LOL read between the lines, then go do your march of tantrum whaaaaaaaaaaaaaa  ffs

[ItchyClickfinger]

@phallius I had no idea you hated arabs so much . I feel sorry for ya

[garmyste]

please tell me her name (backing singer)

[danieladanyhella]

@garmyste

It's P.P. Arnold

[underpantswedgy]

Former Pink Floyd member David Gilmour will make a surprise appearance during former bandmate Roger Waters's upcoming 30th anniversary tour for The Wall, announced Waters via his Facebook page on July 14. Marking a reconciliation after years of feuding, the two will perform together at an as-yet-unknown gig during the 2010-11 tour.

[GarryMac73]

The Germans killed the Jews and the killed arabs and the Arabs killed the hostages" is not antis emetic dopey it is an example of the chain of mans inhumanity t o his fellow man. You of all people should understand that DXB2B

[DXB2B]

So the Jews are the bad guys now? What an antisemit brick...

[tugga26]

Every time i hear this song, specially the part when the girl with that amazing voice is singing, it brings tears to my eyes!!! What a song! What a voice!!

[carlosbrion2003]

soberbia!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[mikeinie1]

No matter what is going in the world, this song applies, Gulf of Mexico oil spill, Israel blockade of Gaza.

It all makes perfect sense

[doghouse71]

@mikeinie1

you are so right....

[mrsfesty]

Such a fabulous track - it never fails to amaze me with the pure genius of it. Saw him perform it a few years ago and it brought tears to my eyes. Just hoping he plays it again when I see him play next year.

Roger, you are a living legend.

[USASalim]

Pure Genius...puuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu­re Geniuuuuus. This song gives me goose bump and if you don't feel anything, man there ain't any help for you because you are probably dead.

[sucramnormark]

So this song is in two versions right? In the flesh! and in the flesh?

[pablodelobos]

gracias por subir este video

[PloKoon444]

PINK FLOYD ARE THE BEST!!!!!

[isadealhue]

Este tema de In the flesh es excelente, la voz que uno oye como sobre puesta es de 2001, Odisea del Espacio, el final del robot, genial idea de Waters

[TourDu]

Nothing short of genius.

[NLhcCoen]

Fucking truly amazing artist my respect. I dont like rock and pop at all. check my account what a listining most. But this is fucking great.

[bjclark1948]

zeroclan007 makes a good point, in my humble opinion--however, I think Roger's obsession with WW II is a positive, not a negative. In today's world we accept millions of people dying as something less than significant! World War II, a long time ago,. Korean War--oops, Military Action, not enough death to qualify as a war! Vietnam--no comment required, Iran/Iraq etc. So. . .the Germans kill the Jews, and the Jews kill the Arabs, and the Arabs kill the hostages, and that is the news. . .

[jerseyprincess01]

the germans killed the jew the jews killed the arabs but what did the americans the americans killed the arabs toobut right do any of them have to commit such hanus crimes? ... this MONEY/ WAR

[zeroclan007]

I got the feeling Roger just never got over the world war thing...almost all his music has the same "nobody wins in the end we're all the same so let's act normal' with the accents sometimes more on the sorrow and then on the victory (more on the sorrow imo) as moral. great music! always feel epic by it = )..asif I can handle anything. even write a comment on youtube!! Gooooo Roger!!!

[boeverjan]

It came from Stanley Kubrick's film " 2001 A Space Oddyssee" when Dave, the austronaut disconnected HAL ,the central computer.

[Oalaffa]

At the beginning, he says "I'm afraid Dave" etc. Which Dave? Gilmour!?

[monicauk30]

Wow. This is great music. This is what music is supposed to be, not that crap we see topping the chars these days.

[malabarspyder]

Some artists nail lyrics. Some chords. Beck or Stevie Ray or Clapton nail notes.

Mr Waters nails society.

I listen to the lyrics over and over pondering. They transcend policitcs, country.

The best part is- he doesn't BLAME anyone. Like this was our destiny. Or maybe a waypoint.

I love his music. Fill in the gaps and there is a lot of meaning here, and I haven't even found it all..

[bjclark1948]

I can't help but think that you absolutely nailed your description. Roger Waters is a truly amazing artist--with an ability to put his finger on a problem or situation and describe it spectacularly well. Like you, I appreciate the knowledge without blame, as there are always 2 sides to every story--and in Roger's case, simply pointing out the situation is enough. He's the most talented song writer of the 'baby boomer' generation.

[sassystinkpot]

Can't you see

It all makes perfect sense

Expressed in dollars and cents,

Pounds, shillings and pence

Can't you see

It all makes perfect sense

Thanks for adding!

[fruitloopz4eva]

it does indeed make perfect sense, and pp arnold does a blinding job, almost as good as roger himself, pray keep it coming

[alexeunuco]

i think gilmour and waters together !!!!

[Oalaffa]

Very very good, however I tend to like Gilmour more. This one is still a beautiful piece of music and I can listen to it again and again.

[rimula01]

Roger , that song is amazing

A lot thanks forevver for your talent.-

Elvio

[alfombrodrb]

roger and david together again !!!!

[pliskinn0089]

Please please Roger and david one last tour in honor to rick.. to all the fans to have the chance to see a miracle

[ADyingFaith]

@pliskinn0089 They really shoud. I would defo be there to see that.

[bovb902]

@pliskinn0089 there going to do it david is gonna play in rogerwaters tour the wall

awsoma ha hes gonna play comfortably numb

[ingvaldandre]

@pliskinn0089 What about Nick`? :c

[redskin133]

@pliskinn0089 well said, one last tour for floyd would be awsome with roger back

[henrix999]

Godly.

[rockaires]

Waters is a genial composer, the other Floyd members were great musicians. peace.

[ruipiresas]

roger is the best ........

[zednoraa]

thnx for sharing this video my friend,

[zednoraa]

Uhh...Roger Waters is the best...after all he IS Pink Floyd in the flesh, so In The Flesh is an appropriate name for the concert, i have this live performance in mp3...

[bcwdrums]

Excellent....

[MyRobotnik]

fantastic

[motley1235]

yo no se por que pero yo pienso es el mejor

[motley1235]

Roger Waters the Best

[brickadune]

Roger made the Pink we all know and love

[mikeinie1]

Never mind the Waters/Gilmour debate, they are both magnificent talented musicians, and dont underestimate the contribution of Richard Wright and Nick Mason to Pink Floyd. Pink Floyd was greater than the sum of its individual parts. I have seen Pink Floyd, Roger Waters and David Gilmour in concert and have always been amazed.

This song is just amazing, I love it.

[HywieBach]

Anything Floyd released after Roger left isnn't anything compared to this. That makes perfect sense.x Roger is Floyd.

[pliskinn0089]

I have to agree with you i love The division bell but is diferent. This album and song is a strong argument for the ones that think that roger is THE FLOYD. Im still undecided

[HywieBach]

Cheers boss. Saw him live in Birmingham UK a couple of years ago. They played Dark side. The whole album from start to finish. They also played this. Incredible. PP Arnold is awesome too. Begood buddy.

[mosquitos06]

Gracias por esta musica.

nunca vamos a olividar cuando toco en Buenos Aires

[though84]

Respect MR GILMOUR please,you understand nothing about music if you take offence at David.

[metabog]

Well, I had tears in my eyes by the end of the song.

[gutamaral]

Os trabalhos de Roger Waters são verdadeiros oásis neste empoeirado deserto de mediocridade que assola a música nos dias de hoje. VIDA LONGA AO INIGULÁVEL REI DO ROCK PROGRESSIVO.

[FOTOCHOCK]

Roger is great . he dont need 1000 musician and 1000 lassers he is an artist no a businesesman.

[irena7777777]

Bullshit! Waters isn't half the musician Gilmour is!

[maclagavulin]

sorry, but you don't have any idea what pink floyd was and is now. first of all it was sid barett and then roger waters. d. gilmore is, without any doubt, a great guitareplayer and has become a remarkeable part of pink floyd, but he's not even a quarter of the genius barett and waters used to be.

[irena7777777]

I can't argue with someone who makes ludicrous claims and who's spelling and punctuation is so bad. And he of little intelligence belittles the talent of the legendary David Gilmour! Roger Waters is a great songwriter but not a great musician. Gilmour, on the other hand, is a very good songwriter with the ability to write outstanding music. And Barrett wrote shit songs and wasn't a great musician. Waters has a greater ego than Gilmour, that is certain!

[maclagavulin]

How about your German? As bad as my English, or worse? And what do you know from Pink Floyd, anything before 1980?

[irena7777777]

Before 1980...I have every album you dossile fuck!

[ra0ulvm]

it gives the show more effect thought ;)

[trivium12]

I dont agree wit what he put in the discription, FLOYD IS BETTER!!.....but that said this is an amazing song

[naughtylicious555]

wonderful concert!!

[RebelYellHim]

Pure perfection!

[allen6290]

Roger=Pink

[matt543s]

A wonderful song with a great message.

[Cris1949]

Perfect song, perfect sense!

[zitam41]

Does anyone here know Radio Kaos, if not, search for it, it's awesom, perfect.

[zitam41]

love that man, he is a genius...he was Pink Floyd, more important, he is Roger Waters, the deliverer of the best music ever...just love that man;D

[budzman72]

Pure Genius. Has to be one of the best concerts I've been too. The man is a living Legend.

[ADyingFaith]

@budzman72 Did u go to this actual one or another of his. I love this concert so much.

[neil1963creed]

@budzman72 oh he's much better than that ;)

[Osetie77]

Best song ever!

[rockaires]

Music from a Genius. Long Live Waters.

[sciencesaveus]

The poetry of this song, and much of Amuzed to Death is just incredible. The lines about the joint chiefs of staff and the brokers on walstreet; telling people not to think for themselves, just do what god and country wants you to do; it's so right on.

[porkusmag]

I saw Roger in 2002 and in 2007 (both times in Argentina). Look fellas, he´s Pink Floyd. No doubt about it. No new material, that´s right, but as all the best composers, his music and lyrics are timeless.

[radiokaos65]

Yep, we ain't need none of that Dave's recent and awful stuff. Rog is the true spirit of Pink Floyd and AtD would have made a damn far better floydian album than the crappy Lapse.

[Thraikios]

I really liked to listen to this song in the army

[rhysmyth]

I'm really not liking Roger's recent stuff, his older works are absolutely unearthly/fucking amazing....now they're all about being brotherly and honoring all the people who died in whichever war...he doesn't seem like he's trying anymore, and it sounds like he's talking about random shit instead of singing.

God, but he's so awesome...

[AaronMk91]

This song's an awesome work of art. I like how they used some of HAL's lines in the beginning of the song :D.

If only I can go to see Roger Waters or even David Gilmour. Though, it would be even better if I got to see them re-united, two great musicians at one time.

[elcocineroesteban]

perfecto!!!!

roger sos un genio musical!!!

[feedmepaper]

Great song and great performance. The buildup to the finale is amazing.

[NayMorgo1]

Love It

[VincentLauria0815]

unfassbar geile musik......

[didoban]

Roger Lord, I am your fan since I saw the movie The Wall in 1983, I was 12 years old, my biggest dream, among many, would attend a concert of the Lord, I await the invitation and plane tickets, ok.

[elcocineroesteban]

adimensional!!!

[nephil2006]

I fell of my chair by the quality of this performance. Especially the voices of the female chorus (PP Arnold, Katie Kissoon and Susannah Melvoin).. Look carefully and see how the solo made even Roger Waters himself applaud.

Also it was a nice twitch to use HAL (the computer vice) from Space Odyssee.

[AbrilCo]

reality !  it's amazing

[0n0s0]

Christ... You can literally feel it coming through the monitor and the speakers...

Quite simply a masterpiece performed by a master in a masterful way.

[xtt1341]

所以说，为啥waters比gilmour要高尚，就是这个道理­。真正的杰作。

[fatimagranico]

fantastic song...

[doghouse71]

Incredible!!!!!!!!!!!

[bertorollocoe]

This is the climax, the nirvana of the 3 hour show!!!! This is the peak. Just greatness, yes, makes you cry.

[baboonheart]

absolutely !

[pires1974]

I've seen this live twice and I teared up both times! Incredible!

[pires1974]

One of the most powerful songs I have ever heard.

[mikeinie1]

i think that this is fantastic

[ProphethSamson]

Wonderful, makes you think.

Prophet Samson, Sweden

[cinjerolic123]

im 13 and i love pink floyd l wish they wouldent of broke up though

[kennymact]

i have been there.fantastic,oh Lord

[DjiFal]

I can't describe this - THAT WAS FUCKING FANTASTIC!

[astrablue1]

!what can ye say !

[dagwood002448]

he is god the best

[floresguitar1]

perfect fucking sense

[Trorior]

it all makes perfect sense

[darkfloydian]

que emocion

[stejohno]

masterpiece :P

[TheElusiveBirdMan]

This proves all of you who thing Roger can't sing wrong. This kicks ass!

[JudgeFudgeBr]

Roger is the greatest musician in the history of prog... but there's a little vocal playback at the end.

[gneprrr]

Questa canzone me l'ha fatta conoscere mio padre qualche anno fa... un capolavoro!

[metabog]

Holy... freaking... crap.

I can't help but get teary eyed every time I listen to this. I think if I was there at the live performance I would have died.

[Flatlinergenius]

Excellent music, terrific lyrics. He is one of the best of all times.Haunting stuff. Ethereal.....