Added: 3 years ago
From: crackleunscripted
Views: 708,038
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (1,955)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Comment removed

  • Stupid crowd

  • Doesn't have to sound exactly like the recorded version to be a good performance, just saying.

  • What the fuck are you guys listening to? Her voice is very unique and amazing. This is a great performance, those of you saying it sucks just will only accept the generic pop star voice which is boring... Katy is fun, unique, and great!

  • she sucks...only a hot slut

  • @Hugoj33 OH MEN! KILL YOURSELF PLEASE!

  • @KattyPerryBoys are you in love with her?? jajaja get a life please

  • she can't sing really. they most really need to change a lot of things to make her sound good on the recoreds!!!!!!! GOING TO DIE

  • @TheSnoopy1123 agree with ya!

  • Gaga is way much better , live - lightyears better, to be honest

  • Weee uuuuuusssee tooo beeeee......yaaaaarggggffuuccc­cckkk she can´t sing!!!!

  • Oh gosh...she can't even sing to save her life! Am not a fan nor hater but this really really sucks!! Argh, my ears!!!

  • the only part that seems like the real song is when she says ''and you'' at 0:15

  • she's much better at singing live now!

  • sheis so a hot girl mee ilove katy perry

  • Cause I'm singing it loud, but don't use my mouth!

    I sing through my nose, cause that's how it goes!

    You know I'm the best, no air in my chest!

    Please help, I can't breathe and sound very weak!

    *sing this to the chorus (:*

  • Comment removed

  • Dude, how autotuned are her singles ?! .. She sounds like dying cat or something ..

  • the guitarist wearing black vest is cute.... hahha

  • This was not the best live version.I think she can sing better.

  • Audience Member 1: Hey, going to see Katy Perry?

    Audience Member 2: Yeah, I just want to stand there lifelessly.

    Audience Member 1: Yeah, let's just drink PBR and stand around unimpressed.

  • ou mein got das war schlecht

  • In the actual song I love the way she says 'meeahhh' in 'your no good for me', but here, she spoilt it! :(

  • horrible. horrible.

  • type "ceej in for the kill" damn the kid ripped it!!!!!!!!!!!

  • legs :p

  • that as to be the worst crowd ever rofl x`D

  • Dont know what everyones complaining about , I like her singing and performing.

  • 0:47 Epic face on the crowd

  • I heard that she's shit live. And she really is. Wow. This is terrible!

  • ahhh dear .... katy stop singing please. eww.

  • all the videos i watch the crowd are so shit!

  • amazing !!! 2:42

    

  • is this when she first started?

  • How did she go from being a passionate musician to a corporate sellout in the same music set?  Mannequin, then this? She drops her guitar, looses her passion, and sings this crappy song with crappy lyrics dancing around and looking uncomfortable. This song is mainly liked by thirteen year old girls.

  • @thesovereignones what are you talking about? this song and mannequin were off the same album

  • COOL!:)

  • i was in that crowd

  • She said the b word.

  • i would be pissed if i was her that crowd is awful

  • Ewwwwww ://// Thank god for auto tune sweetie

  • this is the best she's ever preformed live but i never said it was good

  • different but not really baad

  • i only wath the legs

  • i only wath the legs

  • no good for maaaaaaaaaayyyyyy....o wel at least theres 11 other months. fukn doy. ph yeah....katy perry sucks rancid shit from the rectum of a cadaver.

  • the crowd isn't that into the performance because they didn't know who she was- this was before 'i kissed a girl' came out.. just sayin

  • @ginger3046 it just proves that the only reason anyone even pretends to like her is just cuz they THINK everyone else does. this is how the po0p machine makes stars they tell everyone you have to like this cuz its hot and look...everyone else likes it...dont you wana b like everyone else?? katy perry is ugly and these shitty songs suck. they were written by a 3rd rate washed up producer.

  • wow...I live in Austin and I so did not know she was at SXSW in 2008! damn..I miss out

  • I thought she sounded okay I'd listen to her singing any day rather than Justin bieber but geez give her some credit at least she sings live unlike all these other artist

  • what a bad singer!!!! But she is a sexy bitch, no doubt.

  • I've been observing a lot of Katy's live performances and they all seem to be the same disappointment. If you watch other live performances of hers, pay close attention and see that almost everybody in the audience (besides the young teeny boppers in the front row) are not at all impressed by her singing or her performance. It makes me very upset that this is what is becoming of American music. Yet people still buy into this and continue to make these untalented people rich. Such a shame.

  • omg, wtf is that, her voice is so terrible. Wit lady gaga both suck live, beyonce only can sing her own songs ;o

  • @maciekat1 Lady Gaga is great live, Katy sucks!!

  • Maybe the crowd's dead 'cause they don't want to encourage Katy's shitty singing.

  • Is she better or worst than Taylor Swift?

  • @shawnspeed3 Well, I think everyone in the recent industry, except for Ke$ha, are better live singers than Katy Perry. And I've heard a looooot of artists live. Taylor Swift, Miley Cyrus, even Selena Gomez (though I pretty much hate those three) sing live better than Katy Perry. She is just soooo UNtalented that it hurts. How did she get became famous again?

  • @xxxkama7xxx "get became famous"? Wow.

  • @Richardandrew12345 Don't you be so annoyingly specific. Like you never made a spelling mistake on youtube. First I wanted to type "get" but then changed my mind and typed "become" and simply forgot to delete "get". I figured it out after posting and was too lazy to write the whole thing once again.

    I'm curious if the same mistake was made by a person who'd be praising Katy Perry, would you point it out like that as well? Come on, I was just stating a fact, she sucks at singing.

  • Ergghh, what a voice .

  • good

  • are you sure that the people in the crowd are real people and not waxworks?

  • those crowd are zombies...

  • yea....the guy from her song is plain BoRinG and so is the CROWD.

  • Everybody just watch her performance UNPLUGGED with MTW. Trust me.

    -she turns it into a jazzier set...

  • Making me a bit angry that everyone is judging Katy on this performance. If you think that she can't sing, you obviously haven't taken the time to watch her MTV unplugged concert, where she sings beautifully. If you think that she got into this business just because of her looks, you obviously haven't seen her first music video where she hardly had makeup on and she was rejected three times for her first CD.

    how well would you sing for a crowd that was so ungrateful anyhow?

  • @mjf3140 actually she sings fine here. Imperfect ? who cares right ?  One fact is forever clear. Extremely successful people gather lots of haters -

  • I don't know if she's more a beautiful girl or more a very bad singer....(:-0)!!!

  • She can't sing worth beans and shit.

    This makes me sad. I know serious musicians who slave for a serious paycheck and Miss Perry is rolling in it because of her tits.

  • @Picassia serious musicians are often boring. Tits are not.

  • @Picassia She can sing better than those stupid musicians that you know

  • @Picassia I found these SXSW videos when I was searching for Sia Furler stuff (now SHE's a singer worth checking out) and the other Katy Perry performances were songs I'd never heard before. What shocked me was that she was playing a guitar and standing at the mic, and she didn't suck. They weren't even pop. I was floored. She actually has talent. Apparently it's just her teeny bopper pop stuff where she's dancing around with a mic in hand that sucks the talent out of her.

  • @Picassia Your serious musician friends are seriously unheard of. And why, because the "dumb masses" are only after tits?? Get real man, she's got real talent. I fucking hate this song, by the way.

  • @Picassia your'e right, but man, they are some nice ones

  • @Picassia what ever, dumb@@@

  • @Picassia too funny there is a performance of her singing "mannequin" in the side-bar, where she plays guitar and is a serious musician o.O?

  • epic love her!

  • do you know what venue this was at?

  • Singers like her (she's pretty cool) but also like Rhianna and stuff i don't like their music because it's so edited and also they try to shout or strain their voice to sound better/cooler? so to be honest the pitch kinda hurts my ears.... :/

  • Aaaaauuuwwwwfulll. She can't sing. A sign of the times in the music industry today. 

  • even if you fail at SXSW, you're famous just for getting there.

  • This sucked so bad. That jump at the end.... embarrasing. :S

    The crowd was not engaged at all and like three people clapped at the end.

    She was hardly singing, looked like such an ass up there. xo

  • I think Muse played here, and their pretty famous now,

  • nah she must have been quite big then cause hot and cold was in her album and she sang all the songs from her album one of the boys there. So yeah she wasnt a noone she was still quite big. The crowd really annoyed me they could have at least got into it a bit? how awfull would that be to be singing a song and crowd to just be standng there.

  • lol what a joke the crowd is like boring!!!!!!! even the crowed hate her and WTH is wronge with her voice??

  • singing just wasn't for her when she wasn't a ""celeb"" , and it ain't now when she is. so this crowd is way more sincere in their boredom than the crowds nowadays are in their extatic "i want to be like you / have you / for yo've got the fame & big bucks"

    ...come to think of it, why's Katy such a star now?... ah, she's pretty, k.

  • She was a nobdy when she sang this song. You can't epxect the crowd to take notice of her. They're probably thinking when they can go home.

  • do u know who the guys was she was singing with? or the song name?

  • @CrazyHippieLove the song was called hot and cold? and dunno

  • Yeah, I Agree.. Thats Rediculous. They're a Dead Crowd... I would Be so Excited and Loud :D

  • THE CROWD WAS LIKE: O_o o_O o_o O_o O_O o_O

    WTF IS THIS CROWD THERE IS A CELEBRITY IN FRONT OF THEM MORONS!!!!!

  • @mlpochea44

    If a celebrity would be in front of me I would piss on her/him. Who cares...

  • Gottt.. da merkt man das diese POP Tussen alle nicht singen können.. xD

    ist ja echt scheiße gesungen.

  • CAN ANY OF THESE VIDEOS HAVE HER ON KEY? no offence guys your awesome and all that.

  • @Streadofee I don't know but it might be possible that since this is a live performance, she may have just sung it this way.

  • I really love that dress <3

  • <3 <3 <3

  • que dificil cantar para gente taaaaan seria

  • fucking stupid crowd

  • katy is great i know but sometimes she sings different than u expected i mean: sometimes so slow, or fast or maybe some things dont go right

  • this defines suckyness....

  • People's face:

    o_O O_O o_O O_o

  • So out of tune!!!!! Ahhh. this bitch is hot but I want her to sing well

  • What a boring crowd...i would have RAGED.

  • its not bad, but normally shes very bad at live

  • @2revenge123 her singing is fine. have you ever listened to a pop song live before??? this is the result. its not like its a ballad where u can tell if shes can seing well or not. the recorded version has so much editing done to it of course this will sound weak.

  • What's wrong with the crowd?! Seriously, she's awesome :)

  • (people) OMFG KATIE PERRY IS PERFORMING LIVE!!!! (me) HOLY SHIT KATIE PERRY!!!!!!!!!!!!! (in the show) (audience)............... (me) OMFG GO KATIE U ROCK. I MEAN REALLY? U GO TO HER CONCERET AND THEN NO CHEERING AND WHEN SHE ENDS NO WOOOOOOOOOOOOOO WHAT THE FUCK IS WITH THAT?

  • Comment removed

  • Uhm,i thought her voice would be better,but she's still good.But,she's not so good at performances.Like,she's just walking around an idiot!I also don't like how she shouted between lyrics,cuz it sounded weird.

  • she's brave... Stands on stage without voice... Sexy and funny, great in the studio, but she should avoid the live performances...

  • brandnew KATY PERRY - CIRCLE THE DRAIN - LIVE by PIANO TEACHER !

  • hey great work =)

  • The crowd is so awkward...idiots.

  • crowd is soooo cold !!!!!

  • she sounds like someone putting a bunny in a fucking blender

  • she totally has a studio modified voice -.-

  • you can hear  da backin music!!! lol

  • she better off to stop singing because every time she yelled she really scare the shit s out a little children even adult also frighning poor pets animals if they were around!!!!! OMG STOP ITT!!!NOW!!!!!

  • She looks and sounds horrible if closely examaines the voice of every word she sang. she sound like a transexual DUDE in female clothes no offense.....

  • this? is very cool!!! Katy Perry has a gifted} voice, her unpublished songs will be live at ReciveKatyPerry[.]tk

    .

  • i look like her =D? Katy still has a wonderful} vocals, her unrealeased music will be live at ObtainPerryKTune(.)tk

    .

  • She sounds horrible, and this show looks boring. I don't blame the crowd for being so unenthusiastic.

  • How? much I love this song?? Katy Perry still has a gifted} voice, her unrealeased songs will be live at ObtainPerryHits[.]tk

    .

  • @leomaspeyrer if you think this is good singing sorry but its all made with computers she cant sing for a sht without 500 hrs in the studio's without computers.

    btw fk u tomi

  • @kamalaszalankiewicz r u wearing a nice sun glasses walking with a dog and a CAINE

  • The crowd is a fucking joke. What losers.

  • @ArielMichele007, That's sxsw. It's always cold, no one knows anyone and the bands are random. Crowds are filled with scenesters...I hate sxsw. Not a party at all.

  • @ArielMichele007 if i was there i'd be going crazy, the fools don't realise

  • @ArielMichele007 think they all either drank too much southern comfort or used too much coke. maybe both

  • the crowd really sucks

    

  • shiney toy guns was better on this show

  • so much editing =\ but nevertheless, i love the song

  • this crowd is a fucking joke.

  • Lol some crowd

  • I know a lit of singers sound bad live, but this is by far the worst. I loved that song too. So sad to see.

  • better than her usual live, sadly.

  • shes bad live

  • @Screenwipu She's a contralto...you expect her to sing HIGH?

  • @FRANKIELALALA she sings high in her videos with all the effects and shit, but she is absolutely terrible in real life

  • @MICKYMAVYT I know... i said she sings low because shes a cantralto,lowest female singing type smart one. And she still sounds great.

  • hahahha cheeky 

  • i guess shes not so terrible on stage . if u think like tht , think back .. not only her sing terrible in live. there are many singer sing terrible in live . but i dont mean she so terrible , i just talking about ur comments on her . tht's it ;)

  • hot audience...

  • This is shit !!! :D

  • She is not bad singer alive... She is agreat.. and she is fuccccckiiinnngggggg HOOTT My GOD

  • Katy perry go into the adult film industry cause we all know you cant sing like damn did you even hit 1/2 of the notes!!

  • that's just incredible bad :(

  • That's how it's suppsed to sound

  • lmfaoooooo srry to say but this is the worst voice ive evr heard in my life

  • wtf IS WRONG WITH EVERYONE !!

  • Are you people deaf? who is good live then?

  • @ajames7000 the beatles, hendrix, and lots more but who cars shes hot

  • Hahahha freaky dead audience!

    think they are very disappointed to hear her terrible live-voice :P

  • How many teleprompters does she have?

    My ears still hurt btw.

  • Iwant a girl to fart and shit in my face so i can eat her shit and lick her asshole

  • wow this song USED to be good....

  • olha a animação da galera que assiste ao show!!!!

  • Ya Katy Perry sucks when she is live!!!!!

  • OUCH. that hurt my ears.. but shes fiiine.

  • laty sucks when shes live

  • ha, even the crowd thinks shes terrible

  • i already have!!

  • is anyone saying she sucks live musicians? All people sound different live. All bands and musicians edit their music and add effects and all live performances sound different from the recording unless they are lip-sinking or doubling the live show with the recording.

  • funbags...

  • I love Katy live. She puts life into the song, it's never -exactly the same. And I love how she interacts with her guitarist!!!!

  • she is just making up the tune as she goes along!!!!! its not even a few notes but almost all of them. she may be hot ill give her that but she cant sing live! compare the song to the music video and you will see what i mean!

  • love song 

  • mmm actually Katy Perry sounds just like she sounds on the record so...if you didn't like her then then why are you listening to her now? ^.^

  • buenas gomas pero canta pesimo

  • People if u don't like what othe rpeople are saying when they comment then don read the comments!!!!! KATY PERRY SUCKS

  • She sound the same.... of course all pop stars sounds a little bit different in live because if you don't know all musician do editing some of their music. if you dont like her then dont watch LMAO

  • Love hte shoulders at 1:38! :>)

  • she always breathes so loudly )))))))))