Gyorgy Sebok was great, the girl was horrible. Honestly, not the way she played, but the WAY she played.. Look at her movements, her eyes (especially how she looks at him while playing), yuk! It was very distractive, and all those little sounds she made while he was speaking. I think it even made him uncomfortable, it certainly was for me.
"The most difficult aspect of a master class, Sebök said, is trying to get a student to an emptiness, a still point, where (s)he can truly hear what (s)he is doing. For him, music had to flow out of the pianist, and in order for that to happen there had to be a quiet center."
(From T.E. Carhart's book "The Piano Shop on the Left Bank")
Btw, the pianist that is playing here is Ellen Corver.
I would never have thought it possible to see this back on YouTube! Many thanks for posting...I still remember this masterclass vividly, it was extremely interesting to attend it when I was a young student. Sebök was a great teacher, cultured and with a remarkable psychological insight. Moreover, he was an exceptional musician, and this combination is rare.
@pianopera Sebok is not really teaching anything! He is expressing his own point of view without talking about the elements of performance interpretation very carefully described in the numerous teaching teatises of the time which would have allowed the student to then be able to make her own interpretative choices !!
What piece is she playing?
itssevenboxes 3 months ago in playlist piano masterclass
@itssevenboxes Haydn Sonata No.60 Hob.XVI:50, C major
dmitribron 3 months ago
@dmitribron Thanks!
itssevenboxes 3 months ago
Gyorgy Sebok was great, the girl was horrible. Honestly, not the way she played, but the WAY she played.. Look at her movements, her eyes (especially how she looks at him while playing), yuk! It was very distractive, and all those little sounds she made while he was speaking. I think it even made him uncomfortable, it certainly was for me.
re1ntyes 7 months ago
What a gem!
Thanks you very much!
shomolya 9 months ago
Thank you, very very nice!!!
rmfresno 1 year ago
What a Musician..Let's try to learn from him..
konstantinoupianist 1 year ago
I love how he thinks about music. I can't tell if she's just very nervous or disagrees with him.
SolarJakee 1 year ago
Can anybody tell me which piece of debussy she is playing here?
Thank you.
mezjen 1 year ago
Thanks so much for posting this. It brought tears to my eyes. If you have any more, please post.
mayroni 1 year ago
"The most difficult aspect of a master class, Sebök said, is trying to get a student to an emptiness, a still point, where (s)he can truly hear what (s)he is doing. For him, music had to flow out of the pianist, and in order for that to happen there had to be a quiet center."
(From T.E. Carhart's book "The Piano Shop on the Left Bank")
Btw, the pianist that is playing here is Ellen Corver.
pianopera 2 years ago 5
@pianopera Wow. Amazing. How were you able to determine the student's identity?
AlphaSierra5 3 weeks ago
@AlphaSierra5 Because I studied at the same Conservatory in 1987. At that time, she was one of the "star pupils"...
pianopera 3 weeks ago
I would never have thought it possible to see this back on YouTube! Many thanks for posting...I still remember this masterclass vividly, it was extremely interesting to attend it when I was a young student. Sebök was a great teacher, cultured and with a remarkable psychological insight. Moreover, he was an exceptional musician, and this combination is rare.
pianopera 2 years ago 8
Comment removed
mezjen 1 year ago
@pianopera Sebok is not really teaching anything! He is expressing his own point of view without talking about the elements of performance interpretation very carefully described in the numerous teaching teatises of the time which would have allowed the student to then be able to make her own interpretative choices !!
cherieb1900 6 months ago
@pianopera I love Sebök ! And, in my opinion, he would be a very good actor : what impressive facial and vocal emotions he had !
PhilippeLoTheEternal 3 weeks ago