Added: 2 years ago
From: TrulyElla
Views: 552,310
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (717)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Wow she is so beautiful!

  • I agree her music was auto tuned. she should not be singing.

  • I love the song! I disagree that disney is for younger kids.

  • Anyone that needs a WHOLE song auto-tuned should NOT be singing.

  • i'm thinking maybe i'll sing this as a solo

  • SUPER DUPER AUTOTUNE TO THE RESCUE !!!

  • i have the weirdest boner right now

  • I miss Disney.

  • auto tunes are for people who think they can sing .

  • Why do I tear up with I listen to this song o.o

  • i stopped listening after the first 2 lines... seriously the auto tune killed this

  • Kill it with fire

  • wow this is great thanks for ruining the song bitch

  • *sighs* You know, I can tune out Hannah "my dad's the only reson I'm here" Montanna, I can ignore th horrible remade songs of Jonas, I can even deal with the fact that there's only one show on Disney that I'll willingly watch with my younger cousins... But this, this is just evil. I went from Louis Armstrong, one of the best musicans of all time, singing this song to... auto-tuned, annoying, teen pop crap. I'm all for covering a song, but this is like murdering my childhood. F*** you Disney....

  • This just gave me all the reasons why I want to punch her at the throat

    

  • what has the world become !!!!

  • Disney is about creating a reality we can escape to! It's about magic! I love the old disney and nothing can replace it but I do also like the current Disney channel! Walt Disney would be so happy that disney made it this far!!!

  • i think disney died because the creator of disney has died

  • is there a video of her singing this live?

  • This made me cry, Disney hit the rock bottom and been there ever since. Walt, why did you leave us? You can't watch disney anymore if you are over 12, there isn't anything to watch, well you have those crappy DC series, but thats not what I want to see...I'm going to save all my old Disney movies, it is NO chance I will ever show my kids "todays"-disney

  • love it

  • If it ain't broke don't fix it

    Ruined a great song . Nice going

  • man tru that willacait imm 12 and i love nick and victorious!!!! and plus disney give anyone a record deal u dont need talent to become famous with disney.....its said a predict by time i turn 18 disney will be just like boomerang shows and company......

  • sounds like nigahiga its so autotuned... hahaha good ol' days bak then in disney!! :) merry xmas everyone!!

  • Linda Ronstadt,1986

  • Sounds like a robot its so autotuned..

  • autotuneeeeeeeeeee

  • This is way too autotuned. :/

  • What happened to the good times when disney was magic,it platered a smile on the faces of people aged 3 to 93 even older or younger.Now what is it a channel full of teenage girl problems Im 13 years old and have to say I prefer classics

  • Shes not very good they difenitly audo tune all her songs no wonder shes not very famouse

  • wth..they ruined a perfectly good song.

  • then again singing straight to a karaoke microphones recording on some frigging headphones attached to a pc because cant afford to pay for a damn studio its a hard knock life for most of us takes me a whole bloody day to iron out songs best i can with just keep going over the song and listen to it and hear where i go bad and sing whole thing again and correct the flat note because unless you been classically changed and know about notes such what the hell is a G minor

  • shes probably had auto tunning because her vocals are screwed up with nodules from constant screaming high notes which has knackered her voice shes probably some producers kin they always are isn't it ashame some real person at the bottoms dreams dont come true when they can probably sing twice as good as this spoilt little brat

  • Everytime I play SSSG Winter Wonderland I always play this song cuz the winter scenery matches this song

  • WOW SHES HOT!

  • r.i.p disney ; you will be truely missed !

  • Stuff like this makes me glad my mum and dad brought me up with the classic Disney films its a sad day when little children think Hannah Montana is the heart of Disney.

    Mickey mouse ftw!!

  • @rbmufc24 i agree! i am sorry for saying this, but i think Walt Disney would be dissapointed over the ''new disney'' ...

  • 3:02-end, best part!

  • This song lies. . .I wished upon a star for the old Disney to come back. .______. Nothing changed.

  • I admit it is autotuned but she can really sing though if u listen to her things. Disney tries to autotune everything

  • jesse mccartney's version is 100x better!! :/

  • ewww

  • wow wayy to auto tunned but nicly done :)

  • Its a little...too auto tuned. but the beat is nice

  • STOP DOING THIS TO OLD MAGICAL DISNEY SONGS! it makes me so mad arggh!

  • Well I thought it was a good remake. But I DO miss Old Disney :(

  • THUMPS UP if you love BOTH the classics & their covers AND you're smart enough to kno that Disney has NEVER "changed" because they've always been about MUSIC & kids following their dreams of singing & dancing ever since the days of Annette Funicello & Mickey Mouse Club & KIDS INCORPORATED- yes, they've been doing "this" since the SiXTiES & seventies & eighties & NiNETiES even! From Alyssa Milano to Jennifer Love Hewitt to Britney & Fergie to Selena & Miley- been there, done that, still the same!

  • Love it

  • she can't even sing, like wtf, i might as well be singing this gawd awful song

    -_____-"

  • i love this no comment ! xD roxxx !

  • PFFT. It's all about the original!!!

  • ew.

  • auto tune much?

  • Too much autotune...

  • Of only walt was alive today.... Disney used to be magical, now it's just another dying company. Its a sad day when disney sinks to vampires! They try too hard to stay cool but in reality they are losing there older fans I'm almost 13 and I've converted to nick simply cuz Disney tries too hard to please younger kids now instead of the WHOLE family! Im not hating I dislike haters, I'm just speaking the truth!!!!!!

  • @willacait11 what vampire films has Disney done then? xxx XP

  • @messed1up1maniac1 My baby sitter's a vampire? Vampires are just the fad thing of thw moment. Disney is struggling to stay with the "in-crowd" I mean what happened to the classic mickeymouse cartoons. I show them to my baby cousin and she loves them, everyone does. Walt would be very dissapointed if he were ahereday

  • @willacait11 my 14 yr old sister commented that. lol

  • @willacait11 Well, that's a big misconception right there, Uncle Walt was not interested in magic, he was interested in money, to say it simply... he was not a good guy, he abused animators just because disney was the only big company in animation at the time, he was sexist and a little racist... he was a visionary, but his ultimate vision was money, thanks to his method though we received the magic of a lifetime, but that´s just about it, we should actually thank the animators...

  • @willacait11 at least we have pixar, btw this song is just wrong

  • @willacait11 Actually you are hating not speaking the truth. You're acting as if there's only one side to Disney. If you look at the TV side of things, yes they are really only trying to please kids and preteen/teenage girls BUT look at their recent films. Bolt, The Princess and the Frog, Tangled, Winnie the Pooh and don't forget all of Pixar's stuff. Walt would probably be proud of Disney if he was alive today. A few years ago, when Eisner was in charge, eeeehhh maybe not.

  • @joevictor53 I didnt say anything against pixar or the movies.Im talking about the channel. And the classics are the only thing disney that are really "magical" bolt: a lost dog trying to get back to LA

    those others were good because they still have some magic. I mean you cant go wrong with princesses and walt created the original whinnie the pooh. and it was the same story just tweaked a little Im not hating its the truth. they need to go back to making classic stuff that ages 0-110 can enjoy.

  • @willacait11 Not all the "classics" are magical. And if we're talking about films, you've only given them 4 years. Give them a chance. Have you even seen Bolt? You make it sound really bad. It's a lot better than the plot sounds on paper. If used words similar to yours we could easily make Lion King, Aladdin, Beauty and the Beast, etc. all sound crap

  • this isn't a lyric it's a music video

  • Listen...the original version of this was fantastic. Now whats with this "when you wish, when you wish, when you wish, wish upon a star?" I mean why did they do that? Why couldnt they keep it they way it was but have Meaghan sing it? Poor Walt Disney.

  • meaghan is so beautiful!

  • i love it

  • i know all disney stars to day have talent she has a beautiful voice but she killed it i like the orginal one better disney today is nothing like disney back in the old days

    im really dissapointed

  • What the hell is this?

  • She messed up the song.

  • I sorta niss the old Disney!

  • you can SOOOOO hear the autotune

  • @AsianFujiApple its becuz the video is old or they dont want copyright

  • Fuck this. How dare they water down a classic just make it appeal to kids now.

    I hate to use this word, but serious FAIL!!!!!!!

  • this is horrible, it sucks, what happened to the real disney? i am never listening to the ugly pop version of this classics again. they just ruined it.

  • What the fuck is this? They've broken the spirit of the song...

  • Walt Disney would be so dissapointed if he was alive rite now!! they ruined the magic and true original spirit of Disney with Disney Channel. I wish they could start making Disney movies like they use to.....the only way u can get the magic spirit is if u go to Disney Theme Park or watch the classic disney movies......it sucks that DIsney Channel has runined it....they shouldnt be allowed to call them selves DISNEY!

  • extreme autotune & song rape

  • I think my ears are bleeding.

    The fuck did she do to the song? 

  • No hating on her, but she killed it . She made it sound all happy when your supposed to feel melencholy like in the original Disney version. She's mixing modern Disney with old Disney and she's killing it .

  • Not hating on her-she'd probably sound good if it weren't for the autotune-but i hated it. Just watched a cover of it and liked it better(jesse). Have to agree with everyone about the falling qualities of disney productions :( sad but true. Again, no disrespect intended to anyone.

  • it would have been okay without the autotune and if there was just a piano in the background

  • I definitely think Disney needs to stop remixing and making over songs that were perfectly fine originally. But I'm not gonna hate on Meaghan. She got an offer and she took it.

  • I don't only think this is very bad, but i think its a disgrace that someone would even try and do a cover of the song that is probably the most renowned for disney.

  • people like different things. but i must agree. this song isn't as good as the official song. sorry, but it's true.

  • you know what? to all of you people out there that dis this vid. SCREW YOU!!!!!!!!!!! if you don't like it then don't even watch it. those of you that do like it. you don't have to be dising the people that dis this vid. if they don't like it then it's their problem.

  • I really don't like the fact that Disney is just a f*#%! lucrative corporation like many others, but I must admit that it's music is nothing less than magic, so I have to agree with many of you guys... it sucks when a master piece is turned into a giant bag of crap

  • Nice auto-tune

  • If you don´t like why do you see and criticize?

  • uggg... is all i have to say, i asked alot of people what they think disney is after watching this, and all they said was kim possible and hannah montana, and some other bull shit shows.

    then i asked them if they knew who goofy, donald duck and mickey was, they said, OH KINGDOM HEARTS, way to go disney way to fucking go *facepalms*

    please stop touching/remixing the only precious songs we have left in this world...

  • WTF!! IS THIS CRAP!!!!!

  • Just put electronic drums to any piece of music, lol.

  • whats wrong with disney people why they ruin a really beautiful song and they dont even put talented people they are just looking for attractive people what a shame

  • HOW TO DESTROY A MASTERPIECE!

  • This is one of the only videos of an innocuous nature that I have ever 'disliked' on YouTube. What a travesty. You cannot take something that is so precious and integral to childhood memories and trash it like this.

  • Comment removed

  • Come on Disney, you should know better :/

  • i like this song but i like the old one better

  • I do not like when disney remaked their old songs to a new generation beat. Create a new song for the new generation keep the original song for the people who grew up with it.....

  • you officially killed that beautyfull song :(

  • wow, never knew how autotune and this girl with no life could ruin kids' dreams.

  • Why hate on this? I think Meaghan did a really great job on covering this song. Yes, I think the original is better, but it's not like any of YOU haven't sang this song YOUR OWN way before. Stop hating freaks!

  • @TheLehAya

    How does 'hating on the haters' prove your point? 

  • @LyrGil How does asking me a stupid question prove your point? I'm not hating on anyone ya idiot. Don't talk to me.

  • @TheLehAya

    Your level of maturity is hysterically deficient; thank you for again establishing my point. Verbally abusive or demeaning comments belie either a very unhappy individual, or a very spoiled one; you should consider doing away with the habit. Have a good day, cheer up, and God bless you. :)

  • @LyrGil You're level of stupidity is obvious here. Did you read my comment clearly? People are hating on this cover because it's not the original. Big whoop! We all have likes and dislikes get over it and grow up! Good day! 

  • yuck

  • Omg! ..........I dont' Wish anymore

  • No just no. Stop recreating songs :(

  • i love this song its just amazing

  • she sounds a bit like Minnie Mouse.

  • I used to love this song when it came on disney channel. I still love it.

  • beautiful song <3<3

  • OK

    

  • meaghan is very beautiful and can really sing!

  • I admit that this isn't the best. But that doesn't really give you the right to bash on it. I myself would rather no one would make copies of songs, but that's just not gonna happen. I think her voice is unique. And is the remake ever as good as the original? I think not. But you should give her some credit for trying to sing this and make it her own. I don't see any of you trying to make a new version of this or having a successful career like her. So, just chill. Don't like, don't watch.

  • This vid is shiiii..... Plus you can tell that her voice was heavily autotuned. Idk if its the style of the song but, it killed the original feel of the song.

  • what the hell is this crap?

  • I wish that Disney would stop making all the stupid "reality type" shows and go back to making the original cartoons that they used to make that every kid loved....i miss those days soooo much!

  • @funfofa1234 u are totally righht... those shows are sooo dumb

  • i love this version

  • when i was little i watched these movies over overand over again but now i go to disney channel and all i see are grown ppl tryin to get a quick buck i miss the old way the princess would look at the stars and how the animals would dance along and u cried wen the sad parts cmon i miss those days!

  • The techno beat kinda ruined the whole MAGICAL feel of it, you know?

  • That was awful.

  • This is good compared to some ofthe other videos that Disney has made

  • :))))))))))))))))

  • ew

  • Ahh Walt come back to us :( and save us from this crap. Disney was the one magical thing in my life when I was a child and somehow I can't see the magic anymore in the new stuff..

  • I like it :)

  • I like this version but the original is so much better,

  • Why would you do this to a classic Disney song like this??? Seriously--no talent.

  • I hate to see those beautiful songs made up like a normal pop-song... I don't like this version -.-

  • When you wish upon a star

    youtube.com/watch?v=yvfFJ2lmkQ­M

  • its good but its not very clear sorry and also half the lyrics are wrong so youre not even close sorry again

  • @villinest in the description

  • This song has a great meaning! The sad thing? Disney hires pretty girls to get autotuned. Isn't Disney suppossed to be the one thing that's innocent in this world...?

  • @kmkimi2002 i honestly wish we could all still believe that. I remember when Disney use to be about magic and dreams and following your heart. But now, it's only about being trashy teen stars, being popular and making money. If Disney were still alive, I'm sure it would break his heart to see what it's come to.

  • @thespiankid2318 couldnt have aid it better myself

  • This song sounds so dreamy and Disney like :) I can't believe all the shows I grew up with are ending! It's kind of like a slap in the face saying you grew up and you can't be a child forever. I'll miss you Disney! <3

  • "Shimerings" in lyrics!It should be she brings! :)

  • This pretty

  • great!!!!the best version!!!

  • aw hell naw!

  • whaaaaatttheeeeeeefffaaaaaaarr­rkkkk

  • Did anyone realize there is no 3:12

  • she can sing so shut up people

  • @atichenor175 she can talk and then have disney autotune notes in for her, yes.

  • horrible voice

  • How to destroy a dream in 3:13 minutes.

  • my daughter love it..

  • "I wish upon a star that people will stop turning beautiful pieces of music into utter crap like this!"

  • You know there's too much Auto-tune when you sound like GLaDOS.

  • The new Disney doesnt have anything on the old Disney... they old Disney knew what they were doing to make everyone love their work.... from kids..to adults..to elders...everyone loves Disney but the new Disney Channel is really reeking the old style of Disney

  • That wasn't such a bad song hehehe I'm the first to comment

  • wow, what a mess... :|

  • so what if it is autotuned, this version is kind of magical

  • If you guys hate it soooo much, why do you watch it?????

  • @tHaToNeWeIrDgUrL12 Maybe because they thought they were going to hear a beautiful song called "When You Wish Upon a Star." I totally can sympathize! This song used to be beautiful and then it got hijacked by people who know nothing of beauty! Musical taste is indeed subjective, we all have different tastes, I agree with that... Some of us have good taste and some of us like this kind of crap!!!!

  • she can't sing its so auto tuned. Why do they have to give credit to s stupid disney star that can't sing don't make a new version the old one is 10 times better. Kids these days do not know the classic disney movies and its a shame because they are beautiful. All the new movies are too artificial and it brings no culture!

  • Hmm I kinda like this. Reminds me of young drag queen music.

  • I ♥ this song! They play this during the Fireworks in Disneyland!! ((: It's so beautiful..

  • wow thats sad how disney could let a tiny bopper ruin the most acclaimed disney classic song in DISNEY HISTORY

  • Jesse sang it better.

  • she sings to fast to fast that it messes up the song

  • The original was way better! Why do we have to have some disney channel barbie doll mucking it up every time a platinum edition comes out? This faster paced one sucks, the slowness of the original added to the charm of it. There's a reason why it's practically disney's overall theme song.

  • I like it! It's a pretty song even when she sings it! Also, this version is geared towards little girls who would rather have a pretty girl role model to sing along with than some old Disney woman. I love all the camera angles and the lighting, it's a nice music video. This whole video&song used to cheer me up when it would come on Disney Channel as I was falling asleep. Besides, she CAN sing, everyone is auto tuned nowadays. You would be too if you made a song! The chairs in this are amazing!

  • this version of the song made me dislike disney a whole lot less

  • she ruined the song. Fuck you, New Disney

  • thnx for uploading

  • NOOOOOOOOOOOO

    

  • EWW.

  • I love this song, I just don't really like how it's autotuned. ._.

  • omg headacheee

  • just because she is auto tuned doesnt mean she sounds bad... you just cant tell how she actually sounds

  • i really like it